In vitro development of B cells and macrophages from early mouse fetal thymocytes

Key Factors for Thymic Function and Development

The thymus is the organ responsible for T cell development and the formation of the adaptive immunity function. Its multicellular environment consists mainly of the different stromal cells and maturing T lymphocytes. Thymus-specific progenitors of epithelial, mesenchymal, and lymphoid cells with stem cell properties represent only minor populations. The thymic stromal structure predominantly determines the function of the thymus. The stromal components, mostly epithelial and mesenchymal cells, form this specialized area. They support the consistent developmental program of functionally distinct conventional T cell subpopulations. These include the MHC restricted single positive CD4+ CD8- and CD4- CD8+ cells, regulatory T lymphocytes (Foxp3+), innate natural killer T cells (iNKT), and γδT cells. Several physiological causes comprising stress and aging and medical treatments such as thymectomy and chemo/radiotherapy can harm the thymus function. The present review summarizes our knowledge of the development and function of the thymus with a focus on thymic epithelial cells as well as other stromal components and the signaling and transcriptional pathways underlying the thymic cell interaction. These critical thymus components are significant for T cell differentiation and restoring the thymic function after damage to reach the therapeutic benefits.

Initial seeding of the embryonic thymus by immune-restricted lympho-myeloid progenitors

The final stages of restriction to the T cell lineage occur in the thymus after the entry of thymus-seeding progenitors (TSPs). The identity and lineage potential of TSPs remains unclear. Because the first embryonic TSPs enter a non-vascularized thymic rudiment, we were able to directly image and establish the functional and molecular properties of embryonic thymopoiesis-initiating progenitors (T-IPs) before their entry into the thymus and activation of Notch signaling. T-IPs did not include multipotent stem cells or molecular evidence of T cell-restricted progenitors. Instead, single-cell molecular and functional analysis demonstrated that most fetal T-IPs expressed genes of and had the potential to develop into lymphoid as well as myeloid components of the immune system. Moreover, studies of embryos deficient in the transcriptional regulator RBPJ demonstrated that canonical Notch signaling was not involved in pre-thymic restriction to the T cell lineage or the migration of T-IPs.

B-cell development: one problem, multiple solutions

Interspecies variations in the processes of B-cell development and repertoire generation contrast with the greater consistency of T-cell development. B-cell development in mice and humans, with postnatal B-cell generation of new repertoire in the bone marrow throughout life, is regarded as the 'standard' pattern. In contrast, accounts of B cells in birds, sheep, cattle, rabbits and pigs (the 'other' species) describe cessation of gene diversification in the perinatal period, with the gut-associated lymphoid tissue (GALT) functioning as the primary lymphoid organ thereafter. It has become customary to regard the developmental pathways of T and B cells within any individual species as being as dissimilar as the functions of the two mature cell types. Reinterpretation of B-cell development patterns in different species is overdue in response to two types of reports. The first of these describe T-B 'crossover', specifically the intrathymic production of B cells and the extrathymic production of T cells. The second attests to the extent of sharing of B-cell developmental features across the two groups of species. We propose that, as is a feature of other haematopoietic cells, a menu of alternative B- and T-cell pathways has been retained and shared across species. A single pathway usually predominates in any species, masking alternatives. The observed predominance of any pathway is determined by factors such as placental permeability, extent of maturation of the immune system by birth and the feasibility of direct experimental intervention in development.

The B lineage potential of thymus settling progenitors is critically dependent on mouse age

The nature and lineage potential, particularly that for B cells, of thymus settling progenitors (TSP) in the adult mouse has been the subject of considerable debate. Lack of B cell potential would suggest pre-thymic, whereas its presence would suggest intra-thymic loss of B cell potential. Using limiting dilution analysis (LDA) in vitro and transfer experiments in vivo, we show that the B cell potential of TSP is critically dependent on mouse age, reaching a maximum of about 1 in 20 cells at birth, decreasing 50-fold in adult mice. Cells with a TSP phenotype can be found in the neonatal blood. Furthermore, using LDA, we show that Notch ligand signaling of TSP results in the loss of B cell potential with a half-life of approximately 12 h. Taken together, these results indicate that loss of B cell potential by TSP is an intra-thymic event and highlight the developmental pressure acting on the immune system to rapidly colonize primary lymphoid organs with functional progenitors. This critical time coincides with birth in the mouse. In the adult mouse, we estimate than only about 5 TSP cells/day would be required to maintain steady-state thymopoiesis.

Regulation of intrathymic T-cell development by Lunatic Fringe- Notch1 interactions

Intrathymic Notch1 signaling critically regulates T-lineage specification and commitment as well as T-cell progenitor survival and differentiation. Notch1 activation is continuously required during progression of early CD4/CD8-double-negative thymocytes to the CD4/CD8-double-positive stage. This developmental transition occurs as thymocytes migrate from the corticomedullary junction (CMJ) to the outer subcapsular zone (SCZ) of the thymus. Members of two families of structurally distinct Notch ligands, Delta-like 1 and Jagged-1, are expressed by cortical thymic epithelial cells, but it is not known which ligands are functionally required within the CMJ and SCZ microenvironmental niches. Our laboratory has investigated this question by genetically manipulating thymocyte expression of Lunatic Fringe (L-Fng), a glycosyltransferase that enhances sensitivity of Notch receptors to Delta-like ligands. This approach has revealed that low-threshold intrathymic Notch1 signals instruct multipotent thymus-seeding progenitors to suppress their B-cell potential and choose the T-cell fate. This strategy has also revealed that Delta-like Notch ligands are functionally limiting in both the CMJ and SCZ microenvironmental niches. Finally, we discuss our recent demonstration that L-Fng-mediated competition for Delta-like ligands is an important mechanism for regulating thymus size.

Tracing the first waves of lymphopoiesis in mice

RAG1/GFP knock-in mice were used to precisely chart the emergence and expansion of cells that give rise to the immune system. Lymphopoietic cells detectable in stromal co-cultures arose as early as E8.5, i.e. prior to establishment of the circulation within the paraaortic splanchnopleura (P-Sp). These cells were Tie2+ RAG1- CD34Lo/-Kit+ CD41-. While yolk sac (YS) also contained lymphopoietic cells after E9.5, CD41+ YS cells from ⩽25-somite embryos produced myelo-erythroid cells but no lymphocytes. Notch receptor signaling directed P-Sp cells to T lymphocytes but did not confer lymphopoietic potential on YS cells. Thus, definitive hematopoiesis arises in at least two independent sites that differ in lymphopoietic potential. Expression of RAG1, the earliest known lymphoid event, first occurred around E10.5 within the embryos. RAG1/GFP+ cells appeared in the liver at E11.0 and progenitors with B and/or T lineage potential were enumerated at subsequent developmental stages.

