In vitro characterization of the tobacco rpoB promoter reveals a core sequence motif conserved between phage-type plastid and plant mitochondrial promoters

A promoter switch that can rescue a plant sigma factor mutant

Chloroplasts sigma factors act in concert with PEP, the bacterial-type plastid RNA polymerase. Using a sigma knockout line from Arabidopsis thaliana, we investigated mutant-specific changes in plastid gene expression at RNA level. One characteristic feature was the appearance of a long transcript that spans the atpB-E operon and extends considerably into the far-upstream region of atpB. This region reveals a cluster of typical promoter elements for NEP, the second (phage-type) plastid RNA polymerase. The NEP promoter cluster can help maintain RNA synthesis in situations where no functional sigma factor is available for PEP.

Building up of the plastid transcriptional machinery during germination and early plant development

The plastid genome is transcribed by three different RNA polymerases, one is called plastid-encoded RNA polymerase (PEP) and two are called nucleus-encoded RNA polymerases (NEPs). PEP transcribes preferentially photosynthesis-related genes in mature chloroplasts while NEP transcribes preferentially housekeeping genes during early phases of plant development, and it was generally thought that during plastid differentiation the building up of the NEP transcription system precedes the building up of the PEP transcription system. We have now analyzed in detail the establishment of the two different transcription systems, NEP and PEP, during germination and early seedling development on the mRNA and protein level. Experiments have been performed with two different plant species, Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) and spinach (Spinacia oleracea). Results show that the building up of the two different transcription systems is different in the two species. However, in both species NEP as well as PEP are already present in seeds, and results using Tagetin as a specific inhibitor of PEP activity demonstrate that PEP is important for efficient germination, i.e. PEP is already active in not yet photosynthetically active seed plastids.

Eukaryotic transcription factors in plastids--Bioinformatic assessment and implications for the evolution of gene expression machineries in plants

The expression of genes in higher plant chloroplasts includes a complex transcriptional regulation which can be explained only in part with the action of the actually known components of the transcriptional machinery. This suggests the existence of still unknown important regulatory factors which influence chloroplast transcription. In order to test if such factors could exist we performed in silico analyses of Arabidopsis genes encoding putative transcription factors looking for putative N-terminal chloroplast transit peptides in the amino acid sequences. Our results suggest that 48 (and maybe up to 100) transcription factors of eukaryotic origin are likely to be imported into plastids. None of them has been described yet. This set of transcription factors highly expands the actually known regulation capacity of the chloroplast transcription machinery and provides a possible explanation for the complex initiation patterns of chloroplast transcripts. As consequence of a massive import of eukaryotic transcription factors a comprehensive reconstruction of the ancient prokaryotic gene expression machinery must be assumed resulting in a novel compatible combination of eukaryotic and prokaryotic protein components. In turn, the opposite process has been induced in the nucleus by the integration of prokaryotic components of the plastid ancestor via its loss of genes during endosymbiosis. Thus, a mutual exchange of regulatory factors, i.e. transcription factors occurred which resulted in the unique signalling network of today's plants. An evolutionary model of how this could have emerged during endosymbiosis in a timely coordinated manner is proposed.

Sub-plastidial localization of two different phage-type RNA polymerases in spinach chloroplasts

Plant plastids contain a circular genome of ∼150 kb organized into ∼35 transcription units. The plastid genome is organized into nucleoids and attached to plastid membranes. This relatively small genome is transcribed by at least two different RNA polymerases, one being of the prokaryotic type and plastid-encoded (PEP), the other one being of the phage-type and nucleus-encoded (NEP). The presumed localization of a second phage-type RNA polymerase in plastids is still questionable. There is strong evidence for a sequential action of NEP and PEP enzymes during plant development attributing a prevailing role of NEP during early plant and plastid development, although NEP is present in mature chloroplasts. In the present paper, we have analysed two different NEP enzymes from spinach with respect to subcellular and intra-plastidial localization in mature chloroplasts with the help of specific antibodies. Results show the presence of the two different NEP enzymes in mature chloroplasts. Both enzymes are entirely membrane bound but, unlike previously thought, this membrane binding is not mediated via DNA. This finding indicates that NEP enzymes are not found as elongating transcription complexes on the template DNA in mature chloroplasts and raises the question of their function in mature chloroplasts.

pTAC2, -6, and -12 are components of the transcriptionally active plastid chromosome that are required for plastid gene expression

Transcription in plastids is mediated by a plastid-encoded multimeric (PEP) and a nuclear-encoded single-subunit RNA polymerase (NEP) and a still unknown number of nuclear-encoded factors. By combining gel filtration and affinity chromatography purification steps, we isolated transcriptionally active chromosomes from Arabidopsis thaliana and mustard (Sinapis alba) chloroplasts and identified 35 components by electrospray ionization ion trap tandem mass spectrometry. Eighteen components, called plastid transcriptionally active chromosome proteins (pTACs), have not yet been described. T-DNA insertions in three corresponding genes, ptac2, -6, and -12, are lethal without exogenous carbon sources. Expression patterns of the plastid-encoded genes in the corresponding knockout lines resemble those of Deltarpo mutants. For instance, expression of plastid genes with PEP promoters is downregulated, while expression of genes with NEP promoters is either not affected or upregulated in the mutants. All three components might also be involved in posttranscriptional processes, such as RNA processing and/or mRNA stability. Thus, pTAC2, -6, and -12 are clearly involved in plastid gene expression.

