Failure of the mandatory domestic violence reporting law to increase medical facility referral to police

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To assess the effect of California's 1994 mandatory domestic violence reporting law on Los Angeles Sheriff's Department dispatches to medical facilities for domestic violence incidents.

METHODS

This ecological time-trend study analyzed data from the Los Angeles Sheriff's Department for the period January 1, 1993, to December 31, 1995. All 26,051 dispatches for domestic violence offenses during the study period were analyzed. The outcome measures were changes in biweekly department dispatches for domestic violence offenses resulting from the implementation of the mandatory domestic violence reporting law adjusted for seasonal variation and the Simpson/Goldman murders.

RESULTS

The percentage of biweekly dispatches to medical facilities for domestic violence offenses did not increase in response to the law (beta = -.0072, P = .095). Total domestic violence dispatches increased significantly after the Simpson/Goldman murders but not after passage of the law (beta = 82.7, P < .0001 versus beta = -10.1, P = .2205).

CONCLUSION

The mandatory domestic violence reporting law in California did not increase medical personnel reporting of domestic violence situations to the Sheriff's Department during the 2 years after its implementation.

Need for law enforcement in cases of intimate partner violence in a university ED

The purpose of this study was to quantify the proportion of men and women seen in a university emergency department (ED) for treatment of injuries resulting from intimate partner violence (IPV) that require reports to law enforcement authorities. A total of 1,516 adult ED patients were asked to complete a written survey instrument; 1,003 patients (66.2%) completed the survey. Two percent of patients reported they presented to the ED for treatment of injuries resulting from IPV. Three percent reported IPV within the last year, and 10% reported that they had ever been physically abused by a partner. Six percent of respondents reported that they had ever been threatened with a gun or knife by a partner, 2% within the past year. Only the lifetime prevalence of IPV was significantly greater among female patients, 15% versus 6% (P < .001). Approximately 2% of our ED patients require law enforcement intervention for IPV.

The impact of two related prevention strategies on head injury reduction among nonfatally injured motorcycle riders, California, 1991-1993

Although the traumatic injury death rate in the United States decreased during the last 20 years, the percent of all injury deaths attributable to brain injuries has remained steady. Head injuries are a leading cause of injury among motorcycle riders in crashes, and the helmet is an effective measure to reduce these injuries. To reduce the burden and cost of motorcycle injuries, many states have increased helmet use by introducing mandatory helmet legislation. This report presents evidence on the effects of the motorcycle helmet and helmet use legislation--two interrelated prevention strategies which decrease traumatic brain injury among motorcycle riders. Nonfatally injured motorcyclists were included if they crashed between January 1, 1991 and December 31, 1993 and were treated in one of 18 hospitals in 10 California counties. Medical records for all injured motorcyclists admitted to these 18 hospitals and those treated in the emergency department and released in eight of these hospitals were individually reviewed. Complete lists of injury diagnoses for each rider were coded according to the 1990 Abbreviated Injury Severity Scale by trained clinical staff. Before the universal helmet law was introduced (when only a third of injured riders wore helmets) 38.2% of riders sustained head injuries. When helmet use increased to over 85% of injured riders following the law, less than 25% of riders sustained head injuries. Both the severity and the number of head injuries per individual rider decreased after the mandatory helmet use law led to increased helmet use. Riders wearing helmets suffered fewer skull fractures, fewer intracranial injuries, had less frequent and shorter periods of loss of consciousness, more favorable GCS scores, and shorter hospital stays. Mandatory motorcycle helmet use laws are an effective mechanism to increase helmet use among riders and thus prevent head and brain injuries resulting from motorcycle crashes.

The accuracy of death certificates in identifying work-related fatal injuries

Three national US agencies report on work-related fatal injuries, and one uses the "injury at work" designation on the death certificate to identify and characterize these fatalities. The accuracy of the "injury at work" notation has not been validated. The authors used selected external causes of death (from the International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision, Clinical Modification) that are highly likely to be work-related or not work-related as a standard to compare with the California death certificate "at work" designation for the years 1979-1989. Data from the National Center for Health Statistics for the years 1979-1984 were used to measure prevalence for purposes of determining the predictive value of a positive or negative work-related notation on the death certificate. The sensitivity of the "at work" designation was 77.6%, with a specificity of over 99%. Sensitivity but not specificity varied by age, sex, and specific external cause of death. The predictive value positive of the "at work" designation was about 60%, which suggests caution in using it for some epidemiologic purposes.

