Abnormal Newborn Screening Follow-up for Severe Combined Immunodeficiency in an Amish Cohort with Cartilage-Hair Hypoplasia

Shorter birth length and decreased T-cell production and function predict severe infections in children with non-severe combined immunodeficiency cartilage-hair hypoplasia

Background

Cartilage-hair hypoplasia (CHH) is a syndromic inborn error of immunity caused by variants in the RMRP gene. Disease manifestations vary, and their ability to predict outcome is uncertain. The optimal management of infants with CHH who do not fulfill classical severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) criteria is unknown.

Objective

We described longitudinal changes in lymphocyte counts during childhood and explored correlations of early childhood clinical and laboratory features with clinical outcomes on long-term follow-up of CHH patients.

Methods

Immunologic laboratory parameters, birth length, the presence of Hirschsprung disease, and severe anemia correlated to the primary end points of respiratory and severe infections. We implemented traditional statistical methods and machine learning techniques.

Results

Thirty-two children with CHH were followed up for 2.7 to 22.1 years (median, 8.2 years, in total 331.3 patient-years). None of the patients had classical SCID. Median lymphocyte subclass counts, apart from CD16+/56+ cells, were subnormal throughout childhood, but did not show age-related decline seen in healthy children. Low immunoglobulin levels were uncommon and often transient. Respiratory and/or severe infections developed in 14 children, 8 of whom had low naive T-cell counts, absent T-cell receptor excision circles, and/or partial "leaky" SCID-level lymphopenia. Shorter birth length correlated with lower lymphocyte counts and the occurrence of infections. Of the laboratory parameters, decreased naive T-cell counts and abnormal lymphocyte proliferation responses contributed most to the development of severe infections. In addition, all participants with absent T-cell receptor excision circles developed severe infections. Opportunistic infections occurred only in children with leaky SCID-level lymphopenia.

Conclusions

Shorter birth length and a combination of laboratory abnormalities can predict the development of severe infections in children with CHH.

Oral findings in patients with cartilage-hair hypoplasia - cross-sectional observational study

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Cartilage-hair hypoplasia (CHH) is a rare chondrodysplasia with associated primary immunodeficiency. The aim of this cross-sectional study was to examine oral health indicators in individuals with CHH.

METHODS

In total, 23 individuals with CHH, aged between 4.5 and 70 years, and 46 controls aged between 5 and 76 years were clinically examined for periodontal disease, presence of oral mucosal lesions, tooth decay, masticatory system function, and malocclusions. A chairside lateral flow immunoassay test of active-matrix metalloproteinase was obtained from all the adult participants with a permanent dentition. Laboratory signs of immunodeficiency were recorded for individuals with CHH.

RESULTS

Individuals with CHH and controls had similar prevalence of gingival bleeding on probing (median 6% vs. 4%). Oral fluid active-matrix metalloproteinase concentration was greater than 20 ng/ml in 45% of study subjects in both groups. However, deep periodontal pockets, 4 mm or deeper, were more common in individuals with CHH as compared to the controls (U = 282.5, p = 0.002). Similarly mucosal lesions were significantly more common in individuals with CHH (30% vs. 9%, OR = 0.223, 95%CI 0.057-0.867). The median sum of the number of decayed, missing due to caries, and filled teeth was nine for the individuals with CHH and four for controls. In the CHH cohort, 70% displayed an ideal sagittal occlusal relationship. Malocclusion and temporomandibular joint dysfunction prevalence were similar in both study groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Individuals with CHH have more frequently deep periodontal pockets and oral mucosal lesions than general population controls. Routine intraoral examination by a dentist at regular intervals should be recommended to all individuals with CHH.

Newborn Screening for Severe Combined Immunodeficiency: 10-Year Experience at a Single Referral Center (2009-2018)

In 2008, newborn screening (NBS) for severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) began as a pilot study in Wisconsin and has recently been added to every state's newborn screen panel. The incidence of SCID is estimated at 1 per 58,000 births which may suggest infrequent NBS SCID screen positive results in states with low annual birth rates. In this study, we report our center's experience with NBS positive SCID screen referrals over a 10-year period. A total of 68 full-term newborns were referred to our center for confirmatory testing. Of these referrals, 50% were false positives, 12% were SCID diagnoses, 20% syndromic T cell lymphopenia (TCL) disorders, and 18% non-SCID, non-syndromic TCL. Through collaboration with our newborn screening lab, second-tier targeted gene sequencing was performed for newborns with SCID screen positive results from communities with known founder pathogenic variants and provided rapid genetic confirmation of SCID and non-SCID TCL disorders. Despite extensive genetic testing, two of the eight (25%) identified newborns with SCID diagnoses lacked a definable genetic defect. Additionally, our referrals included ten newborns who were otherwise healthy newborns with idiopathic TCL and varied CD3+ T cell number longitudinal trajectories. Collectively, referrals to our single site over a 10-year period describe a broad spectrum of medically actionable and idiopathic TCL disorders which highlight the importance of clinical immunology expertise in all states, demonstrate efficiencies and challenges for second-tier genetic testing, and further emphasize the need to development standardized evaluation algorithms for non-SCID TCL.

Immunodeficiency in cartilage-hair hypoplasia: Pathogenesis, clinical course and management

Cartilage-hair hypoplasia (CHH) is an autosomal recessive syndromic immunodeficiency with skeletal dysplasia, short stature, hypotrichosis, variable degree of immune dysfunction and increased incidence of anaemia, Hirschsprung disease and malignancy. CHH is caused by variants in the RMRP gene, encoding the untranslated RNA molecule of the mitochondrial RNA-processing endoribonuclease, which participates in for example cell cycle regulation and telomere maintenance. Recent studies have expanded our understanding of the complex pathogenesis of CHH. Immune dysfunction has a major impact on clinical course and prognosis. Clinical features of immune dysfunction are highly variable, progressive and include infections, lung disease, immune dysregulation and malignancy. Mortality is increased compared with the general population, due to infections, malignancy and pulmonary disease. Several risk factors for early mortality have been reported in the Finnish CHH cohort and can be used to guide management. Newborn screening for severe combined immunodeficiency can possibly be of prognostic value in CHH. Regular follow-up by a multidisciplinary team should be implemented to address immune dysfunction in all patients with CHH, also in asymptomatic cases. Haematopoietic stem cell transplantation can cure immune dysfunction, but its benefits in mildly symptomatic patients with CHH remain debatable. Further research is needed to understand the mechanisms behind the variability of clinical features, to search for potential molecular treatment targets, to examine and validate risk factors for early mortality outside the Finnish CHH cohort and to develop management guidelines. This review focuses on the pathogenesis, clinical course and management of CHH.