Haemoglobin E-hereditary elliptocytosis in Malayan aborigines

Accurate light microscopic diagnosis of South-East Asian ovalocytosis

INTRODUCTION

South-East Asian ovalocytosis (SAO) is a common inherited red blood cell polymorphism in South-East Asian and Melanesian populations, coinciding with areas of malaria endemicity. Validation of light microscopy as a diagnostic alternative to molecular genotyping may allow for its cost-effective use either prospectively or retrospectively by analysis of archived blood smears.

METHODS

We assessed light microscopic diagnosis of SAO compared to standard PCR genotyping. Three trained microscopists each assessed the same 971 Giemsa-stained thin blood films for which SAO genotypic confirmation was available by PCR. Generalized mixed modeling was used to estimate the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value of light microscopy vs "gold standard" PCR.

RESULTS

Among red cell morphologic parameters evaluated, knizocytes, rather than ovalocytic morphology, proved the strongest predictor of SAO status (odds ratio [OR] = 19.2; 95% confidence interval [95% CI] = 14.6-25.3; P ≤ 0.0001). The diagnostic performance of a knizocyte-centric microscopic approach was microscopist dependent: two microscopists applied this approach with a sensitivity of 0.89 and a specificity of 0.93. Inter-rater reliability among the microscopists (κ = 0.20) as well as between gold standard and microscopist (κ = 0.36) underperformed due to misclassification of stomatocytes as knizocytes by one microscopist, but improved substantially when excluding the error-prone reader (κ = 0.65 and 0.74, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Light microscopic diagnosis of SAO by knizocyte visual cue performed comparable to time-consuming and costlier molecular methods, but requires specific training that includes successful differentiation of knizocytes from stomatocytes.

Molecular Approach for Distal Renal Tubular Acidosis Associated AE1 Mutations

The molecular approaches to distal renal tubular acidosis (dRTA) associated AE1 mutations lead us to understand the genetic and pathophysiological aspects of the acidification defects. An unanticipated high value of the urine-blood (U-B) PCO(2) after NaHCO(3) loading observed in a case of dRTA and southeast Asian ovalocytosis (SAO) might be from a mistarget of the AE1 to the luminal membrane of type A intercalated cells. The mutations of the AE1 gene resulted in SAO and also affected renal acidification function. Notwithstanding, after the NH4Cl loading in 20 individuals with SAO, the acidification in the distal nephron was normal. The presence of both SAO and G701D mutations of AE1 gene would explain the abnormal urinary acidification in the patients with the compound heterozogosity. In terms of the effect of the mutations on trafficking of AE1, truncated kidney isoform (kAE1) of wild-type showed a 'dominant-positive effect' in rescuing the recessive mutant kAE1 (S773P or G701D) trafficking to the plasma membrane, in contrast with the dominant mutant kAE1 (R589H) resulting in a 'dominant-negative effect' when heterodimerized with the wild-type kAE1. It is notable that the dominant mutants kAE1 (R901X or G609R) expression in MDCK cells clearly results in aberrant surface expression with some mutant protein appearing at the apical membrane. These might result in net bicarbonate secretion and increasing U-B PCO(2) in the distal nephron. The molecular physiological and genetic approaches have permitted identification of the molecular defects, predominantly in transporter proteins, and should in turn prompt development of novel therapeutic strategies.

Bicarbonate transport in cell physiology and disease

The family of mammalian bicarbonate transport proteins are involved in a wide-range of physiological processes. The importance of bicarbonate transport follows from the biochemistry of HCO(3)(-) itself. Bicarbonate is the waste product of mitochondrial respiration. HCO(3)(-) undergoes pH-dependent conversion into CO(2) and in doing so converts from a membrane impermeant anion into a gas that can diffuse across membranes. The CO(2)-HCO(3)(-) equilibrium forms the most important pH buffering system of our bodies. Bicarbonate transport proteins facilitate the movement of membrane-impermeant HCO(3)(-) across membranes to accelerate disposal of waste CO(2), control cellular and whole-body pH, and to regulate fluid movement and acid/base secretion. Defects of bicarbonate transport proteins manifest in diseases of most organ systems. Fourteen gene products facilitate mammalian bicarbonate transport, whose physiology and pathophysiology is discussed in the present review.

