The mechanism of antigenic stimulation of primary and secondary clonal precursor cells

B lymphocyte differentiation in lethally irradiated and reconstituted mice. A histological study using immunofluorescent detection of B lymphocytes

The recovery of the B lymphocyte compartments was investigated in lethally irradiated mice reconstituted with fetal liver cells. This was done by means of immunofluorescence on frozen sections of spleen, lymph nodes and Peyer's patches. The first B lymphocyte recovery in the spleen was observed on day 8, a few days earlier than in lymph nodes and Peyer's patches (day 13). These early B cells in the spleen were found in the central part of the periarteriolar lymphatic sheath (PALS). Later on, while increasing in number, the B cells formed growing follicles at the periphery of the PALS. Subsequently, brightly fluorescent B cells appeared in the marginal zone, which surrounded the follicles. Another two weeks later, around day 30, also germinal center formation was observed in the follicles of the spleen. B cell development in lymph nodes and Peyer's patches started somewhat later than in the spleen, but once started, the recovery of the different compartments was completed very fast. Germinal center reactions were found in lymph nodes and Peyer's patches already on day 25, and thus earlier than in the spleen, but later than the first occurrence of the strongly fluorescent cells in the marginal zone. Apparently, germinalcenter formation is not essential for the recovery of the population of brightly fluorescent B cells in the marginal zone after irradiation and reconstitution.

Optimal strategies in immunology. II. B memory cell production

After a first encounter with most antigens, the immune system responds to susequent encounters with a faster, more efficient and more strenuous antibody response. The memory of previous antigen contacts is carried by lymphocytes. Expanding on the model developed in Part 1 of this paper, we examine the optimal strategy available to the immune system for B memory cell production. We again find that the strategy should be of the bang-bang variety. The model we consider assumes that antigen triggers a subpopulation of B-lymphocytes. These triggered lymphocytes can proliferate and secrete modest amounts of antibody, or differentiate into non-dividing plasma cells which secrete large amounts of antibody, or differentiate into non-antibody secreting memory cells. Given injections of antigen at two widely spaced times we compute the strategy which minimizes a linear combination of the primary and secondary response times. We find that for all biologically reasonable parameter values the best strategies are ones in which memory cells are produced at the end of the primary response. Exerimental results which bear on the actual strategies employed are discussed.

The diversity of the influenza-specific primary B-cell repertoire in BALB/c mice

The primary immune response of BALB/c mice to influenza (PR8) hemagglutinin (HA), a complex protein antigen, has been examined by the splenic focus assay, and the resulting monoclonal anti-HA antibodies have been characterized by their reactivity with heterologous viruses. The analysis of the primary B-cell response to HA revealed marked differences from responses previously defined for haptenic determinants. There were following differences: (a) the frequency of HA-specific B cells in both conventional and germ-free BALB/c mice was 1 in 1.0-1.5 X 10(5) splenic B cells, which is substantially lower than the frequency of B cells responsive to various simple haptenic determinants; (b) monoclonal anti-HA antibodies were predominantly of the IgA or IgM isotypes instead of IgG, which dominates antihapten responses; and (c) after immunization, the frequency of anti-HA-specific B cells increases by 10- to 50-fold, which is much greater increase than that observed after immunization with haptenic determinants. Fine specificity analysis of primary monoclonal HA-specific antibodies revealed extensive diversity and a considerable overlap with the specificities obtained from immune mice. Given the low overall frequency of HA-specific B cells, it could be calculated that the representation of most HA-specific clonotypes within the B-cell repertoire could not exceed 1 in 10(7) B cells. These findings indicate that the primary B-cell clonotype repertoire is extremely diverse and largely antigen independent in its generation.

