Free energy mapping of class I MHC molecules and structural determination of bound peptides

Physicochemical Heuristics for Identifying High Fidelity, Near-Native Structural Models of Peptide/MHC Complexes

There is long-standing interest in accurately modeling the structural features of peptides bound and presented by class I MHC proteins. This interest has grown with the advent of rapid genome sequencing and the prospect of personalized, peptide-based cancer vaccines, as well as the development of molecular and cellular therapeutics based on T cell receptor recognition of peptide-MHC. However, while the speed and accessibility of peptide-MHC modeling has improved substantially over the years, improvements in accuracy have been modest. Accuracy is crucial in peptide-MHC modeling, as T cell receptors are highly sensitive to peptide conformation and capturing fine details is therefore necessary for useful models. Studying nonameric peptides presented by the common class I MHC protein HLA-A*02:01, here we addressed a key question common to modern modeling efforts: from a set of models (or decoys) generated through conformational sampling, which is best? We found that the common strategy of decoy selection by lowest energy can lead to substantial errors in predicted structures. We therefore adopted a data-driven approach and trained functions capable of predicting near native decoys with exceptionally high accuracy. Although our implementation is limited to nonamer/HLA-A*02:01 complexes, our results serve as an important proof of concept from which improvements can be made and, given the significance of HLA-A*02:01 and its preference for nonameric peptides, should have immediate utility in select immunotherapeutic and other efforts for which structural information would be advantageous.

Structural Prediction of Peptide-MHC Binding Modes

The immune system is constantly protecting its host from the invasion of pathogens and the development of cancer cells. The specific CD8⁺ T-cell immune response against virus-infected cells and tumor cells is based on the T-cell receptor recognition of antigenic peptides bound to class I major histocompatibility complexes (MHC) at the surface of antigen presenting cells. Consequently, the peptide binding specificities of the highly polymorphic MHC have important implications for the design of vaccines, for the treatment of autoimmune diseases, and for personalized cancer immunotherapy. Evidence-based machine-learning approaches have been successfully used for the prediction of peptide binders and are currently being developed for the prediction of peptide immunogenicity. However, understanding and modeling the structural details of peptide/MHC binding is crucial for a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms triggering the immunological processes, estimating peptide/MHC affinity using universal physics-based approaches, and driving the design of novel peptide ligands. Unfortunately, due to the large diversity of MHC allotypes and possible peptides, the growing number of 3D structures of peptide/MHC (pMHC) complexes in the Protein Data Bank only covers a small fraction of the possibilities. Consequently, there is a growing need for rapid and efficient approaches to predict 3D structures of pMHC complexes. Here, we review the key characteristics of the 3D structure of pMHC complexes before listing databases and other sources of information on pMHC structures and MHC specificities. Finally, we discuss some of the most prominent pMHC docking software.

Structure Based Prediction of Neoantigen Immunogenicity

The development of immunological therapies that incorporate peptide antigens presented to T cells by MHC proteins is a long sought-after goal, particularly for cancer, where mutated neoantigens are being explored as personalized cancer vaccines. Although neoantigens can be identified through sequencing, bioinformatics and mass spectrometry, identifying those which are immunogenic and able to promote tumor rejection remains a significant challenge. Here we examined the potential of high-resolution structural modeling followed by energetic scoring of structural features for predicting neoantigen immunogenicity. After developing a strategy to rapidly and accurately model nonameric peptides bound to the common class I MHC protein HLA-A2, we trained a neural network on structural features that influence T cell receptor (TCR) and peptide binding energies. The resulting structurally-parameterized neural network outperformed methods that do not incorporate explicit structural or energetic properties in predicting CD8+ T cell responses of HLA-A2 presented nonameric peptides, while also providing insight into the underlying structural and biophysical mechanisms governing immunogenicity. Our proof-of-concept study demonstrates the potential for structure-based immunogenicity predictions in the development of personalized peptide-based vaccines.

Structure-based Methods for Binding Mode and Binding Affinity Prediction for Peptide-MHC Complexes

Understanding the mechanisms involved in the activation of an immune response is essential to many fields in human health, including vaccine development and personalized cancer immunotherapy. A central step in the activation of the adaptive immune response is the recognition, by T-cell lymphocytes, of peptides displayed by a special type of receptor known as Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC). Considering the key role of MHC receptors in T-cell activation, the computational prediction of peptide binding to MHC has been an important goal for many immunological applications. Sequence- based methods have become the gold standard for peptide-MHC binding affinity prediction, but structure-based methods are expected to provide more general predictions (i.e., predictions applicable to all types of MHC receptors). In addition, structural modeling of peptide-MHC complexes has the potential to uncover yet unknown drivers of T-cell activation, thus allowing for the development of better and safer therapies. In this review, we discuss the use of computational methods for the structural modeling of peptide-MHC complexes (i.e., binding mode prediction) and for the structure-based prediction of binding affinity.

