Accurate construction of photoactivated localization microscopy (PALM) images for quantitative measurements

Quantitative Single-Molecule Localization Microscopy

Super-resolution fluorescence microscopy allows the investigation of cellular structures at nanoscale resolution using light. Current developments in super-resolution microscopy have focused on reliable quantification of the underlying biological data. In this review, we first describe the basic principles of super-resolution microscopy techniques such as stimulated emission depletion (STED) microscopy and single-molecule localization microscopy (SMLM), and then give a broad overview of methodological developments to quantify super-resolution data, particularly those geared toward SMLM data. We cover commonly used techniques such as spatial point pattern analysis, colocalization, and protein copy number quantification but also describe more advanced techniques such as structural modeling, single-particle tracking, and biosensing. Finally, we provide an outlook on exciting new research directions to which quantitative super-resolution microscopy might be applied.

A novel and robust method for counting components within bio-molecular complexes using fluorescence microscopy and statistical modelling

Cellular biology occurs through myriad interactions between diverse molecular components, many of which assemble in to specific complexes. Various techniques can provide a qualitative survey of which components are found in a given complex. However, quantitative analysis of the absolute number of molecules within a complex (known as stoichiometry) remains challenging. Here we provide a novel method that combines fluorescence microscopy and statistical modelling to derive accurate molecular counts. We have devised a system in which batches of a given biomolecule are differentially labelled with spectrally distinct fluorescent dyes (label A or B), and mixed such that B-labelled molecules are vastly outnumbered by those with label A. Complexes, containing this component, are then simply scored as either being positive or negative for label B. The frequency of positive complexes is directly related to the stoichiometry of interaction and molecular counts can be inferred by statistical modelling. We demonstrate this method using complexes of Adenovirus particles and monoclonal antibodies, achieving counts that are in excellent agreement with previous estimates. Beyond virology, this approach is readily transferable to other experimental systems and, therefore, provides a powerful tool for quantitative molecular biology.

Single-molecule counting applied to the study of GPCR oligomerization

Single-molecule counting techniques enable a precise determination of the intracellular abundance and stoichiometry of proteins and macromolecular complexes. These details are often challenging to quantitatively assess yet are essential for our understanding of cellular function. Consider G-protein-coupled receptors-an expansive class of transmembrane signaling proteins that participate in many vital physiological functions making them a popular target for drug development. While early evidence for the role of oligomerization in receptor signaling came from ensemble biochemical and biophysical assays, innovations in single-molecule measurements are now driving a paradigm shift in our understanding of its relevance. Here, we review recent developments in single-molecule counting with a focus on photobleaching step counting and the emerging technique of quantitative single-molecule localization microscopy-with a particular emphasis on the potential for these techniques to advance our understanding of the role of oligomerization in G-protein-coupled receptor signaling.

Correction of multiple-blinking artifacts in photoactivated localization microscopy

Photoactivated localization microscopy (PALM) produces an array of localization coordinates by means of photoactivatable fluorescent proteins. However, observations are subject to fluorophore multiple blinking and each protein is included in the dataset an unknown number of times at different positions, due to localization error. This causes artificial clustering to be observed in the data. We present a 'model-based correction' (MBC) workflow using calibration-free estimation of blinking dynamics and model-based clustering to produce a corrected set of localization coordinates representing the true underlying fluorophore locations with enhanced localization precision, outperforming the state of the art. The corrected data can be reliably tested for spatial randomness or analyzed by other clustering approaches, and descriptors such as the absolute number of fluorophores per cluster are now quantifiable, which we validate with simulated data and experimental data with known ground truth. Using MBC, we confirm that the adapter protein, the linker for activation of T cells, is clustered at the T cell immunological synapse.

Calibration-free counting of low molecular copy numbers in single DNA-PAINT localization clusters

Single-molecule localization microscopy (SMLM) has revolutionized light microscopy by enabling optical resolution down to a few nanometer. Yet, localization precision commonly does not suffice to visually resolve single subunits in molecular assemblies or multimeric complexes. Because each targeted molecule contributes localizations during image acquisition, molecular counting approaches to reveal the target copy numbers within localization clusters have been persistently proposed since the early days of SMLM, most of which rely on preliminary knowledge of the dye photophysics or on a calibration to a reference. Previously, we developed localization-based fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (lbFCS) as an absolute ensemble counting approach for the SMLM-variant DNA-PAINT (points accumulation for imaging in nanoscale topography), for the first time, to our knowledge, circumventing the necessity for reference calibrations. Here, we present an extended concept termed lbFCS+, which allows absolute counting of copy numbers for individual localization clusters in a single DNA-PAINT image. In lbFCS+, absolute counting of fluorescent loci contained in individual nanoscopic volumes is achieved via precise measurement of the local hybridization rates of the fluorescently labeled oligonucleotides ("imagers") employed in DNA-PAINT imaging. In proof-of-principle experiments on DNA origami nanostructures, we demonstrate the ability of lbFCS+ to truthfully determine molecular copy numbers and imager association and dissociation rates in well-separated localization clusters containing up to 10 docking strands. For N ≤ 4 target molecules, lbFCS+ is even able to resolve integers, providing the potential to study the composition of up to tetrameric molecular complexes. Furthermore, we show that lbFCS+ allows resolving heterogeneous binding dynamics, enabling the distinction of stochastically generated and a priori indistinguishable DNA assemblies. Beyond advancing quantitative DNA-PAINT imaging, we believe that lbFCS+ could find promising applications ranging from biosensing to DNA computing.