Redox regulation and modification of proteins controlling chloroplast gene expression

Chloroplasts are typical organelles of plant cells and represent the site of photosynthesis. As one very remarkable feature, they possess their own genome and a complete machinery to express the genetic information in it. The plastid gene expression machinery is a unique assembly of prokaryotic-, eukaryotic-, and phage-like components because chloroplasts acquired a great number of regulatory proteins during evolution. Such proteins can be found at all levels of gene expression. They significantly expand the functional and especially the regulatory properties of the "old" gene expression system that chloroplasts inherited from their prokaryotic ancestors. Recent results show that photosynthesis has a strong regulatory effect on plastid gene expression. The redox states of electron transport components, redox-active molecules coupled to photosynthesis, and pools of reactive oxygen species act as redox signals. They provide a functional feedback control, which couples the expression of chloroplast genes to the actual function of photosynthesis and, by this means, helps to acclimate the photosynthetic process to environmental cues. The redox signals are mediated by various specific signaling pathways that involve many of the "new" regulatory proteins. Chloroplasts therefore are an ideal model to study redox-regulated mechanisms in gene expression control. Because of the multiple origins of the expression machinery, these observations are of great relevance for many other biological systems.

Plastid RNA polymerases, promoters, and transcription regulators in higher plants

Plastids are semiautonomous plant organelles exhibiting their own transcription-translation systems that originated from a cyanobacteria-related endosymbiotic prokaryote. As a consequence of massive gene transfer to nuclei and gene disappearance during evolution, the extant plastid genome is a small circular DNA encoding only ca. 120 genes (less than 5% of cyanobacterial genes). Therefore, it was assumed that plastids have a simple transcription-regulatory system. Later, however, it was revealed that plastid transcription is a multistep gene regulation system and plays a crucial role in developmental and environmental regulation of plastid gene expression. Recent molecular and genetic approaches have identified several new players involved in transcriptional regulation in plastids, such as multiple RNA polymerases, plastid sigma factors, transcription regulators, nucleoid proteins, and various signaling factors. They have provided novel insights into the molecular basis of plastid transcription in higher plants. This review summarizes state-of-the-art knowledge of molecular mechanisms that regulate plastid transcription in higher plants.

Proteome analysis of tobacco bright yellow-2 (BY-2) cell culture plastids as a model for undifferentiated heterotrophic plastids

We analyzed the proteome of undifferentiated plastids from a tobacco BY-2 cell culture by shotgun proteomics following multidimensional protein fractionation. The fractionation strategy initiated with the serial extraction of proteins from membranes which allowed us to distinguish soluble, peripheral, and integral membrane proteins. The majority of the identified proteins have a function in the cellular metabolism and most of them are active in amino acid synthesis pathways. A significant number of the identified proteins was not identified in chloroplast proteome analyses before. This suggests BY-2 plastid specific functions that differ from the major activities of chloroplasts. We have used the BY-2 plastid proteins reported here to assess the metabolic activities of undifferentiated heterotrophic plastids and compared the functional profile with that of differentiated heterotrophic amyloplasts. Comparative shotgun proteome analyses as reported here provide information about prevalent metabolic activities of different plastid types.

Affinity purification of the tobacco plastid RNA polymerase and in vitro reconstitution of the holoenzyme

We affinity-purified the tobacco plastid-encoded plastid RNA polymerase (PEP) complex by the alpha subunit containing a C-terminal 12 x histidine tag using heparin and Ni(2+) chromatography. The composition of the complex was determined by mass spectrometry after separating the proteins of the >900 kDa complex in blue native and SDS polyacrylamide gels. The purified PEP contained the core alpha, beta, beta', beta" subunits and five major associated proteins of unknown function, but lacked sigma factors required for promoter recognition. The holoenzyme efficiently recognized a plastid psbA promoter when it was reconstituted from the purified PEP and recombinant plastid sigma factors. Reconstitution of a plastid holoenzyme with individual sigma factors will facilitate identification of sigma factor-specific promoter elements.

Characterization of a rice nuclear-encoded plastid RNA polymerase gene OsRpoTp

We isolated and characterized two rice genes, OsRpoTp and OsRpoTm, that encode putative phage-type RNA polymerases. Predicted amino acid sequences showed high homology of these genes to known RpoT genes. A transient expression assay using green fluorescent protein indicated that the encoded proteins were localized to plastids and mitochondria, respectively. We demonstrated by reverse transcription-PCR experiments and immunoblot analysis that OsRpoTp expression occurred at an early stage of leaf development, prior to the transcript accumulation of the genes that were transcribed by the nuclear-encoded plastid RNA polymerase (NEP). Expression analyses of the chloroplast-deficient rice mutant, virescent-1, showed a discrepancy between OsRpoTp protein accumulation and the level of transcripts of NEP-transcribed genes. Our results suggest that NEP activation is regulated by a process after transcription, and is affected by the developmental state of chloroplast biogenesis.

The virescent-2 Mutation Inhibits Translation of Plastid Transcripts for the Plastid Genetic System at an Early Stage of Chloroplast Differentiation

The rice virescent-2 mutant (v(2)) is temperature conditional and develops chlorotic, chloroplast-deficient leaves at the restrictive temperature. In the v(2) mutant, plastid-encoded proteins involved in photosynthesis and plastid transcriptional regulation were not detectable at any time during chloroplast differentiation. However, the plastid transcripts for these two classes of proteins behaved differently in the mutant, with those for the plastid transcription/translation apparatus accumulating to wild-type levels and those for photosynthetic apparatus being suppressed. Polysome analysis showed that translation of the plastid transcripts encoding the plastid transcription/translation apparatus was blocked at an early stage of chloroplast differentiation. Accumulation of transcripts of nuclear-encoded photosynthetic genes, such as cab and rbcS, was strongly suppressed in the mutant at later stages of chloroplast differentiation, whereas transcripts of genes for the plastid transcription apparatus, such as OsRpoTp and OsSIG2A, accumulated to abnormally high levels at these stages. These results suggest that activation of the plastid translation machinery at an early stage of chloroplast differentiation is important for triggering the transmission of information about plastid developmental state to the nucleus, which in turn is required for the induction of nuclear-encoded chloroplast proteins at later stages of chloroplast differentiation.

