Tolerance of a Vascularized Composite Allograft Achieved in MHC Class-I-mismatch Swine via Mixed Chimerism

[Vascularized composite allografts in France: An update]

Vascularized composite allografts (VCA) encompass the face, upper limb, trachea, penis, abdominal wall, and, more recently, uterus transplants. They offer unique reconstructive possibilities to overcome the limitations of traditional reconstructive techniques. Unlike solid organ transplants (heart, liver, kidney, lung, etc.), VCA is not generally performed in a life-threatening situation but aims to improve quality of life, at the cost of a major constraint to its expansion: the need for lifelong immunosuppressive treatment. Nevertheless, VCA is considered one of the five most important innovations of the modern era of the discipline, and a worldwide survey of plastic surgeons has confirmed that significant changes in reconstructive surgery will be related to VCA in the future. France pioneered this type of transplantation by successfully performing the first VCA (unilateral hand transplant), the first double hand transplant, the first face transplant, the first face retransplant, and the first bilateral shoulder and arm transplant, and continues to demonstrate unprecedented surgical prowess. This activity continues to expand across the country, with active VCA programs notably in the upper limb, face, uterus and penis. This article aims to provide an update on the clinical advances made in France in the field of composite tissue allografts.

[Advances and perspectives in vascularized composite allotransplantation preservation]

Vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA) involves transplants of the face, upper limb, trachea, penis, abdominal wall and, more recently, uterus. These grafts are unique in that they comprise numerous specialized tissues derived from several embryonic layers, each with its own specific constraints. Whereas the skin component, as an immunological barrier, is a real challenge in terms of immune tolerance, the muscle is highly sensitive to ischemia, and ischemia-reperfusion injuries can lead to antigen release and eventually rejection episodes. While the gold standard for the preservation of these grafts remains static cold storage (4 °C), the emergence of dynamic perfusion techniques in solid organ transplantation suggests their adaptation to VCAs. In this review, we outline the challenges imposed by composite tissue allotransplantation, and discuss the latest advances in VCA preservation based on machine perfusion but also on static techniques at negative temperatures. Particular attention is paid to subnormothermic perfusion preservation and supercooling techniques, developed by our team in an attempt to import these optimized techniques from solid organ preservation.

The current state of tolerance induction in vascularized composite allotransplantation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Significant advancements have been made in the field of vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA); however, like solid organ transplantation, bypassing the recipient's immune response remains a significant obstacle to long-term allograft survival. Therefore, strategies to overcome acute and chronic rejection and minimize immunosuppressive therapy are crucial for the future of VCA. This review highlights recent attempts to induce tolerance in VCA and discusses key findings through a clinical lens.

RECENT FINDINGS

Promising VCA tolerance protocols are being investigated, with five recent studies illustrating various successes. These preclinical approaches demonstrate a correlation between the presence of donor-derived T cells and VCA tolerance, the importance of using clinically available reagents within preclinical protocols, and the ability to induce sustained tolerance through nonmyeloablative methods. Furthermore, environmental factors, such as NB-UVB light are being investigated for their immunomodulation properties and may influence VCA graft rejection.

SUMMARY

To widen the scope of VCA, minimization of immunosuppression is needed. Overall, tolerance induction protocols should have a low-toxicity level, minimally invasive induction therapies, and utilize short-term immunosuppressive medications. By examining the milestones of recent studies, researchers can gain new technical approaches to immune modulation and make data-driven amendments to tolerance protocols in preparation for clinical translation.

Enhanced VCA Storage: A Pilot Study Demonstrating Supercooling in Orthotopic Rodent Hindlimb Transplantation

The field of vascularized composite allograft (VCA) transplantation has seen steady, rapid growth, with new innovations driving the evolution from experimental procedures to more standardized therapies. With this expansion comes challenges with graft allocation, preservation, and postoperative graft rejection. Here, we outline the first example of subzero nonfreezing (SZNF), supercooled storage of a whole rat hindlimb with orthotopic transplantation. Rat hindlimbs were procured, loaded, and supercooled for 48 hours at -4°C (n = 4), after which, they were recovered. The loading and recovery phase were performed using subnormothermic machine perfusion (SNMP) during which viability markers (glucose and oxygen consumption, lactate, and resistance) were tracked. Control limbs underwent static cold storage (SCS). After ex vivo validation, the model was piloted in a transplant model, comparing 48 hours of SZNF (n = 1), 48 hours of SCS (n = 1), and 72 hours of SCS (n = 1), which demonstrated no survival beyond postoperative day 4 in the SCS models, and survival until the end of study (postoperative day [POD] 28) in the SZNF model. This study demonstrates the promise of this model in future studies on long-term VCA preservation.

