Basic helix-loop-helix proteins in murine type C retrovirus transcriptional regulation

Control of pathogenicity and disease specificity of a T-lymphomagenic gammaretrovirus by E-box motifs but not by an overlapping glucocorticoid response element

Although transcription factors of the basic helix-loop-helix family have been shown to regulate enhancers of lymphomagenic gammaretroviruses through E-box motifs, the overlap of an E-box motif (Egre) with the glucocorticoid response element (GRE) has obscured their function in vivo. We report here that Egre, but not the GRE, affects disease induction by the murine T-lymphomagenic SL3-3 virus. Mutating all three copies of Egre prolonged the tumor latency period from 60 to 109 days. Further mutating an E-box motif (Ea/s) outside the enhancer prolonged the latency period to 180 days, suggesting that Ea/s works as a backup site for Egre. While wild-type SL3-3 and GRE and Ea/s mutants exclusively induced T-cell lymphomas with wild-type latencies mainly of the CD4(+) CD8(-) phenotype, Egre as well as the Egre and Ea/s mutants induced B-cell lymphomas and myeloid leukemia in addition to T-cell lymphomas. T-cell lymphomas induced by the two Egre mutants had the same phenotype as those induced by wild-type SL3-3, indicating the incomplete disruption of T-cell lymphomagenesis, which is in contrast to previous findings for a Runx site mutant of SL3-3. Mutating the Egre site or Egre and Ea/s triggered several tumor phenotype-associated secondary enhancer changes encompassing neighboring sites, none of which led to the regeneration of an E-box motif. Taken together, our results demonstrate a role for the E-box but not the GRE in T lymphomagenesis by SL3-3, unveil an inherent broader disease specificity of the virus, and strengthen the notion of selection for more potent enhancer variants of mutated viruses during tumor development.

Promoter Choice for Retroviral Vectors: Transcriptional Strength Versus Trans-Activation Potential

Gene expression from retroviral vectors can be driven by either the retroviral long terminal repeat (LTR) promoter or by cellular or viral promoters located internally in an LTR-deleted self-inactivating vector design. Adverse events in a gene therapy clinical trial for X-linked severe combined immune deficiency have led to the realization that the enhancer/promoter elements contained within integrated vectors may also act outside the vector genome to trans-activate host genes. Ideally, the gene expression system chosen for a vector should possess a low probability of trans-activation while still being able to support adequate levels of transgene expression. However, the parameters that define these specific characteristics are unknown. To gain insight into the mechanism of trans-activation, we compared a panel of commonly used retroviral LTRs and cellular and viral promoters for their ability to drive gene expression and to trans-activate a nearby minimal promoter in three different cell lines. These studies identified two elements, the cytomegalovirus enhancer/chicken beta-actin (CAG) and elongation factor (EF)-1alpha promoters, as being of potential value for use in vectors targeting lymphoid cells, as these elements exhibited both high levels of reporter gene expression and relatively low levels of trans-activation in T cells.

Enhancer mutations of Akv murine leukemia virus inhibit the induction of mature B-cell lymphomas and shift disease specificity towards the more differentiated plasma cell stage

This study investigates the role of the proviral transcriptional enhancer for B-lymphoma induction by exogenous Akv murine leukemia virus. Infection of newborn inbred NMRI mice with Akv induced 35% plasma cell proliferations (PCPs) (consistent with plasmacytoma), 33% diffuse large B-cell lymphomas, 25% follicular B-cell lymphomas and few splenic marginal zone and small B-cell lymphomas. Deleting one copy of the 99-bp proviral enhancer sequence still allowed induction of multiple B-cell tumor types, although PCPs dominated (77%). Additional mutation of binding sites for the glucocorticoid receptor, Ets, Runx, or basic helix-loop-helix transcription factors in the proviral U3 region, however, shifted disease induction to almost exclusively PCPs, but had no major influence on tumor latency periods. Southern analysis of immunoglobulin rearrangements and ecotropic provirus integration patterns showed that many of the tumors/cell proliferations induced by each virus were polyclonal. Our results indicate that enhancer mutations weaken the ability of Akv to induce mature B-cell lymphomas prior to the plasma cell stage, whereas development of plasma cell proliferations is less dependent of viral enhancer strength.

