Requirement ofFoxD3-class signaling for neural crest determination inXenopus

Gene-regulatory interactions in neural crest evolution and development

In this review, we outline the gene-regulatory interactions driving neural crest development and compare these to a hypothetical network operating in the embryonic ectoderm of the cephalochordate amphioxus. While the early stages of ectodermal patterning appear conserved between amphioxus and vertebrates, later activation of neural crest-specific factors at the neural plate border appears to be a vertebrate novelty. This difference may reflect co-option of genetic pathways which conferred novel properties upon the evolving vertebrate neural plate border, potentiating the evolution of definitive neural crest.

Tissue-specific expression of FoxD reporter constructs in amphioxus embryos

Cephalochordates (amphioxus), the closest living invertebrate relatives of the vertebrates, are key to understanding the evolution of developmental mechanisms during the invertebrate-to-vertebrate transition. However, a major impediment to amphioxus as a model organism for developmental biology has been the inability to introduce transgenes or other macromolecules into the embryos. Here, we report the development of a reproducible method for microinjection of amphioxus eggs. Specifically, we show that expression of a LacZ reporter construct including 6.3 kb of AmphiFoxD upstream regulatory DNA recapitulates expression of the endogenous gene in the nerve cord, somites, and notochord. We have also identified the 1.6 kb at the 5' end of this region as essential for expression in the first two of these domains and the 4.7 kb at the 3' end as sufficient for expression in the notochord. This study, which is the first report of a method for introduction of large molecules such as DNA into amphioxus embryos, opens the way for studies of gene regulation and function in amphioxus and for comparative studies with vertebrates to understand the relationship between the extensive gene duplications that occurred within the vertebrate lineage and the evolution of vertebrate innovations such as neural crest.

Survey of forkhead domain encoding genes in the Drosophila genome: Classification and embryonic expression patterns

Genetic approaches in Drosophila led to the identification of Forkhead, the prototype of forkhead domain transcription factors that are now known to comprise an evolutionarily conserved family of proteins with essential roles in development and differentiation. Sequence analysis of the recently published genomic scaffold sequence from Drosophila melanogaster has allowed us to determine the presumably full complement of forkhead domain encoding genes in this species. We show herein that the Drosophila genome contains 17 forkhead domain encoding genes; 13 of these genes have orthologs in chordate species, and their products can be assigned to 10 of the 17 forkhead domain subclasses known from chordates. One Drosophila forkhead domain gene only has a Caenorhabditis elegans ortholog and may represent a subclass that is absent in chordates, while the remaining three cannot be classified. We present the mRNA expression patterns of seven previously uncharacterized members of this gene family and show that they are expressed in tissues from all three germ layers, including central and peripheral nervous system, epidermis, salivary gland primordia, endoderm, somatic mesoderm, and hemocyte progenitors. Furthermore, the expression patterns of two of these genes, fd19B and fd102C, suggest a role for them as gap genes during early embryonic head segmentation.

The neurotrophin-receptor-related protein NRH1 is essential for convergent extension movements

Early spherical Xenopus laevis embryos are transformed into a streamlined shape through convergent extension movements. Here we report that a p75(NTR)-related transmembrane protein, NRH1, has an essential function in the regulation of these movements. NRH1 was expressed in marginal zone tissues of the gastrula and in the posterior ectoderm of the neurula. Attenuation of the NRH1 function inhibited convergent extension movements in the embryo and in activin-treated animal caps. NRH1 activated downstream effectors of the Wnt/planar cell polarity pathway: small GTPases and the cascade of MKK7-JNK. Furthermore, gain- and loss-of-function phenotypes of NRH1 were rescued by co-injection of dominant-negative and constitutively active forms of these downstream effectors, respectively, suggesting that NRH1 functions as a positive modulator of planar cell polarity signalling. Interestingly, NRH1 does not require Dishevelled (Xdsh) for the activation of these downstream effectors or translocation of Xdsh to the membrane, suggesting that NRH1 signalling interacts with planar cell polarity signalling downstream of Xdsh. This demonstrates an essential role for p75(NTR)-related signalling in early embryonic morphogenesis.