Optimized partial freezing protocol enables 10-day storage of rat livers

Preserving organs at subzero temperatures with halted metabolic activity holds the potential to prolong preservation and expand the donor organ pool for transplant. Our group recently introduced partial freezing, a novel approach in high-subzero storage at -15 °C, enabling 5-day storage of rodent livers through precise control over ice nucleation and unfrozen fraction. However, increased vascular resistance and tissue edema suggested a need for improvements to extend viable preservation. Here, we describe an optimized partial freezing protocol with key optimizations, including an increased concentration of polyethylene glycol (PEG) to enhance membrane stability while minimizing shear stress during cryoprotectant unloading with an acclimation period and a maintained osmotic balance through an increase in bovine serum albumin (BSA). These approaches ensured the viability during preservation and recovery processes, promoting liver function and ensuring optimal preservation. This was evidenced by increased oxygen consumption, decreased vascular resistance, and edema. Ultimately, we show that using the optimized protocol, livers can be stored for 10 days with comparable vascular resistance and lactate levels to 5 days, outperforming the viability of time-matched static cold stored (SCS) livers as the current gold standard. This study represents a significant advancement in expanding organ availability through prolonged preservation, thereby revolutionizing transplant medicine.

Supercooling preservation of vascularized composite allografts through CPA optimization, thermal tracking, and stepwise loading techniques

Vascularized composite allografts (VCAs) present unique challenges in transplant medicine, owing to their complex structure and vulnerability to ischemic injury. Innovative preservation techniques are crucial for extending the viability of these grafts, from procurement to transplantation. This study addresses these challenges by integrating cryoprotectant agent (CPA) optimization, advanced thermal tracking, and stepwise CPA loading strategies within an ex vivo rodent model. CPA optimization focused on various combinations, identifying those that effectively suppress ice nucleation while mitigating cytotoxicity. Thermal dynamics were monitored using invasive thermocouples and non-invasive FLIR imaging, yielding detailed temperature profiles crucial for managing warm ischemia time and optimizing cooling rates. The efficacy of stepwise CPA loading versus conventional flush protocols demonstrated that stepwise (un)loading significantly improved arterial resistance and weight change outcomes. In summary, this study presents comprehensive advancements in VCA preservation strategies, combining CPA optimization, precise thermal monitoring, and stepwise loading techniques. These findings hold potential implications for refining transplantation protocols and improving graft viability in VCA transplantation.

Sub-zero non-freezing of vascularized composite allografts in a rodent partial hindlimb model

Ischemia is a major limiting factor in Vascularized Composite Allotransplantation (VCA) as irreversible muscular injury can occur after as early as 4-6 h of static cold storage (SCS). Organ preservation technologies have led to the development of storage protocols extending rat liver ex vivo preservation up to 4 days. Development of such a protocol for VCAs has the added challenge of inherent ice nucleating factors of the graft, therefore, this study focused on developing a robust protocol for VCA supercooling. Rodent partial hindlimbs underwent subnormothermic machine perfusion (SNMP) with several loading solutions, followed by a storage solution with cryoprotective agents (CPA) developed for VCAs. Storage occurred in suspended animation for 24h and VCAs were recovered using SNMP with modified Steen. This study shows a robust VCA supercooling preservation protocol in a rodent model. Further optimization is expected to allow for its application in a transplantation model, which would be a breakthrough in the field of VCA preservation.

