DNA sequence analysis of gamma radiation-induced deletions and insertions at the APRT locus of hamster cells

Ionizing radiation and genetic risks. XVII. Formation mechanisms underlying naturally occurring DNA deletions in the human genome and their potential relevance for bridging the gap between induced DNA double-strand breaks and deletions in irradiated germ cells

While much is known about radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) and their repair, the question of how deletions of different sizes arise as a result of the processing of DSBs by the cell's repair systems has not been fully answered. In order to bridge this gap between DSBs and deletions, we critically reviewed published data on mechanisms pertaining to: (a) repair of DNA DSBs (from basic studies in this area); (b) formation of naturally occurring structural variation (SV) - especially of deletions - in the human genome (from genomic studies) and (c) radiation-induced mutations and structural chromosomal aberrations in mammalian somatic cells (from radiation mutagenesis and radiation cytogenetic studies). The specific aim was to assess the relative importance of the postulated mechanisms in generating deletions in the human genome and examine whether empirical data on radiation-induced deletions in mouse germ cells are consistent with predictions of these mechanisms. The mechanisms include (a) NHEJ, a DSB repair process that does not require any homology and which functions in all stages of the cell cycle (and is of particular relevance in G0/G1); (b) MMEJ, also a DSB repair process but which requires microhomology and which presumably functions in all cell cycle stages; (c) NAHR, a recombination-based DSB repair mechanism which operates in prophase I of meiosis in germ cells; (d) MMBIR, a microhomology-mediated, replication-based mechanism which operates in the S phase of the cell cycle, and (e) strand slippage during replication (involved in the origin of small insertions and deletions (INDELs). Our analysis permits the inference that, between them, these five mechanisms can explain nearly all naturally occurring deletions of different sizes identified in the human genome, NAHR and MMBIR being potentially more versatile in this regard. With respect to radiation-induced deletions, the basic studies suggest that those arising as a result of the operation of NHEJ/MMEJ processes, as currently formulated, are expected to be relatively small. However, data on induced mutations in mouse spermatogonial stem cells (irradiation in G0/G1 phase of the cell cycle and DSB repair presumed to be via NHEJ predominantly) show that most are associated with deletions of different sizes, some in the megabase range. There is thus a 'discrepancy' between what the basic studies suggest and the empirical observations in mutagenesis studies. This discrepancy, however, is only an apparent but not a real one. It can be resolved by considering the issue of deletions in the broader context of and in conjunction with the organization of chromatin in chromosomes and nuclear architecture, the conceptual framework for which already exists in studies carried out during the past fifteen years or so. In this paper, we specifically hypothesize that repair of DSBs induced in chromatin loops may offer a basis to explain the induction of deletions of different sizes and suggest an approach to test the hypothesis. We emphasize that the bridging of the gap between induced DSB and resulting deletions of different sizes is critical for current efforts in computational modeling of genetic risks.

Biochemical mechanisms of chromosomal translocations resulting from DNA double-strand breaks

Exposure of mammalian cells to agents that induce DNA double-strand breaks typically results in both reciprocal and nonreciprocal chromosome translocations. Over the past decade, breakpoint junctions of a significant number of translocations and other genomic rearrangements, both in clinical tumors and in experimental models, have been analyzed at the DNA sequence level. Based on these data, reasonable inferences regarding the biochemical mechanisms involved in translocations can be drawn. In a few cases, breakpoints have been shown to correlate with sites of double-strand cleavage by agents to which the cells or patients have been exposed, including exogenous rare-cutting endonucleases, radiomimetic compounds, and topoisomerase inhibitors. These results confirm that translocations primarily reflect misjoining of the exchanged ends of two or more double-strand breaks. Many junctions show significant loss of DNA sequence at the breakpoints, suggesting exonucleolytic degradation of DNA ends prior to joining. The size and frequency of these deletions varies widely, both between experimental systems, and among individual events in a single system. Homologous recombination between repetitive DNA sequences does not appear to be a major pathway for translocations associated with double-strand breaks. Rather, the general features of the junction sequences, particularly the high frequency small terminal deletions, the apparent splicing of DNA ends at microhomologies, and gap-filling on aligned double-strand break ends, are consistent with the known biochemical properties of the classical nonhomologous end joining pathway involving DNA-dependent protein kinase, XRCC4 and DNA ligase IV. Nevertheless, cells with deficiencies in this pathway still exhibit translocations, with grossly similar junction sequences, suggesting an alternative but less conservative end joining pathway. Although evidence for participation of specific DNA end processing enzymes in formation of translocations is largely circumstantial, likely candidates include DNA polymerases lambda and mu, Artemis nuclease, polynucleotide kinase/phosphatase, tyrosyl-DNA phosphodiesterase, DNase III, Werner syndrome protein, and the Mre11/Rad50/NBS1 complex.

