Progressive autoimmune beta cell insufficiency: occurrence in the absence of high-risk HLA alleles DR3, DR4

Type 1 diabetes pathogenesis - Prevention???

Pathogenesis of type 1 diabetes is multi-faceted, including, autoimmunity, genetics and environment. Autoimmunity directed against pancreatic islet cells results in slowly progressive selective beta-cell destruction ("Primary autoimmune insulitis"), culminating over years in clinically manifested insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM). Circulating serum autoantibodies directed against the endocrine cells of the islets of Langerhans (Islet cell autoantibodies - ICAb) are an important hallmark of this disease. Assays for islet cell autoantibodies have facilitated the investigation and understanding of several facets in the pathogenesis of autoimmune diabetes. Their applications have extended into clinical practice and have opened new avenues for early preclinical prediction and preventive prophylaxis in IDDM/type 1 DM. Recently, surprisingly, differences in insulin content between T1DM islets, as well as, 'patchy' or 'lobular' destruction of islets have been described. These unique pathobiological phenomena, suggest that beta cell destruction may not always be inexorable and inevitably complete/total, and thus raise hopes for possible therapeutic interruption of beta cell autoimmunity - destruction and cure of type 1 diabetes. "Recurrent or secondary autoimmune insulitis" refers to the rapid reappearance of islet cell autoantibodies post pancreas transplant, and selective islet beta cell destruction in the grafted pancreas [never forgetting or "anamnestic" beta cell destructive memory], in the absence of any graft pancreas rejection [monozygotic twin to twin transplantation]. The one definite environmental factor is congenital rubella, because of which a subset of children subsequently develop type 1 diabetes. The putative predisposing factors are viruses, gluten and cow's milk. The putative protective factors include gut flora, helminths, viral infections, and Vitamin D. Prevention of T1DM can include: Primary prevention strategies before the development of autoantibodies and Secondary prevention regimens after autoantibody development. Once islet cell autoantibodies have developed, the goal is to establish a therapeutic regimen to preserve at least 90% of the beta cells, and prevent the development of hyperglycaemia. The targets for T1DM reversal should include autoimmunity, beta cell regeneration and protection of beta cell mass. Anti-CD3 teplizumab and anti-CD3 otelixizumab have been shown to provide C-peptide preservation. The unanswered questions in diabetes research include elimination of autoimmune memory responses, reestablishment of immune self-tolerance, and mechanisms of disease initiation.

Masked and overt autoantibodies specific to the DPD epitope of 65-kDa glutamate decarboxylase (GAD65-DPD) are associated with preserved β-cell functional reserve in ketosis-prone diabetes

CONTEXT

Ketosis-prone diabetes (KPD), defined by presentation with diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA), comprises 4 subgroups based on the presence or absence of islet cell autoantibodies (A(-) or A(+)) and β-cell functional reserve (β(-) or β(+)). Among A(+) KPD, autoantibody epitope reactivity to 65-kDa glutamate decarboxylase (GAD65), defined by monoclonal GAD65Ab(DPD), was associated with greater β-cell functional reserve. In a majority of healthy individuals, GAD65Ab are present in the sera but are masked by anti-idiotypic antibodies; in contrast, overtly GAD65Ab-positive patients with autoimmune type 1 diabetes patients lack these anti-idiotypic antibodies.

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to determine the presence of masked and overt GAD65Ab(DPD) in relation to β-cell function and genetic risk factors in KPD patients.

DESIGN

We investigated the associations of masked and overt GAD65Ab(DPD) with β-cell functional reserve, and their relationship with human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class II haplotypes linked to autoimmune diabetes susceptibility or resistance, in a large KPD cohort.

PATIENTS

Adult KPD patients (n = 384) were followed longitudinally in a research clinic.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

β-Cell function, autoantibody status, GAD65Ab epitopes, and HLA class II haplotypes were evaluated.

RESULTS

Overall, KPD patients with β-cell functional reserve (β(+) subgroups) showed significantly higher frequency of masked GAD65Ab(DPD) than patients without β-cell functional reserve (β(-) subgroups): 112 of 144 (79%) compared with 59 of 100 (59%), respectively (P = .002). Masked or overt GAD65Ab(DPD) were also more frequent among autoantibody-positive patients with preserved β-cell functional reserve (A(+)β(+) KPD) than those lacking β-cell function (A(+)β(-) KPD): 77% compared with 55% (P = .01). The susceptibility HLA haplotypes DQA1*0301/DQB1*0302 and DQA1*0301/DQB1*0201 were associated with absence of overt or masked GAD65Ab(DPD) (odds Ratios 2.3 and 2.2, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Masked GAD65Ab(DPD) are strongly associated with preserved β-cell functional reserve among patients with KPD. Absence of GAD65Ab(DPD) reactivity is associated with 2 HLA class II susceptibility haplotypes for autoimmune type 1 diabetes.