The rbcL genes of two Cuscuta species, C. gronovii and C. subinclusa, are transcribed by the nuclear-encoded plastid RNA polymerase (NEP)

Some species of the holoparasitic flowering plant genus Cuscuta, like C. reflexa, have retained a plastid genome that encodes photosynthesis-related gene products as well as the plastid-encoded RNA polymerase (PEP). In contrast, other species like C. gronovii and C. subinclusa have lost the rpo genes coding for the PEP subunits while photosynthetic genes have been retained. In order to ensure expression of the photosynthesis-related genes in the absence of PEP, a number of adaptations within the plastid genome were required that enable gene transcription mediated exclusively by the nuclear-encoded plastid RNA polymerase (NEP). In this study we analyzed promoter sequence conservation and transcription start sites of a typical PEP gene of non-parasitic plants, rbcL, which codes for the large subunit of ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase. We show that despite high sequence conservation of the coding region of rbcL among different Cuscuta species and tobacco, the 5' non-coding regions of C. gronovii and C. subinclusa have suffered extensive deletions encompassing the PEP promoter that is present in C. reflexa and tobacco. Primer-extension analyses enabled the identification of transcripts initiated at NEP promoter motifs in C. gronovii and C. subinclusa that are not detectable in the 5' non-coding region of C. reflexa.

Chloroplast development affects expression of phage-type RNA polymerases in barley leaves

We have identified the barley gene and cDNA encoding the plastid phage-type RNA polymerase (RNAP), nuclear-encoded plastid RNAP (RpoTp), and the nearly full-length cDNA of the mitochondrial RNAP, nuclear-encoded mitochondrial RNAP (RpoTm). RpoTp spans more than 9000 nt, consists of 19 exons and 18 introns, gives rise to a 3632-nt mRNA and is localized to the long arm of chromosome 1 (7H). The length of the deduced polypeptide is 948 residues. The mRNA levels of RpoTp and RpoTm were determined in roots and primary leaf sections of 7-day-old barley seedlings of the albostrians mutant, which were either phenotypically normal and exhibited a gradient of chloroplast development, or contained ribosome-deficient undifferentiated plastids. Transcript levels of RpoTp and RpoTm in almost all sections reached higher concentrations in plastid ribosome-deficient leaves than in the wild-type material, except in the most basal part of the leaf. These data indicate a role of plastid-to-nucleus signalling in the expression of the two RpoT genes. The mRNA levels of the plastid genes, beta-subunit of plastid-encoded RNAP (rpoB), proteolytic subunit of the Clp protease (clpP) and ribosomal protein Rpl2 (rpl2), all known to be transcribed by the nuclear-encoded RNAP (NEP), followed closely the pattern of RpoTp mRNA accumulation, strongly suggesting that RpoTp and NEP are identical. Transcripts of RpoTm and RpoTm-transcribed mitochondrial genes cytochrome oxidase subunit 2 (coxII) and ATPase subunit 9 (atp9) accumulated to the highest levels in the most basal parts of the leaf and declined considerably towards the leaf tip with a pronounced reduction in green versus white leaves. Our data revealed a marked influence of the developmental stage of the plastid on the expression and activity of organellar phage-type RNAPs and their target genes. Thus, interorganellar cross-talk in the regulated expression of nuclear-encoded plastid and mitochondrial RNAP genes might be a key element governing the concerted expression of genes located within plastids, mitochondria and the nucleus of the plant cell.

Organellar gene transcription and early seedling development are affected in the rpoT;2 mutant of Arabidopsis

An Arabidopsis mutant that exhibited reduced root length was isolated from a population of activation-tagged T-DNA insertion lines in a screen for aberrant root growth. This mutant also exhibited reduced hypocotyl length as well as a delay in greening and altered leaf shape. Molecular genetic analysis of the mutant indicated a single T-DNA insertion in the gene RpoT;2 encoding a homolog of the phage-type RNA polymerase (RNAP), that is targeted to both mitochondria and plastids. A second T-DNA-tagged allele also showed a similar phenotype. The mutation in RpoT;2 affected the light-induced accumulation of several plastid mRNAs and proteins and resulted in a lower photosynthetic efficiency. In contrast to the alterations in the plastid gene expression, no major effect of the rpoT;2 mutation on the accumulation of examined mitochondrial gene transcripts and proteins was observed. The rpoT;2 mutant exhibited tissue-specific alterations in the transcript levels of two other organelle-directed nuclear-encoded RNAPs, RpoT;1 and RpoT;3. This suggests the existence of cross-talk between the regulatory pathways of the three RNAPs through organelle to nucleus communication. These data provide an important information on a role of RpoT;2 in plastid gene expression and early plant development.

Overexpression of phage-type RNA polymerase RpoTp in tobacco demonstrates its role in chloroplast transcription by recognizing a distinct promoter type

Plant cells possess three DNA-containing compartments, the nucleus, the mitochondria and the plastids. Accordingly, plastid gene regulation is fairly complex. Albeit plastids retained their own genome and prokaryotic-type gene expression system by a plastid-encoded RNA polymerase (PEP), they need a second nuclear-encoded plastid transcription activity, NEP. Candidate genes for putative NEP catalytic subunits have been cloned in Arabidopsis thaliana (AtRpoTp) and Nicotiana sylvestris (NsRpoTp). To provide evidence for RpoTp as a gene encoding a NEP catalytic subunit, we introduced the AtRpoTp and NsRpoTp cDNAs into the tobacco nucleus under the control of the strong constitutive CaMV 35S promoter. Analysis of transcription from NEP and PEP promoters in these transgenic plants using primer extension assays revealed enhanced transcription from typical type I NEP promoters as PatpB-289 in comparison with the wild type. These data provide direct evidence that RpoTp is a catalytic subunit of NEP and involved in recognition of a distinct subset of type I NEP promoters.

