The Determination of Insulin Overdose in Postmortem Investigations

Semaglutide and GLP-1 Agonists: Forensic and Medicolegal Implications

ABSTRACT

This article is intended as a brief review on the glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) agonist Semaglutide (Ozempic®, Rybelsus®, Wegovy®), an antidiabetic medication that has gained significant popularity in the United States for its role in long-term weight-loss management. While current research on GLP-1 agonists, including semaglutide, focuses primarily on their therapeutic effects in managing diabetes and obesity, information regarding their forensic and medicolegal significance is limited. Concerns related to GLP-1 agonists may arise due to their pharmacokinetics, potential drug-drug interactions, and side effects including hypoglycemia, which can be relevant in cases involving human performance, such as impaired driving, or in unexpected fatalities. Semaglutide additionally presents analytical challenges due to its large, highly charged molecular structure and potentially limited stability in whole blood, which may complicate its detection and quantification in forensic laboratories using common instrumentation. The development of robust analytical methods will be essential to account for its pharmacological effects and to address its potential role in intoxications or unexplained fatalities, especially in the context of misuse or off-label use for weight loss. A strong case can be made for the necessity of further research into the detection, quantification, and interpretation of semaglutide concentrations in forensic toxicology casework.

Insulin-Related Suicides-3 Cases

Insulin is a pancreas-produced hormone, which is essential for normal life. In persons with diabetes, who lack sufficient production of endogenous insulin, the availability of exogenously-produced and administered insulin represents an extremely valuable, life-preserving medical advancement. Unfortunately, as with many other medications, overdosage with insulin can and does occur, sometimes in an intentional suicidal manner. Another possible insulin-related suicidal action involves the intentional cessation of insulin therapy by someone who relies on insulin for survival. In this case series, we present 3 cases of insulin-related suicides, including two related to intentional insulin overdose and one where a known diabetic purposefully stopped taking insulin in order to commit suicide.

Intentional Insulin Overdose and Depression in Subjects with and Without Diabetes Mellitus: A Commentary

Insulin is an essential medication for people with type 1 diabetes mellitus and for some people with type 2 diabetes. Interestingly, insulin abuse has been reported as a mode of suicide, not only among people with diabetes, but also among their relatives, and among medical and paramedical personnel who have access to insulin. The aim of the present commentary was to raise awareness of potential depression-related intentional insulin overdose and its complications, as well as of the diagnosis and treatment of this entity. Insulin overdose may lead to severe and prolonged hypoglycemia, hypoglycemic coma, and death. Moreover, hypokalemia, hypomagnesemia, hypophosphatemia, and elevated liver enzymes are common. Insulin overdose should be suspected among people with diabetes in case of unexplained prolonged hypoglycemia and among people without diabetes who exhibit hypoglycemia and may have access to diabetic medications. The ratio of insulin to C-peptide helps distinguish exogenous insulin administration from endogenous secretion. The cornerstone of therapy is prompt administration of concentrated glucose infusions for days with simultaneous oral intake, when possible, and intense glucose monitoring to prevent hypoglycemia. Moreover, monitoring of serum electrolyte levels is recommended. Finally, psychiatric evaluation aiming at early identification of depression and suicidality is of paramount importance.

A retrospective study of 29 fatal cases of insulin overdose

PURPOSE

To summarize recent cases of fatal insulin poisoning both domestically and internationally, thereby offering valuable insights for the forensic identification of insulin overdose cases.

METHODS

Literature published since 2000 on fatal insulin overdose were systematically searched and screened. Data encompassing variables such as year, age, sex, cause of death, scene conditions, occupations, medical histories of victims and perpetrators, autopsy timing, dosage and administration methods, forensic pathology, and toxicological analysis, were compiled for rigorous statistical analysis.

RESULTS

Among the 29 fatal cases of insulin poisoning, suicides and homicides accounted for 55.2 % and 41.4 %, respectively. Precisely 34.5 % of victims or perpetrators were associated with the medical industry, 27.6 % had diabetes, and 24.1 % had mental illnesses such as depression. Intravenous injection resulted in quicker death than did subcutaneous injection. In some cases, immunohistochemical staining of insulin and protamine at injection sites yielded positive results. The average molar ratio of insulin to C-peptide in post-mortem blood was 13.76 ± 5.167, indicating a significant diagnostic value for insulin poisoning.