Cellular and molecular events during early thymus development

The thymic stromal compartment consists of several cell types that collectively enable the attraction, survival, expansion, migration, and differentiation of T-cell precursors. The thymic epithelial cells constitute the most abundant cell type of the thymic microenvironment and can be differentiated into morphologically, phenotypically, and functionally separate subpopulations of the postnatal thymus. All thymic epithelial cells are derived from the endodermal lining of the third pharyngeal pouch. Very soon after the formation of a thymus primordium and prior to its vascularization, thymic epithelial cells orchestrate the first steps of intrathymic T-cell development, including the attraction of lymphoid precursor cells to the thymic microenvironment. The correct segmentation of pharyngeal epithelial cells and their subsequent crosstalk with cells in the pharyngeal arches are critical prerequisites for the formation of a thymus anlage. Mutations in several transcription factors and their target genes have been informative to detail some of the complex mechanisms that control the development of the thymus anlage. This review highlights recent findings related to the genetic control of early thymus organogenesis and provides insight into the molecular basis by which lymphocyte precursors are attracted to the thymus.

Prethymic T-cell development defined by the expression of paired immunoglobulin-like receptors

T cells are produced in the thymus from progenitors of extrathymic origin. As no specific markers are available, the developmental pathway of progenitors preceding thymic colonization remains unclear. Here we show that progenitors in murine fetal liver and blood, which are capable of giving rise to T cells, NK cells and dendritic cells, but not B cells, can be isolated by their surface expression of paired immunoglobulin-like receptors (PIR). PIR expression is maintained until the earliest intrathymic stage, then downregulated before the onset of CD25 expression. Unlike intrathymic progenitors, generation of prethymic PIR(+) progenitors does not require Hes1-mediated Notch signaling. These findings disclose a prethymic stage of T-cell development programmed for immigration of the thymus, which is genetically separable from intrathymic stages.

Thymic Anlage Is Colonized by Progenitors Restricted to T, NK, and Dendritic Cell Lineages

It remains controversial whether the thymus-colonizing progenitors are committed to the T cell lineage. A major problem that has impeded the characterization of thymic immigrants has been that the earliest intrathymic progenitors thus far identified do not necessarily represent the genuine thymic immigrants, because their developmental potential should have been influenced by contact with the thymic microenvironment. In the present study, we examined the developmental potential of the ontogenically earliest thymic progenitors of day 11 murine fetus. These cells reside in the surrounding mesenchymal region and have not encountered thymic epithelial components. Flow cytometric and immunohistochemical analyses demonstrated that these cells are exclusively Lin(-)c-kit(+)IL-7R(+). Limiting dilution analyses disclosed that the progenitors with T cell potential were abundant, while those with B cell potential were virtually absent in the region of day 11 thymic anlage. Clonal analyses reveled that they are restricted to T, NK, and dendritic cell lineages. Each progenitor was capable of forming a large number of precursors that may clonally accommodate highly diverse TCRbeta chains. These results provide direct evidence that the progenitors restricted to the T/NK/dendritic cell lineage selectively immigrate into the thymus.

Development of CD4+Macrophages from Intrathymic T Cell Progenitors Is Induced by Thymic Epithelial Cells

It was recently demonstrated that there are CD4(+) macrophages, which exhibit strong phagocytic activity, in the thymus. They are suggested to play an important role for the elimination of apoptotic thymocytes. However, the origin and nature of CD4(+) macrophages in the thymus remain unexplored. In this study, we describe that the most immature intrathymic progenitors (CD25(-)/CD44(+)/FcR(+)) give rise to CD4(+) macrophages by oncostatin M-responsive thymic epithelial cells (ORTEC) in an IL-7-dependent manner. Neither conditioned medium of ORTEC nor a mixture of cytokines induced CD4(+) macrophages, and oncostatin M receptor was not expressed in thymocytes, suggesting that the development of CD4(+) macrophages from the immature thymocytes requires a direct interaction with ORTEC. These results collectively suggest that the development of CD4(+) macrophages from the intrathymic T cell progenitors is induced by thymic epithelial cells.

T/NK Bipotent Progenitors in the Thymus Retain the Potential to Generate Dendritic Cells

We have previously shown that the earliest thymic progenitors retain the potential to generate T and NK cells and that they lose the bipotentiality to give rise to unipotent T and NK progenitors during the progression of intrathymic developmental stages. The present study examines the ability of these thymic progenitors for generation of dendritic cells (DC) with a new clonal assay that is capable of determining the developmental potential for DC in addition to T cells and NK cells. We found that the large majority of the T/NK bipotential progenitors in the earliest population of fetal thymus was able to generate DC. Although the DC potential is lost with the progression of the differentiation stage, some of the T/NK bipotential progenitors still retain their DC potential even at the CD44(+)CD25(+) stage.

Cutting Edge: A possible role for CD4+ thymic macrophages as professional scavengers of apoptotic thymocytes

A vast majority of thymocytes are eliminated during T cell development by apoptosis. However, apoptotic thymocytes are not usually found in the thymus, indicating that apoptotic thymocytes must be eliminated rapidly by scavengers. Although macrophages and dendritic cells are believed to play such role, little is known about scavengers in the thymus. We found that CD4(+)/CD11b(+)/CD11c(-) cells were present in the thymus and that they expressed costimulatory molecules for T cell selection and possessed Ag-presenting activity. Moreover, these CD4(+)/CD11b(+) cells phagocytosed apoptotic thymocytes much more efficiently than thymic CD4(-)/CD11b(+) cells as well as activated peritoneal macrophages. CD4(+)/CD11b(+) cells became larger along with thymus development, while no such change was observed in CD4(-)/CD11b(+) cells. Finally, engulfed nuclei were frequently found in CD4(+)/CD11b(+) cells. These results strongly suggest that thymic CD4(+)/CD11b(+) cells are major scavengers of apoptotic thymocytes.