Differential expression of an equivalent clonotype among BALB/c and C57BL/6 mice

The primary anti-phosphorylcholine (PC) response in BALB/c, C57BL/6, and congenic and recombinant inbred strains of these parental types has been examined in the splenic focus system. The frequencies of PC-specific precursors were shown to vary among these strains from 2 to 20 precursors per 10(6) splenic B cells. The distribution of these frequencies suggests that elements closely linked to or within the major histocompatibility complex may play a role in the determination of this parameter, although additional experiments are necessary to adequately assess this possibility. Moreover, all strains tested, regardless of immunoglobulin allotype, expressed monoclonal antibodies indistinguishable from the TEPC 15 myeloma protein (T15) clonotype. Further, the frequency of this clonotype in a given strain did not appear related to allotype, since both high and low T15 frequencies were found among strains of either the BALB/c (a(1)) or C57BL/6 (a(2)) allotype. The examination of normal serum for the T15 idiotype, however, revealed that only mice of the BALB/c allotype (a(1)) expressed the T15 idiotype in detectable quantities. After immunization with Diplococcus pneumoniae, sera from mice of the a(1) allotype consistently contained large quantities of the T15 idiotype, whereas sera from mice of the a(2) allotype exhibited various degrees of cross-reactivity with anti-T15 antibody. These results suggest that: (a) the allotype of an individual, although closely related to serum levels of an idiotype, is unrelated to the proportion of the precursor population which expresses that idiotype and; (b) the serum expression of a given idiotype may reflect regulatory processes, which act either during or before antigenic stimulation, rather than the actual clonotype representation in the repertoire. These findings indicate that distinctions must be made between the expression of idiotypic determinants within precursor B-cell populations and elements which regulate the subsequent appearance of those idiotypes in serum antibodies.

Complete inhibition of the expression of an idiotype by a mechanism of B-cell dominance

Mice of the C.AL-20 strain, which express genes controlling CH regions of the AL/N strain on a BALB/c background, normally synthesize antibodies to the p-azophenylarsonate group (anti-Ar antibodies) with an idiotype characteristic of the A strain. The synthesis of the idiotype, as quantitated by a sensitive assay, can be completely inhibited by the transfer of leukocytes from BALB/c mice producing anti-Ar antibodies, which lack the idiotype. A number of control experiments show that the inhibition is not attributable to suppressor T cells and that the synergistic action of such cells is not required. The results indicate that B-cell dominance, mediated by secondary cells, can completely prevent the expression of unprimed cells with receptors of the same specificity. It is uncertain whether this effect is due entirely to selective capture of antigen by the secondary cells, or whether some type of active suppression by B cells is involved.

Idiotype-specific neonatal suppression of phosphorylcholine-responsive B cells

The effect on neonatal anti-idiotypic suppression on the expression of B cells of the T15 clonotype has been investigated at the level of individual clonal precursor cells. The results indicate that B cells of the T15 clonotype are almost completely eliminated from the repertoire for four months after neonatal injection of allogeneic anti-idiotypic serum. The degree of this suppression is dependent on the amount of anti-idiotypic antibody administered and is less profound if anti-idiotypic antibody is given after the first week of life. No suppression was observed when anti-idiotypic antisera were administered to mice 30 days of age or older, which may indicate that immature B cells are the population most susceptible to suppression. However, since suppression could be reversed by administration of T15 myeloma protein several days after injection of anti-idiotype, the inability to suppress adult BALB/c mice may have been due to the high level of T15 idiotype normally present in their serum. Finally, phosphorylcholine-responsive B cells of identifiable clonotypes other than T15, even a clonotype sharing antigen-combining site determinants with T15, appear unaffected by anti-T15 suppression.

Autoagglutinin produced by organ fragment cultures of mouse spleen

Mouse spleen fragment microcultures produced a heat-labile substance which agglutinated syngeneic erythrocytes. The substance reacted with an antigen present on some strains of mouse erythrocytes and on rat erythrocytes, but absent from other strains of mouse erythrocytes and from guinea pig, rabbit or sheep erythrocytes. Agglutination was inhibited by antisera to mouse immunoglobulins except for antisera specific to mouse IgM which enhanced agglutination. The agglutinin sedimented with 19 S Ig on ultracentrifugation and was destroyed by pretreatment with mercaptoethanol. Using a rosette assay increased numbers of cells, specifically binding syngeneic erythrocytes by means of a surface Ig receptor were demonstrated in spleen fragment microcultures. It is considered that the agglutinin is a noncomplement-activating IgM autoantibody and that the precursors of the cells producing the autoantibody are detected by the rosette assay.

