Economic evaluation of treatment for acute lymphoblastic leukaemia in childhood

Berlin-Frankfurt-Munster (BFM) and Dana-Farber Cancer Institute (DFCI) consortia's treatment strategies for acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) in children are widely used. We compared the health effects and monetary costs of hospital treatments for these two strategies. Parents of children treated at seven centres in Canada, Italy and the USA completed health-related quality of life (HRQL) assessments during four active treatment phases and at 2 years after treatment. Mean HRQL scores were used to calculate quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) for a period of 5 years following diagnosis. Total costs of treatment were determined from variables in administrative databases in a universally accessible and publicly funded healthcare system. Valid HRQL assessments (n = 1200) were collected for 307 BFM and 317 DFCI patients, with costs measured for 66 BFM and 28 DFCI patients. QALYs per patient were <1.0% greater for BFM than DFCI. Median HRQL scores revealed no difference in QALYs. The difference in mean total costs for BFM (US$88 480) and DFCI (US$93 026) was not significant (P = 0.600). This study provides no evidence of superiority for one treatment strategy over the other. Current BFM or DFCI strategies should represent conventional management for the next economic evaluation of treatments for ALL in childhood.

Health-related quality of life during post-induction chemotherapy in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia in remission

Using a multi-attribute approach, we and others have reported on the comprehensive health status of survivors of cancer in childhood, after completion of therapy. However, there is a dearth of information about health status and associated health-related quality of life (HRQL) in children and adults with cancer, during the treatment process; a deficit which this study was intended to redress. All children (n=18) receiving 'maintenance' chemotherapy for acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) at a single institution were assessed prospectively through a single cycle of therapy. Patients, family members and health care professionals used global ratings, the health utilities index mark 2 (HUI2) and mark 3 (HUI3) classification systems, and detailed descriptions of temporary states of health, to provide independent assessments of health status at weekly intervals. Utility scores were derived for each comprehensive health state and for single attribute levels of the HUI2 system, and for the temporary health state descriptions. The classification of the subjects into the most appropriate temporary health states was challenging even for older children and some of the parents. The HUI instruments were used much more easily and produced highly comparable information. The most frequently affected attributes were pain, emotion and mobility/ambulation; in that order. The global (p=0.005) and specific morbidity burdens were, as predicted, greatest in the middle of the cycle of chemotherapy, reflecting the toxicity of steroid use. HUI2 global utility scores demonstrated moderate responsiveness with an intra-class correlation coefficient of 0.43. Cyclical administration of therapy, in particular corticosteroids, produces important changes in health status and HRQL in children with ALL. The HUI are valid and responsive systems for quantifying the burden of morbidity during the treatment of cancer in childhood. These are sensitive tools which can be used in a wide array of other circumstances to quantify changes in health status.

The monetary costs of childhood cancer to the families of patients

The medical costs of cancer treatment are well described, but there are few reports of expenses incurred by families of children with malignant disease. The objective of this study was to describe the monetary costs borne by families of patients with childhood cancer and to determine whether these costs represent an important component of the burden of illness. Families completed a prospective diary survey about daily expenses incurred during each sample week of therapy. We also undertook a retrospective, cross-sectional questionnaire survey about expenses, incurred during the entire duration of treatment, associated with major or one-time cost items. Seventy families of children treated for high risk acute lymphoblastic leukemia, 19 families of children treated for Wilms' tumor stages 2-5, and 16 families of children treated for neuroblastoma stages 3 and 4 completed diaries or questionnaires detailing the costs resulting from the diseases and their treatment. The mean total expenses (in 1986 Canadian dollars) incurred by families of childhood cancer patients over the entire course of therapy are $26,070 for acute lymphoblastic leukemia? $20,074 for Wilms' tumour, and $10,376 for neuroblastoma. On-going weekly costs rather than major one-time purchases account for the largest share of expenses. Overall, in spite of universal first dollar coverage for medical care in Canada, family-borne costs during the course of these illnesses are at least one-third of the average family's after-tax income.

A multiattribute approach to health-status measurement and clinical management illustrated by an application to brain-tumors in childhood

A comprehensive multi-attribute system was devised to assess global morbidity burden. The system was used to obtain qualitative and quantitative measures of health-status for a case series of survivors of brain tumors in childhood. Health-related quality-of-life scores for each global health-state were calculated from a utility function derived from measures of preferences collected during surveys of a random sample of parents of school age children in the general public (n=194). Global multi-attribute health status (MAHS) utility scores revealed a wide range of severity in morbidity burden. We suggest that the assessment of health-related quality-of-life should become an integral part of clinical management.

Bleeding disorders, menorrhagia and iron deficiency: impacts on health-related quality of life

von Willebrand disease (VWD) is a bleeding disorder that occurs in up to 1% of the general population. The great majority of females with VWD experience menorrhagia. The morbidity burden in females with VWD may relate to iron deficiency resulting from menorrhagia. To explore relationships between bleeding disorders, menorrhagia, iron deficiency and the outcomes of health-related quality of life (HRQL) and educational attainment. All subjects with VWD, and females with other bleeding disorders, in the Canadian national registry who were more than 12 years of age were eligible for survey. Survey measures included the HEALTH UTILITIES INDEX(®); abridged Clinical History Assessment Tool; socio-demographic questions and serum ferritin. Statistical analyses included testing differences among groups of means using analysis of variance and of proportions using chi-squared test. Significant size differences in mean HRQL scores were detected between VWD females and both females with other bleeding disorders [diff = (-0.08); P = 0.017] and VWD males [diff = (-0.07); P = 0.039]. Mean HRQL scores differed between females with and without menorrhagia (P < 0.001). Mean HRQL scores were not significantly different between females with and without iron deficiency. Educational attainment was not associated with disease group, menorrhagia status or iron status. Females with VWD have a greater morbidity burden than females in the general population, females with other bleeding disorders and males with VWD. Menorrhagia is associated with low HRQL scores in females with bleeding disorders, including VWD. Further investigation should assess how menorrhagia impacts HRQL in females with bleeding disorders.