Characterization of interactions between transcription factors and a regulatory region spanning nt -320 to -281 of the HIV-1 LTR in T-lymphoid and non-T-lymphoid cells

HIV-1 gene expression is regulated by the interplay of transcription factors with multiple binding motifs present within the U3, R and U5 regions of the long terminal repeat (LTR). Here we report novel DNA binding complexes (termed 9a, 9b and 9c) between nuclear proteins from T-lymphoid and non-T-lymphoid cells and a region of the U3 LTR between nucleotides (nts) -320 to -281 in the HIV strain HXB2. Complex 9b bound a motif predicted to bind E-box or c-Myb proteins and a partially overlapping dyad symmetrical motif, and included basic helix-loop-helix proteins (E12, E47 or ITF-1) but surprisingly not c-Myb. Complex 9c, which bound to a pair of GATA sites, included GATA-3 and GATA-4 in Jurkat and MT-2 cells, respectively. We also demonstrate that the c-Myb/E-box and GATA sites form a bipartite motif required for the formation of complex 9a. Transient transfection experiments with T cells revealed that in the context of a minichromosome assembled full-length LTR, mutation of region -320 to -281 increased basal and PMA-stimulated LTR activity. These findings suggest that this region is an important component of the HIV-1 LTR required for response to different cellular transcription factors.

In vivo analysis of retroviral enhancer mutations in hematopoietic cells: SP1/EGR1 and ETS/GATA motifs contribute to long terminal repeat specificity

The objective of this work was to identify, in the context of chromosomally integrated DNA, the contribution of defined transcription factor binding motifs to the function of a complex retrovirus enhancer in hematopoietic cells in vivo. Repopulating murine hematopoietic cells were transduced with equal gene dosages of replication-incompetent retrovirus vectors encoding enhanced green fluorescent protein. Enhancer sequences were derived from mouse spleen focus-forming virus. Destruction of GC-rich sites representing overlapping targets for SP1 or EGR1 uniformly attenuated gene expression (approximately 25 to 70% of wild-type levels) in all hematopoietic lineages, as shown by multicolor flow cytometry of peripheral blood and bone marrow cells at various time points posttransplantation. In contrast, a point mutation within a dual ETS/GATA motif that abolished transactivation by ETS factors but not by GATA-1 slightly increased activity in erythroid cells and significantly attenuated enhancer function in T lymphocytes. This study shows that controlled gene transfer in transplantable hematopoietic cells allows a functional analysis of distinct cis elements within a complex retrovirus enhancer, as required for the characterization and engineering of various cellular and viral regulatory sequences in basic research and gene therapy.

Type B leukemogenic virus has a T-cell-specific enhancer that binds AML-1

Type B leukemogenic virus (TBLV) induces rapidly appearing T-cell tumors in mice. TBLV is highly related to mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) except that TBLV long terminal repeats (LTRs) have a deletion of negative regulatory elements and a triplication of sequences flanking the deletion. To determine if the LTR triplication represents a viral enhancer element, we inserted the triplication upstream and downstream in either orientation relative to the thymidine kinase promoter linked to the luciferase gene. These experiments showed that upregulation of reporter gene activity by the TBLV triplication was relatively orientation independent, consistent with the activity of eukaryotic enhancer elements. TBLV enhancer activity was observed in T-cell lines but not in fibroblasts, B cells, or mammary cells, suggesting that enhancer function is cell type dependent. To analyze the transcription factor binding sites that are important for TBLV enhancer function, we prepared substitution mutations in a reconstituted C3H MMTV LTR that recapitulates the deletion observed in the TBLV LTR. Transient transfections showed that a single mutation (556M) decreased TBLV enhancer activity at least 20-fold in two different T-cell lines. This mutation greatly diminished AML-1 (recently renamed RUNX1) binding in gel shift assays with a mutant oligonucleotide, whereas AML-1 binding to a wild-type TBLV oligomer was specific, as judged by competition and supershift experiments. The 556 mutation also reduced TBLV enhancer binding of two other protein complexes, called NF-A and NF-B, that did not appear to be related to c-Myb or Ets. AML-1 overexpression in a mammary cell line enhanced expression from the TBLV LTR approximately 30-fold. These data suggest that binding of AML-1 to the TBLV enhancer, likely in combination with other factors, is necessary for optimal enhancer function.

