Recipient age and weight affect chronic renal allograft rejection in rats

Potent early immune response after kidney transplantation in patients of the European senior transplant program

BACKGROUND

The increasing age of organ donors and the transplantation of older recipients have become clinical practice. Age-adapted immunosuppressive protocols considering these changes are currently not established. This study analyzed the age-dependent immune response after human kidney transplantation.

METHODS

One hundred renal allograft recipients were prospectively evaluated from 2004 to 2005. Patients older than 65 years of the European Senior Program receiving kidneys from donors older than 65 years were compared with recipients younger than 65 years receiving kidneys from donors younger than 65 years. Age-dependent modifications of the immune response were evaluated before transplantation and 7 days and 6 months after grafting by flow cytometry analysis of lymphocyte surface markers in peripheral blood. The cytokine pattern was determined by Cytometric Bead Array, T-cell alloreactivity by enzyme-linked immunospot analysis.

RESULTS

There were no differences between the groups regarding patient survival, graft survival, and function at 6 months after transplantation. Before transplantation, 7 days and 6 months thereafter recipients older than 65 years demonstrated significantly elevated numbers of memory T-cells while counts for naive T-cells were significantly reduced. Numbers of activated cytotoxic cells were elevated with increasing age before and 7 days after transplantation. T-cell alloreactivity was more pronounced in older recipients at all time points. Seven days after transplantation tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) levels were significantly higher, whereas TNF-alpha and interleukin-10 (IL-10) concentrations were significantly reduced after 6 months in older recipients.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data demonstrate an initially pronounced immune response in elderly recipients receiving grafts from elderly donors. This observation supports the concept of a donor and recipient age-adapted immunosuppression.

Renal ageing

The function of the kidney, as well as its morphology, changes markedly with age. The glomerular filtration rate falls progressively, independent of overt pathology. Glomerular, vascular and accompanying parenchymal changes occur and other disorders associated with ageing, such as diabetes and hypertension, have a stochastic deleterious effect on both form and function. Declining renal function with age has important implications, not only for individual homeostasis but also for the use of drug therapy and for the receipt and donation of organs for transplantation. Molecular mechanisms and cellular changes underlying some of the functional and structural changes associated with ageing are becoming clearer, as are some of the ways in which genetic background, age and disease can combine to produce functional damage.

Heart allograft protection with low-dose carbon monoxide inhalation: effects on inflammatory mediators and alloreactive T-cell responses

BACKGROUND

Carbon monoxide (CO), a byproduct of heme catalysis, has lately received considerable attention as a regulatory molecule in cellular and biological processes. CO has been shown to provide potent protection against a variety of tissue injuries. We hypothesized in this study that low concentration CO would be beneficial for organ allografts, which frequently undergo several types of injury such as ischemia/reperfusion, alloimmune reaction, and inflammation

METHODS

The efficacy of low-dose CO was examined in a fully allogeneic LEW to BN rat heterotopic heart transplantation (HHTx) model. Recipients were kept in air or exposed to low-dose CO (20 ppm) for 14, 28, or 100 days after HHTx under short-course tacrolimus

RESULTS

CO treatment (d0-28, 0-100) was remarkably effective in prolonging heart allograft survival to a median of >100 from 45 days in the air-control group, with significant reductions of arteritis, fibrosis, and cellular infiltration, including macrophages and T cells. CO inhibited intragraft upregulation of Th1 type cytokines (IL-2, IFNgamma), proinflammatory mediators (IL-1beta, TNFalpha, IL-6, COX-2), and adhesion molecule. Shorter CO exposure in early (0-13d) and late (14-28d) posttransplant periods also prolonged graft survival, with a significant inhibition of inflammatory mediators

CONCLUSIONS

These results show that low dose CO inhalation protects heart allografts and can considerably prolong their survival. CO appears to function via multiple mechanisms, including direct inhibition of Th1 type cytokine production and regulation of inflammatory responses.

Lectin-like oxidized low-density lipoprotein (LDL) receptor (LOX-1)-mediated pathway and vascular oxidative injury in older-age rat renal transplants

BACKGROUND

Older-age renal allografts are associated with inferior survival; however, the mechanisms are unclear. Reactive oxygen species participate in aging and in chronic vascular disease. We investigated how mediators of oxidative stress may increase allograft susceptibility to vascular injury.

