Cost-consequence analysis of a hemostatic matrix alone or in combination for spine surgery patients

BACKGROUND

A five-year retrospective database analysis comparing the use of Floseal ¹ flowable topical hemostat alone (F) and in combination with gelatin/thrombin (F + G/T) to achieve hemostasis and control surgical bleeding showed higher resource utilization for F + G/T cases relative to F matched pairs during spinal surgery. Lower resource use in the F group was characterized by shorter hospital length of stay and surgical time as well as fewer blood transfusions and less hemostat agent used per surgery.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the cost-consequence of using F compared to F + G/T in minor, major and severe spinal surgery from the US hospital perspective.

METHODS

A cost-consequence model was developed using the US hospital perspective. Model inputs include clinical inputs from the literature, cost inputs (hemostatic matrices, blood product transfusion, hospital stay and operating room time) from the literature, and an analysis of annual spine surgery volume (minor, major and severe) using the 2012 National Inpatient Sample (NIS) database. Costs are reported in 2017 US dollars. One-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses address sources of variability in the results.

RESULTS

A medium-volume hospital (130 spine surgeries per year) using F versus F + G/T for spine surgeries is expected to require 85 less hours of surgical time, 58 fewer hospital days and 7 fewer blood transfusions in addition to hemostat volume savings (F: 1 mL, thrombin: 1994 mL). The cost savings associated with the hospital resources for a medium-volume hospital are expected to be $317,959 (surgical hours = $154,746, hospital days = $125,237, blood transfusions = $19,023, hemostatic agents = $18,953) or $2445 per spine surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of F versus F + G/T could lead to annual cost savings for US hospitals performing a low to high volume of spinal surgeries per year.

Treatment patterns and healthcare resource utilization and costs in heavy menstrual bleeding: a Japanese claims database analysis

AIMS

Heavy menstrual bleeding (HMB) is a highly prevalent condition, characterized by excessive menstrual blood loss and cramping, that interferes with activities of daily life. The aim of this study was to investigate treatment patterns in HMB in Japan, and to assess healthcare resource utilization and costs among women newly-diagnosed with the condition.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study retrospectively analyzed health insurance data available in the Japan Medical Data Center (JMDC) database on women aged 18-49 years who were newly-diagnosed with primary or secondary HMB. Treatment patterns were analyzed, and healthcare utilization and costs were evaluated and compared to matched controls.

RESULTS

The study included a total of 635 patients, 210 with primary HMB and 425 with secondary HMB. In the primary HMB cohort, 60.0% of patients received one or more pharmacological or surgical treatments, compared with 76.2% in the secondary HMB cohort. The most commonly prescribed medications in all patients were hemostatic agents (28.7%), traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) (12.1%), and low-dose estrogen progestins (LEPs) (10.1%). After adjustment for patient baseline characteristics, healthcare costs were 1.93-times higher in primary HMB cases (p < .0001) and 4.44-times higher in secondary HMB cases (p < .0001) vs healthy controls. Outpatient care was the main cost driver.

LIMITATIONS

The main limitations of this study are related to its retrospective nature, and the fact that only reimbursed medications were captured in the source database.

CONCLUSIONS

A substantial proportion of HMB patients did not receive the recommended treatments. Healthcare costs were considerably increased in the presence of an HMB diagnosis.

Use of a Sprayed Fibrin Hemostatic Sealant after Laser Therapy for Hereditary Hemorrhagic Telangiectasia Epistaxis

Background

Hereditary hemorrhagic telangiectasia (HHT) is a relatively common autosomal dominant condition. Epistaxis is a frequent manifestation, often occurring daily and requiring iron and blood transfusions. Surgery often is bloody and difficult. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of a sprayed fibrin, hemostatic sealant in preventing postoperative epistaxis after laser treatment of nasal mucosa in HHT. Fibrin sealant was compared with nasal packing for likelihood of postoperative epistaxis and financial impact including material costs and hospitalization fees.

Methods

Retrospective review was performed of 64 individual laser treatments for epistaxis in HHT patients at the University of California, San Diego, Medical Center between 2002 and 2005. Nasal packing was used in 30 procedures and fibrin sealant was used in 34 procedures.

Results

Six of 30 (20%) procedures using postoperative nasal packing required admission with an average hospital expense of $5914. One of 34 patients (3%) in the fibrin sealant group required hospitalization (p = 0.04).

Conclusion

Aerosolized fibrin sealant prevents postoperative epistaxis after nasal laser treatment in HHT patients. Compared with traditional nasal packing we found improved patient comfort and recovery with substantial cost savings.

Cost-effectiveness analysis of a sealing hemostat patch (HEMOPATCH) vs standard of care in cardiac surgery

BACKGROUND

A recent randomized controlled trial showed that patients undergoing ascending aorta surgery treated with HEMOPATCH to control bleeding had a significantly better hemostasis success rate than with dry or wet gauze compression or similar standard of care (SOC).

OBJECTIVE

To compare the cost-effectiveness using two different agents for hemostasis (HEMOPATCH vs dry or wet gauze compression or similar SOC) in cardiac surgery from the European hospital perspective.

METHODS

A literature-based cost-effectiveness model estimating average cost per successful hemostasis event was developed based on the hemostasis efficacy difference (HEMOPATCH = 97.6%, SOC = 65.8%, p < .001). Additional clinically significant end-points studied in the trial (blood transfusions and surgical revisions) were also analyzed. It was assumed that each surgery utilized two units of HEMOPATCH (dimensions of 4.5 × 9 cm) and two units of SOC. Product acquisition costs for HEMOPATCH and SOC were included along with outcome-related costs derived from the literature and inflation-adjusted to 2017 EUR and GBP. Results are presented for an average hospital with an annual case load of 574 cardiac surgeries. One-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed.

RESULTS

Considering only product acquisition cost, HEMOPATCH had an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of €1,659, €1,519, €1,623, and £1,725 per hemostasis success when compared to SOC for Italy, Spain, France, and the UK, respectively. However, when considering the cost and potential difference in the frequency of transfusions and revisions compared to SOC, the use of HEMOPATCH was associated with an annual reduction of six revisions and 60 transfusions, improving the ICER to €1,440, €1,222, €1,461, and £1,592, respectively. Sensitivity analysis demonstrated model robustness.

CONCLUSIONS

This analysis supports the use of HEMOPATCH over SOC in cardiac surgery in European hospitals to improve hemostasis success rates and potential cost offsets from reduced transfusions, complications, and surgical revisions.

Cost-consequence analysis of different active flowable hemostatic matrices in cardiac surgical procedures

BACKGROUND

A recent retrospective comparative effectiveness study found that use of the FLOSEAL Hemostatic Matrix in cardiac surgery was associated with significantly lower risks of complications, blood transfusions, surgical revisions, and shorter length of surgery than use of SURGIFLO Hemostatic Matrix. These outcome improvements in cardiac surgery procedures may translate to economic savings for hospitals and payers.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to estimate the cost-consequence of two flowable hemostatic matrices (FLOSEAL or SURGIFLO) in cardiac surgeries for US hospitals.

METHODS

A cost-consequence model was constructed using clinical outcomes from a previously published retrospective comparative effectiveness study of FLOSEAL vs SURGIFLO in adult cardiac surgeries. The model accounted for the reported differences between these products in length of surgery, rates of major and minor complications, surgical revisions, and blood product transfusions. Costs were derived from Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project's National Inpatient Sample (NIS) 2012 database and converted to 2015 US dollars. Savings were modeled for a hospital performing 245 cardiac surgeries annually, as identified as the average for hospitals in the NIS dataset. One-way sensitivity analysis and probabilistic sensitivity analysis were performed to test model robustness.

RESULTS

The results suggest that if FLOSEAL is utilized in a hospital that performs 245 mixed cardiac surgery procedures annually, 11 major complications, 31 minor complications, nine surgical revisions, 79 blood product transfusions, and 260.3 h of cumulative operating time could be avoided. These improved outcomes correspond to a net annualized saving of $1,532,896. Cost savings remained consistent between $1.3m and $1.8m and between $911k and $2.4m, even after accounting for the uncertainty around clinical and cost inputs, in a one-way and probabilistic sensitivity analysis, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Outcome differences associated with FLOSEAL vs SURGIFLO that were previously reported in a comparative effectiveness study may result in substantial cost savings for US hospitals.

