The last month of life: continuity, care site and place of death

Patient and family caregiver decision making in the context of advanced cancer

BACKGROUND

A basic tenet of palliative care is to maintain an individual's control over the dying process. However, when decline occurs quickly, as may be the case in advanced cancer, transition of responsibility for illness management to a family caregiver may become necessary when care takes place in the home.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to understand the decision-making process that occurs between a dying individual and his or her family caregiver.

METHODS

Participants in this grounded theory study were selected by purposive and theoretical sampling methods. Data were collected and analyzed using a constant comparison approach.

RESULTS

The core category covering captured the inordinate efforts taken by informal caregivers to ensure that their family member would be able to die in the manner of his or her choosing. The basic social process, dancing on the stairs, chronicled the families' decision-making process as they navigated through this delicate and precarious end stage of life.

CONCLUSIONS

Dancing on the stairs required a close relationship between 2 people who were willing to remain engaged with each other, despite the difficulties they faced. This decision-making process may be applicable to other health care transitions in people's lives that need to be managed with another person.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

Palliative care education for nurses in all care health settings may ease transitions for end-stage patients. Health promotion initiatives designed to educate the lay public about advance directives and end-stage illness management in a home setting may help to prepare family caregivers for their future responsibilities.

How palliative care of cancer patients is organised between a university hospital and primary care in Finland

The aim of this study was to find out how palliative care is organised between the Helsinki University Central Hospital (University Hospital) and primary care. The study consisted of 102 patients whose oncological treatment was terminated and the responsibility of palliative care was transferred to primary care. The patients were interviewed by phone using a structured questionnaire. Another questionnaire form was sent to the primary care physicians. Half of the patients were treated in more than one primary care unit. One third of the outpatients were unaware who was responsible for the care. Most of the patients wanted to be at home but this was achieved in less than half of the cases. Most patients were symptomatic while leaving the University Hospital and no improvement was seen thereafter. Every third patient reported of poor quality of palliative care in the primary care. Also the physicians reported a need for training in palliative care.

Exploring the literature surrounding the transition into palliative care: a scoping review

This article explores the current literature surrounding transitions into palliative care. Transitions in care have become more frequent and complex in the Canadian healthcare system. Plagued with difficulty, fear and misunderstanding, the transition into palliative care is one of the most confusing and traumatic transitions a patient and family can face. Despite this, however, transitions into palliative care have been commonly overlooked in transitional research. A scoping review of the existing literature on transitions and palliative care was conducted and three key areas complicating the transition into palliative care were noted: the intrinsic nature of the transitions, the timing of the transition, and the lack of information surrounding this transition. This article highlights a need for further research into the complicated area of transitions into palliative care.

The rapidly changing location of death in Canada, 1994-2004

This 2008 study assessed location-of-death changes in Canada during 1994-2004, after previous research had identified a continuing increase to 1994 in hospital deaths. The most recent (1994-2004) complete population and individual-level Statistics Canada mortality data were analyzed, involving 1,806,318 decedents of all Canadian provinces and territories except Quebec. A substantial and continuing decline in hospitalized deaths was found (77.7%-60.6%). This decline was universal among decedents regardless of age, gender, marital status, whether they were born in Canada or not, across urban and rural provinces, and for all but two (infrequent) causes of death. This shift occurred in the absence of policy or purposive healthcare planning to shift death or dying out of hospital. In the developed world, recent changing patterns in the place of death, as well as the location and type of care provided near death appear to be occurring, making location-of-death trends an important topic of investigation. Canada is an important case study for highlighting the significance of location-of-death trends, and suggesting important underlying causal relationships and implications for end-of-life policies and practices.

Euthanasia and other end-of-life decisions: a mortality follow-back study in Belgium

Background

This study compares prevalence and types of medical end-of-life decisions between the Dutch-speaking and French-speaking communities of Belgium. This is the first nationwide study that can make these comparisons and the first measurement after implementation of the euthanasia law (2002).

