Cross-linked iron dextran is an efficient oral phosphate binder in the rat

Novel iron-containing phosphate binders for treatment of hyperphosphatemia

INTRODUCTION

Hyperphosphatemia is a frequent complication of chronic kidney disease and is associated with increased mortality. Despite side effects, risk of accumulation and high costs, phosphate binders (PBs) have become the crucial cornerstone of therapy. The iron-containing PB sucroferric oxyhydroxide (SO) and ferric citrate hydrate (FCH) have entered the market and other candidates are prior market entry.

AREAS COVERED

A literature search was performed using MEDLINE and EMBASE databases to identify references on iron-containing PB with particular regard to efficacy, safety and potential benefits. Additional hand searches were conducted along with a full-text review of any citation that appeared relevant.

EXPERT OPINION

On the highly competitive market, where the 'ideal' PB is still unknown, novel substances that offer clear benefits over available drugs are desired. Although SO and FCH showed similar efficacy and safety compared to sevelamer, head-to-head studies with lanthanum carbonate are absent. Clinical 1-year data in a limited patient cohort suggested improved adherence for SO and a large randomized controlled trial showed significant reduction in hospitalizations and costs for FCH. Additional large randomized controlled trials have now to prove these possible advantages. Cost-effectiveness in comparison to other PB and the exclusion of significant harms under long-term treatment will determine the future use of both drugs.

Is there a need for new phosphate binders to treat phosphate imbalance associated with chronic kidney disease?

INTRODUCTION

Mineral and bone disorder (MBD) begins early in the course of chronic kidney disease (CKD). Phosphate imbalance in CKD-MBD can lead to various pathologies of clinical importance such as further deterioration of kidney function, cardiovascular complications, renal osteodystrophy and increased mortality.

AREAS COVERED

The authors conducted a systematic review of the biomedical literature to evaluate currently available drugs and new phosphate binder therapeutics in development.

EXPERT OPINION

There is a need to continue searching for novel phosphate binders that better match an 'ideal' product profile. This profile should have: i) a product that is highly efficient in binding phosphate; ii) low patient compliance issues; iii) minimal interaction with other drugs; and iv) reduced side effects and safety concerns. Targeting alternative mechanisms, such as developing inhibitors for intestinal type II sodium-dependent phosphate co-transporter, may also improve the limitations of phosphate binder therapeutics. Current medical practice focuses on using serum phosphorus levels as the only marker for detecting, monitoring and treating phosphate imbalance in CKD. However, the consequences of phosphate imbalance are evident in non-dialysis patients before serum phosphate levels rise above the normal range. There is a need to search for other markers to guide detection and treatment of clinically significant alterations in phosphate metabolism of non-dialysis CKD.

Ironing out the phosphorus problem

Control of serum phosphorus remains a vexing problem in chronic kidney disease. Although novel dialysis regimens may provide excellent phosphorus control, phosphate binders remain necessary for most dialysis patients. Block et al. present a phase I clinical trial examining the safety and efficacy of SBR759, a novel non-calcium, iron-based phosphate binder. Although the risks of iron accumulation and hypocalcemia must be addressed, this phosphate binder appears to be well tolerated and effective and offers a powder-based formulation.