Enhancing Vascularized Composite Allograft Supercooling Preservation: A Multifaceted Approach with CPA Optimization, Thermal Tracking, and Stepwise Loading Techniques

Vascularized composite allografts (VCAs) present unique challenges in transplant medicine, owing to their complex structure and vulnerability to ischemic injury. Innovative preservation techniques are crucial for extending the viability of these grafts, from procurement to transplantation. This study addresses these challenges by integrating cryoprotectant agent (CPA) optimization, advanced thermal tracking, and stepwise CPA loading strategies within an ex vivo rodent model. CPA optimization focused on various combinations, identifying those that effectively suppress ice nucleation while mitigating cytotoxicity. Thermal dynamics were monitored using invasive thermocouples and non-invasive FLIR imaging, yielding detailed temperature profiles crucial for managing warm ischemia time and optimizing cooling rates. The efficacy of stepwise CPA loading versus conventional flush protocols demonstrated that stepwise (un)loading significantly improved arterial resistance and weight change outcomes. In summary, this study presents comprehensive advancements in VCA preservation strategies, combining CPA optimization, precise thermal monitoring, and stepwise loading techniques. These findings hold potential implications for refining transplantation protocols and improving graft viability in VCA transplantation.

The contribution of the donor vascularised hand and face allograft in transplant rejection: An immunological perspective

Overcoming immunological rejection remains a barrier to the safe adoption of Vascularised Composite Allotransplantation (VCA). To mitigate this risk, clinical protocols have been derived from solid organ transplantation, targeting recipient immunomodulation, yet VCA is unique. Face and hand composite allografts are composed of multiple different tissues, each with their own immunological properties. Experimental work suggests that allografts carry variable numbers and populations of donor leukocytes in an organ specific manner. Ordinarily, these passenger leukocytes are transferred from the donor graft into the recipient circulation after transplantation. Whether alloantigen presentation manifests as acute allograft rejection or transplant tolerance is unknown. This review aims to characterise the immunological properties of the constituent parts of the donor face and hand, the potential fate of donor leukocytes and to consider theoretical graft specific interventions to mitigate early rejection.

VCA supercooling in a swine partial hindlimb model

Vascularized composite allotransplantations are complex procedures with substantial functional impact on patients. Extended preservation of VCAs is of major importance in advancing this field. It would result in improved donor-recipient matching as well as the potential for ex vivo manipulation with gene and cell therapies. Moreover, it would make logistically feasible immune tolerance induction protocols through mixed chimerism. Supercooling techniques have shown promising results in multi-day liver preservation. It consists of reaching sub-zero temperatures while preventing ice formation within the graft by using various cryoprotective agents. By drastically decreasing the cell metabolism and need for oxygen and nutrients, supercooling allows extended preservation and recovery with lower ischemia-reperfusion injuries. This study is the first to demonstrate the supercooling of a large animal model of VCA. Porcine hindlimbs underwent 48 h of preservation at - 5 °C followed by recovery and normothermic machine perfusion assessment, with no issues in ice formation and favorable levels of injury markers. Our findings provide valuable preliminary results, suggesting a promising future for extended VCA preservation.

Acute Rejection Rates in Vascularized Composite Allografts: A Systematic Review of Case Reports

INTRODUCTION

Vascularized Composite Allografts (VCA) are usually performed in a full major histocompatibility complex mismatch setting, with a risk of acute rejection depending on factors such as the type of immunosuppression therapy and the quality of graft preservation. In this systematic review, we present the different immunosuppression protocols used in VCA and point out relationships between acute rejection rates and possible factors that might influence it.

METHODS

This systematic review was performed according to the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. We systematically searched Medline (PubMed), Embase, and The Cochrane Library between November 2022 and February 2023, using following Mesh Terms: Transplant, Transplantation, Hand, Face, Uterus, Penis, Abdominal Wall, Larynx, and Composite Tissue Allografts. All VCA case reports and reviews describing multiple case reports were included.

RESULTS

We discovered 211 VCA cases reported. The preferred treatment was a combination of antithymocyte globulins, mycophenolate mofetil (MMF), tacrolimus, and steroids; and a combination of MMF, tacrolimus, and steroids for induction and maintenance treatment, respectively. Burn patients showed a higher acute rejection rate (P = 0.073) and were administered higher MMF doses (P = 0.020).

