Anti-drug Antibody Sample Testing and Reporting Harmonization

A clear scientific and operational need exists for harmonized bioanalytical immunogenicity study reporting to facilitate communication of immunogenicity findings and expedient review by industry and health authorities. To address these key bioanalytical reporting gaps and provide a report structure for documenting immunogenicity results, this cross-industry group was formed to establish harmonized recommendations and a develop a submission template to facilitate agency filings. Provided here are recommendations for reporting clinical anti-drug antibody (ADA) assay results using ligand-binding assay technologies. This publication describes the essential bioanalytical report (BAR) elements such as the method, critical reagents and equipment, study samples, results, and data analysis, and provides a template for a suggested structure for the ADA BAR. This publication focuses on the content and presentation of the bioanalytical ADA sample analysis report. The interpretation of immunogenicity data, including the evaluation of the impact of ADA on safety, exposure, and efficacy, is out of scope of this publication.

Efficacy of a tetravalent chimeric dengue vaccine (DENVax) in Cynomolgus macaques

Three tetravalent formulations of chimeric dengue (DENVax) viruses containing the pre-membrane and envelope genes of serotypes 1-4 expressed by the attenuated DENV-2 PDK-53 genome were tested for safety, immunogenicity, and efficacy in cynomolgus macaques (Macaca fascicularis). Subcutaneous injection of the DENVax formulations was well-tolerated. Low levels of viremia of only one of the four vaccine viruses were detected yet virus neutralizing antibody titers were induced against all four dengue virus serotypes after one or two administrations of vaccine. All animals immunized with the high-dose formulation were protected from viremia, and all immunized animals were completely protected from DENV-3 and DENV-4 challenge. A lower dose of DENVax formulation partially protected animals from DENV-1 or DENV-2 challenge. In contrast, all control animals developed high levels of viremia for multiple days after challenge with DENV 1-4. This study highlights the immunogenicity and efficacy of the tetravalent DENVax formulations in nonhuman primates.

Improving immunogenicity, efficacy and safety of vaccines through innovation in clinical assay development and trial design: the Phacilitate Vaccine Forum, Washington D.C. 2011

The 9th Annual Vaccine Forum organized by Phacilitate in Washington D.C. 2011 brought together 50+ senior level speakers and over 400 participants representing all the key stakeholders concerning vaccines. The main focus of the meeting was to define priorities in the global vaccines sector from funding to manufacturing and evaluation of vaccine efficacy. A special session was devoted to improving immunogenicity, efficacy and safety of vaccines through innovation in clinical assay development and trial design. The current regulatory approach to clinical assay specification, validation and standardization that enable more direct comparisons of efficacy between trials was illustrated by the success in meningococcal vaccine development. The industry approach to validation strategies was exemplified by a new serologic test used on the diagnostic of pneumococcal pneumonia. The application of the Animal Rule to bridge clinical and non-clinical studies in botulism has allowed significant progress in developing one of the first vaccines to seek approval under the FDA Animal Efficacy Rule. An example of pushing the boundaries in the correlation of immunological responses and efficacy points was represented by a recent cell-based influenza vaccine for which the same correlates of protection apply as for the traditional, egg-based flue vaccine. In the field of HIV phase 2b studies are underway, based on promising results obtained with some vaccine candidates. The conclusion of this session was that creativity in vaccine design and evaluation is beneficial and can lead to innovative new vaccine designs as well as to validated assays to assess vaccine efficacy.

Multiple sclerosis patients show sexual dimorphism in cytokine responses to myelin antigens

Multiple sclerosis affects more women than men. The reasons for this are unknown. Previously, we have shown significant differences in women versus men in inflammatory cytokine responses to the major protein component of myelin, proteolipid protein (PLP), which is thought to be a target in MS patients. Here, using the ELISPOT assay, we examined sex differences in single-cell secretion of Th1 and Th2 cytokines from freshly isolated PBMC between relapsing remitting (RR) MS patients and healthy individuals. Cells were stimulated with MS-associated antigens including proteolipid protein (PLP), myelin basic protein (MBP), myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG), and non-disease related antigens. Our data show a sex bias in the cytokine responses to multiple MS-relevant myelin antigens: Women with MS show IFNgamma-skewed responses and men with MS show IL-5-skewed responses. These data extend our previous findings [Pelfrey, C.M., Cotleur, A.C., Lee, J.C., Rudick, R.A. 2002. Sex differences in cytokine responses to myelin peptides in multiple sclerosis. J. Neuroimmunol. 130, 211-223.]: (1) by demonstrating gender skewing in cytokine responses to an expanded myelin antigen repertoire, which includes MBP, MOG and PLP; (2) by showing TNFalpha and IL-10 do not display comparable gender skewing compared to IFNgamma and IL5; (3) by defining the patient population as early, untreated RRMS patients to avoid confounding factors, such as different disease stages/disability and immunomodulatory therapy; and (4) by showing HLA type does not appear to underlie the gender differences. These findings may explain increased susceptibility to MS in women and could contribute to the differences in disease severity between men and women.

