Serial observations after high dose talc slurry in the rabbit model for pleurodesis

Platelet-Rich Plasma for Pleurodesis: An Experimental Study in Rabbits

Background and Objectives: This study was designed to evaluate platelet-rich plasma (PRP) as a method of pleurodesis in a rabbit model. Pleurodesis with PRP was compared against the gold-standard use of talc. The secondary evaluation assessed the ideal time for achieving pleurodesis. Materials and Methods: 25 healthy New Zealand white rabbits were assigned to three groups, as follows: 12 animals in the first and second groups, as well as one animal with no intervention in the final group, which was used as a control. The talc pleurodesis group (baseline) underwent pleurodesis with sterile talc, which is the gold-standard sclerosing agent used for pleurodesis. The PRP group underwent pleurodesis using autologous PRP. The last group had one rabbit with no intervention. A total of 12 rabbits (n = 6 for the talc pleurodesis group and n = 6 for the PRP group) were sacrificed 3 days (72 h) after the intervention, and 12 rabbits (n = 6 for the talc pleurodesis group and n = 6 for the PRP group) were sacrificed 6 days (144 h) after the intervention. In both the talc and PRP group, FBC and CRP were measured before the intervention and in 3 or 6 days afterwards, respectively. The pleura and the lungs were evaluated histopathologically. Results: Macroscopically, there were no statistically significant differences between the two groups. In terms of microscopic findings, there were no statistically significant differences in inflammatory reactions provoked in the visceral and parietal pleura between the PRP and talc. In addition, with talc pleurodesis, a foreign-body reaction was observed in about 50% of the cases, which was not observed with PRP. In terms of inflammation between 3 and 6 days, there were no statistically significant differences with PRP, there was only a statistically significant difference between 3 and 6 days regarding the parietal pleura in the talc group. Conclusions: The instillation of autologous PRP in the pleural cavity shows promise in achieving pleurodesis. The efficacy of PRP as a pleurodesis agent should be examined further.

Pleurodesis induced by talc or silver nitrate: evaluation of collagen and elastic fibers in pleural remodeling

This study evaluated the extracellular matrix (collagen and elastic fibers) in pleurodesis induced by intrapleural talc (TL) or silver nitrate (SN). Study subjects were 420 rabbits divided into two groups and sacrificed from 15 min to 12 months after the injection of the sclerosing agents at intervals previously defined. Pleural adhesions and fibrosis were graded (0-4), and the collagen and elastin were quantified. The maximum score of the pleural adhesions was observed two months after TL (2.80 +/- 0.99) and 15 days after SN (3.75 +/- 0.25). More intense pleural adhesions were observed in the SN group from day 5 (p < 0.05). Pleural thickness and pleural fibrosis were, in general, significantly higher after SN (p < 0.05). Increased deposition of collagen and elastin was observed in both groups but was more evident in the SN group. In the TL group, a linear correlation was observed between pleural adhesions and fibrosis (r = 0.775), between pleural adhesions and collagen (r = 0.779), and between fibrosis and collagen (r = 0.709). In the SN group, these correlations were acceptable (r = 0.605, 0.665, and 0.663). The elastin presented a correlation of 0.707 (p < 0.001) in the TL group and of 0.564 (p < 0.001) in the SN group. In conclusion, intrapleural 0.5% silver nitrate and talc (400 mg/kg) are effective in the induction of pleurodesis. However, the intensity of adhesions and the richness of collagen after SN, in combination with the early onset of tissue remodeling, demonstrate the local superiority of this agent. Considering the easy availability and instillation, the low cost, and the absence of important side effects, silver nitrate might be considered as a sclerosing agent to induce pleurodesis in humans.

Lung damage in experimental pleurodesis induced by silver nitrate or talc: 1-year follow-up

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To compare the lung damage caused by intrapleural silver nitrate (SN) with that caused by talc over a 12-month period.

