Learning to karyotype in the university environment: a computer-based virtual laboratory class (KaryoLab) designed to rationalize time for the tutor/researcher and to encourage more students to engage in cytogenetics

The ability to karyotype G-banded chromosome preparations is an essential skill for chromosome biologists. For this reason, the teaching of the rudiments of G banding analysis forms an integral part of the curriculum in many biology and genetics degree courses. The way in which karyotyping is usually taught involves providing the students with a photograph of G-banded chromosomes, a pair of scissors and some glue from which they can cut out the chromosomes and build the karyotype. This has the disadvantage that large amounts of time are taken in cutting and pasting and comparatively little in learning pattern recognition of individual chromosomes. In this paper we describe the development of a computer-based student practical class "KaryoLab". To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of a teaching tool that combines instruction in cytogenetic analysis with both formative and summative feedback to the student and a virtual elimination of marking time for the tutor. Chromosome research and diagnostics will only continue while there are sufficiently motivated and trained individuals to perform it. We see the software developed here as a significant step towards training and motivating students in cytogenetics.

Chromosome rearrangements between chicken and guinea fowl defined by comparative chromosome painting and FISH mapping of DNA clones

Chromosome homology between chicken (Gallus gallus) and guinea fowl (Numida meleagris) was investigated by comparative chromosome painting with chicken whole chromosome paints for chromosomes 1-9 and Z and by comparative mapping of 38 macrochromosome-specific (chromosomes 1-8 and Z) and 30 microchromosome-specific chicken cosmid DNA clones. The comparative chromosome analysis revealed that the homology of macrochromosomes is highly conserved between the two species except for two inter-chromosomal rearrangements. Guinea fowl chromosome 4 represented the centric fusion of chicken chromosome 9 with the q arm of chicken chromosome 4. Guinea fowl chromosome 5 resulted from the fusion of chicken chromosomes 6 and 7. A pericentric inversion was found in guinea fowl chromosome 7, which corresponded to chicken chromosome 8. All the chicken microchromosome-specific DNA clones were also localized to microchromosomes of guinea fowl except for several clones localized to the short arm of chromosome 4. These results suggest that the cytogenetic genome organization is highly conserved between chicken and guinea fowl.

Chromosome assignment of eight SOX family genes in chicken

Chromosome locations of the eight SOX family genes, SOX1, SOX2, SOX3, SOX5, SOX9, SOX10, SOX14 and SOX21, were determined in the chicken by fluorescence in situ hybridization. The SOX1 and SOX21 genes were localized to chicken chromosome 1q3.1-->q3.2, SOX5 to chromosome 1p1.6-->p1.4, SOX10 to chromosome 1p1.6, and SOX3 to chromosome 4p1.2-->p1.1. The SOX2 and SOX14 genes were shown to be linked to chromosome 9 using two-colored FISH and chromosome painting, and the SOX9 gene was assigned to a pair of microchromosomes. These results suggest that these SOX genes form at least three clusters on chicken chromosomes. The seven SOX genes, SOX1, SOX2, SOX3, SOX5, SOX10, SOX14 and SOX21 were localized to chromosome segments with homologies to human chromosomes, indicating that the chromosome locations of SOX family genes are highly conserved between chicken and human.

Safety issues in assisted reproduction technology: Should men undergoing ICSI be screened for chromosome abnormalities in their sperm?

The incidence of aneuploidy in gametes of men undergoing ICSI has raised the prospect of there being risks associated with ICSI and the question of whether or not to screen men for sperm aneuploidy before treatment. We report results of a questionnaire undertaken to address how IVF staff perceive this problem, whether ICSI men are already being screened for sperm aneuploidy and the extent to which IVF specialists feel that there is merit in such a test. The results suggest that this is seen as a problem but most feel the risks outweigh the benefits. Most claimed their clinics do not screen sperm for aneuploidy but feel that there is merit in doing so. There are considerable benefits to screening i.e. couples would get additional information about the genetic repercussions of ICSI and could make informed decisions before treatment; screening would also facilitate the design of a large research study to give clearer answers on the safety of ICSI. However, we acknowledge counter arguments i.e. families would not necessarily benefit as most would have the ICSI procedure regardless of screen results; sex chromosome trisomies clinically are not severe enough to worry about in this context and there are other potential risks of ICSI that screening would not address.