Development, reliability and validity of a new measure of overall health for pre-school children

BACKGROUND

Few comprehensive systems are available for assessing and reporting the overall health of preschool children.

OBJECTIVES

(i) To develop a multi-dimension health status classification system (HSCS) to describe pre-school (PS) children 2.5-5 years of age; (ii) to report reliability and validity of the newly developed measure.

DESIGN

Existing systems (Health Utilities Index, Mark 2 and 3) were adapted for application to a pre-school population. The new system was tested for acceptability, validity and reliability.

PARTICIPANTS

Three cohorts of children and their parents from Canada and Australia were utilized: Cohort 1 (MAC)-101 3-years old very low birthweight (VLBW, <1500 g) and 50 same age term children from Canada; Cohort 2 (AUS)-150 VLBW 3-years old from Australia; Cohort 3 (OMG)-222 3-years old with cerebral palsy (CP) from Ontario.

METHODS

Parental intra-rater reliability was evaluated by completion of the HSCS-PS Parent questionnaire (MAC) at the clinic visit and again 14 days later. Health professionals (MAC) completed the HSCS-PS Clinician questionnaire. Percent agreement and Kappa values were used to assess parent-clinician agreement. Concurrent validity was tested in two populations of VLBW children (MAC and AUS) and a reference group of term children (MAC) by exploring the relationships between dimensions of the HSCS-PS and well-recognized norm-referenced measures: the Bayley Scales of Infant Development (BSID-II), the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (VABS) and the Stanford-Binet (SB). Construct validity was tested by comparing ratings on both the HSCS-PS and the Gross Motor Function classification system (GMFCS) using a population of pre-school children with CP. Analyses were done using chi2, ANOVA and correlations with tau-b statistic.

RESULTS

The HSCS-PS has 12 dimensions and 3-5 levels per dimension. Response rate for parental intra-rater reliability was 95%, with percent agreement ranging between 86 and 100%. Kappa values for various dimensions ranged from 0.38 to 1.00. Inter-rater reliability between parents and clinicians showed agreement ranging from 72 to 100%. Kappa values ranged from 0.30 to 1.00. CONCURRENT VALIDITY: There was a statistically significant gradient between HSCS-PS Mobility levels and motor scale scores of the BSID-II and VABS. A significant gradient also occurred when comparing HSCS-PS cognition levels to psychometric scores on the BSID-II and SB, as well as HSCS-PS self-care levels compared to VABS Daily Living scores. DISCRIMINATIVE AND CONSTRUCT VALIDITY: Birthweight category was shown to be a significant determinant of proportion of children with multiple HSCS-PS dimensions affected. In addition, HSCS-PS dimension levels were congruent with GMFCS levels where expected: mobility had excellent correlation; self-care, dexterity, speech and cognitive dimensions had moderate correlations.

CONCLUSIONS

The HSCS-PS is readily accepted, quick to complete, widely applicable and provides a multi-dimensional description of health status. Preliminary assessments of reliability and validity are promising. The HSCS-PS can discriminate across populations by birthweight and shows strong relationships with standardized psychometric measures in comparable domains. It can pro- vide a summary profile of functional limitations in various populations of pre-school children in a consistent manner across programs and in different settings.

Inter-observer agreement of a comprehensive health status classification system for pre-school children among patients with Wilms' tumor or advanced neuroblastoma

We assessed inter-observer agreement on a new comprehensive health status classification system for preschool children (CHSCS-PS). Prospective assessments of children aged 2-4.9 years at the time of diagnosis of neuroblastoma (stages 3-4, excluding 4S) or Wilms' tumor (stages II-V) were collected independently from a parent and nurse by self-report during therapy. Responses were used to determine functional status on 10 health domains, as well as an overall disability score. Inter-observer agreement was evaluated by a kappa statistic for agreement about levels within individual domains, and by an intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) for agreement of overall disability scores. Twenty-four parent/nurse pairs of assessments were collected. Agreement was almost perfect for mobility and self-care, substantial for emotion and pain, and slight for speech. There was high percent agreement for vision, hearing, dexterity, learning and remembering, and thinking and problem solving, but insufficient variability in responses to calculate a kappa statistic. The ICC for overall disability scores between observers was 0.86, indicating strong agreement. Given the need for, and paucity of, instruments for the measurement of health-related quality of life in very young children, these results strongly support further evaluation of the CHSCS-PS.

Health status of young children during therapy for advanced neuroblastoma

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to describe the health status experienced by young children during various phases of therapy for advanced neuroblastoma.

