Linguistic analysis of project ownership for undergraduate research experiences

We used computational linguistic and content analyses to explore the concept of project ownership for undergraduate research. We used linguistic analysis of student interview data to develop a quantitative methodology for assessing project ownership and applied this method to measure degrees of project ownership expressed by students in relation to different types of educational research experiences. The results of the study suggest that the design of a research experience significantly influences the degree of project ownership expressed by students when they describe those experiences. The analysis identified both positive and negative aspects of project ownership and provided a working definition for how a student experiences his or her research opportunity. These elements suggest several features that could be incorporated into an undergraduate research experience to foster a student's sense of project ownership.

Amylin replacement with pramlintide as an adjunct to insulin therapy improves long-term glycaemic and weight control in Type 1 diabetes mellitus: a 1-year, randomized controlled trial

AIMS

The autoimmune-mediated destruction of pancreatic beta-cells in Type 1 diabetes mellitus renders patients deficient in two glucoregulatory peptide hormones, insulin and amylin. With insulin replacement alone, most patients do not achieve glycaemic goals. We aimed to determine the long-term efficacy and safety of adjunctive therapy with pramlintide, a synthetic human amylin analogue, in patients with Type 1 diabetes.

METHODS

In a double-blind, placebo-controlled, parallel-group, multicentre study, 651 patients with Type 1 diabetes (age 41 +/- 13 years, HbA(1c) 8.9 +/- 1.0%, mean +/- sd) were randomized to mealtime injections of placebo or varying doses of pramlintide, in addition to their insulin therapy, for 52 weeks.

RESULTS

Addition of pramlintide [60 microg three times daily (TID) or four times daily (QID)] to insulin led to significant reductions in HbA(1c) from baseline to Week 52 of 0.29% (P < 0.011) and 0.34% (P < 0.001), respectively, compared with a 0.04% reduction in placebo group. Three times the proportion of pramlintide- than placebo-treated patients achieved an HbA(1c) of < 7%. The greater reduction in HbA(1c) with pramlintide was achieved without an increase in concomitant insulin use and was accompanied by a significant reduction in body weight from baseline to Week 52 of 0.4 kg in the 60 microg TID (P < 0.027) or QID (P < 0.040) pramlintide treatment groups, compared with a 0.8-kg gain in body weight in the placebo group. The most common adverse event in pramlintide-treated patients was transient, mild-to-moderate nausea.

CONCLUSIONS

These results show that mealtime amylin replacement with pramlintide, as an adjunct to insulin therapy, improves long-term glycaemic and weight control in patients with Type 1 diabetes.

Biochemical identification of A-minor motifs within RNA tertiary structure by interference analysis

A-minor motifs are the most common tertiary structural elements in RNA helix packing. Biochemical identification of these interactions is now feasible using interference mapping analysis with the adenosine analogues 2'-deoxyadenosine and 3-deaza-adenosine. This approach was used to demonstrate that A-minor motifs mediate helix packing interactions that are important for 5'-splice site selection in the group I intron. By analysing the interference pattern of several analogues it is possible to identify and distinguish the four variants of the A-minor motif.

The human amylin analog, pramlintide, corrects postprandial hyperglucagonemia in patients with type 1 diabetes

Mealtime amylin replacement with the human amylin analog pramlintide as an adjunct to insulin therapy improves postprandial glycemia and long-term glycemic control in type 1 diabetes. Preclinical animal studies indicate that these complementary effects may result from at least 2 independent mechanisms: a slowing of nutrient delivery to the small intestine and a suppression of nutrient-stimulated glucagon secretion. The former effect of pramlintide has previously been demonstrated in patients with type 1 diabetes. The present studies characterize the effect of pramlintide on postprandial glucagon secretion in this patient population. Plasma glucagon and glucose concentrations were measured before and after a standardized liquid meal in 2 separate randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies of pramlintide administration to patients with type 1 diabetes. In a 2-day crossover study, 18 patients received a 5-hour intravenous infusion of pramlintide (25 microg/h or 50 microg/h) or placebo in addition to subcutaneous (SC) insulin injections. In a 14-day parallel-group study, 84 patients received SC injections of 30, 100, or 300 microg of pramlintide or placebo 3 times daily in addition to SC injections of insulin. In both studies plasma glucagon concentrations increased in response to the meal in the placebo-plus-insulin group but not in any of the pramlintide-treated groups (all pramlintide treatment arms v placebo, P <.05). We conclude that mealtime amylin replacement with pramlintide prevents the abnormal meal-related rise in glucagonemia in insulin-treated patients with type 1 diabetes, an effect that likely contributes to its ability to improve postprandial glucose homeostasis and long-term glycemic control.

An efficient ligation reaction promoted by a Varkud Satellite ribozyme with extended 5'- and 3'-termini

The Neurospora Varkud Satellite (VS) RNA is capable of promoting a reversible self-cleavage reaction important for its replication pathway. In vivo the VS RNA performs a cis-cleavage reaction to generate monomeric length transcripts that are subsequently ligated to produce circular VS RNA. The predominant form of VS RNA observed in vivo is the closed circular form, though minimal VS ribozyme self-cleavage constructs lack detectable ligation activity. MFOLD analysis of the entire VS RNA sequence revealed an extended region 5' and 3' of the minimal self-cleaving region that could anneal to form a complementary helix, which we have termed helix 7. In full-length VS RNA, this helix appears to span over 40 bp of sequence and brings the 5'- and 3'-ends of the RNA into proximity for the ligation reaction. Here we report a variant of the VS ribozyme with an extended 5'- and 3'-terminus capable of forming a truncated helix 7 that promotes the ligation reaction in vitro. Through mutation and selection of this RNA we have identified a ribozyme containing two point mutations in the truncated helix 7 that ligates with >70% efficiency. These results show that an additional helical element absent in current VS ribozyme constructs is likely to be important for the ligation activity of VS RNA.