Base substitutions, targeted single-base deletions, and chromosomal translocations induced by bleomycin in plateau-phase mammary epithelial cells

Previous work showed that treatment of plateau-phase Chinese hamster ovary cells with the radiomimetic double-strand cleaving agent bleomycin induced very small deletions as well as interchromosomal reciprocal translocations, both of which could be ascribed to errors in end joining of DNA double-strand breaks. In an attempt to assess the possible role of TP53 in suppressing such repair errors, bleomycin-induced mutagenesis at the HPRT locus was examined in immortalized 184B5 human mammary epithelial cells (TP53(+)), and in a TP53-defective derivative, 184B5-E6tfxc6. For both cell lines, the most frequent bleomycin-induced mutations were base substitutions, with no apparent targeting to major bleomycin lesions. However, both lines also sustained single-base deletions that were targeted to expected sites of double-strand breaks, suggesting that they arose by end-joining repair of the breaks. Surprisingly, only a few large deletions or rearrangements, and no interchromosomal events involving the HPRT locus were detected among the mutants. The results suggest that in both cell lines, errors in double-strand break repair resulting in heritable large deletions and rearrangements are rare. Spectral karyotyping of bleomycin-treated 184B5 cells showed that a significant number of translocations were present shortly after bleomycin exposure, but their frequency decreased upon continued culture of the cells. Thus, for these cells, the lack of induced interchromosomal rearrangements can be explained in part by selection against such events as the cells proliferate.

High frequency of deletions at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase locus in an ataxia-telangiectasia lymphoblastoid cell line irradiated with gamma-rays

The molecular nature of gamma-ray-induced mutations at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) locus in an ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T) lymphoblastoid cell line was investigated. Twelve of 15 gamma-ray-induced HPRT-deficient mutants showed deletions. Eight of them had lost the entire HPRT gene, one showed a 1.9-kb deletion, and three had deletions of about 40-150 base pairs. Of the eight mutants that lost the entire gene, five had also lost both DXS79 and DXS86, flanking markers of the HPRT locus. The spectrum of mutations induced by gamma-irradiation in the A-T cells showed a high frequency of deletions in comparison with that in a control cell line, WIL2-NS. Sequence analysis of breakpoint junctions in four mutants revealed that three of them had junctions between short identical sequences at each breakpoint, leaving one copy at the junction. These results suggest that non-homologous end-joining is the major mechanism for deletion formation in A-T cells.

Utility of C57BL/6J x 129/SvJae embryonic stem cells for generating chromosomal deletions: tolerance to gamma radiation and microsatellite polymorphism

We have previously reported a method for making nested deletion complexes in mice by irradiation of ES cells. The key to this technology is that F1 hybrid ES cells (called v17.2) of the genotype (BALB/cTa x 129/SvJae) retain germline colonizing ability after exposure to levels of ionizing radiation that induce chromosomal deletions. In an effort to identify other genotypes of ES cells that are suitable for this technology, the radiation sensitivity of the cell line v6.4, which is of the genotype (C57BL/6J x 129/SvJae), was investigated. After treatment with a range of radiation exposures, the developmental potential of these cells was assayed by injecting them into blastocysts to generate chimeric mice. These experiments showed that while cell lethality increased as the level of radiation increased, the surviving ES cells retained full totipotency at all exposure levels, up to 400 Rads. Because polymorphism between parental microsatellite alleles in the F1 hybrid ES cells is important for ascertaining the sizes of induced deletions, the 129/SvJ and 129/SvJae allele sizes of 48 microsatellite loci on chromosome (Chr) 17 were determined. This revealed a higher level of polymorphism between 129 and C57BL/6J on Chr 17. The radiation tolerance, high polymorphism between parental strains, and presence of the widely used C57BL/6J strain component make v6.4 ES cells an attractive cell line for generating radiation-induced chromosomal deletions.