Expression of phosphorylcholine-specific B cells during murine development

The TEPC 15 (T15) clonotype, a putatively germline antibody specificity, does not appear in the neonatal B-cell repertoire until approximately 1 wk of age. This report extends this observation by the demonstration that (a) the T15 clonotype follows similar kinetics of appearance in germfree as well as conventionally-reared mice; (b) maternal influences and genetic background play a minor role in the development of the T15 clonotype since CBFI neonates raised by C57BL/6 or BALB/c mothers acquire the T15 clonotype at the same time in ontogeny as BALB/c neonates; (c) the lack of phosphorylcholine (PC)-specific B cells shortly after birth is reflected in a dearth of PC-binding cells in the neonate as well; and (d) no PC-specifc B cells are found in 19-day fetal liver or in bone marrow until 7 days of life, coincident with their appearance in the spleen. These findings, along with a previous report that PC-specific splenic B cells are tolerizable as late as day 10 after birth, confirm the invariant, late occurrence of the T15 clonotype and support a highly- ordered, rigorously predetermined mechanism for the acquisition of the B- cell repertoire. The results are discussed in light of other studies on the ontogeny of B-cell specificity, and in terms of the implications on the mechanism by which antibody diversity is generated.

Antibody-specific immunoregulation

In recent years, much evidence has accumulated which demonstrates that an animal's immune system has the capacity to recognize its own antibody idiotypes. These findings suggest that self-idiotypic recognition may potentially play a role in the regulation of B-cell responses. The experiments presented in this report were carried out to determine if an animal develops the ability to specifically regulate the synthesis of antibodies specific for an antigen, subsequent to primary immunization to the particular antigen and concomitant with an initial antibody response. Employing the splenic fragment culture system we have compared the response of primary donor B cells in irradiated recipients which have been previously immunized to hemocyanin (Hy) alone or dinitrophenyl (DNP)-Hy plus Hy. The results indicated that only 25-30 percent of DNP- specific B cells stimulated by DNP-Hy in Hy immunized recipients could bestimulated by DNP-Hy in recipients immunized with Hy as well as DNP-Hy. B-cell responses to other haptens, such as fluoresceinated-Hy, and secondary DNP-specific B-cell responses were unaffected in DNP-Hy immunized animals. The nontrivial and specific nature of the observed decrease in primary DNP-specific B-cell responses was verified by the finding that the response of CB20 donor cells, which differ from BALB/c mice only in the immunoglobulin heavy chain allotype-linked locus, was unaffected in BALB/c recipient mice which had been immunized with DNP-Hy. Thus, it appeared that during a primary humoral immune response to a T- dependent antigen, an antibody-specific regulatory mechanism is induced which specifically limits the stimulation of hapten-specific primary, but not secondary, B cells. The important implications that these findings have for the understanding of the control of primary B-cell responses and the generation of secondary B cells is discussed.

Novel idiotypic and antigen-binding characteristics in two anti-dinitrophenyl monoclonal antibodies

Monoclonal anti-dinitrophenyl antibodies generated in the splenic focus system from B cells of adult BALB/c mice were studied for the presence or absence of murine anti-T15 (M anti-T15) reactivity and for their ability to bind phosphorylcholine (PC). Two foci of the 680 clones analyzed bound PC, and one of these antibodies reacted with M anti-T15 and anti-Fab on a 1:1 weight basis. The discovery of a clonotype reactive with M anti-15 but not with rabbit anti-T15 (R anti-T15) serum, the converse of the R anti-T15+, M anti-T15- clonotype identified in the PC-specific repertoire, points to the novel idiotypic relationships which may be found among homogeneous antibodies binding diverse antigens. The R anti-T15-, M anti-T15+ clonotype may represent a distinct set of hypervariable region sequences inserted into the T15 framework or may be a somatic variant of the T15 germ-line sequence. In addition, the maximum frequency with which this clonotype occurs within the B-cell pool is estimated.

In vitro tolerance induction of neonatal murine B cells as a probe for the study of B-cell diversification

The susceptibility to in vitro tolerance induction has been implicated as a characteristic of B cells early in their development, since DNP-reactive B cells are tolerizable only during the first days after birth, and 25% of adult bone marrow cells are tolerizable. In the present study, a modification of the in vitro splenic focus technique was utilized to determine if PC-specific B cells, by virtue of their late expression (approximately 1 wk post-parturition), also display susceptibility to tolerance induction. The results demonstrate that at 7-10 days after birth, when over 90% of the DNP-specific splenic B cells are resistant to tolerance induction, the majority of PC-specific B cells are tolerizable. These results re-emphasize tolerance susceptibility as a characteristic of developing clones, confirm the late acquisition of PC-specific B cells, and support the contention that the acquisition of the specificity repertoire is a highly ordered, specifically predetermined process which is independent of antigen-driven events.

