COVID-19 Vaccination in Patients with Inborn Errors of Immunity Reduces Hospitalization and Critical Care Needs Related to COVID-19: a USIDNET Report

BACKGROUND

The CDC and ACIP recommend COVID-19 vaccination for patients with inborn errors of immunity (IEI). Not much is known about vaccine safety in IEI, and whether vaccination attenuates infection severity in IEI.

OBJECTIVE

To estimate COVID-19 vaccination safety and examine effect on outcomes in patients with IEI.

METHODS

We built a secure registry database in conjunction with the US Immunodeficiency Network to examine vaccination frequency and indicators of safety and effectiveness in IEI patients. The registry opened on January 1, 2022, and closed on August 19, 2022.

RESULTS

Physicians entered data on 1245 patients from 24 countries. The most common diagnoses were antibody deficiencies (63.7%). At least one COVID-19 vaccine was administered to 806 patients (64.7%), and 216 patients received vaccination prior to the development of COVID-19. The most common vaccines administered were mRNA-based (84.0%). Seventeen patients were reported to seek outpatient clinic or emergency room care for a vaccine-related complication, and one patient was hospitalized for symptomatic anemia. Eight hundred twenty-three patients (66.1%) experienced COVID-19 infection. Of these, 156 patients required hospitalization (19.0%), 47 required ICU care (5.7%), and 28 died (3.4%). Rates of hospitalization (9.3% versus 24.4%, p < 0.001), ICU admission (2.8% versus 7.6%, p = 0.013), and death (2.3% versus 4.3%, p = 0.202) in patients who had COVID-19 were lower in patients who received vaccination prior to infection. In adjusted logistic regression analysis, not having at least one COVID-19 vaccine significantly increased the odds of hospitalization and ICU admission.

CONCLUSION

Vaccination for COVID-19 in the IEI population appears safe and attenuates COVID-19 severity.

Who's your data? Primary immune deficiency differential diagnosis prediction via machine learning and data mining of the USIDNET registry

PURPOSE

There are currently more than 480 primary immune deficiency (PID) diseases and about 7000 rare diseases that together afflict around 1 in every 17 humans. Computational aids based on data mining and machine learning might facilitate the diagnostic task by extracting rules from large datasets and making predictions when faced with new problem cases. In a proof-of-concept data mining study, we aimed to predict PID diagnoses using a supervised machine learning algorithm based on classification tree boosting.

METHODS

Through a data query at the USIDNET registry we obtained a database of 2396 patients with common diagnoses of PID, including their clinical and laboratory features. We kept 286 features and all 12 diagnoses to include in the model. We used the XGBoost package with parallel tree boosting for the supervised classification model, and SHAP for variable importance interpretation, on Python v3.7. The patient database was split into training and testing subsets, and after boosting through gradient descent, the predictive model provides measures of diagnostic prediction accuracy and individual feature importance. After a baseline performance test, we used the Class Weighting Hyperparameter, or scale_pos_weight to correct for imbalanced classification.

RESULTS

The twelve PID diagnoses were CVID (1098 patients), DiGeorge syndrome, Chronic granulomatous disease, Congenital agammaglobulinemia, PID not otherwise classified, Specific antibody deficiency, Complement deficiency, Hyper-IgM, Leukocyte adhesion deficiency, ectodermal dysplasia with immune deficiency, Severe combined immune deficiency, and Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome. For CVID, the model found an accuracy on the train sample of 0.80, with an area under the ROC curve (AUC) of 0.80, and a Gini coefficient of 0.60. In the test subset, accuracy was 0.76, AUC 0.75, and Gini 0.51. The positive feature value to predict CVID was highest for upper respiratory infections, asthma, autoimmunity and hypogammaglobulinemia. Features with the highest negative predictive value were high IgE, growth delay, abscess, lymphopenia, and congenital heart disease. For the rest of the diagnoses, accuracy stayed between 0.75 and 0.99, AUC 0.46-0.87, Gini 0.07-0.75, and LogLoss 0.09-8.55.

DISCUSSION

Clinicians should remember to consider the negative predictive features together with the positives. We are calling this a proof-of-concept study to continue with our explorations. A good performance is encouraging, and feature importance might aid feature selection for future endeavors. In the meantime, we can learn from the rules derived by the model and build a user-friendly decision tree to generate differential diagnoses.