Nuclear factors that bind to the U3 region of two murine myeloid leukemia-inducing retroviruses, Cas-Br-E and Graffi

Cas-Br-E and Graffi are two myeloid leukemia-inducing murine viruses. Cas-Br-E induces, in NIH-Swiss mice, mostly non-T, non-B leukemia composed of very immature cells with no specific characteristics (Bergeron et al. (1993). Leukemia 7, 954-962). The Graffi murine leukemia virus causes exclusively myeloid leukemia, but the tumor cells are clearly of granulocytic nature (Ru et al. (1993). J. Virol. 67, 4722). We were interested to understand the role of the long terminal repeat (LTR) U3 region in the myeloid specificity of these two retroviruses. We used DNase I footprinting and gel mobility shift assays to identify a number of protein binding sites within Cas-Br-E and Graffi U3 regions. The pattern of protected regions is highly similar for the two viruses. Some factors identified in other murine leukemia viruses, like the core binding factor, also bind to Cas-Br-E and Graffi LTR; however, other binding sites seem specific for these two viruses. Only one difference between them was noted, at the 5' end of the U3 region. Transcriptional activity of both LTRs was also analyzed in various cell lines and compared with other murine leukemia viruses. The results show a slight myeloid specificity for the two LTRs, and indicate that the Graffi enhancer is quite strong in a broad range of cell types.

Members of the GATA family of transcription factors bind to the U3 region of Cas-Br-E and graffi retroviruses and transactivate their expression

Cas-Br-E and Graffi are two murine viruses that induce myeloid leukemia in mice: while Cas-Br-E induces mostly non-T, non-B leukemia composed of very immature cells, Graffi causes exclusively a granulocytic leukemia (E. Rassart, J. Houde, C. Denicourt, M. Ru, C. Barat, E. Edouard, L. Poliquin, and D. Bergeron, Curr. Top. Microbiol. Immunol. 211:201-210, 1995). In an attempt to understand the basis of the myeloid specificity of these two retroviruses, we used DNase I footprinting analysis and gel mobility shift assays to identify a number of protein binding sites within the Cas-Br-E and Graffi U3 regions. Two protected regions include potential GATA binding sites. Methylation interference analysis with different hematopoietic nuclear extracts showed the importance of the G residues in these GATA sites, and supershift assays clearly identified the binding factors as GATA-1, GATA-2, and GATA-3. Transient assays with long terminal repeat (LTR)-chloramphenicol acetyltransferase constructs showed that these three GATA family members are indeed able to transactivate Cas-Br-E and Graffi LTRs. Thus, the availability and relative abundance of the various members of the GATA family of transcription factors in a given cell type could influence the transcriptional tissue specificity of murine leukemia viruses and hence their disease specificity.

CBF, Myb, and Ets binding sites are important for activity of the core I element of the murine retrovirus SL3-3 in T lymphocytes

Transcriptional enhancers within the long terminal repeats of murine leukemia viruses are major determinants of the pathogenic properties of these viruses. Mutations were introduced into the adjacent binding sites for three transcription factors within the enhancer of the T-cell-lymphomagenic virus SL3-3. The sites that were tested were, in 5'-to-3' order, a binding site for core binding factor (CBF) called core II, a binding site for c-Myb, a site that binds members of the Ets family of factors, and a second CBF binding site called core I. Mutation of each site individually reduced transcriptional activity in T lymphocytes. However, mutation of the Myb and core I binding sites had larger effects than mutation of the Ets or core II site. The relative effects on transcription in T cells paralleled the effects of the same mutations on viral lymphomagenicity, consistent with the idea that the role of these sequences in viral lymphomagenicity is indeed to regulate transcription in T cells. Mutations were also introduced simultaneously into multiple sites in the SL3-3 enhancer. The inhibitory effects of these mutations indicated that the transcription factor in T cells that recognizes the core I element of SL3-3, presumably CBF, needed to synergize with one or more factors bound at the upstream sites to function. This was tested further by generating a multimer construct that contained five tandem core I elements linked to a basal long terminal repeat promoter. This construct was inactive in T cells. However, transcriptional activity was detected with a multimer construct in which the transcription factor binding sites upstream of the core were also present. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that CBF requires heterologous transcription factors bound at nearby sites to function in T cells.