A pairwise distance distribution correction (DDC) algorithm to eliminate blinking-caused artifacts in SMLM

Single-molecule localization microscopy (SMLM) relies on the blinking behavior of a fluorophore, which is the stochastic switching between fluorescent and dark states. Blinking creates multiple localizations belonging to the same fluorophore, confounding quantitative analyses and interpretations. Here we present a method, termed distance distribution correction (DDC), to eliminate blinking-caused repeat localizations without any additional calibrations. The approach relies on obtaining the true pairwise distance distribution of different fluorophores naturally from the imaging sequence by using distances between localizations separated by a time much longer than the average fluorescence survival time. We show that, using the true pairwise distribution, we can define and maximize the likelihood, obtaining a set of localizations void of blinking artifacts. DDC results in drastic improvements in obtaining the closest estimate of the true spatial organization and number of fluorescent emitters in a wide range of applications, enabling accurate reconstruction and quantification of SMLM images.

A pairwise distance distribution correction (DDC) algorithm to eliminate blinking-caused artifacts in SMLM

Single-molecule localization microscopy (SMLM) relies on the blinking behavior of a fluorophore, which is the stochastic switching between fluorescent and dark states. Blinking creates multiple localizations belonging to the same fluorophore, confounding quantitative analyses and interpretations. Here we present a method, termed distance distribution correction (DDC), to eliminate blinking-caused repeat localizations without any additional calibrations. The approach relies on obtaining the true pairwise distance distribution of different fluorophores naturally from the imaging sequence by using distances between localizations separated by a time much longer than the average fluorescence survival time. We show that, using the true pairwise distribution, we can define and maximize the likelihood, obtaining a set of localizations void of blinking artifacts. DDC results in drastic improvements in obtaining the closest estimate of the true spatial organization and number of fluorescent emitters in a wide range of applications, enabling accurate reconstruction and quantification of SMLM images.

Challenges facing quantitative large-scale optical super-resolution, and some simple solutions

Optical super-resolution microscopy (SRM) has enabled biologists to visualize cellular structures with near-molecular resolution, giving unprecedented access to details about the amounts, sizes, and spatial distributions of macromolecules in the cell. Precisely quantifying these molecular details requires large datasets of high-quality, reproducible SRM images. In this review, we discuss the unique set of challenges facing quantitative SRM, giving particular attention to the shortcomings of conventional specimen preparation techniques and the necessity for optimal labeling of molecular targets. We further discuss the obstacles to scaling SRM methods, such as lengthy image acquisition and complex SRM data analysis. For each of these challenges, we review the recent advances in the field that circumvent these pitfalls and provide practical advice to biologists for optimizing SRM experiments.

Single-molecule microscopy for in-cell quantification of protein oligomeric stoichiometry

Protein organization modification plays a vital role in initiating signaling pathways, transcriptional regulation, and cell apoptosis regulation. Simultaneous quantification of oligomeric state and cellular parameters in the same cell, even though challenging, is required to understand their correlation at the molecular level. Recent advances of fluorescence protein and single-molecule localization microscopy enables the determination of localizations and oligomeric states of target proteins in cells. We reviewed the fluorescence intensity-based, localization-based, and photophysical property-based approaches for in-cell quantification of protein oligomeric stoichiometry. We discussed their working principles, applications, advantages, and limitations. These results also imply the combination of methodologies targeting different biological parameters at the single-cell level is essential to uncover the structure-function relationship at the molecular level.

Unscrambling fluorophore blinking for comprehensive cluster detection via photoactivated localization microscopy

Determining nanoscale protein distribution via Photoactivated Localization Microscopy (PALM) mandates precise knowledge of the applied fluorophore's blinking properties to counteract overcounting artifacts that distort the resulting biomolecular distributions. Here, we present a readily applicable methodology to determine, optimize and quantitatively account for the blinking behavior of any PALM-compatible fluorophore. Using a custom-designed platform, we reveal complex blinking of two photoswitchable fluorescence proteins (PS-CFP2 and mEOS3.2) and two photoactivatable organic fluorophores (PA Janelia Fluor 549 and Abberior CAGE 635) with blinking cycles on time scales of several seconds. Incorporating such detailed information in our simulation-based analysis package allows for robust evaluation of molecular clustering based on individually recorded single molecule localization maps.

Aging-associated changes in CD47 arrangement and interaction with thrombospondin-1 on red blood cells visualized by super-resolution imaging

CD47 serves as a ligand for signaling regulatory protein α (SIRPα) and as a receptor for thrombospondin-1 (TSP-1). Although CD47, TSP-1, and SIRPα are thought to be involved in the clearance of aged red blood cells (RBCs), aging-associated changes in the expression and interaction of these molecules on RBCs have been elusive. Using direct stochastic optical reconstruction microscopy (dSTORM)-based imaging and quantitative analysis, we can report that CD47 molecules on young RBCs reside as nanoclusters with little binding to TSP-1, suggesting a minimal role for TSP-1/CD47 signaling in normal RBCs. On aged RBCs, CD47 molecules decreased in number but formed bigger and denser clusters, with increased ability to bind TSP-1. Exposure of aged RBCs to TSP-1 resulted in a further increase in the size of CD47 clusters via a lipid raft-dependent mechanism. Furthermore, CD47 cluster formation was dramatically inhibited on thbs1-/- mouse RBCs and associated with a significantly prolonged RBC lifespan. These results indicate that the strength of CD47 binding to its ligand TSP-1 is predominantly determined by the distribution pattern and not the amount of CD47 molecules on RBCs, and offer direct evidence for the role of TSP-1 in phagocytosis of aged RBCs. This study provides clear nanoscale pictures of aging-associated changes in CD47 distribution and TSP-1/CD47 interaction on the cell surface, and insights into the molecular basis for how these molecules coordinate to remove aged RBCs.

