Functional genomic screening to enhance oncolytic virotherapy

Functional genomic screening has emerged as a powerful approach for understanding complex biological phenomena. Of the available tools, genome-wide RNA interference (RNAi) technology is unquestionably the most incisive, as it directly probes gene function. Recent applications of RNAi screening have been impressive. Notable amongst these are its use in elucidated mechanism(s) for signal transduction, various aspects of cell biology, tumourigenesis and metastasis, resistance to cancer therapeutics, and the host's response to a pathogen. Herein we discuss how recent RNAi screening efforts have helped turn our attention to the targetability of non-oncogene support pathways for cancer treatment, with a particular focus on a recent study that identified a non-oncogene addiction to the ER stress response as a synergist target for oncolytic virus therapy (OVT). Moreover, we give our thoughts on the future of RNAi screening as a tool to enhance OVT and describe recent technical improvements that are poised to make genome-scale RNAi experiments more sensitive, less noisy, more applicable in vivo, and more easily validated in clinically relevant animal models.

SMG1 and NIK regulate apoptosis induced by Smac mimetic compounds

Smac mimetic compounds (SMCs) are experimental small molecules that induce tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNFα)-dependent cancer cell death by targeting the inhibitor of apoptosis proteins. However, many cancer cell lines are resistant to SMC-mediated apoptosis despite the presence of TNFα. To add insight into the mechanism of SMC-resistance, we used functional siRNA-based kinomic and focused chemical screens and identified suppressor of morphogenesis in genitalia-1 (SMG1) and NF-κB-inducing kinase (NIK) as novel protective factors. Both SMG1 and NIK prevent SMC-mediated apoptosis likely by maintaining FLICE inhibitory protein (c-FLIP) levels to suppress caspase-8 activation. In SMC-resistant cells, the accumulation of NIK upon SMC treatment enhanced the activity of both the classical and alternative nuclear factor-κB pathways, and increased c-FLIP mRNA levels. In parallel, persistent SMG1 expression in SMC-resistant cells repressed SMC-mediated TNFα-induced JNK activation and c-FLIP levels were sustained. Importantly, SMC-resistance is overcome by depleting NIK and SMG1, which appear to facilitate the downregulation of c-FLIP in response to SMC and TNFα treatment, leading to caspase-8-dependent apoptosis. Collectively, these data show that SMG1 and NIK function as critical repressors of SMC-mediated apoptosis by potentially converging on the regulation of c-FLIP metabolism.

A call to arms: using RNAi screening to improve oncolytic viral therapy

Replicating virus-based therapeutics for cancer, or oncolytic virus therapy (OVT), is rapidly emerging as a promising treatment modality for a wide range of cancers. In pre-clinical studies, oncolytic viruses have produced remarkable results in a variety of experimental animal models, and several viruses have entered phase I/II clinical trials. However, OVT is not effective against all tumours, with major treatment bottlenecks being the inability to infect, replicate within, or kill certain cancer cells. Unfortunately, the underlying molecular mechanisms governing these limitations are largely unknown. Recently, RNAi technology has been adapted for systematic interrogation of entire eukaryotic genomes. Since then, several groups have conducted genome-wide RNAi screens to study host/virus interactions. Herein we briefly summarize RNAi screening and its recent application to virology, and propose its use in overcoming key barriers to successful OVT.

Oncolytic viruses: programmable tumour hunters

Despite significant improvements in early detection and refinements of therapeutic protocols over the last several decades, cancer remains one of the leading causes of death in North America. In particular, treatment of metastatic cancers is a highly desirable and yet still elusive goal of the oncologist. One strategy which holds promise is the use of self replicating viral strains with the ability to specifically kill tumour but not normal cells. These so-called "oncolytic viruses" are in general, attenuated for growth in normal cells but are able to exploit tumour specific, genetic defects to gain a growth advantage. In this review, we will discuss the virus:host cell interactions which help form the niche occupied by oncolytic viruses. The current and potential clinical applications/limitations will be discussed for oncolytic viruses from the herpesvirus, adenoviruses, picornavirus, rhabdovirus, and paramyxovirus families.

Different host-cell shutoff strategies related to the matrix protein lead to persistence of vesicular stomatitis virus mutants on fibroblast cells

Acute infection of fibroblastic cell lines by the Indiana strain of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) usually induces dramatic cytopathic effects and shutoff of cellular gene expression. We have compared a series of independent mutants with differences in shutoff induction and found that M was mutated either in the N-terminus (M(51)R) or C-terminus (V(221)F and S(226)R). Furthermore, only double mutants (M mutation and a ts mutation related or not to M) were able to persist on fibroblast cell lines at 39 degrees C. A more detailed investigation of the infection was performed for the mutants T1026, TP3 and G31, differing in their host shutoff effects related to M protein. Viral activity in persistently infected mouse L-929 and monkey Vero cell lines was followed by viral proteins detection, RNA synthesis throughout infection and finally detection of infectious particles. All three mutants cause extensive CPE followed by emergence of persistently infected cells on Vero cells. The same thing is seen on L-929 cells except for T1026 which causes little CPE. Taken together, the results form a basis of further studies to clarify how various viral and cellular factors interact in the establishment of a persistent infection by VSV mutants.