General Prediction of Peptide-MHC Binding Modes Using Incremental Docking: A Proof of Concept

The class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) is capable of binding peptides derived from intracellular proteins and displaying them at the cell surface. The recognition of these peptide-MHC (pMHC) complexes by T-cells is the cornerstone of cellular immunity, enabling the elimination of infected or tumoral cells. T-cell-based immunotherapies against cancer, which leverage this mechanism, can greatly benefit from structural analyses of pMHC complexes. Several attempts have been made to use molecular docking for such analyses, but pMHC structure remains too challenging for even state-of-the-art docking tools. To overcome these limitations, we describe the use of an incremental meta-docking approach for structural prediction of pMHC complexes. Previous methods applied in this context used specific constraints to reduce the complexity of this prediction problem, at the expense of generality. Our strategy makes no assumption and can potentially be used to predict binding modes for any pMHC complex. Our method has been tested in a re-docking experiment, reproducing the binding modes of 25 pMHC complexes whose crystal structures are available. This study is a proof of concept that incremental docking strategies can lead to general geometry prediction of pMHC complexes, with potential applications for immunotherapy against cancer or infectious diseases.

Prediction of peptide binding to a major histocompatibility complex class I molecule based on docking simulation

Binding between major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules and immunogenic epitopes is one of the most important processes for cell-mediated immunity. Consequently, computational prediction of amino acid sequences of MHC class I binding peptides from a given sequence may lead to important biomedical advances. In this study, an efficient structure-based method for predicting peptide binding to MHC class I molecules was developed, in which the binding free energy of the peptide was evaluated by two individual docking simulations. An original penalty function and restriction of degrees of freedom were determined by analysis of 361 published X-ray structures of the complex and were then introduced into the docking simulations. To validate the method, calculations using a 50-amino acid sequence as a prediction target were performed. In 27 calculations, the binding free energy of the known peptide was within the top 5 of 166 peptides generated from the 50-amino acid sequence. Finally, demonstrative calculations using a whole sequence of a protein as a prediction target were performed. These data clearly demonstrate high potential of this method for predicting peptide binding to MHC class I molecules.

DockTope: a Web-based tool for automated pMHC-I modelling

The immune system is constantly challenged, being required to protect the organism against a wide variety of infectious pathogens and, at the same time, to avoid autoimmune disorders. One of the most important molecules involved in these events is the Major Histocompatibility Complex class I (MHC-I), responsible for binding and presenting small peptides from the intracellular environment to CD8⁺ T cells. The study of peptide:MHC-I (pMHC-I) molecules at a structural level is crucial to understand the molecular mechanisms underlying immunologic responses. Unfortunately, there are few pMHC-I structures in the Protein Data Bank (PDB) (especially considering the total number of complexes that could be formed combining different peptides), and pMHC-I modelling tools are scarce. Here, we present DockTope, a free and reliable web-based tool for pMHC-I modelling, based on crystal structures from the PDB. DockTope is fully automated and allows any researcher to construct a pMHC-I complex in an efficient way. We have reproduced a dataset of 135 non-redundant pMHC-I structures from the PDB (Cα RMSD below 1 Å). Modelling of pMHC-I complexes is remarkably important, contributing to the knowledge of important events such as cross-reactivity, autoimmunity, cancer therapy, transplantation and rational vaccine design.

Quantitative prediction of peptide binding to HLA-DP1 protein

The exogenous proteins are processed by the host antigen-processing cells. Peptidic fragments of them are presented on the cell surface bound to the major hystocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules class II and recognized by the CD4+ T lymphocytes. The MHC binding is considered as the crucial prerequisite for T-cell recognition. Only peptides able to form stable complexes with the MHC proteins are recognized by the T-cells. These peptides are known as T-cell epitopes. All T-cell epitopes are MHC binders, but not all MHC binders are T-cell epitopes. The T-cell epitope prediction is one of the main priorities of immunoinformatics. In the present study, three chemometric techniques are combined to derive a model for in silico prediction of peptide binding to the human MHC class II protein HLA-DP1. The structures of a set of known peptide binders are described by amino acid z-descriptors. Data are processed by an iterative self-consisted algorithm using the method of partial least squares, and a quantitative matrix (QM) for peptide binding prediction to HLA-DP1 is derived. The QM is validated by two sets of proteins and showed an average accuracy of 86 percent.