METHODS

Nineteen patients aged 2.00-4.99 years at the time of diagnosis of neuroblastoma (stages 3 or 4) who received active therapy between 1996 and 2000 were enrolled on the study. Their parents provided proxy assessments of their health status at a maximum of 10 assessment points during therapy using the Comprehensive Health Status Classification System for Pre-school Children (CHSCS-PS), which assesses level of function on 10 separate health domains.

RESULTS

Eighty-six assessment questionnaires were completed. Maximum morbidity was reported immediately following diagnosis and in the 2-3 weeks following bone marrow transplantation. The greatest morbidity was observed in the pain, self-care, mobility, and emotion domains.

CONCLUSIONS

In addition to facing a high risk of mortality, young children being treated for advanced neuroblastoma also experience considerable morbidity.

Health status and health-related quality of life in survivors of cancer in childhood in Latin America: a MISPHO feasibility study

Cancer is an increasing cause of disease-related death in childhood within developing countries, where the great majority of the world's children reside. The improving prospects for survival in such children, and the corresponding challenge of undertaking economic evaluations of related health interventions, provide a stimulus to study the health-status and health-related quality of life in survivors of cancer in childhood in Latin America. Spanish language versions of questionnaires for proxy assessors, based on the Health Utilities Index (HUI), were used to elicit responses from parents and physicians. The HUI is a family of multi-attribute, generic, preference-linked measures of health status and health-related quality of life that are reliable, responsive and valid, and have been used previously in pediatric oncology. Valid responses were received from 178 parents and 144 physicians in 6 centres in 4 countries (Cuba, Honduras, Colombia and Uruguay). For children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia the major morbidity burdens were in the attributes of emotion, cognition and pain. The overall burden of morbidity was greater in children with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. In survivors of Hodgkin's disease and Wilms' tumor the attributes most affected were emotion and pain. In general, there was considerable agreement between the assessments provided independently by parents and physicians. This study demonstrates the feasibility of conducting such measurements in developing countries, and reveals similarities in health status and health-related quality of life to comparable populations in more privileged societies.

Visual analog scales: do they have a role in the measurement of preferences for health states?

Visual analog scales (VASs) have long been used as a method of measuring preferences for health outcomes. They are easy and inexpensive to implement, can be administered quickly, and lend themselves to self-completion. Over time, however, disturbing questions have emerged concerning the validity of the VAS approach. This article reviews briefly the history, theory, practice, problems, and advantages of VASs; presents some suggestions to improve the validity of VASs; and recommends a limited but useful role for VASs in the process of measuring preferences for health states.

Venous disease treatment and compliance: the nursing role

This article explores the numerous factors that influence compliance in the management of venous disease. The nurse's/health practitioner's role is highlighted as being pivotal in promoting compliance or non-compliance. The literature suggests there are many components that influence compliance, varying from impersonal relationships, treatment regimes and psychosocial influences. This implies that compliance is a shared responsibility between the healthcare practitioner/nurse and the patient. Holistic assessment incorporating negotiated care plans will provide the foundation of a partnership in care. Nurses have a responsibility to empower the patients with the necessary knowledge and skills to enable them to be an active participant in their own treatment/life regimes. Nurse education is key to effective, tolerable treatments that are acceptable to patients.

Health-related quality of life in survivors of Wilms' tumor and advanced neuroblastoma: aA cross-sectional study

PURPOSE

In pediatric oncology, Wilms' tumor and advanced neuroblastoma represent opposite ends of the spectra of survival probability and therapeutic intensity. Consequently, it was envisaged that survivors of Wilms' tumor would enjoy better health status and health-related quality of life (HRQL) than survivors of advanced neuroblastoma.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Health status questionnaires were sent to the parents of all eligible children and to the children themselves if they were > or = 8 years of age. Responses were received from 84% of 93 eligible families. Responses were converted by established algorithms into levels of two multiattribute health status classification systems known as Health Utilities Index Mark 2 and Mark 3. These systems are linked to measures of preference, in the form of multiattribute utility functions, which provide scores of morbidity for single-attribute levels and of global HRQL for comprehensive health states.

RESULTS

A greater burden of morbidity was identified in the survivors of advanced neuroblastoma than in survivors of Wilms' tumor based on the assessments of the parents of these children. In particular, survivors of advanced neuroblastoma exhibited deficits in hearing and speech. It is possible that this morbidity burden reflects the prevalent use of platinum compounds (causing ototoxicity) in this group. Within parent-child dyads there was a high level of percentage agreement on responses in all attributes except cognition.

CONCLUSION

Extension of this study to a larger sample size of patients will provide clarification of these observations.

Assessment of health status and health-related quality of life in survivors of Hodgkin's disease in childhood

Although the great majority of children with Hodgkin's disease survive with modern treatment strategies, the list of late sequelae is long, yet there is no published information on the comprehensive health status and health-related quality of life (HRQL) in this population. In the experience of a single institution, survivors of Hodgkin's disease in childhood were invited to self-report on their health status using a 15-item questionnaire connected to the Health Utilities Index, a series of multi-attribute health status classification systems that, in turn, are linked to preference functions which provide single-attribute and global utility scores for HRQL. The mean global utility score was 0.85 (on a 0 = dead to 1. 0 = perfect health scale), a figure less than that in survivors of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) but comparable to that in survivors of brain tumors (0.84) or extremely low birthweight (ELBW 0.82). The burden of morbidity is emphasized by the ratio of the numbers of health states per patient:0.67 for survivors of Hodgkin's disease, 0.66 for survivors of brain tumors, 0.39 for survivors of ELBW, 0.47 for survivors of high-risk ALL and 0.28 for survivors of standard-risk ALL. In Hodgkin's disease survivors, the attributes affected most commonly and severely were pain, cognition and emotion. This experience demands exploration of the health status and HRQL in a much larger cohort of such survivors, perhaps in the context of co-operative group studies.