Management of Hyperphosphataemia in Dialysis Patients

Phosphorus control remains a relevant clinical problem in dialysis patients. With age, however, serum phosphorus level decreases significantly because of a spontaneous decrease in protein intake. Older patients usually need lower doses of phosphorus binders. Nevertheless, hyperphosphataemia is observed in a quarter of patients aged >65 years. Phosphorus retention is related to an imbalance between phosphorus intake and removal by dialysis, and is usually aggravated when vitamin D analogues are employed. Hyperphosphataemia induces secondary hyperparathyroidism and the development of osteitis fibrosa. Recent publications describe an association between phosphorus retention and increased calcium and phosphorus product (Ca2+ x P), with significant progression of tissue calcification and higher mortality risk. Dietary intervention, phosphorus removal during dialysis and phosphorus binders are current methods for the management of hyperphosphataemia. However, the phosphorus removed by standard haemodialysis is insufficient to achieve a neutral phosphorus balance when protein intake is >50 g/day. Additional protein restriction may impose the risk of a negative protein balance. More frequent dialysis may help to control resistant hyperphosphataemia. Phosphorus binders constitute the mainstay of serum phosphorus level control in end-stage renal disease patients. Aluminium-based phosphorus binders, associated with toxic effects, have largely been substituted by calcium-based phosphorus binders. However, widespread use of calcium-based phosphorus binders has evidenced the frequent appearance of hypercalcaemia and long-term progressive cardiovascular calcification. Sevelamer, a relatively new phosphorus binder, has proved efficacious in lowering serum phosphorus and parathyroid hormone (PTH) levels without inducing hypercalcaemia. Furthermore, several investigators have reported that sevelamer may prevent progression of coronary calcification. However, its efficacy in severe cases of hyperphosphataemia remains to be confirmed in large series. There are no specific guidelines for phosphorus control in the elderly. Until more information is available, levels of mineral metabolites should be targeted in the same range as those recommended for the general population on dialysis (calcium 8.7-10.2 mg/dL, phosphorus 3.5-5.5 mg/dL and Ca2+ x P 50-55 mg2/dL2). PTH values over 120 ng/L help to avoid adynamic bone disease. Since elderly patients have a higher incidence of adynamic bone (which buffers less calcium) and vascular calcification, sevelamer should be the phosphorus binder of choice in this population; but sevelamer is costly and its long-term efficacy has not been definitively validated. Patients with low normal levels of calcium may receive calcium-based phosphorus binders with little risk. Patients with low values of PTH and high normal calcium should receive sevelamer. Tailored combinations of calcium-based phosphorus binders and sevelamer should be considered, and calcium dialysate concentration adjusted accordingly.

Hyperphosphataemia in renal failure: causes, consequences and current management

Hyperphosphataemia is prevalent among chronic renal failure and dialysis patients. It is known to stimulate parathyroid hormone and suppress vitamin D3 production, thereby inducing hyperparathyroid bone disease. In addition, it may independently contribute to cardiac causes of death through increased myocardial calcification and enhanced vascular calcification. Hyperphosphataemia is also associated with cardiac microcirculatory abnormalities. Therefore, phosphate control is of prime importance. It is important to control phosphate levels early in the course of chronic renal failure in order to avoid and treat secondary hyperparathyroidism, and cardiovascular and soft tissue calcifications. Dietetic restrictions are often difficult to follow long term. Because of its large sphere of hydration and the complex kinetics of phosphate elimination, phosphate is not easily removed by dialysis. Long, slow dialysis may be effective, but this needs logistics and acceptance by patients. Thus, oral phosphate binders are generally required to control serum levels. None of the existing phosphate binding agents is truly satisfactory. Aluminium-containing agents are highly efficient but many clinicians have abandoned their use because of the potential toxicity. Despite of the wide use of calcium-containing agents, there was a link with hypercalcaemia and soft tissue calcifications. Novel phosphate binders in the form of polyallylamine hydrochloride, polyuronic acid derivatives and lanthanum carbonate appear promising. In this review, we discuss causes of hyperphosphataemia, pathological consequences and modalities of treatment.

