An idiotypic replica of carcinoembryonic antigen inducing cellular and humoral responses directed against human colorectal tumours

A Preliminary Study on the Functional Analysis of Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes from Ovarian Cancer Patients Developing Hama after Immunoscintigraphy

In the follow-up of ovarian cancer patients, rising levels of the tumor-associated antigen CA 125 are an indication for immunoscintigraphy. Human anti-mouse antibodies (HAMA) are frequently found after immunoscintigraphy with murine MAb directed against CA 125. Since we observed that patients developing high HAMA-levels in serum remained free of tumor or had stable disease, we examined the cytotoxic activity of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) by a fluorescence-based assay. Our results demonstrate that PBLs of patients with high anti-idiotypic antibodies show an increased cytotoxic activity (by a factor of 4) compared to those of patients with low HAMA levels. The clinical course of the patients after the first injection of murine monoclonal antibody was observed over a period of 1 to 3 years. Improvement or deterioration of patients ‘ clinical condition corresponded with the results obtained by functional analysis. Further investigations concerning the course of cytotoxic activity in HAMA-positive patients will have to clarify HAMA's role in the immune response.

Antibodies designed as effective cancer vaccines

Antigen/antibody complexes can efficiently target antigen presenting cells to allow stimulation of the cellular immune response. Due to the difficulty of manufacture and their inherent instability complexes have proved inefficient cancer vaccines. However, anti-idiotypic antibodies mimicking antigens have been shown to stimulate both antibody and T cell responses. The latter are due to T cell mimotopes expressed within the complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) of antibodies that are efficiently presented to dendritic cells in vivo. Based on this observation we have designed a DNA vaccine platform called ImmunoBody, where cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) and helper T cell epitopes replace CDR regions within the framework of a human IgG1 antibody. The ImmunoBody expression system has a number of design features which allow for rapid production of a wide range of vaccines. The CDR regions of the heavy and light chain have been engineered to contain unique restriction endonuclease sites, which can be easily opened, and oligonucleotides encoding the T cell epitopes inserted. The variable and constant regions of the ImmunoBody are also flanked by restriction sites, which permit easy exchange of other IgG subtypes. Here we show a range of T cell epitopes can be inserted into the ImmunoBody vector and upon immunization these T cell epitopes are efficiently processed and presented to stimulate high frequency helper and CTL responses capable of anti-tumor activity.

Development of cancer vaccines to activate cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Cancer vaccines have been shown to stimulate cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses in a variety of cancer patients. However, the response is often of low frequency and moderate avidity, and does not result in objective clinical responses. This is related to the target antigens, which are usually over-expressed self-antigens that elicit tolerogenic and regulatory immune responses, resulting in deletion or inactivation of high-avidity T cells. Although moderate-avidity T cells can be efficient killers, tumours are often poor targets as they express a variety of molecules to protect them from cell-mediated immunity. Adoptive transfer of large numbers of high-avidity T cells has been shown to induce regression of bulky disease, proving that immune responses can effectively eradicate tumours. New approaches that target activated dendritic cells in vivo, resulting in cross-presentation of CTL epitopes and release of cytokines that suppress regulatory T cells, have resulted in the production of T cells with sufficient avidity to kill tumour target cells. These approaches in combination with regimes, such as cytokine therapy, chemotherapy or radiotherapy, that modulate effector costimulatory expression on tumour targets may result in more effective second-generation cancer vaccines.

Immune responses in advanced colorectal cancer following repeated intradermal vaccination with the anti-CEA murine monoclonal antibody, PR1A3: results of a phase I study

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

The aim was to determine the toxicity, clinical and immune responses to the murine monoclonal anti-carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) antibody, PR1A3, in patients with advanced colorectal cancer.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifteen patients with advanced colorectal cancer received either 0.5-, 1.0- or 5.0-mg doses of PR1A3 mixed with 10% w/v Alum adjuvant (Superfos Biosector, Denmark) intradermally at 4-week intervals for 3 months. Patient serum was assessed for anti-idiotypic (Ab2), anti-anti-idiotypic (Ab3) and human anti-mouse antibody (HAMA) reactivity. Peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) proliferation with phytohaemagglutinin (PHA), CEA and PR1A3, stimulated IL-2, IL-4 and IFN-gamma levels and PR1A3-stimulated IL-2 receptor expression during immunotherapy were determined. Comparisons were made with 16 age-matched controls without malignant disease.