METHODS

We employed the low-responder allogeneic F344-to-Lew rat renal transplantation model. We used nonimmunosuppressed young (donors and recipients aged 12 weeks), old (donors and recipients aged 52 weeks), and old-to-young animal (donors aged 52 weeks and recipients aged 12 weeks) combinations. Grafts were transplanted after 2 hours cold preservation in University of Wisconsin solution and harvested 1, 2, 7 and 10 days later. Additionally, old animals receiving continuous 1.5 mg/kg cyclosporine (CyA) immunosuppression were included. Renal allograft pathology was scored according to Banff criteria. We studied intragraft vascular adhesion molecule-1 (VCAM-1), lectin-like oxidized low-density lipoprotein (LDL) receptor-1 (LOX-1), and hypochlorite-modified LDL expression as well as ED-1+ monocytes/macrophages and CD8+ lymphocyte infiltration. Intragraft in situ superoxide anion radical production was determined with dihydroethidium assay on cryosections.

RESULTS

During the first 2 posttransplant days, old transplants demonstrated higher functional impairment and increased oxidative stress, while young transplant had higher ED-1+ monocytes/macrophage infiltration and VCAM-1 expression. The degree of VCAM-1 expression and ED-1+ monocytes/macrophage and CD8+ lymphocyte infiltration correlated at later time points directly with the transplant age. VCAM-1 and LOX-1 staining were localized predominantly on the endothelium of arterial vessels, shifting the distribution to vascular smooth muscle layer strongly dependent on donor age and the grade of vascular injury. LOX-1 staining colocalized with hypochlorite-modified epitopes in the media of injured arteries. We measured increased in situ superoxide anion radical production in corresponding areas. Immunosuppression with CyA had no protective effect on vascular injury and LOX-1 expression.

CONCLUSION

Induction of LOX-1-related oxidation pathways and increased susceptibility to oxidative stress could play an important role in promoting vascular injury in old renal transplants independent of the recipient age.

Aging and Transplant Arteriosclerosis in Absence of Alloreactivity and Immunosuppressive Drugs in a Rat Aortic Model: Recipient Age???s Contribution

BACKGROUND

Almost half of all transplanted vascularized organ grafts will be lost to transplant arteriosclerosis sometime posttransplantation. Organ shortage for primary transplants and retransplants has led to donor-pool expansion to include elderly donors, knowing that aging per se promotes arteriosclerosis. The current understanding that donor age negatively affects organ and/or patient survival outcome is undermined by variables such as the use of immunosuppressive drugs, their toxicity to the graft, degree of donor-recipient histocompatibility, and the resulting chronic rejection. The purpose of this study was to determine whether the donor's age or recipient's age matters the most in transplant arteriosclerosis in the absence of such variables.

METHODS

A syngeneic combination was used where young (2-month-old) and old (22-month-old) donor aortas were injured to initiate neointimal thickening, then transplanted into age-mismatched recipients for 14, 60, and 90 days and then assessed for neointimal thickening. Base level injury response due ischemia and surgery was evaluated in age-matched and noninjured aortic grafts, respectively.

RESULTS

Young aortas invariably developed thicker neointima when transplanted into old recipients than when transplanted into young ones. Correspondingly, old aortas transplanted in young recipients consistently developed less neointimal thickening than when transplanted into old recipients.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings strongly suggest that the severity of age-related neointima formation is primarily determined by the recipient's age rather than the donor's age. Therefore, in addition to focusing on donor-specific tolerance induction, strategies aiming at increasing the lifespan of vascularized organ grafts also have to take into consideration the recipient's aging milieu.

Influence of aging on tooth eruption: experimental canine mandibular allograft

PURPOSE

Aging is clinically related to tooth eruption; however, there are no known studies that have elucidated the relationship. We examined whether tooth eruption would occur normally in a mature subject.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Using vascularized composite tissue mandibular transplantation, we extracted portions of immature mandibles including the tooth germs from young beagle dogs and placed them into unrelated immature and mature beagle dogs. We then examined eruption of the lower first molar in the grafted mandibular bone and compared the results clinically, radiographically, and histologically.

RESULTS

Normal tooth eruption was observed in the transplanted mandibles in the young dogs. In the mature dogs, eruption from the gingiva was delayed, whereas that from alveolar bone occurred normally in the transplanted mandibles. Further, the whole crown was covered with a cap of gingival tissue in the mature dogs, although this cap was not gingival overgrowth.

CONCLUSIONS

Tooth eruption is influenced by some unknown factors related to aging. Apparently, apoptosis did not occur in the connective tissues between the reduced enamel epithelia and oral epithelia that overlay the teeth in the mature subjects.

Alterations of the immune response with increasing recipient age are associated with reduced long-term organ graft function of rat kidney allografts1

BACKGROUND

Clinically, an increasing number of older recipients are listed for transplantation. We examined recipient age-associated alterations of the immune response and their effects on graft function.

