Repair of calvarial defects with flap tissue: role of bone morphogenetic proteins and competent responding tissues

Therapeutic potential of bone morphogenetic proteins

Recently, there has been substantial progress in the area of bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) research. This review serves as an up-to-date summary of the history of BMPs, the mechanisms of BMP signalling and the role of BMPs in adipose, kidney, liver, bone and nervous system. The potential of BMPs as therapeutic agents will also be discussed.

Distraction osteogenesis of the craniofacial skeleton

Distraction osteogenesis is becoming the treatment of choice for the surgical correction of hypoplasias of the craniofacial skeleton. Its principle is based on the studies of Ilizarov, who showed that osteogenesis can be induced if bone is expanded (distracted) along its long axis at the rate of 1 mm per day. This process induces new bone formation along the vector of pull without requiring the use of a bone graft. The technique also provides the added benefit of expanding the overlying soft tissues, which are frequently deficient in these patients. This article reviews the authors' 11-year clinical and research experience with mandibular distraction osteogenesis. It highlights the indications and contraindications of the technique and emphasizes the critical role that basic science research has played in its evolution.

Expression of bone morphogenetic proteins during membranous bone healing

For the reconstructive plastic surgeon, knowledge of the molecular biology underlying membranous fracture healing is becoming increasingly vital. Understanding the complex patterns of gene expression manifested during the course of membranous fracture repair will be crucial to designing therapies that augment poor fracture healing or that expedite normal osseous repair by strategic manipulation of the normal course of gene expression. In the current study, we present a rat model of membranous bone repair. This model has great utility because of its technical simplicity, reproducibility, and relatively low cost. Furthermore, it is a powerful tool for analysis of the molecular regulation of membranous bone repair by immunolocalization and/or in situ hybridization techniques. In this study, an osteotomy was made within the caudal half of the hemimandible, thus producing a stable bone defect without the need for external or internal fixation. The healing process was then catalogued histologically in 28 Sprague-Dawley rats that were serially killed at 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8 weeks after operation. Furthermore, using this novel model, we analyzed, within the context of membranous bone healing, the temporal and spatial expression patterns of several members of the bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) family, known to be critical regulators of cells of osteoblast lineage. Our data suggest that BMP-2/-4 and BMP-7, also known as osteogenic protein-1 (OP-1), are expressed by osteoblasts, osteoclasts, and other more primitive mesenchymal cells within the fracture callus during the early stages of membranous fracture healing. These proteins continue to be expressed during the process of bone remodeling, albeit less prominently. The return of BMP-2/-4 and OP-1 immunostaining to baseline intensity coincides with the histological appearance of mature lamellar bone. Taken together, these data underscore the potentially important regulatory role played by the bone morphogenetic proteins in the process of membranous bone repair.

Osteoprogenitor cells within skeletal muscle

The formation of ectopic bone within skeletal muscle is a widely observed phenomenon. However, the source of the osteoprogenitor cells responsible for ectopic bone formation remains unknown. This study was designed to test for osteogenic differentiation among cells isolated from skeletal muscle tissue. Different subpopulations of cells derived from an adult mouse skeletal muscle were tested for induction of alkaline phosphatase activity after exposure to bone morphogenetic protein-2 in vitro. A responsive subpopulation was identified, transduced with a retrovirus encoding for beta-galactosidase (Rv-lacZ) and an adenoviral construct encoding for one bone morphogenetic protein-2, and injected into the hindlimb of immune compromised (severe combined immunodeficient, or SCID) mice. The injected cells appeared to actively participate in the ectopic bone formation. The existence of lacZ-positive muscle-derived cells colocalized with osteocalcin-producing cells within lacunae of newly formed bone matrix suggests osteoblast and osteocyte differentiation. Although a specific cell was not isolated, these data support the contentions that osteoprogenitor cells reside within skeletal muscle and that muscle may represent a source other than bone marrow for the harvest of these cells.