Eosinophilic gastrointestinal disorders in patients with inborn errors of immunity: Data from the USIDNET registry

Rationale

Eosinophilic gastrointestinal disorders (EGID), including eosinophilic esophagitis (EoE), are inflammatory disorders of the gastrointestinal mucosa mediated by complex immune mechanisms. Although there have been initial reports of EGID in patients with inborn errors of immunity (IEI), little is known about the presentation of EGID in immunodeficient individuals.

Methods

We queried the U.S. Immunodeficiency Network (USIDNET) for patient records including the terms eosinophilic esophagitis, gastritis, enteritis, or colitis. We analyzed 74 patient records from the database, including diagnoses, demographics, infectious history, laboratory findings, genetic studies, therapeutic interventions, and clinical outcomes.

Results

We examined 74 patient records. A total of 61 patients had isolated EoE, and 13 had distal gastrointestinal involvement consistent with EGID. The most common IEI were common variable immunodeficiency (43.2%), some form of combined immunodeficiency (21.6%), chronic granulomatous disease (8.1%), hyper-IgE syndrome (6.8%), and autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (6.8%). The median age at presentation with IEI was 0.5 years (IQR 1.725, max 39 years) and 56.76% were male. Approximately 20% of the patients in the cohort received a hematopoietic stem cell transplantation for treatment of IEI, but the timing of the HSCT in relationship to the EGID diagnosis was unknown.

Conclusions

Here, we report EGID in a diverse cohort of IEI patients, suggesting that both non-EoE EGID and EoE can be seen as comorbid conditions with a variety of IEI. Our data suggests that EGID may be more common in patients with IEI than would be expected based on estimates of EGID in the general population.

Cutaneous barrier leakage and gut inflammation drive skin disease in Omenn syndrome

Background

Severe early-onset erythroderma and gut inflammation, with massive tissue infiltration of oligoclonal activated T cells are the hallmark of Omenn syndrome (OS).

Objective

The impact of altered gut homeostasis in the cutaneous manifestations of OS remains to be clarified.

Methods

We analyzed a cohort of 15 patients with OS and the 129Sv/C57BL/6 knock-in Rag2^R229Q/R229Q (Rag2^R229Q) mouse model. Homing phenotypes of circulating lymphocytes were analyzed by flow cytometry. Inflammatory cytokines and chemokines were examined in the sera by ELISA and in skin biopsies by immunohistochemistry and in situ RNA hybridization. Experimental colitis was induced in mice by dextran sulfate sodium salt.

Results

We show that memory/activated T cells from patients with OS and from the Rag2^R229Q mouse model of OS abundantly express the skin homing receptors cutaneous lymphocyte associated antigen and CCR4 (Ccr4), associated with high levels of chemokine C-C motif ligands 17 and 22. Serum levels of LPS are also elevated. A broad T_h1/T_h2/T_h17 inflammatory signature is detected in the periphery and in the skin. Increased Tlr4 expression in the skin of Rag2^R229Q mice is associated with enhanced cutaneous inflammation on local and systemic administration of LPS. Likewise, boosting colitis in Rag2^R229Q mice results in increased frequency of Ccr4⁺ splenic T cells and worsening of skin inflammation, as indicated by epidermal thickening, enhanced epithelial cell activation, and dermal infiltration by T_h1 effector T cells.

Conclusions

These results support the existence of an interplay between gut and skin that can sustain skin inflammation in OS.

Pulmonary Disease Burden in Primary Immune Deficiency Disorders: Data from USIDNET Registry

