Neurophysiology of epidurally evoked spinal cord reflexes in clinically motor-complete posttraumatic spinal cord injury

Increased use of epidural Spinal Cord Stimulation (eSCS) for the rehabilitation of spinal cord injury (SCI) has highlighted the need for a greater understanding of the properties of reflex circuits in the isolated spinal cord, particularly in response to repetitive stimulation. Here, we investigate the frequency-dependence of modulation of short- and long-latency EMG responses of lower limb muscles in patients with SCI at rest. Single stimuli could evoke short-latency responses as well as long-latency (likely polysynaptic) responses. The short-latency component was enhanced at low frequencies and declined at higher rates. In all muscles, the effects of eSCS were more complex if polysynaptic activity was elicited, making the motor output become an active process expressed either as suppression, tonic or rhythmical activity. The polysynaptic activity threshold is not constant and might vary with different stimulation frequencies, which speaks for its temporal dependency. Polysynaptic components can be observed as direct responses, neuromodulation of monosynaptic responses or driving the muscle activity by themselves, depending on the frequency level. We suggest that the presence of polysynaptic activity could be a potential predictor for appropriate stimulation conditions. This work studies the complex behaviour of spinal circuits deprived of voluntary motor control from the brain and in the absence of any other inputs. This is done by describing the monosynaptic responses, polysynaptic activity, and its interaction through its input–output interaction with sustain stimulation that, unlike single stimuli used to study the reflex pathway, can strongly influence the interneuron circuitry and reveal a broader spectrum of connectivity.

Spinal cord injuries, human neuropathology and neurophysiology

A correlative approach to human spinal cord injuries (SCI) through the combination of neuropathology and neurophysiology provides a much better understanding of the condition than with either alone. Among the benefits so derived is the wide range of interventions applicable to the restorative neurology (RN) of SCI so that the neurological status of the SCI patient is thereby much improved. The neurophysiological and neuropathological elements underlying these advances are described.

Clinical Cell Therapy Guidelines for Neurorestoration (IANR/CANR 2017)

Cell therapy has been shown to be a key clinical therapeutic option for central nervous system diseases or damage. Standardization of clinical cell therapy procedures is an important task for professional associations devoted to cell therapy. The Chinese Branch of the International Association of Neurorestoratology (IANR) completed the first set of guidelines governing the clinical application of neurorestoration in 2011. The IANR and the Chinese Association of Neurorestoratology (CANR) collaborated to propose the current version "Clinical Cell Therapy Guidelines for Neurorestoration (IANR/CANR 2017)". The IANR council board members and CANR committee members approved this proposal on September 1, 2016, and recommend it to clinical practitioners of cellular therapy. These guidelines include items of cell type nomenclature, cell quality control, minimal suggested cell doses, patient-informed consent, indications for undergoing cell therapy, contraindications for undergoing cell therapy, documentation of procedure and therapy, safety evaluation, efficacy evaluation, policy of repeated treatments, do not charge patients for unproven therapies, basic principles of cell therapy, and publishing responsibility.

Neurocontrol of Movement in Humans With Spinal Cord Injury

In this review of neurocontrol of movement after spinal cord injury, we discuss neurophysiological evidences of conducting and processing mechanisms of the spinal cord. We illustrate that external afferent inputs to the spinal cord below the level of the lesion can modify, initiate, and maintain execution of movement in absence or partial presence of brain motor control after chronic spinal cord injury. We review significant differences between spinal reflex activity elicited by single and repetitive stimulation. The spinal cord can respond with sensitization, habituation, and dis-habituation to regular repetitive stimulation. Therefore, repetitive spinal cord reflex activity can contribute to the functional configuration of the spinal network. Moreover, testing spinal reflex activity in individuals with motor complete spinal cord injury provided evidences for subclinical residual brain influence, suggesting the existence of axons traversing the injury site and influencing the activities below the level of lesion. Thus, there are two motor control models of chronic spinal cord injury in humans: "discomplete" and "reduced and altered volitional motor control." We outline accomplishments in modification and initiation of altered neurocontrol in chronic spinal cord injury people with epidural and functional electrical stimulation. By nonpatterned electrical stimulation of lumbar posterior roots, it is possible to evoke bilateral extension as well as rhythmic motor outputs. Epidural stimulation during treadmill stepping shows increased and/or modified motor activity. Finally, volitional efforts can alter epidurally induced rhythmic activities in incomplete spinal cord injury. Overall, we highlight that upper motor neuron paralysis does not entail complete absence of connectivity between cortex, brain stem, and spinal motor cells, but there can be altered anatomy and corresponding neurophysiological characteristics. With specific input to the spinal cord below the level of the lesion, the clinical status of upper motor neuron paralysis without structural modification can be modified, and movements can be initiated. Thus, external afferent input can partially replace brain control.

Mechanisms of electrical stimulation with neural prostheses

Individual electric and geometric characteristics of neural substructures can have surprising effects on artificially controlled neural signaling. A rule of thumb approved for the stimulation of long peripheral axons may not hold when the central nervous system is involved. This is demonstrated here with a comparison of results from the electrically stimulated cochlea, retina, and spinal cord. A generalized form of the activating function together with accurate modeling of the neural membrane dynamics are the tools to analyze the excitation mechanisms initiated by neural prostheses. Analysis is sometimes possible with a linear theory, in other cases, simulation of internal calcium concentration or ion channel current fluctuations is needed to see irregularities in spike trains. Spike initiation site can easily change within a single target neuron under constant stimulation conditions of a cochlear implant. Poor myelinization in the soma region of the human cochlear neurons causes firing characteristics different from any animal data. Retinal ganglion cells also generate propagating spikes within the dendritic tree. Bipolar cells in the retina are expected to respond with neurotransmitter release before a spike is generated in the ganglion cell, even when they are far away from the electrode. Epidural stimulation of the lumbar spinal cord predominantly stimulates large sensory axons in the dorsal roots which induce muscle reflex responses. Analysis with the generalized activating function, computer simulations of the nonlinear neural membrane behavior together with experimental and clinical data analysis enlighten our understanding of artificial firing patterns influenced by neural prostheses.