Site specific incorporation of 6-azauridine into the genomic HDV ribozyme active site

The HDV ribozyme is proposed to catalyze its self cleavage reaction by a proton transfer mechanism wherein the N3 of its C75 acts as a general acid. The C75 to U mutation, which raises the N3 pKa from about 4 to almost 10. abolishes all enzymatic activity. To test if a U analogue with a neutral pKa can restore ribozyme function we incorporated 6-azauridine (n6U), a uridine analogue with histidine-like N3 pKa. into the genomic HDV ribozyme active site by 2'-O-ACE oligoribonucleotide protection chemistry. The resulting ribozymes were analyzed for their ability to undergo the HDV ribozyme cis-cleavage reaction. Incorporation of n6U at nucleotide position 75 did not restore ribozyme function compared to the U75 mutant. This suggests that the HDV ribozyme reaction mechanism involves more than positioning of a neutral nucleobase at the active site and implies that the exocyclic amino group of C75 participates in establishing the proper active site fold.

pH-dependent conformational flexibility within the ribosomal peptidyl transferase center

A universally conserved adenosine, A2451, within the ribosomal peptidyl transferase center has been proposed to act as a general acid-base catalyst during peptide bond formation. Evidence in support of this proposal came from pH-dependent dimethylsulfate (DMS) modification within Escherichia coli ribosomes. A2451 displayed reactivity consistent with an apparent acidity constant (pKa) near neutrality, though pH-dependent structural flexibility could not be rigorously excluded as an explanation for the enhanced reactivity at high pH. Here we present three independent lines of evidence in support of the alternative interpretation. First, A2451 in ribosomes from the archaebacteria Haloarcula marismortui displays an inverted pH profile that is inconsistent with proton-mediated base protection. Second, in ribosomes from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, C2452 rather than A2451 is modified in a pH-dependent manner. Third, within E. coli ribosomes, the position of A2451 modification (N1 or N3 imino group) was analyzed by testing for a Dimroth rearrangement of the N1-methylated base. The data are more consistent with DMS modification of the A2451 N1, a functional group that, according to the 50S ribosomal crystal structure, is solvent inaccessible without structural rearrangement. It therefore appears that pH-dependent DMS modification of A2451 does not provide evidence either for or against a general acid-base mechanism of protein synthesis. Instead the data suggest that there is pH-dependent conformational flexibility within the peptidyl transferase center, the exact nature and physiological relevance of which is not known.

Investigation of adenosine base ionization in the hairpin ribozyme by nucleotide analog interference mapping

Tertiary structure in globular RNA folds can create local environments that lead to pKa perturbation of specific nucleotide functional groups. To assess the prevalence of functionally relevant adenosine-specific pKa perturbation in RNA structure, we have altered the nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) approach to include a series of a phosphorothioate-tagged adenosine analogs with shifted N1 pKa values. We have used these analogs to analyze the hairpin ribozyme, a small self-cleaving/ligating RNA catalyst that is proposed to employ a general acid-base reaction mechanism. A single adenosine (A10) within the ribozyme active site displayed an interference pattern consistent with a functionally significant base ionization. The exocyclic amino group of a second adenosine (A38) contributes substantially to hairpin catalysis, but ionization of the nucleotide does not appear to be important for activity. Within the hairpin ribozyme crystal structure, A10 and A38 line opposite edges of a solvent-excluded cavity adjacent to the 5'-OH nucleophile. The results are inconsistent with the model of ribozyme chemistry in which A38 acts as a general acid-base catalyst, and suggest that the hairpin ribozyme uses an alternative mechanism to achieve catalytic rate enhancement that utilizes functional groups within a solvent-excluded cleft in the ribozyme active site.

Biochemical detection of monovalent metal ion binding sites within RNA

Many RNAs, including the ribosome, RNase P, and the group II intron, explicitly require monovalent cations for activity in vitro. Although the necessity of monovalent cations for RNA function has been known for more than a quarter of a century, the characterization of specific monovalent metal sites within large RNAs has been elusive. Here we describe a biochemical approach to identify functionally important monovalent cations in nucleic acids. This method uses thallium (Tl+), a soft Lewis acid heavy metal cation with chemical properties similar to those of the physiological alkaline earth metal potassium (K+). Nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) with the sulfur-substituted nucleotide 6-thioguanosine in combination with selective metal rescue of the interference with Tl+ provides a distinct biochemical signature for monovalent metal ion binding. This approach has identified a K+ binding site within the P4-P6 domain of the Tetrahymena group I intron that is also present within the X-ray crystal structure. The technique also predicted a similar binding site within the Azoarcus group I intron where the structure is not known. The approach is applicable to any RNA molecule that can be transcribed in vitro and whose function can be assayed.

A chemical phylogeny of group I introns based upon interference mapping of a bacterial ribozyme

Despite its small size, the 205 nt group I intron from Azoarcus tRNA(Ile) is an exceptionally stable self-splicing RNA. This IC3 class intron retains the conserved secondary structural elements common to group I ribozymes, but lacks several peripheral helices. These features make it an ideal system to establish the conserved chemical basis of group I intron activity. We collected nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) data of the Azoarcus intron using 14 analogs that modified the phosphate backbone, the ribose sugar, or the purine base functional groups. In conjunction with a complete interference set collected on the Tetrahymena group I intron (IC1 class), these data define a "chemical phylogeny" of functional groups that are important for the activity of both introns and that may be common chemical features of group I intron catalysts. The data identify the functional moieties most likely to play a conserved role as ligands for catalytic metal ions, the substrate helix, and the guanosine cofactor. These include backbone functional groups whose nucleotide identity is not conserved, and hence are difficult to identify by standard phylogenetic sequence comparisons. The data suggest that both introns utilize an equivalent set of long range tertiary interactions for 5'-splice site selection between the P1 substrate helix and its receptor in the J4/5 asymmetric bulge, as well as an equivalent set of 2'-OH groups for P1 helix docking into most of the single stranded segment J8/7. However, the Azoarcus intron appears to make an alternative set of interactions at the base of the P1 helix and at the 5'-end of the J8/7. Extensive differences were observed within the intron peripheral domains, particularly in P2 and P8 where the Azoarcus data strongly support the proposed formation of a tetraloop-tetraloop receptor interaction. This chemical phylogeny for group I intron catalysis helps to refine structural models of the RNA active site and identifies functional groups that should be carefully investigated for their role in transition state stabilization.