Molecular anatomy of placode development in Xenopus laevis

We analyzed the spatiotemporal pattern of expression of 15 transcription factors (Six1, Six4, Eya1, Sox3, Sox2, Pax6, Pax3, Pax2, Pax8, Dlx3, Msx1, FoxI1c, Tbx2, Tbx3, Xiro1) during placode development in Xenopus laevis from neural plate to late tail bud stages. Out of all genes investigated, only the expression of Eya1, Six1, and Six4 is maintained in all types of placode (except the lens) throughout embryonic development, suggesting that they may promote generic placodal properties and that their crescent-shaped expression domain surrounding the neural plate defines a panplacodal primordium from which all types of placode originate. Double-labeling procedures were employed to reveal the precise position of this panplacodal primordium relative to neural plate, neural crest, and other placodal markers. Already at neural plate stages, the panplacodal primordium is subdivided into several subregions defined by particular combinations of transcription factors allowing us to identify the approximate regions of origin of various types of placode. Whereas some types of placode were already prefigured by molecularly distinct areas at neural plate stages, the epibranchial, otic, and lateral line placodes arise from a common posterior placodal area (characterized by Pax8 and Pax2 expression) and acquire differential molecular signatures only after neural tube closure. Our findings argue for a multistep mechanism of placode induction, support a combinatorial model of placode specification, and suggest that different placodes evolved from a common placodal primordium by successive recruitment of new inducers and target genes.

Xenopus XsalF

Here we show that XsalF, a frog homolog of the Drosophila homeotic selector spalt, plays an essential role for the forebrain/midbrain determination in Xenopus. XsalF overexpression expands the domain of forebrain/midbrain genes and suppresses midbrain/hindbrain boundary (MHB) markers and anterior hindbrain genes. Loss-of-function studies show that XsalF is essential for the expression of the forebrain/midbrain genes and for the repression of the caudal genes. Interestingly, XsalF functions by antagonizing canonical Wnt signaling, which promotes caudalization of neural tissues. XsalF is required for anterior-specific expressions of GSK3beta and Tcf3, genes encoding antagonistic effectors of Wnt signaling. Loss-of-function phenotypes of GSK3beta and Tcf3 mimic those of XsalF while injections of GSK3beta and Tcf3 rescue loss-of-function phenotypes of XsalF. These findings suggest that the forebrain/midbrain-specific gene XsalF negatively controls cellular responsiveness to posteriorizing Wnt signals by regulating region-specific GSK3beta and Tcf3 expression.

Neural crest and the origin of ectomesenchyme: neural fold heterogeneity suggests an alternative hypothesis

The striking similarity between mesodermally derived fibroblasts and ectomesenchyme cells, which are thought to be derivatives of the neural crest, has long been a source of interest and controversy. In mice, the gene encoding the alpha subunit of the platelet-derived growth factor receptor (PDGFRalpha) is expressed both by mesodermally derived mesenchymal cells and by ectomesenchyme. Whole-mount immunostaining previously revealed that PDGFRalpha is present in the cephalic neural fold epithelium of early murine embryos (Takakura et al. [1997] J Histochem Cytochem 45:883-893). We now show that, within the neural fold, a sharp boundary exists between E-cadherin-expressing non-neural epithelium and the neural epithelium of the dorsal ridge. In addition, we found that cells coexpressing E-cadherin and PDGFRalpha are present in the non-neural epithelium of the neural folds. These observations raise the possibility that at least some PDGFRalpha(+) ectomesenchyme originates from the lateral non-neural domain of neural fold epithelium. This inference is consistent with previous reports (Nichols [ 1981] J Embryol Exp Morphol 64:105-120; Nichols [ 1986] Am J Anat 176:221-231) that mesenchymal cells emerge precociously from an epithelial neural fold domain resembling the primitive streak in the early embryonic epiblast. Therefore, we propose the name "metablast" for this non-neural epithelial domain to indicate that it is the site of a delayed local delamination of mesenchyme similar to involution of mesoderm during gastrulation. We further propose the testable hypothesis that neural crest and ectomesenchyme are developmentally distinct progenitor populations and that at least some ectomesenchyme is metablast-derived rather than neural crest-derived tissue. Developmental Dynamics 229:118-130, 2004.