Neurophysiological assessment of the motor and sensory spinal pathways in chronic spinal cord injury

Introduction of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) has provided means to study non-invasively corticospinal functions in humans. The purpose of the present study was to obtain an objective evaluation of spinal cord functions in spinal cord injury (SCI) subjects using TMS, multichannel surface EMG and somatosensory-evoked potentials (SSEP). Multichannel surface EMG recording was performed during reinforcement manoeuvres and during vibratory tonic reflex. Twenty-five post-traumatic clinically incomplete (ambulatory, AMB, and non-ambulatory, nAMB) SCI subjects were studied and compared to a control group of seven subjects. After preliminary analysis of neurophysiological studies they were divided into four groups according to presence or absence of motor-evoked potentials (MEP) in response to TMS in muscles below the level of the lesion and according to their ability to ambulate. TMS was delivered at vertex at 100% intensity and recorded from the large muscles of the upper and lower limbs. Surface EMG was recorded during reinforcement manoeuvres (RM) in the leg muscles and EMG activity was scored. SSEP were recorded at T12, L2, L4 and SI spinous processes and at Cz' on the scalp following tibial nerve stimulation at popliteal fossa. The prevalence of EMG responses during RM was higher in group with present MEPs (AMB/MEP+ and nAMB/MEP+) than in the group without MEPs. The group with present MEPs also showed better preserved functions of the ascending tracts compared to subjects without MEPs. Groups with present MEPs had 5/10 normal, 2/10 abnormal and 3/10 absent cortical SSEPs, whereas groups without MEPs showed 1/11 normal, 4/11 abnormal and 6/11 absent cortical SSEPs. Sustained function of ascending tracts was also positively correlated with preserved ability to ambulate. It was concluded that TMS in combination with multichannel surface EMG monitoring and sensory evoked potentials may prove feasible in assessing the functional capacity of the spinal cord after spinal cord lesion.

Characteristics of the vibratory reflex in humans with reduced suprasegmental influence due to spinal cord injury

The tonic stretch reflex elicited by vibration of a muscle or tendon provides a means of studying segmental reflex activity in humans with impaired volitional motor activity due to spinal cord injury (SCI). Vibration applied to the achilles or patellar tendon in a group of 51 SCI subjects elicited motor unit activity different from that found in 12 healthy subjects. Four distinct features of motor unit responses to vibration of a single tendon (achilles or patellar) could be seen in the SCI subjects: (i) a rapid onset, tonic response, frequently beginning with a single burst analogous to a tendon jerk, in 72% of vibrated sites; (ii) repetitive, phasic bursts of activity or vibratory-induced clonus in 23% of the tonic responses; (iii) spread of activity to muscles distant from the vibration in 44% of the tonic responses; and vibratory-induced withdrawal reflexes (VWR) which occurred after vibration of 37% of the sites. Overall, 81% of stimulated sites responded to vibration in SCI subjects. In contrast, only 54% of vibrated sites responded in control subjects, always with a gradual onset tonic response, never accompanied by a VWR. The VWR in SCI subjects was typically of much larger amplitude than the tonic responses and involved a mean of 5 muscles (41% bilaterally). Features of these responses provide an insight into underlying neurocontrol mechanisms which may provide guidance in the selection of appropriate intervention or management strategies.

Modification of reflex responses to lumbar posterior root stimulation by motor tasks in healthy subjects

Dynamic task-dependent regulation of reflexes controlled by the central nervous system plays an integral part in neurocontrol of locomotion. Such modifications of sensory-motor transmission can be studied by conditioning a test reflex with specific motor tasks. To elicit short-latency test reflexes, we applied a novel transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation technique that depolarizes large-diameter posterior root afferents. These responses, termed posterior root-muscle (PRM) reflexes, are equivalent to the monosynaptic Hoffmann (H)-reflex but can be evoked in several muscles simultaneously. We elicited PRM reflexes in quadriceps, hamstrings, tibialis anterior, and triceps surae in subjects with intact nervous system. During three different conditioning-test paradigms in a standing position, that is, volitional unilateral single- and multi-joint lower limb movements and leaning backward/forward, we recorded characteristic movement-induced modulations of PRM reflexes in the thigh and leg muscle groups. We could thus demonstrate that monosynaptic PRM reflexes in functional extensor and flexor muscles of the thigh and leg can be elicited in upright standing subjects and can be modulated during the execution of postural maneuvers. The significance is that transcutaneous posterior root stimulation allows extending H-reflex studies of a single muscle to the assessment of synaptic transmission of two-neuron reflex arcs at multiple segmental levels simultaneously.

Model for the study of plasticity of the human nervous system: features of residual spinal cord motor activity resulting from established post-traumatic injury

Established post-traumatic spinal cord injuries can serve as an 'experimental model' in which trauma has partially separated the 'spinal neuronal pool' from supraspinal influence. Our findings show that: (1) when the muscle is deprived of upper motor neuron activity, fatigue resistance is diminished and external, electrically induced daily contractions will restore the level of fatigue resistance close to that of muscles in healthy, active subjects; (2) the spinal interneuron network, when completely deprived of brain influence, is a 'spinal reflex centre' with a relatively restricted and low excitability level; and (3) the 'discomplete spinal cord injury' model illustrates that spasticity is of supra-segmental origin and that there are two basic features of brain motor control of the spinal interneuron system: the command to restrict interneuronal pool activity and the command to activate the interneuronal network. Moreover, I have described the modifiability of fatigue resistance, locomotor patterns and different alternatives in the neurocontrol of motor activity, depending on the kind and degree of residual brain influence. Such significant modifiability can be thought of as plasticity of the neuromuscular system and impaired control of the nervous system.