Autosomal recessive distal renal tubular acidosis associated with Southeast Asian ovalocytosis

BACKGROUND

A defect in the anion exchanger 1 (AE1) of the basolateral membrane of type A intercalated cells in the renal collecting duct may result in a failure to maintain a cell-to-lumen H+ gradient, leading to distal renal tubular acidosis (dRTA). Thus, dRTA may occur in Southeast Asian ovalocytosis (SAO), a common AE1 gene abnormality observed in Southeast Asia and Melanesia. Our study investigated whether or not this renal acidification defect exists in individuals with SAO.

METHODS

Short and three-day NH4Cl loading tests were performed in 20 individuals with SAO and in two subjects, including their families, with both SAO and dRTA. Mutations of AE1 gene in individuals with SAO and members of the two families were also studied.

RESULTS

Renal acidification in the 20 individuals with SAO and in the parents of the two families was normal. However, the two clinically affected individuals with SAO and dRTA had compound heterozygosity of 27 bp deletion in exon 11 and missense mutation G701D resulting from a CGG-->CAG substitution in exon 17 of the AE1 gene. Red cells of the two subjects with dRTA and SAO and the family members with SAO showed an approximate 40% reduction in sulfate influx with normal 4,4'-di-isothiocyanato-stilbene-2,2'-disulfonic acid sensitivity and pH dependence.

CONCLUSION

These findings suggest that compound heterozygosity of abnormal AE1 genes causes autosomal recessive dRTA in SAO.

Measurement of ovalocyte frequency in peripheral blood smears in defining ovalocytosis in Papua New Guinea

Red cell oval morphology is still the only accepted basis for the clinical or epidemiological diagnosis of ovalocytosis. Therefore it is important to know the errors when detecting and counting morphological ovalocytes. In all previous studies of ovalocytosis there was no assessment of the variation which may have occurred in classification due to smearing and staining techniques or the criteria for the diagnosis of ovalocyte morphology; nor was inter or intraobserver variation assessed. We report how different peripheral blood smear methods influence the diagnosis of ovalocytosis in populations in the Madang and East Sepik Provinces in Papua New Guinea. We also examined within and between observer variation in the quantitative assessment of ovalocytosis at x 40 and x 100 microscopy powers. A modified method of making a thin malaria blood smear gave the best preservation of red cell morphology and was adopted for the quantitative ovalocytosis studies. A special haematology smear is unnecessary. Ovalocyte frequency estimations were similar when x 40 and x 100 lenses were used, but x 40 was preferable for assessing morphology. Two observers were consistent in their findings and produced very similar results for the high-quality smears from the planned Madang survey, and rather different results for the smears from the unplanned routine Sepik survey. We conclude that measurement error for ovalocytosis assessment can be quite small and unimportant, minimized by careful planning and quality control. Otherwise measurement error is substantial and threatens validity of classification and grading of ovalocytosis.

Molecular defect of the band 3 protein in southeast Asian ovalocytosis

BACKGROUND

Southeast Asian ovalocytosis is a form of hereditary elliptocytosis in which the red cells are rigid and resistant to malaria invasion. The underlying molecular defect is unknown.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We studied the red cells of 54 patients with ovalocytosis and 122 normal controls. We found that ovalocytes contain a structurally and functionally abnormal band 3 protein, the principal transmembrane protein of red cells. The structural lesion of ovalocyte band 3 was revealed by limited proteolytic cleavage of the protein, which produced fragments of abnormal size that were derived from the cytoplasmic domain of the protein. The structural lesion was present in all the subjects with ovalocytosis but none of the controls. This region of band 3 serves as the principal binding site for the membrane skeleton, a submembrane protein network composed of ankyrin, spectrin, actin, and protein 4.1. The structural defect is dominantly inherited, being tightly linked with the inheritance of ovalocytosis (the probability of linkage is in excess of 10 million to 1). Ovalocyte band 3 bound considerably more tightly than normal band 3 to ankyrin, which connects the membrane skeleton to the band 3 protein. This tight binding of ovalocyte band 3 to the underlying skeleton containing ankyrin was directly confirmed in intact cells by the finding that ovalocyte band 3 had markedly reduced lateral mobility in the membrane.

CONCLUSIONS

The red cells in Southeast Asian ovalocytosis carry a structurally and functionally abnormal band 3 protein. This molecular defect may underlie the increased rigidity of the red cells and their resistance to invasion by malaria parasites.

