RNF43 mutation is associated with aggressive tumor biology along with BRAF V600E mutation in right-sided colorectal cancer

Novel insights into tumorigenesis revealed by molecular analysis of Lynch syndrome cases with multiple colorectal tumors

Background

Lynch syndrome (LS) is an autosomal dominant multi-organ cancer syndrome with a high lifetime risk of cancer. The number of cumulative colorectal adenomas in LS does not generally exceed ten, and removal of adenomas via routine screening minimizes the cancer burden. However, abnormal phenotypes may mislead initial diagnosis and subsequently cause suboptimal treatment.

Aim

Currently, there is no standard guide for the care of multiple colorectal adenomas in LS individuals. We aimed to shed insight into the molecular features and reasons for multiplicity of adenomas in LS patients.

Methods

We applied whole exome sequencing on nine adenomas (ten samples) and three assumed primary carcinomas (five samples) of an LS patient developing the tumors during a 21-year follow-up period. We compared the findings to the tumor profiles of two additional LS cases ascertained through colorectal tumor multiplicity, as well as to ten adenomas and 15 carcinomas from 23 unrelated LS patients with no elevated adenoma burden from the same population. As LS associated cancers can arise via several molecular pathways, we also profiled the tumors for CpG Island Methylator Phenotype (CIMP), and LINE-1 methylation.

Results

All tumors were microsatellite unstable (MSI), and MSI was present in several samples derived from normal mucosa as well. Interestingly, frequent frameshift variants in RNF43 were shared among substantial number of the tumors of our primary case and the tumors of LS cases with multiple tumors but almost absent in our control LS cases. The RNF43 variants were completely absent in the normal tissue, indicating tumor-associated mutational hotspots. The RNF43 status correlated with the mutational signature SBS96. Contrary to LS tumors from the reference set with no elevated colorectal tumor burden, the somatic variants occurred significantly more frequently at C>T in the CpG context, irrespective of CIMP or LINE-1 status, potentially indicating other, yet unknown methylation-related mechanisms. There were no signs of somatic mosaicism affecting the MMR genes. Somatic variants in APC and CTNNB1 were unique to each tumor.

Conclusion

Frequent somatic RNF43 hot spot variants combined with SBS96 signature and increased tendency to DNA methylation may contribute to tumor multiplicity in LS.

Ring Finger 43 Hot-spot Frameshift Mutation G659V in Colorectal Cancer Patients: Report from a Tertiary Cancer Care Hospital in North India

Background

The Ring Finger 43 (RNF43) is a tumor suppressor gene that negatively regulates the Wnt/β-catenin signaling. The p.G659fs is a recurrent RNF43 C-terminal truncating variant frequent in colorectal cancer (CRC) patients. We aimed to identify this hotspot variant in CRC patients and assessed the relationship between the mutation, clinical characteristics, and tumor β-catenin localization.

Materials and Methods

Formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue samples of upfront, surgically resected, sporadic colorectal adenocarcinoma cases were selected. The p.G659fs mutation was determined by capillary sequencing with sequence-specific primers. Tissue microarray and immunohistochemistry were employed to analyze nuclear β-catenin expression and the expression of mismatch repair (MMR) proteins, respectively. In addition, clinical details were retrieved from the hospital medical records and data were analyzed.

Results

The RNF43 p.G659fs mutation was observed in 8% of CRC patients. In total, 25% of tumors showed a loss of immunostaining for one or more MMR proteins and 14.6% of tumors showed positive nuclear β-catenin staining. The p.G659fs variant was significantly enriched in MMR-deficient tumors (P = 0.04). Importantly, no correlation was observed between the variant and nuclear β-catenin localization (P = 0.48), indicating a Wnt-independent role of this variant in CRC tumors.

Conclusions

To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study from North India to show the involvement of RNF43 p.G659fs variant in CRC patients. The mutation correlated with MMR protein deficiency and seems to be conferring tumorigenicity independent of the Wnt pathway.

Subclonal accumulation of immune escape mechanisms in microsatellite instability-high colorectal cancers

BACKGROUND

Intratumor heterogeneity (ITH) in microsatellite instability-high (MSI-H) colorectal cancer (CRC) has been poorly studied. We aimed to clarify how the ITH of MSI-H CRCs is generated in cancer evolution and how immune selective pressure affects ITH.

METHODS

We reanalyzed public whole-exome sequencing data on 246 MSI-H CRCs. In addition, we performed a multi-region analysis from 6 MSI-H CRCs. To verify the process of subclonal immune escape accumulation, a novel computational model of cancer evolution under immune pressure was developed.