Methods

We performed a mortality follow-back study in 2005–2006. Data were collected via the nationwide Sentinel Network of General Practitioners, an epidemiological surveillance system representative of all Belgian GPs.

Weekly, all GPs reported the medical end-of-life decisions among all non-sudden deaths of patients in their practice. We compared the northern Dutch-speaking (60%) and southern French-speaking communities (40%) controlling for population differences.

Results

We analysed 1690 non-sudden deaths. An end-of-life decision with possible life-shortening effect was made in 50% of patients in the Dutch-speaking community and 41% of patients in the French-speaking community (OR 1.4; 95%CI, 1.2 to 1.8). Continuous deep sedation until death occurred in 8% and 15% respectively (OR 0.5; 95%CI, 0.4 to 0.7). Community differences regarding the prevalence of euthanasia or physician-assisted suicide were not significant.

Community differences were more present among home/care home than among hospital deaths: non-treatment decisions with explicit life-shortening intention were made more often in the Dutch-speaking than in the French-speaking community settings (OR 2.2; 95%CI, 1.2 to 3.9); while continuous deep sedation occurred less often in the Dutch-speaking community settings (OR 0.5; 95%CI, 0.3 to 0.9).

Conclusion

Even though legal and general healthcare systems are the same for the whole country, there are considerable variations between the communities in type and prevalence of certain end-of-life decisions, even after controlling for population differences.

Analysis of long-stay patients in the Hospice Palliative Ward of a Medical Center

BACKGROUND

The Pilot Project on Per-diem Payment for Inpatient Hospice Services of Taiwan's National Health Insurance Program was begun in July 2000. The project monitors hospices to control for a median length of stay (LOS) of not longer than 16 days to prevent inappropriate stasis in hospices. To determine the best utilization of palliative care, patients remaining in the hospice for more than 28 days were analyzed to discover their characteristics and reasons for not being discharged.

METHODS

The study sample included 1,670 hospice patients who were admitted to the Hospice Palliative Unit in Taipei Veterans General Hospital between July 16, 1997 and December 31, 2002. Two hundred and sixty admissions (21.5%) with LOS > 28 days were identified. Further instrument survey of selected items was performed by 2 trained staff via chart review independently. The basic data were analyzed and comparison between long-stay patients and non-long-stay patients was made.

RESULTS

The mean LOS of 1,670 hospice patients was 16.0 +/- 14.9 days. Two hundred and sixty-eight patients (16.1%) admitted for longer than 28 days were surveyed. Those who had longer mean survival time, a diagnosis of prostate cancer, a metastatic site in the bone, and readmitted patients were associated with long stay. The study also revealed a significant difference in LOS between fee-for-service (FFS) patients and per-diem payment (PDP) patients (mean LOS, 17.5 +/- 16.4 vs. 14.3 +/- 13.4, p < 0.001). Conditions of major physical distress on Day 29 were delirium (41.9%), depression and/or anxiety (20.4%), and severe dyspnea (21.2%). The main reasons for being unable to be discharged on Day 29 after admission included "prolonged terminal phase" (34.2%), "difficult symptom control" (25.8%), "placement problem" (16.9%), and "need of parenteral medication" (15.0%).

CONCLUSION

Better understanding of the factors related to LOS can help staff in the palliative ward of medical centers to identify patients who are apt to have long stay, and shorten their LOS by successfully dealing with their problems.

Description of an Australian model for end-of-life care in patients with hematologic malignancies

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVES

To present a model for end-of-life care in adult hematology that has been developed from nursing insights.

DATA SOURCES

Insights obtained from 25 nursing interviews during a two-year, qualitative, Australian National Health and Medical Research Council research study.

DATA SYNTHESIS

The nursing insights indicate that an understanding of end-of-life care in hematology needs to be set in a trilogy of overlapping models (labeled functional, evolving, and refractory) that address the complexity of issues associated with professional and hospital culture.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors have used the findings of their national research study to develop a useful, working model to assist with the integration of palliative care into adult hematology.