The murine double-stranded RNA-dependent protein kinase PKR is required for resistance to vesicular stomatitis virus

Interferon (IFN)-induced antiviral responses are mediated through a variety of proteins, including the double-stranded RNA-dependent protein kinase PKR. Here we show that fibroblasts derived from PKR(-/-) mice are more permissive for vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) infection than are wild-type fibroblasts and demonstrate a deficiency in alpha/beta-IFN-mediated protection. We further show that mice lacking PKR are extremely susceptible to intranasal VSV infection, succumbing within days after instillation with as few as 50 infectious viral particles. Again, alpha/beta-IFN was unable to rescue PKR(-/-) mice from VSV infection. Surprisingly, intranasally infected PKR(-/-) mice died not from pathology of the central nervous system but rather from acute infection of the respiratory tract, demonstrating high virus titers in the lungs compared to similarly infected wild-type animals. These results confirm the role of PKR as the major component of IFN-mediated resistance to VSV infection. Since previous reports have shown PKR to be nonessential for survival in animals challenged with encephalomyocarditis virus, influenza virus, and vaccinia virus (N. Abraham et al., J. Biol. Chem. 274:5953-5962, 1999; Y. Yang et al., EMBO J. 14:6095-6106, 1995), our findings serve to highlight the premise that host dependence on the various mediators of IFN-induced antiviral defenses is pathogen specific.

Exploiting tumor-specific defects in the interferon pathway with a previously unknown oncolytic virus

Interferons are circulating factors that bind to cell surface receptors, activating a signaling cascade, ultimately leading to both an antiviral response and an induction of growth inhibitory and/or apoptotic signals in normal and tumor cells. Attempts to exploit the ability of interferons to limit the growth of tumors in patients has met with limited results because of cancer-specific mutations of gene products in the interferon pathway. Although interferon-non-responsive cancer cells may have acquired a growth/survival advantage over their normal counterparts, they may have simultaneously compromised their antiviral response. To test this, we used vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), an enveloped, negative-sense RNA virus exquisitely sensitive to treatment with interferon. VSV rapidly replicated in and selectively killed a variety of human tumor cell lines even in the presence of doses of interferon that completely protected normal human primary cell cultures. A single intratumoral injection of VSV was effective in reducing the tumor burden of nude mice bearing subcutaneous human melanoma xenografts. Our results support the use of VSV as a replication-competent oncolytic virus and demonstrate a new strategy for the treatment of interferon non-responsive tumors.

SR protein kinases: the splice of life

The eukaryotic genome codes for most of its proteins though discontinuous coding sequences called exons, which are separated by noncoding sequences known as introns. Following transcription of a gene, these exons must be spliced precisely, removing the intervening introns, to form meaningful mature messenger RNAs (mRNA) that are transported to the cytoplasm and translated by the ribosomal machinery. To add yet another level of complexity, a process known as alternative splicing exists, whereby a single pre-mRNA can give rise to two or more mature mRNAs depending on the combination of exons spliced together. Alternative splicing of pre-mRNAs is emerging as an important mechanism for gene regulation in many organisms. The classic example of splicing as a regulator of genetic information during a developmental process is sex determination in Drosophila. The now well-characterized cascade of sex-specific alternative splicing events demonstrates nicely how the control of splice site selection during pre-mRNA processing can have a profound effect on the development of an organism. The factors involved in pre-mRNA splicing and alternative splice site selection have been the subject of active study in recent years. Emerging from these studies is a picture of regulation based on protein-protein, protein-RNA, and RNA-RNA interactions. How the interaction of the various splicing constituents is controlled, however, is still poorly understood. One of the mechanisms of regulation that has received attention recently is that of posttranslational phosphorylation. In the following article, we cite the evidence for a role of phosphorylation in constitutive and alternative splicing and discuss some of the recent information on the biochemistry and biology of the enzymes involved.

Characterization of transgenic mice with targeted disruption of the catalytic domain of the double-stranded RNA-dependent protein kinase, PKR

The interferon-inducible, double-stranded RNA-dependent protein kinase PKR has been implicated in anti-viral, anti-tumor, and apoptotic responses. Others have attempted to examine the requirement of PKR in these roles by targeted disruption at the amino terminal-encoding region of the Pkr gene. By using a strategy that aims at disruption of the catalytic domain of PKR, we have generated mice that are genetically ablated for functional PKR. Similar to the other mouse model of Pkr disruption, we have observed no consequences of loss of PKR on tumor suppression. Anti-viral response to influenza and vaccinia also appeared to be normal in mice and in cells lacking PKR. Cytokine signaling in the type I interferon pathway is normal but may be compromised in the erythropoietin pathway in erythroid bone marrow precursors. Contrary to the amino-terminal targeted Pkr mouse, tumor necrosis factor alpha-induced apoptosis and the anti-viral apoptosis response to influenza is not impaired in catalytic domain-targeted Pkr-null cells. The observation of intact eukaryotic initiation factor-2alpha phosphorylation in these Pkr-null cells provides proof of rescue by another eukaryotic initiation factor-2alpha kinase(s).