A single adenosine with a neutral pKa in the ribosomal peptidyl transferase center

Biochemical and crystallographic evidence suggests that 23S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) is the catalyst of peptide bond formation. To explore the mechanism of this reaction, we screened for nucleotides in Escherichia coli 23S rRNA that may have a perturbed pKa (where Ka is the acid constant) based on the pH dependence of dimethylsulfate modification. A single universally conserved A (number 2451) within the central loop of domain V has a near neutral pKa of 7.6 +/- 0.2, which is about the same as that reported for the peptidyl transferase reaction. In vivo mutational analysis of this nucleotide indicates that it has an essential role in ribosomal function. These results are consistent with a mechanism wherein the nucleotide base of A2451 serves as a general acid base during peptide bond formation.

Ribozyme chemogenetics

In this review I will outline several chemogenetic approaches used to determine the chemical basis of large ribozyme function and structure. The term chemogenetics was first used to describe site-specific functional group modification experiments in the analysis of DNA-protein interactions. Within the past few years equivalent experiments have been performed on large catalytic RNAs using both single-site substitution and interference mapping techniques with nucleotide analogues. While functional group mutagenesis is an important aspect of a chemogenetic approach, chemical correlates to genetic revertants and suppressors must also be realized for the genetic analogy to be intellectually valid and experimentally useful. Several examples of functional group revertants and suppressors have now been obtained within the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme. These experiments define an ensemble of tertiary hydrogen bonds that have made it possible to construct a detailed model of the ribozyme catalytic core. The model includes a functionally important monovalent metal ion binding site, a wobble-wobble receptor motif for helix-helix packing interactions, and a minor groove triple helix.

Thiophilic metal ion rescue of phosphorothioate interference within the Tetrahymena ribozyme P4-P6 domain

Divalent metal ions are essential for the folding and catalytic activities of many RNAs. A commonly employed biochemical technique to identify metal-binding sites in RNA is the rescue of Rp alpha-phosphorothioate (PS) interference by the addition of soft divalent metal ions. To access the ability of such experiments to accurately identify metal-ion coordinations within a complex RNA fold, we report metal-rescue results from the Tetrahymena group I intron P4-P6 domain, where the location and coordination of five divalent metal ions have been determined by X-ray crystallography [J.H. Cate et al., Nat Struct Biol, 1997, 4:553]. We used a native gel mobility-shift to assay for P4-P6 folding in the presence of various divalent metal ions, and found that even moderate concentrations of Mn2+ (> or =0.5 mM) can rescue PS interference at sites that do not coordinate metal ions within the P4-P6 crystal structure. To control for such effects, 2'-deoxynucleotide interference was used to titrate the Mn2+ concentration to a level that produces metal-ion-specific rescue (0.3 mM). This concentration of Mn2+ specifically rescued four of the six metal-dependent phosphorothioate effects within the RNA domain, including PS interference resulting from outer-sphere coordination to the metals. Both sites that were not specifically rescued make inner-sphere metal-ion coordinations. Cd2+ and Zn2+ afforded rescue at a smaller subset of the six metal-specific PS sites, though again phosphates making outer-sphere coordinations to metal ions were rescued preferentially. These data on P4-P6 domain folding reinforce the need for caution when interpreting metal-rescue experiments.

An important base triple anchors the substrate helix recognition surface within the Tetrahymena ribozyme active site

Key to understanding the structural biology of catalytic RNA is determining the underlying networks of interactions that stabilize RNA folding, substrate binding, and catalysis. Here we demonstrate the existence and functional importance of a Hoogsteen base triple (U300.A97-U277), which anchors the substrate helix recognition surface within the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme active site. Nucleotide analog interference suppression analysis of the interacting functional groups shows that the U300.A97-U277 triple forms part of a network of hydrogen bonds that connect the P3 helix, the J8/7 strand, and the P1 substrate helix. Product binding and substrate cleavage kinetics experiments performed on mutant ribozymes that lack this base triple (C A-U, U G-C) or replace it with the isomorphous C(+).G-C triple show that the A97 Hoogsteen triple contributes to the stabilization of both substrate helix docking and the conformation of the ribozyme's active site. The U300. A97-U277 base triple is not formed in the recently reported crystallographic model of a portion of the group I intron, despite the presence of J8/7 and P3 in the RNA construct [Golden, B. L., Gooding, A. R., Podell, E. R. & Cech, T. R. (1998) Science 282, 259-264]. This, along with other biochemical evidence, suggests that the active site in the crystallized form of the ribozyme is not fully preorganized and that substantial rearrangement may be required for substrate helix docking and catalysis.

Nucleotide analog interference mapping of the hairpin ribozyme: implications for secondary and tertiary structure formation

The hairpin ribozyme is a small, naturally occurring RNA capable of folding into a distinct three-dimensional structure and catalyzing a specific phosphodiester transfer reaction. We have adapted a high throughput screening procedure entitled nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) to identify functional groups important for proper folding and catalysis of this ribozyme. A total of 18 phosphorothioate-tagged nucleotide analogs were used to determine the contribution made by individual ribose 2'-OH and purine functional groups to the hairpin ribozyme ligation reaction. Substitution with 2'-deoxy-nucleotide analogs disrupted activity at six sites within the ribozyme, and a unique interference pattern was observed at each of the 11 conserved purine nucleotides. In most cases where such information is available, the NAIM data agree with the previously reported single-site substitution results. The interference patterns are interpreted in comparison to the isolated loop A and loop B NMR structures and a model of the intact ribozyme. These data provide biochemical evidence in support of many, but not all, of the non-canonical base-pairs observed by NMR in each loop, and identify the functional groups most likely to participate in the tertiary interface between loop A and loop B. These groups include the 2'-OH groups of A10, G11, U12, C25, and A38, the exocyclic amine of G11, and the minor groove edge of A9 and A24. The data also predict non-A form sugar pucker geometry at U39 and U41. Based upon these results, a revised model for the loop A tertiary interaction with loop B is proposed. This work defines the chemical basis of purine nucleotide conservation in the hairpin ribozyme, and provides a basis for the design and interpretation of interference suppression experiments.

A chemogenetic approach to RNA function/structure analysis

Almost two dozen nucleotide analogs have been synthesized with alpha-phosphorothioate-tagged triphosphates and utilized in an interference modification approach termed Nucleotide Analog Interference Mapping. This method has made it possible to determine the chemical basis of RNA function and structure, including the identification of new rules for RNA helix packing, the functional analysis of a binding site for monovalent metal ions within RNA and the characterization of the catalytic mechanism of RNA enzymes.