Homogeneous antibodies directed against human cell surface antigens: I. The mouse spleen fragment culture response to T and B cell lines derived from the same individual

The use of the mouse spleen fragment culture system is extended to the production of antibodies to human lymphoblastoid cell lines. These antibodies were tested for reactivity against the immunizing cell line, and against a second cell line which had been derived from the same human blood sample. Many of the antibodies were found to discriminate between the 2 isogenic lines. These results demonstrate the potential of the mouse spleen fragment culture system to provide homogeneous reagents which detect distinguishing markers on closely related human cells.

The acquisition of b-cell competence and diversity

The in vitro splenic focus technique has been used to establish the characteristics of the repertoire of B cells in adult BALB/c mice, its stimulation and development. Evidence is presented that the technique yields an accurate estimate of the precursor cell frequency by providing monoclonal responses of a constant portion (4%) of transferred B cells. Since the monoclonally derived antibodies can be analyzed, it has also been possible to determine the isotype and clonotype of many of the resultant antibodies. The adult spleen can be shown to contain a vast repertoire (over 10(7) clonotypes) of primary B cells, each clonotype represented by from less than ten to as many as 10(4) responsive cells. Antigenic stimulation of these primary B cells is highly specific and apparently affinity dependent and leads to both antibody-forming cell clone formation and a population of secondary B cells. Secondary B cells, though derived from the same clonotypes, differ from primary B cell in several characteristics, including a lower degree of secificity of antigenic stimulation. In addition, secondary B cells can be stimulated in collaboration with allogeneic antigen-specific T cells to yield clones producing antibody of the IgG1 isotope, whereas primary B cells similarly stimulated produce only IgM antibodies. Analyses of neonatal B cells indicate that the acquisition of the adult repertoire is a highly patterned process. Thus, whereas 10(4) clonotypes are present at birth, more and more clonotypes are acquired in a highly ordered pattern during the first few weeks of life. It is concluded that this process is probably evolutionarily determined, since antigen-driven events appear to play no role. However, since developing B cells can be shown to be exquisitely sensitive to tolerance induction, negative antigenic selection may play an important role, particularly in eliminating clonotypes recognizing self-determinants for which the species is polymorphic.

Allogeneic carrier-specific enhancement of hapten-specific secondary B-cell responses

We have analyzed the capacity of carrier-specific T cells to enhance the immune response of hapten-specific secondary B cells which do not share genes in the H-2 complex with the T cells. For this analysis we have used the in vitro splenic focus technique which allows assessment of monoclonal responses of B cells isolated in splenic fragment cultures of irradiated reconstituted carrier primed mice. A previous report from this laboratory demonstrated that syngeny in the I region of the H-2 complex was necessary between collaborating hapten-specific primary (nonimmune) B cells and carrier-specific T cells for responses yielding IgG1 but not IgM antibody. These findings lead up to postulate that the expression of I-region gene products on the surface of primary B cells and I-region syngeny with collaborating carrier-specific T cells were essential elements in the triggering events leading to IgG1 synthesis by primary B cells. The results presented in the present report indicate that, unlike primary B cells, the majority of secondary B cells can be stimulated to produce IgG1 antibody in carrier-primed allogeneic recipients. Although the enhancement of secondary IgG1 responses is slightly greater with syngeneic T cells, the allogeneic collaborative interaction requires both carrier priming of recipient mice and stimulation with the homologous hapten-carrier complex and thus appears to be specific. These findings clearly discriminate secondary from primary B cells and indicate that the mechanism of stimulation of secondary B cells to yield IgG1-producing clones differs fundamentally from the stimulation of primary B cells in that the requisite for I-region syngeny is obviated.

