Synthetic lac operator mediates repression through lac repressor when introduced upstream and downstream from lac promoter

Biomolecular Assemblies: Moving from Observation to Predictive Design

Biomolecular assembly is a key driving force in nearly all life processes, providing structure, information storage, and communication within cells and at the whole organism level. These assembly processes rely on precise interactions between functional groups on nucleic acids, proteins, carbohydrates, and small molecules, and can be fine-tuned to span a range of time, length, and complexity scales. Recognizing the power of these motifs, researchers have sought to emulate and engineer biomolecular assemblies in the laboratory, with goals ranging from modulating cellular function to the creation of new polymeric materials. In most cases, engineering efforts are inspired or informed by understanding the structure and properties of naturally occurring assemblies, which has in turn fueled the development of predictive models that enable computational design of novel assemblies. This Review will focus on selected examples of protein assemblies, highlighting the story arc from initial discovery of an assembly, through initial engineering attempts, toward the ultimate goal of predictive design. The aim of this Review is to highlight areas where significant progress has been made, as well as to outline remaining challenges, as solving these challenges will be the key that unlocks the full power of biomolecules for advances in technology and medicine.

Structure-guided approach to site-specific fluorophore labeling of the lac repressor LacI

The lactose operon repressor protein LacI has long served as a paradigm of the bacterial transcription factors. However, the mechanisms whereby LacI rapidly locates its cognate binding site on the bacterial chromosome are still elusive. Single-molecule fluorescence imaging approaches are well suited for the study of these mechanisms but rely on a functionally compatible fluorescence labeling of LacI. Particularly attractive for protein fluorescence labeling are synthetic fluorophores due to their small size and favorable photophysical characteristics. Synthetic fluorophores are often conjugated to natively occurring cysteine residues using maleimide chemistry. For a site-specific and functionally compatible labeling with maleimide fluorophores, the target protein often needs to be redesigned to remove unwanted native cysteines and to introduce cysteines at locations better suited for fluorophore attachment. Biochemical screens can then be employed to probe for the functional activity of the redesigned protein both before and after dye labeling. Here, we report a mutagenesis-based redesign of LacI to enable a functionally compatible labeling with maleimide fluorophores. To provide an easily accessible labeling site in LacI, we introduced a single cysteine residue at position 28 in the DNA-binding headpiece of LacI and replaced two native cysteines with alanines where derivatization with bulky substituents is known to compromise the protein’s activity. We find that the redesigned LacI retains a robust activity in vitro and in vivo, provided that the third native cysteine at position 281 is retained in LacI. In a total internal reflection microscopy assay, we observed individual Cy3-labeled LacI molecules bound to immobilized DNA harboring the cognate O₁ operator sequence, indicating that the dye-labeled LacI is functionally active. We have thus been able to generate a functional fluorescently labeled LacI that can be used to unravel mechanistic details of LacI target search at the single molecule level.

Quantitative Determination of DNA Bridging Efficiency of Chromatin Proteins

DNA looping is important for genome organization in all domains of life. The basis of DNA loop formation is the bridging of two separate DNA double helices. Detecting DNA bridge formation generally involves the use of complex single-molecule techniques (atomic force microscopy, magnetic, or optical tweezers). Although DNA bridging can be qualitatively described, quantification of DNA bridging and bridging dynamics using these techniques is challenging. Here, we describe a novel biochemical assay capable of not only detecting DNA bridge formation, but also allowing for quantification of DNA bridging efficiency and the effects of physico-chemical conditions on DNA bridge formation.

From adjacent activation in Escherichia coli and DNA cyclization to eukaryotic enhancers: the elements of a puzzle

Deoxyribonucleic acid cyclization, Escherichia coli lac repressor binding to two spaced lac operators and repression enhancement can be successfully used for a better understanding of the conditions required for interaction between eukaryotic enhancers and the machinery of transcription initiation. Chronologically, the DNA looping model has first accounted for the properties initially defining enhancers, i.e., independence of action with distance or orientation with respect to the start of transcription. It has also predicted enhancer activity or its disruption at short distance (site orientation, alignment between promoter and enhancer sites), with high-order complexes of protein, or with transcription factor concentrations close or different from the wild-type situation. In another step, histones have been introduced into the model to further adapt it to eukaryotes. They in fact favor DNA cyclization in vitro. The resulting DNA compaction might explain the difference counted in base pairs in the distance of action between eukaryotic transcription enhancers and prokaryotic repression enhancers. The lac looping system provides a potential tool for analysis of this discrepancy and of chromatin state directly in situ. Furthermore, as predicted by the model, the contribution of operators O2 and O3 to repression of the lac operon clearly depends on the lac repressor level in the cell and is prevented in strains overproducing lac repressor. By extension, gene regulation especially that linked to cell fate, should also depend on transcription factor levels, providing a potential tool for cellular therapy. In parallel, a new function of the O1–O3 loop completes the picture of lac repression. The O1–O3 loop would at the same time ensure high efficiency of repression, inducibility through the low-affinity sites and limitation of the level of repressor through self-repression of the lac repressor. Last, the DNA looping model can be successfully adapted to the enhancer auxiliary elements known as insulators.