Metabolic abnormalities in the pathogenesis of type 1 diabetes

Clinical onset of type 1 diabetes (T1D) is thought to result from a combination of overt beta cell loss and beta cell dysfunction. However, our understanding of how beta cell metabolic abnormalities arise during the pathogenesis of disease remains incomplete. Despite extensive research on the autoimmune nature of T1D, questions remain regarding the time frame and nature of beta cell destruction and dysfunction. This review focuses on the characterizations of beta cell dysfunction in the prediabetic and T1D human and mouse model. Studies have shown evidence supporting progressive loss of beta cell mass and function prior to T1D onset, while other scientists argue beta cell destruction occurs later in the disease process. Determining the time frame of beta cell destruction and identifying metabolic mechanisms that drive beta cell dysfunction has high potential for successful interventions to maintain insulin secretion for individuals with established T1D as well as those with prediabetes.

HLA class II alleles specify phenotypes of ketosis-prone diabetes

OBJECTIVE

Ketosis-prone diabetes (KPD) comprises four subgroups based on the presence or absence of beta-cell autoantibodies (A+ or A-) and beta-cell functional reserve (beta+ or beta-). Genetic factors could contribute to their distinctive phenotypes. Our aim was to specify the role of HLA class II alleles associated with susceptibility or resistance to autoimmune type 1 diabetes in determining KPD phenotypes.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

A total of 185 adults presenting with diabetic ketoacidosis were followed longitudinally for a mean of 5.5 years, with measurements of autoantibodies, beta-cell functional reserve, insulin sensitivity, and insulin requirement. Frequencies of susceptibility and resistance alleles at HLA DQA1, DQB1, and DRB1 loci were correlated with clinical and phenotypic features of KPD subgroups and compared with those of ethnic-specific population control subjects.

RESULTS

Susceptibility alleles were more frequent (P < 0.0001) in the two A+ than the two A- KPD subgroups; in the latter, the frequency was no greater than in population control subjects (except for DQB1*0302). Susceptibility alleles differentiated the two clinically similar beta- subgroups (more frequent in A+beta- than A-beta- KPD; P < 0.01). Resistance alleles were more frequent in the two beta+ than the two beta- KPD subgroups (P < 0.01). The frequencies of certain susceptibility (e.g., DQB1*02) and resistance (DQB1*0602) alleles were higher in African-American A-beta+ KPD patients than in African-American control subjects. DQB1*0302 was more frequent in all KPD subgroups compared with control subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

HLA class II alleles associated with susceptibility or resistance to autoimmune type 1 diabetes help specify the four subgroups of KPD. Inheritance of these alleles may influence long-term beta-cell functional reserve.

The role of affiliative loss in the recruitment of helper cells among insulin-dependent diabetics

The study was undertaken to determine whether affiliative loss might play a role in the development of insulin-dependent diabetes by increasing the percentage of helper-inducer T cells when diabetics were reminded of the loss. It was found that diabetics who had experienced the recent death of a loved one showed a marked increase in helper cells, in contrast to diabetics who had not experienced a recent death, after both groups viewed a film about a happy, but doomed, love affair. The diabetics who had experienced a recent death also showed more affiliative distress after viewing the film. This increase in distress was associated with a physiological sign of increased activation, namely, increased plasma cortisol output, which in turn was associated with gains in helper-cell percentages. This suggests that frequent reminders of severe affiliative disturbances during the pre-onset histories of such diabetics may result in physiological activation, which leads to periodical recruitment of helper cells, which could augment the immune attack on the insulin-producing cells in the pancreas. None of these results was obtained with controls, which suggests that the diabetics were unusually sensitive to affiliative distress.

Predictive value of intravenous glucose tolerance test insulin secretion less than or greater than the first percentile in islet cell antibody positive relatives of type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetic patients

We have followed-up 35 islet cell antibody-positive first degree relatives of patients with Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus for an average of 1,300 days with sequential intravenous glucose tolerance tests. At the time of analysis and manuscript submission approximately half (18 of 35) had developed diabetes during follow-up. At initial intravenous glucose tolerance test, 11 had a 1 + 3 min insulin secretion below the first percentile of insulin secretion compared to 225 similarly studied normal control subjects. Six islet cell antibody positive relatives on follow-up developed an intravenous glucose tolerance test less than the first percentile. Fifteen out of 17 (88%) of these islet cell antibody positive relatives with secretion ever found to be below the first percentile are now overtly diabetic (positive predictive value = 88%) and insulin-treated, while only 3 of 18 (17%) without an intravenous glucose tolerance test demonstrating loss of first phase insulin secretion have progressed to diabetes (with approximately 1,300 days of follow-up for both groups relative risk or odds ratio with intravenous glucose tolerance test ever below vs never below the first percentile = 38, p less than 0.001). Intravenous glucose tolerance test response below the first percentile preceded diabetes by an average of 656 days. Even when first phase insulin secretion is below the first percentile, the absolute value of 1 + 3 min insulin above basal insulin correlates with the time to development of diabetes (r = 0.586, p less than 0.001). With our current duration of follow-up, the negative predictive value (intravenous glucose tolerance test never below the first percentile) is 83%, and overall accuracy 86%. Incidence rates of diabetes development amongst our islet cell antibody positive relatives with follow-up while intravenous glucose tolerance test is below the first percentile is 0.48 per year (15 conversions to diabetes amongst 17 relatives in 30.8 patient years of follow-up) vs 0.05 per year (three diabetic patients in 55.5 patient years) with intravenous glucose tolerance test greater than the first percentile.