Molecular determinants of immunogenicity: the immunon model of immune response

The immunological response in vivo to a series of size-fractionated linear polymers of acrylamide substituted with hapten has been measured in mice. A sharp threshold was observed in immunogenic response elicited by various polymer preparations. All polymers with less than 12 to 16 appropriately spaced hapten groups per molecule were nonimmunogenic, while those polymers with greater than this number were fully immunogenic. The results lead to the conclusion that the immunological response at its most elementary level is quantized, i.e., a minimum specific number of antigen receptors (approximately 12 to 16) must be connected together as a spatially continuous cluster, an immunon, before an immunogenic signal is delivered to the responding cell.

Expression of Ia antigens on hapten-specific B cells. I. Delineation of B-cell subpopulations

The nonimmune adult spleen contains at least two B-cell subpopulations. The majority of primary B cells express cell surface Ia determinants and have the capacity to give rise to IgG antibody-producing clones after T-cell dependent antigenic stimulation. There is also a small subpopulation of primary B cells which are, by definition, Ia negative, since their activity is not eliminated by negative selection with anti-Ia serum and complement. The Ia-negative B cells give rise to clones that produce only IgM antibody. These B-cell subsets may form a continuum in B-cell maturation, or they may exist as discrete B-cell lineages. Since the cellular expression of Ia antigens appears to correlate with the ability of the B cell to generate IgG-producing clones, it is speculated that Ia molecules may have a role in the IgM to IgG B-cell switch mechanism.

In vitro tolerance induction of neonatal murine B cells

The susceptibility of neonatal and adult B lymphocytes to tolerance induction was analyzed by a modification of the in vitro splenic focus technique. This technique permits stimulation of individual hapten-specific clonal precursor cells from both neonatal and adult donors. Neonatal or adult BALB/c spleen cells were adoptively transferred into irradiated, syngeneic, adult recipients which had been carrier-primed to hemocyanin (Hy), thus maximizing stimulation to the hapten 2,4-dinitrophenyl coupled by Hy (DNP-Hy). Cultures were initially treated with DNP on several heterologous (non-Hy) carriers and subsequently stimulated with DNP-Hy. Whereas the responsiveness of adult B cells was not diminished by pretreatment with any DNP conjugate, the majority of the neonatal B-cell response was abolished by in vitro culture with all of the DNP-protein conjugates. During the 1st wk of life, the ability to tolerize neonatal splenic B cells progressively decreased. Thus, tolerance in this system is: (a) restricted to B cells early in development; (b) established by both tolerogens and immunogens; (c) achieved at low (10(-9) M determinant) antigen concentrations; and (d) highly specific, discriminating between DNP- and TNP-specific B cells. We conclude that: (a) B lymphocytes, during their development, mature through a stage in which they are extremely susceptible to tolerogenesis; (b) the specific interaction of B-cell antigen receptors with multivalent antigens, while irrelevant to mature B cells, is tolerogenic to neonatal (immature) B cells unless antigen is concomitantly recognized by primed T cells; and (c) differences in the susceptibility of immature and mature B lymphocytes to tolerance induction suggest intrinsic differences between neonatal and adult B cells and may provide a physiologically relevant model for the study of tolerance to self-antigens.

B cell tolerance induced by polymeric antigens. II. Effects of tolerance on hapten-binding lymphocyte levels in primary and secondary antibody responses

Tolerogenic doses of hapten [2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP)]-coupled type 3 pneumococcal polysaccharide (DNP-lys2.5-S3) totally abolished the anti-DNP rosette-forming cell (RFC) response to primary immunization with DNP-hemocyanin in mice, while lightly substituted antigen (DNP-lys0.6-S3) had little effect. Both antigens suppressed secondary anti-DNP RFC responses to DNP-KLH. Limiting doses of DNP-lys-S3 preferentially suppressed antibody-secreting cell levels, and had less effect on RFC. DNP-lys2.5-S3 was 500--1000-fold more potent in "blockading" primary RFC in vitro than DNP-lys0.6-S3, whereas both antigens were equally effective in blocking secondary RFC. These results suggest that the sensitivity of primed B lymphocytes to inactivation by DNP-lys-S3 is related to their high avidity for antigen. Furthermore, this appears to be largely due to a high density of immunoglobulin receptors on primed cells since the affinities of primary and secondary RFC for monovalent hapten were indistinguishable. Treatment of primarily immunized mice with DNP-lys2.5-S3 2 h before assay abolished 90% of RFC. Therefore, the reduction in RFC levels in tolerant mice may be due to cellular blockade by persisting tolerogen. However, it seems unlikely that simple blockade of antigen-reactive cells is the sole mechanism operative in this system.