Effects of sex hormones on costimulatory molecule expression in multiple sclerosis

Sex hormones play a central role as modulators of immune responses and autoimmune diseases. We hypothesized that suppression of MS disease during pregnancy may be mediated by sex steroid hormones via regulation of costimulatory molecules such as CD40L or CD80/CD86 (B7-1/B7-2). We tested two sex hormones that are implicated in immune suppression during pregnancy: estriol and progesterone. We also examined whether this regulation is gender-specific or disease-related. PBMC from untreated relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis (RR MS) patients and controls were examined for expression of T cell and monocyte costimulatory molecules following mitogen stimulation in the presence or absence of sex hormones. In the absence of hormones, we confirmed that mitogen stimulation induced significantly more CD40L on the surface of CD4(+)T cells in MS patients compared to controls, and we extend these findings by showing there were no gender differences in induction of CD40L. Although supra-physiologic doses of hormones mildly suppressed CD40L expression on activated T cells, in vitro exposure to typical pregnancy-related physiologic doses of estriol or progesterone showed very little or no suppression of CD40L. On monocytes, neither estriol nor progesterone significantly altered the expression of CD80/CD86. These results suggest that physiologic doses of estriol or progesterone cannot alter CD40L on T cells or CD80/CD86 on monocytes sufficiently to explain the improvement observed in MS during pregnancy. Thus, although amelioration of MS and other autoimmune diseases during pregnancy is thought to be due to increased sex hormones, the present results do not support a role for suppression of costimulation via estriol or progesterone.

Longitudinal single-cell cytokine responses reveal recurrent autoimmune myelin reactivity in relapsing--remitting multiple sclerosis patients

The relationship between multiple sclerosis (MS) disease activity and myelin protein-induced cytokine responses over time is not elucidated. We addressed this relationship by examining longitudinal cytokine responses to myelin proteins every three months for one year, in the context of gadolinium (gad)-enhancing brain lesions and of clinical relapses. The ELISPOT assay was used to determine the ex vivo cytokine production in response to nine amino acid long peptides spanning the entire proteolipid protein (PLP) and myelin basic protein (MBP) molecules in relapsing-remitting (RR) MS patients and matched healthy controls. We identified three longitudinal levels of myelin-induced cytokine secretion by adding up the positive responses for all PLP or MBP peptides obtained for five timepoints, at three-month intervals: low reactivity (< 200 cumulative cytokine-secreting cells), isolated peptide reactivity (201-450 cumulative cytokine-secreting cells) and recurrent protein-wide bursts of cytokine reactivity (> 451 cumulative cytokine-secreting cells). The majority of MS patients showed recurrent bursts to PLP and MBP. In contrast, controls showed a more even distribution between all levels of cytokine reactivity. The majority of patients with gad-enhancing lesions showed PLP/IFN gamma and MBP/IFN gamma recurrent burst responses. This is the first longitudinal study on MS patients in which nine amino acid long myelin peptides are used to reveal the broad range of PLP- and MBP-peptide cytokine reactivity across the whole molecule of these two major myelin proteins. This study also reveals the extremely dynamic nature of the immune reactivity to numerous regions of myelin, which can fluctuate dramatically over time. Such fluctuation could hamper the efficacy of antigen-based therapies for MS.

Epitope mapping in multiple sclerosis using the ELISPOT assay

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is thought to be an autoimmune disease in which an unknown trigger initiates an immune response against brain proteins. This autoaggressive response causes the breakdown of the myelin sheaths that protect nerve axons, leading to impaired nerve conduction and subsequent neurodegeneration that are characteristic of MS. Many studies have attempted to determine the exact target within the brain. However, there appear to be multiple targets, which may change over time. No single study has examined all targets nor looked at how they can change over the course of the disease and whether these changes are related to the course of disease. We have approached this by using the single-cell resolution capability of the enzyme-linked immunospot assay to examine cytokine reactivity in MS patients in response to a very large set of overlapping peptides that span the two major proteins of myelin: myelin basic protein and proteolipid protein. Our goal was to use the enzyme-linked immunospot assay to perform comprehensive epitope mapping in relapsing-remitting MS patients in a longitudinal study to help define the role of myelin responses in disease progression.

Interferon gamma responses to myelin peptides in multiple sclerosis correlate with a new clinical measure of disease progression

The relationship between autoreactivity to myelin antigens and disease progression in multiple sclerosis (MS) is not fully understood. We addressed this relationship by cross-sectionally comparing an objective measure of MS disability with immune cytokine responses to myelin proteins. The ELISPOT assay was used to determine the ex vivo interferon gamma (IFNgamma) and interleukin-10 (IL-10) production by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) in response to peptides spanning the entire proteolipid protein (PLP) and myelin basic protein (MBP) molecules in 20 patients with relapsing-remitting (RR) MS and 27 age- and sex-matched healthy controls. MS patients showed significantly higher MBP-induced IFNgamma responses and PLP-induced IL-10 responses compared with healthy controls. Using the Multiple Sclerosis Functional Composite (MSFC), a new multifactorial measure of disability, MS patients showed a significant correlation between the IFNgamma response to PLP peptides and MBP peptides, and disability. In contrast, in MS patients, there was no correlation between the MSFC and the response to unrelated control antigens or mitogens. These data show that myelin-specific T lymphocytes secreting the inflammatory cytokine IFNgamma correlate with functional impairment in MS, supporting an antigen-specific link between the immune response to myelin and disability in MS.