RESULTS

Hyperimmune sera from 12 of the 15 patients showed Ab2 reactivity with no detectable Ab3 responses. Strong HAMA reactivity was recorded in 7 of the 15 cases with no adverse clinical effect. Delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses developed in 12 of the 15 patients. Pre-treatment PBMC proliferation with PHA was subnormal in each patient compared with controls, becoming normal (or supranormal) in all patients during immunisation (P<0.001). PBMC proliferation with CEA and PR1A3 increased during immunotherapy (P<0.001) along with stimulated production of IL-2, IFN-gamma and IL-2 receptor expression. Progressive disease was observed in 14 of the 15 patients with minimal toxicity.

CONCLUSION

PR1A3 generated limited idiotypic responses but robust DTH reactivity in most patients. In vitro PBMC proliferation with mitogens and recall antigens is greatly increased during the course of immunisation, with a shift in stimulated cytokine profile.

Colorectal cancer vaccines: what we know and what we don't yet know

Humans have a sophisticated immune system that functions to clear invading organisms and abnormal cells. However, cancers are able to arise despite this immune system. Vaccines have the potential of benefiting cancer patients by stimulating an immune response against tumor-associated antigens (TAA). Our enhanced understanding of how the immune system processes and presents antigens has allowed an array of vaccine modalities to be developed and tested. The TAA with the greatest number of vaccine platforms tested in colorectal cancer is carcinoembyronic antigen (CEA). Trials to date have demonstrated safety and evidence for the induction of an immune response against CEA. This article will review trials conducted with a variety of CEA vaccines. Most studies conducted are phase I or II in the metastatic disease setting, limiting our understanding of the role of the immune response in controlling colon cancers. Phase III trials conducted to date have conflicting data with respect to improvements in disease-free and overall survival. It is our challenge to determine if and which vaccines have sufficient benefit to warrant large-scale trials in the adjuvant and prevention settings.

A novel CEA vaccine stimulates T cell proliferation, γIFN secretion and CEA specific CTL responses

Carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) is a cell surface protein over-expressed by a wide range of tumours. The mouse anti-idiotypic antibody, 708, mimics CEA and can induce both antibody and T cell responses that specifically recognise this antigen. Sequence analysis of 708 revealed homology with a previously identified HLA-A3 T cell epitope in CEA but not to other closely related molecules. 708 was chimerised to a human IgG1 to allow Fc targeting of APCs and was deimmunised to remove unwanted T cell epitopes. The chimerised and deimmunised, but not the mouse 708, could stimulate CTL, proliferation and gammaIFN responses in vitro in normal (HLA-A3, DR1) individuals. Furthermore, the CTLs killed tumour cells expressing CEA suggesting that this deimmunised antibody could be a useful vaccine for solid tumours.

B and T cell responses elicited by monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody (Ab2beta) mimicking gp43 from Paracoccidioides brasiliensis