Computational Resources for MHC Ligand Identification

Advances in the high-throughput determination of functional modulators of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) and improved computational predictions of MHC ligands have rendered the rational design of immunomodulatory peptides feasible. Proteome-derived peptides and 'reverse vaccinology' by computational means will play a driving role in future vaccine design. Here we review the molecular mechanisms of the MHC mediated immune response, present the computational approaches that have emerged in this area of biotechnology, and provide an overview of publicly available computational resources for predicting and designing new peptidic MHC ligands.

T-cell epitope vaccine design by immunoinformatics

Vaccination is generally considered to be the most effective method of preventing infectious diseases. All vaccinations work by presenting a foreign antigen to the immune system in order to evoke an immune response. The active agent of a vaccine may be intact but inactivated ('attenuated') forms of the causative pathogens (bacteria or viruses), or purified components of the pathogen that have been found to be highly immunogenic. The increased understanding of antigen recognition at molecular level has resulted in the development of rationally designed peptide vaccines. The concept of peptide vaccines is based on identification and chemical synthesis of B-cell and T-cell epitopes which are immunodominant and can induce specific immune responses. The accelerating growth of bioinformatics techniques and applications along with the substantial amount of experimental data has given rise to a new field, called immunoinformatics. Immunoinformatics is a branch of bioinformatics dealing with in silico analysis and modelling of immunological data and problems. Different sequence- and structure-based immunoinformatics methods are reviewed in the paper.

Large-scale characterization of peptide-MHC binding landscapes with structural simulations

Class I major histocompatibility complex proteins play a critical role in the adaptive immune system by binding to peptides derived from cytosolic proteins and presenting them on the cell surface for surveillance by T cells. The varied peptide binding specificity of these highly polymorphic molecules has important consequences for vaccine design, transplantation, autoimmunity, and cancer development. Here, we describe a molecular modeling study of MHC-peptide interactions that integrates sampling techniques from protein-protein docking, loop modeling, de novo structure prediction, and protein design in order to construct atomically detailed peptide binding landscapes for a diverse set of MHC proteins. Specificity profiles derived from these landscapes recover key features of experimental binding profiles and can be used to predict peptide binding with reasonable accuracy. Family wide comparison of the predicted binding landscapes recapitulates previously reported patterns of specificity divergence and peptide-repertoire diversity while providing a structural basis for observed specificity patterns. The size and sequence diversity of these structure-based binding landscapes enable us to identify subtle patterns of covariation between peptide sequence positions; analysis of the associated structural models suggests physical interactions that may mediate these sequence correlations.

T-cell epitope prediction and immune complex simulation using molecular dynamics: state of the art and persisting challenges

Atomistic Molecular Dynamics provides powerful and flexible tools for the prediction and analysis of molecular and macromolecular systems. Specifically, it provides a means by which we can measure theoretically that which cannot be measured experimentally: the dynamic time-evolution of complex systems comprising atoms and molecules. It is particularly suitable for the simulation and analysis of the otherwise inaccessible details of MHC-peptide interaction and, on a larger scale, the simulation of the immune synapse. Progress has been relatively tentative yet the emergence of truly high-performance computing and the development of coarse-grained simulation now offers us the hope of accurately predicting thermodynamic parameters and of simulating not merely a handful of proteins but larger, longer simulations comprising thousands of protein molecules and the cellular scale structures they form. We exemplify this within the context of immunoinformatics.

pDOCK: a new technique for rapid and accurate docking of peptide ligands to Major Histocompatibility Complexes

Background

Identification of antigenic peptide epitopes is an essential prerequisite in T cell-based molecular vaccine design. Computational (sequence-based and structure-based) methods are inexpensive and efficient compared to experimental approaches in screening numerous peptides against their cognate MHC alleles. In structure-based protocols, suited to alleles with limited epitope data, the first step is to identify high-binding peptides using docking techniques, which need improvement in speed and efficiency to be useful in large-scale screening studies. We present pDOCK: a new computational technique for rapid and accurate docking of flexible peptides to MHC receptors and primarily apply it on a non-redundant dataset of 186 pMHC (MHC-I and MHC-II) complexes with X-ray crystal structures.

Results

We have compared our docked structures with experimental crystallographic structures for the immunologically relevant nonameric core of the bound peptide for MHC-I and MHC-II complexes. Primary testing for re-docking of peptides into their respective MHC grooves generated 159 out of 186 peptides with Cα RMSD of less than 1.00 Å, with a mean of 0.56 Å. Amongst the 25 peptides used for single and variant template docking, the Cα RMSD values were below 1.00 Å for 23 peptides. Compared to our earlier docking methodology, pDOCK shows upto 2.5 fold improvement in the accuracy and is ~60% faster. Results of validation against previously published studies represent a seven-fold increase in pDOCK accuracy.