Bcl11a is essential for normal lymphoid development

Bcl11a (also called Evi9) functions as a myeloid or B cell proto-oncogene in mice and humans, respectively. Here we show that Bcl11a is essential for postnatal development and normal lymphopoiesis. Bcl11a mutant embryos lack B cells and have alterations in several types of T cells. Phenotypic and expression studies show that Bcl11a functions upstream of the transcription factors Ebf1 and Pax5 in the B cell pathway. Transplantation studies show that these defects in Bcl11a mutant mice are intrinsic to fetal liver precursor cells. Mice transplanted with Bcl11a-deficient cells died from T cell leukemia derived from the host. Thus, Bcl11a may also function as a non-autonomous T cell tumor suppressor gene.

B-cell development in the thymus is limited by inhibitory signals from the thymic microenvironment

B-cell precursors are present in the thymus, and the thymic microenvironment is the source of lymphopoietic factors that include interleukin-7 (IL-7). Despite the fact that intrathymic B-cell progenitors are bone marrow-derived cells, the data in this report demonstrate that these progenitors accumulate at an early pro-B-cell stage of development, cycle less than their bone marrow counterparts, and fail to differentiate efficiently. Additional studies presented herein indicate that these effects are mediated, at least in part, by soluble factors produced by the thymic microenvironment and suggest that they affect the ability of pro-B cells to respond optimally to IL-7. Taken together, these observations demonstrate a specific inhibition of intrathymic B lymphopoiesis, which in turn may explain why lymphoid cell production in the thymus is largely restricted to production of T-lineage cells despite the fact that B-cell precursors and B-lymphopoietic stimuli are present in that organ.

Inducible gene knockout of transcription factor recombination signal binding protein-J reveals its essential role in T versus B lineage decision

The transcription factor recombination signal binding protein-J (RBP-J) functions immediately downstream of the cell surface receptor Notch and mediates transcriptional activation by the intracellular domain of all four kinds of Notch receptors. To investigate the function of RBP-J, we introduced loxP sites on both sides of the RBP-J exons encoding its DNA binding domain. Mice bearing the loxP-flanked RBP-J alleles, RBP-J(f/f), were mated with Mx-Cre transgenic mice and deletional mutation of the RBP-J gene in adult mice was induced by injection of the IFN-alpha inducer poly(I)-poly(C). Here we show that inactivation of RBP-J in bone marrow resulted in a block of T cell development at the earliest stage and increase of B cell development in the thymus. Lymphoid progenitors deficient in RBP-J differentiate into B but not T cells when cultured in 2'-deoxyguanosine-treated fetal thymic lobes by hanging-drop fetal thymus organ culture. Competitive repopulation assay also revealed cell autonomous deficiency of T cell development from bone marrow of RBP-J knockout mouse. Myeloid and B lineage differentiation appears normal in the bone marrow of RBP-J-inactivated mice. These results suggest that RBP-J, probably by mediating Notch signaling, controls T versus B cell fate decision in lymphoid progenitors.

The ontogeny of B cells in the thymus of normal, CD3 epsilon knockout (KO), RAG-2 KO and IL-7 transgenic mice

The ontogeny of thymic B cells was determined by three-color flow cytometry and the presence or absence of B cell progenitors confirmed by cell culture experiments. In the thymus of young normal mice, CD117(+), B220(low) pro- and pre-B cells are present but disappear with age. B220(low), CD5(+), B-1 B cells are present in the thymus of older animals following the appearance of similar cells in the peritoneal cavity and blood. In CD3 epsilon gene-deleted mice, the phenotypic progression and number of thymic B cells remains unaltered, showing that blocking T cell development does not automatically result in an increase of thymic B lymphopoiesis. Pro-B cells in RAG-2 knockout mice are found in the fetal and neonatal blood, spleen and thymus, but with increasing age are only found in the bone marrow. B lymphopoiesis in adult IL-7 transgenic mice is dramatically altered with CD117(+) pro- and pre-B cells present in spleen, lymph node and blood. In the thymus of adult IL-7 transgenic mice, the fraction of CD117(+) thymic B cells is significantly increased. These results show that in the steady state, the phenotype of thymic B cells is critically dependent on both mouse age and the phenotype of circulating B cells.

The human embryo, but not its yolk sac, generates lympho-myeloid stem cells: mapping multipotent hematopoietic cell fate in intraembryonic mesoderm

We have traced emerging hematopoietic cells along human early ontogeny by culturing embryonic tissue rudiments in the presence of stromal cells that promote myeloid and B cell differentiation, and by assaying T cell potential in the NOD-SCID mouse thymus. Hematogenous potential was present inside the embryo as early as day 19 of development in the absence of detectable CD34+ hematopoietic cells, and spanned both lymphoid and myeloid lineages from day 24 in the splanchnopleural mesoderm and derived aorta where CD34+ progenitors appear at day 27. By contrast, hematopoietic cells arising in the third week yolk sac, as well as their progeny at later stages, were restricted to myelopoiesis and therefore are unlikely to contribute to definitive hematopoiesis in man.

Subversion of the T/B lineage decision in the thymus by lunatic fringe-mediated inhibition of Notch-1

Notch-1 signaling is essential for lymphoid progenitors to undergo T cell commitment, but the mechanism has not been defined. Here we show that thymocytes ectopically expressing Lunatic Fringe, a modifier of Notch-1 signaling, induce lymphoid progenitors to develop into B cells in the thymus. This cell fate switch resulted from Lunatic Fringe-mediated inhibition of Notch-1 function, as revealed by experiments utilizing lymphoid progenitors in which Notch-1 activity was genetically manipulated. These data identify Lunatic Fringe as a potent regulator of Notch-1 during the T/B lineage decision and show that an important function of Notch-1 in T cell commitment is to suppress B cell development in the thymus.

Generation of macrophages from early T progenitors in vitro

Early T progenitors in the thymus have been reported to have the capacity to develop into B cells, thymic dendritic cells, and NK cells. Here we describe conditions that induce early T progenitors to develop into macrophages. Initially, we observed that early T progenitors could be induced to develop into macrophages by cytokines produced from a thymic stromal cell line, TFGD, and later we found that the cytokine mixture of M-CSF plus IL-6 plus IL-7 also induced macrophage differentiation from pro-T cells. M-CSF by itself was unable to induce macrophage differentiation from early T progenitors. To correlate this observation with the developmental potential of early T progenitors, mouse embryonic thymocytes were sorted into four populations, pro-T1 to pro-T4, based on the expression of CD44 and CD25, and then cultured with TFGD culture supernatant. We found that pro-T1 and pro-T2 cells, but not pro-T3 and pro-T4 cells, generate macrophages. Limiting dilution analysis of the differentiation capability of sorted pro-T2 cells also confirmed that pro-T2 cells could generate macrophages. These results suggest that T cells and thymic macrophages could originate from a common intrathymic precursor.