Microampere Electric Current Causes Bacterial Membrane Damage and Two-Way Leakage in a Short Period of Time

Physical agents, such as low electric voltage and current, have recently gained attention for antimicrobial treatment due to their bactericidal capability. Although microampere electric current was shown to suppress the growth of bacteria, it remains unclear to what extent the microampere current damaged the bacterial membrane. Here, we investigated the membrane damage and two-way leakage caused by microampere electric current (≤100 μA) with a short exposure time (30 min). Based on MitoTracker staining, propidium iodide staining, filtration assays, and quantitative single-molecule localization microscopy, we observed significant membrane damage, which allowed two-way leakage of ions, small molecules, and proteins. This study paves the way to new development of antimicrobial applications for ultralow electric voltage and current.IMPORTANCE Although electric voltage and current have been studied for a long time in terms of their ability to suppress the growth of bacteria and to kill bacteria, increasing interest has been aroused more recently due to the prevalence of antibiotic resistance of microbes in past decades. Toward understanding the antimicrobial mechanism of low electric voltage and current, previous studies showed that treating bacteria with milliampere electric currents (≥5 mA) for ≥72 h led to significant damage of the bacterial membrane, which likely resulted in leakage of cellular contents and influx of toxic substances through the damaged membrane. However, it remains unclear to what extent membrane damage and two-way (i.e., inward and outward) leakage are caused by lower (i.e., microampere) electric current in a shorter time frame. In this work, we set out to answer this question. We observed that the membrane damage was caused by microampere electric current in half an hour, which allowed two-way leakage of ions, small molecules, and proteins.

Characterization of Photophysical Properties of Photoactivatable Fluorescent Proteins for Super-Resolution Microscopy

Photoactivatable fluorescent proteins (PA-FPs) are widely used in photoactivated localization microscopy (PALM), and information about their blinking properties is important for precise assembling of PALM images and for quantitative molecular counting with PALM. As the photophysical properties of fluorescent proteins depend sensitively on the local physiochemical environment, we developed a series of procedures to characterize the properties of the PA-FPs in fixed cells. As an example, we characterized the properties of Dendra2 in Escherichia coli and found that they are appreciably different from those in vitro. This highlights the importance of characterizing the photophysical properties of PA-FPs under the same experimental conditions as subsequent PALM imaging or molecular counting experiments. Other PA-FPs could be characterized using this strategy.

Toward Absolute Molecular Numbers in DNA-PAINT

Single-molecule localization microscopy (SMLM) has revolutionized optical microscopy, extending resolution down to the level of individual molecules. However, the actual counting of molecules relies on preliminary knowledge of the blinking behavior of individual targets or on a calibration to a reference. In particular for biological applications, great care has to be taken because a plethora of factors influence the quality and applicability of calibration-dependent approaches to count targets in localization clusters particularly in SMLM data obtained from heterogeneous samples. Here, we present localization-based fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (lbFCS) as the first absolute molecular counting approach for DNA-points accumulation for imaging in nanoscale topography (PAINT) microscopy and, to our knowledge, for SMLM in general. We demonstrate that lbFCS overcomes the limitation of previous DNA-PAINT counting and allows the quantification of target molecules independent of the localization cluster density. In accordance with the promising results of our systematic proof-of-principle study on DNA origami structures as idealized targets, lbFCS could potentially also provide quantitative access to more challenging biological targets featuring heterogeneous cluster sizes in the future.

Nanoscale reorganizations of histone-like nucleoid structuring proteins in Escherichia coli are caused by silver nanoparticles

Silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) and ions (Ag⁺) have recently gained broad attention due to their antimicrobial effects against bacteria and other microbes. In this work, we demonstrate the use of super-resolution fluorescence microscopy for investigating and quantifying the antimicrobial effect of AgNPs at the molecular level. We found that subjecting Escherichia coli (E. coli) bacteria to AgNPs led to nanoscale reorganization of histone-like nucleoid structuring (H-NS) proteins, an essential nucleoid associated protein in bacteria. We observed that H-NS proteins formed denser and larger clusters at the center of the bacteria after exposure to AgNPs. We quantified the spatial reorganizations of H-NS proteins by examining the changes of various spatial parameters, including the inter-molecular distances and molecular densities. Clustering analysis based on Voronoi-tessellation were also performed to characterize the change of H-NS proteins' clustering behavior. We found that AgNP-treatment led to an increase in the fraction of H-NS proteins forming clusters. Similar effects were observed for bacteria exposed to Ag⁺ ions, suggesting that the release of Ag⁺ ions plays an important role in the toxicity of AgNPs. On the other hand, we observed that AgNPs with two surface coatings showed difference in the nanoscale reorganization of H-NS proteins, indicating that particle-specific effects also contribute to the antimicrobial activities of AgNPs. Our results suggested that H-NS proteins were significantly affected by AgNPs and Ag⁺ ions, which has been overlooked previously. In addition, we examined the dynamic motion of AgNPs that were attached to the surface of bacteria. We expect that the current methodology can be readily applied to broadly and quantitatively study the spatial reorganization of biological macromolecules at the scale of nanometers caused by metal nanoparticles, which are expected to shed new light on the antimicrobial mechanism of metal nanoparticles.