RESULTS

Our analysis presented the enrichment of functional genomic alterations in antigen-presentation machinery (APM). Associative analysis of neoantigens indicated the generation of immune escape mechanisms via HLA alterations. Multiregion analysis revealed the clonal acquisition of driver mutations and subclonal accumulation of APM defects in MSI-H CRCs. Examination of variant allele frequencies demonstrated that subclonal mutations tend to be subjected to selective sweep. Computational simulations of tumour progression with the interaction of immune cells successfully verified the subclonal accumulation of immune escape mutations and suggested the efficacy of early initiation of an immune checkpoint inhibitor (ICI) -based treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results demonstrate the heterogeneous acquisition of immune escape mechanisms in MSI-H CRCs by Darwinian selection, providing novel insights into ICI-based treatment strategies.

RNF43 is associated with genomic features and clinical outcome in BRAF mutant colorectal cancer

Background

Colorectal cancer (CRC) patients with BRAF mutation have very poor prognosis. It is urgent to search for prognostic factors of BRAF mutant CRC. RNF43 is a ENF ubiquitin ligase of Wnt signaling. Mutation of RNF43 has been observed frequently in various types of human cancers. However, few studies have evaluated the role of RNF43 in CRC. The present study aimed to explore the impact of RNF43 mutations on molecular characteristics and prognosis in BRAF mutant CRC.

Methods

Samples of 261 CRC patients with BRAF mutation were retrospectively analyzed. Tumor tissue and matched peripheral blood samples were collected and subjected to targeted sequencing with a panel of 1021 cancer-related genes. The association of molecular characteristics and survival in patients were then analyzed. 358 CRC patients with BRAF mutation from the cBioPortal dataset were used for further confirmation.

Results

This study was inspired by a CRC patient with BRAF V600E and RNF43 co-mutation, who achieved a best remission of 70% and a progression free survival (PFS) of 13 months. Genomic analysis indicated that RNF43 mutation affected the genomic characteristics of patients with BRAF mutation, including microsatellite instability (MSI), tumor mutation burden (TMB) and the proportion of common gene mutations. Survival analysis showed that RNF43 mutation was a predictive biomarker for better PFS and OS in BRAF mutant CRC.

Conclusion

Collectively, we identified that RNF43 mutations were correlated with favorable genomic features, resulting in a better clinical outcome for BRAF mutant CRC patients.

Receptor Elimination by E3 Ubiquitin Ligase Recruitment (REULR): A Targeted Protein Degradation Toolbox

In recent years, targeted protein degradation (TPD) of plasma membrane proteins by hijacking the ubiquitin proteasome system (UPS) or the lysosomal pathway has emerged as a novel therapeutic avenue in drug development to address and inhibit canonically difficult targets. While TPD strategies have been successful in targeting cell surface receptors, these approaches are limited by the availability of suitable binders to generate heterobifunctional molecules. Here, we present the development of a nanobody (VHH)-based degradation toolbox termed REULR (Receptor Elimination by E3 Ubiquitin Ligase Recruitment). We generated human and mouse cross-reactive nanobodies against five transmembrane PA-TM-RING-type E3 ubiquitin ligases (RNF128, RNF130, RNF167, RNF43, and ZNRF3), covering a broad range and selectivity of tissue expression, with which we characterized the expression in human and mouse cell lines and immune cells (PBMCs). We demonstrate that heterobifunctional REULR molecules can enforce transmembrane E3 ligase interactions with a variety of disease-relevant target receptors (EGFR, EPOR, and PD-1) by induced proximity, resulting in effective membrane clearance of the target receptor at varying levels. In addition, we designed E3 ligase self-degrading molecules, "fratricide" REULRs (RNF128, RNF130, RENF167, RNF43, and ZNRF3), that allow downregulation of one or several E3 ligases from the cell surface and consequently modulate receptor signaling strength. REULR molecules represent a VHH-based modular and versatile "mix and match" targeting strategy for the facile modulation of cell surface proteins by induced proximity to transmembrane PA-TM-RING E3 ligases.