CONCLUSION

Assessment of cases of fatal insulin overdose should be thorough, incorporating case investigation, scene examination, medical records review, autopsy findings, pathological examinations, and laboratory tests, alongside considering the condition of the body and timing of death autopsy. Using mass spectrometry to detect insulin proves valuable, particularly in cases of poor body preservation.

Insulin overdose with fatal outcome?: Two forensic cases

Intentional overdose with insulin preparations is rare. However, fatal consequences due to severe hypoglycemia could occur. Postmortem toxicology screening of insulin is a challenge, given the chemical characteristics of this protein and the difficulty of distinguishing between endogenous and exogenous insulin in blood. Here, we describe two cases of patients with diabetes using insulin and oral anti-diabetics. The main question in both cases was whether or not disturbance in glucose metabolism contributed to death. In case A, there was strong evidence that self-poisoning with insulin and subsequent hypoglycemia caused the death. However, this could not be confirmed due to lack of adequate forensic toxicology tests. In case B, no hypoglycemia was observed. Though, compared with case A, additional forensic examination was performed to investigate whether glycemic disturbances could have contributed to the death. In this report, we focus on the most appropriate analytical methods for the detection of exogenous insulin in the human body and give recommendations for toxicology testing of glucose levels and insulin in postmortem specimens.

Is it really possible to kill with insulin without leaving traces? From lifesaver to killer, the issues surrounding the analytical characterization of postmortem insulin illustrated by an exemplary case

Evidence of an insulin overdose is very complicated in the medico-legal field. The analysis and subsequent interpretation of results is complex, especially when treating postmortem blood samples. The instability of insulin, the special pre-analytical conditions and the absence of specific analytical methods has led most laboratories not to analyze insulin in their routine with a consequent underestimation of cases. This paper aims to assess the difficulties associated with the analytical characterization of insulin by describing a case that typically represents most of the inconveniences encountered following a suspected insulin overdose. The case concerns a man found dead at home by his brother. After an external examination, which did not reveal a specific cause of death, toxicological analysis was requested which did not reveal any substance of toxicological interest. Only 9 months later, it was reported to the toxicologist that the subject was diabetic, on insulin lispro treatment and that three empty syringes were found next to his body. Following analysis by LC-high-resolution mass spectrometry, the presence of insulin lispro at a concentration of 1.1 ng/mL, a therapeutic concentration, was evidenced. Despite the low concentration found, overdose cannot be excluded and this paper will describe the criteria evaluated to reach this conclusion. This case highlights that the interpretation of a postmortem insulin concentration is very complex and requires the evaluation of various elements including the circumstances of death, the subject's medical history, the interval between death and sampling and the sample storage.

A histopathologically diagnosed case of hypoglycemic encephalopathy due to insulin overdose

A 70-year-old man presented with cardiopulmonary arrest. Previous medical history included orally medicated diabetes mellitus, hypertension, stroke, and depression. The family observed that the patient had been sleeping for approximately 10 h. He was brought to the hospital and pronounced dead. Postmortem blood examinations revealed a blood insulin level of 0.54 μU/mL, C-peptide level of 0.14 ng/mL, and blood glucose of 9 mg/dL. Autopsy revealed an injection scar with intradermal hemorrhage and a subcutaneous hemorrhage in the left abdomen measuring 0.2 cm in diameter. Histopathological analysis revealed hemorrhage and inflammatory cell infiltration in the scar. Furthermore, subcutaneous adipose tissue, perivascular area, and neurons stained positive for anti-insulin antibody. HE staining of the brain revealed mild edema, and anti-GFAP antibody revealed clasmatodendrosis with bead-like staining of astrocyte subdivisions in the cerebral gray matter. Postmortem blood glucose evaluation is difficult because blood glucose levels are not stable and blood insulin is degraded relatively quickly. However, the cause of death was determined to be hypoglycemic encephalopathy due to insulin overdose because insulin was detected in the skin at the injection site. Furthermore, immunohistochemical examination of the brain revealed findings that were consistent with hypoglycemic encephalopathy. Therefore, histological examination was useful for postmortem diagnosis. J. Med. Invest. 71 : 340-342, August, 2024.