Bacterial promoter repression by DNA looping without protein-protein binding competition

The Escherichia coli lactose operon provides a paradigm for understanding gene control by DNA looping where the lac repressor (LacI) protein competes with RNA polymerase for DNA binding. Not all promoter loops involve direct competition between repressor and RNA polymerase. This raises the possibility that positioning a promoter within a tightly constrained DNA loop is repressive per se, an idea that has previously only been considered in vitro. Here, we engineer living E. coli bacteria to measure repression due to promoter positioning within such a tightly constrained DNA loop in the absence of protein–protein binding competition. We show that promoters held within such DNA loops are repressed ∼100-fold, with up to an additional ∼10-fold repression (∼1000-fold total) dependent on topological positioning of the promoter on the inner or outer face of the DNA loop. Chromatin immunoprecipitation data suggest that repression involves inhibition of both RNA polymerase initiation and elongation. These in vivo results show that gene repression can result from tightly looping promoter DNA even in the absence of direct competition between repressor and RNA polymerase binding.

Mechanism of promoter repression by Lac repressor-DNA loops

The Escherichia coli lactose (lac) operon encodes the first genetic switch to be discovered, and lac remains a paradigm for studying negative and positive control of gene expression. Negative control is believed to involve competition of RNA polymerase and Lac repressor for overlapping binding sites. Contributions to the local Lac repressor concentration come from free repressor and repressor delivered to the operator from remote auxiliary operators by DNA looping. Long-standing questions persist concerning the actual role of DNA looping in the mechanism of promoter repression. Here, we use experiments in living bacteria to resolve four of these questions. We show that the distance dependence of repression enhancement is comparable for upstream and downstream auxiliary operators, confirming the hypothesis that repressor concentration increase is the principal mechanism of repression loops. We find that as few as four turns of DNA can be constrained in a stable loop by Lac repressor. We show that RNA polymerase is not trapped at repressed promoters. Finally, we show that constraining a promoter in a tight DNA loop is sufficient for repression even when promoter and operator do not overlap.

Operator sequence alters gene expression independently of transcription factor occupancy in bacteria

A canonical quantitative view of transcriptional regulation holds that the only role of operator sequence is to set the probability of transcription factor binding, with operator occupancy determining the level of gene expression. In this work, we test this idea by characterizing repression in vivo and the binding of RNA polymerase in vitro in experiments where operators of various sequences were placed either upstream or downstream from the promoter in Escherichia coli. Surprisingly, we find that operators with a weaker binding affinity can yield higher repression levels than stronger operators. Repressor bound to upstream operators modulates promoter escape, and the magnitude of this modulation is not correlated with the repressor-operator binding affinity. This suggests that operator sequences may modulate transcription by altering the nature of the interaction of the bound transcription factor with the transcriptional machinery, implying a new layer of sequence dependence that must be confronted in the quantitative understanding of gene expression.

Towards evolving a better repressor

Transcriptional regulation is an essential component of all metabolic pathways. At the most basic level, a protein binds to a particular DNA sequence (operator) on the genome and either positively or negatively alters the level of transcription. Together, the protein and its operator form an epigenetic switch that regulates gene expression. In an effort to produce a 'better' switch, we have discovered novel facets of the lac operon that are responsible for optimal functionality. We have uncovered a relationship between operator binding affinity and inducibility and demonstrated that the operator DNA is not a passive component of a genetic switch; it is responsible for establishing binding affinity, specificity as well as translational efficiency. In addition, an operator's directionality can indirectly affect gene expression. Unraveling the basic properties of this classical epigenetic switch demonstrates that multiple factors must be optimized in designing a better switch.

