Quantitative studies of human lung airspace wall in relation to collagen and elastin content

Respiratory bronchiolitis/interstitial lung disease: fibrosis, pulmonary function, and evolving concepts

CONTEXT

The concept of respiratory bronchiolitis/interstitial lung disease (RBILD) was introduced to explain the presence of interstitial lung disease in individuals whose only finding on surgical lung biopsy was smoker's respiratory bronchiolitis (RB). Over time, the diagnostic criteria for RBILD have become progressively more confused.

OBJECTIVE

To review the diagnostic criteria for RBILD.

DESIGN

The review was based on the literature and personal experience.

CONCLUSIONS

The concept of RBILD has changed over time with the recognition that, histologically and radiologically, RB and RBILD are usually indistinguishable. Most authors accept mild alveolar wall fibrosis extending away from the respiratory bronchioles as a part of both RB and RBILD, and occasional cases show quite marked, but probably localized, interstitial fibrosis. What has not been appreciated is that RB is not only an extremely common disease in cigarette smokers but also is ordinarily associated with airflow obstruction. Further, interstitial fibrosis is sometimes found in centrilobular emphysema, and this phenomenon has probably lead to some cases of centrilobular emphysema being misclassified as RB or RBILD. Despite the presence of fibrosis, centrilobular emphysema is still associated with airflow obstruction. We suggest that RBILD be restricted to the clinical setting in which cigarette smokers have a restrictive or mixed obstructive and restrictive functional abnormality, have a marked decrease in diffusing capacity with minimal evidence of airflow obstruction, or have imaging studies showing ground glass opacities/centrilobular nodules plus reticulation and no other lesion besides RB on biopsy to account for these changes. In this setting, the presence of RB-associated interstitial fibrosis probably causes the functional changes.

Emphysema and metalloelastase expression in mouse lung induced by cigarette smoke

Cigarette smoke (CS) causes pulmonary emphysema in humans and elastin degradation plays a key role in its pathogenesis. Previous studies on CS-exposed animals have been equivocal and have not clearly demonstrated the progression of the disease. In this study, morphometry was used to assess lung modifications to alveolar septa, airspaces, elastic and collagen fibers, and alveolar macrophages. Male (n = 40) C57/BL6 mice were exposed 3 times/day, whole body, to CS from three cigarettes for 10, 20, 30, or 60 days. Control groups (n = 10) were sham-smoked or received no exposure (day 0, n = 10). Morphometry included measurements of volume fraction of alveolar septa and airspaces, elastic and collagen fibers, and surface fraction of elastic fibers and alveolar septa. Morphometrical differences in mice after 60 days of exposure were greater than those after 10, 20, or 30 days, suggesting a progression of the disease. Inflammatory lesions in the lungs of mice contained significantly more metalloelastase (MMP-12) in macrophages at 10, 20, and 30 days than in controls of mice exposed for 60 days. These results suggest that elastin degradation took place during development of pulmonary changes in mice exposed to CS, and activation of MMPs specific for elastin may be a determining factor for susceptibility to emphysema.

Collagen content of alveolar wall tissue in emphysematous and non-emphysematous lungs

BACKGROUND

Emphysema is currently defined as "a condition of the lung characterised by abnormal, permanent enlargement of the airspaces distal to the terminal bronchiole, accompanied by destruction of their walls, and without obvious fibrosis." The functional and morphological changes that occur in emphysema have largely been attributed to changes in alveolar elastin rather than in collagen. A study was performed to determine whether the amount of collagen in the alveolar wall changes with age in the lungs of non-smokers and of smokers with different types of macroscopically defined emphysema in relation to a microscopic measurement of lung structure.

METHODS

Total alveolar wall collagen was measured (as hydroxyproline) in known volumes of distended lung tissue (by reverse phase high pressure liquid chromatography) in the lungs of non-smokers (n = 23) and in regions sampled away from emphysematous lesions in the lungs of 36 smokers (four with no emphysema, 13 with centriacinar emphysema (CAE), nine with panacinar emphysema (PAE), and 10 with a mixture (MIX) of both PAE and CAE). Mean lung airspace wall surface area per unit volume (AWUV) was calculated from at least six random blocks per lung and on histological sections immediately adjacent to those prepared for collagen measurement with a rapid scanning device (fast interval processor).

RESULTS

In non-smokers there was no significant correlation between the amount of collagen in the alveolar wall tissue and either mean lung AWUV or increasing patient age when amounts of collagen were expressed either per unit volume of distended lung (40 mm3 sample) or per unit surface area of airspace wall tissue. Smokers without emphysema had similar amounts of collagen to non-smokers. Lungs with PAE and MIX, but not CAE alone, contained significantly more collagen than normal when expressed per unit volume of airspace wall tissue whereas all groups, including CAE, contained significantly raised amounts of collagen when expressed per unit surface area.

CONCLUSIONS

There is no significant age related change in the collagen content of the lungs of non-smokers which suggests that, as AWUV is lost with age, the main collagenous framework is maintained. However, in smokers with emphysema there is a loss of airspace wall tissue in regions remote from the macroscopic lesions that is accompanied by a net increase in collagen mass. The greater accumulation of collagen in MIX lungs than in CAE lungs suggests a greater degree of structural damage, indicative of an alternative pathogenetic mechanism operating between the different types of emphysema. Our results suggest an active alveolar wall fibrosis in emphysema as a consequence of cigarette smoking. It is suggested that the definition of emphysema may require further revision to include such change.