IMPLICATIONS FOR NURSING

The model develops a new language for understanding and fostering the integration of palliative care and hematology.

Predictors associated with the place of death in a country with increasing hospital deaths

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the contribution of type of illness, socio-demographic factors, and area of residence to the place of death in a country with increasing hospital deaths.

DESIGN

Descriptive study of hospital deaths using a 10-year death registration database from the Korean National Statistical Office.

SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS

Through the National Vital Statistics System, 2,402,259 deaths were registered in Korea from 1992 to 2001.

MEASUREMENT AND MAIN RESULTS

There was a significant trend toward an increase in the proportion of hospital deaths, from 16.6% in 1992 to 39.9% in 2001. The proportion of deaths at home decreased over that period, from 72.9 to 49.2%. The risk of hospital death versus home death was lower for those aged 75 years and over (adjusted odds ratio: 0.212; 95% confidence interval: 0.210-0.214) compared with those <55 years, and for people who were highly educated (2.04; 2.02-2.06), had white-collar jobs (1.55; 1.54-1.57), and resided in areas with more available hospital beds (2.46; 2.42-2.51). Compared with other causes of death, the risk of dying in hospital was higher for patients with ischaemic heart disease (1.83; 1.79-1.86), cancer (1.25; 1.23-1.26) and chronic lower respiratory disease (1.21; 1.18-1.23).

CONCLUSIONS

Trends in place of death are influenced by available hospital beds, socio-demographic factors and the nature of the terminal disease, in a country with increasing hospital deaths. These associations should be viewed within the context of culture and local health care systems.

Transitions and shifting goals of care for palliative patients and their families

Terminally ill patients and their families experience many confusing and, at times, traumatic transitions. Examples of such transitions include transitions from cure to comfort care, transitions related to loss, changes in care settings, and psychosocial and spiritual transitions. The purpose of this article is to discuss the experiences of palliative patients and their families as they journey through transitions and how oncology nurses can provide support. Using a composite case study from actual clinical cases as a framework for discussion, the authors present examples of evidence-based strategies that can be used by oncology nurses. Critical points from the case study are Adjustment to death is a process and cannot be rushed. The needs of a palliative patient and family should be heard, honored, and not questioned or challenged. A patient and family should remain in control of decision making, with the hospice and palliative care team acting as guides and facilitators.

Palliative care for patients with cancer: district nurses' experiences

AIM

This paper reports a study exploring district nurses' experiences of providing palliative care for patients with cancer and their families.

BACKGROUND

There is an increasing demand for palliative care in the community, as many patients wish to die at home. District nurses are central to providing palliative care in the community, but there is a dearth of literature on district nurses' experiences in palliative care.

METHOD

A Husserlian phenomenological approach was adopted with a purposive sample of 25 female district nurses. Data were collected using unstructured, tape-recorded interviews and analysed using Colaizzi's seven stages of data analysis.

FINDINGS

Four themes were identified: the communication web; the family as an element of care; challenges for the district nurse in symptom management and the personal cost of caring.

CONCLUSIONS

District nurses' experiences of providing palliative care to family units was challenging but rewarding. The emotive nature of the experience cannot be under-estimated, as many district nurses were touched by the varying situations. Whilst acknowledging the need to maintain an integrated approach to care, district nurses should be identified as the key workers in the complex situation of palliative care.

Enhancing the role of case managers with specialty populations: development and evaluation of a palliative care education program

Palliative home care is an important component of the care system for patients at the end of life and case management is considered an essential element of the Canadian home care system. Case managers play a critical role in allocating resources, thus influencing the costs and the viability of palliative home care. Case management education programs focused on care coordination with specialty palliative care populations are nonexistent. An education program targeted at improving the knowledge and skills of case managers in allocating resources to palliative care populations was developed and pilot-tested in a metropolitan Canadian city home care program. Core curriculum was based on an initial learning needs assessment and used case-based problem solving to enhance case-management skills. An improvement in knowledge was noted on posttests and case managers described increased comfort and confidence in their role as case managers to this patient population. Home care organizations caring for palliative care populations must ensure case managers are prepared for case management roles with specialty populations if the home is to be rendered an appropriate and viable care setting for patients at the end of life.