Biochemical Toxicological Study of Insulin Overdose in Rats: A Forensic Perspective

Due to nonspecific pathological changes and the rapid degradation of insulin in postmortem blood samples, the identification of the cause of death during insulin overdose has always been a difficulty in forensic medicine. At present, there is a lack of studies on the toxicological changes and related mechanisms of an insulin overdose, and the specific molecular markers of insulin overdose are still unclear. In this study, an animal model of insulin overdose was established, and 24 SD rats were randomly divided into a control group, insulin overdose group, and a recovery group (n = 8). We detected the biochemical changes and analyzed the toxicological mechanism of an insulin overdose. The results showed that after insulin overdose, the rats developed irregular convulsions, Eclampsia, Opisthotonos, and other symptoms. The levels of glucose, glycogen, and C-peptide in the body decreased significantly, while the levels of lactate, insulin, and glucagon increased significantly. The decrease in plasma K+ was accompanied by the increase in skeletal muscle K+. The PI3K-AKT signaling pathway was significantly activated in skeletal muscle, and the translocation of GLUT4/Na+-K+-ATPase to sarcolemma was significantly increased. Rare glycogenic hepatopathy occurred in the recovery group after insulin overdose. Our study showed that insulin overdose also plays a role in skeletal muscle cells, mainly through the PI3K-Akt signaling pathway. Therefore, the detection of signaling pathway proteins of the skeletal muscle cell membrane GLUT4 and Na+-K+-ATPase has a certain auxiliary diagnostic value for forensic insulin overdose identification. Glycogen detection in the liver and skeletal muscle is important for the diagnosis of insulin overdose, but it still needs to be differentiated from other causes of death. Skeletal muscle has great potential for insulin detection, and the ratio of insulin to the C-peptide (I:C) can determine whether an exogenous insulin overdose is present.

Insulin murder and the case of Colin Norris

Although insulin is an essential medicine and a life-saving drug, it has also been incriminated in many poisoning deaths; accidental, suicidal and some with malicious intent. Overdosing with insulin precipitates a life-threatening state of hypoglycemia and if untreated leads to coma, irreversible brain damage and death. Normally, the pancreatic β-cells secrete equimolar amounts of insulin and C-peptide into the portal venous blood, although under physiological conditions the plasma concentration ratio (insulin/C-peptide) is less than unity, because insulin is more susceptible to hepatic first-pass metabolism. A high ratio of insulin/C-peptide in plasma from a poisoned patient is compelling evidence that pharmaceutical insulin was administered, which does not contain C-peptide. The analysis of insulin and C-peptide was traditionally done by immunoassay methods (RIA and/or ELISA), although high resolution LC-MS/MS is more suitable for forensic purposes and permits the identification of insulin analogues. Use of insulin as a murder weapon is exemplified by the case of Colin Norris, a male nurse found guilty of murdering four elderly patients and the attempted murder of a fifth by injecting them with insulin. However, the prosecution evidence against Norris was mainly circumstantial and hearsay. Toxicological evidence against Norris consisted of a high insulin/C-peptide concentration ratio in plasma from one of the victims. This analysis was done by an immunoassay method at a clinical laboratory and not a forensic laboratory. Analytical procedures, including chain-of-custody routines, are more stringent at forensic laboratories. Since his conviction, some of the medical evidence against Norris has been called into question, especially the prevalence of spontaneous attacks of hypoglycemia in elderly and frail patients with co-morbidities.

Influence of Preservatives on Insulin in Postmortem Blood: Application to a Case of Insulin Aspart Suicide

Insulin aspart (NovoRapid®, NovoMix®, Novolog® and Fiasp®) is a fast-acting analog of human insulin, indicated in the treatment of type I and II diabetes. It is administered before meals to mimic the physiological insulin secretion that follows a rise in blood glucose. Its misuse for the purposes of suicide and murder and in the context of factitious order has often been described. In forensic medicine, the identification of insulin in biological samples has always been complex. In this paper, we present a case of suicide of a 64-year-old man who died after the injection of insulin aspart. He was suffering from terminal lung cancer and left a letter explaining the reasons for his suicide. Four empty NovoRapid® pens were found near the body. Body examination was unremarkable, and the femoral blood was collected in two dry Vacutainer™ tubes (red cap) and two sodium fluoride (NaF) tubes (gray cap). A liquid chromatography coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry method was used to identify and discriminate insulin aspart from human insulin after immunopurification in the blood samples and in the pens. Blood specimens tested positive for insulin aspart with the concentrations of 36 and 37 ng/mL in dry tubes and 58 and 71 ng/mL in tubes containing NaF when tested ∼3 weeks after the collection of the specimens. The contents of the pens also matched with insulin aspart. The stability of insulin in blood is a critical point in the interpretation of the concentrations due to their rapid decrease caused by the activity of proteases in blood. During a degradation study implemented to compare three preservatives and dry tubes, suitable insulin aspart stability was observed with disodium salt of ethylenediaminetetracetic acid and NaF. Given that NaF is standard in forensic toxicology for measuring blood alcohol concentrations, the authors suggest its use for blood collection when insulin intoxication is suspected.