Paracoccidioidomycosis is a systemic mycosis endemic in Latin America, with a high prevalence in Brazil, Argentina, Colombia and Venezuela. The aetiological agent of disease is the thermal dimorphic fungus, Paracoccidioides brasiliensis. A glycoprotein of 43 kD (gp43) is the major antigen of P. brasiliensis. Antibodies directed to this antigen are detected in the sera of all patients with paracoccidioidomycosis (PCM). Recently, it has been shown that mice immunized with anti-gp43 monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) (Ab1), induce the idiotypic cascade in the gp43 system, which produced both, anti-Id antibodies (Ab2) and anti-anti-Id antibodies (Ab3). To further characterize the idiotypic cascade modulation in mice immunized with anti-gp43 MAb 17c, hybridomas were produced. Ab2 MAbs named 7.B12 inhibited (>95%) the binding of gp43 to MAb 17c (Ab1), suggesting that this anti-Id MAb bind to the idiotope, thus fulfilling the internal image criteria. To elucidate whether Ab2 MAb could act as antigen in serological assays, instead of gp43, sera from PCM patients were tested. Using an ELISA test, it was observed that antibodies from patients and not normal serum bound to Ab2. However, the ELISA test using Ab2 bound to the solid phase made possible to serologically monitor the patients after antifungal therapy, showing an equivalent curve when compared with ELISA test employing purified gp43. Our results also showed that, when mice were immunized with Ab2beta and their cells were exposed to gp43 in vitro, a T cell proliferation response was observed.

Signal sequence deletion and fusion to tetanus toxoid epitope augment antitumor immune responses to a human carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) plasmid DNA vaccine in a murine test system

Carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA, CEACAM5) is expressed on several human carcinomas including colon cancer. CEA contains signal peptides that target the protein through the endoplasmic reticulum and to the cell membrane. We constructed a plasmid DNA vaccine encoding a truncated CEA (deltaCEA), devoid of its signal peptides, and demonstrated that it was retained inside the cell, while full-length CEA (wtCEA) was expressed on the membrane. We hypothesized that intracellular retention of deltaCEA would enhance MHC class I presentation of CEA peptides, thus favoring cellular immune responses. In addition, a promiscuous T-helper epitope (Q830-L844 of tetanus toxoid) was fused to the N-terminal of the truncated CEA gene (tetdeltaCEA). C57BL/6 mice immunized with DNA encoding wtCEA or tetdeltaCEA developed both humoral and cellular immune responses to CEA. SCID mice transplanted with spleen cells from tetdeltaCEA but not wtCEA-immunized C57BL/6 mice showed strong suppression of tumor growth after inoculation of human CEA-expressing colon carcinoma cells. Immune spleen cell populations depleted for either B, T or both B and T cells were active, indicating that effector cells might also reside in other populations. The present approach to manipulating antigen presentation may open new possibilities for immunotherapy against colon and other CEA-secreting carcinomas.

The role of CD55 in protecting the tumour environment from complement attack

CD55 is a complement regulatory protein expressed by cells to protect them from bystander killing by complement. CD55 is over-expressed 2-100-fold on tumour cells and is deposited in large amounts within tumour matrix. Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) produced by tumours to stimulate angiogenesis, also up-regulates endothelial cell surface expression of CD55 and stimulates the release of matrix degrading metalloproteinases. This study investigated the effects of VEGF on CD55 deposition into matrix and the release of CD55 by metalloproteinases. In contrast to inflammatory cytokines, CD55 was up-regulated by VEGF at the cell surface and within the extracellular matrix (ECM). Interestingly, human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVEC) exposed to VEGF released similar amounts of CD55 into the ECM as a tumour cell line expressing 50-fold higher level of CD55 on its cell surface. Furthermore, in contrast to earlier studies, both tumour and HUVEC-derived CD55 was functionally active. However, in contrast to papain that degrades CD55, and collagenase that fails to release CD55, MMP-7 released intact CD55 from ECM. This suggests that it may have a further role to play in protecting cells during inflammation and invasion.

Cancer immunotherapy: insights from transgenic animal models

A wide range of strategies in cancer immunotherapy has been developed in the last decade, some of which are currently being used in clinical settings. The development of these immunotherapeutical strategies has been facilitated by the generation of relevant transgenic animal models. Since the different strategies in experimental immunotherapy of cancer each aim to activate different immune system components, a variety of transgenic animals have been generated either expressing tumor associated, HLA, oncogenic or immune effector cell molecule proteins. This review aims to discuss the existing transgenic mouse models generated to study and develop cancer immunotherapy strategies and the variable results obtained. The potential of the various transgenic animal models regarding the development of anti-cancer immunotherapeutical strategies is evaluated.