Cell surface molecules and truncal neural crest ontogeny: A perspective

The neural crest cell is synonymous with vertebrates and can be viewed as a transitory, mobile vector that conveys neuroepithelial stem cells to a diverse number of remote locations in the embryo. Neural crest cells have been studied intensively over the past 30 years, and it is increasingly apparent that their fate is, at least in part, directed extrinsically by the environment to which they are exposed in vivo. The interface between the cell surface and the opposing environment is clearly an important compartment for the correct deployment of the neural crest. Here, we review some of the molecules present in this location and how they influence the fate of the neural crest and generate disease.

Id expression in amphioxus and lamprey highlights the role of gene cooption during neural crest evolution

Neural crest cells are unique to vertebrates and generate many of the adult structures that differentiate them from their closest invertebrate relatives, the cephalochordates. Id genes are robust markers of neural crest cells at all stages of development. We compared Id gene expression in amphioxus and lamprey to ask if cephalochordates deploy Id genes at the neural plate border and dorsal neural tube in a manner similar to vertebrates. Furthermore, we examined whether Id expression in these cells is a basal vertebrate trait or a derived feature of gnathostomes. We found that while expression of Id genes in the mesoderm and endoderm is conserved between amphioxus and vertebrates, expression in the lateral neural plate border and dorsal neural tube is a vertebrate novelty. Furthermore, expression of lamprey Id implies that recruitment of Id genes to these cells occurred very early in the vertebrate lineage. Based on expression in amphioxus we postulate that Id cooption conferred sensory cell progenitor-like properties upon the lateral neurectoderm, and pharyngeal mesoderm-like properties upon cranial neural crest. Amphioxus Id expression is also consistent with homology between the anterior neurectoderm of amphioxus and the presumptive placodal ectoderm of vertebrates. These observations support the idea that neural crest evolution was driven in large part by cooption of multipurpose transcriptional regulators from other tissues and cell types.

Sox10 is required for the early development of the prospective neural crest in Xenopus embryos

The Sox family of transcription factors has been implicated in the development of different tissues during embryogenesis. Several mutations in humans, mice, and zebrafish have shown that depletion of Sox10 activity produces defects in the development of neural crest derivatives, such as melanocytes, ganglia of the peripheral nervous system, and some specific cell types as glia. We have isolated the Xenopus homologue of the Sox10 gene. It is expressed in prospective neural crest and otic placode regions from the earliest stages of neural crest specification and in migrating cranial and trunk neural crest cells. Loss-of-function experiments using morpholino antisense oligos against Sox10 produce a loss of neural crest precursors and an enlargement of the surrounding neural plate and epidermis. This effect of Sox10 depletion is produced during some of the earliest steps of neural crest specification, as is shown by the inhibition in the expression of Slug and FoxD3, which are early markers of neural crest specification. In addition, we show that Sox10 depletion leads to an increase in apoptosis and a decrease in cell proliferation in the neural folds, suggesting that Sox10 could work as a survival as well as a specification factor in neural crest precursors during premigratory stages. Although some of the deficiencies found in the Waardenburg syndrome and in the Hirschprung disease could be associated with a failure of the development of crest derivatives during the late phase of its development, or even during adulthood, our results suggest that inhibition of Sox10 activity produces an earlier failure of neural crest precursors. In experiments where melanocytes and ganglia were induced in vivo and in vitro, we were able to block their development by inhibiting Sox10 activity. These results are compatible with an additional late role of Sox10 on development of neural crest derivatives, as it has been previously proposed. We show that Sox10 expression is dependent on FGF and Wnt activity, both in the neural crest and in the otic placode territories. Finally, in order to establish the position of Sox10 in the hierarchical cascade of gene activation required for neural crest specification, we used inducible forms of the wild type and dominant negatives for the Snail and Slug genes. Our results show that Snail is able to control Sox10 expression. However, the overexpression of Slug was not able to upregulate Sox10 expression. Taken together, these results indicate that Sox10 may lie between Snail and Slug in the genetic cascade that controls neural crest development.