Chronic pain in a family of 6 in the context of litigation

We describe a family of 6 (2 parents and 4 children), evaluated 6 and 8 years after a minor car accident for chronic pain. A near identical complex of multiple physical, constitutional, and psychological symptoms were shared by all family members, all of whom bore the diagnosis of fibromyalgia. The case was brought to court after nearly a decade of symptomatology and extensive use of the health care system. The minor compensation awarded was consumed ultimately by legal fees. Psychosocial/personality issues and iatrogenic and medico-legal contributions in the evolution and resolution of the legal claim are discussed.

German cross-cultural adaptation of the Health Utilities Index and its application to a sample of childhood cancer survivors

Steady progress in developing effective treatments for childhood cancer and other severe pediatric diseases has established the need to consider the nature and frequency of late physical and psychological effects. The Health Utilities Index Mark 2 and Mark 3 (HUI2/3) systems were developed by Feeny, Furlong, Torrance et al. in Canada. These systems are generic multi-attribute measures of a person's health status and health-related quality of life. The first German version of the Canadian HUI2/3 questionnaire was created in our clinic, following recommended guidelines for cross-cultural adaptation of health-related quality of life measures. The usefulness of the resultant version was investigated using a sample of 142 patients who presented to our oncological outpatients' department for a routine health care visit after completion of treatment. The 15 items of the HUI2/3-questionnaire were answered independently by three groups of assessors--nurses, physicians, and parents or patients. Two additional questions covered ratings of the severity of treatment effects and the specification of these effects. The questionnaire was both easy to use and acceptable to the assessors. Percentage agreement between observers about levels for individual attributes ranged from 56% to 100%, with the lowest agreement on the subjective attributes of emotion, pain and cognition. These results are in accordance with previous studies using the original instrument. HUI2 global utility scores were significantly related to ratings of treatment sequelae, giving support to the discriminant validity of the measure.

CONCLUSION

The German version of HUI2/3 is a useful instrument with generally high inter-observer agreement and good suitability for outcome measurement in childhood cancer patients. Further research is needed to assess the usefulness of the instrument in other clinical populations and its sensitivity in longitudinal studies.

Parental perspectives of the health status and health-related quality of life of teen-aged children who were extremely low birth weight and term controls

OBJECTIVES

To compare the health status and health-related quality of life of teen-aged children who were extremely low birth weight (ELBW) with matched controls from the perspective of their parents.

STUDY DESIGN

Geographically defined cohort; longitudinal follow-up; cross-sectional interviews.

PARTICIPANTS

parents of 149/169 (88%) ELBW children between 12 and 16 years of age (including 41 children with neurosensory impairments) and 126/145 (87%) parents of term controls. Health status of the teenagers was classified according to the 6 attributes of the Health Utilities Index Mark 2, based on information obtained during parent interviews. Parents were asked to imagine themselves living in their own child's health state and 4 preselected hypothetical health states when providing directly measured standard gamble utility scores.

RESULTS

Parents of ELBW children reported a higher frequency and more complex functional limitations than parents of controls for their own children's health status. Also, the mean utilities were lower (ELBW =.91 vs controls =. 97) and the variability in their scores was greater. There were no differences in the valuation of the hypothetical health states provided by parents of ELBW and control children.

CONCLUSIONS

ELBW children were reported to have a greater burden of disability than were control children based on parental descriptions. Nonetheless, parents of ELBW children, on average, rated the health-related quality of life of their children fairly high. Thus, differences in reported functional status are not necessarily associated with lower utility scores.

Health Utilities Index Mark 3: evidence of construct validity for stroke and arthritis in a population health survey

BACKGROUND

The Health Utilities Index Mark 3 (HUI3) is a comprehensive, compact health status classification and health state preference system. The HUI3 system has been included in 4 Canadian population health surveys and numerous clinical trials.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the construct validity of the HUI3 for the measurement of health-related quality of life (HRQL) and attribute-specific morbidity in respondents to the 1990 Ontario Health Survey reported to have arthritis or stroke. The authors assessed (1) whether those with stroke, arthritis, and both conditions had lower HRQL scores than those with neither condition and (2) whether HUI3 detects morbidity in specific health attributes affected by arthritis and stroke. Stroke (but not arthritis) were expected to affect speech and cognition; arthritis (but not stroke) to affect pain; both to affect mobility, dexterity, and emotion; and neither to affect vision and hearing.

RESEARCH DESIGN

Linear regression models of HRQL and attribute-specific utilities were estimated as a function of 3 indicator variables of health problem (stroke only, arthritis only, both) and variables included to reduce confounding.

RESULTS

Subjects with stroke, arthritis, and both conditions had substantially lower HRQL than those with neither condition. Stroke subjects had greater morbidity in speech and cognition than arthritis subjects; somewhat surprisingly, pain morbidity was only slightly higher among arthritis subjects; neither condition affected vision or hearing. These associations were robust to various model specifications.