Conclusions

The limitations of our previous methodology have been addressed in the new docking protocol making it a rapid and accurate method to evaluate pMHC binding. pDOCK is a generic method and although benchmarks against experimental structures, it can be applied to alleles with no structural data using sequence information. Our outcomes establish the efficacy of our procedure to predict highly accurate peptide structures permitting conformational sampling of the peptide in MHC binding groove. Our results also support the applicability of pDOCK for in silico identification of promiscuous peptide epitopes that are relevant to higher proportions of human population with greater propensity to activate T cells making them key targets for the design of vaccines and immunotherapies.

An introduction to epitope prediction methods and software

In this paper, current prediction methods and algorithms for both T- and B cell epitopes are reviewed, and a comprehensive summary of epitope prediction software and databases currently available online is also provided. This review can offer researchers in this field a sense of direction and insights for future work. However, our main purpose is to introduce clinical and basic biomedical researchers who are not familiar with these biological analysis tools and databases to these online resources and to provide guidance on how to use them effectively.

Ranking of binding and nonbinding peptides to MHC class I molecules using inverse folding approach: implications for vaccine design

T cell recognition of the peptide-MHC complex initiates a cascade of immunological events necessary for immune responses. Accurate T-cell epitope prediction is an important part of the vaccine designing. Development of predictive algorithms based on sequence profile requires a very large number of experimental binding peptide data to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. Here we used inverse folding approach to study the peptide specificity of MHC Class-I molecule with the aim of obtaining a better differentiation between binding and nonbinding sequence. Overlapping peptides, spanning the entire protein sequence, are threaded through the backbone coordinates of a known peptide fold in the MHC groove, and their interaction energies are evaluated using statistical pairwise contact potentials. We used the Miyazawa & Jernigan and Betancourt & Thirumalai tables for pairwise contact potentials, and two distance criteria (Nearest atom >> 4.0 A & C-beta >> 7.0 A) for ranking the peptides in an ascending order according to their energy values, and in most cases, known antigenic peptides are highly ranked. The predictions from threading improved when used multiple templates and average scoring scheme. In general, when structural information about a protein-peptide complex is available, the current application of the threading approach can be used to screen a large library of peptides for selection of the best binders to the target protein. The proposed scheme may significantly reduce the number of peptides to be tested in wet laboratory for epitope based vaccine design.

Amino acid biophysical properties in the statistical prediction of peptide-MHC class I binding

Background

A key step in the development of an adaptive immune response to pathogens or vaccines is the binding of short peptides to molecules of the Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) for presentation to T lymphocytes, which are thereby activated and differentiate into effector and memory cells. The rational design of vaccines consists in part in the identification of appropriate peptides to effect this process. There are several algorithms currently in use for making such predictions, but these are limited to a small number of MHC molecules and have good but imperfect prediction power.

Results

We have undertaken an exploration of the power gained by taking advantage of a natural representation of the amino acids in terms of their biophysical properties. We used several well-known statistical classifiers using either a naive encoding of amino acids by name or an encoding by biophysical properties. In all cases, the encoding by biophysical properties leads to substantially lower misclassification error.

Conclusion

Representation of amino acids using a few important bio-physio-chemical property provide a natural basis for representing peptides and greatly improves peptide-MHC class I binding prediction.

Ab initio prediction of peptide-MHC binding geometry for diverse class I MHC allotypes

Since determining the crystallographic structure of all peptide-MHC complexes is infeasible, an accurate prediction of the conformation is a critical computational problem. These models can be useful for determining binding energetics, predicting the structures of specific ternary complexes with T-cell receptors, and designing new molecules interacting with these complexes. The main difficulties are (1) adequate sampling of the large number of conformational degrees of freedom for the flexible peptide, (2) predicting subtle changes in the MHC interface geometry upon binding, and (3) building models for numerous MHC allotypes without known structures. Whereas previous studies have approached the sampling problem by dividing the conformational variables into different sets and predicting them separately, we have refined the Biased-Probability Monte Carlo docking protocol in internal coordinates to optimize a physical energy function for all peptide variables simultaneously. We also imitated the induced fit by docking into a more permissive smooth grid representation of the MHC followed by refinement and reranking using an all-atom MHC model. Our method was tested by a comparison of the results of cross-docking 14 peptides into HLA-A*0201 and 9 peptides into H-2K(b) as well as docking peptides into homology models for five different HLA allotypes with a comprehensive set of experimental structures. The surprisingly accurate prediction (0.75 A backbone RMSD) for cross-docking of a highly flexible decapeptide, dissimilar to the original bound peptide, as well as docking predictions using homology models for two allotypes with low average backbone RMSDs of less than 1.0 A illustrate the method's effectiveness. Finally, energy terms calculated using the predicted structures were combined with supervised learning on a large data set to classify peptides as either HLA-A*0201 binders or nonbinders. In contrast with sequence-based prediction methods, this model was also able to predict the binding affinity for peptides to a different MHC allotype (H-2K(b)), not used for training, with comparable prediction accuracy.