Safety of New Phosphate Binders for Chronic Renal Failure

Phosphate (Pi) retention is a common problem in patients with chronic kidney disease, particularly in those who have reached end-stage renal disease (ESRD). In addition to causing secondary hyperparathyroidism and renal osteodystrophy, recent evidence suggests that, in ESRD patients, high serum phosphorus concentration and increased calcium and phosphorous (Ca x P) product are associated with vascular and cardiac calcifications and increased mortality. Dietary phosphorus restriction and Pi removal by dialysis are not sufficient to restore Pi homeostasis. Reduction of intestinal Pi absorption with the use of Pi binders is currently the primary treatment for Pi retention in patients with ESRD. The use of large doses of calcium-containing Pi binders along with calcitriol administration may contribute to over-suppression of parathyroid hormone secretion and adynamic bone disease as well as to a high incidence of vascular calcifications. When used in patients with impaired renal function, aluminium salts were found to accumulate in bone and other tissues, resulting in osteomalacia and encephalopathy.Sevelamer, an aluminium- and calcium-free Pi binder can reduce serum phosphorus concentration and is associated with a significantly lower incidence of hypercalcaemia, while maintaining the ability to suppress parathyroid hormone production. An additional benefit of sevelamer is its ability to lower low density lipoprotein-cholesterol and total cholesterol levels. Sevelamer attenuates the progression of vascular calcifications in haemodialysis patients, which may lead to lower mortality. The use of sevelamer in non-dialysed patients might aggravate metabolic acidosis, common in these patients. Several other calcium-free Pi binders are in development. Lanthanum carbonate has shown significant promise in clinical trials in ESRD patients. Magnesium salts do not offer a significant advantage over currently available Pi binders. Their use is restricted to patients receiving dialysis since excess magnesium must be removed by dialysis. Iron-based compounds have shown variable efficacy in short-term clinical trials in small numbers of haemodialysis patients. Mixed metal hydroxyl carbonate compounds have shown efficacy in animals but have not been studied in humans. Major safety issues include absorption of the metal component with possible tissue accumulation and toxicity.

Hyperphosphatemia in end-stage renal disease

Hyperphosphatemia occurs universally in end-stage renal disease (ESRD) unless efforts are made to prevent positive phosphate balance. Positive phosphate balance results from the loss of renal elimination of phosphate and continued obligatory intestinal absorption of dietary phosphate. Increased efflux of phosphate from bone because of excess parathyroid hormone-mediated bone resorption can also contribute to increased serum phosphate concentrations in the setting of severe hyperparathyroidism. It is important to treat hyperphosphatemia because it contributes to the pathogenesis of hyperparathyroidism, vascular calcifications, and increased cardiovascular mortality in ESRD patients. Attaining a neutral phosphate balance, which is the key to the management of hyperphosphatemia in ESRD, is a challenge. Control of phosphorus depends on its removal during dialysis and the limitation of gastrointestinal absorption by dietary phosphate restriction and chelation of phosphate. Knowledge of the quantitative aspects of phosphate balance is useful in optimizing our use of phosphate binders, dialysis frequency, and vitamin D sterols. The development of new phosphate binders and efforts to find new ways to inhibit gastrointestinal absorption of phosphate will lead to improvements in the control of serum phosphate levels in ESRD.

Compounds in development to combat hyperphosphataemia

Hyperphosphataemia in haemodialysis patients is associated with secondary hyperparathyroidism and more importantly with an increased cardiovascular mortality in dialysed patients. Removal of phosphate during dialysis is less than net intestinal uptake. This imbalance results in a positive phosphate balance. To control serum phosphate concentration oral phosphate binders have to be taken to reduce net intestinal uptake. The use of classical phosphate binders such as calcium carbonate, calcium acetate and aluminium-containing phosphate binders is limited by their side effects. Hypercalcaemia aggravates vascular calcification and cardiovascular risk. Aluminium intoxication causes aluminium osteopathy, anaemia and encephalopathy. Therefore, the development of calcium- and aluminium free phosphate binders has become a challenge to clinical nephrology. Polyallylamine hydrochloride (sevelamer) is one of the new alternative compounds which has been shown to effectively bind phosphate in dialysis patients. A promising approach in the development of alternative phophate binders are trivalent-iron (Fe(III)) containing phosphate binders. They were not only successfully tested in experimental animals but have also been shown to reduce urinary phosphate excretion and serum phosphate concentrations in patients with preterminal failure and those on maintenance haemodialysis. This review outlines the experimental and clinical data on Fe-III based phosphate binders providing evidence that they will be as effective and safe as phosphate binders without the major side effects of classical phosphate-binding compounds.