CONCLUSIONS

The HUI3 system appears valid for measuring health status and HRQL for stroke and arthritis in the context of a noninstitutionalized population health survey.

Differences in preferences for neonatal outcomes among health care professionals, parents, and adolescents

CONTEXT

In neonatal intensive care, parents make important clinical management decisions in conjunction with health care professionals. Yet little information is available on whether preferences of health care professionals and parents for the resulting health outcomes differ.

OBJECTIVE

To measure and compare preferences for selected health states from the perspectives of health care professionals (ie, neonatologists and neonatal nurses), parents of extremely low-birth-weight (ELBW) or normal birth-weight infants, and adolescents who were either ELBW or normal birth-weight infants.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional cohort study.

SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS

A total of 742 participants were recruited and interviewed between 1993 and 1995, including 100 neonatologists from hospitals throughout Canada; 103 neonatal nurses from 3 regional neonatal intensive care units; 264 adolescents (aged 12-16 years), including 140 who were ELBW infants and 124 sociodemographically matched term controls; and 275 parents of the recruited adolescents.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

Preferences (utilities) for 4 to 5 hypothetical health states of children were obtained by direct interviews using the standard gamble method.

RESULTS

Overall, neonatologists and nurses had similar preferences for the 5 health states, and a similar proportion rated some health states as worse than death (59% of neonatologists and 68% of nurses; P=.20). Health care professionals rated the health states lower than did parents of ELBW and term infants (P<.001). Overall, 64% of health care professionals and 45% of parents rated 1 or more health states to be worse than death (P<.001). Differences in mean utility scores between health care professionals and parents and adolescent respondents were most pronounced for the 2 most severely disabled health states (P<.001).

CONCLUSIONS

When asked to rate the health-related quality of life for the hypothetical conditions of children, health care professionals tend to provide lower utility scores than do adolescents and their parents. These findings have implications for decision making in the neonatal intensive care unit.

Health-related quality of life in survivors of tumours of the central nervous system in childhood--a preference-based approach to measurement in a cross-sectional study

There is an evident need to measure the comprehensive burden of morbidity experienced by survivors of brain tumours in childhood. To this end, a questionnaire based on the Health Utilities Index mark 2 (HUI2) and mark 3 (HUI3) systems was completed independently for a cohort of such children by their parents, by a nurse, by physicians and by a selected group of the children themselves. Each of the HUI2 and HUI3 systems consists of a multi-attribute health status classification scheme linked to a preference function which provides utility scores for levels within single attributes (domains of health) and for global health states. All eligible families (n = 44) participated. Even cognitively impaired children of at least 9.5 years of age could complete the questionnaire. The greatest burden of morbidity, occurring in two-thirds of children, was in the attribute of cognition. Surprisingly, almost one-third of children experienced pain. Global health status was lowest in children who underwent radiotherapy before the age of 5 years and the corresponding utility scores were related inversely to the volume irradiated. Children with demonstrable disease had lower scores than those in whom disease was not evident. There was a high level of agreement (intraclass correlation coefficients > 0.5) on formal assessment of inter-rater reliability for global health-related quality of life utility scores. The usefulness of measures of health status and health-related quality of life, in children surviving brain tumours, has been demonstrated by this study.

Applicability of the Health Utilities Index to a population of childhood survivors of central nervous system tumours in the U.K

This paper describes the application of a multi-attribute, preference-linked health status and health-related quality of life measurement system--the Health Utilities Index (developed in Canada)--to a group of subjects in the U.K. Children who had survived tumours of the central nervous system (n = 30, age 6-16 years) formed the study group. Respondents (children, parents, physicians and physiotherapists) found the activity (completion of a 15-item questionnaire) to be acceptable and not burdensome (it was accomplished easily by all children > or = 10 years of age). Instrumental reliability was established by acceptable intra- and interobserver agreement and construct validity was supported by strong similarities between the results obtained in this study and those reported from a similar group of children in Canada. The greatest burden of morbidity was reported for the attributes of emotion and cognition (each affected in > 50% of the children). Pain was surprisingly prevalent (affected in approximately one-third of children). The finding of a large number of unique health states emphasises the complex morbidity burden experienced by these children who self-reported poorer overall health (as reflected in utility scores) than did the proxy respondents. The information obtained from this study is readily interpretable and clinically useful. The results of this study also illustrate that extreme caution must be exercised in undertaking linguistic modifications to established instruments for, in this instance, these resulted in a loss of the ability to detect the most severe emotional morbidity and reduced the comparability of results between studies. With this provision, the Health Utilities Index is evidently applicable in the U.K. and the original version has been recommended for use in brain tumour studies by the U.K. CCSG (the U.K. Children's Cancer Study Group).

Self-reported comprehensive health status of adult brain tumor patients using the Health Utilities Index

BACKGROUND

The comprehensive health status of adult survivors of brain tumors is largely unexplored.

METHODS

Using a multiattribute approach embodied in a 15-item self-assessment questionnaire, the overall burden of morbidity was measured in 50 brain tumor patients who were attending a neurooncology outpatient clinic. The comprehensive health status was accorded utility scores, and comparisons were made with health status measurements of the general population.