Cost-consequence analysis of two different active flowable hemostatic matrices in spine surgery patients

OBJECTIVES

A recently published retrospective analysis comparing two different active flowable hemostatic matrices (FLOSEAL and SURGIFLO Kit with Thrombin) showed significantly increased resource use and complications (surgery time, risk of blood product transfusion, and amount of matrix used) with SURGIFLO use compared to FLOSEAL in major spine surgery, and also significantly increased surgical time with SURGIFLO use in severe spine surgery. This analysis was developed as a follow-up to this prior analysis, to evaluate the cost-consequence of using FLOSEAL vs SURGIFLO in major and severe spine surgery.

METHODS

A cost consequence model was constructed from a US hospital provider perspective. Model parameters combined clinical inputs from the published retrospective analysis with supplemental analyses on annual spine surgery volume using the 2012 National Inpatient Sample (NIS) database. Cost of hemostatic matrices, blood product transfusion, and operating room time were identified from published literature. Various one-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed.

RESULTS

The base case for a medium volume hospital showed that, compared to SURGIFLO, patients receiving FLOSEAL required three fewer blood product transfusions and saved 27 h of OR time, resulting in annual savings of $151 per major and $574 per severe spine surgery. Additional scenarios for high and low volume hospitals supported cost savings in the base case. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis revealed FLOSEAL was cost-saving in 76% of simulations in major spine and 97% of iterations in severe spine surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

This economic analysis indicates that use of FLOSEAL instead of SURGIFLO hemostatic matrices to induce hemostasis in both major and severe spine surgery could potentially lead to sizable cost savings in US hospitals, regardless of spinal surgery case-mix.

Healthcare resource utilization in patients receiving idarucizumab for reversal of dabigatran anticoagulation due to major bleeding, urgent surgery, or procedural interventions: interim results from the RE-VERSE AD™ study

AIMS

Patients treated with anticoagulants may experience serious bleeding or require urgent surgery or intervention, and may benefit from rapid anticoagulant reversal. This exploratory analysis assessed healthcare resource utilization (HCRU) in patients treated with idarucizumab, a specific reversal agent for dabigatran etexilate.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

RE-VERSE AD™ (NCT02104947), a prospective, multi-center open-label study, is evaluating idarucizumab for dabigatran reversal in patients with serious bleeding (Group A) or undergoing emergency surgery/procedures (Group B). HCRU outcome measures evaluated in the first 90 patients enrolled were use of blood products and pro-hemostatic agents, length of stay (LOS) in hospital, and LOS in intensive care unit (ICU).

RESULTS

Blood products or pro-hemostatic agents were given to 63% (32/51) of patients in Group A and 23% (9/39) of patients in Group B on the day of/day after surgery. An overnight hospital stay was reported for 82% (42/51) of patients in Group A with median LOS = 7 (range = 1-71) bed-days. For Group B, 92% (36/39) had an overnight hospital stay with a median LOS = 9 (range = 1-92) bed-days. In Group A, 17 patients were admitted to the ICU for at least 1 day with median LOS = 4 (range = 1-44) days; in Group B the number was 15 with median LOS = 2 (range = 1-92) days.

LIMITATIONS

The lack of a control group and the small patient numbers limit the strength of the conclusions.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of idarucizumab may simplify emergency management of dabigatran-treated patients with life-threatening bleeds and reduce perioperative complications in patients undergoing emergency surgery.

Treatment of heparin-induced thrombocytopenia before and after the implementation of a hemostatic and antithrombotic stewardship program

In October 2013, we implemented a hemostatic and antithrombotic (HAT) stewardship program with the primary focus of ensuring appropriate use of intravenous direct thrombin inhibitors (DTI) in patients with heparin-induced thrombocytopenia (HIT). We sought to compare the duration and cost of DTI therapy for the management of HIT before and after implementation of the HAT stewardship program. Following institutional review board approval, we conducted a single center, retrospective chart review of all patients with a suspected diagnosis of HIT as assessed by an anti-heparin-PF4 enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay 6 months pre-HAT and post-HAT implementation. Patients were excluded if they were initiated on a DTI at an outside hospital, had a prior episode of HIT, or received mechanical circulatory support. Clinical characteristics, including demographics, comorbidities, medications, laboratory values, clinical and safety outcomes, length of stay, and mortality, were collected. A total of 592 patients were included; 333 patients were evaluated pre-HAT, while 259 patients were evaluated post-HAT. The mean duration of DTI treatment was significantly decreased in the post-HAT cohort (6.64 vs 5.17 days, p = 0.01), primarily driven by decreased duration of use for patients with suspected HIT (4.07 vs 2.86 days, p = 0.01). The HAT Stewardship program demonstrated a total decrease in annual costs associated with the diagnosis and management of HIT of $248,500. Our results indicate that the implementation of the HAT stewardship program had a significant impact on reducing the duration and costs of DTI therapy and the costs of laboratory evaluations in the management of HIT at our institution.

[Topical haemostatic agents in neurosurgery]

Haemostasis is of fundamental significance in neurosurgery, and insufficient control of bleeding is associated with morbidity and mortality. Topical haemostatic agents play an important role, as the characteristics of neuronal tissue limit the use of classical surgical haemostasis techniques. Appropriate choice of agent depends on the location and type of bleeding, but also on knowledge of the products' mechanisms of action, indications, price and accessibility. Biological products are superior to the mechanical in efficacy but require more preparation and are significantly more cost-intensive.

Prospective, Randomized, Controlled Trial of a Hemostatic Sealant in Children Undergoing Adenotonsillectomy

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the efficacy of Floseal as a hemostatic sealant compared to traditional electrocautery hemostasis after cold knife adenotonsillectomy.

STUDY DESIGN: Prospective, randomized, controlled trial of 68 consecutive patients undergoing cold steel adenotonsillectomy. Patients were randomized to receive either Floseal (FS) or electrocautery (EC) for hemostasis.

RESULTS: FS patients had shorter operative times than EC patients (16 min vs 31.2 min, P < 0.0001) and less blood loss (49.2 mL vs 70.8 mL, P < 0.05). Four EC patients were crossed over to Floseal when adequate hemostasis could not be achieved in the adenoid bed. No Floseal patients were crossed over. FS patients had significantly less pain on postoperative days two through 11 ( P < 0.05) and less use of narcotic pain medications over the first 10 postoperative days ( P < 0.05). FS patients also had a faster return to regular diet (5.5 days vs 7.9 days, P < 0.01) and activity (5.3 days vs 7.8 days, P < 0.01) as compared to the EC patients. There were no significant complications in either group.

CONCLUSIONS: Floseal is safe and efficacious, and decreases postoperative morbidity as compared to electrocautery hemostasis after cold steel adenotonsillectomy.

SIGNIFICANCE: This study demonstrates the safety and efficacy of Floseal as a hemostatic method in children undergoing adenotonsillectomy.

Prospective, Randomized, Controlled Clinical Trial of a Novel Matrix Hemostatic Sealant in Children Undergoing Adenoidectomy

PROBLEM ADDRESSED: Floseal is a novel matrix hemostatic sealant composed of collagen-derived particles and topical bovine-derived thrombin. It is applied as a high-viscosity gel for hemostasis and has been clinically proven to control bleeding. This study is a prospective, randomized, controlled clinical trial of Floseal sealant compared to traditional suction cautery hemostasis in children undergoing adenoidectomy.

METHODS AND MEASURES: Seventy patients (mean age 7.0 yrs, 45.7% male) with obstructive sleep apnea underwent traditional cold steel adenoidectomy with an adenoid curette and were then randomized to receive the hemostatic sealant (Floseal) or cautery to obtain hemostasis. Patients were crossed over to the other hemostatic technique if hemostasis was not achieved after more than 100 mL of blood loss or 15 minutes elapsed time. Objective data collected included time to hemostasis and blood loss during hemostasis. Visual analog scales (VAS) were used to record subjective data by the operating surgeon including bleeding following adenoid pack removal (0 = none, 3 = brisk) and ease of operation (1 = extremely easy, 6 = extremely difficult). Parents recorded diet on a journal and were contacted by phone at postoperative day 7 and questioned with regard to return to regular diet and use of narcotics.