Possible involvement of the 5'-flanking region and the 5'UTR of plastid accD gene in NEP-dependent transcription

In many developmentally and functionally important higher plant plastid genes, expression depends on a specific nuclear-encoded RNA polymerase (NEP). Molecular mechanisms for NEP-mediated gene expression are poorly understood. We have improved a transient expression assay based on biolistics and the dual-luciferase reporter technique, which facilitated investigations into the regulation of plastid genes in vivo. We scrutinized the 5'-flanking region and the 5'-untranslated region (5'UTR) of accD, a plastid gene encoding a subunit of the prokaryotic-type acetyl-CoA carboxylase which is transcribed exclusively by NEP. The results indicated that two AT-rich sequences, one of them containing two overlapping YRTA-like motifs, were essential for accD expression in vivo. The results also revealed that the length of the 5'UTR rather than a particular sequence element was a determinant for the level of accD expression. Because transcripts accumulated in proportion to reporter enzyme activity and protein levels, and transcript degradation rates were independent of the nature of the 5'UTR, it was unlikely that the 5'UTR acts as a translational enhancer or a stabilizer of the transcripts. Therefore, the length of 5'UTR might be a factor contributing to the efficiency of NEP-dependent transcription in plastids.

Maize BMS cultured cell lines survive with massive plastid gene loss

As part of developing an ex planta model system for the study of maize plastid and mitochondrial gene expression, a series of established Black Mexican Sweet (BMS) suspension cell lines was characterized. Although the initial assumption was that their organelle biochemistry would be similar enough to normal in planta cells to facilitate future work, each of the three lines was found to have plastid DNA (ptDNA) differing from control maize plants, in one case lacking as much as 70% of the genome. The other two BMS lines possessed either near-wild-type ptDNA or displayed an intermediate state of gene loss, suggesting that these clonal lines are rapidly evolving. Gene expression profiles of BMS cells varied dramatically from those in maize leaf chloroplasts, but resembled those of albino plants lacking plastid ribosomes. In spite of lacking most plastid gene expression and apparently mature rRNAs, BMS cells appear to import proteins from the cytoplasm in a normal manner. The regions retained in BMS ptDNAs point to a set of tRNA genes universally preserved among even highly reduced plastid genomes, whereas the other preserved regions may illuminate which plastid genes are truly indispensable for plant cell survival.

A role of the -35 element in the initiation of transcription at psbA promoter in tobacco plastids

Most plastid promoters recognized by bacteria-like plastid RNA polymerase (PEP) are similar to E. coli sigma(70)-type promoters comprising "-35" and "-10" elements. Among them, psbA promoter is unique in bearing additional elements between the conserved -35 and -10 elements. The psbA promoter activity is differentially maintained in the mature chloroplasts where the activity of most PEP promoters declines. Previously, we identified two types of PEP activities in wheat seedlings [Satoh et al. (1999) Plant J. 18: 407]; PEP present in the mature chloroplasts of the leaf tip (tip-type PEP) can initiate transcription from the -35-destructed psbA promoter, but the -35 element is essential for transcription by PEP present in immature chloroplasts of the leaf base (base-type PEP). To reveal which type of PEP functions in various types of plastids in tobacco, we analyzed the tobacco psbA promoter by means of a transplastomic approach. The promoter core context (-42 to +9) was sufficient for developmental regulation of the psbA promoter activity. The -35 promoter element was important for transcription initiation at the psbA promoter in all types of plastids, including chloroplasts in mature leaves, leucoplasts in roots, etioplasts in etiolated cotyledons. The conclusion is that the PEP bearing a promoter preference, similar to the wheat base-type PEP, functions dominantly in tobacco chloroplasts.

Eukaryotic genome evolution: rearrangement and coevolution of compartmentalized genetic information

The plant cell operates with an integrated, compartmentalized genome consisting of nucleus/cytosol, plastids and mitochondria that, in its entirety, is regulated in time, quantitatively, in multicellular organisms and also in space. This genome, as do genomes of eukaryotes in general, originated in endosymbiotic events, with at least three cells, and was shaped phylogenetically by a massive and highly complex restructuring and intermixing of the genetic potentials of the symbiotic partners and by lateral gene transfer. This was accompanied by fundamental changes in expression signals in the entire system at almost all regulatory levels. The gross genome rearrangements contrast with a highly specific compartmental interplay, which becomes apparent in interspecific nuclear-plastid cybrids or hybrids. Organelle exchanges, even between closely related species, can greatly disturb the intracellular genetic balance ("hybrid bleaching"), which is indicative of compartmental coevolution and is of relevance for speciation processes. The photosynthetic machinery of plastids, which is embedded in that genetic machinery, is an appealing model to probe into genomic and organismic evolution and to develop functional molecular genomics. We have studied the reciprocal Atropa belladonna-Nicotiana tabacum cybrids, which differ markedly in their phenotypes, and found that transcriptional and post-transcriptional processes can contribute to genome/plastome incompatibility. Allopolyploidy can influence this phenomenon by providing an increased, cryptic RNA editing potential and the capacity to maintain the integrity of organelles of different taxonomic origins.

Unique architecture of the plastid ribosomal RNA operon promoter recognized by the multisubunit RNA polymerase in tobacco and other higher plants

Expression of the plastid rRNA operon (rrn) during development is highly regulated at the level of transcription. The plastid rrn operon in most higher plants is transcribed by the plastid-encoded RNA polymerase (PEP), the multisubunit plastid RNA polymerase from PrrnP1, a sigma(70)-type promoter with conserved -10 and -35 core promoter elements. To identify functionally important sequences, the tobacco PrrnP1 was dissected in vivo and in vitro. Based on in vivo deletion analysis, sequences upstream of nucleotide -83 do not significantly contribute to promoter function. The in vitro analyses identified an essential hexameric sequence upstream of the -35 element (GTGGGA; the rRNA operon upstream activator [RUA]) that is conserved in monocot and dicot species and suggested that the -10 element plays only a limited role in PrrnP1 recognition. Mutations in the initial transcribed sequence (+9 to +14) enhanced transcription, the characteristic of strong promoters in prokaryotes. We propose that sigma interaction with the -10 element in PrrnP1 is replaced in part by direct PEP-RUA (protein-DNA) interaction or by protein-protein interaction between the PEP and an RUA binding transcription factor.