PURPOSE

Pulmonary manifestations are common in patients with primary immunodeficiency disorders (PIDs) but the prevalence, specific diseases, and their patterns are not well characterized.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective analysis of pulmonary diseases reported in the database of the United States Immunodeficiency Network (USIDNET), a program of the Immune Deficiency Foundation. PIDs were categorized into 10 groups and their demographics, pulmonary diagnoses and procedures, infections, prophylaxis regimens, and laboratory findings were analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 1937 patients with various PIDs (39.3% of total patients, 49.6% male, average age 37.9 years (SD = 22.4 years)) were noted to have a pulmonary disease comorbidity. Pulmonary diseases were categorized into broad categories: airway (86.8%), parenchymal (18.5%), pleural (4.6%), vascular (4.3%), and other (13.9%) disorders. Common variable immune deficiency (CVID) accounted for almost half of PIDs associated with airway, parenchymal, and other pulmonary disorders. Pulmonary procedures performed in 392 patients were mostly diagnostic (77.3%) or therapeutic (16.3%). These patients were receiving a wide variety of treatments, which included immunoglobulin replacement (82.1%), immunosuppressive (32.2%), anti-inflammatory (12.7%), biologic (9.3%), and cytokine (7.6%)-based therapies. Prophylactic therapy was being given with antibiotics (18.1%), antifungal (3.3%), and antiviral (2.2%) medications, and 7.1% of patients were on long-term oxygen therapy due to advanced lung disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Pulmonary manifestations are common in individuals with PID, but long-term pulmonary outcomes are not well known in this group of patients. Further longitudinal follow-up will help to define long-term prognosis of respiratory comorbidities and optimal treatment modalities.

Noninfectious Manifestations and Complications of Chronic Granulomatous Disease

Chronic granulomatous disease (CGD), a primary immunodeficiency characterized by a deficient neutrophil oxidative burst and the inadequate killing of microbes, is well known to cause a significantly increased risk of invasive infection. However, infectious complications are not the sole manifestations of CGD; substantial additional morbidity is driven by noninfectious complications also. These complications can include, for example, a wide range of inflammatory diseases that affect the gastrointestinal tract, lung, skin, and genitourinary tract and overt autoimmune disease. These diseases can occur at any age and are especially problematic in adolescents and adults with CGD. Many of these noninfectious complications present a highly challenging therapeutic conundrum, wherein immunosuppression must be balanced against an already markedly increased risk of invasive fungal and bacterial infections. In this review, the myriad noninfectious complications of CGD are discussed, as are important gaps in our understanding of these processes, which warrant further investigation.

Analysis of T-cell repertoire diversity in Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome

Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS) is an X-linked immunodeficiency characterized by thrombocytopenia, eczema, and variable degrees of impaired cellular and humoral immunity. Age-dependent T-cell lymphopenia has been described in WAS, however, the diversity of the T-cell compartment over time in these patients has not been characterized. We have used complementarity-determining region 3 (CDR3) size distribution analysis to assess T-cell receptor (TCR) Vbeta repertoire in 13 patients with WAS. Diverse CDR3 size pattern was demonstrated in patients under 15 years of age regardless of the levels of WAS protein (WASP) expression. In contrast, older patients showed significantly higher skewing of TCRVbeta repertoire as compared with healthy adults. We did not find correlation between clinical score and complexity of TCRVbeta repertoire. These findings suggest that WASP deficiency does not limit thymic generation of a normal TCR and indicate that T-cell oligoclonality may contribute to the immunodeficiency in older patients with WAS.

Multiple patients with revertant mosaicism in a single Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome family

We previously reported on a 43-year-old patient with Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS) who experienced progressive clinical improvement and revertant T-cell mosaicism. Deletion of the disease-causing 6-bp insertion was hypothesized to have occurred by DNA polymerase slippage. We now describe 2 additional patients from the same family who also had revertant T lymphocytes that showed selective in vivo advantage. Somatic mosaicism was demonstrated on leukocytes cryopreserved in the first patient when he was 22 years old, 11 years before his death from kidney failure. The second patient is now 16 years old, has a moderate clinical phenotype, and developed revertant cells after the age of 14 years. These results support DNA polymerase slippage as a common underlying mechanism, and they indicate that T-cell mosaicism may have different clinical effects in WAS.

Differential contribution of Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome protein to selective advantage in T- and B-cell lineages

Somatic mosaicism because of in vivo reversion has been recently reported in a small number of patients affected with Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS). Flow cytometry analysis of WAS protein (WASP) expression has shown that these patients carried revertant cells only among T lymphocytes. Here, we have used high-resolution capillary electrophoresis to analyze genomic DNA from highly purified cells of one of these patients and detected revertant sequences also within the B-cell fraction. The demonstration of revertant cells among both T and B lymphocytes in this patient is consistent with the reversion event having occurred in a common lymphoid progenitor. However, although WASP-expressing T cells showed selective advantage and were readily detectable in the periphery of the mosaic patient, revertant B lymphocytes remained below the detection threshold of flow cytometry. These findings suggest that, contrary to T cells, differentiation and survival of B lymphocytes is minimally dependent on WASP.