Interconvertible lac repressor-DNA loops revealed by single-molecule experiments

At many promoters, transcription is regulated by simultaneous binding of a protein to multiple sites on DNA, but the structures and dynamics of such transcription factor-mediated DNA loops are poorly understood. We directly examined in vitro loop formation mediated by Escherichia coli lactose repressor using single-molecule structural and kinetics methods. Small (∼150 bp) loops form quickly and stably, even with out-of-phase operator spacings. Unexpectedly, repeated spontaneous transitions between two distinct loop structures were observed in individual protein–DNA complexes. The results imply a dynamic equilibrium between a novel loop structure with the repressor in its crystallographic “V” conformation and a second structure with a more extended linear repressor conformation that substantially lessens the DNA bending strain. The ability to switch between different loop structures may help to explain how robust transcription regulation is maintained even though the mechanical work required to form a loop may change substantially with metabolic conditions.

Some proteins that regulate DNA transcription do so by binding simultaneously to two separated sites on the DNA molecule, forming a DNA loop. Although such loops are common, many of their features are poorly characterized. Of particular interest is the question of how some proteins accommodate the formation of loops of different sizes, particularly when the loops are small and thus require strong bending (and, in some cases, twisting) of the DNA to form. We observed the shape and behavior of individual DNA molecules bent into tight loops by Lac repressor, a transcription-regulating protein from the bacterium Escherichia coli. Loops were formed in DNA molecules with repressor-binding sites on opposite faces of the DNA double helix almost as readily as in those with sites on the same side, suggesting that the repressor is highly flexible. The DNA can switch back and forth between a tighter and a looser loop structure “on the fly” during the lifetime of a single loop, further evidence that Lac repressor is capable of adopting different shapes that may serve to minimize DNA bending or twisting in loops. The ability of the repressor to readily switch between different loop shapes may allow it to maintain effective control of transcription across situations in which the difficulty of bending or twisting DNA changes substantially.

A large-scale conformational change in a transcription factor protein allows DNA loops to dynamically switch between alternative conformations that may contribute to robust transcription regulation.

Functional consequences of exchanging domains between LacI and PurR are mediated by the intervening linker sequence

Homologue function can be differentiated by changing residues that affect binding sites or long-range interactions. LacI and PurR are two proteins that represent the LacI/GalR family (>500 members) of bacterial transcription regulators. All members have distinct DNA-binding and regulatory domains linked by approximately 18 amino acids. Each homologue has specificity for different DNA and regulatory effector ligands; LacI and PurR also exhibit differences in allosteric communication between DNA and effector binding sites. A comparative study of LacI and PurR suggested that alterations in the interface between the regulatory domain and linker are important for differentiating their functions. Four residues (equivalent to LacI positions 48, 55, 58, and 61) appear particularly important for creating a unique interface and were predicted to be necessary for allosteric regulation. However, nearby residues in the linker interact with DNA ligand. Thus, differences observed in interactions between linker and regulatory domain may be the cause of altered function or an effect of the two proteins binding different DNA ligands. To separate these possibilities, we created a chimeric protein with the LacI DNA-binding domain/linker and the PurR regulatory domain (LLhP). If the interface requires homologue-specific interactions in order to propagate the signal from effector binding, then LLhP repression should not be allosterically regulated by effector binding. Experiments show that LLhP is capable of repression from lacO1 and, contrary to expectation, allosteric response is intact. Further, restoring the potential for PurR-like interactions via substitutions in the LLhP linker tends to diminish repression. These effects are especially pronounced for residues 58 and 61. Clearly, binding affinity of LLhP for the lacO1 DNA site is sensitive to long-range changes in the linker. This result also raises the possibility that mutations at positions 58 and 61 co-evolved with changes in the DNA-binding site. In addition, repression measured in the absence and presence of effector ligand shows that allosteric response increases for several LLhP variants with substitutions at positions 48 and 55. Thus, while side chain variation at these sites does not generally dictate the presence or absence of allostery, the nature of the amino acid can modulate the response to effector.

Ligand-induced conformational changes and conformational dynamics in the solution structure of the lactose repressor protein