Fatal injuries in motorcycle riders according to helmet use

OBJECTIVE

Helmets have been shown to be effective in preventing head injuries in motorcyclists, but some studies have suggested that helmets may cause injury to parts of the head or neck because they add mass to the head.

DESIGN

This study examined patterns of fatal injuries in helmeted and unhelmeted motorcyclists.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Coroner reports, hospital records, and police reports for motorcyclists fatally injured in crashes from July 1, 1988 through October 31, 1989 were examined. All injury diagnoses were abstracted and coded to the 1990 version of The Abbreviated Injury Scale and the International Classification of Diseases, 9th revision.

MAIN RESULTS

Cerebral injury, intracranial hemorrhage, face, skull vault, and cervical spine injuries were more likely to be found in fatally injured unhelmeted motorcyclists than in helmeted motorcyclists.

CONCLUSIONS

These results expand earlier reports showing that helmets provide protection for all types and locations of head injuries, and show that they are not associated with increased neck injury occurrence.

Compliance with the 1992 California motorcycle helmet use law

To evaluate helmet use in California before and after the introduction of an unrestricted helmet use law on January 1, 1992, observations of motorcycles and their riders were made at 60 locations in seven California counties, twice before and four times after the law was introduced. Helmet use increased from about 50% in 1991 to more than 99% throughout 1992. Compliance was achieved despite variations in helmet use by motorcycle design and road type. Seven percent of riders used nonstandard helmets after the law. With adequate enforcement, unrestricted helmet use laws can achieve almost 100% compliance and reduce the number of people riding motorcycles.

The effect of the 1992 California motorcycle helmet use law on motorcycle crash fatalities and injuries

OBJECTIVE

To determine the effects of the California motorcycle helmet use law on statewide fatalities and a large sample of nonfatal injuries before and after law implementation.

DESIGN

Police reports and death certificates were collected for motorcycle crash fatalities in California for 1991 (prelaw) and 1992 (postlaw). Official counts of registered motorcycles provided a statewide basis for exposure to a motorcycle crash. Autopsy results were collected for fatalities in 11 counties. Hospital records were reviewed for nonfatal injuries in 28 hospitals in 10 of the 11 counties. Police reports were linked to injury data for the riders.

SUBJECTS AND PATIENTS

A total of 850 fatalities and injury data for 547 fatally injured riders and 3252 nonfatally injured patients.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Changes in number and rates among statewide fatalities were estimated. The number and pattern of head injuries in fatally and nonfatally injured motorcycle riders were evaluated.

RESULTS

After implementation of the helmet use law, statewide motorcycle crash fatalities decreased by 37.5%, from 523 fatalities in 1991 to 327 in 1992, more than 37%, and an estimated 92 to 122 fatalities were prevented. Motorcycle fatality rates were reduced by 26.5%, from 70.1 per 100,000 registered motorcycles in 1991 to 51.5 per 100,000 in 1992. Head injuries decreased significantly among both fatally and nonfatally injured motorcyclists.

CONCLUSION

Enactment of an unrestricted helmet law significantly reduces the incidence of motorcycle crash fatalities and the number and severity of head injuries.

Lower extremity injuries from motorcycle crashes: a common cause of preventable injury

Lower extremity injuries are among the most common injuries sustained by motorcycle riders in crashes and often lead to extended and costly medical treatment and permanent disability. This study characterizes lower extremity injuries in a group of 700 motorcycle riders in crashes in Los Angeles County from July 1, 1988, through October 31, 1989. Motorcycle crash fatalities (n = 163) were identified through the Los Angeles County Coroner's office, and nonfatally injured riders (n = 537) were identified at four of the ten level I and level II trauma centers in the county. Lower extremity injuries were diagnosed in 301 (56%) of nonfatally injured and in 75 (46%) of fatally injured riders. Fractures were the most common lower extremity injury and were diagnosed in 52% and 42% of riders with nonfatal and fatal injuries, respectively. Over a third of all fractures were to the tibia or fibula. Drivers and passengers did not differ in their risk for lower extremity injuries. Multiple-vehicle collisions resulted in a higher risk of lower extremity injuries than did single-vehicle collisions. The highest risk for lower extremity fractures was observed among riders in broadside collisions in which another vehicle struck the motorcycle (risk ratio = 2.7). Modifications in vehicle design and rider apparel may prevent some lower extremity injuries in motorcycle crashes.

Effect of immediate resuscitation on children with submersion injury

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To determine the effect of immediate resuscitative efforts on the neurological outcome of children with submersion injury.