RESULTS

The questionnaire was completed with ease by 90% of the respondents. Among the respondents, only 10% of the patients did not report some form of morbidity, and 80% reported multiple impairments. The most prevalent impairments occurred in the attributes of sensation, emotion, and cognition (in this predominantly ambulant group); each of these elements was limited in the majority of patients. A surprising finding was the self-report of pain by nearly 50% of the respondents.

CONCLUSIONS

In this group of patients, the burden of morbidity and its complexity greatly exceeded that reported for the general population and were inadequately revealed by Karnofsky performance scores. The use of multiattribute health status measurement tools offers numerous advantages and should be employed in the routine clinical management of cancer patients.

Does it matter whom and how you ask? inter- and intra-rater agreement in the Ontario Health Survey

A large amount of information in the 1990 Ontario Health Survey (OHS) was collected from proxy respondents using questions administered in face-to-face interviews. Can this type of information represent candid self-reported measures of health status? Inter-rater agreement was assessed using Cohen's kappa statistic for responses to questions that were answered both by individuals about themselves and by proxies on their behalf. Intra-rater agreement, assessing the effect of mode of survey administration (in-person interviews versus self-completed written questionnaires) on the responses, was also investigated using the kappa statistic. We conclude that: (1) proxy responses in the OHS for impairments of emotion and pain are not reliable indicators of self-response (kappa < 0.32) because proxy respondents consistently under-report the burden of morbidity; (2) levels of morbidity reported by subjects to interviewer-administered questionnaires may underestimate morbidity, relative to morbidity reported by subjects using self-administered questionnaires completed in privacy. We also hypothesize that the relative magnitudes of inaccuracy introduced by interviewer administration relative to proxy reporting depends on the phenomenon being measured. When assessing pain, mode of administration is quantitatively a more important source of disagreement than type of respondent.

Economic evaluation of allogeneic bone marrow transplantation: a rudimentary model to generate estimates for the timely formulation of clinical policy

PURPOSE

To provide an evidence-based approach to the formulation of clinical policy with respect to allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) that involves perceived trade offs between two major factors: costs and consequences. The report also highlights key informational deficiencies.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Adults with acute myeloid leukemia (AML) in second complete remission (2CR) and those with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) in first complete remission (1CR) were assigned to BMT or control groups solely on the availability of a suitable donor. All hospital-borne costs were estimated, based on services used according to manual chart review, in four categories: diagnostic and therapeutic costs, professional fees, drug costs, and ward costs. Incremental costs and incremental life-years were calculated, and the quotient determined a cost per life-year gained by BMT for AML (2CR) and ALL (1CR).

RESULTS

The incremental cost (in 1992 Canadian dollars) per life-year gained by BMT (cost-effectiveness) for AML (2CR) was $29,200; and for ALL (1CR) it was minus $29,200.

CONCLUSION

For AML (2CR), allogeneic BMT creates better outcomes than standard treatment, but is more costly. For ALL (1CR), both the costs and outcomes are similar for BMT and standard therapy. Quality adjustments made to life-years gained did not change these conclusions.

Typhoid fever in the park: epidemiology of an outbreak at a cultural interface

The number of reported outbreaks of typhoid fever in the United States has recently increased. Only six were reported from 1980-1989, but seven outbreaks were reported in 1990. In August 1990, health officials in Montgomery County, Maryland, were notified of two cases of typhoid fever among persons who had attended both a family picnic attended by 60 persons and a Latin Food Festival attended by 100,000 people. We obtained interviews, blood and stool cultures, and Vi serologies from attendees at and food handlers for the picnic. We defined cases as culture-confirmed or probable. Of the 60 picnic attendees, 24 (40%) had cases, of which 16 were culture confirmed. Those who ate potato salad were at increased risk of disease (17/32 vs. 6/28, relative risk [RR] = 2.5, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.1-5.4). Picnic attendees who also attended the Latin Food Festival were not at significantly greater risk of disease than those who did not, (11/22 vs. 13/38, RR = 1.5, CI = 0.8-2.7) and we found no evidence of disease among other festival attendees. The potato salad was prepared with intensive handling and without adequate temperature control by a recent immigrant from El Salvador who was asymptomatic, did not attend the picnic, had Salmonella typhi (S. typhi) in her stool, and had elevated Vi antibodies, strongly suggestive of the carrier state. Outbreaks of typhoid fever are a threat for cosmopolitan communities. While currently available control measures are unlikely to prevent all outbreaks, thorough investigation can identify previously unrecognized carriers.

Multi-attribute health status classification systems. Health Utilities Index

In this article, multi-attribute approaches to the assessment of health status are reviewed with a special focus on 2 recently developed systems, the Health Utilities Index (HUI) Mark II and Mark III systems. The Mark II system consists of 7 attributes: sensation, mobility, emotion, cognition, self-care, pain and fertility. The Mark III system contains 8 attributes: vision, hearing, speech, ambulation, dexterity, emotion, cognition and pain. Each attribute consists of multiple levels of functioning. A combination of levels across the attributes constitutes a health state. The HUI systems are deliberately focused on the fundamental core attributes of health status, and on the capacity of individuals to function with respect to these attributes. Thus, the measure obtained constitutes a pure description of health status, uncontaminated by differential opportunity or preference. Multi-attribute systems provide a compact but comprehensive framework for describing health status for use in population health and programme evaluation studies. An important advantage of such systems is their ability to simultaneously provide detail on an attribute-by-attribute basis and to capture combinations of deficits among attributes. An additional advantage is their compatibility with multi-attribute preference functions, which provide a method for computing a summary health-related quality-of-life score for each health state.