CONCLUSIONS

In contrast to previous statements, the field of VCA is not rapidly evolving, as it has encountered challenges in addressing immune-related concerns. This is highlighted by the absence of a standardized immunosuppression regimen. Consequently, more substantial data are required to draw more conclusive results regarding the immunogenicity of VCAs and the potential superiority of one immunosuppressive treatment over another. Future efforts should be made to report the VCA surgeries comprehensively, and muti-institutional long-term prospective follow-up studies should be performed to compare the number of acute rejections with influencing factors.

Machine Perfusion Enables 24-h Preservation of Vascularized Composite Allografts in a Swine Model of Allotransplantation

The current gold standard for preserving vascularized composite allografts (VCA) is 4°C static cold storage (SCS), albeit muscle vulnerability to ischemia can be described as early as after 2 h of SCS. Alternatively, machine perfusion (MP) is growing in the world of organ preservation. Herein, we investigated the outcomes of oxygenated acellular subnormothermic machine perfusion (SNMP) for 24-h VCA preservation before allotransplantation in a swine model. Six partial hindlimbs were procured on adult pigs and preserved ex vivo for 24 h with either SNMP (n = 3) or SCS (n = 3) before heterotopic allotransplantation. Recipient animals received immunosuppression and were followed up for 14 days. Clinical monitoring was carried out twice daily, and graft biopsies and blood samples were regularly collected. Two blinded pathologists assessed skin and muscle samples. Overall survival was higher in the SNMP group. Early euthanasia of 2 animals in the SCS group was linked to significant graft degeneration. Analyses of the grafts showed massive muscle degeneration in the SCS group and a normal aspect in the SNMP group 2 weeks after allotransplantation. Therefore, this 24-h SNMP protocol using a modified Steen solution generated better clinical and histological outcomes in allotransplantation when compared to time-matched SCS.

Exploring Costimulatory Blockade-Based Immunologic Strategies in Transplantation: Are They a Promising Immunomodulatory Approach for Organ and Vascularized Composite Allotransplantation?

The field of transplantation, including the specialized area of vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA), has been transformed since the first hand transplant in 1998. The major challenge in VCA comes from the need for life-long immunosuppressive therapy due to its non-vital nature and a high rate of systemic complications. Ongoing research is focused on immunosuppressive therapeutic strategies to avoid toxicity and promote donor-specific tolerance. This includes studying the balance between tolerance and effector mechanisms in immune modulation, particularly the role of costimulatory signals in T lymphocyte activation. Costimulatory signals during T cell activation can have either stimulatory or inhibitory effects. Interfering with T cell activation through costimulation blockade strategies shows potential in avoiding rejection and prolonging the survival of transplanted organs. This review paper aims to summarize current data on the immunologic role of costimulatory blockade in the field of transplantation. It focuses on strategies that can be applied in vascularized composite allotransplantation, offering insights into novel methods for enhancing the success and safety of these procedures.

Immunogenicity and tolerance induction in vascularized composite allotransplantation

Vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA) is the transplantation of multiple tissues such as skin, muscle, bone, nerve, and vessels, as a functional unit (i.e., hand or face) to patients suffering from major tissue trauma and functional deficits. Though the surgical feasibility has been optimized, issues regarding graft rejection remains. VCA rejection involves a diverse population of cells but is primarily driven by both donor and recipient lymphocytes, antigen-presenting cells, macrophages, and other immune as well as donor-derived cells. In addition, it is commonly understood that different tissues within VCA, such as the skin, elicits a stronger rejection response. Currently, VCA recipients are required to follow potent and lifelong immunosuppressing regimens to maximize graft survival. This puts patients at risk for malignancies, opportunistic infections, and cancers, thereby posing a need for less perilous methods of inducing graft tolerance. This review will provide an overview of cell populations and mechanisms, specific tissue involved in VCA rejection, as well as an updated scope of current methods of tolerance induction.