Human anti-idiotypic antibodies can be good immunogens as they target FC receptors on antigen-presenting cells allowing efficient stimulation of both helper and cytotoxic T-cell responses

Anti-idiotypic antibodies that mimic tumour-associated antigens can stimulate anti-tumour T-cell responses. In this article, we have studied the role of Fc in the presentation of T-cell epitopes by 2 anti-idiotypic antibodies, 105AD7 and 708. The human monoclonal antibody 105AD7, which mimics CD55, stimulated strong in vitro T-cell proliferation, gammaIFN secretion and redirected cytotoxicity in unprimed T cells from healthy donors. However, removal of the Fc region of the anti-idiotype reduced the sensitivity of the assay 1,000-fold, as did inhibiting Fc uptake of the anti-idiotype by an excess of human IgG. The mouse anti-idiotype 708, which mimics CEA, failed to stimulate in vitro T-cell responses on unprimed T cells from healthy donors. However, when a human IgG1 Fc region replaced its mouse Fc region, the anti-idiotype induced T-cell proliferation, gammaIFN secretion and redirected cytotoxicity in lymphocytes from unimmunised donors. Human anti-idiotypes are therefore good immunogens since they target Fc receptors on antigen-presenting cells, allowing efficient stimulation of both helper and cytotoxic T-cell responses. The immunogenicity of other anti-idiotypes may therefore be enhanced by human Fc targeting of antigen-presenting cells.

Colorectal cancer vaccines

BACKGROUND

Advances in molecular pathology have enabled a number of colorectal cancer antigens to be identified and characterized. The commonest investigated include 17-1A, 791Tgp72 and carcinoembryonic antigen. Vaccines have been developed that stimulate the immune system to target these antigens. This paper reviews current areas of research in this field.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Relevant articles were obtained on vaccines for colorectal cancer from Medline and the Bath Information Data System. A number of approaches are currently being evaluated in Phase I, II and III trials. These include anti-idiotypic antibody immunization, DNA vaccines, mucin and heat shock protein-based vaccines, oncogenes and viral vectors.

CONCLUSION

Evidence is accumulating to suggest that immune responses may be generated against colorectal cancer using these approaches. While the concept of vaccination against this malignancy is essentially experimental, surgeons should be aware of current advances.

Immune response to the carcinoembryonic antigen in patients treated with an anti-idiotype antibody vaccine

We have generated an IgG1 murine monoclonal anti-idiotype antibody (Ab2) designated 3H1, which mimics a specific epitope on the carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA). Patients with CEA positive tumors are immunologically "tolerant" to CEA. We used 3H1 as a surrogate for CEA for vaccine therapy of 12 patients with advanced colorectal cancer. Each of the patients received a minimum of four intracutaneous injections of aluminum hydroxide precipitated 3H1 at either 1, 2, or 4 mg dosage per injection. 9 of 12 patients demonstrated anti-anti-idiotypic (Ab3) response to 3H1. All nine patients generated specific anti-CEA antibody demonstrated by reactivity with radiolabeled purified CEA; some cases were confirmed by immunoprecipitation of purified CEA. We also demonstrated Ab3 stained both autologous and allogeneic colonic tumors. 7 of 12 patients demonstrated idiotype specific T cell proliferative responses and four also showed T cell proliferation to CEA. Toxicity was limited to local reaction with mild fever and chills. All 12 patients eventually progressed after finishing 4-13 dosages. This is the first report demonstrating that a vaccine therapy is capable of breaking "immune tolerance" to CEA in patients with CEA positive tumors. Future studies will focus on treating patients with minimal residual disease.