Murine dendritic cells derived from myeloid progenitors of the thymus are unable to produce bioactive IL-12p70

Dendritic cells (DC) are present at low density in the thymus where they mediate negative selection of self-reactive thymocytes. Previous reports suggest that thymic DC (TDC) are a single population of lymphoid-related DC. In this study, we documented the presence in the adult mouse thymus of an additional population of TDC exhibiting a myeloid phenotype (CD11c(+) CD8alpha(-) CD11b(+)). This population, which can be purified, represented approximately 20% of the total TDC and differs from the population of lymphoid TDC (CD11c(+) CD8(+) CD11b(-)) by its incapacity to produce IL-12p70 under double stimulation by LPS and anti-CD40. Furthermore, using an original culture system allowing expansion of DC from myeloid progenitors, we demonstrated that DC exhibiting a similar myeloid phenotype can be derived from a common DC/macrophage progenitor resident in the adult mouse thymus. We found that, in contrast with myeloid splenic DC expanded in the same conditions, these cultured TDC were unable to produce IL-12p70 under double stimulation by LPS and anti-CD40 or LPS and IFN-gamma. Thus, our results suggest that 1) adult mouse thymus contains at least two phenotypically and functionally distinct populations of DC; and 2) cultured myeloid DC derived from thymus and spleen differ by their ability to produce IL-12p70. The mechanisms underlying the differences in IL-12-secreting capacities of the cultured splenic and thymic DC are under current investigation.

Chemokines define distinct microenvironments in the developing thymus

During thymus development, prothymocytes home to the thymus where they migrate as maturing thymocytes from the cortex to the medulla. Chemotaxis assays show that developing T cells of newborn mice respond to certain chemokines depending on their differentiation state. In situ expression analyses indicate that the same chemokines are expressed in distinct microenvironments within the thymic stroma. Expression of chemokines is regulated temporally during embryogenesis; in the alymphoid early thymic anlage, only TECK, SDF-1 and SLC but not ELC, MDC or TARC are expressed. Fetal blood prothymocytes destined to colonize the thymus respond to the embryonic chemokines TECK and SDF-1 in chemotaxis assays with high efficacy. The in vivo significance of this finding is demonstrated by studies in the nude mouse where the thymic anlage lacks TECK and SDF-1 expression and prothymocytes home to the parathyroid anlage rather than to the thymic anlage. Developing thymocytes respond to chemokines expressed in distinct microenvironments within the thymic stroma in a way that correlates well with the previously observed migration pattern from cortex to medulla. The complexity of these chemokine-defined microenvironments increases as the thymic anlage develops to a mature thymus.

A mouse thymic stromal cell line producing macrophage-colony stimulating factor and interleukin-6

A thymic stromal cell line, TFGD, was established from a thymic tumor mass developed spontaneously in p53 knock out mouse, and was found to produce cytokines that could induce bone marrow hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) to differentiate into macrophages. The cytokines produced by the TFGD line were assessed by immunoassays. High level of macrophage-colony stimulating factor (M-CSF) and interleukin (IL)-6 was detected in the TFGD-culture supernatant, whereas granulocyte/macrophage-colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF), IL-3, IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, or interferon (IFN)-gamma was undetectable. Blocking experiments showed that anti-M-CSF monoclonal antibody could neutralize the differentiation-inducing activity shown by the TFGD-culture supernatant. Dot blot analysis of the total RNA isolated from the cultured fetal thymic stromal cells showed that M-CSF transcripts were expressed in the normal thymus. These observations, together with the earlier finding that M-CSF plus IL-6 is the optimal combination of cytokines for the induction of macrophage differentiation from HSCs in vitro, may indicate that thymic macrophages could be generated within the thymus by cytokines involving M-CSF.

B lymphopoiesis in the thymus

The thymus has been regarded as the major site of T cell differentiation. We find that in addition to alphabeta and gammadelta T cells, a significant number (approximately 3 x 104 per day) of B220+IgM+ mature B cells are exported from the thymus of C57BL/6 mice. Of these emigrating B cells, we estimate that at least approximately 2 x 104 per day are cells which developed intrathymically, whereas a maximum of approximately 0.8 x 104 per day are cells which circulated through the thymus from the periphery. The thymus possesses a significant number of pro-B and pre-B cells that express CD19, VpreB, lambda5, and pax-5. These B cell progenitors were found in the thymic cortex, whereas increasingly mature B cells were found in the corticomedullar and medullary regions. Other lymphoid cells, including NK cells and lymphoid dendritic cells, are not exported from the thymus at detectable levels. Thus, the thymus contributes to the formation of peripheral pools of B cells as well as of alphabeta and gammadelta T cells.

Differentiation from thymic B cell progenitors to mature B cells in vitro

The role of the thymic microenvironment in the development of murine thymic B cells has yet to be fully clarified. We therefore investigate the microenvironment that supports the development of mature thymic B cells (sIg+/B220+/CD43-B cells) from thymic B cell progenitors with immunophenotypes of sIg-/B220med/CD43+ cells. As we have previously reported, thymic B cells generated from these progenitors in the thymus are CD5+ B cells. We next study the in vitro condition that supports the differentiation of thymic B cell progenitors. Stromal cells (from the bone marrow or thymus), thymus-derived cell lines with the character of thymic nurse cells (TNCs) or thymic epithelial cells (TECs), or the bone marrow-derived cell line (MS-5) are tested for their ability to support B-lymphopoiesis from thymic B cell progenitors. Interestingly, thymic stromal cells (but neither stromal cells from the bone marrow nor stromal cell lines) support the differentiation of thymic B cell progenitors into thymic B cells in the presence of IL-7. Cortical epithelia (but not medullary epithelia, thymic macrophages or dendritic cells) are found to contribute to thymic B cell differentiation. Surface phenotype and Ig rearrangement analyses reveal that mature B cells generated in this condition are primarily CD5+ B cells, indicating that the thymic microenvironment (particularly cortical epithelia) determines the differentiation of thymic B cells.