DESIGN

One hundred forty rabbits received an intrapleural injection of 0.5% SN or 400 mg/kg talc slurry in 2 mL saline solution. Groups of 10 rabbits were killed after 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, or 12 months. The macroscopic pleurodesis, microscopic lung changes (ie, collapse, hemorrhage, and edema), and cellular infiltrates (number and proportion of cells) were graded on a scale of 0 to 4.

RESULTS

The mean (+/- SEM) adhesion score after SN injection (3.3 +/- 0.1) was higher (p < 0.001) than that after talc injection (2.3 +/- 0.1). The mean alveolar collapse score was greater (p < 0.001) 1 month after SN injection (2.2 +/- 0.3) than after talc injection (0.2 +/- 0.1) and was similar from the second month on. The degree of parenchymal hemorrhage, by alveolar collapse score, (SN injection, 0.2 +/- 0.1; talc injection, 0.2 +/- 0.0) and edema (SN injection, 0.4 +/- 0.1; talc injection, 0.3 +/- 0.1) was minimal in both groups (p > 0.05). One month after the injection, the total number of inflammatory cells was greater (p < 0.001) in rabbits that had received SN injections (2.7 +/- 0.3) than in those that had received talc injections (1.2 +/- 0.1). From the second month on, cellularity decreased and became similar in both groups. The cellular profile was different, with a predominantly neutrophilic reaction after talc injection and a predominantly eosinophilic reaction after SN injection.

CONCLUSIONS

Rabbits injected with intrapleural 0.5% SN had significantly higher scores for adhesions than did those that had received talc injections, with mild and reversible alveolar collapse and an eosinophilic responses, conditions showing a clear tendency to normalize with time.

Transforming growth factor beta2 induced pleurodesis is not inhibited by corticosteroids

BACKGROUND

Talc and tetracyclines induce pleurodesis by directly injuring the pleura. The injury results in intense inflammation which subsequently leads to fibrosis. Corticosteroids can inhibit talc pleurodesis by reducing the inflammatory process. We hypothesised that transforming growth factor beta2 (TGFbeta2), a fibrogenic cytokine with immunomodulatory functions, could induce effective pleurodesis without generating significant pleural inflammation and therefore remain effective despite co-administration of corticosteroids.

METHODS

Thirty rabbits were divided into two groups. Rabbits in the steroid group received weekly intramuscular injections of triamcinolone diacetate (0.8 mg/kg). Ten rabbits in each group were given 5.0 microg TGFbeta2 intrapleurally via a chest tube while the remaining five received 1.7 microg TGFbeta2. Pleurodesis was graded macroscopically after 14 days from 1 (none) to 8 (>50% symphysis).

RESULTS

TGFbeta2 produced excellent pleurodesis at both 5.0 microg and 1.7 microg doses. The pleural effusions produced after the injection were low in all inflammatory markers. No significant differences were seen between the steroid group and controls in macroscopic pleurodesis scores (7.2 (1.3) v 7.1 (1.2)), levels of inflammatory markers in the pleural fluids (leucocyte 1107 (387)/mm(3) v 1376 (581)/mm(3); protein 3.1 (0.3) mg/dl v 2.9 (0.3) mg/dl, and LDH 478 (232) IU/l v 502 (123) IU/l), and the degree of microscopic pleural fibrosis and pleural inflammation.

CONCLUSIONS

TGFbeta2 can induce effective pleurodesis and remains effective in the presence of high dose parenteral corticosteroids.

Transforming growth factor β2 induced pleurodesis is not inhibited by corticosteroids

BACKGROUND

Talc and tetracyclines induce pleurodesis by directly injuring the pleura. The injury results in intense inflammation which subsequently leads to fibrosis. Corticosteroids can inhibit talc pleurodesis by reducing the inflammatory process. We hypothesised that transforming growth factor β2 (TGFβ2), a fibrogenic cytokine with immunomodulatory functions, could induce effective pleurodesis without generating significant pleural inflammation and therefore remain effective despite co-administration of corticosteroids.