RESULTS: Compared to patients in the cautery group (n = 35), Floseal patients (n = 35) had significantly shorter times to hemostasis (0.6 ± 1.3 minutes vs 9.5 ± 5.4 minutes (mean ± SD), P < 0.001), less blood loss (2.5 ± 9.2 mL vs 29.4 ± 27.1 mL, P < 0.001), less subjective bleeding (0.0 ± 0.6 vs 2.0 ± 0.7, (median 4-point VAS ± SD), P < 0.001), and subjectively easier operations (2.6 ± 1.0 vs 5.2 ± 1.0 (mean 6-point VAS ± SD), P < 0.001). Furthermore, Floseal patients returned to regular diet earlier (2.7 ± 0.7 vs 4.1 ± 0.5 days (mean ± SD), P < 0.001) and had less use of narcotics at 7 days postoperatively (40% vs 69%, P < 0.05). Lastly, three patients in the cautery group were crossed over to the Floseal group, but no Floseal subjects were crossed over to the cautery group. The retail cost of Floseal is $85. Operating room costs are estimated at $12/minute. Reducing the operative length by 8.9 minutes on average produces a cost savings of $106.80 per operation. There were no complications in either experimental group including postoperative hemorrhage, hospitalization, blood transfusion, or aspiration.

CONCLUSIONS: Floseal matrix hemostatic sealant is a safe, efficacious, easy, and cost-effective technique for obtaining hemostasis in children undergoing adenoidectomy. Limitations of the study include the fact that it is nonblinded, which does allow for some bias in the subjective data recorded. However, utilizing 4 different operating surgeons, 3 of whom were not affiliated with the study, minimized this.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE OF STUDY: This study demonstrates the safety and efficacy of a novel hemostatic sealant in children undergoing adenoidectomy. Floseal matrix hemostatic sealant can be used as a first-line hemostatic agent, and it is a good tool in the armamentarium of otolaryngologists who encounter significant bleeding following adenoidectomy.

Reduction in hospital costs and resource consumption associated with the use of advanced topical hemostats during inpatient procedures

OBJECTIVE

The use of hemostatic agents has increased over time for all surgical procedures. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the newer topical absorbable hemostat products Surgicel * Fibrillar † and Surgicel SNoW ‡ (Surgicel advanced products, abbreviated as SAPs) compared to the older product Surgicel Original (SO) with respect to healthcare resource use and costs in procedures where these hemostats are most commonly used.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

A retrospective analysis of the Premier hospital database was used to identify adults who underwent brain/cerebral (BC), cardiovascular (CV: valve surgery and coronary artery bypass graft) and carotid endarterectomy (CEA) between January 2011-December 2012. Among these patients, those treated with SAPs were compared to those treated with SO. Propensity score matching (PSM) was used to create comparable groups to evaluate differences between SAPs and SO.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary end-points for this study were length of stay (LOS), all-cause total cost, number of intensive care unit (ICU) days, ICU cost, transfusion costs and units, and SO/SAP product units per discharge.

RESULTS

Matched PSM created patient cohorts for SO and SAPs were created for BC (n = 758 for both groups), CV (n = 3388 for both groups), and CEA (n = 2041 for both groups) procedures. Patients that received SAPs had a 14-16% lower mean LOS for each procedure compared to SO, as well as 12-18% lower total mean cost per discharge for each procedure (p < 0.02 for all results). Mean ICU costs for SAPs were also lower, with a reduction of 20% for BC and 19% for CV compared to SO (p < 0.01). However, for CEA, there was no statistically significant difference in ICU costs for SAPs compared to SO.

CONCLUSIONS

In a retrospective hospital database analysis, the use of SAPs were associated with lower healthcare resource utilization and costs compared to SO.

[Medical and economic impact of a haemostatic sealant on the rate of transfusion after total knee arthroplasty]

OBJECTIVES

Blood loss reduction in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) contributes to the prevention of morbidity and mortality and in the management of health care costs. Fibrin haemostatic sealant have controversial effectiveness in reducing postoperative blood loss and transfusion requirements. Our study evaluated the medical and economic benefits of this treatment with the assumption that it decreases the frequency of blood transfusion after TKA.

METHODS AND PATIENTS

Our single-center and randomized study included 60 patients pose unilateral primary TKA for osteoarthritis. Distribution was done in 2 groups of 30 patients each. Group 1 patients treated with a dose of 5 mL Evicel®, compared to untreated group 2. Were collected the number of patients transfused. The treatment cost was compared to the sealant cost.

RESULTS

Results are not statistically significant. Two patients were transfused in group 1 and 3 in group 2 (P=0.64). The treatment cost for 30 patients is 13,500 €, for a savings of cells packed at 187 €, an additional cost of 13,313 € in group 1.

CONCLUSION

The use of fibrin haemostatic sealant in TKA did not induce a significant difference in terms of blood or transfusion savings, with a significant cost. We do not recommend its routine use in TKA.

Similar patient outcomes yet different hospital costs between flowable hemostatic agents

INTRODUCTION

SURGIFLO and FLOSEAL are absorbable gelatin-based products that form hemostatic matrices. These products are indicated as adjuncts to hemostasis when control of bleeding by conventional surgical techniques (such as suture, ligature or cautery) is ineffective or impractical. This study analyzed the effect of surgery time and the choice of product on cost to the hospital and patient outcomes.

METHODS

The data source was the Premier Hospital database from January 1, 2010-June 30, 2012. Eligible patients were ≥18 years of age with a spinal fusion or refusion surgery with either SURGIFLO (Ethicon Inc.) or FLOSEAL (Baxter International Inc.). The hospital Charge Master was used to identify the amount of flowable product, whether it included Thrombin, and the cost. Multivariable models were performed on overall cost and likelihood of surgical complications. All models were adjusted for patient demographics and severity as well as hospital, and surgical characteristics.

RESULTS

A total of 24,882 patient records from 121 hospitals were analysed, which included 15,088 FLOSEAL records and 9794 SURGIFLO records, with 1498 SURGIFLO with Thrombin patients. Little or no differences in surgical complications were found between surgeries with SURGIFLO vs. surgery with FLOSEAL. Regression models showed a reduction in cost of $65 associated with use of SURGIFLO with Thrombin and an additional $21 reduction in hospital cost for each additional hour of surgery. Modeling which accounts for hospital fixed effects suggest that, in addition to a gap of ∼$300 favoring SURGIFLO with Thrombin, every additional hour of surgery was associated with an additional reduction in hospital costs of ∼$26.

CONCLUSIONS

While the choice of flowable product had no effect on clinical outcomes, use of SURGIFLO was associated with hospital cost savings for flowable product. These savings increased with the length of surgery, even when controlling for the amount of flowable product (mL) used.

Hospital economic impact from hemostatic matrix usage in cardiac surgery

OBJECTIVE

Improved health outcomes can result in economic savings for hospitals and payers. While effectiveness of topical hemostatic agents in cardiac surgery has been demonstrated, evaluations of their economic benefit are limited. This study quantifies the cost consequences to hospitals, based on clinical outcomes, from using a flowable hemostatic matrix vs non-flowable topical hemostatic agents in cardiac surgery.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

Applying clinical outcomes from a prospective randomized clinical trial, a cost consequence framework was utilized to model the economic impact of comparator groups. From that study, clinical outcomes were obtained and analyzed for a flowable hemostatic matrix (FLOSEAL, Baxter Healthcare Corporation) vs non-flowable topical hemostats (SURGICEL Nu-Knit, Ethicon-Johnson & Johnson; GELFOAM, Pfizer). Costing analyses focused on the following outcomes: complications, blood transfusions, surgical revisions, and operating room (OR) time. Cardiac surgery costs were analyzed and expressed in 2012 US dollars based on available literature searches and US data. Comparator group variability in cost consequences (i.e., cost savings) was calculated based on annualized impact and scenario testing.