Structural prediction of peptides binding to MHC class I molecules

Peptide binding to class I major histocompatibility complex (MHCI) molecules is a key step in the immune response and the structural details of this interaction are of importance in the design of peptide vaccines. Algorithms based on primary sequence have had success in predicting potential antigenic peptides for MHCI, but such algorithms have limited accuracy and provide no structural information. Here, we present an algorithm, PePSSI (peptide-MHC prediction of structure through solvated interfaces), for the prediction of peptide structure when bound to the MHCI molecule, HLA-A2. The algorithm combines sampling of peptide backbone conformations and flexible movement of MHC side chains and is unique among other prediction algorithms in its incorporation of explicit water molecules at the peptide-MHC interface. In an initial test of the algorithm, PePSSI was used to predict the conformation of eight peptides bound to HLA-A2, for which X-ray data are available. Comparison of the predicted and X-ray conformations of these peptides gave RMSD values between 1.301 and 2.475 A. Binding conformations of 266 peptides with known binding affinities for HLA-A2 were then predicted using PePSSI. Structural analyses of these peptide-HLA-A2 conformations showed that peptide binding affinity is positively correlated with the number of peptide-MHC contacts and negatively correlated with the number of interfacial water molecules. These results are consistent with the relatively hydrophobic binding nature of the HLA-A2 peptide binding interface. In summary, PePSSI is capable of rapid and accurate prediction of peptide-MHC binding conformations, which may in turn allow estimation of MHCI-peptide binding affinity.

Structural prediction of peptides bound to MHC class I

An ab initio structure prediction approach adapted to the peptide-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I system is presented. Based on structure comparisons of a large set of peptide-MHC class I complexes, a molecular dynamics protocol is proposed using simulated annealing (SA) cycles to sample the conformational space of the peptide in its fixed MHC environment. A set of 14 peptide-human leukocyte antigen (HLA) A0201 and 27 peptide-non-HLA A0201 complexes for which X-ray structures are available is used to test the accuracy of the prediction method. For each complex, 1000 peptide conformers are obtained from the SA sampling. A graph theory clustering algorithm based on heavy atom root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) values is applied to the sampled conformers. The clusters are ranked using cluster size, mean effective or conformational free energies, with solvation free energies computed using Generalized Born MV 2 (GB-MV2) and Poisson-Boltzmann (PB) continuum models. The final conformation is chosen as the center of the best-ranked cluster. With conformational free energies, the overall prediction success is 83% using a 1.00 Angstroms crystal RMSD criterion for main-chain atoms, and 76% using a 1.50 Angstroms RMSD criterion for heavy atoms. The prediction success is even higher for the set of 14 peptide-HLA A0201 complexes: 100% of the peptides have main-chain RMSD values < or =1.00 Angstroms and 93% of the peptides have heavy atom RMSD values < or =1.50 Angstroms. This structure prediction method can be applied to complexes of natural or modified antigenic peptides in their MHC environment with the aim to perform rational structure-based optimizations of tumor vaccines.

Design of enhanced agonists through the use of a new virtual screening method: application to peptides that bind class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules

A new screening procedure is described that uses docking calculations to design enhanced agonist peptides that bind to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I receptors. The screening process proceeds via single mutations of one amino acid at the positions that directly interact with the MHC receptor. The energetic and structural effects of these mutations have been studied using fragments of the original ligand that vary in length. The results of these docking studies indicate that the mutant affinity ranking of long peptides can be practically reproduced with a screening approach performed using fragments of six residues. Fragments of four and five residues could mimic, in some cases, the structural arrangement of the side chains of the full-length peptide. We have compared the structural and energetic results of the docking calculations with experimental data using three unrelated ligand peptides that differ greatly in their affinity for the MHC complex. Analysis of the affinity of the fragments led to the identification of three important parameters in the construction of fragments that mimic the structural and energetic properties of the full-length ligand: the length of the fragment; its intermolecular energy; and the number and localization, internal or terminal, of the anchor residues. The results of this new peptide-design methodology have been applied to suggest new peptides derived from the MUC1-8 peptide that could be used as murine vaccines that trigger the immune response through the MHC class I protein H-2K(b).