Transposition without transposase: a spontaneous mutation in bacteria

Transposition mutations are typically associated with the activities of transposable elements such as transposons and insertion sequences, whose mobility is dependent upon transposase enzymes that catalyze exchanges between element ends and target sites. We describe a single transposition event in which a block of donor sequence is inserted at a target site without the involvement of any known transposase or the ends of any known transposable element. We propose that this is a new type of spontaneous mutation which may be difficult to detect in standard mutant hunts but may be of evolutionary importance.

Targeted base substitutions and small deletions induced by neocarzinostatin at the APRT locus in plateau-phase CHO cells

Treatment of confluence-arrested CHO-D422 cells for 48 h with low concentrations (0.5-3 nM) of the radiomimetic antibiotic neocarzinostatin resulted in an increase in up to 11-fold in the frequency of mutations at the hemizygous APRT locus. Analysis by PCR and DNA sequencing revealed that the mutations were a mixture of base substitutions, small deletions, and large-scale rearrangements. base substitutions occurred preferentially at sequence positions where the drug is known to produce abasic sites with closely opposed strand breaks, e.g., AGT, TGT and AGC, where the abasic site occurs at the underlined base and the strand break occurs opposite the first base in each triplet. These results suggest that the substitutions were produced by replicative bypass of the abasic sites, perhaps during attempted repair of the accompanying strand break. Single-base deletions, which comprised nearly half of all deletions, were targeted to these same sequence positions, suggesting that they may have been generated either by replicative bypass of the abasic sites, or by end-joining repair of double-strand breaks, which are induced the same sites. Quantitative analysis of neocarzinostatin-induced damage to APRT DNA in vitro confirmed the association between lesions involving concommitant damage to both DNA strands, and mutations. The results are consistent the hypothesis that agents which induce such bistranded DNA damage can produce biologically significant levels of mutagenesis even in nondividing cells.

The joining of non-complementary DNA double-strand breaks by mammalian extracts

We have developed a high efficiency system in which mammalian extracts join DNA double-strand breaks with non-complementary termini. This system has been used to obtain a large number of junction sequences from a range of different break-end combinations, allowing the elucidation of the joining mechanisms. Using an extract of calf thymus it was found that the major mechanism of joining was by blunt-end ligation following removal or fill-in of the single-stranded bases. However, some break-end combinations were joined through an efficient mechanism using short repeat sequences and we have succeeded in separating this mechanism from blunt-end joining by the biochemical fractionation of extracts. Characterization of activities and sequence data in an extensively purified fraction that will join ends by the repeat mechanism led to a model where joining is initiated by 3' strand invasion followed by pairing to short repeat sequences close to the break site. Thus the joining of double-strand breaks by mammalian extracts is achieved by several mechanisms and this system will allow the purification of the factors involved in each by the judicial choice of the non-complementary ends used in the assay.

High-frequency illegitimate integration of transfected DNA at preintegrated target sites in a mammalian genome

To examine the mechanisms of recombination governing the illegitimate integration of transfected DNA into a mammalian genome, we developed a cell system that selects for integration events in defined genomic regions. Cell lines with chromosomal copies of the 3' portion of the adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (APRT) gene (targets) were established. The 5' portion of the APRT gene, which has no homology to the integrated 3' portion, was then electroporated into the target cell lines, and selection for APRT gene function was applied. The reconstruction of the APRT gene was detected at frequencies ranging from less than 10(-7) to 10(-6) per electroporated cell. Twenty-seven junction sequences between the integrated 5' APRT and its chromosomal target were analyzed. They were found to be randomly distributed in a 2-kb region immediately in front of the 3' portion of the APRT gene. The junctions fell into two main classes: those with short homologies (microhomologies) and those with inserted DNA of uncertain origin. Three long inserts were shown to preexist elsewhere in the genome. Reconstructed cell lines were analyzed for rearrangements at the target site by Southern blotting; a variety of simple and complex rearrangements were detected. Similar analysis of individual clones of the parental cell lines revealed analogous types of rearrangement, indicating that the target sites are unstable. Given the high frequency of integration events at these sites, we speculate that transfected DNA may preferentially integrate at unstable mammalian loci. The results are discussed in relation to possible mechanisms of DNA integration.