Insulin and Oral Hypoglycemic Drug Overdose in Post-Mortem Investigations: A Literature Review

Background and Objectives: Insulin and oral hypoglycemic agents are drugs widely used in the world population due to their therapeutic effects on diabetes mellitus. Despite these benefits, they can also cause accidental or voluntary drug overdose. This review aims to evaluate post-mortem investigations in cases of suspected hypoglycemic drug overdose. Materials and Methods: We performed a comprehensive search using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review (PRISMA) standards; we systematically searched the PubMed, Science Direct Scopus, Google Scholar, and Excerpta Medica Database (EM-BASE) databases from the point of database inception until August 2022. The following inclusion criteria were used: (1) original research articles, (2) reviews and mini-reviews, (3) case reports/series, (4) and only papers written in English. Results: Thirty-three scientific papers, including original research articles, case reports, and case series, fulfilled the inclusion criteria. A total of 109 cases of insulin or hypoglycemic drug overdose were found. There were 71 cases of suicide (65%), 25 cases of accidental poisoning (23%), and 13 cases of homicide (12%). The most commonly used drug was insulin (95.4%). Autopsy and post-mortem examinations were performed in 84 cases, while toxicological investigations were performed in 79 cases. The most common gross findings in the autopsy were pulmonary edema (55.7%) and congestion (41.8%), while the most common histological finding was neuronal depletion or necrosis (29.1%). Conclusions: In the suspicion of death from insulin or overdose from oral hypoglycemic agents, autopsy findings may be nonspecific, and the search for injection marks can be positive at the external examination. Significant post-mortal alterations can interest biological samples and an early autopsy investigation is recommended.

Biodistribution of Insulin Following Massive Insulin Subcutaneous Injection

A man in his 30s injected insulin several times into his abdomen and was found dead several hours later. Micropathological findings showed alveolar injury with hemorrhaging and cerebral parietal lobe nerve cell edema. Biochemical examinations showed that the blood insulin level was high, significantly so at the insulin injection sites. The blood glucose and C-peptide levels were low. The insulin level in the kidneys was low. In forensic medicine, a postmortem diagnosis of insulin subcutaneous injection is often difficult. When insulin injection is suspected, particularly high insulin levels can be expected at the insulin injection site, rather than in the blood.

The Other Face of Insulin—Overdose and Its Effects

Insulin is the most effective glycemic-lowering drug, and for people suffering from type 1 diabetes it is a life-saving drug. Its self-dosing by patients may be associated with a higher risk of overdose, both accidental and deliberate. Insulin-induced hypoglycemia causes up to 100,000 emergency department calls per year. Cases of suicide attempts using insulin have been described in the literature since its introduction into therapy, and one of the important factors in their occurrence is the very fact of chronic disease. Up to 90% of patients who go to toxicology wards overdose insulin consciously. Patients with diabetes are burdened with a 2–3 times higher risk of developing depression compared to the general population. For this reason, it is necessary to develop an effective system for detecting a predisposition to overdose, including the assessment of the first symptoms of depression in patients with diabetes. A key role is played by a risk-conscious therapeutic team, as well as education. Further post-mortem testing is also needed for material collection and storage, as well as standardization of analytical methods and interpretation of results, which would allow for more effective detection and analysis of intentional overdose—both by the patient and for criminal purposes.