Posterior root-muscle reflexes elicited by transcutaneous stimulation of the human lumbosacral cord

Continuous epidural stimulation of lumbar posterior root afferents can modify the activity of lumbar cord networks and motoneurons, resulting in suppression of spasticity or elicitation of locomotor-like movements in spinal cord-injured people. The aim of the present study was to demonstrate that posterior root afferents can also be depolarized by transcutaneous stimulation with moderate stimulus intensities. In healthy subjects, single stimuli applied through surface electrodes placed over the T11-T12 vertebrae with a mean intensity of 28.6 V elicited simultaneous, bilateral monosynaptic reflexes in quadriceps, hamstrings, tibialis anterior, and triceps surae by depolarization of lumbosacral posterior root fibers. The nature of these posterior root-muscle reflexes was demonstrated by the duration of the refractory period, and by modifying the responses with vibration and active and passive movements. Stimulation over the L4-L5 vertebrae selectively depolarized posterior root fibers or additionally activated anterior root fibers within the cauda equina depending on stimulus intensity. Transcutaneous posterior root stimulation with single pulses allows neurophysiological studies of state- and task-dependent modulations of monosynaptic reflexes at multiple segmental levels. Continuous transcutaneous posterior root stimulation represents a novel, non-invasive, neuromodulative approach for individuals with different neurological disorders.

Human lumbar cord circuitries can be activated by extrinsic tonic input to generate locomotor-like activity

We have demonstrated that non-patterned electrical stimulation of the lumbar cord can induce stepping-like activity in the lower limbs of complete spinal cord injured individuals. This result suggested the existence of a human lumbar locomotor pattern generator, which can convert a tonic input to a rhythmic motor output. We have studied the human lumbar cord in isolation from supraspinal input but under extrinsic tonic input delivered by spinal cord stimulation. Large-diameter afferents within the posterior roots are directly depolarized by the electrical stimulation. These afferents project to motoneurons as well as to lumbar interneurons involved in the motor control of lower limbs. Stimulation at 25-50 Hz can elicit rhythmic alternating flexion/extension movements of the lower limbs in supine individuals. Reducing the tonic input frequency to 5-15 Hz initiates lower limb extension. Epidural stimulation applied during manually assisted treadmill stepping in complete spinal cord injured persons immediately increases the central state of excitability of lumbar cord networks and enhances stepping-like functional motor outputs. Sustained, non-patterned tonic input via the posterior roots can activate human lumbar cord networks. Pattern generating configurations of these multifunctional circuitries can be set-up depending on the stimulation parameters and particularly on the input frequency.

Motor control in the human spinal cord and the repair of cord function

In this review we describe clinical and neurophysiological features of motor control in human spinal cord injury based on two models. First, motor control is considered in subjects with injury-induced complete division of the spinal cord from brain and brainstem structures, and second, in those in which the division is partial. We describe motor control in terms of segmental and plurisegmental reflex activity that dominates motor unit output to the muscles following complete separation from the brain motor structures by accidental injury. With incomplete separation of the spinal cord from brain structures, motor control is defined as the voluntary manipulation of reflex and automatic activity integrated with internal and external feedback signals. We review here motor control found after complete spinal cord injury with paradigm of single and regular-repeating stimuli applied to elicit cutaneous and muscle stretch reflex responses. We argue, that isolated spinal cord neural circuitry is capable of organizing characteristic reflex events that depend on the characteristics of the stimulus. Also, the profile of residual brain and brainstem, modified by the reduction in descending long spinal tract fibers arriving at their targets in the spinal gray matter, produces characteristic changes in motor output to the muscles that leads to the development of new neural strategies for control of segmental and plurisegmental neural circuitry. In the second part of this review, we discuss available treatment modalities for impaired cord function and briefly outline neurobiological interventions under development for repair of spinal cord injury.

Motor Control in the Human Spinal Cord

Features of the human spinal cord motor control are described using two spinal cord injury models: (i) the spinal cord completely separated from brain motor structures by accidental injury; (ii) the spinal cord receiving reduced and altered supraspinal input due to an incomplete lesion. Systematic studies using surface electrode polyelectromyography were carried out to assess skeletal muscle reflex responses to single and repetitve stimulation in a large number of subjects. In complete spinal cord injured subjects the functional integrity of three different neuronal circuits below the lesion level is demonstrated: first, simple mono- and oligosynaptic reflex arcs and polysynaptic pathways; second, propriospinal interneuron system with their cell in the gray matter and the axons in the white matter of the spinal cord conducting activity between different spinal cord segments; and third, internuncial gray matter neurons with short axons and dense neuron contact within the spinal gray matter. All of these three systems participate continuously in the generation of spinal cord reflex output activating muscles. The integration of these systems and their relative degree of excitation and set-up produces characteristic functions of motor control. In incomplete spinal cord injured patients, the implementation of brain motor control depends on the profile of residual brain descending input and its integration with the functional neuronal circuits below the lesion. Locomotor patterns result from the establishment of a new structural relationship between brain and spinal cord. The functions of this new structural relationship are expressed as an alternative, but characteristic and consistent neurocontrol. The more we know about how the brain governs spinal cord networks, the better we can describe human motor control. On the other hand such knowledge is essential for the restoration of residual functions and for the construction of new cord circuitry to expand the functions of the injured spinal cord.