Nucleotide analog interference mapping

Single-atom substitution experiments provide atomic resolution biochemical information concerning RNA structure and function. Traditionally, these experiments are performed using chimeric RNAs generated by reassembly of full-length RNA from a synthetic substituted oligonucleotide and a truncated RNA transcript. Unfortunately, this technique is limited by the technical difficulty of assembling and measuring the effect of each singly substituted molecule in a given RNA. Here we review an alternate method for rapidly screening the effect of chemical group substitutions on RNA function. Nucleotide analog interference mapping is a chemogenetic approach that utilizes a series 5'-O-(1-thio)-nucleoside analog triphosphates to simultaneously, yet individually, probe the contribution of a functional group at every nucleotide position in an RNA molecule. A population of randomly substituted RNAs is prepared by including phosphorothioate-tagged nucleotide analogs in an in vitro transcription reaction. The active molecules in the RNA population are selected by an activity assay, and the location of the analog substitution detrimental to activity is identified by cleavage at the phosphorothioate tag with iodine and resolution of the cleavage fragments by gel electrophoresis. This method, which is as easy as RNA sequencing, is applicable to any RNA that can be transcribed in vitro and has an assayable function. Here we describe protocols for the synthesis of phosphorothioate-tagged analogs and their incorporation into RNA transcripts. The incorporation properties and unique biochemical signatures of each individual analog are discussed.

A hydrogen-bonding triad stabilizes the chemical transition state of a group I ribozyme

BACKGROUND

The group I intron is an RNA enzyme capable of efficiently catalyzing phosphoryl-transfer reactions. Functional groups that stabilize the chemical transition state of the cleavage reaction have been identified, but they are all located within either the 5'-exon (P1) helix or the guanosine cofactor, which are the substrates of the reaction. Functional groups within the ribozyme active site are also expected to assist in transition-state stabilization, and their role must be explored to understand the chemical basis of group I intron catalysis.

RESULTS

Using nucleotide analog interference mapping and site-specific functional group substitution experiments, we demonstrate that the 2'-OH at A207, a highly conserved nucleotide in the ribozyme active site, specifically stabilizes the chemical transition state by approximately 2 kcal mol-1. The A207 2'-OH only makes its contribution when the U(-1) 2'-OH immediately adjacent to the scissile phosphate is present, suggesting that the 2'-OHs of A207 and U(-1) interact during the chemical step.

CONCLUSIONS

These data support a model in which the 3'-oxyanion leaving group of the transesterification reaction is stabilized by a hydrogen-bonding triad consisting of the 2'-OH groups of U(-1) and A207 and the exocyclic amine of G22. Because all three nucleotides occur within highly conserved non-canonical base pairings, this stabilization mechanism is likely to occur throughout group I introns. Although this mechanism utilizes functional groups distinctive of RNA enzymes, it is analogous to the transition states of some protein enzymes that perform similar phosphoryl-transfer reactions.

Identification of adenosine functional groups involved in substrate binding by the ribonuclease P ribozyme

The RNA component of bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) binds to substrate pre-tRNAs with high affinity and catalyzes site-specific phosphodiester bond hydrolysis to generate the mature tRNA 5' end. Herein we describe the use of biotinylated pre-tRNA substrates to isolate RNase P ribozyme-substrate complexes for nucleotide analogue interference mapping of ribozyme base functional groups involved in substrate recognition. By using a series of adenosine base analogues tagged with phosphorothioate substitutions, we identify specific chemical groups involved in substrate binding. Only 10 adenosines in the Escherichia coli ribozyme show significant sensitivity to interference: A65, A66, A136, A232-234, A248, A249, A334, and A347. Most of these adenosine positions are universally conserved among all bacterial RNase P RNAs; however, not all conserved adenosines are sensitive to analogue substitution. Importantly, all but one of the sensitive nucleotides are located at positions of intermolecular cross-linking between the ribozyme and the substrate. One site of interference that did not correlate with available structural data involved A136 in J11/12. To confirm the generality of the results, we repeated the interference analysis of J11/12 in the Bacillus subtilis RNase P ribozyme, which differs significantly in overall secondary structure. Notably, the B. subtilis ribozyme shows an identical interference pattern at the position (A191) that is homologous to A136. Furthermore, mutation of A136 in the E. coli ribozyme gives rise to a measurable increase in the equilibrium binding constant for the ribozyme-substrate interaction, while mutation of a nearby conserved nucleotide (A132) that is not sensitive to analogue incorporation does not. These results strongly support direct participation of nucleotides in the P4, P11, J5/15, and J18/2 regions of ribozyme structure in pre-tRNA binding and implicate an additional region, J11/12, as involved in substrate recognition. In aggregate, the interference results provide a detailed chemical picture of how the conserved nucleotides adjacent to the pre-tRNA substrate contribute to substrate binding and provide a framework for subsequent identification of the specific roles of these chemical groups in substrate recognition.

A minor groove RNA triple helix within the catalytic core of a group I intron

Close packing of several double helical and single stranded RNA elements is required for the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme to achieve catalysis. The chemical basis of these packing interactions is largely unknown. Using nucleotide analog interference suppression (NAIS), we demonstrate that the P1 substrate helix and J8/7 single stranded segment form an extended minor groove triple helix within the catalytic core of the ribozyme. Because each triple in the complex is mediated by at least one 2'-OH group, this substrate recognition triplex is unique to RNA and is fundamentally different from major groove homopurine-homopyrimidine triplexes. We have incorporated these biochemical data into a structural model of the ribozyme core that explains how the J8/7 strand organizes several helices within this complex RNA tertiary structure.

A specific monovalent metal ion integral to the AA platform of the RNA tetraloop receptor

Metal ions are essential for the folding and activity of large catalytic RNAs. While divalent metal ions have been directly implicated in RNA tertiary structure formation, the role of monovalent ions has been largely unexplored. Here we report the first specific monovalent metal ion binding site within a catalytic RNA. As seen crystallographically, a potassium ion is coordinated immediately below AA platforms of the Tetrahymena ribozyme P4-P6 domain, including that within the tetraloop receptor. Interference and kinetic experiments demonstrate that potassium ion binding within the tetraloop receptor stabilizes the folding of the P4-P6 domain and enhances the activity of the Azoarcus group I intron. Since a monovalent ion binding site is integral to the tetraloop receptor, a tertiary structural motif that occurs frequently in RNA, monovalent metal ions are likely to participate in the folding and activity of a wide diversity of RNAs.