RESULTS

RESULTS suggest that if a flowable hemostatic matrix (rather than a non-flowable hemostat) was utilized exclusively in 600 mixed cardiac surgeries annually, a hospital could improve patient outcomes by a reduction of 33 major complications, 76 minor complications, 54 surgical revisions, 194 transfusions, and 242 h of OR time. These outcomes correspond to a net annualized cost consequence savings of $5.38 million, with complication avoidance as the largest contributor.

CONCLUSIONS

This cost consequence framework and supportive modeling was used to evaluate the hospital economic impact of outcomes resulting from the usage of various hemostatic agents. These analyses support that cost savings can be achieved from routine use of a flowable hemostatic matrix, rather than a non-flowable topical hemostat, in cardiac surgery.

The use fibrinogen/thrombin-coated equine collagen patch in children requiring reoperations for congenital heart disease. A single center clinical experience

AIM

The aim of this study was to evaluate the efficacy and cost-effectiveness of fibrinogen/thrombin-coated collagen patch (FTCCP)(TachoSil®) during intraoperative hemostasis in patients with congenital heart disease, who required a reoperation during childhood.

METHODS

We reviewed data on the intraoperative blood product requirements and hospital costs of children (age <16 years) who underwent a reoperation for treating their congenital heart disease between January 2009 and December 2011.

RESULTS

One-hundred and seventeen patients were included. Median age at surgery was 2.1 years (range 3 days-14.1 years). Main causes of intraoperative bleeding were: 1) reinforcement of suture lines (106 patients, 90.6%); 2) lung lesions (5 patients, 4.2%); 3) epicardial lesions (3 patients, 2.6%); and 4) chest wall lesions (3 patients, 2.6%). At logistic regression the amount of packed red blood cells (PRBC) requirement was significantly higher in patients with preoperative cyanosis (P=0.008, OR=3.85) and in patients who required the use of cardiopulmonary bypass (P=0.005, OR=21.19). The use of FTCCP (N.=90 patients) as first line treatment was significantly associated with a lower PRBC requirement (P=0.0003, OR=0.1) which in addition to the avoidance of other hemostatic/sealant agents, leads to lower hospital cost.

CONCLUSION

FTCCP is an effective hemostatic agent which can be safely used during the hemostasis of children requiring reoperations for their congenital heart malformations. When used as first line treatment, with specific indications, FTCCP limited the intraoperative PRBC requirement and the use of other hemostatic/sealant agents thus reducing hospital costs.

Achieving hemostasis with topical hemostats: making clinically and economically appropriate decisions in the surgical and trauma settings

Achieving hemostasis is a crucial focus of clinicians working in surgical and trauma settings. Topical hemostatic agents-including mechanical hemostats, active hemostats, flowable hemostats, and fibrin sealants-are frequently used in efforts to control bleeding, and new options such as hemostatic dressings, initially used in combat situations, are increasingly being used in civilian settings. To achieve successful hemostasis, a number of vital factors must be considered by surgeons and perioperative nurses, such as the size of the wound; bleeding severity; and the efficacy, possible adverse effects, and method of application of potential hemostatic agents. Understanding how and when to use each of the available hemostatic agents can greatly affect clinical outcomes and help to limit the overall cost of treatment.

Successful management of bleeding after dental procedures with application of blood stopper: a single center prospective trial

AIM

Ankaferd Blood Stopper (ABS), as an herbal complementary medicine, has been approved for the management of clinical hemorrhages in Turkey, including dental interventions. Basic, preclinical and clinical studies disclosed the settings of the topical hemostatic use of ABS. The aim of this study is therefore to assess the efficacy and safety of ABS as an antihemorrhagic agent in the bleedings associated with dental procedures in patients with normal and impaired hemostasis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

ABS has been topically applied by homogeneously spraying to the 113 patients during dental interventions within its on-label indications. A median of 0.5 ml (IQR:0.5-1 ml) ABS was administered after tooth extraction with prolonged hemorrhages.

RESULTS

After the administration, bleeding stopped in less than 10 seconds in 59 (52.2%) patients, and below 22.5 seconds (IQR: 18, 8-30) in 54 patients (47.8%). A total of 141 procedures were performed in these 113 patients, and nearly 72.5 ml ABS was used with a total cost of 98 €.

CONCLUSION

ABS as a new herbal medicine was found to be an effective method for controlling bleeding related to dental procedures. No patient had wound infection and the healing process appeared to be normal. Topical ABS could be useful for the local hemostasis and wound healing in periodontal surgeries.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

In this prospective study ABS, for the first time, has demonstrated its potential for being an effective hemostatic agent for the management of bleedings due to dental procedures.

Randomized study of aprotinin effect on transfusions and blood loss in primary THA

A projected increase in total hip arthroplasties, shortfalls in blood availability, and awareness of complications of transfusion make blood management in orthopaedic surgery important. In a multicenter, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study, we hypothesized use of aprotinin would reduce blood transfusions (any and allogeneic) and blood loss in total hip arthroplasty. Using an intent-to-treat approach, we recruited 393 patients stratified by preoperative autologous blood donation or none and then randomized them to receive aprotinin (176 patients receiving a 10,000 kallikrein inhibitor units [KIU] test dose, 2 million KIU load, 0.5 million KIU per hour) or placebo (177 patients). We assessed patients at baseline; postoperative days 1, 2, 3, and 7 (or discharge); and 6 +/- 2 weeks. Primary efficacy was percentage of patients having blood transfusion through day 7 or discharge. We based safety on reported adverse events. Aprotinin reduced transfusions by 46% (30 of 176 versus 56 of 177 patients). Aprotinin reduced the total number of any blood units and the number of allogeneic blood units transfused relative to placebo (48 versus 109 units and 30 versus 72 units, respectively). Serious complications were similar in the two groups (placebo, 11%; aprotinin, 10%). Our data suggest full-dose aprotinin is safe and effective in decreasing blood transfusion in total hip arthroplasty.

Evaluation of Autologous Platelet-Poor Plasma Gel as a Hemostatic Adjunct After Posterior Iliac Crest Bone Harvest

PURPOSE

To evaluate the hemostatic efficacy of autologous platelet-poor plasma (PPP) gel following posterior iliac crest bone graft harvesting for oral and maxillofacial reconstruction.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This was a prospective study of 24 consecutive patients involving 26 posterior iliac crest bone harvests that had bone wax and either 1-gram of bovine microfibrillar collagen or 20 mL of autologous PPP, activated as a gel, used as adjunct hemostatic agents. Compression bulb suction drain was placed into the graft site and drain output recorded every 8 hours for 64 hours. Cost analysis was also undertaken between the 2 methods. Statistical significance between means of each group was determined by Student's t test and found significant for P < .05.

RESULTS

There were no statistically significant differences in average drain output between the PPP and MFC groups for each 8-hour interval. There was no statically significant difference in average total drain output between the PPP and MFC groups over the entire 64 hour period. Additionally, unlike the addition of MFC, the addition of PPP added no additional costs to the procedure.

CONCLUSION

PPP gel, when compared with bovine microfibrillar collagen, is an effective and inexpensive adjunct in hemostasis following posterior iliac crest bone harvest.

Acute plateletpheresis and aprotinin reduces the need for blood transfusion following Ross operation

The effect of acute intraoperative plateletpheresis (25% platelet yield) in combination with intraoperative low-dose aprotinin (2 million units) on blood conservation was investigated in 18 young adult patients undergoing elective Ross operation. The results were compared with a group of 19 similar patients without plateletpheresis (control group). The hematological and coagulation parameters at admission and discharge were statistically similar in both groups. The total blood product transfusion requirements were significantly reduced in the plateletpheresis group compared with the control group (3.2 units and 5.1 units, respectively, P=0.036). The total blood donor exposure was also reduced significantly in the plateletpheresis group compared with the control group (3.2 and 6.9 donors/patient, respectively, P<0.001). The direct costs for the hospital for the plateletpheresis procedure, including costs for all blood products, were similar to those for blood products alone in the control group. In summary, acute plateletpheresis in combination with low-dose aprotinin significantly reduces the blood product transfusions and blood donor exposures following the Ross operation; the treatment is cost-effective.