Hereditary ovalocytosis and reduced susceptibility to malaria in Papua New Guinea

Ovalocytosis, an hereditary condition in which most erythrocytes are oval in shape, is a polymorphism that occurs in up to 20% or more of the population in Papua New Guinea and Malaysia. Due to the geographical correlation of the trait with endemic malaria, the possibility of a selective advantage in resistance to malaria has been raised. In a study of 202 individuals with greater than or equal to 50% oval red cells matched by age, sex and village of residence with controls having less than or equal to 30% oval cells, ovalocytic subjects had blood films negative for Plasmodium vivax (P = 0.009), for P. falciparum (P = 0.044), and for all species of malaria parasites (P = 0.013), more often than controls. Among individuals parasitaemic at any time there were no clear differences in density of parasitaemia. However, in children 2 to 4 years old, parasite densities of both species were lower in ovalocytic subjects than in controls (0.01 less than P less than 0.025). The differential susceptibility to malaria infection suggested by this study has implications for the evaluation of interventions, including possible future vaccine field trials, in populations where high-frequency ovalocytosis is present.

The mode of inheritance of ovalocytosis/elliptocytosis in Malaysian Orang Asli families

Hereditary ovalocytosis/elliptocytosis occurs in polymorphic frequencies among several Malaysian populations and also in Melanesia. Although the condition has been described as an autosomal dominant, Melanesian family studies suggest that it is inherited recessively. Based on 75 Orang Asli families, it is shown that the Malaysian form of elliptocytosis is most likely inherited as an autosomal dominant. It appears, therefore, that either the inference of recessive inheritance in Melanesians is incorrect or that the ovalocytosis/elliptocytosis phenotypes are due to distinct genetic entities in the two regions.

Analysis of a large pedigree with elliptocytosis, multiple lipomatosis, and biological false-positive serological test for syphilis

Elliptocytosis, multiple lipomatosis, and biological false-postive serological test for syphilis (BFPSTS) were found in a single individual. One hundred eighty relatives were tested for the three diseases: 74 were typed for seven blood group antigens, and 58 were typed for four electrophoretic enzyme markers. Likelihood analysis of the pedigree data confirmed independent dominant inheritance for elliptocytosis and lipomatosis. BFPSTS appears dominant, but the analysis was inconclusive. No linkages were found between any disease gene and any marker gene. Two female pedigree members with BFPSTS developed systemic lupus erythematosus, a finding in agreement with the previously described association. The analysis did not lead to any conclusions about the causal relationship between the two traits.

Malaria and hereditary ovalocytosis

Hereditary ovalocytosis in Papua New Guinea is restricted to areas of endemic malaria and may confer increased resistance to the disease. The incidence of malaria was investigated in 1616 Melanesiams of known red cell morphology and severity of infection determined in a smaller subsample. Ovalocytics tended to be more resistant to severe malarial infections than normocytics. The ratio of parasitaemia in 112 ovalocytics compared with 741 normocytic children was 1.05 for P. falciparum; 0.90 for P. vivax; 0.54 for P. malariae, and 0.91 for infection with any species. The difficulties in conclusively demonstrating any selective advantage of the condition are discussed.

Genetic microdifferentiation in the Semai Senoi of Malaysia

Blood samples, demographic and cultural data were collected from seven settlements of Semai Senoi, a swidden farming ethnic group of Malaysia. Three genetic loci (ABO blood group, hereditary ovalcytosis, and hemoglobin) were analyzed in a total sample of 546 individuals. These data indicate a considerable degree of genetic microdifferentiation in this area of the Semai distribution. Parent-offspring birthplace data (analyzed by means of a migration matrix) and settlement histories show that settlements are not strongly isolated. Genetic differences in the study area demonstrate a reasonable correspondence with migration and the history of the settlements. Genetic convergence also occurs through the addition of migrant groups to established populations leading to new patterns of marriage between donor and recipient groups. The genetic structure of the total Semai population through time thus comprises a mosaic of shifiting allele frequencies in a series of semi-isolated local populations.

Haemoglobin Lepore Boston and elliptocytosis in a family of Indonesian-German ancestry

A family is presented in which Hb Lepore Boston was found in six individuals over three generations. The gene must have had its origin either in Java (Indonesia) or in what is now the Federal Republic of Germany. The haemoglobin was characterized by amino-acid analysis of the six tryptic peptides that have a different composition in the beta- and the delta-chain. The ratio of glycine to alanine in position 136 of the fetal haemoglobin, which was somewhat raised in the Hb Lepore carriers, averaged 31:39. In addition an elliptocytosis gene was found, which was inherited independently from Hb Lepore; the simultaneous presence of elliptocytosis in three family members did not seem to aggravate the mild anaemia caused by Hb Lepore.