Ex vivo gene therapy to produce bone using different cell types

Gene therapy and tissue engineering promise to revolutionize orthopaedic surgery. This study comprehensively compares five different cell types in ex vivo gene therapy to produce bone. The cell types include a bone marrow stromal cell line, primary muscle derived cells, primary bone marrow stromal cells, primary articular chondrocytes, and primary fibroblasts. After transduction by an adenovirus encoding for bone morphogenetic protein-2, all of the cell types were capable of secreting bone morphogenetic protein-2. However, the bone marrow stromal cell line and muscle derived cells showed more responsiveness to recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 than did the other cell types. In vivo injection of each of the cell populations transduced to secrete bone morphogenetic protein-2 resulted in bone formation. Radiographic and histologic analyses corroborated the in vitro data regarding bone morphogenetic protein-2 secretion and cellular osteocompetence. This study showed the feasibility of using primary bone marrow stromal cells, primary muscle derived cells, primary articular chondrocytes, primary fibroblasts, and an osteogenesis imperfecta stromal cell line in ex vivo gene therapy to produce bone. The study also showed the advantages and disadvantages inherent in using each cell type.

The efficiency of muscle-derived cell-mediated bone formation

The development of new clinically applicable methods for the delivery of bone morphogenic protein (BMP) is an area of intensive research. Cell-mediated gene therapy approaches are being explored as a potential delivery vehicle. Primary muscle-derived cells isolated from an adult mouse were transduced with an adenoviral-BMP-2 construct. These cells were injected into the triceps surae of severe combined immune deficient (SCID) mice where they induced heterotopic bone formation. BMP-2 expression by these muscle-derived cell constructs was measured in vitro to estimate in vivo BMP-2 delivery. In vitro expression of BMP-2 by 3 x l0(5) muscle-derived cells was 87.89 ng/72 h. These results suggest that the efficiency of muscle cell-based gene delivery of BMP-2 exceeds the direct delivery of recombinant BMP-2 protein.

Adenovirus-mediated direct gene therapy with bone morphogenetic protein-2 produces bone

The need to improve bone healing permeates the discipline of orthopedic surgery. Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) are capable of inducing ectopic and orthotopic bone formation. However, the ideal approach with which to deliver BMPs remains unknown. Gene therapy to deliver BMPs offers several theoretical advantages over implantation of a recombinant BMP protein, including persistent BMP delivery and eliminating the need for a foreign body carrier. A replication defective adenoviral vector was constructed to carry the rhBMP-2 gene (AdBMP-2). The direct in vivo gene therapy approach was applied in both immunodeficient and immunocompetent animals to produce intramuscular bone as early as 2 weeks following injection. Radiographic and histologic analysis revealed radiodense bone containing mature bone marrow elements. Adenovirus-mediated delivery of a marker gene (beta-galactosidase) into control animals produced no bone but indicated the cells transduced with the AdBMP-2 vector. Furthermore, comparisons between immunodeficient and immunocompetent animals illustrated the magnitude and significance of the immune response. Gene therapy to deliver BMP-2 has innumerable potential clinical applications from bone defect healing to joint replacement prosthesis stabilization. This study is the first to establish the feasibility of in vivo gene therapy to deliver active BMP-2 and produce bone.

Use of muscle cells to mediate gene transfer to the bone defect

Segmental bone defects and nonunions are relatively common problems facing all orthopaedic surgeons. Osteogenic proteins, i.e., BMP-2, can promote bone healing in segmental bone defects. However, a large quantity of the human recombinant protein is needed to enhance the bone healing potential. Cell mediated gene therapy in the bone defect can allow a sustained expression of the osteogenic proteins and further enhance bone healing. Muscle cells can be easily isolated and cultivated, and they are known to be an efficient gene delivery vehicle to muscle and nonmuscle tissues. Furthermore, they are capable of transforming into osteoblasts when stimulated by BMP-2. Thus, the utilization of muscle cells as the gene delivery vehicle to a bone defect would be an important step in establishing a less invasive treatment for non-unions and segmental bone defects. Muscle cells were transduced when the adenoviral-lacZ vector and injected into the bone defect and the muscles surrounding the defect. Expression of the marker gene was visualized 7 days after the injection, both macroscopically and microscopically, using lacZ histochemistry. The lacZ expressing cells in the defect tissue were also stained for desmin, a muscle specific marker, indicating the presence of muscle cells that have fused into myofibers in this nonmuscle bone defect area. With successful myoblast mediated gene delivery into the segmental bone defect, future experiments would focus on delivering viral vectors expressing osteogenic proteins to eventually improve bone healing postinjury.