The evaluation of novel mixed metal hydroxy-carbonates as phosphate binders: an in-vivo study in the rat

A number of novel phosphate binders based on mixed metal hydroxide structures incorporating Fe and Ca, or Fe and Mg (classified as CT, Crosfield test compounds), were compared with the established phosphate binders Mg(OH)2, Al(OH)3, CaCO3 and a commercial hydrotalcite (Al- and Mg-based) using a rat model. The changes in urine and soluble faecal phosphate were used to evaluate efficacy of phosphate binding. The binders were mixed into a standard rat maintenance food at a concentration of 1% (w/w). Four rats were used for each binder study group and fed over 7 days. Urine and faeces were collected (in a metabolic cage) over the last 24-h study period and the phosphate content measured. The urinary phosphate was significantly reduced (P < 0.001) with CTFeCa (72+/-44 microm), CTFeMg (13+/-4 microm), CT100 (26+/-11 microm), and Mg(OH)2 (65+/-53 microm), compared with control (766+/-188 microm), Al(OH)3 (1,256+/-279 microm), and CaCO3 (857+/-25 microm). The soluble phosphate content of the faeces was significantly reduced (P < 0.05) by up to 60 % with CTFeCa, CTFeMg and Mg(OH)2, and up to 40% with CT100 and Al(OH)3, compared with 30% in controls and 10% with CaCO3. The new mixed metal hydroxy-carbonate compounds based on FeCa or FeMg are effective phosphate binders in-vivo and warrant further testing in patients.

Effect of iron(III) chitosan intake on the reduction of serum phosphorus in rats

Because of the widespread use of aluminium- and calcium-containing phosphate binders for the control of hyperphosphataemia in patients with end-stage renal failure, an iron(III) chitosan complex was synthesised and fed to rats to measure its effect on serum phosphorus and calcium, intestinal phosphate binding and phosphate absorption. Thirty-six Wistar rats were randomly selected and distributed into a baseline group (n = 6), a control group (n = 8 (days 0-15), n = 8 (days 16-30)) and a treatment group (n = 8 (days 0-15), n = 8 (days 16-30)). The control groups ingested AIN-76 diet mix with a 1% w/w fibre content; however, the treatment groups had the fibre content completely substituted with iron(III) chitosan. The mean weights of the treated rats were slightly lower from 15 days (not significant); but overall, rat growth was not stunted in the treatment groups. The serum phosphorus levels of the treated group (n = 8) were significantly reduced after 15 days (P = 0.004; control: 5.7+/-0.9 mg dL(-1); treatment: 4.4+/-0.5 mg dL(-1); 95% CI of difference: 0.5-2.2) and 30 days (P = 0.002; control: 5.5+/-0.9 mg dL(-1); treatment = 4.1+/-06 mg dL(-1); 95% CI of difference: 0.6-2.3) as compared with the respective control group. The serum calcium-phosphorus product was 62.0+/-12.1 mg2 dL(-2) for the control and 45.1+/-6.6 mg2 dL(-2) for the treatment group after 30 days (P = 0.004). The serum iron concentration of the treatment group did not differ from the baseline value after 15 and 30 days, but the treatment group was significantly higher than the control group (P<0.05) after 30 days. The faeces phosphorus levels (mg day(-1)) were higher (P<0.01) and its iron content was much higher (P<0.01) for the treated group. The urine phosphorus (mg kg(-1)) was not significantly reduced for the treated group, but the mean was consistently less. The kidney and liver weights of both groups were similar, but the phosphorus content of the kidney (mg (g kidney)(-1)) was higher for the treated group after 30 days (P = 0.041; control, 4.2+/-1.2 mg g(-1) vs treatment, 5.6+/-1.4 mg g(-1). Because iron(III) chitosan had a high phosphorus-binding capacity of 308 (mg P) per gram of Fe3+ for both the in-vitro (pH 7.5) and in-vivo studies, which is greater than nearly all commonly used phosphate binders, and a small net phosphorus absorption difference of 3.7 mg day(-1), it is an efficient phosphate binder for lowering serum phosphate levels without increasing serum calcium levels.