X/XY/XYY mosaicism as a cause of subfertility in boars: a single case study

Sex chromosome abnormalities are common in mammals and humans and are often associated with subfertility. In this study a boar with normal sperm parameters was indicated to have reduced prolificacy from figures obtained for return rate, farrowing rate and total number of piglets born. G-banded cytogenetic analysis of peripheral blood identified an abnormal mosaic sex chromosome constitution 39,XYY[74]/38,XY[23]/37,X[3]. Cytogenetic analysis of fibroblasts confirmed this mosaic karyotype with similar percentages of cell lines observed 39,XYY[76]/38,XY[19]/37,X[5]. External genitalia revealed a poorly developed scrotum with the right testicle being smaller than the left. To the best of our knowledge this is the first time that this chromosome constitution has been reported in the pig. It is of particular interest that this karyotype is associated with reduced boar fertility, which could lead to potential economic losses if such a boar were selected for breeding purposes.

Molecular-cytogenetic analysis reveals sequence differences between the sex chromosomes of Oreochromis niloticus: evidence for an early stage of sex-chromosome differentiation

Sex determination in the Nile tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus, is primarily genetic, with XX females and XY males. A candidate sex-determining region in the terminal region of the largest chromosome pair has been identified by analysis of meiotic chromosomes. This region shows an inhibition of pairing and synapsis in the XY genotype, but not in XX or YY genotypes, suggesting that recombination is inhibited. Here we show that chromosome microdissection and subsequent amplification by degenerate oligonucleotide-primed PCR (DOP-PCR) can be used to produce in situ hybridization probes to this largest pair of O. niloticus chromosomes. Furthermore, analysis of the comparative hybridization of X and Y chromosome-derived probes to different genotypes provides the first demonstration that sequence differences exist between the sex chromosomes of O. niloticus. This provides further support for the theory that this chromosome pair is related to sex determination and further suggests that the sex chromosomes are at a very early stage of divergence.

Identification of putative sex chromosomes in the blue tilapia, Oreochromis aureus, through synaptonemal complex and FISH analysis

Sex determination in the blue tilapia, Oreochromis aureus, is primarily a ZW female-ZZ male system. Here, by analysis of the pachytene meiotic chromosomes of O. aureus, we demonstrate the presence of two distinct regions of restricted pairing present only in heterogametic fish. The first, a subterminal region of the largest bivalent is located near to the region of unpairing found in the closely related species O. niloticus, while the second is in a small bivalent, most of which was unpaired. These results suggest that O. aureus has two separate pairs of sex chromosomes.

Karyotype evolution in Tilapia: mitotic and meiotic chromosome analysis of Oreochromis karongae and O. niloticus x O. karongae hybrids

The karyotype of Oreochromis species is considered to be highly conserved, with a diploid chromosome complement of 2n = 44. Here we show, by analysis of mitotic and meiotic chromosomes, that the karyotype of O. karongae, one of the Lake Malawi 'chambo' species, is 2n = 38. This difference in chromosome number does not prevent the production of inter-specific hybrids between O. niloticus (2n = 44) and O. karongae (2n = 38). Analysis of the meiotic chromosomes of the O. niloticus x O. karongae hybrids indicates that three separate chromosome fusion events have occurred in O. karongae. Comparison of the O. karongae and O. niloticus karyotypes suggests that these consist of one Robertsonian fusion and two fusions of a more complex nature.

Micro- and macrochromosome paints generated by flow cytometry and microdissection: tools for mapping the chicken genome

Despite the chicken being one of the most genetically mapped of all animals, its karyotype remains poorly defined. This is primarily due to microchromosomes that belie assignment by conventional methods. To address this problem, we have developed chromosome-specific paints using flow cytometry and microdissection. For the microchromosomes it was necessary to amplify and label DNA from single microdissected chromosomes.