Sox10 regulates the development of neural crest-derived melanocytes in Xenopus

The transcription factors of the Sox family play important roles in diverse developmental processes. A number of genetic studies have established that Sox10 is a major regulator of neural crest formation. Here, we report the cloning and functional analysis of the Xenopus Sox10 gene. Sox10 mRNA accumulates during gastrulation at the lateral edges of the neural plate, in the neural crest-forming region. In this tissue, Sox10 expression is regulated by Wnt signaling and colocalizes with two major regulators of neural crest formation, Slug and Sox9. While initially expressed in neural crest cells from all axial levels, at the tailbud stage, Sox10 is downregulated in the cranial neural crest and persists mostly in neural crest cells from the trunk region. Overexpression of Sox10 causes a dramatic expansion of the Slug expression domain. We show that the C-terminal portion of Sox10 is sufficient to mediate this activity. Later during embryogenesis, Sox10-injected embryos show a massive increase in pigment cells (Trp-2-expressing cells). The responsiveness of the embryo to Sox10 overexpression by expansion of the Slug expression domain and ectopic production of Trp-2-positive cells and differentiated melanocytes is lost during gastrulation, as revealed by a hormone-inducible Sox10 construct. These results suggest that Sox10 is involved in the specification of neural crest progenitors fated to form the pigment cell lineage.

Xenopus Nbx, a novel NK-1 related gene essential for neural crest formation

The vertebrate neural crest is formed at the border between the neural plate and nonneural ectoderm during neurulation and eventually gives rise to a variety of cell types, including neurons, glia, facial chondrocytes and osteoblasts, and melanocytes. Although several secreted molecules, such as BMP, Wnts, FGF, and Noelin, have been implicated in neural crest formation, little is known about the precise intracellular mechanism underlying neural crest induction and differentiation. Here, we have identified a novel NK-1 class homeobox gene Nbx in Xenopus whose expression is correlated with neural crest formation. We also found that Nbx harbors an Eh1 domain and is a transcriptional repressor. Overexpression of Nbx suppressed neural plate makers and caused enhanced expression of the neural crest maker Slug. In contrast, the overexpression of a dominant negative form of Nbx during neurula stages suppressed the expression of the neural crest marker Slug and expanded neural markers such as Otx2 and Sox2. Taken together, we propose that Nbx is an essential transcriptional repressor required to permit neural crest induction by inhibiting the neural fate.

Essential role for puma in development of postembryonic neural crest-derived cell lineages in zebrafish

Multipotent neural crest stem cells have been identified in late gestation amniote embryos. Yet, significant questions remain about the mechanisms by which these cells are generated, maintained, and recruited during postembryonic development. The zebrafish, Danio rerio, offers an opportunity to identify genes essential for these processes, by screening for mutants with defects in traits likely to depend on these cells during metamorphosis and adult life. One such trait is the pigment pattern formed by neural crest-derived pigment cells, or chromatophores, which include black melanophores, yellow xanthophores, and iridescent iridophores. Previous analyses have demonstrated that the adult zebrafish pigment pattern depends on the de novo differentiation of latent precursor cells during both early and late phases of pigment pattern metamorphosis. To better understand the development of these cells, in this study, we analyze the zebrafish puma mutant, which ablates most of the adult melanophores that differentiate during metamorphosis, but leaves intact early larval melanophores that differentiate during embryogenesis. We use epistasis analyses to show that puma promotes the development of both early-appearing metamorphic melanophores that depend on the kit receptor tyrosine kinase, as well as late-appearing metamorphic melanophores that depend on both the G-protein-coupled endothelin receptor b1 (ednrb1) and the kit-related fms receptor tyrosine kinase. We further demonstrate that, during pigment pattern metamorphosis, puma mutants have deficiencies in the numbers of cells expressing transcripts for kit, ednrb1, and fms, as well as the HMG domain transcription factor sox10. Because the puma mutant phenotype is temperature-sensitive, we use temperature-shift experiments to identify a critical period for puma activity during pigment pattern metamorphosis. Finally, we use cell transplantations to show that puma acts cell-autonomously to promote the expansion of pigment cell lineages during metamorphosis. These results suggest a model for the lineage diversification of neural crest stem cells during zebrafish postembryonic development.