Identifying RNA minor groove tertiary contacts by nucleotide analogue interference mapping with N2-methylguanosine

Nucleotide analogue interference mapping (NAIM) is a general biochemical method that rapidly identifies the chemical groups important for RNA function. In principle, NAIM can be extended to any nucleotide that can be incorporated into an in vitro transcript by an RNA polymerase. Here we report the synthesis of 5'-O-(1-thio)-N2-methylguanosine triphosphate (m2GalphaS) and its incorporation into two reverse splicing forms of the Tetrahymena group I intron using a mutant form of T7 RNA polymerase. This analogue replaces one proton of the N2 exocyclic amine with a methyl group, but is as stable as guanosine (G) for secondary structure formation. We have identified three sites of m2GalphaS interference within the Tetrahymena intron: G22, G212, and G303. All three of these guanosine residues are known to utilize their exocyclic amino groups to participate in tertiary hydrogen bonds within the ribozyme structure. Unlike the interference pattern with the phosphorothioate of inosine (IalphaS, an analogue that deletes the N2 amine of G), m2GalphaS substitution did not cause interference at positions attributable to secondary structural stability effects. Given that the RNA minor groove is likely to be widely used for helix packing, m2GalphaS provides an especially valuable reagent to identify RNA minor groove tertiary contacts in less well-characterized RNAs.

N 2-methylguanosine is iso-energetic with guanosine in RNA duplexes and GNRA tetraloops

Modified nucleotides are resource-intensive alternatives to the four nucleotides that constitute the bulk of natural RNAs. Yet, even in cases where modifications are highly conserved, their functions are difficult to identify. One possible function might be to modulate the stability of RNA structures. To investigate this possibility for N 2-methylguanosine (m2G), which is present in a wide variety of RNAs, we have determined the thermodynamic consequences of substituting m2G for G in G-C Watson-Crick pairs and G@U wobble pairs within RNA duplexes. The m2G substitution is iso-energetic with G in all cases, except for aninternal m2G@U pair, where it has a modest (0.3 kcal/mol) stabilizing effect. We have also examined theconsequences of replacing G by m2G, and A by N 6, N 6-dimethyladenosine (m26A) in the helix 45 tetraloop of 16S rRNA, which would otherwise be a standard GNRA tetraloop. This loop is a conserved, hypermethylated region of the ribosome where methylation appears to modulate activity. m26A substitution destabilizes the tetraloop, presumably because it prevents the formation of the G@A sheared pair it would otherwise contain. m2G substitution has no effect on tetraloop stability. Together, these results suggest that m2G is equally stable as either the s-cis or s-trans rotamer. The lack of a significant effect on secondary structural stability in these systems suggests that m2G is introduced into naturally occurring RNAs for reasons other than modulation of duplex stability.

The chemical basis of adenosine conservation throughout the Tetrahymena ribozyme

Adenosines are present at a disproportionately high frequency within several RNA structural motifs. To explore the importance of individual adenosine functional groups for group I intron activity, we performed Nucleotide Analog Interference Mapping (NAIM) with a collection of adenosine analogues. This paper reports the synthesis, transcriptional incorporation, and the observed interference pattern throughout the Tetrahymena group I intron for eight adenosine derivatives tagged with an alpha-phosphorothioate linkage for use in NAIM. All of the analogues were accurately incorporated into the transcript as an A. The sites that interfere with the 3'-exon ligation reaction of the Tetrahymena intron are coincident with the sites of phylogenetic conservation, yet the interference patterns for each analogue are different. These interference data provide several biochemical constraints that improve our understanding of the Tetrahymena ribozyme structure. For example, the data support an essential A-platform within the J6/6a region, major groove packing of the P3 and P7 helices, minor groove packing of the P3 and J4/5 helices, and an axial model for binding of the guanosine cofactor. The data also identify several essential functional groups within a highly conserved single-stranded region in the core of the intron (J8/7). At four sites in the intron, interference was observed with 2'-fluoro A, but not with 2'-deoxy A. Based upon comparison with the P4-P6 crystal structure, this may provide a biochemical signature for nucleotide positions where the ribose sugar adopts an essential C2'-endo conformation. In other cases where there is interference with 2'-deoxy A, the presence or absence of 2'-fluoro A interference helps to establish whether the 2'-OH acts as a hydrogen bond donor or acceptor. Mapping of the Tetrahymena intron establishes a basis set of information that will allow these reagents to be used with confidence in systems that are less well understood.

Complementary sets of noncanonical base pairs mediate RNA helix packing in the group I intron active site

Helix packing is critical for RNA tertiary structure formation, although the rules for helix-helix association within structured RNAs are largely unknown. Docking of the substrate helix into the active site of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme provides a model system to study this question. Using a novel chemogenetic method to analyze RNA structure in atomic detail, we report that complementary sets of noncanonical base pairs (a G.U wobble pair and two consecutively stacked sheared A.A pairs) create an RNA helix packing motif that is essential for 5'-splice site selection in the group I intron. This is likely to be a general motif for helix-helix interaction within the tertiary structures of many large RNAs.

RNA seeing double: close-packing of helices in RNA tertiary structure

Structured RNA molecules play essential roles in RNA processing, chromosome maintenance and protein biosynthesis. RNA necessarily uses different strategies than proteins for folding and assembly of complex architectures. The RNA-folding problem is largely an issue of helical packing: how does RNA organize and pack short, double-helical segments to produce active sites and recognition motifs for proteins? Noncanonical base pairs, metal ions and 2'-hydroxyl groups are key elements in RNA higher-order structure formation.