Comparative painting reveals strong chromosome homology over 80 million years of bird evolution

Chickens and the great flightless emu belong to two distantly related orders of birds in the carinate and ratite subclasses that diverged at least 80 million years ago. In the first ZOO-FISH study between bird species, we hybridized single chromosome paints from the chicken (Gallus domesticus) onto the emu chromosomes. We found that the nine macrochromosomes show remarkable homology between the two species, indicating strong conservation of karyotype through evolution. One chicken macrochromosome (4) was represented by a macro- and a microchromosome in the emu, suggesting that microchromosomes and macrochromosomes are interconvertible. The chicken Z chromosome paint hybridized to the emu Z and most of the W, confirming that ratite sex chromosomes are largely homologous; the centromeric region of the W which hybridized weakly may represent the location of the sex determining gene(s).

Diagnosis of sex and cystic fibrosis status in fetal erythroblasts isolated from cord blood

Diagnosis of fetal cells in the maternal circulation will obviate the need for invasive sampling procedures. It is essential however, before this can be put into wide clinical practice, that a reliable isolation procedure and a simple, robust means of genotyping rare fetal cells be developed. A relatively inexpensive, sensitive diagnostic procedure which can detect single gene defects and/or aneuploidy is fluorescent PCR. This has been used extensively in molecular diagnostics including preimplantation diagnosis but, to our knowledge, has not been applied widely for the diagnosis of isolated fetal erythroblasts. Here we used cord blood as a model system for fetal cells in the maternal circulation: we isolated erythroblasts on a glass slide, employed a simple micromanipulation technique to place them into a PCR tube and then applied fluorescent PCR to diagnose sex and cystic fibrosis status in 10 patients. Nine samples had a normal cystic fibrosis status, one patient, however, had a mutant allele suggesting that this fetus was a carrier for cystic fibrosis. Fluorescent PCR has virtually limitless potential in the genotyping of rare fetal cells isolated from the maternal circulation.

Functional evidence of novel tumor suppressor genes for cutaneous malignant melanoma

Losses of heterozygosity involving chromosomes 9 and 10 are frequent events in the development and progression of cutaneous malignant melanoma. To investigate whether specifically deleted chromosomal regions encode tumor suppressor genes (TSGs), we introduced normal chromosome 10 into the tumorigenic human metastatic melanoma cell line UACC-903 by microcell fusion. In addition, two chromosome 9 derivatives that were microdeleted in the region of the p16INK4A/p15INK4B locus were transferred to determine whether an additional melanoma TSG or TSGs reside on chromosome 9p, as indicated by previous melanoma allele loss studies. In comparison to parental cells, microcell hybrids generated with chromosomes 9 (microdeleted) and 10 displayed reduced anchorage-independent growth in soft agar and markedly reduced tumorigenicity in athymic (nu/nu) mice. These data define a TSG or TSGs that function independently of p15/p16 on chromosome 9 and provide evidence for a TSG (or TSGs) on chromosome 10 that may be important in melanoma development.

A telomere-independent senescence mechanism is the sole barrier to Syrian hamster cell immortalization

Reactivation of telomerase and stabilization of telomeres occur simultaneously during human cell immortalization in vitro and the vast majority of human cancers possess high levels of telomerase activity. Telomerase repression in human somatic cells may therefore have evolved as a powerful resistance mechanism against immortalization, clonal evolution and malignant progression. The comparative ease with which rodent cells immortalize in vitro suggests that they have less stringent controls over replicative senescence than human cells. Here, we report that Syrian hamster dermal fibroblasts possess substantial levels of telomerase activity throughout their culture life-span, even after growth arrest in senescence. In our studies, telomerase was also detected in uncultured newborn hamster skin, in several adult tissues, and in cultured fibroblasts induced to enter the post-mitotic state irreversibly by serum withdrawal. Transfection of near-senescent dermal fibroblasts with a selectable plasmid vector expressing the SV40 T-antigen gene resulted in high-frequency single-step immortalization without the crisis typically observed during the immortalization of human cells. Collectively, these data provide an explanation for the increased susceptibility of rodent cells to immortalization (and malignant transformation) compared with their human equivalents, and provide evidence for a novel, growth factor-sensitive, mammalian senescence mechanism unrelated to telomere maintenance.

