From Concept to Crystals via Prediction: Multi‐Component Organic Cage Pots by Social Self‐Sorting

Computational modeling to assist in the discovery of supramolecular materials

Computational modeling is increasingly used to assist in the discovery of supramolecular materials. Supramolecular materials are typically primarily built from organic components that are self-assembled through noncovalent bonding and have potential applications, including in selective binding, sorption, molecular separations, catalysis, optoelectronics, sensing, and as molecular machines. In this review, the key areas where computational prediction can assist in the discovery of supramolecular materials, including in structure prediction, property prediction, and the prediction of how to synthesize a hypothetical material are discussed, before exploring the potential impact of artificial intelligence techniques on the field. Throughout, the importance of close integration with experimental materials discovery programs will be highlighted. A series of case studies from the author's work across some different supramolecular material classes will be discussed, before finishing with a discussion of the outlook for the field.

High-Throughput Computational Evaluation of Low Symmetry Pd2 L4 Cages to Aid in System Design*

Unsymmetrical ditopic ligands can self-assemble into reduced-symmetry Pd2 L4 metallo-cages with anisotropic cavities, with implications for high specificity and affinity guest-binding. Mixtures of cage isomers can form, however, resulting in undesirable system heterogeneity. It is paramount to be able to design components that preferentially form a single isomer. Previous data suggested that computational methods could predict with reasonable accuracy whether unsymmetrical ligands would preferentially self-assemble into single cage isomers under constraints of geometrical mismatch. We successfully apply a collaborative computational and experimental workflow to mitigate costly trial-and-error synthetic approaches. Our rapid computational workflow constructs unsymmetrical ligands and their Pd2 L4 cage isomers, ranking the likelihood for exclusively forming cis-Pd2 L4 assemblies. From this narrowed search space, we successfully synthesised four new, low-symmetry, cis-Pd2 L4 cages.

Isoreticular Crystallization of Highly Porous Cubic Covalent Organic Cage Compounds*

Modular frameworks featuring well-defined pore structures in microscale domains establish tailor-made porous materials. For open molecular solids however, maintaining long-range order after desolvation is inherently challenging, since packing is usually governed by only a few supramolecular interactions. Here we report on two series of nanocubes obtained by co-condensation of two different hexahydroxy tribenzotriquinacenes (TBTQs) and benzene-1,4-diboronic acids (BDBAs) with varying linear alkyl chains in 2,5-position. n-Butyl groups at the apical position of the TBTQ vertices yielded soluble model compounds, which were analyzed by mass spectrometry and NMR spectroscopy. In contrast, methyl-substituted cages spontaneously crystallized as isostructural and highly porous solids with BET surface areas and pore volumes of up to 3426 m2  g-1 and 1.84 cm3  g-1 . Single crystal X-ray diffraction and sorption measurements revealed an intricate cubic arrangement of alternating micro- and mesopores in the range of 0.97-2.2 nm that are fine-tuned by the alkyl substituents at the BDBA linker.

Soluble Congeners of Prior Insoluble Shape-Persistent Imine Cages

One of the most applied reaction types to synthesize shape‐persistent organic cage compounds is the imine condensation reaction and it is assumed that the formed cages are thermodynamically controlled products due to the reversibility of the imine condensation. However, most of the synthesized imine cages reported are formed as precipitate from the reaction mixture and therefore rather may be kinetically controlled products. There are even examples in literature, where resulting cages are not soluble at all in common organic solvents to characterize or study their formation by NMR spectroscopy in solution. Here, a triptycene triamine containing three solubilizing n‐hexyloxy chains has been used to synthesize soluble congeners of prior insoluble cages. This allowed us to study the formation as well as the reversibility of cage formation in solution by investigating exchange of building blocks between the cages and deuterated derivatives thereof.