Biological variation of prostate specific antigen levels in serum: an evaluation of day-to-day physiological fluctuations in a well-defined cohort of 24 patients

PURPOSE

We evaluated the daily biological variation of serum prostate specific antigen (PSA) concentrations to determine the critical difference required between 2 consecutive PSA measurements that would indicate a significant elevation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 24 men, grouped according to clinical diagnosis and PSA, underwent phlebotomy for 10 consecutive weekdays. Duplicate serum samples were measured using 3 separate lots of Tandem-E and IMx PSA assays. The biological variation was calculated and the 2 PSA assay systems were compared. The critical difference was examined to determine the percent elevation necessary to indicate (with 95% confidence) that PSA had increased beyond what would be expected from biological and analytical variation.

RESULTS

The biological variation, defined in terms of percent coefficient of variation, had a log-normal distribution with a geometric mean of 7.3% coefficient of variation and a 95th percentile value of 19.2% coefficient of variation using the Tandem-E PSA assay. Assuming an analytical variation of 5% coefficient of variation, the median critical difference was 20.5% and the 95th percentile critical difference was 45.8%. There was no significant difference between the 2 PSA assay systems in biological variation. However, PSA concentrations measured by the IMx assay were consistently lower compared to values measured by the Tandem-E assay.

CONCLUSIONS

Characterizing the biological variation of serum PSA assists in evaluating the significance of changes in serial PSA measurements. The degree of biological variation differs among patients, such that an increase between 2 consecutive PSA levels that is less than 20 to 46% may be due to biological and analytical variation. These data influence interpretation of repeated measurements of serum PSA with time.

Defining the chemical groups essential for Tetrahymena group I intron function by nucleotide analog interference mapping

Improved atomic resolution biochemical methods are needed to identify the chemical groups within an RNA that are essential to its activity. As a step toward this goal, we report the use of 5'-O-(1-thio)inosine monophosphate (IMP alphaS) in a nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) assay that makes it possible to simultaneously, yet individually, determine the contribution of almost every N2 exocyclic amine of G within a large RNA. Using IMP alphaS, we identified the exocyclic amines that are essential for 5' or 3' exon ligation by the Tetrahymena group I intron. We report that the amino groups of three phylogenetically conserved guanosines (G111, G112, and G303) are important for 3' exon ligation. The amine of G22, as well as the amines of the other four guanosines within the P1 helix, are essential for ligation of the 5' exon. Previous work has shown that point mutation of either G22 or G303 to an adenosine (A) substantially reduces activity. Like inosine, adenosine lacks an N2 amino group. Interference rescue of the G22A and G303A point mutations was detected at the site of mutation by NAIM using 5'-O-(1-thio)diaminopurine riboside monophosphate (DMP alphaS), an adenosine analog that has an N2 exocyclic amine. The G22A point mutant could also be rescued by incorporation of DMP alphaS at A24. By analogy to genetics, there are interference phenotypes comparable to loss of function, reversion, and suppression. This method can be readily extended to other nucleotide analogs for the analysis of chemical groups essential to a variety of RNA and DNA activities.

Three recognition events at the branch-site adenine

An adenosine at the branch site, the nucleophile for the first transesterification step of splicing, is nearly invariant in mammalian pre-mRNA introns. The chemical groups on the adenine base were varied systematically and assayed for formation of early spliceosome complexes and execution of the first and second steps of splicing. Recognition of constituents of the adenine is critical in formation of a U2 snRNP-containing complex on a minimal branch-site oligonucleotide. Furthermore, the efficiencies of the first and second chemical steps have different dependencies on the functional groups of the adenine. In total, the chemical groups on the adenine base at the branch site are differentially recognized during at least three different processes in the splicing of pre-mRNA. Moreover, a protein, p14, interacts with the adenine in a base-specific fashion and may mediate early recognition of this base.

Exocyclic amine of the conserved G.U pair at the cleavage site of the Tetrahymena ribozyme contributes to 5'-splice site selection and transition state stabilization

A phylogenetically conserved guanine.uracil (G.U) pair defines the 5'-exon/intron boundary of precursor RNAs containing group I introns. In this wobble base pair, the G forms two hydrogen bonds with U in a base pairing geometry shifted from that of a canonical Watson-Crick pair. On the basis of thermodynamic measurements of synthetic base pair analogs (inosine, diaminopurine riboside, guanosine, or adenosine paired with U, C, or isocytidine) in place of the G.U pair, we have previously reported that the N2 exocyclic amine of the G is important for docking the 5'-exon into the active site of the Tetrahymena ribozyme [Strobel, S. A., & Cech, T. R. (1995) Science 267, 675-679]. Here we describe kinetic characterization of ribozyme-substrate combinations containing the same series of analogs. By measuring the rate constants of 5'-exon miscleavage (cleavage at incorrect phosphates), we demonstrate that the 5'-exon/intron boundary is primarily defined by the exocyclic amine of the G. The amine makes its contribution (2.5 kcal.mol-1) in the context of all three wobble pairs tested but fails to make a significant contribution (< 0.8 kcal.mol-1) when presented in a Watson-Crick base pairing geometry. We also demonstrate that the exocyclic amine makes a modest contribution to chemical transition state stabilization (1.0 kcal.mol-1 relative to an inosine-U pair). The majority of this transition state contribution (0.7 kcal.mol-1) is independent of that contributed by the 2'-hydroxyl of the neighboring U. This argues against the model in which substantial transition state stabilization is derived from a water molecule bridging between the exocyclic amine of G and the 2'-hydroxyl of U. Instead it suggests that the tertiary interaction between the exocyclic amine and its hydrogen bonding partner in the active site is slightly improved during the chemical transition. We conclude that the exocyclic amine of G is the primary contributor to many characteristics of reactivity that have been ascribed to the conserved G.U pair, including stabilization of the chemical transition state and definition of the 5'-exon/intron boundary.