Patientsʼ Experiences of Palliative Care in the Home

In recent times the rapid expansion of interest in palliative care has become a significant feature of health care development. Caring in the palliative way means simultaneous attention to the medical, nursing, spiritual, emotional, and social needs of the patient. The main purpose of the present study has been to obtain an understanding of patients' experiences of palliative care at home with service from district nurses. The research design is influenced by Giorgi's phenomenology. Six patients diagnosed with cancer and receiving palliative care at home were interviewed and the transcribed interviews were analyzed. Interviews were conducted in the patients' homes. The findings show that the essential meaning of the patients' experiences of palliative home care can be described as "uncertain safety." This meaning of essence is explicated by 4 themes, which are labeled "Safe but unsafe at home," "A sense of powerlessness," "Change of everyday life," and "Hope and belief in the future." The findings of the study point out the importance of well functioning teamwork and resources to facilitate patient's experiences of safety in their own homes. It should be noted that the patient and their next of kin are members of the team.

Factors associated with site of death: a national study of where people die

OBJECTIVES

Recent public attention has focused on quality of care for the dying. Where one dies is an important individual and public health concern.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The 1993 National Mortality Followback Survey (NMFS) was used to estimate the proportion of deaths occurring at home, in a hospital, or in a nursing home. Sociodemographic variables, underlying cause of death, geographic region, hospice use, social support, health insurance, patients' physical limitations, and physical decline were considered as possible predictors of site of death. The relationship between these predictors and site death with multinomial logistic regression methods was analyzed.

RESULTS

Nearly 60% of deaths occurred in hospitals, and approximately 20% of deaths took place at home or in nursing homes. Decedents, who were black, less educated, and enrolled in an HMO were more likely to die in the hospital. After adjustment, functional decline in the last 5 months of life was an important predictor of dying at home (for loss of 3 or more ADLs [OR, 1.57; 95% CI, 1.11-2.21]). Having functional limitations 1 year before death, and experiencing functional decline in the last 5 months of life were both associated with dying in a nursing home.

CONCLUSIONS

Rapid physical decline during the last 5 months was associated with dying at home or in a nursing home, whereas earlier functional loss was associated with dying in a nursing home.

Changing geographies of care: employing the concept of therapeutic landscapes as a framework in examining home space

Changes in health care service delivery have resulted in the transfer of care from formal spaces such as hospitals and institutions towards informal settings such as home. Due to the degree of this transfer, it is increasingly important for geographers to explore the experience and meaning of these changing geographies of care in order to reveal and understand the impact and effect on particular individuals and places. Recognizing that the home environment not only designates a dwelling but also represents a multitude of meanings (such as personal identity, security and privacy) that likely vary according to class, ethnicity and family size (among other socio-demographic variables), it presents a complex site for study. This paper suggests research directions to further understand the role of caregiving in contributing to the experience and meaning of the home environment by informal caregivers, the majority of which are women. Using a political economy approach, this paper first reviews the reorganization of health care services and discusses how this is reshaping the experience of informal caregivers at home. A review of the place identity literature contextualizes the specific discussion of the literature on the meaning of home, both of which are then critically examined. Next, the concept of therapeutic landscapes is discussed as an idealized framework to explore the health-promoting properties of home on informal caregivers. Questions for research are outlined before conclusions highlight how research on home space can allow a better understanding of the impact and effect of caregiving on family caregivers and the places where they live. Such research can inform the changes and trends in health care service policy.

Racial and ethnic differences in place of death: United States, 1993

OBJECTIVES

To examine racial and ethnic differences in place of death, adjusting for likely confounders.

DESIGN

A retrospective cohort analyzed using multinomial logistic regression.

SETTING

United States in 1993.