We present here the results of a series of small-angle X-ray scattering studies aimed at understanding the role of conformational changes and structural flexibility in DNA binding and allosteric signaling in a bacterial transcription regulator, lactose repressor protein (LacI). Experiments were designed to detect possible conformational changes that occur when LacI binds either DNA or the inducer IPTG, or both. Our studies included the native LacI dimer of homodimers and a dimeric variant (R3), enabling us to probe conformational changes within the homodimers and distinguish them from those involving changes in the homodimer-homodimer relationships. The scattering data indicate that removal of operator DNA (oDNA) from R3 results in an unfolding and extension of the hinge helix that connects the LacI regulatory and DNA-binding domains. In contrast, only very subtle conformational changes occur in the R3 dimer-oDNA complex upon IPTG binding, indicative of small adjustments in the orientations of domains and/or subdomains within the structure. The binding of IPTG to native (tetrameric) LacI-oDNA complexes also appears to facilitate a modest change in the average homodimer-homodimer disposition. Notably, the crystal structure of the native LacI-oDNA complex differs significantly from the average solution conformation. The solution scattering data are best fit by an ensemble of structures that includes (1) approximately 60% of the V-shaped dimer of homodimers observed in the crystal structure and (2) approximately 40% of molecules with more "open" forms, such as those generated when the homodimers move with respect to each other about the tetramerization domain. In gene regulation, such a flexible LacI would be beneficial for the interaction of its two DNA-binding domains, positioned at the tips of the V, with the required two of three LacI operators needed for full repression.

Adaptation of a luciferase gene reporter and lac expression system to Borrelia burgdorferi

The development of new genetic systems for studying the complex regulatory events that occur within Borrelia burgdorferi is an important goal of contemporary Lyme disease research. Although recent advancements have been made in the genetic manipulation of B. burgdorferi, there still remains a paucity of basic molecular systems for assessing differential gene expression in this pathogen. Herein, we describe the adaptation of two powerful genetic tools for use in B. burgdorferi. The first is a Photinus pyralis firefly luciferase gene reporter that was codon optimized to enhance translation in B. burgdorferi. Using this modified reporter, we demonstrated an increase in luciferase expression when B. burgdorferi transformed with a shuttle vector encoding the outer surface protein C (OspC) promoter fused to the luciferase reporter was cultivated in the presence of fresh rabbit blood. The second is a lac operator/repressor system that was optimized to achieve the tightest degree of regulation. Using the aforementioned luciferase reporter, we assessed the kinetics and maximal level of isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG)-dependent gene expression. This lac-inducible expression system also was used to express the gene carried on lp25 required for borrelial persistence in ticks (bptA). These advancements should be generally applicable for assessing further the regulation of other genes potentially involved in virulence expression by B. burgdorferi.

LeuO protein delimits the transcriptionally active and repressive domains on the bacterial chromosome

LeuO protein relieves bacterial gene silencer AT8-mediated transcriptional repression as part of a promoter relay mechanism found in the ilvIH-leuO-leuABCD gene cluster. The gene silencing activity has recently been characterized as a nucleoprotein filament initiated at the gene silencer. In this gene locus, the nucleoprotein filament cis-spreads toward the target leuO promoter and results in the repression of the leuO gene. Although the cis-spreading nature of the transcriptionally repressive nucleoprotein filament has been revealed, the mechanism underlying LeuO-mediated gene silencing relief remains unknown. We have demonstrated here that LeuO functions analogously to the eukaryotic boundary element that delimits the transcriptionally active and repressive domains on the chromosome by blocking the cis-spreading pathway of the transcriptionally repressive heterochromatin. Given that one LeuO-binding site is positioned between the gene silencer and the target promoter, the simultaneous presence of a second LeuO-binding site synergistically enhances the blockade, resulting in a cooperative increase in LeuO-mediated gene silencing relief. A known DNA loop-forming protein, the lac repressor (LacI), was used to confirm that cooperative protein binding via DNA looping is responsible for the blocking synergy. Indeed, a distal LeuO site located downstream cooperates with the LeuO sites located upstream of the leuO gene, resulting in synergistic relief for the repressed leuO gene via looping out the intervening DNA between LeuO sites in the ilvIH-leuO-leuABCD gene cluster.

Adjacent cooperation of proteins on DNA are not representative of long-distance interactions

The cI repressor of bacteriophage lambda is better-fitted to the proximal interactions in which it naturally takes part than to the long-distance cooperative interactions on DNA for which it has become representative. The first observation in support of this statement is the ambiguity of an untypical DNAase I footprint which has become a diagnostic for DNA circularisation (and thus for the capacity of the protein to control expression at a distance). However, it was also observed without effective DNA looping when lac repressor binds to nearly contiguous sites. Additionally, the surface of interaction between the two dimers seems to be more important than the one commonly admitted (via some contacts between the flexible arms), the biological function of the repressor is lost when the sites are separated and loops have not been observed for large separation of the sites. In fact, naturally distant interactions can conform to shorter distances, as an intrinsic property of DNA looping. On the contrary, interactions which are naturally optimised for contiguity are generally constrained to proximity. Alternative protein-protein contacts are generally responsible for this situation (cf. CRP versus NRI in Escherichia coli).

