Value of clonality studies of cutaneous T lymphocytes in the diagnosis and follow-up of patients with mycosis fungoides

Angioimmunoblastic T-cell lymphoma and Kaposi sarcoma: A fortuitous collision?

AIMS

Follicular helper T-cell (TFH) lymphoma of the angioimmunoblastic-type (AITL), one of the most prevalent T-cell lymphomas, typically encompasses proliferation of high endothelial venules and Epstein-Barr virus-positive immunoblasts, but neither infection with HHV8 nor association with Kaposi's sarcoma (KS) have been described. The aims of this study are to characterise the association between AITL and HHV8 infection or KS.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Three male patients aged 49-76 years, HIV-negative, with concurrent nodal involvement by AITL and KS, were identified from our files and carefully studied. Two patients originated from countries where endemic KS occurs, including one with cutaneous KS. The lymphomas featured abundant vessels, expanded follicular dendritic cells and neoplastic TFH cells [PD1+ (three of three), ICOS+ (three of three), CXCL13+ (three of three), CD10+ (two of three), BCL6 (two of three)] but lacked EBV+ immunoblasts. The foci of KS consisted of subcapsular proliferations of ERG+, CD31+ and/or CD34+ , HHV8+ spindle cells. High-throughput sequencing showed AITL-associated mutations in TET2 (three of three), RHOA (G17V) (three of three) and IDH2 (R172) (two of three), which were absent in the microdissected KS component in two cases. Relapses in two patients consisted of AITL, without evidence of KS. No evidence of HHV8 infection was found in a control group of 23 AITL cases.

CONCLUSION

Concurrent nodal involvement by AITL and KS is rare and identification of both neoplastic components may pose diagnostic challenges. The question of whether the association between AITL and KS may be fortuitous or could reflect the underlying immune dysfunction in AITL remains open.

Primary cutaneous peripheral T-cell lymphomas with a T-follicular helper phenotype: an integrative clinical, pathological and molecular case series study

BACKGROUND

Primary cutaneous peripheral T-cell lymphomas with a T-follicular helper phenotype (pcTFH-PTCL) are poorly characterized, and often compared to, but not corresponding with, mycosis fungoides (MF), Sézary syndrome, primary cutaneous CD4⁺ lymphoproliferative disorder, and skin manifestations of angioimmunoblastic T-cell lymphomas (AITL).

OBJECTIVES

We describe the clinicopathological features of pcTFH-PTCL in this original series of 23 patients, and also characterize these cases molecularly.

METHODS

Clinical and histopathological data of the selected patients were reviewed. Patient biopsy samples were also analysed by targeted next-generation sequencing.

RESULTS

All patients (15 men, eight women; median age 66 years) presented with skin lesions, without systemic disease. Most were stage T3b, with nodular (n = 16), papular (n = 6) or plaque (atypical for MF, n = 1) lesions. Three (13%) developed systemic disease and died of lymphoma. Nine (39%) patients received more than one line of chemotherapy. Histologically, the lymphomas were CD4⁺ T-cell proliferations, usually dense and located in the deep dermis (n = 14, 61%), with the expression of at least two TFH markers (CD10, CXCL13, PD1, ICOS, BCL6), including three markers in 16 cases (70%). They were associated with a variable proportion of B cells. Eight patients were diagnosed with an associated B-cell lymphoproliferative disorder (LPD) on biopsy, including Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-positive diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (n = 3), EBV⁺ LPD (n = 1) and monotypic plasma cell LPD (n = 4). Targeted sequencing showed four patients to have a mutated TET2-RHOAG17V association (as frequently seen in AITL) and another a TET2/DNMT3A/PLCG1/SETD2 mutational profile. The latter patient, one with a TET2-RHOA association, and one with no detected mutations, developed systemic disease and died. Five other patients showed isolated mutations in TET2 (n = 1), PLCG1 (n = 2), SETD2 (n = 1) or STAT5B (n = 1).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with pcTFH-PTCL have pathological and genetic features that overlap with those of systemic lymphoma of TFH derivation. Clinically, most remained confined to the skin, with only three patients showing systemic spread and death. Whether pcTFH-PTCL should be integrated as a new subgroup of TFH lymphomas in future classifications is still a matter of debate. What is already known about this topic? There is a group of cutaneous lymphomas that express T-follicular helper (TFH) markers that do not appear to correspond to existing World Health Organization diagnostic entities. These include mycosis fungoides, Sézary syndrome, or primary cutaneous CD4⁺ small/medium-sized T-cell lymphoproliferative disorder or cutaneous extensions of systemic peripheral T-cell lymphomas (PTCL) with TFH phenotype. What does this study add? This is the first large original series of patients with a diagnosis of primary cutaneous PTCL with a TFH phenotype (pcTFH-PTCL) to be molecularly characterized. pcTFH-PTCL may be a standalone group of cutaneous lymphomas with clinicopathological and molecular characteristics that overlap with those of systemic TFH lymphomas, such as angioimmunoblastic T-cell lymphoma, and does not belong to known diagnostic groups of cutaneous lymphoma. This has an impact on the treatment and follow-up of patients; the clinical behaviour needs to be better clarified in further studies to tailor patient management.

Single-Cell RNA Sequencing Unveils the Clonal and Transcriptional Landscape of Cutaneous T-Cell Lymphomas

PURPOSE

Clonal malignant T lymphocytes constitute only a fraction of T cells in mycosis fungoides skin tumors and in the leukemic blood of Sézary syndrome, the classic types of cutaneous T-cell lymphomas. However, lack of markers specific for malignant lymphocytes prevents distinguishing them from benign T cells, thus delaying diagnosis and the development of targeted treatments. Here we applied single-cell methods to assess the transcriptional profiles of both malignant T-cell clones and reactive T lymphocytes directly in mycosis fungoides/Sézary syndrome patient samples.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

Single-cell RNA sequencing was used to profile the T-cell immune repertoire simultaneously with gene expression in CD3+ lymphocytes from mycosis fungoides and healthy skin biopsies as well as from Sézary syndrome and control blood samples. Transcriptional data were validated in additional advanced-stage mycosis fungoides/Sézary syndrome skin and blood samples by immunofluorescence microscopy.