Organization, Developmental Dynamics, and Evolution of Plastid Nucleoids

The plastid is a semiautonomous organelle essential in photosynthesis and other metabolic activities of plants and algae. Plastid DNA is organized into the nucleoid with various proteins and RNA, and the nucleoid is subject to dynamic changes during the development of plant cells. Characterization of the major DNA-binding proteins of nucleoids revealed essential differences in the two lineages of photosynthetic eukaryotes, namely nucleoids of green plants contain sulfite reductase as a major DNA-binding protein that represses the genomic activity, whereas the prokaryotic DNA-binding protein HU is abundant in plastid nucleoids of the rhodophyte lineage. In addition, current knowledge on DNA-binding proteins, as well as the replication and transcription systems of plastids, is reviewed from comparative and evolutionary points of view. A revised hypothesis on the discontinuous evolution of plastid genomic machinery is presented: despite the cyanobacterial origin of plastids, the genomic machinery of the plastid genome is fundamentally different from its counterpart in cyanobacteria.

The Chlamydomonas reinhardtii organellar genomes respond transcriptionally and post-transcriptionally to abiotic stimuli

The Chlamydomonas reinhardtii plastid and mitochondrial transcriptomes were surveyed for changes in RNA profiles resulting from growth in 12 culture conditions representing 8 abiotic stimuli. Organellar RNA abundance exhibited marked changes during nutrient stress and exposure to UV light, as revealed by both RNA gel blot and DNA microarray analyses. Of particular note were large increases in tufA and clpP transcript abundance during nutrient limitation. Phosphate and sulfur limitation resulted in the most global, yet opposite, effects on organellar RNA abundance, changes that were dissected further using run-on transcription assays. Removal of sulfate from the culture medium, which is known to reduce photosynthesis, resulted in 2-fold to 10-fold decreases in transcription rates, which were reflected in lower RNA abundance. The decrease in transcriptional activity was completely reversible and recovered to twice the control level after sulfate replenishment. Conversely, phosphate limitation resulted in a twofold to threefold increase in RNA abundance that was found to be a post-transcriptional effect, because it could be accounted for by increased RNA stability. This finding is consistent with the known metabolic slowdown under phosphate stress. Additionally, inhibitor studies suggested that unlike those in higher plants, Chlamydomonas chloroplasts lack a nucleus-encoded plastid RNA polymerase. The apparently single type of polymerase could contribute to the rapid and genome-wide transcriptional responses observed within the chloroplast.

The plastid chromosome of Atropa belladonna and its comparison with that of Nicotiana tabacum: the role of RNA editing in generating divergence in the process of plant speciation

The nuclear and plastid genomes of the plant cell form a coevolving unit which in interspecific combinations can lead to genetic incompatibility of compartments even between closely related taxa. This phenomenon has been observed for instance in Atropa-Nicotiana cybrids. We have sequenced the plastid chromosome of Atropa belladonna (deadly nightshade), a circular DNA molecule of 156,688 bp, and compared it with the corresponding published sequence of its relative Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco) to understand how divergence at the level of this genome can contribute to nuclear-plastid incompatibilities and to speciation. It appears that (1) regulatory elements, i.e., promoters as well as translational and replicational signal elements, are well conserved between the two species; (2) genes--including introns--are even more highly conserved, with differences residing predominantly in regions of low functional importance; and (3) RNA editotypes differ between the two species, which makes this process an intriguing candidate for causing rapid reproductive isolation of populations.

Comparative analysis of plastid transcription profiles of entire plastid chromosomes from tobacco attributed to wild-type and PEP-deficient transcription machineries

Transcription of plastid chromosomes in vascular plants is accomplished by at least two RNA polymerases of different phylogenetic origin: the ancestral (endosymbiotic) cyanobacterial-type RNA polymerase (PEP), of which the core is encoded in the organelle chromosome, and an additional phage-type RNA polymerase (NEP) of nuclear origin. Disruption of PEP genes in tobacco leads to off-white phenotypes. A macroarray-based approach of transcription rates and of transcript patterns of the entire plastid chromosome from leaves of wild-type as well as from transplastomic tobacco lacking PEP shows that the plastid chromosome is completely transcribed in both wild-type and PEP-deficient plastids, though into polymerase-specific profiles. Different probe types, run-on transcripts, 5' or 3' labelled RNAs, as well as cDNAs, have been used to evaluate the array approach. The findings combined with Northern and Western analyses of a selected number of loci demonstrate further that frequently no correlation exists between transcription rates, transcript levels, transcript patterns, and amounts of corresponding polypeptides. Run-on transcription as well as stationary RNA concentrations may increase, decrease or remain similar between the two experimental materials, independent of the nature of the encoded gene product or of the multisubunit assembly (thylakoid membrane or ribosome). Our findings show (i) that the absence of photosynthesis-related, plastome-encoded polypeptides in PEP-deficient plants is not directly caused by a lack of transcription by PEP, and demonstrate (ii) that the functional integration of PEP and NEP into the genetic system of the plant cell during evolution is substantially more complex than presently supposed.