Wnt-frizzled signaling in the induction and differentiation of the neural crest

The neural crest is a transient population of multipotent progenitors arising at the lateral edge of the neural plate in vertebrate embryos. After delamination and migration from the neuroepithelium, these cells contribute to a diverse array of tissues including neurons, smooth muscle, craniofacial cartilage, bone cells, endocrine cells and pigment cells. Considerable progress in recent years has furthered our understanding at a molecular level of how this important group of cells is generated and how they are assigned to specific lineages. Here we review a number of recent studies supporting a role for Wnt signaling in neural crest induction, differentiation, and apoptosis. We also summarize the timing of expression of a number of Wnt ligands and receptors with respect to neural crest induction.

Induction of neural crest in Xenopus by transcription factor AP2alpha

We report experiments with Xenopus laevis, using both intact embryos and ectodermal explants, showing that the transcription factor AP2alpha is positively regulated by bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) and Wnt signaling, and that this activation is an essential step in the induction of neural crest (NC). Ectopic expression of AP2alpha is sufficient to activate high-level expression of NC-specific genes such as Slug and Sox9, which can occur as isolated domains within the neural plate as well as by expansion of endogenous NC territories. AP2alpha also has the property of inducing NC in isolated ectoderm in which Wnt signaling is provided but BMP signaling is minimized by overexpression of chordin. Like other NC regulatory factors, activation of AP2alpha requires some attenuation of endogenous BMP signaling; however, this process occurs at a lower threshold for AP2alpha. Furthermore, AP2alpha expression domains are larger than for other NC factors. Loss-of-function experiments with antisense AP2alpha morpholino oligonucleotides result in severe reduction in the NC territory. These results support a central role for AP2alpha in NC induction. We propose a model in which AP2alpha expression, along with inactivation of NC inhibitory factors such as Dlx3, establish a feedback loop comprising AP2alpha, Sox9, and Slug, leading to and maintaining NC specification.

Identification of neural crest competence territory: Role of Wnt signaling

In recent years, research on neural crest induction has allowed the identification of several molecules as candidates for neural crest inducers. Although many of these molecules have the ability to induce neural crest in different assays, a general mechanism of neural crest induction that includes a description of the tissues that produce the inductive signals and the time and steps in which this process takes place remains elusive. To better understand the mechanism of neural crest induction, we developed an assay that has been used previously by Nieuwkoop to study anterior-posterior pattern of the neural plate. Folds of competent ectoderm were implanted in different positions of a young neurula embryo, and the induction of neural crest was analyzed using the expression of the neural crest marker Xslug. We identified a very localized region of the early neurula where it is possible to get neural crest induction, whereas all of the regions tested showed a clear induction of the neural plate marker Xsox2. These results indicate that there is a region in the embryo with the appropriate combination of signals needed to induce neural crest cells; we called this region the neural crest competence territory. In addition, our results show that neural crest induction is always accompanied by neural plate induction, but there are many cases where neural plate was induced without neural crest. These results support the model in which the neural crest is induced by an interaction between neural plate and epidermis, but they also suggest that additional signals are required. By making grafts of different sizes and implanting them in the epidermis or the neural plate, we concluded that one of the inductive signals is produced in the dorsal region of the embryo and travels into the ectoderm. Finally, by performing gain- and loss-of-function of Wnt signaling experiments, we show that this pathway plays an important role not only in neural crest induction but also in the specification of the neural crest competence territory. Developmental Dynamics 229:109-117, 2004.