Modeling the structure of bound peptide ligands to major histocompatibility complex

In this article, we present a new technique for the rapid and precise docking of peptides to MHC class I and class II receptors. Our docking procedure consists of three steps: (1) peptide residues near the ends of the binding groove are docked by using an efficient pseudo-Brownian rigid body docking procedure followed by (2) loop closure of the intervening backbone structure by satisfaction of spatial constraints, and subsequently, (3) the refinement of the entire backbone and ligand interacting side chains and receptor side chains experiencing atomic clash at the MHC receptor-peptide interface. The method was tested by remodeling of 40 nonredundant complexes of at least 3.00 A resolution for which three-dimensional structural information is available and independently for docking peptides derived from 15 nonredundant complexes into a single template structure. In the first test, 33 out of 40 MHC class I and class II peptides and in the second test, 11 out of 15 MHC-peptide complexes were modeled with a Calpha RMSD < 1.00 A.

Toward the quantitative prediction of T-cell epitopes: QSAR studies on peptides having affinity with the class I MHC molecular HLA-A*0201

It would be useful for vaccine development to develop a method of rapidly identifying peptide epitopes. In this paper, the empirical three-dimensional quantitative structure-affinity relationship (3D-QSAR) methods were used to study the relationship between the three dimensional structural parameters (the isotropic surface area, ISA, and the electronic charge index, ECI) of the HLA-A*0201 binding peptide and the HLA-A*0201/peptide binding affinities. A set of 102 peptides having affinity with the class I MHC HLA-A*0201 molecule was used as training set. A test set of 40 peptides was used to determine the predictive value of the models. The 3D-QSAR models yielded a q2 = 0.5724 and a high rpred2 = 0.6955. The standard regression coefficients indicated that the hydrophobic interactions played an important role in peptide-MHC molecule binding and predicted the specific amino acid residue essential at a certain position of the peptide. The approach tested in the current paper is highly complementary to many of the methods described in references and possesses good predictability. It is a rapid and convenient method to detect high affinity peptide epitopes.

JenPep: a novel computational information resource for immunobiology and vaccinology

JenPep is a relational database containing a compendium of thermodynamic binding data for the interaction of peptides with a range of important immunological molecules: the major histocompatibility complex, TAP transporter, and T cell receptor. The database also includes annotated lists of B cell and T cell epitopes. Version 2.0 of the database is implemented in a bespoke postgreSQL database system and is fully searchable online via a perl/HTML interface (URL: http://www.jenner.ac.uk/JenPep).

Computer-aided design of chiral ligands. Part 2. Functionality mapping as a method to identify stereocontrol elements for asymmetric reactions

A computational method to determine the energetically favorable positions of functional groups with respect to the transition states of stereoselective reactions based on force field energy minimization is presented. The parameters of this functionality mapping, the characteristics of the target transition states, and the features of the probe structures are outlined. Our method was found to reproduce the positions of the stereodiscriminating fragments for some known chiral ligands including the Masamune dimethylborolane, dimenthylborane, the Corey stien reagent, the Roush allylboronate tartrates, and the secondary amine Diels-Alder catalysts described by MacMillan. Functionality mapping can be used to better understand the specific interactions in the transition states leading to the products by providing a quantitative measure of the stabilization/destabilization afforded by the different ligand components via nonbonded interactions. The method can determine if a chiral ligand imparts the observed selectivity by stabilizing one reaction pathway, by destabilizing a reaction pathway, or by a combination of both. Orientational as well as positional information about potential functional groups is readily obtained. In addition to its utility as an analytical tool, functionality mapping can be used to explore starting points for the design of new chiral ligands.

Proteomics in Vaccinology and Immunobiology: An Informatics Perspective of the Immunone

The postgenomic era, as manifest, inter alia, by proteomics, offers unparalleled opportunities for the efficient discovery of safe, efficacious, and novel subunit vaccines targeting a tranche of modern major diseases. A negative corollary of this opportunity is the risk of becoming overwhelmed by this embarrassment of riches. Informatics techniques, working to address issues of both data management and through prediction to shortcut the experimental process, can be of enormous benefit in leveraging the proteomic revolution. In this disquisition, we evaluate proteomic approaches to the discovery of subunit vaccines, focussing on viral, bacterial, fungal, and parasite systems. We also adumbrate the impact that proteomic analysis of host-pathogen interactions can have. Finally, we review relevant methods to the prediction of immunome, with special emphasis on quantitative methods, and the subcellular localization of proteins within bacteria.

Toward the quantitative prediction of T-cell epitopes: coMFA and coMSIA studies of peptides with affinity for the class I MHC molecule HLA-A*0201

A set of 102 peptides with affinity for the class I MHC HLA-A0201 molecule was subjected to three-dimensional quantitative structure-affinity relationship (3D QSAR) studies using comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA). A test set of 50 peptides was used to determine the predictive value of the models. The CoMFA models gave q(2) and r(2)pred below 0.5. The best CoMSIA model has q(2) = 0.542 and r(2)pred = 0.679, and includes hydrophobic, steric, and H-bond donor fields. The hydrophobic interactions play a dominant role in peptide-MHC molecule binding. CoMSIA coefficient contour maps were used to analyze the structural features of the peptides accounting for the affinity in terms of the three positively contributing physicochemical properties: local hydrophobicity, steric bulk and hydrogen-bond-donor ability.