RESULTS

Several nonoverlapping clonotypes are expanded in the skin and blood of individual advanced-stage mycosis fungoides/Sézary syndrome patient samples, including a dominant malignant clone as well as additional minor malignant and reactive clones. While we detected upregulation of patient-specific as well as mycosis fungoides- and Sézary syndrome-specific oncogenic pathways within individual malignant clones, we also detected upregulation of several common pathways that included genes associated with cancer cell metabolism, cell-cycle regulation, de novo nucleotide biosynthesis, and invasion.

CONCLUSIONS

Our analysis unveils new insights into mycosis fungoides/Sézary syndrome pathogenesis by providing an unprecedented report of the transcriptional profile of malignant T-cell clones in the skin and blood of individual patients and offers novel prospective targets for personalized therapy.

Primary Cutaneous CD4+ Small/Medium T-Cell Lymphoproliferative Disorders: A Clinical, Pathologic, and Molecular Study of 60 Cases Presenting With a Single Lesion: A Multicenter Study of the French Cutaneous Lymphoma Study Group

Primary cutaneous CD4 small/medium T-cell lymphoproliferative disorder (PCSMLPD) is a recently recognized entity in the 2017 World Health Organization (WHO) classification. It belongs to the T-follicular helper (TFH) lymphoproliferations. The clinical, pathologic, and molecular features of this localized disease are underresearched. We conducted a retrospective multicentric study of 60 patients with a PCSMLPD that presented as a single cutaneous lesion. Clinical, pathologic, and targeted molecular analyses were performed. PCSMLPD presented mostly as a nodule (45%), located on the head and neck area (50%) in adults (mean age: 59 y [43.3 to 75.2]). All patients had an indolent disease course, either at initial staging or during follow-up (mean: 16.6 mo [1.3 to 31.9]). Spontaneous regression was reported in 31.9% of cases. The infiltrates were most often nodular and/or diffuse, expanding in the whole dermis (78%, Pattern 1), rather than subepidermal band-like in the superficial dermis (22%, Pattern 2). Epidermotropism, folliculotropism, and capillary hyperplasia were common. The expression of TFH lineage markers was more extensive in lesions with Pattern 2, but a substantial B-cell infiltrate was seen in both types of lesions. A clonal rearrangement of the TCR genes was identified in 68% of cases. One sample of the 13 tested revealed a mutation in the DNMT3A gene among the 9 genes studied (TET2, DNMT3A, IDH2, RHOA, SETD2, PLCG1, STAT3, STAT5B, and CD28). PCSMLPD follows a benign clinical course and can spontaneously regress after biopsy. Although PCSMLPD expresses TFH lineage markers, mutations usually found in angioimmunoblastic T-cell lymphomas are uncommon.

Skin colonization by circulating neoplastic clones in cutaneous T-cell lymphoma

Mycosis fungoides (MF) is a mature T-cell lymphoma currently thought to develop primarily in the skin by a clonal expansion of a transformed, resident memory T cell. However, this concept does not explain the key characteristics of MF, such as the debut with multiple, widespread skin lesions or inability of skin-directed therapies to provide cure. The testable inference of the mature T-cell theory is the clonality of MF with respect to all rearranged T-cell receptor (TCR) genes. Here, we used a whole-exome sequencing approach to detect and quantify TCR-α, β, and γ clonotypes in tumor cell clusters microdissected from MF lesions. This method allowed us to calculate the tumor cell fraction of the sample and therefore an unequivocal identification of the TCR clonotypes as neoplastic. Analysis of TCR sequences from 29 patients with MF stage I to IV proved the existence of multiple T-cell clones within the tumor cell fraction, with a considerable variation between patients and between lesions from the same patient (median, 11 clones; range, 2-80 clones/sample). We have also detected multiple neoplastic clones in the peripheral blood in all examined patients. Based on these findings, we propose that circulating neoplastic T-cell clones continuously replenish the lesions of MF, thus increasing their heterogeneity by a mechanism analogous to the consecutive tumor seeding. We hypothesize that circulating neoplastic clones might be a promising target for therapy and could be exploited as a potential biomarker in MF.

Expression of TFH Markers and Detection of RHOA p.G17V and IDH2 p.R172K/S Mutations in Cutaneous Localizations of Angioimmunoblastic T-Cell Lymphomas

Skin biopsies of 41 angioimmunoblastic T-cell lymphoma patients were retrospectively analyzed for the expression of follicular helper T-cell (TFH) markers, Epstein-Barr virus (EBV), and the presence of RHOA (p.G17V) and IDH2 (p.R172K/S) mutations using allele-specific polymerase chain reaction. We categorized cases into 4 distinctive patterns: (1) low-density lymphocytic perivascular infiltrates (n=11), (2) dense perivascular infiltrates with atypical cells and occasional inflammatory cells (n=13), (3) diffuse infiltrates reminiscent of angioimmunoblastic T-cell lymphoma (n=4), or (4) other aspects (n=13). Two EBV and 2 plasmacytoid lymphoproliferative disorders were seen. We observed variable expression of TFH markers (CD10 [50%], BCLB6 [84%], PD1 [94%], CXCL13 [84%], and ICOS [97.5%]), and EBV B-blasts (26%). A TFH phenotype was identified in 82% and 73%, respectively, of cases with the most challenging patterns 1 and 2. TFH markers and EBV can thus help for diagnosis and are detected in samples with low-density infiltrates. We found RHOA G17V and IDH2 R172K/S mutations in the skin in 14/18 (78%) and 3/16 (19%) cases, respectively. The RHOA G17V mutation was identified in a proportion of biopsies with patterns 1 and 2, which represent a diagnostic challenge. The RHOA G17V mutation was detected both in the skin and lymph node (LN) biopsies in 7/9 (64%) cases, and in only the skin or the LN of 1 sample each. The frequency of RHOA G17V mutation was similar to that reported in LNs. It may represent a sensitive diagnostic marker in the skin, helpful in cases with low-density infiltrates.