Frequency-dependent selection of alternative spinal pathways with common periodic sensory input

Electrical stimulation of the lumbar cord at distinct frequency ranges has been shown to evoke either rhythmical, step-like movements (25-50 Hz) or a sustained extension (5-15 Hz) of the paralysed lower limbs in complete spinal cord injured subjects. Frequency-dependent activation of previously "silent" spinal pathways was suggested to contribute to the differential responsiveness to distinct neuronal "codes" and the modifications in the electromyographic recordings during the actual implementation of the evoked motor tasks. In the present study we examine this suggestion by means of a simplified biology-based neuronal network. Involving two basic mechanisms, temporal summation of synaptic input and presynaptic inhibition, the model exhibits several patterns of mono- and/or oligo-synaptic motor output in response to different interstimulus intervals. It thus reproduces fundamental input-output features of the lumbar cord isolated from the brain. The results confirm frequency-dependent spinal pathway selection as a simple mechanism which enables the cord to respond to distinct neuronal codes with different motor behaviours and to control the actual performance of the latter.

Stepping-like movements in humans with complete spinal cord injury induced by epidural stimulation of the lumbar cord: electromyographic study of compound muscle action potentials

STUDY DESIGN

It has been previously demonstrated that sustained nonpatterned electric stimulation of the posterior lumbar spinal cord from the epidural space can induce stepping-like movements in subjects with chronic, complete spinal cord injury. In the present paper, we explore physiologically related components of electromyographic (EMG) recordings during the induced stepping-like activity.

OBJECTIVES

To examine mechanisms underlying the stepping-like movements activated by electrical epidural stimulation of posterior lumbar cord structures.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study is based on the assessment of epidural stimulation to control spasticity by simultaneous recordings of the electromyographic activity of quadriceps, hamstrings, tibialis anterior, and triceps surae. We examined induced muscle responses to stimulation frequencies of 2.2-50 Hz in 10 subjects classified as having a motor complete spinal cord injury (ASIA A and B). We evaluated stimulus-triggered time windows 50 ms in length from the original EMG traces. Stimulus-evoked compound muscle action potentials (CMAPs) were analyzed with reference to latency, amplitude, and shape.

RESULTS

Epidural stimulation of the posterior lumbosacral cord recruited lower limb muscles in a segmental-selective way, which was characteristic for posterior root stimulation. A 2.2 Hz stimulation elicited stimulus-coupled CMAPs of short latency which were approximately half that of phasic stretch reflex latencies for the respective muscle groups. EMG amplitudes were stimulus-strength dependent. Stimulation at 5-15 and 25-50 Hz elicited sustained tonic and rhythmic activity, respectively, and initiated lower limb extension or stepping-like movements representing different levels of muscle synergies. All EMG responses, even during burst-style phases were composed of separate stimulus-triggered CMAPs with characteristic amplitude modulations. During burst-style phases, a significant increase of CMAP latencies by about 10 ms was observed.

CONCLUSION

The muscle activity evoked by epidural lumbar cord stimulation as described in the present study was initiated within the posterior roots. These posterior roots muscle reflex responses (PRMRRs) to 2.2 Hz stimulation were routed through monosynaptic pathways. Sustained stimulation at 5-50 Hz engaged central spinal PRMRR components. We propose that repeated volleys delivered to the lumbar cord via the posterior roots can effectively modify the central state of spinal circuits by temporarily combining them into functional units generating integrated motor behavior of sustained extension and rhythmic flexion/extension movements. This study opens the possibility for developing neuroprostheses for activation of inherent spinal networks involved in generating functional synergistic movements using a single electrode implanted in a localized and stable region.

Initiating extension of the lower limbs in subjects with complete spinal cord injury by epidural lumbar cord stimulation

We provide evidence that the human spinal cord is able to respond to external afferent input and to generate a sustained extension of the lower extremities when isolated from brain control. The present study demonstrates that sustained, nonpatterned electrical stimulation of the lumbosacral cord--applied at a frequency in the range of 5-15 Hz and a strength above the thresholds for twitches in the thigh and leg muscles--can initiate and retain lower-limb extension in paraplegic subjects with a long history of complete spinal cord injury. We hypothesize that the induced extension is due to tonic input applied by the epidural stimulation to primary sensory afferents. The induced volleys elicit muscle twitches (posterior root muscle-reflex responses) at short and constant latency times and coactivate the configuration of the lumbosacral interneuronal network, presumably via collaterals of the primary sensory neurons and their connectivity with this network. We speculate that the volleys induced externally to the lumbosacral network at a frequency of 5-15 Hz initiate and retain an "extension pattern generator" organization. Once established, this organization would recruit a larger population of motor units in the hip and ankle extensor muscles as compared to the flexors, resulting in an extension movement of the lower limbs. In the electromyograms of the lower-limb muscle groups, such activity is reflected as a characteristic spatiotemporal pattern of compound motor-unit potentials.

Clinical elements for the neuromuscular stimulation and functional electrical stimulation protocols in the practice of neurorehabilitation

The physicians and their multidisciplinary teams involved in the clinical practice of neurological rehabilitation have more and more opportunities to apply neuromuscular stimulation (NMS) and functional electrical stimulation (FES) of peripheral nerves as a part of their daily practice. In this article, we outline clinical protocols of NMS and FES in the following clinical conditions of upper motor neuron dysfunction: to prevent consequences of disuse of the neuromuscular system of the upper motor neuron, to facilitate recovery processes of impaired upper motor neuron functions due to acute and/or subacute neurological conditions, to maintain or enhance the trophic state of the muscle, to modify altered control of muscle tone, to modify altered patterns of automatic and volitional functional movements, to enhance functional movement of the single joint muscle group within intact functional multijoint movement, and to modify altered neurocontrol of posture, locomotion, and skillful movements. We emphasize the importance of understanding the motor control alteration while developing clinical protocols and defining the goals. It is very important to be aware that similar clinical findings and due to the same cause can have different features of residual motor control, and therefore potentials for recovery or modification can be very different.