Reliability of the Health Utilities Index--Mark III used in the 1991 cycle 6 Canadian General Social Survey Health Questionnaire

This study presents information on the test-retest reliability of the Health Utility Index--Mark III (HUI) system used in cycle 6 of the Canadian General Social Survey (GSS). The HUI system used in this reliability study consists of an eight-attribute health status classification system (HSCS) and a function for generating a summary score of health-related quality of life. To estimate test-retest reliability, a stratified random sample of individuals (n = 506) completing GSS telephone interviews during August and September, 1991 were interviewed again 1 month later. Weighting adjustments based on the probability of selection were invoked during the analyses to provide unbiased estimates of test-retest reliability for all GSS respondents in the August-September period. The results indicate that the individual questions, attributes and provisional index scores generally provided reliable information on health status in the GSS. The exceptions to this were limitations in speech and dexterity which were reported very infrequently. Kappa estimates of test-retest reliability for individual questions varied from 0.184 to 0.766. For the eight attributes, kappa estimates varied from 0.137 to 0.728. Using the provisional index scores to quantify health overall, a test-retest reliability of 0.767 was obtained (intra-class correlation coefficient).

Multi-attribute preference functions. Health Utilities Index

Multi-attribute utility theory, an extension of conventional utility theory, can be applied to model preference scores for health states defined by multi-attribute health status classification systems. The type of preference independence among the attributes determines the type of preference function required: additive, multiplicative or multilinear. In addition, the type of measurement instrument used determines the type of preference score obtained: value or utility. Multi-attribute utility theory has been applied to 2 recently developed multi-attribute health status classification systems, the Health Utilities Index (HUI) Mark II and Mark III systems. Results are presented for the Mark II system, and ongoing research is described for the Mark III system. The theory is also discussed in the context of other well known multi-attribute systems. The HUI system is an efficient method of determining a general public-based utility score for a specified health outcome or for the health status of an individual. In clinical populations, the scores can be used to provide a single summary measure of health-related quality of life. In cost-utility analyses, the scores can be used as quality weights for calculating quality-adjusted life years. In general populations, the measure can be used as quality weights for determining population health expectancy.

Evaluating treatments for childhood cancer. A process for critical appraisal of the literature and a summary of the results

An overview of published studies on three common cancers in childhood was conducted to estimate the effectiveness and consequences of treatment. Of 1,016 separate citations, 316 were reviewed in detail but only 162 were deemed to be "useful." An approach to a structured appraisal of the literature is presented.

Comparison of the health-related quality of life of extremely low birth weight children and a reference group of children at age eight years

OBJECTIVES

To estimate and compare the health-related quality of life (HRQOL) of extremely low birth weight (ELBW) children and a reference group of children at age 8 years.

DESIGN

The study utilized a utility equation from preference measures derived from a random sample of 194 general-population parents surveyed in 1987. This equation was applied to multiattribute health state descriptions of the study participants. Utilities can be used to estimate a single cardinal value between 0.0 and 1.0 (0 = dead; 1 = perfect health) to reflect the global HRQOL for that individual.

SETTING

Geographically defined region in central-west Ontario, Canada.

PARTICIPANTS

One hundred fifty-six ELBW survivors born between 1977 and 1982, and 145 reference children from the general population, matched for age, sex, and socioeconomic status to the index cases.

RESULTS

Mean HRQOL scores were lower for ELBW (0.82, SD 0.21) than for reference group (0.95, SD 0.07; p < 0.0001). The ELBW group had greater variability in HRQOL scores (p < 0.001), and the distribution was such that 50% of ELBW children but only 10% of the reference group had scores < 0.88. Only 14% of ELBW children were assigned HRQOL scores of 1.0, compared with 50% of reference subjects (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate that from the perspective of the general population, the overall long-term burden experienced by ELBW children is greater than that for reference children. The methods used to assess HRQOL have wide applicability for evaluation of different treatment programs.

Comprehensive assessment of the health status of extremely low birth weight children at eight years of age: comparison with a reference group

OBJECTIVE

To apply a multiattribute health status (MAHS) classification system to data available on two cohorts of school-aged children to describe several dimensions of health simultaneously. The MAHS system describes both the type and severity of functional limitations according to seven attributes: sensation, mobility, emotion, cognition, self-care, pain, and fertility (fertility not applicable in this study), with four or five levels of function within each attribute.

DESIGN

The MAHS system was applied retrospectively to clinical and psychometric data collected prospectively at age 8 years. MAHS application was by selection of items from the database and development of computer-assisted algorithms to assign functional levels within each attribute.

SETTING

Geographically defined region in central-west Ontario, Canada.

PARTICIPANTS

One hundred fifty-six extremely low birth weight (ELBW) survivors born between 1977 and 1982 (follow-up rate 90%) and 145 reference children matched for age, sex, and socioeconomic status.

RESULTS

14% of ELBW subjects had no functional limitations, 58% had reduced function for one or two attributes, and 28% had at least three affected. The corresponding figures for the reference group were 50%, 48%, and 2% (p < 0.0001). The limitations were more severe and complex in the ELBW group, and were notably in cognition (58%), sensation (48%), mobility (21%), and self-care (17%), compared with 28%, 11%, 1%, and 0% for reference children (all p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

These data indicate that fewer ELBW than reference children were free of functional limitations and a significantly higher proportion had multiple attributes affected. The MAHS classification approach is a useful instrument to compare the health status of different groups and populations, and to monitor changes with time.