Clonal characterization of a bipotent T cell and NK cell progenitor in the mouse fetal thymus

We recently described a population of fetal thymocytes with a CD117+NK1.1+CD90lowCD25- phenotype, which were shown to contain committed T cell and NK cell progenitors. However, the characterization of a single cell with a restricted T and NK cell precursor potential was lacking. Here, using an in vitro model for T and NK cell differentiation, we provide conclusive evidence demonstrating the existence of a clonal lineage-restricted T and NK cell progenitor. These results establish that fetal thymocytes with a CD117+NK1.1+CD90lowCD25- phenotype represent bipotent T and NK cell progenitors.

Commitment of common T/Natural killer (NK) progenitors to unipotent T and NK progenitors in the murine fetal thymus revealed by a single progenitor assay

We have established a new clonal assay system that can evenly support the development of T and natural killer (NK) cells. With this system, we show that all T cell progenitors in the earliest CD44(+)CD25(-)FcgammaRII/III(-) fetal thymus (FT) cell population retain NK potential, and that the NK lineage-committed progenitors (p-NK) also exist in this population. T cell lineage-committed progenitors (p-T), which are unable to generate NK cells, first appear at the CD44(+)CD25(-) FcgammaRII/III(+) stage in day 12 FT. The proportion of p-T markedly increases during the transition from the CD44(+)CD25(-) stage to the CD44(+)CD25(+) stage in day 14 FT. On the other hand, p-NK preferentially increase in number at the CD44(+)CD25(-) stage between days 12 and 14 of gestation. The production of p-NK continues up to the CD44(+)CD25(+) stage, but ceases before the rearrangement of T cell receptor beta chain genes. It was further shown that the CD44(+)CD25(-) CD122(+) population of day 14 FT exclusively contains p-NK. These results indicate that the earliest T cell progenitor migrating into the FT is T/NK bipotent, and strongly suggest that the bipotent progenitor continuously produces p-NK and p-T until the CD44(+)CD25(+) stage.

Quantification of T-Cell Progenitors During Ontogeny: Thymus Colonization Depends on Blood Delivery of Progenitors

An in vivo thymus reconstitution assay based on intrathymic injection of hematopoietic progenitors into irradiated chicks was used to determine the number of T-cell progenitors in peripheral blood, paraaortic foci, bone marrow (BM), and spleen during ontogeny. This study allowed us to analyze the regulation of thymus colonization occurring in three waves during embryogenesis. It confirmed that progenitors of the first wave of thymus colonization originate from the paraaortic foci, whereas progenitors of the second and the third waves originate from the BM. The analysis of the number of T-cell progenitors indicates that each wave of thymus colonization is correlated with a peak number of T-cell progenitors in peripheral blood, whereas they are almost absent during the periods defined as refractory for colonization. Moreover, injection of T-cell progenitors into the blood circulation showed that they homed into the thymus without delay during the refractory periods. Thus, thymus colonization kinetics depend mainly on the blood delivery of T-cell progenitors during embryogenesis.

Quantification of T-Cell Progenitors During Ontogeny: Thymus Colonization Depends on Blood Delivery of Progenitors

An in vivo thymus reconstitution assay based on intrathymic injection of hematopoietic progenitors into irradiated chicks was used to determine the number of T-cell progenitors in peripheral blood, paraaortic foci, bone marrow (BM), and spleen during ontogeny. This study allowed us to analyze the regulation of thymus colonization occurring in three waves during embryogenesis. It confirmed that progenitors of the first wave of thymus colonization originate from the paraaortic foci, whereas progenitors of the second and the third waves originate from the BM. The analysis of the number of T-cell progenitors indicates that each wave of thymus colonization is correlated with a peak number of T-cell progenitors in peripheral blood, whereas they are almost absent during the periods defined as refractory for colonization. Moreover, injection of T-cell progenitors into the blood circulation showed that they homed into the thymus without delay during the refractory periods. Thus, thymus colonization kinetics depend mainly on the blood delivery of T-cell progenitors during embryogenesis.

Emergence of T Cell Progenitors Without B Cell or Myeloid Differentiation Potential at the Earliest Stage of Hematopoiesis in the Murine Fetal Liver

It has been unclear whether the progenitors colonizing the thymus are multipotent or T cell lineage restricted. We investigated the developmental potential of hematopoietic progenitors in various populations of liver and blood cells from day 12 fetuses using the recently established in vitro experimental system effective in determining the capability of individual progenitors to generate T, B, and myeloid cells. Multipotent progenitors (p-Multi) were exclusively found in the Sca-1 high-positive (Sca-1high) subpopulation of lineage marker (Lin)−c-kit+CD45+ fetal liver cells. Restriction of developmental capacity begins at the Sca-1high stage, and a large majority of progenitors in the Sca-1low or Sca-1− population are restricted to generate T, B, or myeloid cells. Such a lineage commitment or restriction taking place in the fetal liver is independent of the thymus, because no difference in the proportion of different types of progenitors were seen between nu/nu and nu/+ fetuses. T cell lineage-restricted progenitors (p-T) were abundant in the blood of day 12 fetuses, whereas p-Multi were undetectable. It was further shown that the p-Multi generated a large number of B and myeloid cells in the thymic lobe. These results strongly suggest that it is p-T but not p-Multi that migrate into the thymus.

GKLF in thymus epithelium as a developmentally regulated element of thymocyte-stroma cross-talk

Gut-enriched Krüppel-like factor (GKLF) is a transcriptional regulator expressed in differentiated epithelia. We identified GKLF transcript as a regulated element in thymic epithelium of recombinase-deficient mice during thymus development induced by anti-CD3 antibody injection. This treatment recapitulates the organogenetic process depending on productive rearrangement of T cell receptor (TCR) beta gene with thymocytes expansion and acquisition of the CD4+8+ double positive phenotype. In wildtype mice, GKLF is expressed very early in embryogenesis and becomes intensely up-regulated in thymus epithelium at day 18 of gestation when TCR beta expressing cells have selectively expanded and express both CD4 and CD8. The results presented here suggest that thymocytes may regulate GKLF transcriptionally in the cortical epithelium at the developmental check-point controlled by TCR beta gene rearrangement. Furthermore, GKLF expression in hematopoietic stroma might suggest the thus far uncharacterised participation of this factor in hematopoiesis.