Pediatric primary follicular mucinosis: further evidence of its relationship with mycosis fungoides

Follicular mucinosis (FM) is an uncommon reaction pattern in which the accumulation of mucin in the follicular epithelium is the main pathologic finding. FM may be idiopathic (primary follicular mucinosis [PFM]), in association with mycosis fungoides or cutaneous T-cell lymphoma, or in association with other neoplastic and inflammatory conditions. Herein we report a case of PFM with identical T-cell clone rearrangement at anatomically distinct sites, supporting the idea that some authors have proposed, that FM may represent a low-grade lymphoproliferative disease related to mycoses fungoides with favorable prognosis.

Peripheral T-cell lymphoma in HIV-infected patients: a study of 17 cases in the combination antiretroviral therapy era

Most cases of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-associated non-Hodgkin Lymphoma (NHL) are of B-cell origin; T-cell NHLs are rarely reported. Within a single centre prospective cohort of 370 HIV-NHL, 17 (5%) were of T-cell origin (82% male; median age, 39 years). Median CD4+ cell count was 0·194 × 10(9) /l and 41% had undetectable plasma HIV-RNA at lymphoma diagnosis. All patients received combination antiretroviral therapy during chemotherapy. All histological samples were centrally reviewed. The distribution of the histological subtypes differed from the general population with absence of angioimmunoblastic subtype. Lymphoma was disseminated in 14 patients, and seven patients had performance status >2. All patients received full-dose chemotherapy: eight standard and nine intensive regimens. Two patients who received intensive chemotherapy died during therapy. The complete remission rate was 53%; 62·5% with standard therapy and 44% with intensive therapy. After a median follow-up of 7·2 years, the median overall survival was 9·4 months. Most deaths (85%) occurred within the first year following diagnosis, as a consequence of lymphoma progression in 10/13 cases. In this rare but severe complication of HIV infection the use of intensive chemotherapy does not appear to be beneficial for response, with increased toxicity.

A simple and efficient method for DNA extraction from skin and paraffin-embedded tissues applicable to T-cell clonality assays

PCR-based clonality assay of rearranged T-cell receptor genes gamma and beta (TCRG and TCRB) in a number of cases could be essential to discriminate between cutaneous T-cell lymphomas and reactive lymphoproliferative lesions in the skin. However, extraction of good-quality DNA from skin specimens (especially formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded) remains a challenge. Common procedures, being labour-intensive and time-consuming and requiring toxic solvents such as phenol and chloroform, still may end up with DNA sample of insufficient quality. We herewith present a simple and efficient method for DNA isolation based on ammonia extraction of tissue, followed by neutralization and simultaneous salting out of proteins with acetic acid. We have analysed 30 samples - 24 fresh (16 skin, two spleen and six lymph node) and six paraffin-embedded. Standard procedure (proteinase K digestion, followed by phenol/chloroform extraction) has been carried out simultaneously. We observed good PCR signal for TCRG rearrangements in 30 samples processed with the new protocol and only in 20 extracted with proteinase K/phenol/chloroform. For TCRB, the success rate was 29 of 30 with the new protocol, compared to 11 of 30 with conventional protocol. The proposed method of DNA extraction should improve the value of T-cell clonality assay, because insufficient DNA quality and quantity may bias analysis towards monoclonality and therefore cause false-positive results.

High-scatter T cells: a reliable biomarker for malignant T cells in cutaneous T-cell lymphoma

In early-stage cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL), malignant T cells are confined to skin and are difficult to isolate and discriminate from benign reactive cells. We found that T cells from CTCL skin lesions contained a population of large, high-scatter, activated skin homing T cells not observed in other inflammatory skin diseases. High-scatter T (T(HS)) cells were CD4(+) in CD4(+) mycosis fungoides (MF), CD8(+) in CD8(+) MF, and contained only clonal T cells in patients with identifiable malignant Vβ clones. T(HS) cells were present in the blood of patients with leukemic CTCL, absent in patients without blood involvement, and contained only clonal malignant T cells. The presence of clonal T(HS) cells correlated with skin disease in patients followed longitudinally. Clonal T(HS) cells underwent apoptosis in patients clearing on extracorporeal photopheresis but persisted in nonresponsive patients. Benign clonal T-cell proliferations mapped to the normal low-scatter T-cell population. Thus, the malignant T cells in both MF and leukemic CTCL can be conclusively identified by a unique scatter profile. This observation will allow selective study of malignant T cells, can be used to discriminate patients with MF from patients with other inflammatory skin diseases, to detect peripheral blood involvement, and to monitor responses to therapy.

Clonal relationship of extranodal marginal zone lymphomas of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue involving different sites

Patients with mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) lymphoma often have multiple sites of disease at initial diagnosis or during the clinical course. The neoplasms at multiple sites are often presumed to be identical, indicating dissemination or relapse. However, evidence to support this presumption is usually not available. We compared IGH VDJ sequences in 4 patients with 2 sequential sites of MALT lymphoma. The specimen pairs were stomach and nasopharynx, stomach and lung, ocular adnexa and nasopharynx, and ocular adnexa and parotid gland. The median interval between biopsies was 4 months (range, 1-32 months). Monoclonal IGH gene rearrangement was detected in all cases. In 3 patients, the VDJ sequences were distinct; in 1 patient the 2 biopsy specimens shared the same clone. MALT lymphomas involving multiple sites in a patient are usually not clonally related but arise independently, likely due to chronic antigenic stimulation, inducing oligoclonal B-cell proliferations and eventually a dominant B-cell clone.

T-cell clonality analysis in biopsy specimens from two different skin sites shows high specificity in the diagnosis of patients with suggested mycosis fungoides

BACKGROUND

The diagnosis of mycosis fungoides (MF) is often difficult because of significant clinical and histopathologic overlap with inflammatory dermatoses. T-cell receptor (TCR)gamma chain rearrangement by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) (TCR-PCR) is a helpful adjuvant tool in this setting, but several of the inflammatory dermatoses in the differential diagnosis of MF may contain a clonal T-cell proliferation.

OBJECTIVE

We examined whether analysis for T-cell clonality and comparison of the clones with the standardized BIOMED-2 PCR multiplex primers for the TCRgamma chain from two anatomically distinct skin sites improves diagnostic accuracy.