Evaluating the culture of fetal erythroblasts from maternal blood for non-invasive prenatal diagnosis

Fetal erythroblasts circulating in maternal blood are important candidate cells for non-invasive prenatal diagnosis. We have cultured erythroblasts from 16 maternal blood samples, both with and without prior enrichment by magnetic activated cell sorting (MACS), in a semi-solid medium containing growth factors. Individual colonies were examined by PCR with sex chromosome-specific primers and microsatellite marker primers. No conclusive Y-chromosome specific amplification could be demonstrated in any of the 16 cases, even when the mother was confirmed to be carrying a male fetus. All colonies tested by microsatellite marker PCR were of maternal origin. Our results suggest that the probability of obtaining fetal colonies from fetal erythroblasts circulating in maternal blood is very low and that approaches for culturing fetal erythroblasts in vitro cannot yet be used reliably for prenatal diagnosis using current methods for fetal cell enrichment.

Defining the anatomy of the Rangifer tarandus sex chromosomes

A comprehensive cytogenetic characterization of the unusally large reindeer (Rangifer tarandus) sex chromosomes is presented for the purpose of studying the evolution of these atypical gonosomes. Sex chromosome idiograms were constructed from G-banded and C-banded chromosomes to illustrate the relative amounts and locations of euchromatin and heterochromatin. Hybridization with a Mazama gouazoubira X whole-chromosome paint revealed that essentially all reindeer X-linked euchromatin and most reindeer Y-linked euchromatin is conserved interspecifically. Subsequently, painting probes were generated from flow-sorted reindeer X chromosomes, flow-sorted reindeer Y chromosomes, and from microdissections of specific gonosomal regions to establish specific segment-to-segment homologies between these gonosomes. In particular, one microdissection-generated paint demonstrated that certain constituent repetitive DNAs, found in C-band region Xq31, were also present in essentially all heterochromatin blocks of the Y chromosome. Microdissection-generated paints from other X-linked heterochromatin blocks revealed the presence of DNA sequences that lacked homologous sequences on the Y chromosomes and were more specific for their region of origin. These characteristics of the reindeer sex chromosomes are consistent with the notion that mammalian sex chromosomes were derived from homologous progenitor chromosome pairs and provide insights into the evolution of these atypical mammalian gonosomes.

Chromosome specific comparative genome hybridisation for determining the origin of intrachromosomal duplications

Chromosome specific comparative genome hybridisation (CGH) is a novel approach for the detection of cytogenetic abnormalities. It combines flow sorting of chromosomes, degenerate oligonucleotide primed (DOP)-PCR and a modified comparative genome hybridisation (CGH) technique to define the site and extent of intrachromosomal duplications. Chromosome specific paint probes for aberrant chromosomes and their normal homologues from four subjects with unbalanced duplications within chromosomes 2p11-15, 3q25-26, 5q34-qter, and 12q23-24.2 were made. They were then cohybridised on normal metaphase spreads and the ratio of their relative intensities of hybridisation analysed. The results were compared to those of similar experiments where regular CGH was performed on the same four patients. We provide evidence that this method can detect duplications and deficiencies which might be missed by conventional CGH, as the ratio of hybridisation of abnormal/normal DNA is 2:1 rather than 3:2. It is the method of choice where mosaicism is present or where only one of several homologous chromosomes is duplicated. Furthermore, it suggests that DOP-PCR amplifies all or most of the euchromatic regions of the genome equally.

Alphoid variant-specific FISH probes can distinguish autosomal meiosis I from meiosis II non-disjunction in human sperm

Over the past few years, several groups have used fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) to study aneuploidy in human sperm. Several important observations have derived from these studies, including the demonstration of chromosome-specific variation in non-disjunction frequencies, and the possible association of aneuploidy with environmental agents and with increasing paternal age. However, an important technical limitation of these studies has been the inability to distinguish between autosomal non-disjunction occurring at meiosis I and meiosis II. In the present report, we describe a simple FISH-based approach designed to overcome this limitation. Using oligonucleotide probes capable of distinguishing subtle differences in the alpha satellite sequences of chromosome 17, we demonstrate that (in appropriate heterozygotes) it is possible to simultaneously identify disomic sperm and to determine the meiotic stage of origin of the additional chromosome. This novel approach has important implications for future FISH sperm studies, since the ability to distinguish between meiosis I and meiosis II non-disjunction will make it possible to determine whether putative etiological agents affect chromosome segregation at both, or only one, of the two meiotic stages.