Regulation of NK1.1 Expression During Lineage Commitment of Progenitor Thymocytes

We recently identified a stage in fetal ontogeny (NK1.1+/CD117+) that defines committed progenitors for T and NK lymphocytes. These cells are found in the fetal thymus as early as day 13 of gestation, but are absent in the fetal liver. Nonetheless, multipotent precursors derived from both the fetal thymus and fetal liver are capable of rapidly differentiating to the NK1.1+ stage upon transfer into fetal thymic organ culture (FTOC). This suggests that expression of NK1.1 marks a thymus-induced lineage commitment event. We now report that a subset of the most immature fetal thymocytes (NK1.1−/CD117+) is capable of up-regulating NK1.1 expression spontaneously upon short-term in vitro culture. Interestingly, fetal liver-derived CD117+ precursors remain NK1.1− upon similar culture. Spontaneous up-regulation of NK1.1 surface expression is minimally affected by transcriptional blockade, mitogen-induced activation, or exposure of these cells to exogenous cytokines or stromal cells. These data suggest that induction of NK1.1 expression on cultured thymocytes may be predetermined by exposure to the thymic microenvironment in vivo. Importantly, multipotent CD117+ thymocytes subdivided on the basis of NK1.1 expression after short-term in vitro culture show distinct precursor potential in lymphocyte lineage reconstitution assays. This demonstrates that even the earliest precursor thymocyte population, although phenotypically homogeneous, contains a functionally heterogeneous subset of lineage-committed progenitors. These findings characterize a thymus-induced pathway in the control of lymphocyte lineage commitment to the T and NK cell fates.

Identification of a fetal hematopoietic precursor with B cell, T cell, and macrophage potential

Despite years of investigation, precursor-progeny relationships within the developing lymphoid lineages of the hematopoietic system remain poorly defined. We have characterized the potential of precursors found within a subpopulation of fetal liver defined by AA4.1 and Fc gammaRII/III expression and predominantly restricted to lymphoid and macrophage development. When cultured in methylcellulose with appropriate cytokines, AA4.1+/Fc gammaR+ precursors generate colonies consisting of various lineages, including the combination of B cell, T cell, and macrophage. Retroviral marking studies showed that the lymphoid cells and macrophages within these colonies arise from a common precursor. These results demonstrate the presence of a common precursor with B cell-, T cell-, and macrophage-restricted potential and as such define an early restriction point within the fetal lymphoid system.

Cutting Edge: Presence of Progenitors Restricted to T, B, or Myeloid Lineage, but Absence of Multipotent Stem Cells, in the Murine Fetal Thymus

The most immature population of fetal thymus (FT) cells has been shown to generate not only T but also B and myeloid cells. The present study was undertaken to clarify whether such a multipotent activity of the earliest population of FT cells is attributed to multipotent hemopoietic progenitors or to a mixture of lineage-restricted progenitors. Examination of individual FT progenitors by a recently established clonal assay system, which is able to determine the developmental potential of each progenitor toward T, B, and myeloid lineages, elucidated that a large majority of progenitors in FT were restricted to the T cell lineage. Presence of a small number of B or myeloid lineage-restricted progenitors was also disclosed. No multipotent progenitors, however, were detected in FT. These results are consistent with our recent finding that restriction of hemopoietic stem cells to T, B, and myeloid lineages takes place in the fetal liver.

Lineage commitment and differentiation of T and natural killer lymphocytes in the fetal mouse

T cells and natural killer (NK) cells are presumed to share a common intrathymic precursor. The development of conventional alpha beta T lymphocytes begins within the early fetal thymus, after the colonization of multipotent CD117+ precursors. Irrevocable commitment to the T lineage is marked by thymus-induced expression of CD25. However, the contribution of the fetal thymus to NK lineage commitment and differentiation remains largely unappreciated. Recently, we demonstrated that the development of functional mouse NK cells occurs first in the fetal thymus. Moreover, the appearance of mature fetal thymic NK cells (NK1.1+/CD117-) is preceded by a thymus-induced developmental stage (NK1.1+/CD117+) that marks lineage commitment of multipotent hematopoietic precursors to the T and NK-cell fates. Commitment to the T/NK bipotent stage is induced by fetal thymic stroma, but is not thymus dependent. Recent data indicate that CD90+/CD117lo fetal blood prothymocytes exhibit NK lineage potential and are phenotypically and functionally identical to fetal thymic NK1.1+/CD117+ progenitors. This finding also indicates that full commitment of circulating precursors to the T-cell lineage occurs after thymus colonization. In this review, we discuss recent insights into the cellular and molecular events involved in fetal mouse T and NK lineage commitment and differentiation to unipotent progenitors.

Role of interleukin-7 in T-cell development from hematopoietic stem cells

All lymphocytes are derived from hematopoietic stem cells (HSC). The interleukin-7 receptor (IL-7R) transduces non-redundant signals for both T and B-cell development from HSC. The upregulation of the IL-7R occurs at the stage of the clonogenic common lymphoid progenitor, a recently identified population that can give rise to all lymphoid lineages (T, B and natural killer cells) at a single cell level. The IL-7R plays a critical role in the rearrangement of immunoglobulin heavy chain genes required for B-cell development. IL-7R expression is critically regulated in developing thymocytes; thymocytes that fail the positive selection process downregulate the IL-7R, but those undergoing positive selection upregulate or maintain IL-7R expression. Recent data indicate that IL-7 signaling enhances the survival of developing thymocytes and mature T cells, presumably by its upregulating Bcl-2. Detailed analysis of the signaling cascades activated by the IL-7R may help to reveal the differential roles of IL-7 signaling in T and B-cell development.

The linkage between T-cell and dendritic cell development in the mouse thymus

Thymic dendritic cells (DC) mediate negative selection at a relatively late stage of the T-cell developmental pathway. We present evidence that the development of thymic DC and of T-lineage cells is linked via a common precursor at an early stage of thymocyte development. T-lineage precursor populations from the adult mouse thymus, prior to T-cell receptor gene rearrangement, display a capacity to produce DC as well as T cells in the thymus, and are very efficient precursors of DC in culture. These lymphoid/DC precursors have little capacity to form myeloid cells, indicating that thymic DC are a lymphoid-related rather than myeloid-related lineage. In contrast to myeloid-related DC, granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor is not required for the development of these lymphoid-related DC in vivo or in vitro. DC can develop in mutant mice lacking mature T cells, provided the common precursors are present. However, in mutant mice lacking functional Ikaros transcription factors, there are deficiencies in lymphoid precursor cells, in mature lymphoid cells and in DC.