Determination of the immunoreactivity of radiolabelled monoclonal antibody fragments by binding to immobilised anti-idiotypic antibodies

The feasibility of using immobilised anti-combining site (anti-idiotypic) antibodies as targets for assessing the immunoreactivity of radiolabelled anti-tumour monoclonal antibodies has been assessed. With two anti-tumour monoclonal antibodies (anti-CEA and anti-gp72) it was possible to quantify binding of their 125I labelled Fab fragment preparations to their anti-idiotypic monoclonal antibodies immobilised on cyanogen bromide activated Sepharose. Binding was specific for immobilised anti-idiotypic antibodies reactive with the anti-tumour antibody fragments. Moreover binding was inhibited by unlabelled Fab or intact monoclonal antibody, but not by an irrelevant antibody or its Fab fragment. The use of anti-idiotypic antibodies for quantifying immunoreactions of radiolabelled antibodies has advantages over the use of initial target antigen, which may be available only in inconvenient forms, such as cultured tumour cells.

Immunization with anti-idiotype monoclonal antibodies bearing the internal image of the renal-cell carcinoma-associated antigen G250 induces specific cellular immune responses

We have previously isolated and characterized 6 anti-idiotype antibodies (Ab2s) directed against monoclonal antibody G250 (MAbG250) which reacts with a tumor-associated antigen (TAA) expressed in a large proportion of human renal-cell carcinomas (RCC). These 6 Ab2s (NUH31, 51, 71, 82, 91: IgG1, NUH44: IgG2a) showed MAbG250 binding site specificity and induction of anti-TAA antibody resembling MAbG250 (so-called AbI') in rabbits, indicating that they are internal image antibodies. To investigate whether these Ab2s could induce G250-TAA-specific cell-mediated immunity, delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) tests were carried out with G250 antigen-positive and/or -negative cells in the ears of BALB/c mice. Mice primed with Ab2 showed antigen-specific DTH responses, whereas no significant DTH response was observed with G250-negative cells. This antigen-specific DTH could be transferred to naive mice by lymphocytes harvested from Ab2-sensitized mice. In addition to the classical DTH responses observed 24 and 48 hr after tumor challenge, an early-phase antigen-specific hypersensitivity response was seen 2 hr after challenge. This early component of the specific hypersensitivity reaction but not the classical DTH could be transferred to naive mice by serum from Ab2-sensitized mice, indicating that the early reaction was due to serum factors. These findings demonstrate that all Ab2s induced tumor-specific cellular immune responses directed against human RCC, and suggest that they may be useful as RCC-TAA surrogates, i.e., as tumor vaccines for RCC patients.

Clinical outcome of colorectal cancer patients treated with human monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody

A human monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody (105AD7) has been developed which mimics a colorectal-tumour-associated antigen and induces cellular anti-colorectal tumour immune responses in animals. Thirteen patients with advanced colorectal cancer were immunized with 105AD7 and their survival was compared with that of a contemporary group of unimmunized patients with similar disease status. No toxicity related to anti-idiotype immunization was seen. Cellular responses to anti-idiotypic immunization were indicated by lymphocyte proliferation to gp72-positive tumour cells, and production of interleukin-2; anti-tumour antibodies were not detected. Median survival following diagnosis of advanced disease of immunized patients was 12 months, compared with 4 months in unimmunized patients. The improved survival of immunized patients in this study without associated toxicity suggests that 105AD7 immunization may have considerable potential for immunotherapy of colorectal cancer.

Mimicry of a carcinoembryonic antigen epitope by a rat monoclonal anti-idiotype antibody

Anti-idiotype antibodies (Ab2) that immunologically mimic tumor antigens are auspicious agents for the active immunization of cancer patients. We have developed W12, a rat monoclonal IgG1 Ab2 to MN-14, a murine anti-carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) monoclonal antibody. W12 is specific for MN-14 and does not react with other isotype-matched anti-CEA monoclonal antibodies. Moreover, W12 inhibits the binding between MN-14 and CEA. Anti-CEA antibodies can be induced by immunization with W12 (but not with control rat IgG) in xenogenic animals (mice or rabbits). Immunoblotting studies indicate that the internal image determinant borne by W12 is conformational and requires the association of the heavy and light chains of the Ab2 molecule. This study indicates that W12 is a potential idiotype vaccine in patients with CEA-producing cancers.