Molecular nature of spontaneous mutations at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (hprt) locus in Chinese hamster ovary cells

The hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (hprt) locus has been widely used as a selectable genetic marker for studies of mammalian cell mutagenesis. We report here the spontaneous mutation spectrum at the hprt locus in 64 independently isolated mutants of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. All nine hprt exons were simultaneously analyzed via multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for rapid detection of gene deletions or insertions. Structural point mutations were identified by direct sequence analysis of the PCR amplified cDNA. The molecular nature of RNA splicing errors and insertions was analyzed by solid-phase direct exon sequencing. Single base substitutions were found in 24 mutants (38%), of which 21 were missense and 3 were nonsense mutations. Transversions were about twice as frequent as transitions. Fifteen mutants (23%) had deletions involving either intragenic small fragments (2), single exons (9), or multiple exons (4). The majority of deletion breakpoints (71%) were located in regions surrounding exons 4, 5, and 6. RNA splicing mutations were observed in 15 mutants (23%) and affected exons 3-8; most (6/15) resulted in the loss of exon 7. Two insertion mutants, one with a 209 bp insert in exon 4 and the other with a 88 bp insert accompanied by a 24 bp deletion in exon 6, represent novel mutations reported for the first time in spontaneous mutants of the mammalian hprt gene.

Radiation-induced genomic instability

Quantitative assessment of the heritable somatic effects of ionizing radiation exposures has relied upon the assumption that radiation-induced lesions were 'fixed' in the DNA prior to the first postirradiation mitosis. Lesion conversion was thought to occur during the initial round of DNA replication or as a consequence of error-prone enzymatic processing of lesions. The standard experimental protocols for the assessment of a variety of radiation-induced endpoints (cell death, specific locus mutations, neoplastic transformation and chromosome aberrations) evaluate these various endpoints at a single snapshot in time. In contrast with the aforementioned approaches, some studies have specifically assessed radiation effects as a function of time following exposure. Evidence has accumulated in support of the hypothesis that radiation exposure induces a persistent destabilization of the genome. This instability has been observed as a delayed expression of lethal mutations, as an enhanced rate of accumulation of non-lethal heritable alterations, and as a progressive intraclonal chromosomal heterogeneity. The genetic controls and biochemical mechanisms underlying radiation-induced genomic instability have not yet been delineated. The aim is to integrate the accumulated evidence that suggests that radiation exposure has a persistent effect on the stability of the mammalian genome.

Induction of micronuclei by acute and chronic exposure in vivo to gamma rays in murine polychromatic erythrocytes

The effect on micronuclei (MN) frequency of in vivo exposure to different dose rates of gamma rays in murine polychromatic erythrocytes (PCE) was studied. Groups of animals were irradiated with 1.0 Gy of gamma rays administered in 10, 100, 1000 or 10,000 min; the micronucleated polychromatic-erythrocytes (MN-PCE) frequency was scored in blood samples obtained from the tail of mice at various times before, during or after irradiation. The time-response curves for the 10, 100, and 1000 min exposure were similar; however, the two first curves showed a peak at 1800 min and the last at 2400 min after exposure. The curve obtained from the 10,000 min exposure showed a plateau for a long period during and after the exposure. However, the integration of the area under the curves indicates that the damage caused by the different radiation protocols was the same, suggesting that throughout time, the lesions were not repaired but rather diluted by cell division.

Multiplex DNA amplification and solid-phase direct sequencing for mutation analysis at the hprt locus in Chinese hamster cells

We report here the development of multiplex in vitro DNA amplification and solid-phase direct exon sequencing for the analysis of mutations at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (hprt) locus in Chinese hamster cells. 18 representative HPRT-deficient mutants, derived either spontaneously, or after exposure to UV light or ionizing radiation, were analyzed. All 9 hprt exons were simultaneously amplified via the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for rapid deletion detection. 5 mutants involve single- or multiple-exon deletions. Altered multiplex PCR patterns were detected in mutants Bsp-040, Bsp-065 and BGR-606. Subsequent direct sequence analysis reveals that Bsp-040 and Bsp-065 carry a 52-bp and a 13-bp intragenic DNA deletion in exon 3, respectively. BGR-606 contains a 223-bp insertion accompanied by a 10-bp deletion of intron sequence within exon 4 fragment. Other subtle DNA alterations identified by direct exon sequence analysis include single-base substitutions, small deletions and insertions, and RNA splicing mutations.