In vivo identification of intermediate stages of the DNA inversion reaction catalyzed by the Salmonella Hin recombinase

The Hin recombinase catalyzes a site-specific recombination reaction that results in the reversible inversion of a 1-kbp segment of the Salmonella chromosome. The DNA inversion reaction catalyzed by the Salmonella Hin recombinase is a dynamic process proceeding through many intermediate stages, requiring multiple DNA sites and the Fis accessory protein. Biochemical analysis of this reaction has identified intermediate steps in the inversion reaction but has not yet revealed the process by which transition from one step to another occurs. Because transition from one reaction step to another proceeds through interactions between specific amino acids, and between amino acids and DNA bases, it is possible to study these transitions through mutational analysis of the proteins involved. We isolated a large number of mutants in the Hin recombinase that failed to carry out the DNA exchange reaction. We generated genetic tools that allowed the assignment of these mutants to specific transition steps in the recombination reaction. This genetic analysis, combined with further biochemical analysis, allowed us to define contributions by specific amino acids to individual steps in the DNA inversion reaction. Evidence is also presented in support of a model that Fis protein enhances the binding of Hin to the hixR recombination site. These studies identified regions within the Hin recombinase involved in specific transition steps of the reaction and provided new insights into the molecular details of the reaction mechanism.

A positive selection vector for cloning of long polymerase chain reaction fragments based on a lethal mutant of the crp gene of Escherichia coli

We have constructed a cloning vector with a tight positive selection for recombinant clones in Escherichia coli. The positive selection pressure results from a lethal mutation within the E. coli gene coding for the catabolite gene activator protein CAP, which is disrupted whenever a fragment is successfully inserted. Here, we show that this "suicide" vector, pCAPs, is suitable for cloning of PCR products as long as 9.3 kb into several unique restriction sites which are scattered throughout the lethal gene.

Lactose repressor protein: functional properties and structure

The lactose repressor protein (LacI), the prototype for genetic regulatory proteins, controls expression of lactose metabolic genes by binding to its cognate operator sequences in E. coli DNA. Inducer binding elicits a conformational change that diminishes affinity for operator sequences with no effect on nonspecific binding. The release of operator is followed by synthesis of mRNA encoding the enzymes for lactose utilization. Genetic, chemical and physical studies provided detailed insight into the function of this protein prior to the recent completion of X-ray crystallographic structures. The structural information can now be correlated with the phenotypic data for numerous mutants. These structures also provide the opportunity for physical and chemical studies on mutants designed to examine various aspects of lac repressor structure and function. In addition to providing insight into protein structure-function correlations, LacI has been utilized in a wide variety of applications both in prokaryotic gene expression and in eukaryotic gene regulation and studies of mutagenesis.

Molecular dynamics simulations of small DNA plasmids: effects of sequence and supercoiling on intramolecular motions

Small (600 base pair) DNA plasmids were modeled with a simplified representation (3DNA) and the intramolecular motions were studied using molecular mechanics and molecular dynamics techniques. The model is detailed enough to incorporate sequence effects. At the same time, it is simple enough to allow long molecular dynamics simulations. The simulations revealed that large-scale slithering occurs in a homogeneous sequence. In a heterogeneous sequence, containing numerous small intrinsic curves, the centers of the curves are preferentially positioned at the tips of loops. With more curves than loop tips (two in unbranched supercoiled DNA), the heterogeneous sequence plasmid slithers short distances to reposition other curves into the loop tips. However, the DNA is immobilized most of the time, with the loop tips positioned over a few favored curve centers. Branching or looping also appears in the heterogeneous sequence as a new method of repositioning the loop tips. Instead of a smooth progression of increasing writhing with increasing linking difference, theoretical studies have predicted that there is a threshold between unwrithed and writhed DNA at a linking difference between one and two. This has previously been observed in simulations of static structures and is demonstrated here for dynamic homogeneous closed DNA. Such an abrupt transition is not found in the heterogeneous sequence in both the static and dynamic cases.