Six active phage-type RNA polymerase genes in Nicotiana tabacum

In higher plants, a small nuclear gene family encodes mitochondrial as well as chloroplast RNA polymerases (RNAP) homologous to the bacteriophage T7-enzyme. The Arabidopsis genome contains three such RpoT genes, while in monocotyledonous plants only two copies have been found. Analysis of Nicotiana tabacum, a natural allotetraploid, identified six different RpoT sequences. The study of the progenitor species of tobacco, N. sylvestris and N. tomentosiformis, uncovered that the sequences represent two orthologous sets each of three RpoT genes (RpoT1, RpoT2 and RpoT3). Interestingly, while the organelles are inherited exclusively from the N. sylvestris maternal parent, all six RpoT genes are expressed in N. tabacum. GFP-fusions of Nicotiana RpoT1 revealed mitochondrial targeting properties. Constructs containing the amino-terminus of RpoT2 were imported into mitochondria as well as into plastids. Thus, the dual-targeting feature, first described for Arabidopsis RpoT;2, appears to be conserved among eudicotyledonous plants. Tobacco RpoT3 is targeted to chloroplasts and the RNA is differentially expressed in plants lacking the plastid-encoded RNAP. Remarkably, translation of RpoT3 mRNA has to be initiated at a CUG codon to generate a functional plastid transit peptide. Thus, besides AGAMOUS in Arabidopsis, Nicotiana RpoT3 provides a second example for a non-viral plant mRNA that is exclusively translated from a non-AUG codon.

Dual targeting of phage-type RNA polymerase to both mitochondria and plastids is due to alternative translation initiation in single transcripts

We isolated and sequenced a nuclear gene and cDNA encoding a bacteriophage T7-type RNA polymerase, NsRpoT-B, from Nicotiana sylvestris. The gene, NsRpoT-B, consists of 19 exons and 18 introns and encodes a polypeptide of 1020 amino acid residues. The predicted NsRpoT-B protein shows 71% amino acid identity with NsRpoT-A which is a mitochondrial protein. Quantitative RT-PCR revealed that steady-state NsRpoT-B mRNA accumulation is highest in the mature leaves and lowest in the cotyledons. Transient expression assays in protoplasts from N. sylvestris leaves demonstrated that the putative N-terminal transit peptide of NsRpoT-B encodes dual targeting signals directing the protein into mitochondria and plastids. This strongly suggests that NsRpoT-B functions as an RNA polymerase transcribing genes from two different plant organelle genomes. NsRpoT-B transcripts have two potential translation initiation codons. An in vitro translation assay indicated that a chimeric mRNA encoding the N-terminal NsRpoT-B fused to an sGFP produced two polypeptides translated from the first and second initiation codons. This implies that the dual targeting of NsRpoT-B protein is regulated, in part, at the level of translation. We have designated this protein NsRpoTpm.

An Arabidopsis sigma factor (SIG2)-dependent expression of plastid-encoded tRNAs in chloroplasts

A eubacteria-type RNA polymerase (PEP) plays crucial roles for chloroplast development in higher plants. The core subunits are encoded on plastid DNA (rpo genes) while the regulatory sigma factors are encoded on the nuclear DNA (SIG genes). However, the definite gene specificity of each sigma factor is unknown. We recently identified an Arabidopsis recessive pale-green mutant abc1 in which T-DNA is inserted in SIG2 (sigB). In this mutant, almost normal etioplasts were developed under dark conditions while the small chloroplasts with poor thylakoid membranes and stacked lamellar were developed under light conditions. The sig2-1 mutant was deficient in accumulating enough photosynthetic and photosynthesis-related proteins as well as chlorophyll. However, mRNAs of their structural genes were not significantly reduced. Further analyses revealed that several plastid-encoded tRNAs including trnE-UUC that has dual function for protein and ALA biosyntheses were drastically reduced in the sig2-1 mutant. In contrast, nucleus-encoded T7 phage-type RNA polymerase (NEP)-dependent gene transcripts were steadily accumulated in the mutant. These results indicate that progress of chloroplast development requires SIG2-dependent expression of plastid genes, particularly some of the tRNA genes.

One RNA polymerase serving two genomes

The land plant Arabidopsis thaliana contains three closely related nuclear genes encoding phage-type RNA polymerases (RpoT;1, RpoT;2 and RpoT;3). The gene products of RpoT;1 and RpoT;3 have previously been shown to be imported into mitochondria and chloroplasts, respectively. Here we show that the transit peptide of RpoT;2 possesses dual targeting properties. Transient expression assays in tobacco protoplasts as well as stable transformation of Arabidopsis plants demonstrate efficient targeting of fusion peptides consisting of the N-terminus of RpoT;2 joined to green fluorescent protein to both organelles. Thus, RpoT;2 might be the first RNA polymerase shown to transcribe genes in two different genomes. RNA polymerase activity of recombinant RpoT;2 is uneffected by the inhibitor tagetin, qualifying the gene product of RpoT;2 as a phage-type polymerase.

Three new nuclear genes, sigD, sigE and sigF, encoding putative plastid RNA polymerase sigma factors in Aarabidopsis thaliana

Three new nuclear genes (sigD, sigE and sigF) of Arabidopsis thaliana, encoding putative plastid RNA polymerase sigma factors, were identified and analyzed. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that higher plant sigma factors fell into at least four distinct subgroups within a diverse protein family. In addition, Arabidopsis sig genes contained conserved chromosomal intron sites, indicating that these genes arose by DNA duplication events during plant evolution. Transcript analyses revealed two alternatively spliced transcripts generated from the sigD region, one of which is predicted to encode a sigma protein lacking the carboxy-terminal regions 3 and 4. Finally, the amino-terminal sequence of the sigF gene product was shown to function as a plastid-targeting signal using green fluorescent protein fusions.

Processing and degradation of chloroplast mRNA

The conversion of genetic information stored in DNA into a protein product proceeds through the obligatory intermediate of messenger RNA. The steady-state level of an mRNA is determined by its relative synthesis and degradation rates, i.e., an interplay between transcriptional regulation and control of RNA stability. When the biological status of an organism requires that a gene product's abundance varies as a function of developmental stage, environmental factors or intracellular signals, increased or decreased RNA stability can be the determining factor. RNA stability and processing have long been known as important regulatory points in chloroplast gene expression. Here we summarize current knowledge and prospects relevant to these processes, emphasizing biochemical data. The extensive literature on nuclear mutations affecting chloroplast RNA metabolism is reviewed in another article in this volume (Barkan and Goldschmidt-Clermont, this issue).