Cost-effectiveness of cell salvage and alternative methods of minimising perioperative allogeneic blood transfusion: a systematic review and economic model

OBJECTIVES

To compare patient outcomes, resource use and costs to the NHS and NHS Blood Transfusion Authority (BTA) associated with cell salvage and alternative methods of minimising perioperative allogeneic blood transfusion.

DATA SOURCES

Electronic databases covering the period 1996-2004 for systematic reviews and 1994-2004 for economic evidence.

REVIEW METHODS

Existing systematic reviews were updated with data from selected randomised controlled trials (RCTs) that involved adults scheduled for elective non-urgent surgery. Any resource use or cost data were extracted for potential use in populating an economic model. Relative risks or weighted mean difference of each outcome for each intervention were assessed, taking into account the number of RCTs included in each outcome and intervention and the presence of any heterogeneity. This allowed indirect comparison of the relative effectiveness of each intervention when the intervention is compared with allogeneic blood transfusion. A decision analytic model synthesised clinical and economic data from several sources, to estimate the relative cost-effectiveness of cell salvage for people undergoing elective surgery with moderate to major expected blood loss. The perspective of the NHS and patients and a time horizon of 1 month were used. The economic model was developed from reviews of effectiveness and cost-effectiveness and clinical experts. Secondary analysis explored the robustness of the results to changes in the timing and costs of cell salvage equipment, surgical procedure, use of transfusion protocols and time horizon of analysis.

RESULTS

Overall, 668 studies were identified electronically for the update of the two systematic reviews. This included five RCTs, of which two were cell salvage and three preoperative autologous donation (PAD). Five published systematic reviews were identified for antifibrinolytics, fibrin sealants and restrictive transfusion triggers, PAD plus erythropoietin, erythropoietin alone and acute normovolaemic haemodilution (ANH). Twelve published studies reported full economic evaluations. All but two of the transfusion strategies significantly reduced exposure to allogeneic blood. The relative risk of exposure to allogeneic blood was 0.59 for the pooled trials of cell salvage (95% confidence interval: 0.48 to 0.73). This varied by the type and timing of cell salvage and type of surgical procedure. For cell salvage, the relative risk of allogeneic blood transfusion was higher in cardiac surgery than in orthopaedic surgery. Cell salvage had lower costs and slightly higher quality-adjusted life years compared with all of the alternative transfusion strategies except ANH. The likelihood that cell salvage is cost-effective compared with strategies other than ANH is over 50%. Most of the secondary analyses indicated similar results to the primary analysis. However, the primary and secondary analyses indicated that ANH may be more cost-effective than cell salvage.

CONCLUSIONS

The available evidence indicates that cell salvage may be a cost-effective method to reduce exposure to allogeneic blood transfusion. However, ANH may be more cost-effective than cell salvage. The results of this analysis are subject to the low quality and reliability of the data used and the use of indirect comparisons. This may affect the reliability and robustness of the clinical and economic results. There is a need for further research that includes adequately powered high-quality RCTs to compare directly various blood transfusion strategies. These should include measures of health status, health-related quality of life and patient preferences for alternative transfusion strategies. Observational and tracking studies are needed to estimate reliably the incidence of adverse events and infections transmitted during blood transfusion and to identify the lifetime consequences of the serious hazards of transfusion on mortality, health status and health-related quality of life.

The safety and efficacy of the use of vasopressin in sepsis and septic shock

Sepsis remains a significant problem and cause of morbidity and mortality in intensive care. Vasopressin infusions are currently used as rescue therapy for the treatment of vasodilatory, catecholamine-resistant septic shock. At present, there are no large randomised, controlled trials in the literature investigating vasopressin in this role, although two such studies are currently ongoing in Canada. This review outlines the pathophysiology of sepsis and that of vasopressin in sepsis and reviews the available evidence for the use of vasopressin in sepsis and septic shock. A review of the safety data for vasopressin in this indication is included. Recommendations for the use of vasopressin in septic shock, along with suggestions for the direction of further work in the field are presented.

Recombinant activated factor VII for bleeding in patients without inherited bleeding disorders

(1) Recombinant activated factor VII (rFVIIa) is licensed in Canada for the prevention and treatment of bleeding in hemophiliacs, but it is increasingly used to control bleeding in non-hemophilic patients during surgery, or during treatment for severe trauma or intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH). (2) In one clinical trial, there was a significant reduction in mortality among patients with ICH treated with rFVIIa. In another trial, administration of rFVIIa significantly reduced the number of trauma patients needing massive blood transfusions although there was no significant difference in mortality. (3) Adequately powered randomized controlled trials are needed to clarify the efficacy and safety of rFVIIa for non-bleeding disorder indications. Phase III trials in ICH and trauma are underway. (4) There is potential for non-hemophilic use, particularly if clinical efficacy and cost effectiveness are established.

Pharmacoeconomic analysis of recombinant factor VIIa versus APCC in the treatment of minor-to-moderate bleeds in hemophilia patients with inhibitors

OBJECTIVE

To compare the cost-effectiveness of three treatment regimens using recombinant activated Factor VII (rFVIIa), NovoSeven, and activated prothrombin-complex concentrate (APCC), FEIBA VH, for home treatment of minor-to-moderate bleeds in hemophilia patients with inhibitors.

METHODS

A literature-based, decision-analytic model was developed to compare three treatment regimens. The regimens consisting of first-, second-, and third-line treatments were: rFVIIa-rFVIIa-rFVIIa; APCC-rFVIIa-rFVIIa; and APCC-APCC-rFVIIa. Patients not responding to first-line treatment were administered second-line treatment, and those failing second-line received third-line treatment. Using literature and expert opinion, the model structure and base-case inputs were adapted to the US from a previously published analysis. The percentage of evaluable bleeds controlled with rFVIIa and APCC were obtained from published literature. Drug costs (2005 US$) based on average wholesale price were included in the base-case model. Univariate and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (second-order Monte Carlo simulation) were conducted by varying the efficacy, re-bleeding rates, patient weight, and dosing to ascertain robustness of the model.

RESULTS

In the base-case analysis, the average cost per resolved bleed using rFVIIa as first-, second-, and third-line treatment was $28 076. Using APCC as first-line and rFVIIa as second- and third-line treatment resulted in an average cost per resolved bleed of $30 883, whereas the regimen using APCC as first- and second-line, and rFVIIa as third-line treatment was the most expensive, with an average cost per resolved bleed of $32 150. Cost offsets occurred for the rFVIIa-only regimen through avoidance of second and third lines of treatment. In probabilistic sensitivity analyses, the rFVIIa-only strategy was the least expensive strategy more than 68% of the time.

CONCLUSIONS

The management of minor-to-moderate bleeds extends beyond the initial line of treatment, and should include the economic impact of re-bleeding and failures over multiple lines of treatment. In the majority of cases, the rFVIIa-only regimen appears to be a less expensive treatment option in inhibitor patients with minor-to-moderate bleeds over three lines of treatment.

Recombinant factor VIIa as an adjunctive therapy for patients requiring large volume transfusion: a pharmacoeconomic evaluation

BACKGROUND

Acute haemorrhage requiring large volume transfusion presents a costly and unpredictable risk to transfusion services. Recombinant factor VIIa (rFVIIa) (NovoSeven, Novo Nordisk, Bagsvaard, Denmark) may provide an important adjunctive haemostatic strategy for the management of patients requiring large volume blood transfusions.

AIMS

To review blood transfusion over a 12-month period and assess the major costs associated with haemorrhage management. A pharmoeconomic evaluation of rFVIIa intervention for large volume transfusion was conducted to identify the most cost-effective strategy for using this haemostatic product.

METHODS

Audit and analysis of all patients admitted to Christchurch Public Hospital requiring > 5 units of red blood cells (RBC) during a single transfusion episode. Patients were stratified into groups dependent on RBC units received and further stratified with regard to ward category. Cumulative costs were derived to compare standard treatment with an hypothesized rFVIIa intervention for each transfusion group. Sensitivity analyses were performed by varying parameters and comparing to original outcomes.

RESULTS

Comparison of costs between the standard and hypothetical model indicated no statistically significant differences between groups (P < 0.05). Univariate and multivariate sensitivity analyses indicate that intervention with rFVIIa after transfusion of 14 RBC units may be cost-effective due to conservation of blood components and reduction in duration of intensive area stay.