B cell tolerance induced by polymeric antigens. I. Comparison of the dose and epitope density requirements for inactivation of primed and unprimed B cells in vivo

Hapten [2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP)]-specific tolerance was induced in nonimmune or DNP-hemocyanin (DNP-KLH) primed mice by administering hapten-conjugated type 3 pneumococcal polysaccharide (DNP-lys-S3). The dose of DNP-lys2.5-S3 required to suppress the primary anti-DNP antibody responses was approximately ten times higher than that required to suppress the secondary response. Large doses of lightly substituted antigen (DNP-lys0.6-S3) had no effect on primary antibody responses, while small doses of this conjugate suppressed 90-95% of the secondary response. The conclusion from this (presumably B cell) tolerance model is that B lymphocytes "mature" in their susceptibility to tolerization following primary contact with immunogen, since primed cells are inactivated by lower doses of tolerogen, and by tolerogen with lower epitope density, than nonimmune B cells. These and other data suggest that the tolerance threshold of B lymphocytes is related to their state of differentiation, and especially to their antigen-binding characteristics.

B cell tolerance induced by polymeric antigens. V. Different avidities of primed and virgin precursor cells for paucivalent antigen

We have compared the avidity of virgin and primed hapten-specific precursor cells for DNP-lys-S3 (dinitrophenylated type 3 pneumococcal polysaccharide) by measuring its capacity to prevent them from binding highly radioactive DNP-hemocyanin, and thereby protect them from committing hapten-specific "suicide". Moderately substituted conjugates (e.g. DNP-lys2.7S3) protected virgin and memory B cells impartially. In contrast, DNP-lys0.6S3 protected memory cells efficiently, but protected virgin cells only at considerably higher concentrations. These results are consistent with previous evidence - from this and other systems - that there is a higher density of receptors on primed than on unprimed B cells - the significance of which is discussed.

The specificity of T lymphocyte responses to chemically defined antigens

A system is described that allows the definition of T cell receptor specificity with some precision. It involves immunization of guinea pigs with hapten coupled to mycobacteria. The T cells of such animals respond to many but not all carriers modified by that hapten. Such T cells recognize neither hapten nor carrier alone, but rather determinants involving both the hapten and the carrier. No evidence for hapten-specific T cells was found. A model of the antigen binding site of the T cell receptor emerged from these experiments. According to this model, the T cell receptor consists of a single site of relatively large extent involving multiple subsites which are of low and roughly equal affinity. Thus, the haptenic group is not immunodominant for T cells as it is for B cells and for anti-hapten antibody. This suggests that the antigen binding receptor on T cells differs in some fundamental way from that on B cells. It is proposed that antigen recognition by T cells is mediated by an immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region that is not paired with an immunoglobulin light chain variable region.

A proposition on the distribution of antibody affinities, with implications for the mechanism of B-cell activation

For most antisera a linear relationship can be shown between log antigen concentration and the log concentration of antibody required to bind half the available antigen. This paper shows that the slope of this line, s, is related to the distribution of individual antibody clonotypes of different affinity. It is argued that the general form of the distribution approximates to exponential (rather than for example Gaussian) and that this indicates a requirement for some force to be exerted through the antigen-receptor bond in order to activate a B cell. An alternative parameter, A, which gives more weight to high affinity clonotypes, is offered in place of K0 as a measure of the avidity and biological effectiveness of an antiserum.

The allogeneic bisection of carrier-specific enhancement of monoclonal B-cell responses