Epidural electrical stimulation of posterior structures of the human lumbosacral cord: 3. Control Of spasticity

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of spinal cord stimulation (SCS) on severe spasticity of the lower limbs in patients with traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI) under close scrutiny of the site and parameters of stimulation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eight SCI patients (four women, four men) were included in the study. Levels of spasticity before and during stimulation were compared according to a clinical rating scale and by surface electrode polyelectromyography (pEMG) during passive flexion and extension of the knee, supplemented by a pendulum test with the stimulating device switched either on or off over an appropriate period.

RESULTS

Both the clinical and the experimental parameters clearly demonstrated that SCS, when correctly handled, is a highly effective approach to controlling spasticity in spinal cord injury subjects. The success of this type of treatment hinges on four factors: (1) the epidural electrode must be located over the upper lumbar cord segment (L1, L2, L3); (2) the train frequency of stimulation must be in the range of 50 - 100 Hz, the amplitude within 2 - 7 V and the stimulus width of 210 micross; (3) the stimulus parameters must be optimized by clinically assessing the effect of arbitrary combinations of the four contacts of the quadripolar electrode; and (4) amplitudes of stimulation must be adjusted to different body positions.

CONCLUSIONS

Severe muscle hypertonia affecting the lower extremities of patients with chronic spinal cord injuries can be effectively suppressed via stimulation of the upper lumbar cord segment.

Epidural electrical stimulation of posterior structures of the human lumbosacral cord: 2. quantitative analysis by computer modeling

OBJECTIVES

Analysis of the computed recruitment order of an ensemble of ventral and dorsal root fibers should enlighten the relation between the position of a bipolar electrode and the observed order of muscle twitches.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Thresholds of selected spinal root fibers are investigated in a two step procedure. First the electric field generated by the electrodes is computed with the Finite Element Method. In the second step the calculated voltage profile along each target neuron is used as input data for a cable model. For every electrode position the electrical excitability is analyzed for 12 large diameter ventral and dorsal root fibers of the second and fourth lumbar and first sacral segment. The predictions of the neural responses of any target fiber are based on the activating function concept and on the more accurate computer simulations of the electrical behavior of all nodes and internodes in the vicinity of the electrode.

RESULTS

For epidural dorsal lumbosacral spinal cord stimulation we found the following rules. (i) The recruitment order of the spinal roots is highly related to the cathode level. (ii) Dorsal root fibers have the lowest threshold values, ventral root fibers are more difficult to excite and dorsal columns are not excitable within the clinical range of 10 V. (iii) For a cathode close to the level of the spinal cord entry of a target fiber thresholds are lowest and spike initiation is expected at the border between cerebrospinal fluid and white matter; excitation of L4 roots is not possible with 210 micros/10 V pulses when cathode is more than 2.2 cm cranial to their entry level (1.5 cm for S1 roots; standard data). (iv) Cathodes positioned (essentially) below the entry level cause spike initiation close to the cathode, in a region where the fibers follow the descending course within the cerebospinal fluid. (v) At rather low stimulation voltage twitches are expected in all investigated lower limb muscles for cathodes below L5 spinal cord level.

CONCLUSIONS

Our simulations demonstrate a strong relation between electrode position and the order of muscle twitches which is based on the segmental arrangement of innervation of lower limb muscles. The proposed strategy allows the identification of the position of the electrode relative to spinal cord segments.

Epidural electric stimulation of posterior structures of the human lumbar spinal cord: 1. muscle twitches - a functional method to define the site of stimulation

OBJECTIVES

To describe an electrophysiological method for determining the relation between lumbar cord dorsal roots and cathode of epidural electrode for spinal cord stimulation (SCS).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Data has been collected from 13 subjects who have been under evaluation of effectiveness of SCS for control of spasticity. Induced muscle twitches from both quadriceps (Q), adductors (A), hamstrings (H), tibial anterior muscles (TA) and triceps surae muscles (TS) were simultaneously recorded with surface-electrode polyelectromyography (pEMG) and analyzed for amplitudes, latency times and recruitment order.

RESULTS

Stimulation of dorsal lumbar cord structures evoked characteristic EMG events during muscle twitch responses. Their amplitudes varied with stimulus strength. Latency times were rather invariable regardless of stimulus strength. Two distinct recruitment orders were demonstrated depending on whether the stimulating cathode was placed over the upper (=response from quadriceps and/or adductor muscles) or the lower (=response from tibialis anterior and triceps surae) lumbar cord segments. The chances to stimulate upper lumbar cord segments are best around the 12th thoracic vertebra.

CONCLUSIONS

pEMG recording of muscle twitches enables us to accurately differentiate between upper and lower lumbar cord segments. Furthermore, our findings regarding amplitude, latency and recruitment order strongly suggest that we stimulate posterior roots not posterior columns of the lumbar spinal cord.

Evidence for a spinal central pattern generator in humans

Non-patterned electrical stimulation of the posterior structures of the lumbar spinal cord in subjects with complete, long-standing spinal cord injury, can induce patterned, locomotor-like activity. We show that epidural spinal cord stimulation can elicit step-like EMG activity and locomotor synergies in paraplegic subjects. An electrical train of stimuli applied over the second lumbar segment with a frequency of 25 to 60 Hz and an amplitude of 5-9 V was effective in inducing rhythmic, alternating stance and swing phases of the lower limbs. This finding suggests that spinal circuitry in humans has the capability of generating locomotor-like activity even when isolated from brain control, and that externally controlled sustained electrical stimulation of the spinal cord can replace the tonic drive generated by the brain.