Parameters affecting the use of the lac repressor system in eukaryotic cells and transgenic animals

Elements of the lactose operon were used to study parameters affecting gene expression in cultured cells and transgenic animals. A Lac repressor protein containing a nuclear transport signal was shown to inhibit expression of a reporter gene by interacting with lac operator sequences. In cultured cells, operator sequence, operator placement and induction parameters were all shown to be important for obtaining tight repression of a reporter gene followed by high level expression upon induction. Induction levels were also dependent on the reporter gene, with the luciferase gene yielding higher induction levels than the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene. In transgenic animals, the lacI mRNA was not detected in the C57BL/6 mouse strain until the animal was exposed to a demethylating agent. After 5-azacytidine treatment, expression of lacI mRNA was detected in the brain, heart, kidney, lung and ovary. In the FVB transgenic mouse strain, expression of lacI mRNA was detected without 5-azacytidine treatment in the kidney, liver, lung, and testes. Preliminary experiments with double transgenic animals containing both lacI and operator/luciferase transgenes showed a decrease in luciferase expression compared to the luciferase-only animals in both tissue extracts and transgenic fetal primary cultures, although IPTG induction was not achieved in these animals or primary cultures. The applicability and challenges of the system for regulation of gene expression are discussed.

Stringent regulation of human growth hormone expression in cultured murine C2C12 myoblasts by the E. coli lac repressor

Gene transfer techniques can be used to encode the production of a polypeptide product, such as human growth hormone (hGH), that is missing in an acquired or inherited disease state such as growth hormone deficiency. In one model system, engineered C2C12 myoblasts are injected intramuscularly into a mouse and subsequently secrete hGH into the circulation. In this regard, a gene-expression regulatory system that functions in myoblasts would be of interest. We demonstrate that the Escherichia coli ldc operon system can be used to stringently regulate the expression of hGH in engineered C2C12 myoblasts in tissue culture. A DNA segment encoding hGH was linked to a DNA segment containing an SV40 enhancer and promoter. The latter components were positioned between two synthetic lac operators. Lac repressor expression was driven by a simian cytomegalovirus promoter. In transient co-transfection assays, hGH expression from cultured C2C12 myoblasts could be modulated up to 60-fold (P = 0.002) with the inducing agent, isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactoside (IPTG). In the absence of IPTG, hGH expression was almost fully repressed. These results show that the components of the E. coli lac operon provide a stringent regulatory system for use in myoblasts. The system might prove to be useful for the regulation of transferred genes in animals.

The expression of the penicillin G amidase gene of Escherichia coli by primer extension analysis

Escherichia coli ATCC 11105 and JM109, transformed with a multicopy plasmid carrying the penicillin G amidase (PGA) gene, were grown at 26 degrees and 37 degrees C, in the presence or the absence of phenylacetic acid (PAA) or of glucose. A method based on primer extension was developed to quantify in vivo levels of PGA mRNAs. A unique transcription start site was found to be used in all the fermentation conditions tested. This site is located 28 nucleotides upstream of the initiation codon. Its utilization is subjected to catabolic repression and is induced by PAA. This site is used at 37 degrees C, but the PGA mRNA level in E. coli ATCC 11105 is lower at 37 degrees C than at 26 degrees C. Induction of the pga gene by PAA was found to be more efficient in the producer strain. Taking into account the amount of PGA mRNA present in the cells at 37 degrees C, one would expect the production of active PGA at this temperature. This is not the case. Thus, at 37 degrees C, expression is blocked at a step after transcription.

A linguistic representation of the regulation of transcription initiation. I. An ordered array of complex symbols with distinctive features

The inadequacy of context-free grammars in the description of regulatory information contained in DNA gave the formal justification for a linguistic approach to the study of gene regulation. Based on that result, we have initiated a linguistic formalization of the regulatory arrays of 107 sigma 70 E. coli promoters. The complete sequences of promoter (Pr), operator (Op) and activator binding sites (I) have previously been identified as the smallest elements, or categories, for a combinatorial analysis of the range of transcription initiation of sigma 70 promoters. These categories are conceptually equivalent to phonemes of natural language. Several features associated with these categories are required in a complete description of regulatory arrays of promoters. We have to select the best way to describe the properties that are pertinent for the description of such regulatory regions. In this paper we define distinctive features of regulatory regions based on the following criteria: identification of subclasses of substitutable elements, simplicity, selection of the most directly related information, and distinction of one array among the whole set of promoters. Alternative ways to represent distances in between regulatory sites are discussed, permitting, together with a principle of precedence, the identification of an ordered set of complex symbols as a unique representation for a promoter and its associated regulatory sites. In the accompanying paper additional distinctive features of promoters and regulatory sites are identified.