METHODS

We examined two biopsy specimens each from 10 patients with unequivocal MF, from 18 patients with inflammatory dermatoses, and from 18 patients who could initially not be definitively given a diagnosis based on clinical and histopathologic criteria.

RESULTS

Eight of 10 patients with unequivocal MF had an identical clone in both biopsy specimens. Two of 18 patients with inflammatory dermatoses were found to have a clone in one of the biopsy specimens. On further follow-up of the 18 patients with morphologically nondiagnostic biopsy specimens, 13 of 18 were later confirmed to have MF and 5 of 18 had inflammatory dermatoses. Eleven of 13 patients with MF had an identical clone in both biopsy specimens; two of 13 had a polyclonal amplification pattern in both biopsy specimens. Four of 5 patients with inflammatory dermatoses had no clone in either biopsy specimen. One patient with an inflammatory dermatosis had an identical clone in both specimens. The sensitivity of TCR-PCR analysis to evaluate for an identical clone at different anatomic skin sites (dual TCR-PCR) is 82.6% and the specificity is 95.7%.

LIMITATIONS

The number of patients in the study group was limited.

CONCLUSION

These data suggest that dual TCR-PCR is a very promising technique with high specificity in distinguishing MF from inflammatory dermatoses.

Histopathologic-molecular correlation in early mycosis fungoides using T-cell receptor gamma gene rearrangement by polymerase chain reaction with laser capture microdissection

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Early mycosis fungoides (MF) is difficult to distinguish from other benign inflammatory dermatoses. We evaluated clonal T-cell receptor (TCR) gamma gene rearrangement by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) as a surrogate to histologic diagnosis in early MF.

METHODS

Twenty paraffin-embedded skin biopsies from nine patients diagnosed with MF were included. Two multiplex PCR encompassing various Vgamma and Jgamma regions were used to detect TCRgamma gene rearrangements. Histologic diagnoses were categorized as "diagnostic", "consistent", "suggestive", or "nondiagnostic". We compared TCRgamma PCR results with histologic parameters to determine the differences between PCR-positive and PCR-negative groups.

RESULTS

TCRgamma PCR was positive in 53% (8/15) of the patch stage, in 100% (2/2) of the plaque stage, and in 100% (3/3) of the tumor stage. TCRgamma PCR was positive in 50% (4/8) of the specimens in both the diagnostic and consistent of MF groups, 71% (5/7) in the suggestive of MF group. We found that inflammation was more severe in PCR-negative specimens. Papillary dermal fibrosis was common, and differed significantly between PCR-positive and PCR-negative groups (p = 0.01). T-cell monoclonality was detected in one nondiagnostic lesion in a patient with psoriasis and MF.

CONCLUSION

TCRgamma PCR allows the diagnosis of MF in patients with lymphocyte-poor lesions, suggestive of MF pathologically. TCRgamma PCR is more likely to be negative with moderate to severe inflammation, particularly with papillary dermal fibrosis. We suggest that the ratio of malignant clonal to reactive T-cells is critical for MF diagnosis.

Molecular Analysis of T-Cell Receptor β Genes in Cutaneous T-Cell Lymphoma Reveals Jβ1 Bias

Molecular characterization of T-cell receptor junctional region sequences in cutaneous T-cell lymphoma had not been previously reported. We have examined in detail the features of the T-cell receptor beta (TCRB) gene rearrangements in 20 individuals with well-defined stages of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL) comprising 10 cases with early-stage mycosis fungoides (MF) and 10 cases with late-stage MF or Sezary syndrome. Using BIOMED-2 PCR primers, we detected a high frequency of clonally rearranged TCR gamma and TCRB genes (17/20 and 15/20 cases, respectively). We carried out sequencing analysis of each complete clonal variable (V)beta-diversity (D)beta-joining(J)beta fingerprint generated by PCR amplification, and determined the primary structure of the Vbeta-Dbeta-Jbeta junctional regions. We observed considerable diversity in the T-cell receptor Vbeta gene usage and complementarity-determining region 3 loops. Although we found that TCRB gene usage in CTCL and normal individuals share common features, our analysis also revealed preferential usage of Jbeta1 genes in all cases with advanced stages of disease.

Detailed analysis of the T-cell lymphocytic infiltrate in penile lichen sclerosus: an immunohistochemical and molecular investigation

AIM

To determine the extent of clonal outgrowth in the lymphocytic tissue infiltrate of lichen sclerosus (LS). The presence of T cells with a monoclonally rearranged T-cell receptor gamma-gene (TCRgamma) has been described in up to 50% of biopsies of vulvar and penile LS.

MATERIAL AND RESULTS

We analysed 33 foreskin specimens with LS for the presence of clonal T cells by conventional polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis and with TCRgamma-PCR-based fluorescent fragment analysis. Eighteen of 33 patients revealed a band indicating a monoclonally rearranged TCRgamma on conventional PCR analysis. Subsequent TCRgamma-PCR-based fluorescent fragment analysis identified 8/18 patients with monoclonal T-cell DNA ranging from 1.4% to 23.1% of total T-cell DNA analysed and a size range from 56 to 72 base pairs. Four of 18 patients had an oligoclonal and 6/18 patients revealed a polyclonal banding pattern. The lymphocytic infiltrate contained low numbers of gammadelta T cells and cytotoxic T cells in comparable numbers to the low percentage of clonal TCRgamma DNA.

CONCLUSIONS

The low percentage of clonal TCRgamma DNA argues against a systemic neoplastic disease, but rather for a local immune disorder. The target antigen of the clonal outgrowth is unknown, but an exaggerated antigen-dependent proliferation of T cells due to chronic local antigen exposure, probably an infectious antigen, is the most likely explanation.