Assessment of corticospinal function in spinal cord injury using transcranial motor cortex stimulation: a review

Other than clinical examination, few methods exist for assessing the functional condition of descending long tracts of the spinal cord in humans. This review covers neurophysiological examination of the corticospinal system using transcranial electrical and magnetic motor cortex stimulation. The neurophysiological basis for the motor evoked potentials (MEPs) and the differences between the two methods are discussed followed by a review of their use in individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI). Transcranial motor cortex stimulation is used to monitor descending spinal cord tract condition during spinal surgeries and could be useful for assessing central nervous system trauma, especially in the unconscious multitrauma patient. In the chronic phase of SCI, recordings of MEPs have enabled the estimation of central conduction times that relate to the condition of axons passing through the injured segment of the spinal cord. They were found to correlate well with clinical examination scores but as predictors of outcome, the reports have been mixed. The use of transcranial motor cortex stimulation to modify segmental reflexes and in combination with volitional attempts have also provided evidence of conduction across the lesion in paralyzed SCI subjects. However, MEPs can be absent in some SCI individuals who may be able to volitionally activate muscles below the level of the spinal cord lesion. Such findings are useful in elucidating the neural mechanisms underlying the performance of a volitional movement and may serve to guide and monitor the effects of future treatments for paralysis in SCI and other neurological disorders.

Effect of fatiguing maximal voluntary contraction on excitatory and inhibitory responses elicited by transcranial magnetic motor cortex stimulation

Vertex transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) elicited tibialis anterior motor evoked potentials (MEPs) and silent periods (SPs) that were recorded during and following isometric maximal volitional contraction (MVC). During MVC in 6 healthy subjects, MEP amplitudes in the exercised muscle showed an increasing trend from an initial value of 4539 +/- 809 muV (mean +/- SE) to 550 +/- 908 muV (P < 0.13) while force and EMG decreased (P < 0.01). Also, SP duration increased from 165 +/- 37 ms to 231 +/- 32 ms (P < 0.01). Thus, during a fatiguing MVC both excitatory and inhibitory TMS-induced responses increased. TMS delivered during repeated brief 10% MVC contractions before and after a fatiguing MVC in 5 subjects, showed no change in MEP amplitude but SP duration was prolonged after MVC. This SP prolongation was focal to the exercised muscle. Silent periods recorded after pyramidal tract stimulation were unchanged following the MVC. These results suggest that MEP and SP might have common sources of facilitation during an MVC and that inhibitory mechanisms remain focally augmented following a fatiguing MVC.

Influence of concurrent tasks on gait: a dual-task approach

We studied the effect of concurrent tasks on motor control of gait with dual-task methodology. Ten healthy subjects were instructed to perform different cognitive and motor tasks during gait on a conductive walkway. Footswitch signals were recorded and stride time and double-support time were calculated. It was assumed that the former reflects gait-patterning mechanisms and the latter relates to balance control. Statistical analysis showed an increase in double-support time when a memory-retention task (digit-span) and a fine motor task (buttoning) were executed simultaneously during gait. During gait performance of the cognitive task declined compared to baseline conditions. Attentional demand of concurrent cognitive and motor tasks appeared to force subjects to modulate their gait strategy to ensure control of balance. Stride time was consistent across task conditions except when subjects performed fast finger-tapping during gait. Then all but one subject showed a decrease in stride time and an increase in stride-frequency that was repeatable on retest. Since different rhythmic movements are likely to share common neurobiological networks, we assumed that the modulation of stride-frequency was due to structural interference.

Early and late motor evoked potentials reflect preset agonist-antagonist organization in lower limb muscles

A single transcranial magnetic stimulus can evoke two involuntary muscle responses in lower limb muscles of healthy humans. The purpose of the present study was to find out if these responses, when evoked during the processing period of a simple or choice reaction time task, such as ankle dorsiflexion, have specific characteristics related to the task. During the auditory reaction time, a transcranial magnetic stimulus was delivered to observe changes in the excitability of the central nervous system. A dual-cone coil was used, which effectively stimulated the fairly deep-lying lower limb motor cortex. Stimuli were delivered in a random order with 20-300-ms delays from the auditory go-signal. Motor evoked potentials (MEP) in right and left anterior tibial and soleus muscles were analyzed while early MEPs were observed invariably in both muscles; late MEPs occurred consistently only in soleus muscles. Both early and late MEP amplitudes were larger in simple reaction time trials than in choice reaction time trials. The late MEP appeared earlier in the simple reaction time task than in the choice reaction time task, reflecting faster central processing of simple reaction time tasks. The amplitude of the soleus late MEP in the simple reaction time task followed closely the amplitude of anterior tibial early MEP, suggesting a preset agonist-antagonist organization. This relationship was not present in the choice reaction time task.