Interlocking of plasmid DNAs due to Lac repressor-operator interaction

The presence of a single lac repressor binding sequence on plasmid DNAs is shown to mediate the formation of interlocked dimers in E. coli. The presence of both homo- and hetero-interlocked dimers suggests that the lac repressor complex can bring together randomly two plasmid DNA molecules to facilitate gyrase-mediated interlocking. The exclusive formation of multiply intertwined dimers also suggest that the lac repressor complex may bind simultaneously to a pair of replicated daughter plasmid molecules prior to their segregation. The formation of interlocked plasmid DNAs can be indicative of interaction between two DNA bound proteins in vivo.

How Lac repressor finds lac operator in vitro

Filter-binding and gel mobility shift assays were used to analyse the kinetics of the interaction of Lac repressor with lac operator. A comparison of the two techniques reveals that filter-binding assays with tetrameric Lac repressor have often been misinterpreted. It has been assumed that all complexes of Lac repressor and lac operator DNA bind with equal affinity to nitrocellulose filters. This assumption is wrong. Sandwich or loop complexes where two lac operators bind to one tetrameric Lac repressor are not or are only badly retained on nitrocellulose filters under normal conditions. Taking this into account, dimeric and tetrameric Lac repressor do not show any DNA-length dependence of their association and dissociation rate constants when they bind to DNA fragments smaller than 2455 base-pairs carrying a single symmetric ideal lac operator. A ninefold increased association rate to ideal lac operator on lambda DNA is observed for tetrameric but not dimeric Lac repressor. It is presumably due to intersegment transfer involving lac operator-like sequences.

Effect of lac repressor oligomerization on regulatory outcome

Regulatory outcome in a bacterial operon depends on the interactions of all the components which influence mRNA production. Levels of mRNA can be altered profoundly by both negative and positive regulatory elements which modulate initiation of transcription. The occupancy of regulatory sites on the DNA by repressors and activators is determined not only by the affinity of these proteins for their cognate site(s) but also by the oligomeric state of the regulatory protein. The lac operon in Escherichia coli provides an excellent prototypic example of the influence of protein assembly on the transcriptional status of the associated structural genes. DNA loop formation is essential for maximal repression of the lac operon and is contingent upon the presence of multiple operator sites in the DNA and the ability of the repressor to self-associate to form a bidentate tetramer. The stability of this looped complex is enhanced significantly by DNA supercoiling. Tetramer assembly from dimers apparently occurs via interactions of a 'leucine zipper' motif in the C-terminal domain of the protein, and the tetramer is essential to formation of looped complexes. Furthermore, analysis of the DNA-binding characteristics of dimeric mutants has established that the monomer-dimer association and dimer-DNA binding (monomer does not bind to DNA) are coupled equilibria. Thus, dimer assembly is essential for generating a DNA-binding unit, and tetramer assembly is required for formation of the stable looped DNA structure that maximally represses mRNA synthesis. Protein-protein interactions therefore play a pivotal role in the regulatory activities of the lac repressor and must be considered when analysing the activities of any oligomeric DNA-binding protein.

The remote control of transcription, DNA looping and DNA compaction

mRNA synthesis can be controlled at some distance from the start of transcription in eukaryotes and prokaryotes. It is generally assumed that the distal elements of the transcriptional machinery directly interact with the proximal elements, forcing the DNA to bend in a loop. DNA loop formation and transcription can be affected by the distance between the sites, their helical positioning, their orientation, their concentration (responsible for a cis- or a trans-effect of the DNA sequences), and DNA compaction in chromatin. The corresponding in vitro and in vivo situations have been critically examined for a number of systems, mostly prokaryotic.

DNA looping alters local DNA conformation during transcription

The effect of protein-mediated DNA looping on local DNA conformation during active transcription was studied using the lac repressor-operator system. Our results suggest that lac repressor-mediated DNA looping within a plasmid DNA molecule containing two lac repressor binding sequences in vivo effectively separates plasmid DNA into two topological domains. Supercoils generated by transcription within each topological domain can be rapidly removed by DNA topoisomerase I.

Analysis of the gel electrophoresis of looped protein-DNA complexes by computer simulation

The theory of mass transport coupled to reversible interactions under chemical kinetic control forms the basis of a numerical model that has been applied to systems such as lac repressor-lac operator DNA, in which a protein binds in two different modes to linear DNA carrying two specific binding sites. Three complexes may be formed: (1) a linear 1:1 complex with one protein molecule bound to one site on the DNA molecule; (2) a 1:1 complex in which a single protein molecule is bound to both sites simultaneously, thereby inducing a large DNA loop; and (3) a 2:1 linear complex in which two protein molecules are bound in tandem, each occupying a single site. The computational model affords a quantitative numerical simulation of the observed gel electrophoretic patterns produced by titration of the DNA with protein and provides new insights into the shape and nature of the patterns. In particular, the patterns may represent unimodal or bimodal reaction zones. Nevertheless, analysis of the peaks in the patterns obtained at low DNA and high protein concentration provides essential information as to the stoichiometry of the complexes and satisfactory estimates of association constants. The theory thus provides the experimenter with guidelines for quantitative evaluation of the results of gel retardation assays of the particular system under investigation, once protein-induced DNA (or RNA) loops have been established by independent physical or chemical methods. It is suggested that these insights might also find application to systems involving the binding of two or three different proteins to DNA with loop formation.