Defining early mycosis fungoides

This editorial review summarizes the results of 5 meetings sponsored by the International Society for Cutaneous Lymphoma at which the clinicopathologic and ancillary features of early mycosis fungoides were critically examined. Based on this analysis, an algorithm was developed for the diagnosis of early mycosis fungoides involving a holistic integration of clinical, histopathologic, immunopathologic, and molecular biological characteristics. A novel aspect of this algorithm is that it relies on multiple types of criteria rather than just one, for example, histopathology. Before its finalization, the proposed diagnostic algorithm will require validation and possibly further refinement at multiple centers during the next several years. It is anticipated that a more standardized approach to the diagnosis of early mycosis fungoides will have a beneficial impact on the epidemiology, prognostication, treatment, and analysis of clinical trials pertaining to this most common type of cutaneous lymphoma.

T-cell receptor γ gene rearrangement by multiplex polymerase chain reaction/heteroduplex analysis in patients with cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (mycosis fungoides/Sézary syndrome) and benign inflammatory disease: correlation with clinical, histological and i

BACKGROUND

A dominant T-cell clone can be detected by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in 40-90% of cutaneous samples from patients with cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

From 1996 to 2003 we analysed 547 cutaneous biopsies performed to exclude CTCL (mycosis fungoides, MF/Sézary syndrome, SS). The final diagnosis was benign inflammatory disease (BID) in 353 samples (64.5%) and CTCL in 194 (35.5%). T-cell receptor (TCR)-gamma gene rearrangement was studied by using a multiplex PCR/heteroduplex (HD) analysis. The PCR results were correlated with the clinical picture, the histological pattern and the presence of T-cell lineage antigen loss, using univariate and multivariate logistic regression analyses.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the sensitivity and specificity of the multiplex PCR/HD analysis and to identify which are the clinical, histopathological or immunophenotypical features significantly associated with a positive T-cell clonality.

RESULTS

A clonality was demonstrated in 83.5% of CTCL and in 2.3% of BID (P < 0.001). A significantly higher percentage of clonal cases was associated with the cutaneous T-score (71.4% in T1, 76.1% in T2 and 100% in nodular and erythrodermic MF samples) and with the presence of a T-cell lineage antigen loss (93.9% vs. 77.4%). Moreover, clonality was closely related to an increase in the histopathological score (51.3% in the samples with a score < 5, compared with 92% in the lesions with > or = 5). No significant difference in the percentage of clonal cases was found between T1/T2 and T3/T4 lesions with a histopathological score > or = 5. The multivariate logistic regression showed that the density and extent of the cell infiltrate, the degree of epidermotropism and the presence of cytological atypia share an independent predictive value for clonality in T1/T2 samples, even if the highest odds ratios (3.6) were associated with the density of the cell infiltrate. The disease course of T1/T2 patients was analysed according to the PCR findings. All the PCR-negative patients showed a long-standing stable disease course; on the other hand, a disease progression occurred in 12/87 (13.8%) positive patients.

CONCLUSIONS

The multiplex PCR/HD analysis is associated with a high diagnostic accuracy (92.7%) in CTCL patients. The finding of a clonal T-cell rearrangement is more closely associated with the histological pattern (in particular with the density and extent of the cell infiltrate) rather than with the MF cutaneous T-score or immunophenotype.

Correlations between clinical, histologic, blood, and skin polymerase chain reaction outcome in patients treated for mycosis fungoides

Little information is currently available regarding post-treatment outcome of TCR-targeted PCR in skin and/or peripheral blood in patients with Mycosis Fungoides (MF) when a dominant gene rearrangement is present at time of diagnosis. To address this matter, a study evaluating the correlations between post-treatment clinical, histological, blood and skin PCR data was conducted in MF patients. Twenty-seven MF patients with dominant gene rearrangement in skin lesions at time of diagnosis were selected. Peripheral blood samples were investigated as well before treatment and post treatment molecular data in skin and blood were compared with clinical and histological outcome. A dominant gene rearrangement was detected before treatment in blood of 16/25 patients. The dominant gene rearrangement disappeared from cutaneous lesions in 8/13 patients displaying complete clinical and histological response whereas skin PCR remained positive in all 10 patients with histologically persistent disease. A dominant gene rearrangement was still present in blood in 10/16 patients after treatment and blood data were not correlated with skin molecular response. This study confirms frequent detection of a dominant gene rearrangement in peripheral blood in MF patients and shows that PCR may remain positive in lesional sites even when skin lesions are successfully treated.

Minimal residual disease in mycosis fungoides follow-up can be assessed by polymerase chain reaction

BACKGROUND

T-cell receptor (TCR) gene rearrangement analysis, i.e. T-cell clonality, using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is a routine method used to assess the presence of a cutaneous dominant T-cell clone in mycosis fungoides (MF).

OBJECTIVES

To compare the outcome of cutaneous lesions of MF after treatment with the fate of the cutaneous T-cell clonality, and to determine whether minimal residual disease can be detected in patients in clinical complete remission.

METHODS

Fifty-one patients histologically diagnosed as having MF (17 stage IA, 21 stage IB and 13 stage III) were included in this retrospective study. T-cell clonality was analysed by GC-clamp multiplex PCRgamma-denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Every patient had two cutaneous biopsies at least 3 months apart. The second biopsy was performed at the site of a treated lesion.

RESULTS

The presence or absence of a dominant T-cell clone in the skin remained identical in 26 of the 31 (84%) patients with persistent disease. Thirteen patients with a detectable dominant T-cell clone at diagnosis went into complete clinical remission. In nine of these 13 (69%) patients, the T-cell clone was no longer detectable after treatment. The remaining four (31%) patients had an unchanged T-cell clonality.

CONCLUSIONS

The TCR gene rearrangement imprint is a stable and reliable tumour marker of MF disease. One-third of patients in complete clinical remission had a cutaneous molecular residual disease, the prognostic value of which will be analysed in an ongoing prospective study.

Assessment of histologic criteria in the diagnosis of mycosis fungoides

BACKGROUND

The histologic diagnosis of early mycosis fungoides (MF) can be difficult to establish in many instances because the subtle changes observed in patches of MF are also present in many inflammatory dermatoses.