CONCLUSION

Intervention with rFVIIa for haemorrhage control is most cost-effective relatively early in the RBC transfusion period. Our hypothetical model indicates the optimal time point is when 14 RBC units have been transfused.

[Surgery in patients with bleeding disorders--expensive treatment for a small group of patients]

BACKGROUND

During surgical procedures, patients with bleeding disorders have a major risk of bleeding complications. To reduce the risk of bleeding it is necessary to provide pre-, peri- and postoperative antihaemorrhagic therapy. In less severe bleeding disorders, pharmacologic treatment may be sufficient, but in patients with severe bleeding disorders there is always a need for clotting factor concentrates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study includes all patients with bleeding disorders admitted to Rikshospitalet University Hospital between 1997 and 2003 for surgical procedures during which therapy with clotting factor concentrates was mandatory.

RESULTS AND INTERPRETATION

Over the study period, 135 patients underwent a total of 255 different surgical procedures. In 47% of the patients there was a causal relationship between the need for surgery and the bleeding disorder. Our results show that patients with severe bleeding disorders, including patients with inhibitors, can be treated safely provided that the patients receive adequate treatment with clotting factor concentrates. However, substitution therapy with clotting factor concentrates is very expensive. Cost related to substitution therapy is the main determinant of how many patients with severe bleeding disorders can undergo elective surgery in our hospital each year.

What is the evidence for using hemostatic agents in surgery?

The pharmacological methods used to achieve systemic hemostasis have generated much discussion due to concerns of serious adverse effects (e.g., thromboembolic complications) and costs of therapy in addition to efficacy considerations. There are a limited number of well-controlled trials involving pharmacological hemostasis for spine surgery. In the largest double-blinded randomized controlled trial to date involving spine surgery, there was a trend toward reduced homologous transfusion in patients receiving aprotinin, but the only statistically significant result ( p<0.001) was a reduction in autologous red cell donations. The findings of this trial are important, since the investigators used a number of restrictive transfusion strategies (e.g., autologous donation, low hematocrit trigger for transfusion, blood-salvaging procedures with the exception of no cell saver) that were not always employed in earlier trials involving hemostatic agents. Smaller studies involving antifibrinolytic agents other than aprotinin have demonstrated reductions in blood loss and transfusion requirements in patients undergoing spine surgery, although the results were not always statistically significant. A very large randomized trial would be required to address comparative medication- and transfusion-related adverse events; such a trial involving patients undergoing cardiac surgery is currently being performed. Additionally, cost-effectiveness analyses are needed to help define the role of these agents based on the data that is available.

Early Operative Intervention versus Conventional Treatment in Epistaxis: Randomized Prospective Trial

OBJECTIVE

This prospective randomized trial was designed to compare intranasal endoscopic sphenopalatine artery ligation (ESAL) with conventional nasal packing in the treatment of recurrent epistaxis.

METHODS

Patients were registered in the study databank following referral for epistaxis control to the otolaryngology service at the University of Alberta. All patients were initially packed using Merocel (Xomed Surgical Products, Jacksonville, FL) nasal dressings bilaterally. Patients were enrolled in the study following failure of Merocel packings. Informed consent was obtained in accordance with the Health Research Ethics Board. The patients were then managed with Vaseline nasal packs or ESAL. Patient demographics, treatment characteristics, number of hospitalization days, and rates of recurrence were recorded prospectively. The total cost of treatment for each patient was calculated.

RESULTS

Nineteen patients were enrolled in the study. There was a significant reduction in cost and length of hospitalization of the patients undergoing ESAL compared with the conventional nasal packings. ESAL was also 89% effective in controlling the bleeding and had minimal sequelae or complications. The overall calculated cost of patients undergoing ESAL was dollars 5133 compared with dollars 12213 in the conservative group, resulting in an average saving of dollars 7080 per patient. There was overwhelming patient satisfaction with ESAL compared with nasal packings.

CONCLUSION

ESAL is an excellent, well-tolerated, and cost-effective method of treating recurrent epistaxis.

[Coagulation factors and hemostatic agents]

A large variety of therapeutic agents are available to prevent or treat hemorrhagic events. An etiologic focusing is essential to permit a rational use of these drugs. Some medications are cheap, others are very expensive, and the clinician has to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of his prescription in each situation.

Economic modelling of different treatment strategies for haemophilia A with high-responding inhibitors

This paper reports a systematic review of the cost-effectiveness of treatment options in patients with haemophilia A with inhibitors. As very little relevant published evidence was identified, an economic modelling exercise was undertaken to calculate the cost-effectiveness of different strategies in the treatment of high-responding haemophilia A patients with inhibitors. A decision analysis approach was used to model the expected lifetime clinical outcomes and costs of the more common regimens currently used in UK in treating severe haemophiliacs with inhibitors. The model attempts to reflect the outcomes of clinical events, costs and life expectancy for each different treatment regimen for haemophilic boys with inhibitors who are high responders (defined as inhibitor level >/=10 BU) throughout their life. The basic model structure is centred on a Markov decision process, which was used to simulate, at quarter-yearly intervals, the movement through discrete health states and their complications. The model allows a comparison of cost-effectiveness between three immune tolerance induction (ITI) regimens (Bonn, Mälmo and Low-Dose protocols) and against a relevant 'on-demand' (OD) regimen. It also shows the cost-effectiveness of different OD regimens using different bypassing agents. The results of the economic modelling indicate that treating haemophilia A patients who have high-responding inhibitors OD with recombinant activated factor VII is cost-effective compared to treatment with activated prothrombin complex concentrates. However, when OD treatment regimens are compared with the three ITI protocols, the Malmö ITI protocol is the preferred treatment strategy, generating more quality adjusted life-years (QALYs) and less cost than either an OD regimen or the Bonn or Low-Dose ITI protocols.

A model of the direct and indirect effects of aprotinin administration on the overall costs of coronary revascularization surgery in a university teaching hospital cardiothoracic unit

BACKGROUND

Cardiac patients sometimes bleed postoperatively and consequently require rethoracotomy, necessitating a longer stay in the intensive care unit (ICU) of the cardiothoracic unit (CTU). When ICU capacity is limited, rethoracotomy necessitates postponing treatment of the next patient. Aprotinin, a bovine lung-derived proteinase inhibitor, has been shown to reduce the frequency of rethoracotomies in cardiac patients.

OBJECTIVE

This study was undertaken to quantify the reduction of potentially avoidable cost to the CTU of postoperative bleeding, both directly and indirectly, by administering aprotinin before and during coronary artery bypass graft (CABG).

METHODS

A novel, validated operational research model was developed, featuring the principal CABG-related health care resource parameters believed to influence waiting lists and times. Factors and costs were derived from both local data from a CTU and relevant recent literature.

RESULTS

According to the model, aprotinin therapy reduced the waiting list by approximately 3% by reducing the number of rethoracotomies. Using data from the literature, for an annual throughput of 431 patients who would receive aprotinin costing 97,333 pounds per year, the annual net savings to the CTU would be 46,586 pounds, which comprised direct savings on blood products of 35,036 pounds and indirect marginal savings of 11,550 pounds derived from 3.2% fewer rethoracotomies (each at a marginal cost of 837 pounds). By reason, then, reinvesting savings in increasing CTU capacity would yield further waiting-list reductions and improve patient morbidity. These results had 2 major limitations. First, it was assumed that all operations would have the same duration and all surgeons would perform operations in the same manner. Second, nonurgent patients were assumed to have been treated in order of strict referral sequence, which may not be done in real-world practice.

CONCLUSIONS

Aprotinin reduced costs in CABG directly by reducing the use of blood products and indirectly by reducing waiting lists, as well as by reducing morbidity and mortality associated with waiting time.