Requirement for the thymus in alphabeta T lymphocyte lineage commitment

We recently identified a fetal thymic developmental stage (NK1.1+/CD117(lo)) that characterizes committed T/NK progenitors. We now report the existence of phenotypically and functionally identical T/NK progenitors in mouse fetal blood and spleen but not in fetal liver. These precursors are indistinguishable from previously characterized fetal blood "prothymocytes" (CD90+/CD117(lo)), with the exception that they express NK1.1, lack markers associated with T lineage commitment, maintain a germline TCRbeta locus, and can give rise to both T and NK cells. Moreover, NK1.1+/CD90+/CD117(lo) fetal blood precursors are present in athymic nude mice. These results suggest that the T/NK lineage commitment pathway is thymus-independent. In contrast, full commitment to the alphabeta T lineage does not precede thymus colonization.

Flt3 Ligand Plus IL-7 Supports the Expansion of Murine Thymic B Cell Progenitors That Can Mature Intrathymically

Flt3 ligand (flt3L) has potent effects on hemopoietic progenitors, dendritic cells, and B lymphopoiesis. We have investigated the effects of flt3L on intrathymic precursors. The addition of flt3L + IL-7 to lobe submersion cultures of murine fetal thymic lobes resulted in the expansion of an immature population of Thy-1low, CD44high, HSAhigh cells. This population contained cells with precursor activity, as determined by their capacity to repopulate deoxyguanosine-treated fetal thymic lobes. Upon reentry to the thymic lobe, flt3L + IL-7-cultured Thy-1low, CD44high, HSAhigh cells underwent expansion and differentiation into B cells. Two weeks after fetal thymic organ culture following thymic lobe reconstitution, intrathymic cells were Thy-1−, B220+, and a subset was sIgM+. The intrathymic B cells shared features of adult thymic B cells, including CD5 expression and proliferative responses to IL-4 + IL-5 + CD40 ligand, but not to LPS or soluble anti-IgM. Ig production was noted upon stimulation with IL-4 + IL-5 + LPS and IL-4 + IL-5 + CD40 ligand. In conclusion, we have demonstrated that flt3L + IL-7 supports the expansion of a subset of progenitors present in the fetal thymus. The cultured progenitors can repopulate a fetal thymic lobe and develop into mature functional B cells, demonstrating that the fetal thymus is able to support B cell as well as T cell development.

Prethymic expression of a transgenic TCR beta chain on a precursor of T-cells

Mice carrying a rearranged TCR Vbeta 8.2 transgene express the Vbeta protein on the vast majority of peripheral T-cells. The bone marrow and peripheral blood, as well as other lymphoid organs of both untreated animals and animals depleted of T-cells by neonatal thymectomy and/or injection from birth of monoclonal anti-TCR antibodies, contain a small population of cells that express low levels of the Vbeta transgene product, but no T-cell or other detectable lineage-specific phenotypic markers. When such TG-bearing BM cells are purified and injected directly into the non-TG thymus, they show the phenotypic maturation sequences of intrathymic T-cell development and, subsequently, mature TG-bearing peripheral T-cells. However, this population failed to support long-term recovery from lethal irradiation. Both Vbeta 8.2 TG and CD3delta mRNA transcripts are strongly expressed in the cell population, but no CD3gamma, CD3epsilon, CD3zeta, CD4, CD8beta, pre-Talpha, or RAG-1 transcript was detected. The transgene-encoded TCR component is not bound to the cell membrane exclusively by a phosphatidylinositol linkage. The data show that the fully rearranged TCR transgene and transcripts for at least one of the associated CD3 components, CD3delta, can be expressed on a subpopulation of BM and PBL cells that has not passed through the thymus. The phenotypic characteristics of this cell population resemble those described for the earliest thymocyte described by others. The TG protein molecule in this model may provide a specific developmental marker for a prothymocyte lineage subset that lacks pluripotential properties.

Identification of a novel developmental stage marking lineage commitment of progenitor thymocytes

Bipotent progenitors for T and natural killer (NK) lymphocytes are thought to exist among early precursor thymocytes. The identification and functional properties of such a progenitor population remain undefined. We report the identification of a novel developmental stage during fetal thymic ontogeny that delineates a population of T/NK-committed progenitors (NK1. 1(+)/CD117(+)/CD44(+)/CD25(-)). Thymocytes at this stage in development are phenotypically and functionally distinguishable from the pool of multipotent lymphoid-restricted (B, T, and NK) precursor thymocytes. Exposure of multipotent precursor thymocytes or fetal liver- derived hematopoietic progenitors to thymic stroma induces differentiation to the bipotent developmental stage. Continued exposure to a thymic microenvironment results in predominant commitment to the T cell lineage, whereas coculture with a bone marrow-derived stromal cell line results in the generation of mature NK cells. Thus, the restriction point to T and NK lymphocyte destinies from a multipotent progenitor stage is marked by a thymus-induced differentiation step.

Isolation of the most immature population of murine fetal thymocytes that includes progenitors capable of generating T, B, and myeloid cells

Thymus cells of murine fetuses at day 12 of gestation are exclusively of the CD3-CD4-CD8-CD44+CD25- phenotype, which is known as a hallmark of the most immature subset of thymus cells. In the present study, we show that day 12 fetal thymus (FT) cells express Fc gamma RII/ III (FcR) at a broad range of levels on their surface. The FcR+ FT cells seem to represent T lineage cells, because a large majority of them express the T lineage specific transcription factors TCF-1 and GATA-3 as well as CD3 epsilon in the cytoplasm. Also shown is that the FcR- population contains progenitors capable of developing into not only T cells but also B and myeloid cells, whereas FcR+ progenitors are mostly committed to the T lineage. These findings indicate that thymic T lineage cells express FcR on their surface at the earliest stage of differentiation, and thus FcR is a useful marker in isolating the most immature population of murine FT cells.

Involvement of transcription factors TCF-1 and GATA-3 in the initiation of the earliest step of T cell development in the thymus

Flow cytometric and immunocytochemical analyses of murine fetal thymus (FT) cells with antibodies to various surface markers and transcription factors reveal that the synthesis of TCF-1 and GATA-3 protein begins simultaneously in a fraction of the most immature population of FT cells, which have the phenotype of CD4-CD8-CD44+CD25-. No TCF-1-producing cells is found in the fetal liver (FL). In CD44+CD25- FT cells, the production of TCF-1 is immediately followed by intracellular expression of CD3 epsilon. It is also found that the T cell development from FL, but not FT, progenitors in the FT organ culture system is severely inhibited by the addition of antisense oligonucleotides for either TCF-1 or GATA-3. These results strongly suggest that TCF-1 and GATA-3 play essential roles in the initiation of the earliest steps of T cell development in the thymus.