Chiral Self-sorting of Giant Cubic [8+12] Salicylimine Cage Compounds

Chiral self-sorting is intricately connected to the complicated chiral processes observed in nature and no artificial systems of comparably complexity have been generated by chemists. However, only a few examples of purely organic molecules have been reported so far, where the self-sorting process could be controlled. Herein, we describe the chiral self-sorting of large cubic [8+12] salicylimine cage compounds based on a chiral TBTQ precursor. Out of 23 possible cage isomers only the enantiopure and a meso cage were observed to be formed, which have been unambiguously characterized by single crystal X-ray diffraction. Furthermore, by careful choice of solvent the formation of meso cage could be controlled. With internal diameters of din =3.3-3.5 nm these cages are among the largest organic cage compounds characterized and show very high specific surface areas up to approx. 1500 m2  g-1 after desolvation.

Endohedral Hydrogen Bonding Templates the Formation of a Highly Strained Covalent Organic Cage Compound*

A highly strained covalent organic cage compound was synthesized from hexahydroxy tribenzotriquinacene (TBTQ) and a meta-terphenyl-based diboronic acid with an additional benzoic acid substituent in 2'-position. Usually, a 120° bite angle in the unsubstituted ditopic linker favors the formation of a [4+6] cage assembly. Here, the introduction of the benzoic acid group is shown to lead to a perfectly preorganized circular hydrogen-bonding array in the cavity of a trigonal-bipyramidal [2+3] cage, which energetically overcompensates the additional strain energy caused by the larger mismatch in bite angles for the smaller assembly. The strained cage compound was analyzed by mass spectrometry and 1 H, 13 C and DOSY NMR spectroscopy. DFT calculations revealed the energetic contribution of the hydrogen-bonding template to the cage stability. Furthermore, molecular dynamics simulations on early intermediates indicate an additional kinetic effect, as hydrogen bonding also preorganizes and rigidifies small oligomers to facilitate the exclusive formation of smaller and more strained macrocycles and cages.

Gas Storage in Porous Molecular Materials

Molecules with permanent porosity in the solid state have been studied for decades. Porosity in these systems is governed by intrinsic pore space, as in cages or macrocycles, and extrinsic void space, created through loose, intermolecular solid-state packing. The development of permanently porous molecular materials, especially cages with organic or metal-organic composition, has seen increased interest over the past decade, and as such, incredibly high surface areas have been reported for these solids. Despite this, examples of these materials being explored for gas storage applications are relatively limited. This minireview outlines existing molecular systems that have been investigated for gas storage and highlights strategies that have been used to understand adsorption mechanisms in porous molecular materials.

Inducing Social Self-Sorting in Organic Cages To Tune The Shape of The Internal Cavity

Many interesting target guest molecules have low symmetry, yet most methods for synthesising hosts result in highly symmetrical capsules. Methods of generating lower symmetry pores are thus required to maximise the binding affinity in host-guest complexes. Herein, we use mixtures of tetraaldehyde building blocks with cyclohexanediamine to access low-symmetry imine cages. Whether a low-energy cage is isolated can be correctly predicted from the thermodynamic preference observed in computational models. The stability of the observed structures depends on the geometrical match of the aldehyde building blocks. One bent aldehyde stands out as unable to assemble into high-symmetry cages-and the same aldehyde generates low-symmetry socially self-sorted cages when combined with a linear aldehyde. We exploit this finding to synthesise a family of low-symmetry cages containing heteroatoms, illustrating that pores of varying geometries and surface chemistries may be reliably accessed through computational prediction and self-sorting.