The ability of T cells to enhance the response of syngeneic and allogeneic B cells to thymus-dependent hapten-carrier conjugates was analyzed. This analysis was carried out on individual primary B cells in splenic fragment cultures derived from irradiated reconstituted mice. This system has several advantages: (a) the response of the B cells is entirely dependent on carrier priming of the irradiated recipient; (b) this B-cell response can be quantitated in terms of the number of responding cells; and (c) very small B-cell responses can be readily detected and analyzed. The results indicate that the majority of hapten-specific B cells were stimulated in allogeneic and syngeneic recipients only if these recipients were previously carrier primed. The number of B cells responding in carrier-primed allogeneic recipients was 60-70% of that in syngeneic carrier-primed recipients. The antibody-forming cell clones resulting from B cells stimulated in the allogeneic environment produced small amounts of antibody and antibody solely of the IgM immunoglobulin class, while the larger responses in syngeneic recipients were predominantly IgG1 or IgM plus IgG1. The capacity of collaborative interactions between carrier-primed T cells and primary B cells to yield IgG1 antibody-producing clones was shown to be dependent on syngeny between these cells in the H-2 gene complex. It is concluded that: (a) B cells can be triggered by T-dependent antigens to clone formation through collaboration with T cells which differ at the H-2 complex as long as these T cells recognize the antigen; (b) the immunoglobulin class produced by the progeny of stimulated B cells generally depends on the nature of the stimulatory event rather than the nature of the B cell itself; and (c) stimulation to IgG1 production is dependent on syngeny between the collaborating T and B cells probably within the Ir-1A region. The role of the Ia antigens in the formation of IgG1-producing clones is not yet clear; Ia identity could permit IgG1 production or, conversely, nonidentity of Ia could induce all allogeneic interactions which prohibit IgG1 production.

The analysis of the monoclonal immune response to influenza virus. I. Production of monoclonal anti-viral antibodies in vitro

Limiting numbers of spleen cells from mice primed with influenza virus were transferred into lethally irradiated syngeneic recipients. Upon antigenic stimulation of fragment cultures of the recipient spleens it was observed that a linear relationship existed between the number of transferred spleen cells and the number of responding fragments. The antibody product of individual fragments exhibited a highly restricted heterogeneity in isoelectric focusing as well as in its reactivity against various viral antigenic determinants. It was concluded that the limiting cell type in this adoptive transfer system corresponds to the virus-primed B cell which, upon antigenic stimulation, gives rise to a clone of antibody-producing cells. PR8-specific precursor B cells occurred at a frequency of at least 1/4000 splenic B cells in PR8-primed BALB/c mice. Approximately 25% of the stimulated cell clones produced sufficient quantities of antibody (200 ng) to render feasible an analysis of closely related viral antigens.

The characterization fo the B-cell repertoire specific for the 2,4-dinitrophenyl and 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl determinants in neonatal BALB/c mice

The (B-cell) repertoire responsive to the DNP and TNP haptenic determinants in BALB/c neonates was analyzed in terms of the specificity of stimulation of neonatal B cells as well as the diversity of specificities available in neonatal populations. The results indicate that the parameters of stimulation of neonatal B cells are similar to those of nonimmune adults, particularly in the exquisitely specific stimulatory process which readily discriminates between haptens as closely related as 2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP) and 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl (TNP). The clonotypes of monoclonal anti-DNP and anti-TNP antibodies derived from isolated neonatal BALB/c splenic B cells in fragment culture were analyzed by isoelectric focusing. During the first 4 days of neonatal life almost all of the anti-DNP-specific clones were of clonotypes displaying IgM antibodies with pI's of 5.05, 5.25, or 5.55. These could be distinguished from clonotypes responding to TNP which were also predominantly of three distinct pI's, 5.00, 5.15 or 5.40. These clonotypes, which represent the vast majority of the DNP- and TNP-specific antibody capability during the first 4 days of life, represented less than half of the clones by day 6 and were a small minority by day 9. The observation that individual 1--4-day-old donors had many B cells representative of a given predominant clonotype is evidence for cellular precommitment of specificity and indicates that clones of precommitted B cells exist as the products of normal, antigen-independent, generative processes. The observation of frequently recurring clonotypes in inbred neonates attests to the "germ line" origin of these clonotypes; however, variance in the occurrence of these clonotypes from donor to donor implies a random element in their expression. The finding that several clonotypes occur repeatedly in high numbers early in neonatal development, while other clonotypes occur only sporadically at early times, has been interpreted as a reflection of a sequential ontogenic expression of clonotypes. Thus the DNP- and TNP-specific clonotypes which predominate in neonates may be seen as representative of a total of 5,000-10,000 clonotypes which are expressed as early as the 15th to 17th day of gestation while most clonotypes appear after the 18th day of gestation.