METHODS

To assess the frequency and significance of many of these histologic parameters, we retrospectively reviewed 50 slides from patients with documented MF in patch, plaque, and tumor stages. The diagnosis of MF was unequivocally established either by the progression of patients to advanced stages of the disease or by indubitable histologic findings. In the second phase of the study, we compared the histologic parameters observed in 24 patch stage MF patients with those in 24 non-MF patients. The non-MF group were patients whose pathologic pattern was suspicious for MF, but who definitely did not have MF on clinical grounds. The two groups were matched by histologic pattern. Two different observers evaluated the slides and the intensities of 32 histologic parameters were graded on a four-point scale to minimize the subjective variability in the histologic reports.

RESULTS

On univariate analysis, the following parameters achieved significance in distinguishing MF from non-MF: Pautrier's microabscesses, haloed lymphocytes, disproportionate epidermotropism, epidermal lymphocytes larger than dermal lymphocytes, hyperconvoluted lymphocytes in the epidermis and dermis, absence of dyskeratosis, and papillary dermal fibrosis. None of these features proved to have additional discriminating power on multivariate analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

The efficacy of single histologic features in the diagnosis of early MF is generally poor and, to discriminate MF from its inflammatory simulators, a combination of cytologic and architectural features must be used.

Clonal heterogeneity in mycosis fungoides and its relationship to clinical course

Mycosis fungoides (MF) is a cutaneous T-cell lymphoma characterized by multifocal disease and protracted clinical course. The few studies that have assessed T-cell receptor (TCR) gene rearrangements (GRs) present at different anatomic sites in MF have generally reported a common clone. We used a previously validated 4-color polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay to assess the size and V-family usage of TCR-gamma GRs in 102 concurrent and/or sequential morphologically involved biopsy specimens (91 skin and 11 lymph nodes) from 39 MF patients. This assay detected TCR-gamma clonal GRs in 89 samples (87%) from 36 patients (92%). In 24 patients (77%), an identical clonal GR was present in at least 2 skin samples. However, in one third of these patients, additional different clonal GRs were also noted. Four patients (13%) had clonal GRs that were distinct in different skin samples. In 3 patients (10%), no GR was detected in any sample. In a comparison of lymph node and skin samples, 8 patients had the identical clonal GRs at both sites, 2 patients had different clonal GRs, and 1 patient had no GR identified at either site. Independent of clinical stage, patients who had the same GR detected in multiple concurrent biopsy specimens at the time of diagnosis were more likely to have progressive disease than those who had different GRs (P =.04). Four-color TCR-gamma PCR analysis can uncover multiple distinct clonal GRs in different samples consistent with multiclonal or oligoclonal disease in a significant proportion of MF patients. Demonstration of identical clonal GRs in multiple biopsy specimens at the time of diagnosis may provide prognostic information related to disease progression.

A T-cell receptor gamma polymerase chain reaction assay using capillary electrophoresis for the diagnosis of cutaneous T-cell lymphomas

Detection of clonal T-cell receptor gamma rearrangements by polymerase chain reaction (TCRgamma PCR) followed by high-resolution electrophoresis has now become a valuable tool in the diagnosis of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL). The identification of clonal TCRgamma PCR products by fluorescent fragment analysis (FFA) on a capillary DNA sequencer is described here and compared with an established hetero-duplex temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (HD-TGGE). Of 55 CTCL derived lesional skin samples, clonality was obtained in 46 samples by FFA (83.6%) and in 45 samples by HD-TGGE (81.8%). Of 35 control skin specimens from various nonmalignant dermatoses, two samples (pityriasis lichenoides chronica) showed clonality by both methods, one sample (chronic dermatitis) only by FFA. The sensitivity of FFA was established using three clonal T-cell lines and peripheral blood mononuclear cells. The detection limit for clonal material was approximately 1% to 2.5% in mixtures of DNA and 1% to 3% in cell dilutions. For cell dilution series, we confirmed a linear correlation between the clonal/polyclonal peak-size ratios and the portion of clonal cells up to about 10%. Thus, the initial ratio between mono-and polyclonal template is correctly displayed by FFA within that concentration range. In conclusion, FFA on capillary DNA sequencer is a well-suited separation technique in TCRgamma PCR-based clonality analysis also exhibiting quantitative properties.

Evidence that an identical T cell clone in skin and peripheral blood lymphocytes is an independent prognostic factor in primary cutaneous T cell lymphomas

The monoclonality of the T cell receptor gamma-chain gene was analyzed by polymerase chain reaction in skin and blood specimens of 85 patients with cutaneous T cell lymphomas including 67 mycosis fungoides, seven Sézary syndromes, and 11 CD30- nonepidermotropic cutaneous T cell lymphomas. A cutaneous T cell clone was detected in 69% of mycosis fungoides and 100% of Sézary syndromes. This frequency varied according to the clinical stage: 57% in early stages (Ia-IIa) to 96% in advanced stages (IIb-IV, Sézary syndrome). A peripheral blood T cell clone was detected in 42% of early stages and in 74% of late stages but was identical to the cutaneous one in 15% and in 63%, respectively. A significant association between initial clinical stage and T cell monoclonality was observed. In nonepidermotropic cutaneous T cell lymphomas, T cell monoclonality was detected in 55% of skin and 36% of blood samples. Univariate and multivariate analyses showed that, besides the initial clinical stage, an identical cutaneous and blood T cell clone was an independent prognostic factor for disease progression of mycosis fungoides/Sézary syndrome (hazard ratio 3.4, 95% confidence interval 1.4-9.9). Parallel polymerase chain reaction study of skin and blood specimens may therefore provide an initial prognostic marker that could help to monitor therapeutic strategies. A fully prospective study, with simultaneous therapeutic trials, needs to be done to confirm our findings and to include treatment variables in the statistical analysis.