METHODS

Thirty rabbits were divided into two groups. Rabbits in the steroid group received weekly intramuscular injections of triamcinolone diacetate (0.8 mg/kg). Ten rabbits in each group were given 5.0 μg TGFβ2 intrapleurally via a chest tube while the remaining five received 1.7 μg TGFβ2. Pleurodesis was graded macroscopically after 14 days from 1 (none) to 8 (>50% symphysis).

RESULTS

TGFβ2produced excellent pleurodesis at both 5.0 μg and 1.7 μg doses. The pleural effusions produced after the injection were low in all inflammatory markers. No significant differences were seen between the steroid group and controls in macroscopic pleurodesis scores (7.2 (1.3)v 7.1 (1.2)), levels of inflammatory markers in the pleural fluids (leucocyte 1107 (387)/mm3v 1376 (581)/mm3; protein 3.1 (0.3) mg/dl v 2.9 (0.3) mg/dl, and LDH 478 (232) IU/l v 502 (123) IU/l), and the degree of microscopic pleural fibrosis and pleural inflammation.

CONCLUSIONS

TGFβ2can induce effective pleurodesis and remains effective in the presence of high dose parenteral corticosteroids.

Experimental Pleurodesis in Rabbits Induced by Silver Nitrate or Talc

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To compare the pleurodesis results from the intrapleural injection of silver nitrate and talc slurry over an observation period of 12 months in rabbits.

DESIGN

Rabbits were randomized to receive 2 mL of 0.5% silver nitrate or 400 mg/kg of talc slurry in 2 mL intrapleurally. Ten rabbits in each group were killed at 1 month, 2 months, 4 months, 6 months, 8 months, 10 months, and 12 months after intrapleural injection. The degree of gross pleurodesis and the amount of microscopic pleural fibrosis and inflammation were graded on a scale of 0 to 4.

RESULTS

The mean +/- SEM gross pleurodesis score in the 70 rabbits that received silver nitrate was 3.34 +/- 0.08, which was significantly higher than the score of 2.32 +/- 0.09 in the 70 rabbits that received talc. The mean gross pleurodesis score was significantly higher at each of the observation times (p < 0.05), except at 2 months, in the rabbits that received silver nitrate. The pleurodesis was distributed throughout the thorax in the rabbits that received silver nitrate, while it was only in the ventral thorax in the rabbits that received talc slurry. The gross pleurodesis scores showed no tendency to decrease during the 12-month observation period in either treatment group. The persistence of talc in the pleural space did not lead to chronic inflammatory changes because the inflammation scores were similar in both groups at all observation times. The microscopic pleural fibrosis score tended to decrease with time in the silver nitrate group but not in the talc slurry group.

CONCLUSIONS

The intrapleural injection of 2 mL of 0.5% silver nitrate produces a better pleurodesis than does the intrapleural injection of 400 mg/kg of talc slurry in rabbits. The pleurodesis induced by silver nitrate persists for at least 1 year. The efficacy of silver nitrate as a sclerosing agent in humans should be evaluated.

Transforming growth factor-beta2 induces pleurodesis significantly faster than talc