Predicting sequences and structures of MHC-binding peptides: a computational combinatorial approach

Peptides bound to MHC molecules on the surface of cells convey critical information about the cellular milieu to immune system T cells. Predicting which peptides can bind an MHC molecule, and understanding their modes of binding, are important in order to design better diagnostic and therapeutic agents for infectious and autoimmune diseases. Due to the difficulty of obtaining sufficient experimental binding data for each human MHC molecule, computational modeling of MHC peptide-binding properties is necessary. This paper describes a computational combinatorial design approach to the prediction of peptides that bind an MHC molecule of known X-ray crystallographic or NMR-determined structure. The procedure uses chemical fragments as models for amino acid residues and produces a set of sequences for peptides predicted to bind in the MHC peptide-binding groove. The probabilities for specific amino acids occurring at each position of the peptide are calculated based on these sequences, and these probabilities show a good agreement with amino acid distributions derived from a MHC-binding peptide database. The method also enables prediction of the three-dimensional structure of MHC-peptide complexes. Docking, linking, and optimization procedures were performed with the XPLOR program [1].

Predicting binding affinities of protein ligands from three-dimensional models: application to peptide binding to class I major histocompatibility proteins

A simple and fast free energy scoring function (Fresno) has been developed to predict the binding free energy of peptides to class I major histocompatibility (MHC) proteins. It differs from existing scoring functions mainly by the explicit treatment of ligand desolvation and of unfavorable protein-ligand contacts. Thus, it may be particularly useful in predicting binding affinities from three-dimensional models of protein-ligand complexes. The Fresno function was independently calibrated for two different training sets: (a) five HLA-A0201-peptide structures, which had been determined by X-ray crystallography, and (b) three-dimensional models of 37 H-2K(k)-peptide structures, which had been obtained by knowledge-based homology modeling. For both training sets, a good cross-validated fit to experimental binding free energies was obtained with predictive errors of 3-3.5 kJ/mol. As expected, lipophilic interactions were found to contribute the most to HLA-A0201-peptide interactions, whereas H-bonding predominates in H-2K(k) recognition. Both cross-validated models were afterward used to predict the binding affinity of a test set of 26 peptides to HLA-A0204 (an HLA allele closely related to HLA-A0201) and of a series of 16 peptides to H-2K(k). Predictions were more accurate for HLA-A2-binding peptides as the training set had been built from experimentally determined structures. The average error in predicting the binding free energy of the test peptides was 3.1 kJ/mol. For the homology model-derived equation, the average error in predicting the binding free energy of peptides to K(k) was significantly higher (5.4 kJ/mol) but still very acceptable. The present scoring function is thus able to predict with a good accuracy binding free energies from three-dimensional models, at the condition that the backbone coordinates of the MHC-bound peptide have first been determined with an accuracy of about 1-1.5 A. Furthermore, it may be easily recalibrated for any protein-ligand complex.

Knowledge-based structure prediction of MHC class I bound peptides: a study of 23 complexes

BACKGROUND

The binding of T-cell antigenic peptides to MHC molecules is a prerequisite for their immunogenicity. The ability to identify binding peptides based on the protein sequence is of great importance to the rational design of peptide vaccines. As the requirements for peptide binding cannot be fully explained by the peptide sequence per se, structural considerations should be taken into account and are expected to improve predictive algorithms. The first step in such an algorithm requires accurate and fast modeling of the peptide structure in the MHC-binding groove.

RESULTS

We have used 23 solved peptide-MHC class I complexes as a source of structural information in the development of a modeling algorithm. The peptide backbones and MHC structures were used as the templates for prediction. Sidechain conformations were built based on a rotamer library, using the 'dead end elimination' approach. A simple energy function selects the favorable combination of rotamers for a given sequence. It further selects the correct backbone structure from a limited library. The influence of different parameters on the prediction quality was assessed. With a specific rotamer library that incorporates information from the peptide sidechains in the solved complexes, the algorithm correctly identifies 85% (92%) of all (buried) sidechains and selects the correct backbones. Under cross-validation, 70% (78%) of all (buried) residues are correctly predicted and most of all backbones. The interaction between peptide sidechains has a negligible effect on the prediction quality.

CONCLUSIONS

The structure of the peptide sidechains follows from the interactions with the MHC and the peptide backbone, as the prediction is hardly influenced by sidechain interactions. The proposed methodology was able to select the correct backbone from a limited set. The impairment in performance under cross-validation suggests that, currently, the specific rotamer library is not satisfactorily representative. The predictions might improve with an increase in the data.

