Serology for automated cytotoxicity testing. II. Routine reading of HLA-typing using the Contrast Fluorescence Test

Outcomes among 562 recipients of placental-blood transplants from unrelated donors

BACKGROUND

A program for banking, characterizing, and distributing placental blood, also called umbilical-cord blood, for transplantation provided grafts for 562 patients between August 24, 1992, and January 30, 1998. We evaluated this experience.

METHODS

Placental blood was stored under liquid nitrogen and selected for specific patients on the basis of HLA type and leukocyte content. Patients were prepared for the transplantation of allogeneic hematopoietic cells in the placental blood and received prophylaxis against graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) according to routine procedures at each center.

RESULTS

Outcomes at 100 days after transplantation were known for all 562 patients, and outcomes at 1 year for 94 percent of eligible recipients. The cumulative rates of engraftment among the recipients, according to actuarial analysis, were 81 percent by day 42 for neutrophils (median time to engraftment, 28 days) and 85 percent by day 180 for platelets (median, day 90). The speed of myeloid engraftment was associated primarily with the leukocyte content of the graft, whereas transplantation-related events were associated with the patient's underlying disease and age, the number of leukocytes in the graft, the degree of HLA disparity, and the transplantation center. After engraftment, age, HLA disparity, and center were the primary predictors of outcome. Severe acute GVHD (grade III or IV) occurred in 23 percent of patients, and chronic GVHD occurred in 25 percent. The rate of relapse among recipients with leukemia was 9 percent within the first 100 days, 17 percent within 6 months, and 26 percent by 1 year. These rates were associated with the severity of GVHD, type of leukemia, and stage of the disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Placental blood is a useful source of allogeneic hematopoietic stem cells for bone marrow reconstitution.

Evaluation of an automated method of percent reactive antibody determination

A fluorescence-based automated method of percent reactive antibody (PRA) analysis is described. This method utilizes the conventional antibody-mediated, C'-dependent lymphocyte microcytotoxicity assay to detect alloantibodies, but replaces the eosin-based method for detection of cell death with a fluorescence-based method. To identify viable cells, lymphocytes were pretreated with carboxy fluorescein diacetate (CFDA), which fluoresces green, to identify viable cells. To identify dead cells after the reaction with antibody and C', they were treated with propidium iodide (PI), which fluoresces red. Pretreatment of lymphocytes with CFDA did not affect their ability or interact with alloantibodies in the microcytotoxicity assays. When visually analyzed, detection of cell death by fluorescence was as sensitive as detection by eosin exclusion. However electronic detection of fluorescence was slightly more sensitive than visual detection. Automation of the fluorescent method required a calculation that converts electronic data to an ASHI score for cell death. One such method is described and evaluated. Both the automated and the conventional methods of analysis were used to obtain PRA values for various sera. There was good correlation between the PRA values obtained with the automated method versus the conventional method. Further, there was good correlation for PRA-derived alloantibody specificities obtained with the automated method versus the conventional method. These data demonstrate that automated fluorescence-based PRA analysis is an effective and practical alternative to conventional PRA analysis.

Applications of automated simultaneous double fluorescence (SDF): I. Unbiased, quantitative HLA-A,B phenotyping

An automated HLA typing method has been developed and standardized. The procedure involves simultaneous excitation and reading of two fluorochromes, carboxy-fluorescein diacetate and propidium iodide, by a purpose-built Terasaki tray scanner known as the Astroscan 2100. Data obtained from 95 donors typed by this method and by the classical NIH dye exclusion method prove this system to be suitable for routine HLA-A,-B typing (similarity coefficient 0.9861). This comparison has highlighted significant observer bias, whereby the observer tends to downgrade very weakly positive reactions to negative and upgrade moderately positive reactions to strong positive. Elimination of this bias reduces the chances of any clinically disastrous consequence.

Applications of automated simultaneous double fluorescence (SDF). II. HLA class I phenotyping using immunomagnetically separated T lymphocytes

HLA class I phenotyping was performed using T-lymphocyte populations isolated by immunomagnetic beads (IMBs) coated with monoclonal antibodies with specificity for CD2, CD4 or CD8. The results were compared to those obtained using density gradient-separated lymphocytes (PBL). The typing trays were read by the automated simultaneous double-fluorescence (SDF) technique previously established in our laboratory using an Astroscan 2100 system. The aims of the present study were to establish whether the advantages of IMB lymphocyte separation and automated plate reading by SDF were complementary and whether the results obtained by IMB-SDF and PBL-SDF were concordant. Similarity coefficients for paired results obtained by IMB-SDF and PBL-SDF varied between 0.825 using anti-CD8-coated IMBs and 0.914 using anti-CD4-coated IMBs with a consistent excess of stronger results observed with the PBL-SDF technique. The variations observed did not result in incorrect phenotype assignment but would significantly influence a cross-matching test. These results illustrate the feasibility of using IMB-separated lymphocytes for HLA phenotyping by SDF.