Three years experience of operating and selling recovered struvite from full-scale plant

The adoption of phosphorus removal at sewage treatment works (STW) creates two main problems. Firstly large amounts of sludge are produced and secondly the quantity of the effluent deteriorates due to the increase in the phosphorus load of the sidestream. Furthermore, these processes do not remove phosphorus in a form that would enable it to be recycled. Therefore in order to control these process difficulties and produce a recyclable phosphorus product a sidestream struvite crystallisation reactor was developed. The struvite was produced in a fluidised bed reactor using dewatered filtrate from anaerobic sludge digestion. Magnesium hydroxide was added in a magnesium to phosphate ratio of 1:1 and the pH was adjusted to between 8.2-8.8 with the addition of sodium hydroxide. A retention time of 10 days alowed the growth of pellets between 0.5-1.0 mm in size. The recovered struvite contained only minute traces of toxic substances and was sold to fertiliser companies for 27,000 yen tonne(-1). It is used to enhance existing fertilisers, which are widely used on paddy rice, vegetables and flowers.

Safety and efficacy of currently available fibrin tissue adhesives

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to review preparation methods, bonding power, preparation time, and costs associated with currently available autologous and homologous fibrin tissue adhesive preparations.

METHODS

Two autologous fibrin tissue adhesive preparations (AFTA-A and AFTA-E), a single-donor homologous preparation, and 2 multiple-donor pooled homologous fibrin tissue adhesives, Vi-Guard and Tisseel, were evaluated and compared in relation to bonding power, preparation time, cost, bicompatibility, and biodegradability.

RESULTS

Vi-Guard and Tisseel showed significantly greater bonding strengths than their single-donor counterparts. AFTA-C offers the quickest preparation time. All preparations were found to be similar in biocompatibility and biodegradability in soft tissue tests. Histology showed no infection or tissue reaction from adhesive exposure in any of the preparations.

CONCLUSION

The optimal choice of a fibrin tissue adhesive is determined by the particular clinical indication. Currently available fibrin tissue adhesives vary appreciably in their bonding strength, cost, level of exposure risk, and preparation methods and times. Autologous preparations, which offer optimal safety, lack the strength and availability characteristics found with the multiple-donor preparations.

Systemic hemostatic medications for reducing surgical blood loss

OBJECTIVE

To review randomized trials involving the use of systemic hemostatic medications for reducing surgical blood loss.

DATA SOURCES

Articles were obtained through searches of MEDLINE (1966-September 2000). The bibliographies of retrieved publications were reviewed for additional references.

STUDY SELECTION

All randomized studies and pharmacoeconomic evaluations that involved medications used for systemic hemostasis in the perioperative period were included.

DATA EXTRACTION

Randomized studies involving conjugated estrogens, aminocaproic acid, tranexamic acid, desmopressin, and aprotinin for systemic hemostasis were extracted. Studies of proton-pump inhibitors for upper gastrointestinal bleeding and octreotide for variceal bleeding were excluded, as were trials involving the use of any hemostatic agent for cardiovascular surgery. The primary outcome under review was a reduction in bleeding as defined by reduced transfusion requirements.

DATA SYNTHESIS

There is limited efficacy and toxicity information concerning the use of conjugated estrogens for reducing surgery-related bleeding. Similarly, there are a limited number of randomized studies involving aminocaproic acid and tranexamic acid, and with the exception of tranexamic acid for reducing transfusion requirements with knee surgery, the study results are either conflicting or negative. For desmopressin, evidence from a substantial number of randomized trials documents its lack of efficacy. Aprotinin has reduced bleeding and transfusion requirements in a number of randomized studies involving patients undergoing orthopedic surgery, but cost-effectiveness studies are needed to better define its therapeutic role. Trials of aprotinin during hepatic surgery have yielded conflicting results.

CONCLUSIONS

Most hemostatic medications used for reducing surgery-related bleeding have limited or contradictory evidence of efficacy.

Evaluation of a combined calcium sodium alginate and bio-occlusive membrane dressing in the management of split-thickness skin graft donor sites

The optimal treatment of the split-thickness skin graft (STSG) donor site remains an unresolved issue. This study was conducted to evaluate the combined use of calcium sodium alginate and a bio-occlusive membrane dressing in the management of STSG donor sites. This study was a prospective evaluation of all patients requiring an STSG over a 6-month period ending October 1998. There were 57 patients with a mean age of 61 years. All skin grafts were harvested with an electric dermatome from the anterior thigh and were 0.012 to 0.016 inches thick. Donor sites were dressed with calcium sodium alginate followed by a bio-occlusive dressing. Postoperatively, the skin graft donor site dressing was removed and replaced. The mean skin graft area was 114 cm2. The first dressing change occurred, on average, 3 days postoperatively. All dressings were taken down and the wounds reevaluated 7 days postoperatively. Fifty-two patients (91%) had achieved complete reepithelialization by this time. Five patients (9%) required an additional dressing. All wounds were healed completely by postoperative day 10. Donor site discomfort was minimal and limited to the time of dressing change. There were no wound-related complications. The average cost of dressing supplies was $48.00 per patient and $23.00 per dressing. This method of managing STSG donor sites allowed for unimpeded reepithelialization without wound complication. The bio-occlusive dressing eliminated the pain typically associated with fine mesh gauze dressings. The absorptive property of the calcium sodium alginate eliminated the problem of seroma formation and leakage seen routinely with the use of a bio-occlusive dressing alone. These results confirm that this technique is both efficacious and cost-effective.

Ultra-low dose aprotinin decreases transfusion requirements and is cost effective in coronary operations

BACKGROUND

The recommended dose of aprotinin has been shown to reduce blood loss and need for blood transfusions, but the cost precludes its routine use. This study was designed to determine whether a less expensive, ultra-low dose of aprotinin is effective when used in coronary artery bypass grafting with left internal mammary artery.

METHODS

Patients (n = 202) were randomized to receive either placebo or aprotinin, 0.5 million KIU before incision and 0.5 million KIU during initiation of cardiopulmonary bypass. Differences in quantity of blood transfused were analyzed. Further groups were analyzed to account for the effect of aspirin. Multivariable analysis was performed to determine risk factors for transfusion. Direct costs of blood products and aprotinin were tabulated for each group.

RESULTS

There was an important reduction in the proportion of patients transfused, and number of blood units transfused when aprotinin was given before coronary artery bypass grafting. These differences were even more important in patients on aspirin preoperatively. Independent predictors for increased number of transfusions were aspirin continued before operation, smaller body surface area, and the use of placebo instead of ultra-low dose aprotinin. There was no difference in morbidity between treatment groups. There was a reduction in direct costs associated with the use of aprotinin.

CONCLUSIONS

These data support the routine use of aprotinin 1 million KIU in coronary artery bypass grafting with left internal mammary artery to reduce cost and transfusion requirements.

Role of aprotinin in the management of patients during and after cardiac surgery

Management of patients undergoing cardiac surgery has evolved in recent years as more is understood about the physiological changes and responses that occur during and after cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB). In particular, our understanding of the mechanisms involved in haemostasis and in the inflammatory response to bypass surgery, has allowed significant refinements in patient management. Improvements in the pharmacological conservation of blood loss have been striking, particularly with the development of the serine protease inhibitor, aprotinin (Trasylol, Bayer). Aprotinin represents a significant improvement, especially for patients at high risk, since it reduces the need for allogeneic and (sometimes scarce) blood products. However, in view of its cost, making an appropriate selection of patients most at risk of serious blood loss is a major consideration in the use of aprotinin. While its mechanisms of action are not well understood, the use of aprotinin also appears to reduce inflammatory response to CPB.

Comparison of blood-conservation strategies in cardiac surgery patients at high risk for bleeding

BACKGROUND

Aprotinin and tranexamic acid are routinely used to reduce bleeding in cardiac surgery. There is a large difference in agent price and perhaps in efficacy.

METHODS

In a prospective, randomized, partially blinded study, 168 cardiac surgery patients at high risk for bleeding received either a full-dose aprotinin infusion, tranexamic acid (10-mg/kg load, 1-mg x kg(-1) x h(-1) infusion), tranexamic acid with pre-cardiopulmonary bypass autologous whole-blood collection (12.5% blood volume) and reinfusion after cardiopulmonary bypass (combined therapy), or saline infusion (placebo group).