METHODS

Three- and 18-month-old Lewis (LEW) rats received kidneys from 3- and 18-month-old Fischer 344 (F344) rats (1.5 mg/kg/d cyclosporine A for 10 days; n=6/group) and were observed for 180 days. In additional groups, double kidney transplantations were performed to determine the impact of nephron mass and recipient age on graft outcome.

RESULTS

All young recipients but only 66% of old recipients survived the observation period. Increasing recipient age resulted in a significant decrease in renal allograft function (P<0.001), more advanced morphologic evidence of chronic allograft damage (P<0.001), and greater cellular infiltration (P<0.05) and major histocompatibility complex expression (P<0.01) within grafts. Additional in vitro studies examined age-related changes in the cellular immune response by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, fluorescence-activated cell sorter analysis, and alloreactive enzyme-linked immunospot: splenocytes from old LEW rats produced significantly more interleukin (IL)-2 (P<0.0001), IL-4 (P<0.05), interferon (IFN)-gamma (P<0.0001), and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (P<0.05). IFN-gamma-producing memory-type T cells were significantly elevated in older rats (P<0.0001). Moreover, they revealed significantly more alloreactive T cells directed against F344 (146 +/- 64.2 and 512 +/- 277/10(6) T cells; P<0.05). Double renal allografts from young donors into old recipients confirmed an independent effect of recipient age on the acceleration of chronic graft deterioration.

CONCLUSIONS

The enhanced cellular immune responsiveness in elderly recipients was associated with advanced chronic graft injury. Clinically, older recipients may need a modified immunosuppression.

Apoptosis and treatment of chronic allograft nephropathy with everolimus

BACKGROUND

Chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN) is responsible for most cases of late kidney allograft loss. However, no effective treatment is available so far. Everolimus (RAD) (40-O [2-hydroxyethyl] rapamycin) is a new immunosuppressive agent with antiproliferative and apoptosis-enhancing effects. We asked whether everolimus can ameliorate CAN even at advanced stages, whether everolimus treatment affects the level of growth factor mRNA, and whether everolimus treatment affects the number of apoptotic cells in the graft.

METHODS

We transplanted kidneys from Fisher rats into Lewis rats and treated recipients with everolimus over different time periods. Grafts were analyzed 20 or 28 weeks after transplantation.

RESULTS

Everolimus delayed the progression of CAN when started at an early stage. Surprisingly, everolimus even ameliorated CAN when initiated at an advanced stage. Interestingly, apoptosis was more prevalent in treated animals, particularly in those with delayed treatment as compared with controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Everolimus ameliorates CAN as a result of antiproliferative or apoptosis-enhancing effects.

The marginal kidney donor

In parallel with increased clinical demand, less than optimal or so-called marginal kidney grafts are being used for transplantation. In addition to donor age, it appears that several factors may impact negatively on the quality of the graft. Most importantly, a more precise definition of the term 'marginal graft' is needed. The present review analyzes potential risk factors, suggests scoring systems for a more precise definition, and discusses potential treatment options to improve the quality of marginal grafts.

Strain differences in angiotensin-converting enzyme and angiotensin II type I receptor expression. Possible implications for experimental chronic renal transplant failure

BACKGROUND

The Fisher to Lewis (F-L) model of renal transplantation (Rtx) is widely used. Rtx from F to L without immunosuppressive treatment results in 50% survival, whereas L to F results in survival rates similar to syngrafts. When treated with an angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitor or antihypertensive triple therapy, renal damage is markedly reduced in F-L allografts. Despite similar reductions in blood pressure, the ACE inhibitor (ACE-I) is more effective than antihypertensive triple therapy, suggesting that the inhibition of intrarenal ACE plays an additional role in the attenuation of renal damage.

METHODS

In the present study, we investigated strain-related differences in intrarenal ACE activity between F and L rats and whether treatment with ACE-I in F-L allografted rats results in reduction of intrarenal ACE. Intrarenal ACE was measured by activity assays, immunohistochemistry and PCR.

RESULTS

In control kidneys from healthy F rats (n=8), we found a four-fold higher ACE activity than in native L rats (n=8, p<0.01). This was confirmed by a three-fold difference in ACE mRNA expression (n=5 for both, p<0.01). Using immunohistochemistry, we found strong tubular ACE expression in the F rat, whereas the L rat had no tubular ACE at all. In F-L allografts (n=9) we noted significant glomerulosclerosis and proteinuria after 34 weeks. Treatment with ACE-I in F-L (n=8) prevented the development of these changes. Although ACE mRNA and ACE protein expression were similar in treated and untreated allografts, intrarenal ACE activity was reduced by 50% in allografts with ACE-I.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, intrarenal levels of ACE may play a role in the development of renal damage in experimental chronic renal transplant failure.