Transforming growth factor-beta2 (TGF-beta2) has recently been shown to produce effective pleurodesis in rabbits. Conventional pleurodesing agents such as talc act by inducing pleural injury, which results in acute inflammation and fibrosis. TGF-beta2 is a profibrotic cytokine capable of producing fibrosis without inducing significant pleural inflammation. We hypothesize that intrapleural administration of TGF-beta2 would (1) produce an effective pleurodesis faster; (2) stimulate more collagen deposition, and (3) induce less inflammation when compared with intrapleural injection of talc. Thirty rabbits were divided into two groups and given either TGF-beta(2) (1.7 microg) or talc slurry (400 mg/kg) via a chest tube. Five rabbits from each group were killed at Days 1, 4, and 7. Gross pleurodesis was graded from 1 (none) to 8 (complete symphysis). The microscopic pleural inflammation and fibrosis were graded from 0 to 4. Pleural thickening and the total area of collagen deposition were compared. Intrapleural injection of TGF-beta2 produced effective pleurodesis within 7 d (median pleurodesis score = 7 at Day 7). At Day 7, TGF-beta2 induced significantly more collagen deposition (19.4 +/- 19.6% versus 4.6 +/- 2.9% of total area of pleura at Day 7), higher pleural fibrosis score (3.0 +/- 1.0 versus 1.8 +/- 0.5), and pleural thickness (286 +/- 191 versus 85 +/- 37 microm) than did talc. There was no difference in the degree of pleural inflammation between the two groups at Day 7 (2.6 +/- 0.9 for TGF-beta2 versus 2.4 +/- 0.6 for talc) or at any other time points. In conclusion, the intrapleural administration of TGF-beta2 produced excellent pleurodesis in rabbits at a rate faster than talc slurry and all other pleurodesing agents investigated before. TGF-beta2 stimulated more collagen deposition without inducing excess inflammation when compared with talc slurry. TGF-beta2 may have advantages over talc slurry in the management of recurrent pleural effusion and pneumothorax.

Silver nitrate is superior to talc slurry in producing pleurodesis in rabbits

STUDY OBJECTIVE

The ideal agent for producing pleurodesis has not been identified. Although talc is the agent most commonly used at the present time, there are concerns about its safety. Silver nitrate is a possible alternative agent. The purpose of the present study was to compare the effectiveness of intrapleural silver nitrate and talc slurry in producing pleurodesis in rabbits. Additionally, the total amount of pleural collagen and the distribution of thick and thin collagen fibers were studied.

DESIGN

Two groups of 10 rabbits received either 0.50% silver nitrate or 400 mg/kg talc in a total volume of 2 mL intrapleurally. The animals were killed 28 days after injection, and the pleural spaces were assessed grossly for evidence of pleurodesis and microscopically for evidence of inflammation and fibrosis. Collagen was assessed with the van Gieson's and picrosirius stains.

RESULTS

The macroscopic pleurodesis (scale, 0 to 4; mean +/- SEM) resulting from the intrapleural injection of silver nitrate (3.4+/-0.2) was significantly better (p<0.001) than that resulting from talc (1.6+/- 0.1). The mean degree of microscopic pleural fibrosis induced by silver nitrate (3.3+/-0.3) was significantly higher (p = 0.003) than that induced by talc (1.8+/-0.1). The mean amount of microscopic pleural collagen (van Gieson's) was significantly greater (p<0.001) in the rabbits that received silver nitrate (3.0+/-0.2) than in those that received talc (1.6+/-0.2). The distribution of thick and thin collagen fibers did not differ between the groups.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that, in our rabbit model, intrapleural silver nitrate was more effective than talc in producing a pleurodesis.

A single intrapleural injection of transforming growth factor-beta(2) produces an excellent pleurodesis in rabbits

The purpose of the present study was to determine whether the intrapleural injection of transforming growth factor beta(2) (TGF-beta(2)) would produce a pleurodesis in rabbits. Single intrapleural injections of TGF-beta(2) at doses of 5.00 microg (n = 12), 1.67 microg (n = 10), 0.50 microg (n = 10), or 0.167 microg (n = 4), or of the parenteral buffer alone (n = 5) were given in a volume of 2 ml to New Zealand white rabbits. Chest tubes were left in place for at least 72 h. Pleural fluid was aspirated at 24-h intervals and was measured and subjected to chemical analysis. The animals were killed 14 d after the injection. The intrapleural injection of TGF-beta(2) resulted in a dose-dependent pleurodesis (on a scale of 0 to 4, where 0 = no pleurodesis and 4 = complete pleurodesis) with mean scores of 3.6, 2.6, 1.5, 0.7, and 0.3 for the groups that received 5.0, 1.67, 0.50, and 0.167 microg of TGF-beta(2) and buffer alone, respectively. Intrapleural injection of the larger doses of TGF-beta(2) resulted in the formation of a large amount of pleural fluid. The fluid had a significantly lower white blood cell (WBC) count and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) level than did the fluid that results from the intrapleural injection of 10 mg/kg doxycycline or 400 mg/kg talc slurry. On the basis of this study we conclude that a single intrapleural injection of TGF-beta(2) induces pleurodesis in a dose-dependent manner. A dose of 5.0 microg produced satisfactory pleurodesis in almost all of the rabbits so treated. Larger doses of TGF-beta(2) induced larger pleural effusions with relatively low pleural fluid WBC counts and LDH levels. The ability of TGF-beta to produce a pleurodesis in patients with recurrent pleural effusions or pneumothorax should be investigated. A single intrapleural injection of TGF-beta(2) may produce a pleurodesis both safely and painlessly.