Clinical associations and genetic interactions of oncogenic BRAF alleles

BRAF is a serine/threonine-specific protein kinase that regulates the MAPK/ERK signaling pathway, and mutations in the BRAF gene are considered oncogenic drivers in diverse types of cancer. Based on the signaling mechanism, oncogenic BRAF mutations can be assigned to three different classes: class 1 mutations constitutively activate the kinase domain and lead to RAS-independent signaling, class 2 mutations induce artificial dimerization of BRAF and RAS-independent signaling and class 3 mutations display reduced or abolished kinase function and require upstream signals. Despite the importance of BRAF mutations in cancer, the clinical associations, genetic interactions and therapeutic implications of non-V600 BRAF mutations have not been explored comprehensively yet. In this study, the author analyzed publically available data from the AACR Project GENIE to further understand clinical associations and genetic interactions of oncogenic BRAF mutations. The analyses identified 93 recurrent BRAF mutations, out of which 50 could be assigned to a functional class based on literature review. The author could show that the frequency of BRAF mutations varies across cancer types and subtypes, and that the BRAF mutation classes are unequally distributed across cancer types and subtypes. Using permutation testing-based co-occurrence analyses, the author defined the genetic interactions of BRAF mutations in multiple cancer types and revealed unexplored genetic interactions that might define clinically relevant subgroups. With non-small cell lung cancer as example, the author further showed that the genetic interactions are BRAF mutation class-specific. The presented analyses explore the properties of oncogenic BRAF mutations and will help to further delineate the complex role of BRAF in cancer.

Exome sequencing revealed comparable frequencies of RNF43 and BRAF mutations in Middle Eastern colorectal cancer

Mutation-induced activation of Wnt-β Catenin signaling pathway is frequent in CRC. The E3 ubiquitin ligase, RNF43, has been reported to negatively regulate the Wnt signaling pathway and RNF43 mutations are frequently seen in CRC. However, its role in Middle Eastern CRC remains unclear. Therefore, we employed Exome and Sanger sequencing technology to assess the frequency of RNF43 mutations and its association with other clinico-pathological features in Middle Eastern CRC. RNF43 mutations were found in 5.9% (13/220) of CRC cases and was inversely correlated to APC and TP53 mutations. A strong association of RNF43 mutations with right sided and sporadic microsatellite instable (MSI) CRC was observed. No association was identified between RNF43 mutation and other clinico-pathological features including BRAF mutation, age, tumor histological subtype, tumor grade or patients’ prognosis. Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that MSI status and wild type APC were independent predictor of RNF43 mutation. We conclude that RNF43 mutations occur in Middle Eastern CRC at comparable frequencies with BRAF mutations and represent a distinct molecular subtype which further enhances our understanding of how different mutational subsets of Wnt tumor suppressor genes link to distinct tumor characteristics, which might be considered for treatment strategies for CRC patients.

Gene Mutational Clusters in the Tumors of Colorectal Cancer Patients With a Family History of Cancer

Introduction

Family history is a high-risk factor for colorectal cancer (CRC). The risk comes not only from known germline mutations but also from the other family-related mechanisms. Uncovering them would be an important step to improve the diagnosis and treatment of these patients.

Method

Samples from 168 patients with advanced CRC were collected and applied to next-generation sequencing of 624 pan-cancer genes. Genomic mutations and significantly mutated genes were identified. Significantly mutated genes and co-mutated genes were used to cluster patients. For each cluster of patients, mutational signatures were extracted. The identified mutational signatures were further validated in the other independent cohort.

Result

Significantly mutated genes including TP53, APC, KRAS, and SMAD4 were found associated with tumor mutational burden and microsatellite instability. LRP1, ACVR2A, and SETBP1 were found co-mutated. Patients with mutations in LRP1, ACVR2A, and SETBP1 tend to have a family history of cancer. Those patients tended to have right-sided tumors with high tumor mutational burden and microsatellite instability. Among them, signature analysis identified two possible etiologies, SBS10a (defective polymerase epsilon exonuclease domain) and SBS6 (defective DNA mismatch repair and microsatellite unstable tumors). These signatures were also found in another independent cohort.

Conclusion

The gene cluster (LRP1, ACVR2A, and SETBP1) could be a good biomarker of these patients with a family risk, which was characterized by right-sidedness, high tumor mutational burden, and high microsatellite instability.

RNF43 inhibits WNT5A-driven signaling and suppresses melanoma invasion and resistance to the targeted therapy

RNF43 is an E3 ubiquitin ligase and known negative regulator of WNT/β-catenin signaling. We demonstrate that RNF43 is also a regulator of noncanonical WNT5A-induced signaling in human cells. Analysis of the RNF43 interactome using BioID and immunoprecipitation showed that RNF43 can interact with the core receptor complex components dedicated to the noncanonical Wnt pathway such as ROR1, ROR2, VANGL1, and VANGL2. RNF43 triggers VANGL2 ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation and clathrin-dependent internalization of ROR1 receptor and inhibits ROR2 activation. These activities of RNF43 are physiologically relevant and block pro-metastatic WNT5A signaling in melanoma. RNF43 inhibits responses to WNT5A, which results in the suppression of invasive properties of melanoma cells. Furthermore, RNF43 prevented WNT5A-assisted development of resistance to BRAF V600E and MEK inhibitors. Next, RNF43 acted as melanoma suppressor and improved response to targeted therapies in vivo. In line with these findings, RNF43 expression decreases during melanoma progression and RNF43-low patients have a worse prognosis. We conclude that RNF43 is a newly discovered negative regulator of WNT5A-mediated biological responses that desensitizes cells to WNT5A.