Immunological aspects of diabetes mellitus: prospects for pharmacological modification

It is now well known that insulin-dependent diabetes is a chronic progressive autoimmune disease. The prolonged prediabetic phase of progressive beta-cell dysfunction is associated with immunological abnormalities. A prediabetic period is suggested by the appearance of islet cell antibodies, anti-insulin antibodies, and anti-insulin receptor antibodies. The existence of activated T lymphocytes and abnormal T cell subsets are also other markers. There is still no concensus about the use of the immunosuppression superimposed upon conventional insulin therapy in early diagnosed IDDM and the follow-up of the relatives of IDDM patients who share the genetic predisposition and serological markers for the risk of future onset of IDDM. Treatment in the prodromal period cannot be justified because a link between the disease and early markers such as ICA has not been established with certainty (Diabetes Research Program NIH, 1983). Many immunopharmacological manipulations were reported to be effective in animal models. However, most of them are not readily applied to human subjects. Moreover, IDDM patients are now believed to be heterogeneous, with a complex genetic background. HLA-DR, and more recently DQ, are closely related to the genetic predisposition to IDDM but those genes are not themselves diabetogenic. The contribution of autoimmunity does not appear to be uniform, and in some cases, the contribution of virus is considered more important. There is a lack of a marker for the future onset of IDDM. ICA and ICSA were found after mumps infection, but the existence of those autoantibodies and even the co-existence of HLA-DR3 do not always indicate the future trend to insulin dependency. More precise markers will be disclosed through the biochemical analysis of the target antigens on pancreatic beta-cell for islet antibodies and effector T cells. Much safer and more effective immunopharmacological treatment will be developed through animal experimentation using rat and mouse models. The recent development and interest in this field will further facilitate the attainment of the goal for the complete prevention of IDDM.

Analysis of DR and DQ gene products of the DR4 haplotype in patients with IDDM: possible involvement of more than one locus

Fifteen DR4-bearing haplotypes from twelve patients with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) were analyzed serologically, cellularly, and biochemically. The HLA-Dw composition of these DR4-positive haplotypes was Dw4 (46%), Dw14 (22%), and Dw10 (33%). The biochemical analysis by two-dimensional electrophoresis (2D-PAGE) of the DR beta chains showed that each Dw specificity is characterized by a specific DR4 beta chain that appears to be identical in normal and diabetic individuals. Analysis of DQ beta chains in the DR4-bearing haplotypes revealed that certain Dw specificities such as Dw4 are characterized by the presence of either the DQw7 (formerly DQw3.1) or DQw8 (formerly DQw3.2) alleles, which generate the Dw4.1 or Dw4.2 subtypes, respectively. Others such as Dw14 and Dw10 are characterized by the presence of the DQw8 allele. In our sample of 12 patients the Dw4.2 (Dw4, DR4 beta I-4 DQw8) and Dw10 (Dw10, DR4 beta I-1, DQw8) subtypes were predominant. It is concluded that individual DR beta and DQ beta gene products from the DR4-bearing haplotype of IDDM patients are identical to those of normal control subjects and that Dw14 as well as Dw10 are involved in disease susceptibility. We suggest that disease susceptibility may be influenced by more than one locus within the HLA-D region.

Polymorphisms of DQ beta genes in HLA-DR4 haplotypes from healthy and diabetic individuals

The restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) of DQ beta was assessed in a panel of control and insulin-dependent diabetes (IDD) patients who were serologically typed as HLA-DR4 homozygotes or HLA-DR3, DR4 heterozygotes. Digestions of genomic DNA with Bam HI, Bgl II, Pst I, Xba I, and Hind III revealed a total of 15 RFLPs in the panel of 71 HLA-DR4 chromosomes. These RFLPs were organized into six allelic groups on the basis of segregation analysis in families. Complete RFLP haplotypes for the 5 restriction enzymes could be constructed for 42 of the HLA-DR4 chromosomes. This analysis revealed 18 RFLP haplotypes of DQ beta associated with the DR4 chromosomes tested. Two of these haplotypes, designated DQ3.DR4. a and DQ3.DR4.b, accounted for over 50% of the DR4 chromosomes analyzed. These two haplotypes were antithetical for the RFLPs detected by all five enzymes, indicating that they represent very distinct forms of DQ beta. The remaining 16 haplotypes were infrequent or unique and were closely related to either a DQ3.DR4.a or DQ3.DR4.b. Two of the RFLPs detected, a 5.8 kb Bgl II fragment and a 10.5 kb Bam HI fragment, had increased frequencies in disease-associated chromosomes. However, none of the RFLPs we detected exhibited a statistically significant increase in IDD or control populations. In contrast, the DQ3.DR4.b DQ beta haplotype was significantly decreased in IDD-associated DR4 chromosomes (P = 0.04). These results suggest that the DQ3.DR4.b DQ beta allele may be protective for the development of IDD.