Choosing the right label for single-molecule tracking in live bacteria: side-by-side comparison of photoactivatable fluorescent protein and Halo tag dyes

Visualizing and quantifying molecular motion and interactions inside living cells provides crucial insight into the mechanisms underlying cell function. This has been achieved by super-resolution localization microscopy and single-molecule tracking in conjunction with photoactivatable fluorescent proteins (PA-FPs). An alternative labelling approach relies on genetically-encoded protein tags with cell-permeable fluorescent ligands which are brighter and less prone to photobleaching than fluorescent proteins but require a laborious labelling process. Either labelling method is associated with significant advantages and disadvantages that should be taken into consideration depending on the microscopy experiment planned. Here, we describe an optimised procedure for labelling Halo-tagged proteins in live Escherichia coli cells. We provide a side-by-side comparison of Halo tag with different fluorescent ligands against the popular photoactivatable fluorescent protein PAmCherry. Using test proteins with different intracellular dynamics, we evaluated fluorescence intensity, background, photostability, and results from single-molecule localization and tracking experiments. Capitalising on the brightness and extended spectral range of fluorescent Halo ligands, we also demonstrate high-speed and dual-colour single-molecule tracking.

A Platform To Enhance Quantitative Single Molecule Localization Microscopy

Quantitative single molecule localization microscopy (qSMLM) is a powerful approach to study in situ protein organization. However, uncertainty regarding the photophysical properties of fluorescent reporters can bias the interpretation of detected localizations and subsequent quantification. Furthermore, strategies to efficiently detect endogenous proteins are often constrained by label heterogeneity and reporter size. Here, a new surface assay for molecular isolation (SAMI) was developed for qSMLM and used to characterize photophysical properties of fluorescent proteins and dyes. SAMI-qSMLM afforded robust quantification. To efficiently detect endogenous proteins, we used fluorescent ligands that bind to a specific site on engineered antibody fragments. Both the density and nano-organization of membrane-bound epidermal growth factor receptors (EGFR, HER2, and HER3) were determined by a combination of SAMI, antibody engineering, and pair-correlation analysis. In breast cancer cell lines, we detected distinct differences in receptor density and nano-organization upon treatment with therapeutic agents. This new platform can improve molecular quantification and can be developed to study the local protein environment of intact cells.

Biological Insight from Super-Resolution Microscopy: What We Can Learn from Localization-Based Images

Super-resolution optical imaging based on the switching and localization of individual fluorescent molecules [photoactivated localization microscopy (PALM), stochastic optical reconstruction microscopy (STORM), etc.] has evolved remarkably over the last decade. Originally driven by pushing technological limits, it has become a tool of biological discovery. The initial demand for impressive pictures showing well-studied biological structures has been replaced by a need for quantitative, reliable data providing dependable evidence for specific unresolved biological hypotheses. In this review, we highlight applications that showcase this development, identify the features that led to their success, and discuss remaining challenges and difficulties. In this context, we consider the complex topic of defining resolution for this imaging modality and address some of the more common analytical methods used with this data.

Quantification of endogenous and exogenous protein expressions of Na,K-ATPase with super-resolution PALM/STORM imaging

Transient transfection of fluorescent fusion proteins is a key enabling technology in fluorescent microscopy to spatio-temporally map cellular protein distributions. Transient transfection of proteins may however bypass normal regulation of expression, leading to overexpression artefacts like misallocations and excess amounts. In this study we investigate the use of STORM and PALM microscopy to quantitatively monitor endogenous and exogenous protein expression. Through incorporation of an N-terminal hemagglutinin epitope to a mMaple3 fused Na,K-ATPase (α₁ isoform), we analyze the spatial and quantitative changes of plasma membrane Na,K-ATPase localization during competitive transient expression. Quantification of plasma membrane protein density revealed a time dependent increase of Na,K-ATPase, but no increase in size of protein clusters. Results show that after 41h transfection, the total plasma membrane density of Na,K-ATPase increased by 63% while the endogenous contribution was reduced by 16%.

Molecular coordination of Staphylococcus aureus cell division

The bacterial cell wall is essential for viability, but despite its ability to withstand internal turgor must remain dynamic to permit growth and division. Peptidoglycan is the major cell wall structural polymer, whose synthesis requires multiple interacting components. The human pathogen Staphylococcus aureus is a prolate spheroid that divides in three orthogonal planes. Here, we have integrated cellular morphology during division with molecular level resolution imaging of peptidoglycan synthesis and the components responsible. Synthesis occurs across the developing septal surface in a diffuse pattern, a necessity of the observed septal geometry, that is matched by variegated division component distribution. Synthesis continues after septal annulus completion, where the core division component FtsZ remains. The novel molecular level information requires re-evaluation of the growth and division processes leading to a new conceptual model, whereby the cell cycle is expedited by a set of functionally connected but not regularly distributed components.