The value of clonality in the diagnosis and follow-up of patients with cutaneous T-cell infiltrates

The diagnosis of early stages of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL) is often difficult, especially for lesions that are at the borderline between reactive and neoplastic skin T-cell infiltrates. T-cell monoclonality in these lesions is considered by some to be an important prognostic factor of neoplastic evolution, whereas others claim that clonality can also be found in benign skin infiltrates and is therefore of limited diagnostic value. To address this controversy, the authors analyzed retrospectively eight patients with lymphocytic skin lesions who progressed to CTCL, and three patients with recurrent T-cell lymphocytic infiltrates who had not developed CTCL. From a total of 65 biopsies of eight progressing patients, 32 were diagnosed as histologically malignant and 33 were diagnosed as benign or borderline. The authors found clonality by either polymerase chain reaction or Southern blot analysis in 88% of malignant and in 79% of nonmalignant lesions. None of the 37 biopsies of non-progressing patients was clonal. These results indicate strongly that the presence of monoclonality in T-cell skin infiltrates is related closely to the risk of developing CTCL. The value of clonality as a marker of malignancy is supported by the absence of T-cell clonal populations in all infiltrates from patients who had not progressed to lymphoma.

Sodium valproate-induced cutaneous pseudolymphoma followed by recurrence with carbamazepine

We report a patient with a sodium valproate-induced cutaneous pseudolymphoma, presenting with an erythematous papule, histologically mimicking a non-epidermotropic T-cell lymphoma. Polymerase chain reaction study of the skin biopsy revealed monoclonal rearrangement of the T-cell receptor gamma gene. Withdrawal of sodium valproate was followed by regression of the lesion, but 5 months after substitution by carbamazepine, two further papules appeared, with similar histological features and a T-cell clone identical to the initial one. Carbamazepine was stopped and the lesions disappeared without relapse over a 4-year follow-up. Sodium valproate is very rarely responsible for a hypersensitivity syndrome, and our case is the first report of sodium valproate-induced cutaneous pseudolymphoma. The recurrence with carbamazepine may be due to a common effect on T-cell lymphocyte function. The return of the same monoclonal population shows that the recurrence of monoclonal T cells may be observed in benign conditions and is not an exclusive hallmark of cutaneous lymphoma.

Diagnostic value of dominant T-cell clones in peripheral blood in 363 patients presenting consecutively with a clinical suspicion of cutaneous lymphoma

It is now widely accepted that polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of cutaneous T-cell clonality is of diagnostic value in cutaneous T-cell lymphomas (CTCLs) and most helpful in the diagnosis of mycosis fungoides (MF). However, the diagnostic and prognostic value of circulating clonal T cells remains unclear. We studied T-cell clonality in the peripheral blood (PB) and the cutaneous lesion, sampled at the same time, in 363 consecutively seen patients with a clinical suspicion of cutaneous lymphoma. Using a PCR technique providing a specific imprint of T-cell clones (PCRγ–denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis), we found that detection of identical circulating and cutaneous T-cell clones was associated with the diagnosis of CTCL (P &lt; .001). Detection of circulating tumor cells in patients with MF was infrequent (12.5%), except in those with erythrodermic MF (42%; P = .003). Moreover, among the 46 patients who had identical circulating and cutaneous T-cell clones, 25 (56%) had erythroderma. The finding of a dominant clone in the PB but not in the skin was frequent, regardless of the clinicohistologic classification; it occurred in 30% of patients with CTCL, 41% with non-CTCL malignant infiltrates, and 34% with benign infiltrates. This pattern was significantly more frequent in patients over 60 years of age (P &lt; .002), even in the CTCL group (P &lt; .01). In conclusion, dominant T-cell clones detected in the PB of patients with MF by using a routine PCR technique are rarely tumoral and are more often related to age. A multicenter prospective study is under way to establish the prognostic value of circulating tumor cells.

Diagnostic value of dominant T-cell clones in peripheral blood in 363 patients presenting consecutively with a clinical suspicion of cutaneous lymphoma

It is now widely accepted that polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of cutaneous T-cell clonality is of diagnostic value in cutaneous T-cell lymphomas (CTCLs) and most helpful in the diagnosis of mycosis fungoides (MF). However, the diagnostic and prognostic value of circulating clonal T cells remains unclear. We studied T-cell clonality in the peripheral blood (PB) and the cutaneous lesion, sampled at the same time, in 363 consecutively seen patients with a clinical suspicion of cutaneous lymphoma. Using a PCR technique providing a specific imprint of T-cell clones (PCRγ–denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis), we found that detection of identical circulating and cutaneous T-cell clones was associated with the diagnosis of CTCL (P < .001). Detection of circulating tumor cells in patients with MF was infrequent (12.5%), except in those with erythrodermic MF (42%; P = .003). Moreover, among the 46 patients who had identical circulating and cutaneous T-cell clones, 25 (56%) had erythroderma. The finding of a dominant clone in the PB but not in the skin was frequent, regardless of the clinicohistologic classification; it occurred in 30% of patients with CTCL, 41% with non-CTCL malignant infiltrates, and 34% with benign infiltrates. This pattern was significantly more frequent in patients over 60 years of age (P < .002), even in the CTCL group (P < .01). In conclusion, dominant T-cell clones detected in the PB of patients with MF by using a routine PCR technique are rarely tumoral and are more often related to age. A multicenter prospective study is under way to establish the prognostic value of circulating tumor cells.

Cutaneous T cell lymphoma in children

Cutaneous T cell lymphoma (CTCL) is a term used to describe a heterogeneous group of lymphoproliferative disorders that involve the skin. Mycosis fungoides and Sézary syndrome are two forms of CTCL that arise in adults and are uncommon in children. Dermatologists frequently employ the term CTCL as a synonym for mycosis fungoides and Sézary syndrome. There has been increased recognition that the mycosis fungoides and Sézary syndrome forms of CTCL may arise in children and adolescents. Moreover, younger adults with these types of CTCL report onset of symptoms during adolescence. The literature regarding CTCL in childhood is limited. The purpose of this article is the review the literature regarding CTCL arising in children. The clinical presentation including morphologic variants, diagnosis, prognosis, and management are summarized.

Reactive and neoplastic lymphocytes in human bone marrow: morphological, immunohistological, and molecular biological investigations on biopsy specimens

BACKGROUND

Slight, diffuse or focal lymphocyte proliferation is relatively common in bone marrow biopsy specimens. It may be impossible to determine whether this represents a reactive lymphocytosis or low grade non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL) on the basis of routine investigations alone.

AIM

To investigate the supplementary use of molecular biological techniques in this situation.