Correlation of motor control in the supine position and assistive device used for ambulation in chronic incomplete spinal cord-injured persons

Neurocontrol of movement after spinal cord injury (SCI) is often spared, but few studies have investigated the chronic incomplete SCI patient. Multichannel surface electromyography (SEMG) can describe characteristics of neurocontrol during a series of volitional and reflex events. The relationship of these neurocontrol characteristics to clinical function is incompletely described. This study, retrospectively, evaluated the relationship between neurocontrol patterns evoked by lower limb movement in the supine position and the assistive device used for ambulation in chronic, incomplete SCI persons. The records of 15 neurologically healthy (9 male, 6 female) and 36 incomplete SCI persons (27 male, 9 female) (C2-T10) were used. SEMG was recorded from both quadriceps, adductors, hamstrings, anterior tibialis and triceps surae muscles and displayed on a stripchart for analysis. SEMG patterns of activity recorded in the supine position during volitional, unilateral, multijoint (hip and knee flexion and extension) movement attempts were characterized, divided into seven groups and compared with the subjects' self-selected ambulation device (independent, cane, crutches, walker or nonambulatory). The neurocontrol patterns recorded in the supine position correlated well with the SCI subjects ambulatory assistive device. Marked decreases in motor unit output and/or loss of motor organization were found in the nonambulatory group. Coactivation of proximal muscles, poor timing of muscle activity and radiation of activity into contralateral muscles were also noted in subjects who required a walker or crutches. To a lesser degree, abnormal motor patterns were also noted in subjects who ambulated with a cane or independently.

Features of motor control in patients with proximal childhood spinal muscle atrophy (pilot study)

The differences in the motor performance during different tasks between 19 subjects suffering from SMA and 10 healthy controls were observed. The simultaneous EMG activity of twelve lower limbs and lower trunk muscles was recorded with surface electrodes. EMG data were automatically reduced and compared with data evaluated from performed by physiotherapist manual testing of muscle strength. Results showed characteristic differences between healthy and spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) subjects: 1. SMA patients display generally more activity occurring in numerous muscle groups and more spinal levels are activated. 2. SMA patients reveal a disturbed functional relation between the posterior and anterior compartments of muscles. 3. EMG activity in SMA patients is spreading out also to the contralateral muscle groups even during slight, unilateral singlejoint movements. Oligosegmental, plurisegmental and brain sources are probably responsible for mentioned phenomena. The reciprocal influences between reduced number of motoneurons (in SMA) and function of central movement generators results in different mode of movement execution in SMA patients.

Surface and epidural lumbosacral spinal cord evoked potentials in chronic spinal cord injury

Nine patients were examined in the chronic stage of spinal cord injury (12 to 56 months postinjury). Surface lumbosacral spinal cord evoked potentials (LSEPs) were obtained using electrodes placed over the S1, L2, L4, and T12 vertebral levels, referenced to a T6 surface electrode. Epidural LSEPs were obtained using a multielectrode lead placed percutaneously into the epidural space for evaluation of the efficacy of spinal cord stimulation for modification of pain and spasticity. The LSEPs resulting from supramaximal stimulation of the tibial nerve at the popliteal fossa were composed of propagating and stationary action potential components. Based on the surface LSEP amplitudes and latencies established in healthy subjects, the data was divided into normal (less than 2 SD), marginal (between 2 and 2.5 SD), and abnormal (greater than 2.5 SD) categories. Comparison of surface and epidural LSEPs at the T12 vertebral level for the normal group (n = 6, 4 incomplete and 2 complete) revealed a mean epidural/surface amplitude ratio of 9.44 and a latency for the major negative component of 15.2 +/- 0.6 ms for the epidural versus 14.8 +/- 0.6 ms for the surface LSEP. In cases where the lead was progressively removed and LSEPs recorded (n = 4) the propagating components rapidly attenuated and increased in duration while the stationary components attenuated but did not change in duration. The LSEPs for the marginal group (n = 2, 1 incomplete and 1 complete) showed similar epidural/surface amplitude ratios. In the abnormal case (n = 1, complete) surface LSEPs were absent but epidural LSEPs were present but with stationary and propagating components of low amplitude. This study demonstrates the ability of the epidural LSEP to provide more information than the surface LSEP of the functional condition of the lumbosacral spinal cord, particularly regarding the character of the propagating action potentials and in cases when the surface LSEPs appear to be of very low amplitude or absent.

Modification of cervical dystonia by selective sensory stimulation

Cervical dystonia is often refractory to all forms of therapy. Many patients, however, are able to transiently abolish their spasms following a specific gesture that presumably enhances sensory input. Such observations prompted us to develop a protocol to determine if various forms of sensory stimulation could modify the motor control patterns in cervical dystonia. Surface EMG recordings of multiple neck and trunk muscles were obtained in 11 consecutive cervical dystonia patients. Baseline patterns of voluntary and involuntary muscle activation were established during a series of motor and non-motor tasks. The tasks were repeated during the application of vibratory or electrical stimulation to select muscle groups or to cutaneous and mixed nerves. Analysis of the results was made on the basis of paper and computer recordings of the data. Sensory stimulation decreased involuntary muscle activity and reduced spasms in 5 subjects. However, objective or subjective improvement usually occurred only after specific stimuli were applied to specific anatomical sites. In these cases, the protocol identified the site at which a specific sensory stimulus could be applied to control the dystonia. We conclude that selective sensory stimulation can beneficially modify cervical dystonia in some patients. Such findings warrant further investigation of the use of sensory stimulation for control of cervical dystonia.

Evidence of subclinical brain influence in clinically complete spinal cord injury: discomplete SCI

Previous studies of the neurocontrol of movement in spinal cord injury (SCI) subjects revealed that even those without volitional movement may retain some degree of preservation of distal brain influence. We previously defined a discomplete lesion as one which is clinically complete but which is accompanied by neurophysiological evidence of residual brain influence on spinal cord function below the lesion. In order to document the nature and extent of such neurocontrol, we recorded surface EMGs from multiple muscle groups to study patterns of motor unit activity in response to tendon vibration, activation of muscles below the lesion by reinforcement maneuvers above the lesion and by voluntary suppression of plantar withdrawal reflexes. We analyzed data from this brain motor control assessment (BMCA) procedure in order to describe the frequency of occurrence and characteristics of residual control in discomplete SCI subjects, comparing with findings in (clinically and neurophysiologically) complete and in (clinically and neurophysiologically) incomplete SCI subjects. From a group of 139 SCI subjects seen for management of spasticity, 88 had clinically complete lesions. Of these, 74 (84%) were discomplete as defined by responses to the above maneuvers. The selection of management and intervention strategies, whether physiological, pharmacological, behavioral or surgical, should give consideration to the high likelihood that clinically complete subjects may be neurophysiologically incomplete.