Sub-Zero Non-Freezing of Vascularized Composite Allografts Preservation in Rodents

Ischemia is a major limiting factor in Vascularized Composite Allotransplantation (VCA) as irreversible muscular injury can occur after as early as 4-6 hours of static cold storage (SCS). Organ preservation technologies have led to the development of storage protocols extending rat liver ex vivo preservation up to 4 days. Development of such a protocol for VCAs has the added challenge of inherent ice nucleating factors of the graft, therefore this study focused on developing a robust protocol for VCA supercooling. Rodent partial hindlimbs underwent subnormothermic machine perfusion (SNMP) with several loading solutions, followed by cryoprotective agent (CPA) cocktail developed for VCAs. Storage occurred in suspended animation for 24h and VCAs were recovered using SNMP with modified Steen. This study shows a robust VCA supercooling preservation protocol in a rodent model. Further optimization is expected to allow for its application in a transplantation model, which would be a breakthrough in the field of VCA preservation.

Novel cell-based strategies for immunomodulation in vascularized composite allotransplantation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA) has become a clinical reality in the past two decades. However, its routine clinical applications are limited by the risk of acute rejection, and the side effects of the lifelong immunosuppression. Therefore, there is a need for new protocols to induce tolerance and extend VCA survival. Cell- based therapies have emerged as an attractive strategy for tolerance induction in VCA. This manuscript reviews the current strategies and applications of cell-based therapies for tolerance induction in VCA.

RECENT FINDINGS

Cellular therapies, including the application of bone marrow cells (BMC), mesenchymal stem cells (MSC), adipose stem cells, regulatory T cells (Treg) cells, dendritic cells and donor recipient chimeric cells (DRCC) show promising potential as a strategy to induce tolerance in VCA. Ongoing basic science research aims to provide insights into the mechanisms of action, homing, functional specialization and standardization of these cellular therapies. Additionally, translational preclinical and clinical studies are underway, showing encouraging outcomes.

SUMMARY

Cellular therapies hold great potential and are supported by preclinical studies and clinical trials demonstrating safety and efficacy. However, further research is needed to develop novel cell-based immunosuppressive protocol for VCA.

Supercooling: A Promising Technique for Prolonged Organ Preservation in Solid Organ Transplantation, and Early Perspectives in Vascularized Composite Allografts

Ex-vivo preservation of transplanted organs is undergoing spectacular advances. Machine perfusion is now used in common practice for abdominal and thoracic organ transportation and preservation, and early results are in favor of substantially improved outcomes. It is based on decreasing ischemia-reperfusion phenomena by providing physiological or sub-physiological conditions until transplantation. Alternatively, supercooling techniques involving static preservation at negative temperatures while avoiding ice formation have shown encouraging results in solid organs. Here, the rationale is to decrease the organ's metabolism and need for oxygen and nutrients, allowing for extended preservation durations. The aim of this work is to review all advances of supercooling in transplantation, browsing the literature for each organ. A specific objective was also to study the initial evidence, the prospects, and potential applications of supercooling preservation in Vascularized Composite Allotransplantation (VCA). This complex entity needs a substantial effort to improve long-term outcomes, marked by chronic rejection. Improving preservation techniques is critical to ensure the favorable evolution of VCAs, and supercooling techniques could greatly participate in these advances.

Tolerance Induction in Vascularized Composite Allotransplantation-A Brief Review of Preclinical Models

Pre-clinical studies are an obligatory tool to develop and translate novel therapeutic strategies into clinical practice. Acute and chronic rejection mediated by the recipient's immune system remains an important limiting factor for the (long-term) survival of vascularized composite allografts (VCA). Furthermore, high intensity immunosuppressive (IS) protocols are needed to mitigate the immediate and long-term effects of rejection. These IS regiments can have significant side-effects such as predisposing transplant recipients to infections, organ dysfunction and malignancies. To overcome these problems, tolerance induction has been proposed as one strategy to reduce the intensity of IS protocols and to thereby mitigate long-term effects of allograft rejection. In this review article, we provide an overview about animal models and strategies that have been used to induce tolerance. The induction of donor-specific tolerance was achieved in preclinical animal models and clinical translation may help improve short and long-term outcomes in VCAs in the future.