Minor groove recognition of the conserved G.U pair at the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction site

The guanine-uracil (G.U) base pair that helps to define the 5'-splice site of group I introns is phylogenetically highly conserved. In such a wobble base pair, G makes two hydrogen bonds with U in a geometry shifted from that of a canonical Watson-Crick pair. The contribution made by individual functional groups of the G.U pair in the context of the Tetrahymena ribozyme was examined by replacement of the G.U pair with synthetic base pairs that maintain a wobble configuration, but that systematically alter functional groups in the major and minor grooves of the duplex. The substitutions demonstrate that the exocyclic amine of G, when presented on the minor groove surface by the wobble base pair conformation, contributes substantially (2 kilocalories.mole-1) to binding by making a tertiary interaction with the ribozyme active site. It contributes additionally to transition state stabilization. The ribozyme active site also makes tertiary contacts with a tripod of 2'-hydroxyls on the minor groove surface of the splice site helix. This suggests that the ribozyme binds the duplex primarily in the minor groove. The alanyl aminoacyl transfer RNA (tRNA) synthetase recognizes the exocyclic amine of an invariant G.U pair and contacts a similar array of 2'-hydroxyls when binding the tRNA(Ala) acceptor stem, providing an unanticipated parallel between protein-RNA and RNA-RNA interactions.

The 2,6-diaminopurine riboside.5-methylisocytidine wobble base pair: an isoenergetic substitution for the study of G.U pairs in RNA

Phylogenetically invariant G.U wobble pairs are present in a wide variety of RNA's. As a means to study the contribution of individual chemical groups within a G.U pair, we have synthesized and thermodynamically characterized oligoribonucleotides containing the unnatural nucleosides 2,6-diaminopurine riboside (DAP) and 5-methylisocytidine (MeiC). The DAP.MeiC pair at the end of an RNA duplex is as stable as a G.U pair, consistent with formation of a wobble base pair with two hydrogen bonds. DAP.MeiC is a valuable substitution for the study of G.U wobble pairs because it is conformationally similar to the G.U pair, but has a different array of functional groups in the major and minor grooves of the duplex and a reversed hydrogen bonding polarity between the bases. We also report the stability of several other terminal pairs proposed to be in a wobble configuration including inosine.U (I.U), A.MeiC, DAP.C, A.C, G.5-methyl-U,2'-deoxyguanosine.U, and 2'-deoxy-7-deazaguanosine.U. These pairs present a diversity of functional group substitutions in the context of a wobble conformation. Comparison of wobble pairs with and without the N2 exocyclic amine, i.e., G.U vs I.U, DAP.MeiC vs A.MeiC, and DAP.C vs A.C, demonstrates that the amine does not contribute to base pairing stability when the pair is located at the terminal position of the RNA duplex. However, at a position internal to the duplex, the exocyclic amine does improve helix stability. An internal I.U pair is less stable (approximately 1 kcal.mol-1) than an internal G.U pair, and substantially less stable (approximately 2 kcal.mol-1) than an internal A-U pair. These data provide quantitation for the reduced duplex stability observed upon conversion of A-U to I.U pairs by double-stranded RNA adenosine deaminase (dsRAD). This collection of wobble pairs will help identify the contribution made by individual functional groups in RNA/protein interactions and in the tertiary folding of RNA.

Replacement of the conserved G.U with a G-C pair at the cleavage site of the Tetrahymena ribozyme decreases binding, reactivity, and fidelity

There is a phylogenetically conserved G.U pair at the 5'-splice site of group I introns. When this is mutagenized to a G-C pair, splicing of these introns is greatly reduced. We have used a ribozyme derived from the Tetrahymena group I intron to compare the binding and reactivity of oligonucleotides that form either a G.U or a G-C pair at this position. Ribozyme binding of oligonucleotides at 42 degrees C was measured by native gel electrophoresis and equilibrium dialysis. Binding of GGCCCUCC (C(-1)P), which base-pairs with the ribozyme guide sequence to form a G-C at the cleavage site, was 10-fold weaker than the binding of GGCCCUCU (U(-1)P), which maintains the conserved G.U pair at the cleavage site. This is surprising since a terminal G-C enhances the binding between oligonucleotides by 20-fold relative to a terminal G.U. Thermal denaturation studies indicate that C(-1)P and several analogs with deoxy substitutions bind the guide-sequence oligonucleotide, GGAGGGAAA, as strongly as they bind the ribozyme. In contrast, U(-1)P binds 240-fold more strongly to the ribozyme than to GGAGGGAAA, a difference that is decreased by deoxy substitutions. Thus, while U(-1)P binds the ribozyme through a combination of base-pairing and specific 2-OH and other tertiary interactions, C(-1)P may bind by base-pairing alone. The substrate GGCCCUCCAAAAA (C(-1)S) is cleaved 100-fold more slowly than GGCCCUCUAAAAA (U(-1)S) and also has a higher propensity to be cleaved at the wrong nucleotide position.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Translocation of an RNA duplex on a ribozyme

RNA cleavage by the Tetrahymena ribozyme requires recognition of the reaction-site helix by the catalytic apparatus. This binding can occur in several registers, each of which results in reaction at a different nucleotide in the helix. We now identify commensurate sets of 2'-hydroxyl interactions on both strands of the reaction-site helix that account for its translocation into alternative binding registers. These results indicate that the ribozyme has a relatively rigid substrate-binding pocket into which the helix can bind in different alignments. A similar mechanism of reaction site recognition is proposed to occur during intron circularization and ribozyme polymerase activity. Translocation of the reaction site duplex provides an example of structural heterogeneity in packing of helices during the tertiary folding of RNA.

Tertiary interactions with the internal guide sequence mediate docking of the P1 helix into the catalytic core of the Tetrahymena ribozyme

The L-21 ScaI ribozyme catalyzes sequence-specific cleavage of an oligonucleotide substrate. Cleavage is preceded by base pairing of the substrate to the internal guide sequence (IGS) at the 5' end of the ribozyme to form a short RNA duplex (P1). Tertiary interactions between P1 and the catalytic core dock P1 into the active site of the ribozyme. These include interactions between the catalytic core and 2'-hydroxyls of the substrate at nucleotide positions -3u and perhaps -2c. In this study, 2'-hydroxyls of the IGS strand that contribute to P1 recognition by the ribozyme are identified. IGS 2'-hydroxyls (nucleotide positions 22-27) were individually modified to either 2'-deoxy or 2'-methoxynucleotides within full-length semisynthetic L-21 ScaI ribozymes generated using T4 DNA ligase. Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of the resulting IGS variant ribozymes justify the following conclusions: (i) 2'-Hydroxyls at nucleotide positions G22 and G25 play a critical energetic role in docking P1 into the catalytic core, contributing 2.6 and 2.1 kcal.mol-1, respectively. (ii) The loss of binding energy is manifest primarily as an increase in the rate of dissociation. Because turnover for the wild-type ribozyme is limited by product dissociation, G22 and G25 deoxy variants display up to a 20-fold increase in the multiple-turnover rate at saturating substrate. (iii) IGS tertiary interactions are energetically coupled with the tertiary interactions made to the substrate, consistent with P1 becoming undocked from its binding site in J8/7 upon substitution of either the G22 or G25 2'-hydroxyl. (iv) The G22 deoxy variant loses energetic coupling between guanosine and substrate binding, suggesting that in this variant the P1 helix is also undocked from its binding site in J4/5, the proposed site of guanosine and substrate interaction. Therefore, in combinations with previous studies four P1 2'-hydroxyls are implicated as important for docking. The contributions of the 2'-hydroxyl tertiary interactions are not equivalent and follow the hierarchical order G22 > G25 >> -3u > -2c. Because the G22 2'-hydroxyl appears to mediate P1 docking into both J8/7 and J4/5, it may serve as the molecular linchpin for the recognition of P1 by the catalytic core.