Production of antibodies of identical idiotype but diverse immunoglobulin classes by cells derived from a single stimulated B cell

The availability of anti-phosphocholine antibody of the TEPC 15 idiotype from the clonal progeny of a single precursor cell, stimulated in vitro, permitted the demonstration of monoclonal antibodies with as many as three immunoglobulin classes with identical variable regions. This demonstration was dependent on sensitive radioimmunoassays which showed a one to one relationship between the total anti-phosphocholine antibody produced by a clone and the sum of anti-phosphocholine antibody of the different classes as well as the amount of antibody of the TEPC 15 idiotype. The class distribution was confirmed by isoelectric focusing identification of IgM, Igta, and IgGl antibodies of the TEPC 15 idiotype produced by single clones which showed characteristic pI values for each immunoglobulin class. Thus, within the generative phase of a single antibody-producing cell clone, various heavy chain constant regions can be linked to the same variable region, and single precursor cells have the capacity to generate progeny expressing at least three distinct immunoglobulin classes.

B lymphocyte activation and lattice formation

When B lymphocyte activation is viewed within the general context of the clonal selection theory it is seen that this complex process must, under normal physiological conditions, be initiated only after antigen recognition by the B cell, that is, after antigen binding to the cells immunoglobulin receptors. The cross linking of receptors by effectively multivalent antigens, so as to form a receptor-antigen lattice may be generally required for activation. A theory is developed for the rate of lattice formation in the presence of inhibition by free hapten. It is shown that free hapten can very effectively inhibit the rate of lattice formation, particularly on high affinity cells, even though it cannot compete with multivalent binding at equilibrium.

Radioactive antigen suicide of an anti-DNP (2,4-dinitrophenyl) clone. II. Follow-up of clones relatively resistant to radioactive antigen suicide when initially selected

After suicide of the anti-dinitrophenyl (DNP) clone E21 in a previous experiment (Eur. J. Immunol. 1975. 5:58) several new clones (S clones) appeared promptly in the recipients. There was compelling evidence that they were then resistant to suicide, relative to E21. We now report further studies on these S clones and their antibodies. The antibodies of half of the S clones had affinities ten to one hundred times higher than E21 (3 x 10(-7) M); none was lower. The four tested were also able to bind DNP on the particular conjugate used for the suicide procedure. Three of the S clones were serially propagated, they showed a very great capacity for proliferation, transferring into 510, 85 and 110 recipients each. When their cells were tested at subsequent passages, they recovered early after inhibition by radioactive antigen. Two S clones may still have been somewhat refractory to suicide but, probably in all three, rapid proliferation was largely responsible for the recovery of the few cells escaping suicide, and helped them to appear suicide resistant.

Heterogeneity of the BALB/c antiphosphorylcholine antibody response at the precursor cell level

Immune responsiveness to phosphorylcholine (PC) in BALB/c mice has been characterized by combining (a) usuage of highly sensitive radioimmunoassays for quantitation of antibody, heavy-chain class, and idiotype on a weight basis; (b) isolation of PC-specific B cells in fragment cultures; and (c) stimulation in a carrier-primed environment with the PC hapten coupled to carrier through a tripeptide spacer in order to maximize carrier recognition. The specificity and accuracy of the radioimmunoassays have veen verified by specific inhibition, lack of nonspecific binding, and excellent concordance of values for monoclonal antibody concentration obtained independently for Fab and idiotype content. The latter evidence also serves as strong confirmation of the monoclonality of in vitro monofocal responses as well as the preservation of the idiotype on antibodies of differing immunoglobulin classes. The results indicate that while B cells expressing the TEPC 15 idiotype predominate, other idiotypes may be represented by 2-50% of PC-specific precursors, and monoclonal antibodies even of the TEPC 15 idiotype are produced in both the IgM and IgG1 immunoglobulin classes. These findings are confirmed by the analysis of serum antibodies produced in carrier-primed mice immunized with hapten coupled through a tripeptide spacer, thus re-emphasizint the enhancement of primary responsiveness, particularly IgG1 production, by maximizing carrier recognition. The finding of idiotype diversity in the PC response, as well as diversity of expression in terms of quantity and immunoglobulin class of antibody synthesized by the clonal progeny of B cells within the TEPC 15 clonotype, emphasize the heterogeneity of the B-cell population both in terms of specificity repertoire and the physiological state of cells even within a single clonotype.