The potent enhancer activity of the polycythemic strain of spleen focus-forming virus in hematopoietic cells is governed by a binding site for Sp1 in the upstream control region and by a unique enhancer core motif, creating an exclusive target for PEBP/CBF

The polycythemic strain of the spleen focus-forming virus (SFFVp) contains the most potent murine retroviral enhancer configuration known so far for gene expression in myeloerythroid hematopoietic cells. In the present study, we mapped two crucial elements responsible for the high activity of the SFFVp enhancer to an altered upstream control region (UCR) containing a GC-rich motif (5'-GGGCGGG-3') and to a unique enhancer core (5'-TGCGGTC-3'). Acquisition of these motifs accounts for half of the activity of the complete retroviral enhancer in hematopoietic cells, irrespective of the developmental stage or lineage. Furthermore, the UCR motif contains the major determinant for the enhancer activity of SFFVp in embryonic stem (ES) cells. Using electrophoretic mobility shift assays, we show that the UCR of SFFVp, but not of Friend murine leukemia virus, is targeted by the ubiquitous transcriptional activator, Sp1. The core motif of SFFVp creates a specific and high-affinity target for polyomavirus enhancer binding protein/core binding factor (PEBP/CBF) and excludes access of CAAT/enhancer binding protein. Cotransfection experiments with ES cells imply that PEBP/CBF cooperates with the neighboring element, LVb (the only conserved Ets consensus in the SFFVp enhancer), and that the Sp1 motif in the UCR stimulates transactivation through the Ets-PEBP interaction. Putative secondary structures of the retroviral enhancers are proposed based on these data.

Importance of a c-Myb binding site for lymphomagenesis by the retrovirus SL3-3

All murine leukemia viruses (MuLVs) and related type C retroviruses contain a highly conserved binding site for the Ets family of transcription factors within the enhancer sequences in the viral long terminal repeats (LTRs). The T-cell lymphomagenic MuLV SL3-3 (SL3-3) also contains a c-Myb binding site adjacent to the Ets site. The presence of this Myb site distinguishes SL3 from most other MuLVs. We tested the importance of these two sites for the lymphomagenicity of SL3-3. Mutation of the Ets site had little effect on viral pathogenicity, as it only slightly extended the latency period to disease onset. In contrast, mutation of the Myb site strongly inhibited pathogenicity, as only a minority of the inoculated mice developed tumors in the two mouse strains that were tested. All tumors that were induced by either mutant appeared to be lymphomas, and no evidence for reversion of either mutation was detected. The effects of the Ets and Myb site mutations on transcriptional activity of the SL3 LTR were tested by inserting the viral enhancer sequences into a plasmid containing the promoter region of the c-myc gene linked to a reporter gene. Mutation the Myb site almost eliminated enhancer activity in T lymphocytes, while mutation of the Ets site had smaller effects. Thus, the effects of the enhancer mutations on transcriptional activity in T cells paralleled their effects on viral lymphomagenicity. The absence of the c-Myb site in the LTR enhancer of the weakly lymphomagenic MuLV, Akv, likely contributes to the low pathogenicity of this virus relative to SL3-3. However, Moloney MuLV also lacks the Myb site in its LTR, although it induces T-cell lymphomas with a potency similar to that of SL3-3. Thus, it appears that SL3-3 and Moloney MuLV evolved genetic determinants of T-cell lymphomagenicity that are, at least in part, distinct.