Second-site mutation in the Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS) protein gene causes somatic mosaicism in two WAS siblings

Revertant mosaicism due to true back mutations or second-site mutations has been identified in several inherited disorders. The occurrence of revertants is considered rare, and the underlying genetic mechanisms remain mostly unknown. Here we describe somatic mosaicism in two brothers affected with Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS). The original mutation causing disease in this family is a single base insertion (1305insG) in the WAS protein (WASP) gene, which results in frameshift and abrogates protein expression. Both patients, however, showed expression of WASP in a fraction of their T cells that were demonstrated to carry a second-site mutation causing the deletion of 19 nucleotides from nucleotide 1299 to 1316. This deletion abrogated the effects of the original mutation and restored the WASP reading frame. In vitro expression studies indicated that mutant protein encoded by the second-site mutation was expressed and functional, since it was able to bind to cellular partners and mediate T cell receptor/CD3 downregulation. These observations were consistent with evidence of in vivo selective advantage of WASP-expressing lymphocytes. Molecular analysis revealed that the sequence surrounding the deletion contained two 4-bp direct repeats and that a hairpin structure could be formed by five GC pairs within the deleted fragment. These findings strongly suggest that slipped mispairing was the cause of this second-site mutation and that selective accumulation of WASP-expressing T lymphocytes led to revertant mosaicism in these patients.

Persistence and expression of the adenosine deaminase gene for 12 years and immune reaction to gene transfer components: long-term results of the first clinical gene therapy trial

The first human gene therapy experiment begun in September 1990 used a retroviral vector containing the human adenosine deaminase (ADA) cDNA to transduce mature peripheral blood lymphocytes from patients with ADA deficiency, an inherited disorder of immunity. Two patients who had been treated with intramuscular injections of pegylated bovine ADA (PEG-ADA) for 2 to 4 years were enrolled in this trial and each received a total of approximately 10(11) cells in 11 or 12 infusions over a period of about 2 years. No adverse events were observed. During and after treatment, the patients continued to receive PEG-ADA, although at a reduced dose. Ten years after the last cell infusion, approximately 20% of the first patient's lymphocytes still carry and express the retroviral gene, indicating that the effects of gene transfer can be remarkably long lasting. On the contrary, the persistence of gene-marked cells is very low (< 0.1%), and no expression of the transgene is detectable in lymphocytes from the second patient who developed persisting antibodies to components of the gene transfer system. Data collected from these original patients have provided novel information about the longevity of T lymphocytes in humans and persistence of gene expression in vivo from vectors driven by the Moloney murine leukemia virus long-terminal repeat (LTR) promoter. This long-term follow-up has also provided unique evidence supporting the safety of retroviral-mediated gene transfer and illustrates clear examples of both the potential and the pitfalls of gene therapy in humans.

Somatic mosaicism in Wiskott--Aldrich syndrome suggests in vivo reversion by a DNA slippage mechanism

Somatic mosaicism caused by in vivo reversion of inherited mutations has been described in several human genetic disorders. Back mutations resulting in restoration of wild-type sequences and second-site mutations leading to compensatory changes have been shown in mosaic individuals. In most cases, however, the precise genetic mechanisms underlying the reversion events have remained unclear, except for the few instances where crossing over or gene conversion have been demonstrated. Here, we report a patient affected with Wiskott--Aldrich syndrome (WAS) caused by a 6-bp insertion (ACGAGG) in the WAS protein gene, which abrogates protein expression. Somatic mosaicism was documented in this patient whose majority of T lymphocytes expressed nearly normal levels of WAS protein. These lymphocytes were found to lack the deleterious mutation and showed a selective growth advantage in vivo. Analysis of the sequence surrounding the mutation site showed that the 6-bp insertion followed a tandem repeat of the same six nucleotides. These findings strongly suggest that DNA polymerase slippage was the cause of the original germ-line insertion mutation in this family and that the same mechanism was responsible for its deletion in one of the propositus T cell progenitors, thus leading to reversion mosaicism.