Cavitand-Based Pd-Pyridyl Coordination Capsules: Guest-Induced Homo- or Heterocapsule Selection and Applications of Homocapsules to the Protection of a Photosensitive Guest and Chiral Capsule Formation

A 2 : 4 mixture of tetrakis[4-(4-pyridyl)phenyl]cavitand (1) or tetrakis[4-(4-pyridyl)phenylethynyl]cavitand (2) and Pd(dppp)(OTf)₂ self-assembles into a homocapsule {1₂  ⋅ [Pd(dppp)]₄ }⁸⁺  ⋅ (TfO^- )₈ (C1) or {2₂  ⋅ [Pd(dppp)]₄ }⁸⁺  ⋅ (TfO^- )₈ (C2), respectively, through Pd-Npy coordination bonds. A 1 : 1 : 4 mixture of 1, 2, and Pd(dppp)(OTf)₂ produced a mixture of homocapsules C1, C2, and a heterocapsule {1 ⋅ 2 ⋅ [Pd(dppp)]₄ }⁸⁺  ⋅ (TfO^- )₈ (C3) in a 1 : 1 : 0.98 mole ratio. Selective formation (self-sorting) of homocapsules C1 and C2 or heterocapsule C3 was controlled by guest-induced encapsulation under thermodynamic control. Applications of Pd-Npy coordination capsules with the use of 1 were demonstrated. Capsule C1 serves as a guard nanocontainer for trans-4,4'-diacetoxyazobenzene to protect against the trans-to-cis photoisomerization by encapsulation. A chiral capsule {1₂  ⋅ [Pd((R)-BINAP)]₄ }⁸⁺  ⋅ (TfO^- )₈ (C5) was also constructed. Capsule C5 induces supramolecular chirality with respect to prochiral 2,2'-bis(alkoxycarbonyl)-4,4'-bis(1-propynyl)biphenyls by diastereomeric encapsulation through the asymmetric suppression of rotation around the axis of the prochiral biphenyl moiety.

Alkane Shape- and Size-Recognized Selective Vapor Sorption in "Channel-Like" Crystals Based on Thiacalixarene Assemblies

Alkanes composed of C-C and C-H show a low electric polarization, and therefore, there is only very weak interaction between alkanes and adsorbents. Thus, it is difficult to separate a specific alkane from a mixture of alkanes by adsorption. Here, two activated "channel-like" crystals generated from brominated thiacalix[4]arene propyl ethers, which adopt 1,3-alternate and partial cone conformations, recognize specific alkane vapors depending on alkane-shape and -size, sorting in three-type alkane guests such as linear, branched, and cyclic alkanes. Two activated crystals, which are prepared by removal of solvent upon heating under reduced pressure, incorporate branched and/or cyclic alkane vapors by a unique "gate-opening" mechanism via a crystal transformation in the process. Linear alkane vapors do not trigger gate opening and are not taken up by the activated crystals. The shape and size molecular-recognition properties of the activated crystals promises considerable usefulness for the separation of linear, branched, and cyclic alkanes.

Adaptive Covalent Networks Enabled by Dual Reactivity: The Evolution of Reversible Covalent Bonds, Their Molecular Assemblies, and Guest Recognition

Adaptive chemistry allows transformation and selection within molecular networks, and adaptive systems composed of different types of dynamic covalent reactions (DCRs) are challenging. Herein, we demonstrate dual reactivity-based covalent networks encompassing the regulation of and switching between C-N- and C-S-based reversible covalent assemblies. The creation and exchange of C-N- or C-S-derived assemblies exhibiting diverse architectures, including linear structures, macrocycles, and cages, were achieved. The shift of reactivity then permitted the interconversion between C-N- and C-S-containing assemblies. Moreover, the adaption of intramolecular and intermolecular scaffolds was feasible via linker design. The latent hemiaminal chirality center offered a pathway for the induction of chirality within assemblies. Finally, switchable structural change and controlled extraction of ions were realized with Hg²⁺ as a guest for macrocycles. The remarkable complexity of networks described herein could open the door for the utility in sophisticated functional systems.

Organic Cage Dumbbells

Molecular dumbbells with organic cage capping units were synthesised via a multi-component imine condensation between a tri-topic amine and di- and tetra-topic aldehydes. This is an example of self-sorting, which can be rationalised by computational modelling.