Phosphate binders on iron basis: a new perspective?

Uremic patients on maintenance hemodialysis are in positive phosphate balance. This is mainly the result of the complex elimination kinetics of phosphate during dialysis. Removal of phosphate is less than net dietary intake. Classical phosphate binders such as calcium carbonate, calcium acetate, and aluminum-based compounds are limited by side effects (hypercalcemia) and outright toxicity (aluminium). There have been numerous recent attempts to develop alternative phosphate binders, e.g., polyallylamine-hydrochloride (Renagel), lanthanum carbonate, and trivalent iron-containing compounds. The latter is based on old observations that iron salts may cause hyperphosphatemia and rickets in experimental animals and in patients. This idea has recently been taken up again, and effective inhibition of net intestinal phosphate uptake in non-uremic and uremic rats has been shown using simple iron salts (citrate, chloride, ammonium citrate) and complex compounds (cross-linked dextran and stabilized polynuclear iron hydroxide). In uremic rats, the latter compound reduces urinary phosphate excretion as an indicator of reduced intestinal phosphate uptake and has also been shown to be effective in subjects with preterminal renal failure. So far, no side effects or short-term toxicity has been observed. The compound appears promising and deserves further evaluation.

Oral phosphate binders: phosphate binding capacity of iron (III) hydroxide complexes containing saccharides and their effect on the urinary excretion of calcium and phosphate in rats

Phosphate binders that contain aluminum or calcium are frequently prescribed to treat hyperphosphatemia in patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD), but an accumulation of aluminum can lead to encephalopathy, aluminum-related bone disease (ARBD) such as osteomalacia, anaemia, and resistance to erythropoietin, and calcium accumulation can lead to hypercalcaemia. High phosphate concentrations are reduced in vitro and in vivo by a phosphate adsorption pill, which is synthesized by hydrolyzing ferrous sulfate in the presence of saccharides, to form an iron (III)-saccharide complex that is acid resistant and binds phosphate greater than iron (III) hydroxide alone. Under in vitro conditions, containing 3.26 mg P/dL, the iron (III)-sucrose complex showed the highest phosphate adsorption capacity at pH 2 with artificial gastric juice, 58.9 mg P/g binder. For the 7 day in vivo study, 0% (Group 1), 1% (Group 2), 4% (Group 3), and 8% (Group 4) iron (III)-sucrose complex was admixed into the rodent chow by weight and fed to 15 male Wistar rats. The weight and volume of the feces and urine, and the calcium, iron, and phosphorus excretions in the feces and urine samples were monitored for any signs of irregularity. Total urine outflow was collected during a 24-h period to determine the amount of phosphate recovered, which indicates the ability of the phosphate binder to reduce gastrointestinal phosphate absorption. The fecal iron excretion was significantly effected by the amount of binder ingested throughout the study for Group 2 (p < 0.001), Group 3 (p < 0.01), and Group 4 (p < 0.001). The urinary calcium excretion (mg/rat/24-h) significantly increased by the 7th day for Group 2 (p < 0.05) and Group 4 (p < 0.01) in comparison to the control. Finally, after 7 days, there was a significant drop in the urinary phosphorus levels (mg P/rat/24-h) in a dose dependent manner for Group 2: from 7.82 +/- 1.46 to 1.98 +/- 0.10 mg P/rat/24-h (102 mg P/dL/24-h; p < 0.05); Group 3: from 6.70 +/- 1.14 to 0.16 +/- 0.09 mg P/rat/24-h (6.0 mg P/dL/24-h; p < 0.01); and Group 4: from 8.25 +/- 0.67 to 0.04 +/- 0.01 mg P/rat/24-h (0.9 mg P/dL/24-h; p < 0.01). The results show that this new adsorbent might provide an alternative to conventional aluminum and calcium containing phosphate-binding agents for combating hyperphosphataemia.