Hematopoietic stem cells in the mouse embryonic yolk sac

The yolk sac is the first site of hematopoiesis during mammalian development. The yolk sac is also the first site of blood vessel development. Development of the blood islands in the yolk sac is an integrated process in which these two developmental events, hematopoiesis and vasculogenesis, proceed in concert. This review focuses on mouse yolk sac hematopoietic stem cells (YS-HSC), describing their differentiation in vitro and in vivo. YS-HSC go through a progressive series of changes prior to the initiation of lineage-specific differentiation. Experiments tracing their origins from postulated hemangioblasts, and the subsequent interaction between these stem cells and yolk sac endothelial cells are described. Differences between the extraembryonic YS-HSC and HSC found later within the embryo, perinatally or in adults, are described. YS-HSC have greater reproductive capability than HSC obtained from fetal liver, umbilical cord blood or adult bone marrow; they do not yet express major histocompatibility complex-associated antigens and they are able to reconstitute adult immunocompromised animals even when introduced in small numbers (< 100 cells/mouse). With recent results demonstrating the feasibility of expanding YS-HSC in vitro as well as of introducing new genes into these cells by transfection, the YS-HSC shows promise both as a means of achieving long-term restitution of hematopoiesis across histocompatibility barriers and as a self-renewing vehicle for gene transfer.

Early T lymphocyte progenitors

The earliest steps along the pathway leading to T cells in mice and humans are reviewed. These are the steps between the multipotent hemopoietic stem cell (HSC) and the fully committed precursors undergoing T cell receptor (TCR) gene rearrangement. At this level significant differences between adult and fetal lymphopoiesis have been demonstrated. The extent of lymphoid commitment of precursors within bone marrow is still unresolved, although HSCs clearly undergo developmental changes before migration to the thymus. Both multipotent and T-restricted precursors have now been isolated from fetal blood, suggesting both may seed the thymus. Within the thymus, several minute but discrete populations of T precursors precede the stage of TCR gene rearrangement. They include precursors that are not exclusively T-lineage committed, although they are distinct from HSCs. These precursors have a potential to form NK cells, B cells, dendritic cells, and sometimes other myeloid cells. Some factors that control early lymphoid development are discussed, including IL-7 and the Ikaros transcription factors. These will eventually help to clarify the process of T-lineage commitment.

Cellular interactions in thymocyte development

Interactions between stromal cells and thymocytes play a crucial role in T cell development. The thymic stroma is complex and consists of epithelial cells derived from the pharyngeal region during development, together with macrophages and dendritic cells of bone marrow origin. In addition, fibroblasts and matrix molecules permeate the whole framework. It is now apparent that these individual stromal components play specialized roles at different stages of T cell differentiation. Thus, at the early CD4-8- stage of development, T cell precursors require fibroblast as well as epithelial cell interactions. Later, at the CD4+8+ stage, as well as providing low avidity TCR/MHC-peptide interactions, thymic epithelial cells have been shown to possess unique properties essential for positive selection. Dendritic cells, on the other hand, are probably efficient mediators of negative selection, but they may not be solely responsible for this activity. Alongside the functional roles of stromal cells, considerable progress is being made in unraveling the nature of the signaling pathways involved in T cell development. Identification of the pre-T cell receptor (pre-TCR) and associated signaling molecules marks an important advance in understanding the mechanisms that control gene rearrangement and allelic exclusion. In addition, a better understanding of the signaling pathways that lead to positive selection on the one hand and negative selection on the other is beginning to emerge. Many issues remain unresolved, and some are discussed in this review. What, for example, is the nature of the chemotactic factor(s) that attract stem cells to the thymus? What is the molecular basis of the essential interactions between early thymocytes and fibroblasts, and early thymocytes and epithelial cells? What is special about cortical epithelial cells in supporting positive selection? These and other issues are ripe for analysis and can now be approached using a combination of modern molecular and cellular techniques.

Regulation of thymocyte development from immature progenitors

T lymphocytes differentiate from hematopoietic stem cells that settle in the microenvironment of the thymus. The earliest stages of mouse alpha/beta T-cell differentiation occurring before surface expression of the TCR include three important events: proliferation, commitment to the T lineage, and rearrangement and expression of the TCR loci. Recent evidence suggests that the survival as well as differentiation of early thymocytes depends critically on molecular signals such as those generated by the recently described pre-TCR complex.

In-vitro models of stroma-dependent lymphopoiesis

The differentiation of hematopoietic stem cells into lymphocytes can be replicated ex vivo under the inductive influence of the stromal cells that frame the bone marrow and thymus. We summarize hereafter the development of culture systems where lymphopoiesis-supporting cell compartments are maintained in either their normal three-dimensional arrangement, in organotypic culture, or as culture dish-adherent monolayers and review the recent and current uses of those in-vitro models to investigate T- and B-cell differentiation in mouse and man.

Pathways from hematopoietic stem cells to thymocytes

A long-standing debate has been whether commitment to the T cell lineage occurs exclusively following thymus colonization, or whether prethymic T lineage restricted progenitors exist. Recently, the analysis of murine fetal blood for the presence of hematopoietic progenitor cells has led to the identification of a T lineage committed precursor population (designated prothymocytes). Fetal blood prothymocytes lack multipotent progenitor potential as shown by the fact that they fail to reconstitute B lymphocyte, myeloid and erythroid lineages. In addition to prothymocytes, fetal blood also contains a phenotypically distinct, pluripotent progenitor population which can reconstitute both T and B lymphocytes as well as myeloid and erythroid lineages. The identification of a circulating, T lineage restricted precursor population, which is also found in the blood of fetal athymic mice, provides strong evidence that T lineage commitment can precede thymus colonization. The thymus is not, however, exclusively colonized by prothymocytes. Under appropriate developmental conditions, multipotent precursor activity for non-T lineages such as B lymphocytes and thymic dendritic cells can be revealed within the intrathymic precursor pool. Moreover, evidence has been accumulated for a common progenitor for T cells and natural killer cells which may be distinct from multipotent intrathymic progenitors.