Cytogenetic analysis of spontaneous abortions: comparison of techniques and assessment of the incidence of confined placental mosaicism

Cytogenetic studies on spontaneous abortions traditionally have used one of two methodologies, direct preparations or long-term culture, to determine the chromosome constitution of either the cytotrophoblast or villous stroma, respectively. Few studies have utilized both techniques simultaneously to compare the relative efficiencies of each method and to assess the contribution of confined placental mosaicism (CPM). The present report summarizes cytogenetic studies on 691 consecutive spontaneous abortions using long-term culture, direct preparations, or both. All 691 cases were analyzed by long-term culture and 177 cases were analyzed using both long-term culture and direct preparations. The results indicate that the two methods have similar success rates, 82% for long-term culture and 76% for direct preparation; however, the proportion of normal females was significantly increased in the culture method, presumably attributable to maternal contamination. In 107 cases, results were obtained from both methods with 22 discrepancies identified. However, most of these involved a 46,XX result in culture, consistent with maternal contamination in the cultured preparation. Therefore, to estimate the proportion of CPM we excluded cases with a 46,XX result in culture and found four (6.1%) of the remaining 65 cases to be consistent with CPM. These cases consisted of normal or mosaic aneuploid cytotrophoblast and non-mosaic aneuploid villous stroma. These studies suggest that each method has specific advantages in the analysis of spontaneous abortions. Direct preparations are less prone to maternal contamination, but certain chromosome abnormalities are more likely to be identified using long-term culture.

Sex ratio in normal and disomic sperm: evidence that the extra chromosome 21 preferentially segregates with the Y chromosome

In humans, deviations from a 1:1 male:female ratio have been identified in both chromosomally normal and trisomic live births: among normal newborns there is a slight excess of males, among trisomy 18 live borns a large excess of females, and among trisomy 21 live borns an excess of males. These differences could arise from differential production of or fertilization by Y- or X-bearing sperm or from selection against male or female conceptions. To examine the proportion of Y- and X-bearing sperm in normal sperm and in sperm disomic for chromosomes 18 or 21, we used three-color FISH (to the X and Y and either chromosome 18 or chromosome 21) to analyze >300,000 sperm from 24 men. In apparently normal sperm, the sex ratio was nearly 1:1 (148,074 Y-bearing to 148,657 X-bearing sperm), and the value was not affected by the age of the donor. Certain of the donors, however, had significant excesses of Y- or X-bearing sperm. In disomy 18 sperm, there were virtually identical numbers of Y- and X-bearing sperm; thus, the excess of females in trisomy 18 presumably is due to selection against male trisomic conceptions. In contrast, we observed 69 Y-bearing and 44 X-bearing sperm disomic for chromosome 21. This is consistent with previous molecular studies, which have identified an excess of males among paternally derived cases of trisomy 21, and suggests that some of the excess of males among Down syndrome individuals is attributable to a nondisjunctional mechanism in which the extra chromosome 21 preferentially segregates with the Y chromosome.

The effect of Y-chromosome alpha-satellite array length on the rate of sex chromosome disomy in human sperm

Trisomy is the leading known cause of mental retardation and pregnancy loss in humans, yet virtually nothing is known of the underlying nondisjunctional mechanisms. Since studies of other organisms suggest an association between centromere size or sequence and meiotic nondisjunction, we recently initiated studies to examine the effect of centromere size variation on human nondisjunction. In the present report, we summarize studies correlating variation in the size of the Y-chromosome centromere with sex chromosome nondisjunction. In one set of studies, we used pulsed-field gel electrophoresis to estimate Y-chromosome alpha-satellite array lengths in normal males, and correlated these values with Y-chromosome sperm disomy levels as determined by fluorescence in situ hybridization. In a second set of studies, we determined the Y-chromosome alpha-satellite array length of 47,XYY males, since the karyotypes of these individuals are a consequence of Y chromosome nondisjunction. Neither set of studies provided evidence for an effect of Y-chromosome alpha-satellite array length on Y-chromosome nondisjunction. Thus, if there is an association between Y-chromosome centromere size and nondisjunction, the effect is subtle and below the detection levels of the present study or involves extreme size variants that were not represented in the present study population.