Pigment pattern formation in zebrafish: a model for developmental genetics and the evolution of form

The zebrafish Danio rerio is an emerging model organism for understanding vertebrate development and genetics. One trait of both historical and recent interest is the pattern formed by neural crest-derived pigment cells, or chromatophores, which include black melanophores, yellow xanthophores, and iridescent iridophores. In zebrafish, an embryonic and early larval pigment pattern consists of several stripes of melanophores and iridophores, whereas xanthophores are scattered widely over the flank. During metamorphosis, however, this pattern is transformed into that of the adult, which comprises several dark stripes of melanophores and iridophores that alternate with light stripes of xanthophores and iridophores. In this review, we place zebrafish relative to other model and non-model species; we review what is known about the processes of chromatophore specification, differentiation, and morphogenesis during the development of embryonic and adult pigment patterns, and we address how future studies of zebrafish will likely aid our understanding of human disease and the evolution of form.

An amphioxus winged helix/forkhead gene, AmphiFoxD: insights into vertebrate neural crest evolution

During amphioxus development, the neural plate is bordered by cells expressing many genes with homologs involved in vertebrate neural crest induction. However, these amphioxus cells evidently lack additional genetic programs for the cell delaminations, migrations, and differentiations characterizing definitive vertebrate neural crest. We characterize an amphioxus winged helix/forkhead gene (AmphiFoxD) closely related to vertebrate FoxD genes. Phylogenetic analysis indicates that the AmphiFoxD is basal to vertebrate FoxD1, FoxD2, FoxD3, FoxD4, and FoxD5. One of these vertebrate genes (FoxD3) consistently marks neural crest during development. Early in amphioxus development, AmphiFoxD is expressed medially in the anterior neural plate as well as in axial (notochordal) and paraxial mesoderm; later, the gene is expressed in the somites, notochord, cerebral vesicle (diencephalon), and hindgut endoderm. However, there is never any expression in cells bordering the neural plate. We speculate that an AmphiFoxD homolog in the common ancestor of amphioxus and vertebrates was involved in histogenic processes in the mesoderm (evagination and delamination of the somites and notochord); then, in the early vertebrates, descendant paralogs of this gene began functioning in the presumptive neural crest bordering the neural plate to help make possible the delaminations and cell migrations that characterize definitive vertebrate neural crest.

The formation of sensorimotor circuits

Recent studies have identified some of the key molecular pathways that control the genesis of spinal sensorimotor circuits. Transcription factors play a central role in these events, regulating both the specification of neurons that constitute these sensorimotor pathways and the expression of downstream molecules that control the wiring up of these neurons into topologically interconnected neuronal networks.

Early induction of neural crest cells: lessons learned from frog, fish and chick

The identification of genes in Xenopus, chick and zebrafish expressed early in prospective neural crest (NC) cells has challenged the previous view that the NC is induced during the closure of the neural tube. We compare here the early inductive molecular mechanisms in different organisms and, despite observed differences, propose a general common model for NC induction.

Induction of the neural crest: a multigene process

In the embryo, the neural crest is an important population of cells that gives rise to diverse derivatives, including the peripheral nervous system and the craniofacial skeleton. Evolutionarily, the neural crest is of interest as an important innovation in vertebrates. Experimentally, it represents an excellent system for studying fundamental developmental processes, such as tissue induction. Classical embryologists have identified interactions between tissues that lead to neural crest formation. More recently, geneticists and molecular biologists have identified the genes that are involved in these interactions; this recent work has revealed that induction of the neural crest is a complex multistep process that involves many genes.

Dorsalization of the neural tube by Xenopus tiarin, a novel patterning factor secreted by the flanking nonneural head ectoderm

We have isolated a novel secreted dorsalizing factor of the neural tube, Xenopus Tiarin, which belongs to the olfactomedin-related family. Tiarin expression starts at the late gastrula stage in the nonneural ectoderm adjacent to the anterior neural plate. Overexpression of Tiarin in the embryo causes expansion of dorsal neural markers and suppression of ventral markers. In the eye-forming field, Tiarin overexpression induces the retinal markers and represses optic stalk markers. Tiarin directly dorsalizes neural tissues in the absence of mesodermal tissues and antagonizes the ventralizing activity of Sonic hedghog (Shh). Unlike BMP4, another dorsalizing factor, Tiarin does not display antineuralizing activity on the ectoderm or mesoderm-ventralizing activity. These findings show that Tiarin is a novel patterning signal candidate acting in the specification of the dorsal neural tube.