Genetic engineering of the chloroplast

Transformation of the plastid genome has a number of inherent advantages for the engineering of gene expression in plants. These advantages include: 10-50 times higher transgene expression levels; the absence of gene silencing and position effect variation; the ability to express polycistronic messages from a single promoter; uniparental plastid gene inheritance in most crop plants that prevents pollen transmission of foreign DNA; integration via a homologous recombination process that facilitates targeted gene replacement and precise transgene control; and sequestration of foreign proteins in the organelle which prevents adverse interactions with the cytoplasmic environment. It is now 12 years since the first conclusive demonstration of stable introduction of cloned DNA into the Chlamydomonas chloroplast by the Boynton and Gillham laboratory, and 10 years since the laboratory of Pal Maliga successfully extended these approaches to tobacco. Since then, technical developments in plastid transformation and advances in our understanding of the rules of plastid gene expression have facilitated tremendous progress towards the goal of establishing the chloroplast as a feasible platform for genetic modification of plants.

Characterization of the initiation sites of both polarity strands of a viroid RNA reveals a motif conserved in sequence and structure

Viroids replicate through a rolling-circle mechanism in which the infecting circular RNA and its complementary (-) strand are transcribed. The precise site at which transcription starts was investigated for the avocado sunblotch viroid (ASBVd), the type species of the family of viroids with hammerhead ribozymes. Linear ASBVd (+) and (-) RNAs begin with a UAAAA sequence that maps to similar A+U-rich terminal loops in their predicted quasi-rod-like secondary structures. The sequences around the initiation sites of ASBVd, which replicates and accumulates in the chloroplast, are similar to the promoters of a nuclear-encoded chloroplastic RNA polymerase (NEP), supporting the involvement of an NEP-like activity in ASBVd replication. Since RNA folding appears to be kinetically determined, the specific location of both ASBVd initiation sites provides a mechanistic insight into how the nascent ASBVd strands may fold in vivo. The approach used here, in vitro capping and RNase protection assays, may be useful for investigating the initiation sites of other small circular RNA replicons.

Regulation of plastid rDNA transcription by interaction of CDF2 with two different RNA polymerases

The plastid genome is known to be transcribed by a plastid-encoded prokaryotic-type RNA polymerase (PEP) and by a nucleus-encoded phage-type RNA polymerase (NEP). The spinach plastid rrn operon promoter region harbours three different, overlapping promoters. Two of them are of the prokaryotic type. The third promoter is a non-consensus-type NEP promoter. We separated three different transcriptional activities from spinach chloroplasts: PEP, the phage-type RNA polymerase NEP-1, and a third, hitherto undescribed transcriptional activity (NEP-2). NEP-2 specifically transcribes the rrn operon in the presence of the transcription factor CDF2. CDF2 was previously shown to recruit PEP to the rrn promoter to repress transcription. Together, our results suggest the existence of a third RNA polymerase in plastids and a mechanism of rDNA transcriptional regulation that is based on the interaction of the transcription factor CDF2 with two different transcriptional systems.

A chloroplastic RNA polymerase resistant to tagetitoxin is involved in replication of avocado sunblotch viroid

Avocado sunblotch viroid (ASBVd), the type species of the family Avsunviroidae, replicates and accumulates in the chloroplast. Two main chloroplastic RNA polymerases have been described: the plastid-encoded polymerase (PEP) with a multisubunit structure similar to the Escherichia coli enzyme and a single-unit nuclear-encoded polymerase (NEP) resembling phage RNA polymerases. On a different basis, sensitivity to tagetitoxin, two major RNA polymerase activities, tagetitoxin sensitive (TS) and resistant (TR), have been found in plastids. The most plausible candidates for the TS and TR RNA polymerases are PEP and NEP, respectively. To gain an insight into the enzymology of the polymerization of ASBVd strands, purified chloroplast preparations from ASBVd-infected leaves were assayed for their in vitro ability to transcribe ASBVd RNAs together with some representative genes (psbA, 16SrDNA, accD, and rpoB) of the three classes of chloroplastic genes according to their promoter structure. High concentrations of alpha-amanitin had no effect on gene or on viroid transcription, but tagetitoxin (5-10 microM) prevented transcription of all these genes without affecting synthesis of ASBVd strands; only at higher tagetitoxin concentrations (50-100 microM) was a 25% inhibition observed. These results suggest that NEP is the RNA polymerase required in ASBVd replication, although the participation of another TR RNA polymerase from the chloroplast cannot be excluded.

Avsunviroidae family: viroids containing hammerhead ribozymes

This chapter focuses on the second viroid family, whose members are also referred to as hammerhead viroids, taking into account their most outstanding feature. If the word “small” is the first to come to mind when considering viroids, perhaps the second word is “hammerhead,” because this class of ribozymes, which because of its structural simplicity has an enormous biotechnological potential, is described in avocado sunblotch viroid (ASBVd) as well as in a viroid-like satellite RNA. The most outstanding feature of the Avsunviroidae members is their potential to adopt hammerhead structures in both polarity strands and to self-cleave in vitro accordingly. Viroids differ from viruses not only in their genome size but also in other fundamental aspects, prominent among which is the lack of messenger activity of both viroid RNAs and their complementary strands.

Nuclear-chloroplast signalling

Chloroplast development and function relies both on structural and on regulatory factors encoded within the nucleus. Recent work has lead to the identification of several nuclear encoded genes that participate in a wide array of chloroplast functions. Characterization of these genes has increased our understanding of the signalling between these two compartments. Accumulating evidence shows that a variety of molecular mechanisms are used for intercompartmental communication and for regulating co-ordinated chloroplast protein expression.