Identification of colon-tumor-associated antigens by T-cell lines derived from tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes and peripheral-blood lymphocytes from patients immunized with an autologous tumor-cell/bacillus Calmette-Guérin vaccine

Tumor immunity developing as a response to an autologous colon-tumor/bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine appears to be associated with induction of CD4+ helper T cells, implied by the observation that vaccine efficacy is associated with major histocompatibility complex class-II molecule expression on the vaccine tumor cells. Therefore, in an attempt to identify colon-tumor-associated antigens responsible for conferring immunity, we examined and compared the proliferative responses of peripheral-blood lymphocytes (PBL) from patients immunized with the autologous tumor/BCG vaccine to T-cell lines cloned expanded from colon-tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes to 5 antigens isolated on the basis of their reactivity by colon-tumor-reactive human monoclonal antibodies. Enzymatically dissociated colon tumors provided a source for establishment of cloned T-cell lines, tumor cell lines propagated in vitro or in vivo as nude-mouse xenografts and EBV-transformed B-cell lines used as antigen-presenting cells. Of 104 different T-cell lines tested, only 3 proliferated in response to CTAA 28A32-46K, and I to the CTAA28A32-32K antigen. In contrast, PBL from 64% of patients immunized with the autologous colon-tumor/BCG vaccine responded to the CTAA 28A32-32K antigen. This antigen is related to a family of calcium- and phospholipid-binding placental proteins termed annexins. Since proliferative responses developed to this antigen after vaccination in 64% of individuals, this antigen may be an important common colon-tumor-associated rejection antigen.

Induction of delayed-type hypersensitivity responses by monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies to tumor cells expressing carcinoembryonic antigen and tumor-associated glycoprotein-72

The use of anti-idiotypic antibodies as immunogens represents one potential approach to active specific immunotherapy of cancer. Two panels of syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies were generated. One panel was directed against mAb CC49 and the other to mAb COL-1. mAb CC49 recognizes the pancarcinoma antigen (Ag), tumor-associated glycoprotein-72 (TAG-72), and mAb COL-1 recognizes carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA). Seven anti-idiotypic (AI) antibodies (Ab2) designated AI49-1-7 were generated that recognize the variable region of mAb CC49. These mAb were shown to inhibit the interaction of mAb CC49 (Ab1) with TAG-72 (Ag). Five anti-idiotypic antibodies designated CAI-1-5 were also generated to the anti-CEA mAb, COL-1 (Ab1). These Ab2 were shown to inhibit the interaction between COL-1 (Ab1) and CEA (Ag). Immunization of mice, rats, and rabbits with Ab2 directed against CC49 or COL-1 could not elicit specific Ab3 humoral immune responses, i.e., antibody selectively reactive with their respective target antigens. However, immunization of mice with the CC49 anti-idiotypic antibody (Ab2), designated AI49-3, could induce a delayed-type hypersensitivity response (DTH) specific for tumor cells that express TAG-72. Similarly, immunization of mice with an anti-idiotypic antibody directed against COL-1, designated CAI-1, could induce specific DTH cell-mediated immune responses to murine tumor cells that express human CEA on their surface. These results thus demonstrate that while some anti-idiotype mAb may not be potent immunogens in eliciting Ab3 humoral responses, they are capable of eliciting specific cellular immune responses against human carcinoma-associated antigens. This type of mAb may ultimately be useful in active immunotherapy protocols for human carcinoma.

Monoclonal antibodies in the detection and therapy of micrometastatic epithelial cancers

The initial promise of monoclonal antibodies as major therapeutic agents in human epithelial cancer has not been realized. Inaccessibility of cells in solid tumors due to factors such as the nature of the vascular endothelia and high pressure in the tumor are primarily responsible for the failure of antibody therapy. Although new strategies employing recombinant antibodies and immunoglobulins designed to actively engage the immune system may prove beneficial, micrometastatic tumor cells (at the stage of minimal residual disease) are likely to be the only suitable targets for antibody therapy. The diagnostic approaches to identify and characterize these cells and their use for prognosis and monitoring adjuvant immunotherapy is discussed.