Induction of large DNA deletions by persistent nicks: a new hypothesis

DNA deletions of more than one or two base pairs are induced frequently enough so that these form a reasonable fraction of mutations for only a few mutagens. Of these agents, some such as ionizing radiations form DNA double-strand breaks, and very large deletions are thought to result from a DNA end from one break ligating with a second break on the same DNA molecule. However, deletions of kilobase pairs and more are sometimes induced by ionizing radiation at a higher rate than can be accounted for by the numbers of double-strand breaks. Published data on induced deletions in particular Escherichia coli strains suggest a process involving a single lesion that could explain several features of large deletions: frequent occurrence in mammalian cells and scarcity in prokaryotes, nonrandom location which is perhaps associated with locations of origins of replication, and differences in the fraction of deletions among mutations in various genes. Some agents inducing deletions make single-strand nicks, not double-strand breaks, and the proposed mechanism hypothesizes that the inducing lesion is a persistent nick in one DNA strand--for example, a radiation-induced single-strand break with associated damage on the complementary strand that interferes with repair.

A transposon-like element in the deletion-prone region of the dystrophin gene

The central portion of the dystrophin gene locus is a preferential site for deletions causing progressive muscular dystrophy of the Duchenne type (DMD). The nucleotide sequence of a deletion junction fragment from a DMD patient was determined, revealing that the proximal breakpoint of the deletion in intron 43 fell within the sequence of a transposon-like element. This segment, belonging to the THE-1 family of human transposable elements, is normally present in a complete form in intron 43 of the dystrophin gene. The deletion mutation was maternally transmitted and eliminated two-thirds of the THE-1 element. Analysis of DNA from additional DMD patients revealed a second deletion with the proximal breakpoint mapping within the same THE-1 element.

A novel, plasmid-based system for studying gene rearrangements in mammalian cells

We have developed a plasmid-based system for isolating gene rearrangements in mammalian cells by selection for reversion of a promoterless drug resistance gene. pNH4 contains the selectable marker gene neo under the control of the herpes simplex virus, thymidine kinase (tk) promoter and, upstream and in the opposite orientation, a dormant promoterless hygromycin B resistance gene (hph) that can be expressed following rearrangement events. An NIH 3T3 cell line stably transfected with pNH4 that has a spontaneous frequency of generation of Hphr colonies of approximately 10(-8) was isolated. Treatment of this line with ethyl methanesulfonate raised the frequency of Hphr colony formation approximately 100-fold. Approximately 60% (21 of 35) of ethyl methanesulfonate-induced Hphr clones showed rearrangements detectable by Southern blot analysis within a 40-kb region surrounding the integrated construct, including a nonhomologous recombination event and, possibly, a large insertion. Additionally, three Hphr clones showed evidence of gene amplification. Northern (RNA) blot analysis of hph mRNA suggests that the rearrangements may provide a function that allows the tk promoter to initiate transcription off the opposite strand, thus yielding hph transcripts. Cell lines harboring pNH4, or modifications of it, may be valuable for studying recombination mechanisms responsible for the various types of genetic rearrangements found in cancer cells.

A novel, plasmid-based system for studying gene rearrangements in mammalian cells

We have developed a plasmid-based system for isolating gene rearrangements in mammalian cells by selection for reversion of a promoterless drug resistance gene. pNH4 contains the selectable marker gene neo under the control of the herpes simplex virus, thymidine kinase (tk) promoter and, upstream and in the opposite orientation, a dormant promoterless hygromycin B resistance gene (hph) that can be expressed following rearrangement events. An NIH 3T3 cell line stably transfected with pNH4 that has a spontaneous frequency of generation of Hphr colonies of approximately 10(-8) was isolated. Treatment of this line with ethyl methanesulfonate raised the frequency of Hphr colony formation approximately 100-fold. Approximately 60% (21 of 35) of ethyl methanesulfonate-induced Hphr clones showed rearrangements detectable by Southern blot analysis within a 40-kb region surrounding the integrated construct, including a nonhomologous recombination event and, possibly, a large insertion. Additionally, three Hphr clones showed evidence of gene amplification. Northern (RNA) blot analysis of hph mRNA suggests that the rearrangements may provide a function that allows the tk promoter to initiate transcription off the opposite strand, thus yielding hph transcripts. Cell lines harboring pNH4, or modifications of it, may be valuable for studying recombination mechanisms responsible for the various types of genetic rearrangements found in cancer cells.