PARTICIPANTS

A nationally representative sample of 22,658 deaths in 1993 from the National Mortality Followback Survey.

MEASUREMENTS

Place of death as determined on the death certificate, with controls for age, sex, income, education, and cause of death. The outcomes of interest were death in a hospital during an inpatient stay, death in a nursing home, death in a private residence, or death in some other place.

RESULTS

After adjustment, 43% of whites die after an inpatient hospital stay, as do 50% of blacks and 56% of Mexican Americans. Twenty percent of whites, 22% of Mexican Americans, and 14% of blacks die in nursing homes. Twenty-two percent of whites, 18% of blacks, and 9% of Mexicans die in a private residence.

CONCLUSIONS

There are substantial differences between whites, blacks, and Mexican Americans in place of death that cannot be explained by differences in age, sex, income, education, and causes of death between the groups.

Is good 'quality of life' possible at the end of life? An explorative study of the experiences of a group of cancer patients in two different care cultures

The purpose of this paper was to explore how a group of gravely ill patients, cared for in different care cultures, assessed their quality of life during their last month of life. The study material comprised quality of life assessments from 47 cancer patients, completed during their last month of life. Two quality of life questionnaires, the EORTC QLQ-C30 and a psychosocial well-being questionnaire, were used. The data were treated in accordance with instructions for the respective questionnaires, and the results are presented primarily as means, mostly at the group level. Assessments from patients in two different care cultures, care-orientated and cure-orientated, were compared. The results show that despite having an assessed lower quality of life in many dimensions than people in general, several patients experienced happiness and satisfaction during their last month of life. 'Cognitive functioning' and 'emotional functioning' were the dimensions that differed least from those of the general population, and 'physical functioning', 'role functioning' and 'global health status/quality of life' differed the most. 'Fatigue' showed the highest mean for the symptom scales/items. There was a tendency for those cared for in the cure-orientated care culture to report more symptoms than those in the care-orientated care culture. An exception to this was 'pain', which was reported more often by those in the care-orientated care culture. The implications of the results are discussed from different angles. The significance of knowledge concerning how patients experience their quality of life is also discussed with respect to the care and the planning of care for dying patients.

Where do patients with cancer die in Belfast?

BACKGROUND

Most patients with cancer prefer to die at home but the majority die in institutions.

AIM

To determine place of death for patients with cancer in Belfast, to examine changes over time and identify factors associated with place of death.

METHODS

A survey of deaths registered in Belfast over a six-month period for 1977, 1987 and 1997 identified patients dying from cancer. Epidemiological data included age, gender, malignancy, social class, marital status, area of residence and place of death.

RESULTS

Home deaths fell from 35% in 1977 to 28% in 1997. Hospital deaths fell from 50% in 1977 to 40% in 1987 rising to 42% in 1997. Hospice deaths rose from 13% in 1977 to 25% in 1987 falling to 23% in 1997. There was an association between place of death and age, marital status, type of cancer and area of residence, but not with social class or gender.

CONCLUSION

The majority of people fail to achieve a home death. Resources need to be targeted to those most at risk of an institutional death; females, the elderly, the unmarried, those with haematological malignancies and residents of South Belfast.

Patient participation in decision making at the end of life as seen by a close relative

The aim of the present study was to describe variations in patient participation in decisions about care planning during the final phase of life for a group of gravely ill patients, and how the different actors' manner of acting promotes or impedes patient participation. Thirty-seven qualitative research interviews were conducted with relatives of the patients. The patients' participation in the decisions could be categorized into four variations: self-determination, co-determination, delegation and nonparticipation. The manner in which patients, relatives and caregivers acted differed in the respective variations; this seemed either to promote or to impede the patients' opportunities of participating in the decision making. The possibility for participation seems to be context dependent and affected by many factors such as the dying patient's personality, the social network, the availability of different forms of care, cultural values, and the extent to which nurses and other caregivers of the different forms of care can and want to support the wishes of the patients and relatives in the decision-making process.