Recombinant human basic fibroblast growth factor accelerates fracture healing by enhancing callus remodeling in experimental dog tibial fracture

Effect of recombinant human basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) on fracture healing was investigated using a tibial fracture in beagle dogs. Transverse fractures in the middle of the diaphyses were created in the right tibiae and bFGF was injected into the fracture sites at a single dose of 200 micrograms. The time course of changes in callus volume and morphology of the fracture sites were evaluated at weeks 2, 4, 8, 16, and 32 after treatment, and the fracture strength was analyzed at weeks 16 and 32. At week 2, a radiogram of the fracture site showed obvious membranous ossification in the group injected with bFGF. Basic FGF extended the callus area at week 4 and increased the bone mineral content (BMC) in the callus at week 8. bFGF also increased the osteoclast number in the periosteal callus at weeks 2 and 4. In the bFGF group, a maximal increase in the osteoclast index was found at week 4, and an identical increase was recognized in the control group at weeks 8 and 16. These findings strongly suggested that bFGF stimulated not only callus formation but osteoclastic callus resorption. BMC in the bFGF group was followed by a rapid decrease from week 8, while that in the control group was identical from week 4. Fracture strength of the bFGF group showed significant recovery by week 16, and recovery was still evident by week 32. We conclude that bFGF promotes the fracture healing in dogs by the stimulation of bone remodeling.

Experimental reconstruction of the mandible using polylactic acid tubes and basic fibroblast growth factor in alloplastic scaffolds

PURPOSE

This study evaluated the use of a mitogenic growth factor in combination with barrier membranes and porous alloplastic scaffolds for the repair of segmental defects of the mandible.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifteen Göttingen minipigs were used for the study. In five animals, mandibular defects of 2 cm were created on both sides of the mandible and bridged by a system of polylactic acid (PLA) tubes and pyrolized bovine bone. On one side of the mandible, the alloplastic scaffolds were loaded with 115 microg recombinant human basic fibroblast growth factor (rhbFGF). In five other animals, defects 4 cm in length were created bilaterally, similarly bridged, and loaded with 230 microg of rhFGF. In five control animals, bilateral 2-cm defects were created that were left empty on one side and bridged with an empty PLA tube on the other. Mitogenic efficacy of the growth factor was assessed on fibroblast cultures by di-methyl-thiazol-2-tetrazolium-bromide assay before implantation.

RESULTS

After 5 months, there was negligible bone regeneration in the control defects, regardless of whether they had been left completely empty or bridged by empty PLA tubes. The 2-cm defects showed bridging in 8 of 10 tubes, with complete consolidation by bone ingrowth in four defects. The 4-cm defects showed bony union in six cases, with complete bone fill in two tubes, and four defects incompletely filled. The bFGF had no appreciable effect with regard to velocity, quantity, and three-dimensional structure of bone formation, neither in the short nor in the long defects despite clear in vitro efficacy.

CONCLUSION

Repair of segmental defects using bioresorbable membranes appears to be possible. However, a single-dose application of bFGF is apparently ineffective, possibly because of rapid dilution.

A molecular approach to bone regeneration

Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) are becoming increasingly recognised as valuable molecular tools for regenerating bone and accelerating fracture healing. New bone growth is the result of BMP-induced differentiation of pluripotent mesenchymal cells along osteoblastic pathways. This phenomenon recapitulates in adults specific aspects of skeletal morphogenesis co-ordinated by BMPs during development. An understanding of the basic scientific research which has led to the characterisation and purification of these remarkable molecules is essential if their full therapeutic potential is to be realised.