eVIP2: Expression-based variant impact phenotyping to predict the function of gene variants

While advancements in genome sequencing have identified millions of somatic mutations in cancer, their functional impact is poorly understood. We previously developed the expression-based variant impact phenotyping (eVIP) method to use gene expression data to characterize the function of gene variants. The eVIP method uses a decision tree-based algorithm to predict the functional impact of somatic variants by comparing gene expression signatures induced by introduction of wild-type (WT) versus mutant cDNAs in cell lines. The method distinguishes between variants that are gain-of-function, loss-of-function, change-of-function, or neutral. We present eVIP2, software that allows for pathway analysis (eVIP Pathways) and usage with RNA-seq data. To demonstrate the eVIP2 software and approach, we characterized two recurrent frameshift variants in RNF43, a negative regulator of Wnt signaling, frequently mutated in colorectal, gastric, and endometrial cancer. RNF43 WT, RNF43 R117fs, RNF43 G659fs, or GFP control cDNA were overexpressed in HEK293T cells. Analysis with eVIP2 predicted that the frameshift at position 117 was a loss-of-function mutation, as expected. The second frameshift at position 659 has been previously described as a passenger mutation that maintains the RNF43 WT function as a negative regulator of Wnt. Surprisingly, eVIP2 predicted G659fs to be a change-of-function mutation. Additional eVIP Pathways analysis of RNF43 G659fs predicted 10 pathways to be significantly altered, including TNF-α via NFκB signaling, KRAS signaling, and hypoxia, highlighting the benefit of a more comprehensive approach when determining the impact of gene variant function. To validate these predictions, we performed reporter assays and found that each pathway activated by expression of RNF43 G659fs, but not expression of RNF43 WT, was identified as impacted by eVIP2, supporting that RNF43 G659fs is a change-of-function mutation and its effect on the identified pathways. Pathway activation was further validated by Western blot analysis. Lastly, we show primary colon adenocarcinoma patient samples with R117fs and G659fs variants have transcriptional profiles similar to BRAF missense mutations with activated RAS/MAPK signaling, consistent with KRAS signaling pathways being GOF in both variants. The eVIP2 method is an important step towards overcoming the current challenge of variant interpretation in the implementation of precision medicine. eVIP2 is available at https://github.com/BrooksLabUCSC/eVIP2.

RNF43 mutation analysis in serrated polyposis, sporadic serrated polyps and Lynch syndrome polyps

Aims

RNF43 is suggested to be involved in the serrated pathway towards colorectal cancer and encodes a transmembrane Ring‐type E3 ubiquitin ligase that negatively regulates the Wnt pathway. This study aimed to elucidate the role of RNF43 gene variants in serrated polyposis syndrome (SPS) and serrated polyps.

Methods and results

Three cohorts were tested. The first cohort included germline DNA of 26 SPS patients tested for pathogenic variants in RNF43 by Sanger sequencing all exons. In the second cohort we tested somatic DNA for RNF43 mutations from sporadic serrated lesions: 25 hyperplastic polyps, 35 sessile serrated lesions and 38 traditional serrated adenomas (TSA). In the third cohort we investigated RNF43 mutations in 49 serrated polyps and 60 conventional adenomas from 40 patients with Lynch syndrome. No germline RNF43 pathogenic variants were detected in our SPS cohort. In sporadic colorectal lesions we detected RNF43 deleterious frameshift mutations in three TSA and one SSL. The RNF43 mutations in previously described homopolymeric hot‐spots were detected in microsatellite‐instable (MSI) polyps and the other RNF43 mutations in microsatellite‐stable (MSS) serrated polyps. RNF43 hot‐spot mutations were discovered in seven serrated polyps and 12 conventional adenomas from Lynch patients.

Conclusion

Truncating germline RNF43 mutations are uncommon in SPS patients. Somatic mutations in RNF43 were found in sporadic TSA and SSL and both serrated polyps and adenomas from Lynch syndrome patients, suggesting that they do not develop early in the pathway to CRC and are not specific for serrated polyp subtypes.