Homologies between human and marmoset (Callithrix jacchus) chromosomes revealed by comparative chromosome painting

Regions of DNA homology between human and marmoset (Callithrix jacchus) chromosomes have been demonstrated using fluorescence in situ hybridization. All 24 chromosome paints and two centromere repeat sequences from Homo sapiens (HSA) have been annealed to previously G-banded metaphase spreads of Callithrix jacchus. All human paint probes, except Y, successfully hybridized to marmoset chromosomes. Fifteen of them hybridized to one region only, seven to two regions, and paint 1 to three regions. Homologies proposed from previous banding comparisons have been confirmed for HSA 2, 4-6, 10-12, 18, 19, 21 and X and partially confirmed for HSA 1 and 3, but were not in agreement for HSA 14 and 17. Human centromere repeat sequences for X and 18 did not hybridize to marmoset chromosomes. Because, at present, there is the confusion situation of several different numbering systems for marmoset chromosomes, we propose a new simpler nomenclature based on descending order of chromosome size.

Identifying the sex of human preimplantation embryos in X-linked disease: amplification efficiency of a Y-specific alphoid repeat from single blastomeres with two lysis protocols

INTRODUCTION

Preimplantation diagnosis involves detecting genetic defects in one or two blastomeres biopsied from cleavage stage embryos following a vitro fertilization (IVF). For X-linked recessive disease, identification of the sex of embryos allows transfer of only unaffected females. To examine how critical the preparation of the single blastomere is for amplification of a Y chromosome specific repeat sequence using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), the incidence of amplification failure has been examined following two lysis protocols.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Amplification of a Y alphoid repeat sequence from single blastomeres disaggregated from cleavage stage embryos was examined after either (1) lysis in distilled water and freeze-thawing twice or (2) a two-step lysis protocol involving an initial treatment in potassium hydroxide and dithiothreitol. Some of the embryos had been previously sexed by cleavage-stage biopsy and fluorescent in situ hybridization with X- and Y-specific probes.

RESULTS

Amplification failure occurred in 6 of 50 (12%) and 4 of 60 (7%) single blastomeres from male embryos following lysis in distilled water or using the two-step protocol, respectively. Conversely, amplification from contaminating DNA occurred in 5 of 63 (8%) single blastomeres from female embryos and 6 of 94 (6%) of control medium-blanks.

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of amplification failure was improved but not eliminated using the two-step lysis protocol. At least two cells, therefore, would be necessary for accurate identification of males by amplification of Y-specific repeat sequences alone. Nevertheless, this protocol for preparing cleavage-stage blastomeres is likely to give more consistent amplification of any unique or repeat sequences.

The incidence, origin, and etiology of aneuploidy

Aneuploidy, the presence of an extra or missing chromosome, is the most frequent cause of mental retardation and pregnancy loss in our species. Studies can be divided into those of incidence, origin, and etiology. Trisomy 21 is the most common aneuploidy among liveborns whereas monosomy X and trisomy 16 are the most frequent causes of pregnancy loss. Aneuploidy primarily arises by the process of nondisjunction in the first meiotic division of maternal meiosis; however, this varies among chromosomes in that some show a significant proportion of paternal and/or meiosis II errors. The most common etiological factor associated with aneuploidy is advancing maternal age and it is generally agreed that this is a result of the increasing likelihood of nondisjunction in the aging ovary. There has been intense debate as to the existence of of a paternal age effect and recent studies on human sperm suggest that there may be a small effect for the sex chromosomes. Furthermore, recent molecular studies on trisomic conceptuses have revealed a second etiological factor associated with nondisjunction, namely, reduced genetic recombination.