Second-site proviral enhancer alterations in lymphomas induced by enhancer mutants of SL3-3 murine leukemia virus: negative effect of nuclear factor 1 binding site

SL3-3 is a highly T-lymphomagenic murine retrovirus. Previously, mutation of binding sites in the U3 repeat region for the AML1 transcription factor family (also known as core binding factor [CBF], polyomavirus enhancer binding protein 2 [PEBP2], and SL3-3 enhancer factor 1 [SEF1]) were found to strongly reduce the pathogenicity of SL3-3 (B. Hallberg, J. Schmidt, A. Luz, F. S. Pedersen, and T. Grundström, J. Virol. 65:4177-4181, 1991). We have now examined the few cases in which tumors developed harboring proviruses that besides the AML1 (core) site mutations carried second-site alterations in their U3 repeat structures. In three distinct cases we observed the same type of alteration which involved deletions of regions known to contain binding sites for nuclear factor 1 (NF1) and the addition of extra enhancer repeat elements. In transient-expression experiments in T-lymphoid cells, these new U3 regions acted as stronger enhancers than the U3 regions of the original viruses. This suggests that the altered proviruses represent more-pathogenic variants selected for in the process of tumor formation. To analyze the proviral alterations, we generated a series of different enhancer-promoter reporter constructs. These constructs showed that the additional repeat elements are not critical for enhancer strength, whereas the NF1 sites down-regulate the level of transcription in T-lymphoid cells whether or not the AML1 (core) sites are functional. We therefore also tested SL3-3 viruses with mutated NF1 sites. These viruses have unimpaired pathogenic properties and thereby distinguish SL3-3 from Moloney murine leukemia virus.

E-box sequence and context-dependent TAL1/SCL modulation of basic helix-loop-helix protein-mediated transcriptional activation

TAL1/SCL is a basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) oncoprotein that is expressed in several cell lines including many hematolymphoid cells, but not in T- and B-lineage cells. The TAL1 gene was originally discovered as being transcriptionally activated by chromosomal rearrangements in T-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (T-ALL). Here we have shown that TAL1 and the ubiquitously expressed murine bHLH transcription factor ALF1 formed heterodimers that, compared with ALF1 homodimers, had a more restricted E-box specificity and bound preferentially to the glucocorticoid-responsive E-box (Egre) motif (AACAGATGGT). Overexpression of the dominant inhibitory HLH protein Id1 in NIH3T3 cells reduced the transcriptional activity mediated by ALF1 homodimers, whereas the transcriptional activity mediated by TAL1/ALF1 heterodimers was resistant to Id overexpression. Our results show that ALF1 may serve as a dimerization partner for the bHLH oncoprotein TAL1 and form a complex with a distinctive DNA binding property. These findings support the hypothesis that the leukemic characteristics of the TAL1 oncoprotein could be mediated by activation of a set of target genes as heterodimeric complexes with ubiquitously expressed bHLH transcription factors such as ALF1 and that a principal role of TAL1 might be to neutralize an Id-mediated inactivation.

Various modes of basic helix-loop-helix protein-mediated regulation of murine leukemia virus transcription in lymphoid cell lines

The transcriptionally regulatory regions of the lymphomagenic Akv and SL3-3 murine leukemia retroviruses (MLVs) contain two types of E-box consensus motifs, CAGATG. One type, EA/S, is located in the upstream promoter region, and the other, E(gre), is located in a tandem repeat with enhancer properties. We have examined the requirements of the individual E-boxes in MLV transcriptional regulation. In lymphoid cell lines only, the E(gre)-binding protein complexes included ALF1 or HEB and E2A basic helix-loop-helix proteins. Ectopic ALF1 and E2A proteins required intact E(gre) motifs for mediating transcriptional activation. ALF1 transactivated transcription of Akv MLV through the two E(gre) motifs equally, whereas E2A protein required the promoter-proximal E(gre) motif. In T- and B-cell lines, the E(gre) motifs were of major importance for Akv MLV transcriptional activity, while the EA/S motif had some effect. In contrast, neither E(gre) nor EA/S motifs contributed pronouncedly to Akv MLV transcription in NIH 3T3 cells lacking DNA-binding ALF1 or HEB and E2A proteins. The Id1 protein was found to repress ALF1 activity in vitro and in vivo. Moreover, ectopic Id1 repressed E(gre)-directed but not EA/S-directed MLV transcription in lymphoid cell lines. In conclusion, E(gre) motifs and interacting basic helix-loop-helix proteins are important determinants for MLV transcriptional activity in lymphocytic cell lines.