Co-activation of ipsi- and contralateral muscle groups during contraction of ankle dorsiflexors

Seventeen adult, healthy subjects, age 38.4 +/- 0.24 years (mean +/- SEM) 7 of which were females, were studied. Each subject was seated on a specially designed chair with trunk and legs fixed and the foot strapped to a rigid plate that was attached to a load cell. The position of the strap was adjusted so as to lie across the foot at the level of the metatarsal bones. The knee and ankle joints were adjusted to 90 degrees. To record EMG activity, pairs of surface electrodes were placed over the belly of both the right and left tibialis anterior, quadriceps, hamstring and contralateral triceps surae muscles. Two experimental paradigms were used, A and B. In A the subject was asked to sustain maximum voluntary contraction (MVC) of the ankle dorsiflexors until the force decreased to 50% of the initial value; in B the subject was asked to carry out contractions of the ankle dorsiflexors for 6 seconds followed by 4 sec relaxation periods. The initial contraction was 20% of MVC followed by 40, 60, 80 and 100% of MVC which represented one cycle. The subject was asked to repeat this cycle 10 times. Voluntary contraction of ankle dorsiflexors was regularly accompanied by activation of other muscles, usually first in the same leg, later in the contralateral leg during MVC of ankle dorsiflexors. When intermittent contractions with step wise increments of force developed by the ankle dorsiflexors were carried out, co-activation of ipsilateral and contralateral muscle groups occurred before the force of the contracting muscles decreased.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Neurophysiological assessment of spinal cord and head injury

Selected neurophysiologic studies can supplement clinical examination in assessing residual motor function after spinal cord or head injury. The ability of polyelectromyographic recording to detect subclinical suprasegmental control is illustrated in paraplegic patients after spinal cord injury. Excitatory or inhibitory modulation of segmental motor activity in a subpopulation of patients with clinically complete motor paralysis suggests residual connection across the lesion. This observation is consistent with the pathologic finding that complete transection of the spinal cord is rare after spinal cord injury. A preliminary study of motor-evoked potentials also indicates their potential value as an objective measure of the functional status of descending pathways. Neurophysiological assessment of subclinical residual motor function may be useful in understanding the role of suprasegmental input in the manifestation of spasticity, in objectively documenting recovery of function after injury, and may aid in the development of more specific restorative measures. Our limited experience in head-injured patients also suggests the potential usefulness of these tools in supplementing clinical evaluation.

General rehabilitation, complications and evaluation

Review of the literature regarding general aspects of neurological rehabilitation reveals three areas of professional and scientific advances. The first focuses on the importance of education in rehabilitation medicine and the assessment of factors contributing to the outcome of neurological rehabilitation programs. The second area represents the developing practice of interventional restorative neurology within neurorehabilitation programs. The third is centered on increased awareness of the practical value of new achievements in the neurosciences, especially with respect to recovery processes after injury to the nervous system.

Muscle fatigue in some neurological disorders

Fatigue of tibialis anterior (TA) was induced by repetitive electrical stimulation. Using this test, patients with upper motor neuron muscle weakness owing to multiple sclerosis (MS) and injuries to the spinal cord showed greater fatigability of their TA muscles, suggesting that the muscle fiber population changed toward that typical of fatigable motor units. During repetitive stimulation, in addition to the decrement in tension there was an increase in half-relaxation time of tetanic contractions at 40 Hz in both subjects and patients. The increase in half relaxation during repeated activity was greater in patients with MS and spinal cord injury than in healthy subjects, suggesting that the long-term inactivity affected the efficiency of the Ca2+ uptake mechanism of their muscle fibers. Thus long-term inactivity of patients with upper motoneuron dysfunction leads to increased fatigability of their muscles and exaggerates the slowing of muscle relaxation after prolonged exercise.

Spinal cord evoked injury potentials in patients with acute spinal cord injury

Six patients were examined in the acute stage of spinal cord injury, between 11 h and 12 days posttrauma. Quadripolar epidural electrodes were positioned either percutaneously using a Tuohy needle or directly into the epidural space during surgical intervention. These electrodes were combined with a common reference to obtain monopolar recordings of spinal cord evoked potentials resulting from either median nerve stimulation at the wrist or tibial nerve stimulation at the popliteal fossa. Spinal cord evoked injury potentials (SCEIPs), stationary potentials with positive polarity on the distal aspect of the lesion and negative polarity on the proximal aspect, were recorded in all cases. The average amplitude (n = 3) of the SCEIP resulting from tibial nerve stimulation as measured across the lesion was 13.5 microV with an average duration of 12.7 msec. For median nerve stimulation, the average amplitude (n = 3) of the SCEIP was 16.3 microV with an average duration of 6.7 msec. There was a change in polarity in all cases over a distance of less than 6 mm, the distance between the electrode contacts on the epidural electrode. In one case, recordings were performed initially at 11 h and repeated at 21 days posttrauma. In the latter recording, the SCEIP was still present but was five times smaller in amplitude. Coincidentally, the patient also showed clinical signs of improvement in sensory and motor spinal cord function. This study demonstrates the feasibility of recording the SCEIP in patients with acute spinal cord injury, describes the features of these SCEIPs, discusses their origins, and explores the utility of recording the SCEIP as an aid in determining the severity of the injury as well as a means of monitoring changes in spinal cord function.