DESIGN

A case-control study was designed to determine if immediate resuscitation by rescuers or bystanders reduces the frequency of severe neurological damage or death in children with a documented submersion event. Logistic regression was used calculate an adjusted odds ratio.

PARTICIPANTS

The study group consisted of 166 children, aged zero to 14 years, having a submersion event during May 1984 through August 1992, and admitted through various emergency departments to Huntington Memorial Hospital in Pasadena, California.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

All study subjects had an observed and documented episode of apnea at the time of submersion. Outcomes were evaluated on the basis of neurological impairment or death. Exposure was verified from historical accounts of postsubmersion events provided by family, friends, and/or paramedical personnel. The study factors included age and gender, duration of submersion, hypothermia, presence of apnea, resuscitative efforts, and clinical outcome. Children with a good outcome were 4.75 (adjusted odds ratio (OR)) times more likely to have a history of immediate resuscitation than children with poor outcome (95% confidence interval: 3.44 < OR < 6.06, P = .0001). Various types of resuscitative efforts and potential confounding factors were also evaluated. CPR and mouth-to-mouth resuscitation were the most effective types for the prevention of death or severe anoxic encephalopathy.

CONCLUSION

Immediate resuscitation before the arrival of paramedical personnel is associated with a significantly better neurological outcome in children with submersion injury.

Hemolytic anemia associated with injection of fluorescein

A 49-year-old woman presented with a hemoglobin level of 9.5 g per dL (95 g/L), reticulocyte count of 6.7 percent (0.067), and hemoglobinuria. The next day, the hemoglobin had dropped to 5.8 g per dL (58 g/L), and total bilirubin was 8.8 mg per dL (150 mumol/L). The serum reacted 2+ with all red cells (RBCs). The direct antiglobulin test (DAT) was 3+ with anti-IgG and 1+ with anti-C3, but eluates prepared by two different methods did not react with untreated RBCs. The eluate reacted 2+ with amoxicillin-coated RBCs; amoxicillin had been listed in the patient's record as a previous medication. The patient denied recent ingestion of amoxicillin. Further investigation documented the injection of a dye, fluorescein sodium (AK-FLUOR-25%), for a ophthalmologic fluorescein angiographic study 2 days before admission. RBCs coated with AK-FLUOR reacted with the eluate. Controls consisting of normal serum, an eluate prepared from DAT-negative RBCs, and a serum known to contain anti-penicillin did not react with AK-FLUOR-coated RBCs. Nine days later, the DAT was negative and the serum did not react with untreated RBCs. In the presence of AK-FLUOR (1-in-125) or amoxicillin (1 mg/mL), the serum reacted 2+ in the antiglobulin test. Antibodies to AK-FLUOR and amoxicillin appeared to react by two mechanisms, which is similar to results in recent reports of other drugs associated with hemolytic anemia. AK-FLUOR has not previously been reported to be associated with hemolytic anemia.

Mortality from infectious diseases among New Mexico's American Indians, Hispanic whites, and other whites, 1958-87

To examine ethnic differences in infectious disease-related mortality in New Mexico's American Indian, Hispanic White and other White populations, we analyzed vital records data from 1958 to 1987. We found that for most infectious causes, American Indians had the highest mortality rates, followed by Hispanics. The state's minority populations remain at increased risk for infectious disease mortality.

Effects of concurrent drug therapy on technetium Tc-99m gluceptate biodistribution

Drug interactions with technetium Tc-99m gluceptate resulting in altered biodistribution were studied using chart review and animal tests. Charts of nine patients who had abnormal gallbladder uptake of technetium Tc-99m gluceptate during a two-year period were reviewed to obtain data such as concurrent drug therapy, primary diagnosis, and laboratory values. Adult New Zealand white rabbits were then used for testing the biodistribution of technetium Tc-99m gluceptate when administered concurrently with possibly interacting drugs identified in the chart review--penicillamine, penicillin G potassium, penicillin V potassium, acetaminophen, and trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole. Chart review revealed no conclusive patterns of altered biodistribution associated with other factors. The data did suggest the possibility that the five drugs listed above might cause increased hepatobiliary clearance of the radiopharmaceutical. Animal tests showed that i.v. penicillamine caused substantial distribution of radioactivity into the gallbladder and small bowel. Minimally increased gallbladder radioactivity occurred when oral acetaminophen and trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole were administered concurrently. Oral and i.v. penicillins did not increase gallbladder activity. Penicillamine may cause substantial alteration of the biodistribution of technetium Tc-99m gluceptate.