Attempted Murder of a Young Child Followed by an Attempted Suicide of the Mother by Injection of Insulin Aspart: Identification of Quantification of Insulin by LC-HRMS and UPLC-MS/MS in Blood of the Two Cases

The identification and quantification of insulin and its analogues have always been a challenge in the forensic field. Murder, suicide attempts and induced hypoglycemia in the context of factitious disorders have been described with the use of synthetic analogues of human insulin. There is very few information in the literature about aspart insulin concentrations in overdose cases. In this paper, we present a case of a nurse who tried to murder her 10-year-old daughter by injecting her aspart insulin and who, later, tried to commit suicide by injecting herself the same hormone. Two empty syringes and a FIASP ® Flextouch pen were found in the woman's apartment. A LC-HRMS method was developed in order to identify and discriminate aspart insulin from human insulin in blood samples as well as in syringes and pen, while an LC-MS/MS method was developed for the quantification of insulin in blood samples. Aspart insulin tested positive at 5.7 and 2.4 ng/mL in the blood specimens of the mother and the child, respectively. The contents of the syringes and pen also corresponded to aspart insulin. Although the mother claims to have injected an overdose of aspart insulin, the concentrations found were in the therapeutic range for subjects under therapy. Due to the high instability of insulin and the long time elapsed between sampling and forensic analysis (8 months) due to administrative reasons, the concentration at the time of collection was probably much higher. In this case, it was possible to identify aspart insulin and discriminate it from human insulin in a context of attempted murder and subsequent attempted suicide using high-resolution mass spectrometry, which is of paramount importance in forensic medicine.

Forensic proteomics

Protein is a major component of all biological evidence, often the matrix that embeds other biomolecules such as polynucleotides, lipids, carbohydrates, and small molecules. The proteins in a sample reflect the transcriptional and translational program of the originating cell types. Because of this, proteins can be used to identify body fluids and tissues, as well as convey genetic information in the form of single amino acid polymorphisms, the result of non-synonymous SNPs. This review explores the application and potential of forensic proteomics. The historical role that protein analysis played in the development of forensic science is examined. This review details how innovations in proteomic mass spectrometry have addressed many of the historical limitations of forensic protein science, and how the application of forensic proteomics differs from proteomics in the life sciences. Two more developed applications of forensic proteomics are examined in detail: body fluid and tissue identification, and proteomic genotyping. The review then highlights developing areas of proteomics that have the potential to impact forensic science in the near future: fingermark analysis, species identification, peptide toxicology, proteomic sex estimation, and estimation of post-mortem intervals. Finally, the review highlights some of the newer innovations in proteomics that may drive further development of the field. In addition to potential impact, this review also attempts to evaluate the stage of each application in the development, validation and implementation process. This review is targeted at investigators who are interested in learning about proteomics in a forensic context and expanding the amount of information they can extract from biological evidence.

Is insulin intoxication still the perfect crime? Analysis and interpretation of postmortem insulin: review and perspectives in forensic toxicology

Insulin is an anabolic hormone essential to glucose homeostasis. Insulin therapy, comprising human insulin (HI) or biosynthetic analogs, is critical for the management of type-1 diabetes and many of type-2 diabetes. However, medication error including non-adapted dose and confusion of insulin type, and misuse, such as massive self-administration or with criminal intent, can have lethal consequences. The aim of this paper is to review the state of knowledge of insulin analysis in biological samples and of the interpretation of insulin concentrations in the situation of insulin-related death investigations. Analytic aspects are considered, as quantification can be strongly impacted by methodology. Immunoanalysis, the historical technique, has a prominent role due to its sensitivity and ease of implementation. Recently, liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry has provided indispensable selectivity in forensic contexts, distinguishing HI, analogs, and degradation products. We review the numerous antemortem (dose, associated pathology, injection-to-death interval, etc.) and postmortem parameters (in corpore degradation, in vitro degradation related to hemolysis, etc.) involved in the interpretation of insulin concentration. The interest and limitations of various alternative matrices providing a valuable complement to blood analysis are discussed. Vitreous humor is one of the most interesting, but the low diffusion of insulin in this matrix entails very low concentrations. Injection site analysis is relevant for identifying which type of insulin was administered. Muscle and renal cortex are matrices of particular interest, although additional studies are required. A table containing most case reports of fatal insulin poisoning published, with analytical data, completes this review. A logic diagram is proposed to highlight analytical issues and the main parameters to be considered for the interpretation of blood concentrations. Finally, it remains a challenge to provide reliable biological data and solid interpretation in the context of death related to insulin overdose. However, the progress of analytical tools is making the "perfect crime" ever more difficult to commit.