Identification of two essential sequence elements in the nonconsensus type II PatpB-290 plastid promoter by using plastid transcription extracts from cultured tobacco BY-2 cells

In higher plants, plastid genes are transcribed by at least two types of DNA-dependent RNA polymerases. One of them is the well-known plastid-encoded prokaryotic type of polymerase that recognizes sigma(70)-type promoters consisting of -35 and -10 consensus elements. The other recently recognized RNA polymerase has been found to be encoded entirely in the nucleus, and it recognizes a completely different set of promoters, designated previously as nonconsensus type II (NCII) promoters. Here, we report the development of an in vitro transcription system using nonphotosynthetic plastids of cultured tobacco BY-2 cells. This system preferentially and accurately initiates transcription from NCII promoters. The conditions for in vitro transcription were optimized by using the tobacco PatpB-290 promoter, which has been found to be the most highly expressed NCII promoter in vivo. Analysis of in vitro transcription initiation in a series of PatpB-290 5' deletion constructs revealed that sequences upstream of nucleotide -41 do not influence the transcriptional activity of this promoter. A 43-bp region (nucleotides -35 to +8) was further analyzed by introducing single or multiple nucleotide substitutions into two regions (box I and box II) of high sequence conservation. We report here that the ATAGAA sequence comprising box II and the -11 to +4 region (relative to transcription initiation) in box I significantly influence the activity of this NCII promoter.

Identification and characterization of T3/T7 bacteriophage-like RNA polymerase sequences in wheat

Using PCR-based methods, we assembled two wheat cDNA sequences, wheat-G and wheat-C, that encode T3/T7 bacteriophage-like RNA polymerases (RNAPs) sharing 45% amino acid identity. In phylogenetic analyses using maximum likelihood, parsimony and distance methods, the predicted protein sequence of wheat-G (1005 amino acids, 113 kDa) clusters with sequences of previously assigned mitochondrial RNAPs from dicotyledonous plants (Arabidopsis thaliana, Chenopodium album); likewise, in such analyses, the wheat-C sequence (949 amino acids, 107 kDa) affiliates specifically with the Arabidopsis sequence that encodes a phage-like RNAP thought to function in chloroplasts. To confirm biochemically the assignment of the gene encoding the putative wheat mitochondrial RNAP, we isolated a ca. 100 kDa wheat mitochondrial protein that is enriched in fractions displaying specific in vitro transcription activity and that reacts with an antibody raised against a recombinant maize phage-type RNAP. Internal peptide sequence information obtained from the 100-kDa polypeptide revealed that it corresponds to the predicted wheat-G cDNA sequence, providing direct evidence that the wheat-G gene (which we propose to call RpoTm) encodes the wheat mitochondrial RNAP.

Organellar RNA polymerases of higher plants

The nuclear genome of the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana contains a small gene family consisting of three genes encoding RNA polymerases of the single-subunit bacteriophage type. There is evidence that similar gene families also exist in other plants. Two of these RNA polymerases are putative mitochondrial enzymes, whereas the third one may represent the nuclear-encoded RNA polymerase (NEP) active in plastids. In addition, plastid genes are transcribed from another, entirely different multisubunit eubacterial-type RNA polymerase, the core subunits of which are encoded by plastid genes [plastid-encoded RNA polymerase (PEP)]. This core enzyme is complemented by one of several nuclear-encoded sigma-like factors. The development of photosynthetically active chloroplasts requires both PEP and NEP. Most NEP promoters show certain similarities to mitochondrial promoters in that they include the sequence motif 5'-YRTA-3' near the transcription initiation site. PEP promoters are similar to bacterial promoters of the -10/-35 sigma 70 type.

Developmental stage-specific multi-subunit plastid RNA polymerases (PEP) in wheat

Most photosystem I and II plastid genes are transcribed by a plastid encoded Escherichia coli-like RNA polymerase (PEP). In this study, we show that both promoter selectivity and light-dependency of PEP change dramatically during development in wheat leaves. In the leaf tip, psbA and psbD promoter activities are light induced, whilst psbC, psbE and 16S rRNA promoters do not function efficiently irrespective of light conditions. In contrast to the leaf tip, in the basal portion all PEP promoters studied function in the dark as well as the light, except for psbD. Using in vitro transcription, we found that PEP in the illuminated leaf tip can initiate transcription from the -35 destructed psbA promoter, but the -35 element is essential for transcription in the basal portion. There is an extended -10 element in the psbA promoter, recognized by the PEP in the illuminated leaf tip or purified sigma 70-type Escherichia coli RNA polymerase but not by the PEP in the leaf base. These results suggest that during wheat leaf development, PEP in the leaf base that is functional for most PEP promoters even in the dark is replaced by the light-dependent PEP selectively transcribing the psbA and psbD promoters.

Green fluorescent protein as a marker to investigate targeting of organellar RNA polymerases of higher plants in vivo

The recent identification of phage-type RNA polymerases encoded in the nuclear genome of higher plants has provided circumstantial evidence for functioning of these polymerases in the transcription of the mitochondrial and plastid genomes, as demonstrated by sequence analysis and in vitro import experiments. To determine the subcellular localization of the phage-type organellar RNA polymerases in plants, the putative transit peptides of the RNA polymerases RpoT;1 and RpoT;3 from Arabidopsis thaliana and RpoT from Chenopodium album were fused to the coding sequence of a green fluorescent protein (GFP). The constructs were used to stably transform A. thaliana. Transgenic plants were examined for green fluorescence with epifluorescence and confocal laser scanning microscopy. Plants expressing the GFP fusions under control of the CaMV35S promoter exhibited a distinct subcellular localization of the GFP fluorescence for each of the fusion constructs. In plants expressing GFP fusions with the putative transit peptides of ARAth;RpoT;1 and CHEal;RpoT, fluorescence was found exclusively in mitochondria, both in root and leaf cells. In contrast, GFP fluorescence in plants expressing the ARAth;RpoT;3-GFP construct accumulated in chloroplasts of leaf cells and nongreen plastids (leucoplasts) of root cells. By demonstrating targeting in plants, the data add substantial evidence for the phage-type RNA polymerases from C. album and A. thaliana to function in the transcriptional machinery of mitochondria and plastids.