METHODS

529 formalin fixed, paraffin embedded bone marrow biopsy specimens from the iliac crest were subjected to histological and immunohistochemical staining to determine the number and nature of the lymphocytes present. The cases were divided into three groups according to the lymphocyte count: normal (< 10% of nucleated bone marrow cells), slightly increased (10-30%), and markedly increased (> 30%). All of the last group could be diagnosed as NHL from the morphological findings alone. The clonality of rearrangements of the IgH and TCR gamma genes was investigated by polymerase chain reaction (PCR).

RESULTS

Monoclonality was observed in 7.5% of the 372 cases with a normal lymphocyte count, in 50% of the cases with a modest increase in lymphocyte numbers (suggesting a diagnosis of low grade NHL not detected by immunostaining), and in 77% of the cases with markedly increased lymphocyte numbers.

CONCLUSIONS

If PCR is used in addition to the immunohistochemical investigation of bone marrow biopsies, considerably more cases of NHL can be identified, making this of particular use in staging and detection of recurrences.

Clonal T-cell receptor gamma-chain gene rearrangement by PCR-based GeneScan analysis in advanced cutaneous T-cell lymphoma: a critical evaluation

Detection of clonal T-cell receptor gamma (TCRgamma)-chain gene rearrangement is a promising approach to distinguish between cutaneous T-cell lymphomas (CTCLs) and reactive T-cell infiltrates. Despite the improved sensitivity by using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) rather than Southern blot analysis, monoclonality could be demonstrated in only 53-90 per cent of CTCL biopsies in recent studies. In the present study, formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded specimens of 21 selected patients with clear-cut advanced-stage CTCL were analysed using a semi-nested TCRgamma PCR with newly developed consensus primer pairs. Detection of PCR products was done by GeneScan analysis (GSA); this technique is advantageous due to its sensitivity and accuracy in the detection and size determination of PCR products and it is easier to interpret than direct read-outs from TGGE or DGGE gels. In serial dilution experiments, TCRgamma-PCR-GSA allowed the detection of clonal, rearranged T-cells with a high in vitro sensitivity against a polyclonal background (1-6 per cent). Despite the selection of clear-cut, advanced-stage CTCL cases, however, dominant clonal TCRgamma-chain gene rearrangement was found in only 16 of the 21 patients analysed, indicating an overall clinical sensitivity of 76 per cent. Specificity was evaluated using biopsy specimens from 21 control patients suffering from long-standing psoriasis (n=13) and eczema (n=8). Surprisingly, GeneScan profiles showing apparently single dominant peaks were detected in 14 per cent of these skin lesions, but these profiles turned out to be pseudo-monoclonal by repeated determinations. In conclusion, TCRgamma-PCR-GSA does not suffice reliably to exclude malignancy, due to its limited clinical sensitivity, but with precautions taken to detect pseudo-monoclonality and to secure specificity, TCRgamma-PCR-GSA is a valuable instrument in the diagnosis of CTCL.

Prognostic Significance of a Polymerase Chain Reaction–Detectable Dominant T-Lymphocyte Clone in Cutaneous Lesions of Patients With Mycosis Fungoides

Although mycosis fungoides (MF) is considered to be an indolent lymphoma, survival is highly influenced by TNM stage. At diagnosis, most MF patients present with early stage disease and a high probability of long-term survival. Treatment is generally directed towards skin lesions, and achievement and duration of complete responses are variable. A dominant T-cell clone is detectable in the cutaneous lesions of 60% of patients. The aim of this study was to determine whether the presence of a T-cell clonal population influences the clinical course of the disease after topical therapy. Cutaneous biopsies from 68 patients were histologically diagnosed as MF and T-cell clonality was analyzed by in vitro amplification of TCR-γ chain gene rearrangements (polymerase chain reaction γ [PCRγ]). After a median follow-up of 48 months, response to treatment was clinically assessed. Age, sex, duration of symptoms before diagnosis, type of cutaneous lesions (T stage), TNM stage, and PCRγ were evaluated as predictive factors of response to treatment in univariate and multivariate analyses. Univariate analysis demonstrated that T1 cutaneous lesions (P = .05) and PCRγ negativity (P = .007) were associated with a higher complete remission rate. Using multivariate analysis, T stage (relative risk, 3.13; P = .06) and PCRγ (relative risk, 4.4; P = .01) remained independent significant predictive parameters of response. In conclusion, T stage and cutaneous PCRγ at diagnosis are the two predictive parameters of treatment response for MF. Therefore, the cutaneous PCRγ findings should be considered in the analysis of future therapeutic trials.

© 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.

Prognostic Significance of a Polymerase Chain Reaction–Detectable Dominant T-Lymphocyte Clone in Cutaneous Lesions of Patients With Mycosis Fungoides

Although mycosis fungoides (MF) is considered to be an indolent lymphoma, survival is highly influenced by TNM stage. At diagnosis, most MF patients present with early stage disease and a high probability of long-term survival. Treatment is generally directed towards skin lesions, and achievement and duration of complete responses are variable. A dominant T-cell clone is detectable in the cutaneous lesions of 60% of patients. The aim of this study was to determine whether the presence of a T-cell clonal population influences the clinical course of the disease after topical therapy. Cutaneous biopsies from 68 patients were histologically diagnosed as MF and T-cell clonality was analyzed by in vitro amplification of TCR-γ chain gene rearrangements (polymerase chain reaction γ [PCRγ]). After a median follow-up of 48 months, response to treatment was clinically assessed. Age, sex, duration of symptoms before diagnosis, type of cutaneous lesions (T stage), TNM stage, and PCRγ were evaluated as predictive factors of response to treatment in univariate and multivariate analyses. Univariate analysis demonstrated that T1 cutaneous lesions (P = .05) and PCRγ negativity (P = .007) were associated with a higher complete remission rate. Using multivariate analysis, T stage (relative risk, 3.13; P = .06) and PCRγ (relative risk, 4.4; P = .01) remained independent significant predictive parameters of response. In conclusion, T stage and cutaneous PCRγ at diagnosis are the two predictive parameters of treatment response for MF. Therefore, the cutaneous PCRγ findings should be considered in the analysis of future therapeutic trials.

© 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.