Effectiveness of silver nitrate compared to talc slurry as pleural sclerosing agent in rabbits. Influence of concomitant intrapleural lidocaine

The ideal agent for producing pleurodesis has not been identified. Talc, the most commonly used, poses several problems. Another possibility is silver nitrate, which was widely used in the past.

PURPOSE

To determine the influence of the intrapleural instillation of lidocaine in producing a pleurodesis with silver nitrate, to define the effect of lidocaine in the maturation of the collagen fibers, and to confirm that the pleurodesis after silver nitrate is stronger than after talc.

METHODS

We studied three groups of 8 rabbits. Two groups received 0.5% silver nitrate; in one we had previously injected 0.5 ml of 2% lidocaine. The third group received 400 mg/kg talc (2 ml). The animals were sacrificed 28 days after the injection, and the pleural spaces were assessed grossly for evidence of pleurodesis and microscopically for evidence of inflammation and fibrosis. The total amount of pleural collagen and the distribution of thick and thin collagen fibers were quantified. Collagen was identified using picrosirius red stain.

RESULTS

In the two groups that received silver nitrate (without lidocaine: 3.5 + 03 and with lidocaine: 3.2 + 0.3), the macroscopic pleurodesis (scale 0 - 4) was significantly (p = 0.001) better than that resulting from talc (1.6 + 0.2). The mean degree of pleural fibrosis induced by silver nitrate (3.5 + 0.2) was significantly (p = 0.004) higher than that induced by talc (1.9 + 0.1). The previous instillation of lidocaine resulted in a tendency for decreased amounts of fibrosis (3.1 + 0.4). The mean amount (10(3)mm2) of pleural collagen was significantly (p = 0.009) greater in the rabbits that received silver nitrate (116.9 + 22.7) than in those that received talc (10.7 + 3.4). The injection of lidocaine slightly reduced the collagen (80.1 + 30.3). The distribution of collagen fibers did not differ among the groups.

CONCLUSION

This rabbit model clearly confirms that intrapleural silver nitrate is more effective than talc for producing pleurodesis. The previous intrapleural instillation of lidocaine results in a decreasing trend in the amount of collagen, but does not change the effectiveness of the pleural fusion or modify the process of collagen maturation.

Respiratory failure following talc pleurodesis

BACKGROUND

Sterile talc is currently the agent of choice for pleurodesis. Its success rate is excellent, and talc is generally well tolerated. However, a recent experience with fulminant pneumonitis following talc pleurodesis prompted a review of our experience.

METHODS

A retrospective review of patients undergoing talc pleurodesis at our institution between December 1993 and December 1997 was performed, documenting respiratory and other complications. Statistical analysis was performed using Student's t test and Pearson correlations.

RESULTS

Seventy-eight patients received 89 talc pleurodesis procedures. Respiratory complications or death occurred in 33%; 9% of patients developed adult respiratory distress syndrome. There was no statistical difference in outcomes between patient groups, methods of application, or talc dosages utilized.

CONCLUSIONS

This series revealed a significantly higher rate of serious complications than that reported in the current literature, without implicating a clear reason for these outcomes. Our data raise questions about the safety of talc pleurodesis.