Site-specific cleavage of human chromosome 4 mediated by triple-helix formation

Direct physical isolation of specific DNA segments from the human genome is a necessary goal in human genetics. For testing whether triple-helix mediated enzymatic cleavage can liberate a specific segment of a human chromosome, the tip of human chromosome 4, which contains the entire candidate region for the Huntington's disease gene, was chosen as a target. A 16-base pyrimidine oligodeoxyribonucleotide was able to locate a 16-base pair purine target site within more than 10 gigabase pairs of genomic DNA and mediate the exact enzymatic cleavage at that site in more than 80 percent yield. The recognition motif is sufficiently generalizable that most cosmids should contain a sequence targetable by triple-helix formation. This method may facilitate the orchestrated dissection of human chromosomes from normal and affected individuals into megabase sized fragments and facilitate the isolation of candidate gene loci.

Single-site enzymatic cleavage of yeast genomic DNA mediated by triple helix formation

Physical mapping of chromosomes would be facilitated by methods of breaking large DNA into manageable fragments, or cutting uniquely at genetic markers of interest. Key issues in the design of sequence-specific DNA cleaving reagents are the specificity of binding, the generalizability of the recognition motif, and the cleavage yield. Oligonucleotide-directed triple helix formation is a generalizable motif for specific binding to sequences longer than 12 base pairs within DNA of high complexity. Studies with plasmid DNA show that triple helix formation can limit the operational specificity of restriction enzymes to endonuclease recognition sequences that overlap oligonucleotide-binding sites. Triple helix formation, followed by methylase protection, triple helix-disruption, and restriction endonuclease digestion produces near quantitative cleavage at the single overlapping triple helix-endonuclease site. As a demonstration that this technique may be applicable to the orchestrated cleavage of large genomic DNA, we report the near quantitative single-site enzymatic cleavage of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae genome mediated by triple helix formation. The 340-kilobase yeast chromosome III was cut uniquely at an overlapping homopurine-EcoRI target site 27 base pairs long to produce two expected cleavage products of 110 and 230 kilobases. No cleavage of any other chromosome was detected. The potential generalizability of this technique, which is capable of near quantitative cleavage at a single site in at least 14 megabase pairs of DNA, could enable selected regions of chromosomal DNA to be isolated without extensive screening of genomic libraries.

Site-specific cleavage of a yeast chromosome by oligonucleotide-directed triple-helix formation

Oligonucleotides equipped with EDTA-Fe can bind specifically to duplex DNA by triple-helix formation and produce double-strand cleavage at binding sites greater than 12 base pairs in size. To demonstrate that oligonucleotide-directed triple-helix formation is a viable chemical approach for the site-specific cleavage of large genomic DNA, an oligonucleotide with EDTA-Fe at the 5' and 3' ends was targeted to a 20-base pair sequence in the 340-kilobase pair chromosome III of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Double-strand cleavage products of the correct size and location were observed, indicating that the oligonucleotide bound and cleaved the target site among almost 14 megabase pairs of DNA. Because oligonucleotide-directed triple-helix formation has the potential to be a general solution for DNA recognition, this result has implications for physical mapping of chromosomes.

Sequence and structural requirements of a mitochondrial protein import signal defined by saturation cassette mutagenesis

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae F1-ATPase beta subunit precursor contains redundant mitochondrial protein import information at its NH2 terminus (D. M. Bedwell, D. J. Klionsky, and S. D. Emr, Mol. Cell. Biol. 7:4038-4047, 1987). To define the critical sequence and structural features contained within this topogenic signal, one of the redundant regions (representing a minimal targeting sequence) was subjected to saturation cassette mutagenesis. Each of 97 different mutant oligonucleotide isolates containing single (32 isolates), double (45 isolates), or triple (20 isolates) point mutations was inserted in front of a beta-subunit gene lacking the coding sequence for its normal import signal (codons 1 through 34 were deleted). The phenotypic and biochemical consequences of these mutations were then evaluated in a yeast strain deleted for its normal beta-subunit gene (delta atp2). Consistent with the lack of an obvious consensus sequence for mitochondrial protein import signals, many mutations occurring throughout the minimal targeting sequence did not significantly affect its import competence. However, some mutations did result in severe import defects. In these mutants, beta-subunit precursor accumulated in the cytoplasm, and the yeast cells exhibited a respiration defective phenotype. Although point mutations have previously been identified that block mitochondrial protein import in vitro, a subset of the mutations reported here represents the first single missense mutations that have been demonstrated to significantly block mitochondrial protein import in vivo. The previous lack of such mutations in the beta-subunit precursor apparently relates to the presence of redundant import information in this import signal. Together, our mutants define a set of constraints that appear to be critical for normal activity of this (and possibly other) import signals. These include the following: (i) mutant signals that exhibit a hydrophobic moment greater than 5.5 for the predicted amphiphilic alpha-helical conformation of this sequence direct near normal levels of beta-subunit import (ii) at least two basic residues are necessary for efficient signal function, (iii) acidic amino acids actively interfere with import competence, and (iv) helix-destabilizing residues also interfere with signal function. These experimental observations provide support for mitochondrial protein import models in which both the structure and charge of the import signal play a critical role in directing mitochondrial protein targeting and import.