Toward a predictive understanding of molecular recognition

T cells circulate in blood and the lymphatic system, continually engaging cells through transient non-specific adhesion. In a normally functioning immune system, these interactions permit sufficient time for T-cell receptors (TCRs) to sample major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-peptide complexes for the presence of foreign antigen, with detection of the latter to some extent being triggered by a longer dwell time of the receptor on the complex. Precisely how this incremental stability, which may be relatively small, leads to activation is unclear, but it appears to be related to diffusion-mediated formation of ternary complex dimers. The formation of stable dimers can explain the high sensitivity of the response, but leaves a number of questions unaddressed, including the following: i) How can high sensitivity be reconciled with high specificity, and how can a short TCR dwell time be reconciled with a comparably short time for ternary complex pair formation? ii) What is the nature of the early signals on the plasma membrane that determine alternative responses e.g. proliferation at one extreme and apoptosis at the other? iii) What are the cell-surface correlates of biphasic dose response functions i.e. of responses that peak as a function of dose and then descend? This paper has two loosely coupled goals. One is to review and assess the mathematical and computational methods available for analyzing reactions with and between mobile membrane-bound receptors. These methods range from phenomenological to mechanistic, the latter being based on the details of atomic structure. The other is to apply these methods to address biological questions, such as those raised above, part of whose answer may lie in the kinetic competition between alternative reaction paths.

Empirical free energy calculation: comparison to calorimetric data

An effective free energy potential, developed originally for binding free energy calculation, is compared to calorimetric data on protein unfolding, described by a linear combination of changes in polar and nonpolar surface areas. The potential consists of a molecular mechanics energy term calculated for a reference medium (vapor or nonpolar liquid), and empirical terms representing solvation and entropic effects. It is shown that, under suitable conditions, the free energy function agrees well with the calorimetric expression. An additional result of the comparison is an independent estimate of the side-chain entropy loss, which is shown to agree with a structure-based entropy scale. These findings confirm that simple functions can be used to estimate the free energy change in complex systems, and that a binding free energy evaluation model can describe the thermodynamics of protein unfolding correctly. Furthermore, it is shown that folding and binding leave the sum of solute-solute and solute-solvent van der Waals interactions nearly invariant and, due to this invariance, it may be advantageous to use a nonpolar liquid rather than vacuum as the reference medium.

Consistency in structural energetics of protein folding and peptide recognition

We report a new free energy decomposition that includes structure-derived atomic contact energies for the desolvation component, and show that it applies equally well to the analysis of single-domain protein folding and to the binding of flexible peptides to proteins. Specifically, we selected the 17 single-domain proteins for which the three-dimensional structures and thermodynamic unfolding free energies are available. By calculating all terms except the backbone conformational entropy change and comparing the result to the experimentally measured free energy, we estimated that the mean entropy gain by the backbone chain upon unfolding (delta Sbb) is 5.3 cal/K per mole of residue, and that the average backbone entropy for glycine is 6.7 cal/K. Both numbers are in close agreement with recent estimates made by entirely different methods, suggesting a promising degree of consistency between data obtained from disparate sources. In addition, a quantitative analysis of the folding free energy indicates that the unfavorable backbone entropy for each of the proteins is balanced predominantly by favorable backbone interactions. Finally, because the binding of flexible peptides to receptors is physically similar to folding, the free energy function should, in principle, be equally applicable to flexible docking. By combining atomic contact energies, electrostatics, and sequence-dependent backbone entropy, we calculated a priori the free energy changes associated with the binding of four different peptides to HLA-A2, 1 MHC molecule and found agreement with experiment to within 10% without parameter adjustment.

Two complementary methods for predicting peptides binding major histocompatibility complex molecules

Peptides that bind to major histocompatibility complex products (MHC) are known to exhibit certain sequence motifs which, though common, are neither necessary nor sufficient for binding: MHCs bind certain peptides that do not have the characteristic motifs and only about 30% of the peptides having the required motif, bind. In order to develop and test more accurate methods we measured the binding affinity of 463 nonamer peptides to HLA-A2.1. We describe two methods for predicting whether a given peptide will bind to an MHC and apply them to these peptides. One method is based on simulating a neural network and another, called the polynomial method, is based on statistical parameter estimation assuming independent binding of the side-chains of residues. We compare these methods with each other and with standard motif-based methods. The two methods are complementary, and both are superior to sequence motifs. The neural net is superior to simple motif searches in eliminating false positives. Its behavior can be coarsely tuned to the strength of binding desired and it is extendable in a straightforward fashion to other alleles. The polynomial method, on the other hand, has high sensitivity and is a superior method for eliminating false negatives. We discuss the validity of the independent binding assumption in such predictions.