An assessment of global health status in survivors of acute lymphoblastic leukemia in childhood

PURPOSE

Progressive improvement in survival rates of children with cancer demands an appraisal of the "cost of cure." Much information is available on the frequency and severity of individual late effects in long-term survivors, but there are few data on multiple sequelae in individual patients or on global morbidity burdens.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

To address this issue, we developed a multiattribute health status classification system. This consists of three to five levels of function within each of seven attributes: sensation, mobility, emotion, cognition, self-care, pain, and fertility. The system was applied to survivors of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL).

RESULTS

Overall burdens of morbidity were greater in those who had had "high-risk" disease than in children treated less intensively for "standard-risk" ALL. Deficits in emotional and cognitive status were especially common (alone and in combination). These were more prevalent in younger patients and exhibited a dose relationship to cranial irradiation.

CONCLUSIONS

Such appraisals of morbidity must be compared with prevalence rates in the general population.

Economic evaluation of cardiac rehabilitation soon after acute myocardial infarction

Although there are extensive clinical evaluations of cardiac rehabilitation after acute myocardial infarction (AMI), no full economic evaluation is available. Patients with AMI and mild to moderate anxiety or depression, or both, while still in hospital were randomized to either an 8-week rehabilitation intervention (n = 99) or usual care (n = 102). Comprehensive costs and health-related quality of life, measured with the time trade-off preference score, were obtained in a 12-month trial, and together with survival data derived from published meta-analyses, cost-utility and cost-effectiveness of early cardiac rehabilitation were estimated. The best estimate of the incremental net direct 12-month costs for patients randomized to rehabilitation was $480 (United States, 1991)/patient. During 1-year follow-up, rehabilitation patients had fewer "other rehabilitation visits" (p < 0.0001) and gained 0.052 quality-adjusted life-year more than did the group with usual care. The cost-utility ratio was $9,200/quality-adjusted life-year gained with cardiac rehabilitation during the year of follow-up. This economic evaluation of cardiac rehabilitation does not consider the important distinctions between affordability and worth of alternative health-care services. The data provide evidence that brief cardiac rehabilitation initiated soon after AMI for patients with mild to moderate anxiety or depression, or both, is an efficient use of health-care resources and may be economically justified.

The comprehensive assessment of health status in survivors of childhood cancer: application to high-risk acute lymphoblastic leukaemia

The health status of 69 survivors of high-risk acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) is assessed using a multi-attribute classification system. Seven attributes are included: sensation, mobility, emotion, cognition, self-care, pain and fertility. Three to five levels of functioning are defined for each attribute. Comprehensive health states are described as a specific combination of seven attribute levels. The system captures combinations of sequelae. The system provides a compact but comprehensive tool for long term follow up of survivors of childhood cancer. The results underscore the cognitive and emotional burdens of morbidity affecting survivors of high-risk ALL.

A comprehensive multiattribute system for classifying the health status of survivors of childhood cancer

PURPOSE

A multiattribute health status classification system was devised to describe comprehensively the health status of survivors of childhood cancer.

METHODS

The system consists of seven attributes: sensation, mobility, emotion, cognition, self-care, pain, and fertility. Three to five levels of functioning are defined for each attribute. Any specific combination of seven attribute levels constitutes a health state. In the first survey, the system was used to classify the health status of 20 children currently undergoing therapy for high-risk acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL), Wilms' tumor, or neuroblastoma, and eight who had completed treatment. A second survey consisted of 13 children with brain tumors on active treatment.

RESULTS

In general, independent ratings by clinicians were in agreement, and consensus was readily achieved in 1 to 2 minutes per patient. Children on therapy experienced a higher burden of morbidity than those off treatment. Brain tumor patients experienced more morbidity than patients in the first survey.

CONCLUSION

The multiattribute system provides a compact but comprehensive tool for long-term follow-up of survivors of childhood cancer. It captures both multiple sequelae and varying levels of severity. By using a mathematical utility function, a single summary score of health-related quality of life may be assigned to each health state. Additional studies to establish reproducibility, validity, responsiveness, and generalizability are indicated.

Penfluridol, a peroral long-acting neuroleptic, for the maintenance treatment of schizophrenic patients who relapse

In a multicenter collaborative study, 28 newly readmitted schizophrenic patients, stabilized for one week on short-acting neuroleptic drugs, had their medication abruptly changed to penfluridol given once a week on an outpatient basis. The average dose required for maintenance was approximately 40 mg weekly. Analysis of BPRS evaluations carried out during the 16-week trial revealed a significant linear trend toward further improvement. Social functioning, as measured by the KAS questionnaire in the outpatient period of the trial, also revealed a significant linear trend toward improvement. Significant worsening was not found with any psychometric evaluation. Side effects, when observed, were neither frequent nor severe. Three laboratory and vital sign values showed significant changes: increase in BUN concentrations, decrease in pulse rate, and increase in body weight. The changes in weight and pulse appeared to be within relatively normal ranges, and the increase in BUN concentrations did not appear to be clinically significant. During the first part of a long-term study, penfluridol received a high degree of patient acceptability and is a welcome addition to the maintenance treatment of schizophrenia.