The murine PKR tumor suppressor gene is rearranged in a lymphocytic leukemia

The double-stranded RNA-dependent kinase, PKR, is encoded by an interferon inducible gene and is largely responsible for the anti-viral effects of this cytokine. Recent studies have shown that PKR may also play a role in the regulation of normal cellular growth. Although numerous examples of viral strategies for inactivation of PKR exist, there is no evidence of PKR inactivation in tumors. We demonstrate here that the Tik gene, which encodes a dual-specificity kinase, is the murine homolog of PKR, the dsRNA-dependent kinase, and has undergone a rearrangement of one allele in a murine lymphocytic leukemia cell. We have cloned a cDNA that corresponds to a mutated transcript from the rearranged mPKR gene and show that while the mutated polypeptide retains its ability to dimerize and bind dsRNA, it is catalytically inactive. Although this mutated mPKR lacks apparent dominant-negative function, the net effect of reduced PKR activity in these cells may be significant.

The Clk2 and Clk3 dual-specificity protein kinases regulate the intranuclear distribution of SR proteins and influence pre-mRNA splicing

The three members of the Clk family of kinases (Clk1, 2, and 3) have been shown to undergo conserved alternative splicing to generate catalytically active (Clk) and inactive (ClkT) isoforms. The prototype, murine Clk1 (mClk1), is a nuclear dual-specificity kinase that can interact with, and cause the nuclear redistribution of, SR proteins. In this study, we demonstrate that the human Clk2 and Clk3 (hClk2 and 3) are also found within the nucleus and display dual-specificity kinase activity. The truncated isoforms, hClk2(T) and hClk3(T), colocalize with SR proteins in nuclear speckles. We also show catalytically active hClk2 and hClk3 cause the redistribution of SR proteins and can regulate the alternative splicing of a model precursor mRNA substrate in vivo.

In vivo regulation of alternative pre-mRNA splicing by the Clk1 protein kinase

Controlled expression of cellular and viral genes through alternative precursor messenger RNA (pre-mRNA) splicing requires serine/arginine-rich (SR) proteins. The Clk1 kinase, which phosphorylates SR proteins, is regulated through alternative splicing of the Clk1 pre-mRNA, yielding mRNAs encoding catalytically active and truncated inactive polypeptides (Clk1 and Clk1T, respectively). We present evidence that Clk1 and Clk1T proteins regulate the splicing of Clk1 and adenovirus pre-mRNAs in vivo. The peptide domain encoded by the alternatively spliced exon of Clk1 is essential for the regulatory activity of the Clk1 kinase. This is the first direct demonstration of an in vivo link between alternative splicing and protein kinase activity.

Trypanosoma brucei: analysis of cytoplasmic Ca2+ during differentiation of bloodstream stages in vitro

The highly regulated intracellular concentration of calcium (Ca2+) is a well-described regulator of diverse cellular events, including cell cycle control. In the present study we have addressed the regulation of cytosolic Ca2+ in differentiation events in the life cycle of the protozoan parasite Trypanosoma brucei. Bloodstream form (BSF) trypanosomes include the mitotically active long slender forms (LS) which differentiate to two nondividing stages--intermediate (INT) which transform into short stumpy (SS) forms. An axenic in vitro culture system was used to cultivate LS to a density greater than 1.0 x 10(6) cells/ml/day. Populations of the intermediate BSF (INT) and SS were derived from cultured LS by treatment with difluoromethyl ornithine (DFMO, 100 microM) for 2 and 4 days, respectively. A semiquantitative reverse transcriptase-coupled polymerase chain reaction protocol (SQ-RT-PCR) was developed to objectively distinguish the three BSF by monitoring the relative levels of stage-specific mRNAs--cytochrome oxidase II (COXII), variant surface glycoprotein, and procyclin during the differentiation of LS to SS, showing an increase in COXII and procyclin mRNA expression during this process of differentiation. Basal cytosolic Ca2+ levels [Ca2+]i of populations of LS, INT, and SS were studied using Indo-1 dual emission fluorometry. [Ca2+]i was maximal in dividing LS cells and was shown to decrease coincidentally with early events in the process of differentiation to INT and SS. Thapsigargin (1 microM), reported to cause the release of Ca2+ from the endoplasmic reticulum, elevated [Ca2+]i by about 30-60 nM in all BSF; however, the total thapsigargin-releasable stores decreased in parallel with the decrease in basal [Ca2+]i. Control treatments verified that elevations in [Ca2+]i in response to thapsigargin were intracellular in origin. These results may reflect the cessation of cytosolic Ca2+ transients involved in the regulation of mitosis as the parasite exits from the cell cycle and differentiates from rapidly dividing LS to the nondividing SS.