Photoswitching of Green mEos2 by Intense 561 nm Light Perturbs Efficient Green-to-Red Photoconversion in Localization Microscopy

Green-to-red photoconvertible fluorescent proteins (PCFPs) such as mEos2 and its derivatives are widely used in PhotoActivated Localization Microscopy (PALM). However, the complex photophysics of these genetically encoded markers complicates the quantitative analysis of PALM data. Here, we show that intense 561 nm light (∼1 kW/cm²) typically used to localize single red molecules considerably affects the green-state photophysics of mEos2 by populating at least two reversible dark states. These dark states retard green-to-red photoconversion through a shelving effect, although one of them is rapidly depopulated by 405 nm light illumination. Multiple mEos2 switching and irreversible photobleaching is thus induced by yellow/green and violet photons before green-to-red photoconversion occurs, contributing to explain the apparent limited signaling efficiency of this PCFP. Our data reveals that the photophysics of PCFPs of anthozoan origin is substantially more complex than previously thought, and suggests that intense 561 nm laser light should be used with care, notably for quantitative or fast PALM approaches.

Molecular Counting with Localization Microscopy: A Bayesian Estimate Based on Fluorophore Statistics

Superresolved localization microscopy has the potential to serve as an accurate, single-cell technique for counting the abundance of intracellular molecules. However, the stochastic blinking of single fluorophores can introduce large uncertainties into the final count. Here we provide a theoretical foundation for applying superresolved localization microscopy to the problem of molecular counting based on the distribution of blinking events from a single fluorophore. We also show that by redundantly tagging single molecules with multiple, blinking fluorophores, the accuracy of the technique can be enhanced by harnessing the central limit theorem. The coefficient of variation then, for the number of molecules M estimated from a given number of blinks B, scales like ∼1/N_l, where N_l is the mean number of labels on a target. As an example, we apply our theory to the challenging problem of quantifying the cell-to-cell variability of plasmid copy number in bacteria.

Quantitative Localization Microscopy Reveals a Novel Organization of a High-Copy Number Plasmid

The maintenance of high-copy number plasmids within bacteria had been commonly thought to result from free diffusion and random segregation. Recent microscopy experiments, however, observed high-copy number plasmids clustering into discrete foci, which seemed to contradict this model, and hinted at an undiscovered active mechanism, as often found in low-copy number plasmids. We recently investigated the cellular organization of a ColE1-derivative plasmid in Escherichia coli bacteria using quantitative superresolved microscopy based on single-molecule localization in combination with single-molecule fluorescence in situ hybridization (smFISH). We observed that many of the plasmids aggregated into large clusters, although most of the plasmids were randomly distributed throughout the bacteria, minus an excluded volume about the chromosomal DNA. Our results indicate that neither of the previous models completely encompasses the behavior of high-copy number plasmids. We also found many plasmids within the chromosomal volume, providing further evidence that the nucleoid does not fully exclude DNA and RNA.

Unraveling the Thousand Word Picture: An Introduction to Super-Resolution Data Analysis

Super-resolution microscopy provides direct insight into fundamental biological processes occurring at length scales smaller than light's diffraction limit. The analysis of data at such scales has brought statistical and machine learning methods into the mainstream. Here we provide a survey of data analysis methods starting from an overview of basic statistical techniques underlying the analysis of super-resolution and, more broadly, imaging data. We subsequently break down the analysis of super-resolution data into four problems: the localization problem, the counting problem, the linking problem, and what we've termed the interpretation problem.

Super-Resolution Microscopy: Shedding Light on the Cellular Plasma Membrane

Lipids and the membranes they form are fundamental building blocks of cellular life, and their geometry and chemical properties distinguish membranes from other cellular environments. Collective processes occurring within membranes strongly impact cellular behavior and biochemistry, and understanding these processes presents unique challenges due to the often complex and myriad interactions between membrane components. Super-resolution microscopy offers a significant gain in resolution over traditional optical microscopy, enabling the localization of individual molecules even in densely labeled samples and in cellular and tissue environments. These microscopy techniques have been used to examine the organization and dynamics of plasma membrane components, providing insight into the fundamental interactions that determine membrane functions. Here, we broadly introduce the structure and organization of the mammalian plasma membrane and review recent applications of super-resolution microscopy to the study of membranes. We then highlight some inherent challenges faced when using super-resolution microscopy to study membranes, and we discuss recent technical advancements that promise further improvements to super-resolution microscopy and its application to the plasma membrane.

Quantitative Single-Molecule Localization Microscopy (qSMLM) of Membrane Proteins Based on Kinetic Analysis of Fluorophore Blinking Cycles

Photoswitchable or photoactivatable fluorophores are the key in single-molecule localization microscopy. Next to providing fluorescence images with subdiffraction spatial resolution, additional information is available from observing single fluorophores over time. This includes the characteristic photophysical phenomenon of "blinking" that is exhibited by single fluorescent proteins or fluorophores and follows well-defined kinetic laws. Analyzing the kinetics of "blinking" allows determining the number of fluorophores in a multi-molecular complex. As such, quantitative information at the molecular level can be extracted, representing a tremendously useful extension of single-molecule super-resolution microscopy. This concept is in particular useful to study homo- and heterooligomeric signaling protein complexes in the plasma membrane of an intact cell with molecular resolution. Here, we provide an experimental framework for deciphering the stoichiometry of membrane proteins on the basis of SMLM and photoswitching statistics.