RESULTS

There were complete data in 160 patients. The aprotinin (n = 40) and combined therapy (n = 32) groups (data are median [range]) had similar reductions in blood loss in the first 4 h in the intensive care unit (225 [40-761] and 163 [25-760] ml, respectively; P = 0.014), erythrocyte transfusion requirements in the first 24 h in the intensive care unit (0 [0-3] and 0 [0-3] U, respectively; P = 0.004), and durations of time from end of cardiopulmonary bypass to discharge from the operating room (92 [57-215] and 94 [37, 186] min, respectively; P = 0.01) compared with the placebo group (n = 43). Ten patients in the combined therapy group (30.3%) required transfusion of the autologous blood during cardiopulmonary bypass for anemia.

CONCLUSIONS

The combination therapy of tranexamic acid and intraoperative autologous blood collection provided similar reduction in blood loss and transfusion requirements as aprotinin. Cost analyses revealed that combined therapy and tranexamic acid therapy were the least costly therapies.

Octreotide in the treatment of gastrointestinal bleeding caused by angiodysplasia in two patients with von Willebrand's disease

Two cases of von Willebrand's disease and angiodysplasia with intractable gastrointestinal bleeding are presented. Replacement therapy with cryoprecipitate and variable purity von Willebrand factor (VWF) was ineffective, as were other treatments including steroids, immunoglobulin and hormonal replacement. Both patients required massive blood transfusion and product support. The efficacy of somatostatin and an analogue is described. In one patient, we observed a rise in von Willebrand factor activity after octreotide infusion.

Routine coagulation screening in the management of emergency admission for epistaxis--is it necessary?

The role of routine coagulation studies in the management of patients suffering from epistaxis is unclear. In an attempt to address this issue the case notes of all emergency admissions for epistaxis to a large Scottish teaching hospital were retrospectively reviewed over a one-year period. One hundred and forty patients (63 male, 77 female) were admitted between January and December 1998. The patients who had coagulation studies were identified and their results analysed. A total of 121 patients (86.4 per cent) had coagulation studies performed. Of these, 10 (8.3 per cent) had abnormal results and all were taking warfarin or a combination of warfarin and aspirin. No other coagulation abnormalities were identified. This study supports the view that there does not appear to be a role for routine coagulation studies in patients admitted with epistaxis. The investigation for potential haemostatic disorders should be performed when clinically indicated and, if necessary, in consultation with the haematology service.

Hemostatic effects of aprotinin, tranexamic acid and epsilon-aminocaproic acid in primary cardiac surgery

BACKGROUND

The effects of epsilon-aminocaproic acid (EACA) and tranexamic acid (TA) on bleeding and allogeneic transfusions, and the cost of pharmacological and transfusional treatment were compared to aprotinin (AP).

METHODS

We randomized 210 patients subjected to elective cardiac surgery. Of these, 68 patients received EACA (a bolus of 5 g, an infusion of 2 g/h, and 2.5 g in the priming), 72 patients received TA (a bolus of 1 g, an infusion of 400 mg/h, and 500 mg in the priming), and 70 patients received AP (a bolus of 280 mg, an infusion of 70 mg/h, and 280 mg in the priming). Postoperative blood loss and homologous transfusions were collected and the cost of pharmacological treatment and homologous transfusions were calculated.

RESULTS

Bleeding but not allogeneic transfusions was significantly higher in the EACA group (467+/-234 versus TA, 311+/-231 versus AP, 283+/-233; p < 0.001). Costs of pharmacological and transfusional treatment were significantly lower in the TA group ($58.10+/-$105.10) versus the EACA group ($100.70+/-$158.60) versus the AP group ($432.60+/-$118.70) (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to AP, TA has the same effects on bleeding and transfusions, but with a significant reduction of costs. Patients treated with EACA showed a significantly higher postoperative bleeding with an increased trend of transfusion requirement.

Low cost locally prepared fibrin glue for clinical applications: reported of 145 cases. Committee of Bangkok International Hemophilia Training Center

Fibrin glue (FG) is one of the blood products known to be very useful for local hemostatic measure and as a medically valuable tool for adhesion, sealing, anastomosis, repair microvascular and nerve grafts in medical and surgical procedures. Before 1996, FG was used to a limited extent in Thailand due to the high cost. Technology for locally prepared FG was transferred to Bangkok International Hemophilia Training Center of the World Federation of Hemophilia (IHTC-WFH) in July 1996 by Prof. Uri Martinowitz and the late Prof. Henri Horoszowski. Since then FG has been widely used and proved to be very useful in Thailand. This paper reports 145 cases using low cost locally prepared FG at Ramathibodi Hospital during November 1996 to December 1997. A total of 145 cases with age range from 5 months to 73 years, which included 55 pediatrics and 90 adults, 100 males and 45 females. The amount of FG used was 1-80 ml per case. Clinical procedures included dental surgery (46), open heart surgery (35), ENT (28), orthopedic (13) including 2-3 joint correction in one session in 2 hemophiliacs, neurology (11), plastic repair (7), liver (2) and severe bleeding in dengue hemorrhagic fever (3). Forty-seven cases had hemostatic disorders. The result of local hemostatic, adhesive and sealant effect of FG was satisfactory with no complications. In open heart surgery, the amount of content in chest drain decreased and none required reopen-surgery to stop bleeding. Dental surgery was performed in 43 patients with bleeding disorders i.e. hemophilia, idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura, leukemia, severe thrombocytopenia, patients on anticoagulant, etc. Only 3 cases (7%) required blood component compared to all of the 50 no-FG controlled cases (100%) that required blood component therapy. FG has proved to be very useful in many aspects i.e. minimizing blood product usage, decreasing medical workload, reducing medical cost and increasing patients' convenience and satisfaction in particular.

Predictors of large esophageal varices in patients with cirrhosis

OBJECTIVE

Recent guidelines recommend that all cirrhotics undergo screening upper endoscopy to identify those patients at risk for bleeding from varices. However, this practice may not be cost effective as large esophageal varices are seen only in 9-36% of these patients. The aim of this study was to determine whether clinical variables were predictive of the presence of large esophageal varices.

METHODS

This is a retrospective analysis of cirrhotics who had a screening upper endoscopy during an evaluation for liver transplantation at three different centers and who had not previously bled from varices. A multivariate model was derived on the combined cohort using logistic regression. Three hundred forty-six patients were eligible for the study.

RESULTS

The prevalence of large esophageal varices was 20%. On multivariate analysis, splenomegaly detected by computed tomographic scan (odds ratio: 4.3; 95% confidence interval: 1.6-11.5) or by physical examination (odds ratio: 2.0; 95% confidence interval: 1.1-3.8), and low platelet count were independent predictors of large esophageal varices. On the basis of these variables, cirrhotics were stratified into high- and low-risk groups for the presence of large esophageal varices. Patients with a platelet count of > or = 88,000/mm3 (median value) and no splenomegaly by physical examination had a risk of large esophageal varices of 7.2%. Those with splenomegaly or platelet count < 88,000/mm3 had a risk of large esophageal varices of 28% (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Our data show that clinical predictors could be used to stratify cirrhotic patients for the risk of large esophageal varices and such stratification could be used to improve the cost effectiveness of screening endoscopy.

Economic evaluation of high-dose and low-dose aprotinin therapy during cardiopulmonary bypass

BACKGROUND

Aprotinin therapy is now widely used during cardiac surgery. This study examined the clinical and economic effectiveness of high-dose or low-dose aprotinin in comparison to placebo.

METHODS

In a double blind, randomized study, three groups of 50 patients received high-dose aprotinin costing AUS$614 per patient (AUS$ = Australian dollars), low-dose aprotinin costing AUS$220 per patient or placebo. Resource use influenced by aprotinin therapy was measured.

RESULTS

Both doses were effective in reducing chest drainage and postoperative transfusion requirements, high-dose being more effective than low-dose. Both doses reduced the rate of reoperations for hemostasis. A base case of statistically significant differences associated with the high-dose and low-dose aprotinin showed cost savings of AUS$77 and AUS$348 per patient, respectively. If the demonstrated less significant reductions in operating room and ward stay are included, these savings become AUS$463 and AUS$715, respectively. Alternately, if cross-matches are replaced by group-and-hold and cell savers are not used, the savings per patient would be AUS$196 and AUS$467, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

While high-dose aprotinin is clinically more effective than low-dose aprotinin, low-dose therapy demonstrates greater cost savings.