Model-independent counting of molecules in single-molecule localization microscopy

Most biomolecular processes rely on tightly controlled stoichiometries, from the formation of molecular assemblies to cellular signaling. Single-molecule localization micro-scopy studies of fluorophore blinking offer a promising route to probe oligomeric states. Here we show that the distribution of the number of blinking events assumes a universal functional form, independent of photophysics, under relatively mild assumptions. The number of photophysical states, the kinetics of interconversion, and the fraction of active fluorophores enter as two or three constants. This essentially model-independent formulation allows us to determine molecule counts from fluorophore blinking statistics. The formulas hold even if the fluorophores have many different yet unresolved dark states, as long as there is only a single fluorescent state, or if there are different yet unresolvable fluorescent states, as long as there is only a single dark state. We demonstrate the practical applicability of this approach by quantifying the oligomerization states of membrane proteins tagged with the mEos2 fluorescent protein. We find that the model parameters, obtained by likelihood maximization, are transferable. With the counting statistics being independent of the detailed photophysics and its parameters being transferable, the method should be robust and broadly applicable to counting colocalized molecules in vivo and in vitro.

Optical and force nanoscopy in microbiology

Microbial cells have developed sophisticated multicomponent structures and machineries to govern basic cellular processes, such as chromosome segregation, gene expression, cell division, mechanosensing, cell adhesion and biofilm formation. Because of the small cell sizes, subcellular structures have long been difficult to visualize using diffraction-limited light microscopy. During the last three decades, optical and force nanoscopy techniques have been developed to probe intracellular and extracellular structures with unprecedented resolutions, enabling researchers to study their organization, dynamics and interactions in individual cells, at the single-molecule level, from the inside out, and all the way up to cell-cell interactions in microbial communities. In this Review, we discuss the principles, advantages and limitations of the main optical and force nanoscopy techniques available in microbiology, and we highlight some outstanding questions that these new tools may help to answer.

Defining the rate-limiting processes of bacterial cytokinesis

Bacterial cytokinesis is accomplished by the essential 'divisome' machinery. The most widely conserved divisome component, FtsZ, is a tubulin homolog that polymerizes into the 'FtsZ-ring' ('Z-ring'). Previous in vitro studies suggest that Z-ring contraction serves as a major constrictive force generator to limit the progression of cytokinesis. Here, we applied quantitative superresolution imaging to examine whether and how Z-ring contraction limits the rate of septum closure during cytokinesis in Escherichia coli cells. Surprisingly, septum closure rate was robust to substantial changes in all Z-ring properties proposed to be coupled to force generation: FtsZ's GTPase activity, Z-ring density, and the timing of Z-ring assembly and disassembly. Instead, the rate was limited by the activity of an essential cell wall synthesis enzyme and further modulated by a physical divisome-chromosome coupling. These results challenge a Z-ring-centric view of bacterial cytokinesis and identify cell wall synthesis and chromosome segregation as limiting processes of cytokinesis.

Arginine 66 Controls Dark-State Formation in Green-to-Red Photoconvertible Fluorescent Proteins

Photoactivated localization microscopy (PALM) is a powerful technique to investigate cellular nanostructures quantitatively and dynamically. However, the use of PALM for molecular counting or single-particle tracking remains limited by the propensity of photoconvertible fluorescent protein markers (PCFPs) to repeatedly enter dark states. By designing the single mutants mEos2-A69T and Dendra2-T69A, we completely swapped the blinking behaviors of mEos2 and Dendra2, two popular PCFPs. We combined X-ray crystallography and single-molecule microscopy to show that blinking in mEos2 and Dendra2 is largely controlled by the orientation of arginine 66, a highly conserved residue in Anthozoan PCFPs. The Arg66 side-chain conformation affects the bleaching and the on-to-off transition quantum yields, as well as the fraction of molecules entering long-lived dark states, resulting in widely different apparent blinking behaviors that largely modulate the efficiency of current blinking correction procedures. The present work provides mechanistic insight into the complex photophysics of Anthozoan PCFPs and will facilitate future engineering of bright and low-blinking variants suitable for PALM.

One, two or three? Probing the stoichiometry of membrane proteins by single-molecule localization microscopy

Probing the oligomeric state of abundant molecules, such as membrane proteins in intact cells, is essential, but has not been straightforward. We address this challenge with a simple counting strategy that is capable of reporting the oligomeric state of dense, membrane-bound protein complexes. It is based on single-molecule localization microscopy to super-resolve protein structures in intact cells and basic quantitative evaluation. We validate our method with membrane-bound monomeric CD86 and dimeric cytotoxic T-lymphocyte-associated protein as model proteins and confirm their oligomeric states. We further detect oligomerization of CD80 and vesicular stomatitis virus glycoprotein and propose coexistence of monomers and dimers for CD80 and trimeric assembly of the viral protein at the cell membrane. This approach should prove valuable for researchers striving for reliable molecular counting in cells.

Steady-state cross-correlations for live two-colour super-resolution localization data sets

Cross-correlation of super-resolution images gathered from point localizations allows for robust quantification of protein co-distributions in chemically fixed cells. Here this is extended to dynamic systems through an analysis that quantifies the steady-state cross-correlation between spectrally distinguishable probes. This methodology is used to quantify the co-distribution of several mobile membrane proteins in both vesicles and live cells, including Lyn kinase and the B-cell receptor during antigen stimulation.

A multi-layered protein network stabilizes the Escherichia coli FtsZ-ring and modulates constriction dynamics

The prokaryotic tubulin homolog, FtsZ, forms a ring-like structure (FtsZ-ring) at midcell. The FtsZ-ring establishes the division plane and enables the assembly of the macromolecular division machinery (divisome). Although many molecular components of the divisome have been identified and their interactions extensively characterized, the spatial organization of these proteins within the divisome is unclear. Consequently, the physical mechanisms that drive divisome assembly, maintenance, and constriction remain elusive. Here we applied single-molecule based superresolution imaging, combined with genetic and biophysical investigations, to reveal the spatial organization of cellular structures formed by four important divisome proteins in E. coli: FtsZ, ZapA, ZapB and MatP. We show that these interacting proteins are arranged into a multi-layered protein network extending from the cell membrane to the chromosome, each with unique structural and dynamic properties. Further, we find that this protein network stabilizes the FtsZ-ring, and unexpectedly, slows down cell constriction, suggesting a new, unrecognized role for this network in bacterial cell division. Our results provide new insight into the structure and function of the divisome, and highlight the importance of coordinated cell constriction and chromosome segregation.

Bacterial cell division is a highly regulated process that must be coordinated with other cellular processes (i.e. DNA replication and chromosome segregation) to promote faithful reproduction. In Escherichia coli, this regulation is most often mediated through the polymerization of the prokaryotic tubulin homolog, FtsZ, which forms a ring-like structure (FtsZ-ring) at midcell. The establishment of the FtsZ-ring marks the site of division and enables the assembly of the macromolecular division machinery (divisome). Here we applied single-molecule based superresolution imaging to reveal the three-dimensional structure of FtsZ in the context of its regulatory proteins: ZapA, ZapB and MatP. We found that these four proteins exist in a multi-layered network that extends from the cell membrane to the chromosome. This layered organization not only helps to stabilize the FtsZ-ring, but also serves to coordinate division with DNA status by influencing constriction rate. Our results not only provide a comprehensive view of the divisome, but also allow new insight to be garnered regarding the structure and function of the divisome.

Stochastic approach to the molecular counting problem in superresolution microscopy

Superresolution imaging methods--now widely used to characterize biological structures below the diffraction limit--are poised to reveal in quantitative detail the stoichiometry of protein complexes in living cells. In practice, the photophysical properties of the fluorophores used as tags in superresolution methods have posed a severe theoretical challenge toward achieving this goal. Here we develop a stochastic approach to enumerate fluorophores in a diffraction-limited area measured by superresolution microscopy. The method is a generalization of aggregated Markov methods developed in the ion channel literature for studying gating dynamics. We show that the method accurately and precisely enumerates fluorophores in simulated data while simultaneously determining the kinetic rates that govern the stochastic photophysics of the fluorophores to improve the prediction's accuracy. This stochastic method overcomes several critical limitations of temporal thresholding methods.

In situ single molecule imaging of cell membranes: linking basic nanotechniques to cell biology, immunology and medicine

The cell membrane, which consists of a viscous phospholipid bilayer, different kinds of proteins and various nano/micrometer-sized domains, plays a very important role in ensuring the stability of the intracellular environment and the order of cellular signal transductions. Exploring the precise cell membrane structure and detailed functions of the biomolecules in a cell membrane would be helpful to understand the underlying mechanisms involved in cell membrane signal transductions, which could further benefit research into cell biology, immunology and medicine. The detection of membrane biomolecules at the single molecule level can provide some subtle information about the molecular structure and the functions of the cell membrane. In particular, information obtained about the molecular mechanisms and other information at the single molecule level are significantly different from that detected from a large amount of biomolecules at the large-scale through traditional techniques, and can thus provide a novel perspective for the study of cell membrane structures and functions. However, the precise investigations of membrane biomolecules prompts researchers to explore cell membranes at the single molecule level by the use of in situ imaging methods, as the exact conformation and functions of biomolecules are highly controlled by the native cellular environment. Recently, the in situ single molecule imaging of cell membranes has attracted increasing attention from cell biologists and immunologists. The size of biomolecules and their clusters on the cell surface are set at the nanoscale, which makes it mandatory to use high- and super-resolution imaging techniques to realize the in situ single molecule imaging of cell membranes. In the past few decades, some amazing imaging techniques and instruments with super resolution have been widely developed for molecule imaging, which can also be further employed for the in situ single molecule imaging of cell membranes. In this review, we attempt to summarize the characteristics of these advanced techniques for use in the in situ single molecule imaging of cell membranes. We believe that this work will help to promote the technological and methodological developments of super-resolution techniques for the single molecule imaging of cell membranes and help researchers better understand which technique is most suitable for their future exploring of membrane biomolecules; ultimately promoting further developments in cell biology, immunology and medicine.

Quantitative analysis of single-molecule superresolution images

This review highlights the quantitative capabilities of single-molecule localization-based superresolution imaging methods. In addition to revealing fine structural details, the molecule coordinate lists generated by these methods provide the critical ability to quantify the number, clustering, and colocalization of molecules with 10-50 nm resolution. Here we describe typical workflows and precautions for quantitative analysis of single-molecule superresolution images. These guidelines include potential pitfalls and essential control experiments, allowing critical assessment and interpretation of superresolution images.

In cellulo evaluation of phototransformation quantum yields in fluorescent proteins used as markers for single-molecule localization microscopy

Single-molecule localization microscopy of biological samples requires a precise knowledge of the employed fluorescent labels. Photoactivation, photoblinking and photobleaching of phototransformable fluorescent proteins influence the data acquisition and data processing strategies to be used in (Fluorescence) Photoactivation Localization Microscopy ((F)-PALM), notably for reliable molecular counting. As these parameters might depend on the local environment, they should be measured in cellulo in biologically relevant experimental conditions. Here, we measured phototransformation quantum yields for Dendra2 fused to actin in fixed mammalian cells in typical (F)-PALM experiments. To this aim, we developed a data processing strategy based on the clustering optimization procedure proposed by Lee et al (PNAS 109, 17436–17441, 2012). Using simulations, we estimated the range of experimental parameters (molecular density, molecular orientation, background level, laser power, frametime) adequate for an accurate determination of the phototransformation yields. Under illumination at 561 nm in PBS buffer at pH 7.4, the photobleaching yield of Dendra2 fused to actin was measured to be (2.5±0.4)×10⁻⁵, whereas the blinking-off yield and thermally-activated blinking-on rate were measured to be (2.3±0.2)×10⁻⁵ and 11.7±0.5 s⁻¹, respectively. These phototransformation yields differed from those measured in poly-vinyl alcohol (PVA) and were strongly affected by addition of the antifading agent 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane (DABCO). In the presence of DABCO, the photobleaching yield was reduced 2-fold, the blinking-off yield was decreased more than 3-fold, and the blinking-on rate was increased 2-fold. Therefore, DABCO largely improved Dendra2 photostability in fixed mammalian cells. These findings are consistent with redox-based bleaching and blinking mechanisms under (F)-PALM experimental conditions. Finally, the green-to-red photoconversion quantum yield of Dendra2 was estimated to be (1.4±0.6)×10⁻⁵in cellulo under 405 nm illumination.

Single molecule techniques in DNA repair: a primer

A powerful new approach has become much more widespread and offers insights into aspects of DNA repair unattainable with billions of molecules. Single molecule techniques can be used to image, manipulate or characterize the action of a single repair protein on a single strand of DNA. This allows search mechanisms to be probed, and the effects of force to be understood. These physical aspects can dominate a biochemical reaction, where at the ensemble level their nuances are obscured. In this paper we discuss some of the many technical advances that permit study at the single molecule level. We focus on DNA repair to which these techniques are actively being applied. DNA repair is also a process that encompasses so much of what single molecule studies benefit--searching for targets, complex formation, sequential biochemical reactions and substrate hand-off to name just a few. We discuss how single molecule biophysics is poised to transform our understanding of biological systems, in particular DNA repair.

Nanoscale effects of ethanol and naltrexone on protein organization in the plasma membrane studied by photoactivated localization microscopy (PALM)

Background

Ethanol affects the signaling of several important neurotransmitter and neuromodulator systems in the CNS. It has been recently proposed that ethanol alters the dynamic lateral organization of proteins and lipids in the plasma membrane, thereby affecting surface receptor-mediated cellular signaling. Our aims are to establish whether pharmacologically relevant levels of ethanol can affect the lateral organization of plasma membrane and cytoskeletal proteins at the nanoscopic level, and investigate the relevance of such perturbations for mu-opioid receptor (MOP) function.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We used Photoactivated Localization Microscopy with pair-correlation analysis (pcPALM), a quantitative fluorescence imaging technique with high spatial resolution (15–25 nm) and single-molecule sensitivity, to study ethanol effects on protein organization in the plasma membrane. We observed that short (20 min) exposure to 20 and 40 mM ethanol alters protein organization in the plasma membrane of cells that harbor endogenous MOPs, causing a rearrangement of the lipid raft marker glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI). These effects could be largely occluded by pretreating the cells with the MOP antagonist naltrexone (200 nM for 3 hours). In addition, ethanol induced pronounced actin polymerization, leading to its partial co-localization with GPI.

Conclusions/Significance

Pharmacologically relevant levels of ethanol alter the lateral organization of GPI-linked proteins and induce actin cytoskeleton reorganization. Pretreatment with the MOP antagonist naltrexone is protective against ethanol action and significantly reduces the extent to which ethanol remodels the lateral organization of lipid-rafts-associated proteins in the plasma membrane. Super-resolution pcPALM reveals details of ethanol action at the nanoscale level, giving new mechanistic insight on the cellular and molecular mechanisms of its action.

In vivo organization of the FtsZ-ring by ZapA and ZapB revealed by quantitative super-resolution microscopy

In most bacterial cells, cell division is dependent on the polymerization of the FtsZ protein to form a ring-like structure (Z-ring) at the midcell. Despite its essential role, the molecular architecture of the Z-ring remains elusive. In this work we examine the roles of two FtsZ-associated proteins, ZapA and ZapB, in the assembly dynamics and structure of the Z-ring in Escherichia coli cells. In cells deleted of zapA or zapB, we observed abnormal septa and highly dynamic FtsZ structures. While details of these FtsZ structures are difficult to discern under conventional fluorescence microscopy, single-molecule-based super-resolution imaging method Photoactivated Localization Microscopy (PALM) reveals that these FtsZ structures arise from disordered arrangements of FtsZ clusters. Quantitative analysis finds these clusters are larger and comprise more molecules than a single FtsZ protofilament, and likely represent a distinct polymeric species that is inherent to the assembly pathway of the Z-ring. Furthermore, we find these clusters are not due to the loss of ZapB-MatP interaction in ΔzapA and ΔzapB cells. Our results suggest that the main function of ZapA and ZapB in vivo may not be to promote the association of individual protofilaments but to align FtsZ clusters that consist of multiple FtsZ protofilaments.