DNA looping and unlooping by AraC protein

Expression of the L-arabinose BAD operon in Escherichia coli is regulated by AraC protein which acts both positively in the presence of arabinose to induce transcription and negatively in the absence of arabinose to repress transcription. The repression of the araBAD promoter is mediated by DNA looping between AraC protein bound at two sites near the promoter separated by 210 base pairs, araI and araO2. In vivo and in vitro experiments presented here show that an AraC dimer, with binding to half of araI and to araO2, maintains the repressed state of the operon. The addition of arabinose, which induces the operon, breaks the loop, and shifts the interactions from the distal araO2 site to the previously unoccupied half of the araI site. The conversion between the two states does not require additional binding of AraC protein and appears to be driven largely by properties of the protein rather than being specified by the slightly different DNA sequences of the binding sites. Slight reorientation of the subunits of AraC could specify looping or unlooping by the protein. Such a mechanism could account for regulation of DNA looping in other systems.

Structural studies of protein-nucleic acid interaction: the sources of sequence-specific binding

Structural studies of DNA-binding proteins and their complexes with DNA have proceeded at an accelerating pace in recent years due to important technical advances in molecular genetics, DNA synthesis, protein crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance. The last major review on this subject by Pabo & Sauer (1984) summarized the structural and functional studies of the three sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins whose crystal structures were then known, theE. colicatabolite gene activator protein (CAP) (McKay & Steitz, 1981; McKayet al.1982; Weber & Steitz, 1987), acrorepressor from phage λ (Andersonet al.1981), and the DNA-binding proteolytic fragment ofλcIrepressor protein (Pabo & Lewis, 1982) Although crystallographic studies of theE. coli lacrepressor protein were initiated as early as 1971 when it was the only regulatory protein available in sufficient quantities for structural studies (Steitzet al.1974), little was established about the structural aspects of DNA-binding proteins until the structure of CAP was determined in 1980 followed shortly thereafter by the structure ofλcrorepressor and subsequently that of the λ repressor fragment. There are now determined at high resolution the crystal structures of seven prokaryotic gene regulatory proteins or fragments [CAP,λcro,λcIrepressor fragment, 434 repressor fragment (Andersonet al.1987), 434crorepressor (Wolbergeret al.1988),E. coli trprepressor (Schevitzet al.1985),E. coli metrepressor (Raffertyet al.1989)],EcoRI restriction endonuclease (McClarinet al.1986), DNAse I (Suck & Ofner, 1986), the catalytic domain of γδ resolvase (Hatfullet al.1989) and two sequence-independent double-stranded DNA-binding proteins [the Klenow fragment ofE. coliDNA polymerase I (Olliset al.1985) and theE. coliHu protein (Tanakaet al., 1984)].

Synergistic activation of transcription by multiple binding sites for NF-kappa B even in absence of co-operative factor binding to DNA

Regulation of eukaryotic genes is largely governed by multiple cis-acting DNA sequences recognized by specific transcription factors. The transcription factor NF-kappa B has been implicated as an important regulator of cellular and viral genes, including those of immunoglobulin kappa light chain, interleukin-2, beta-interferon, HIV-1 and cytomegalovirus. We have analyzed the effect of increasing the number of NF-kappa B sites, located directly upstream from the TATA box. Four copies of the sequence gave a more than 100-fold stimulation relative to a single copy, suggesting that NF-kappa B proteins act synergistically to bring about this dramatic increase in transcription. By DNase I footprinting we demonstrated factor binding to two adjacent NF-kappa B sites in vitro. However, we found no evidence for co-operative binding to these DNA sites. We propose that the high transcriptional activity results from another type of co-operation, based on multiple weak interactions of the NF-kappa B factors with another component of the transcription apparatus, perhaps RNA polymerase II itself.

Structure of plectonemically supercoiled DNA

Using electron microscopy and topological methods, we have deduced an average structure for negatively supercoiled circular DNA in solution. Our data suggest that DNA has a branched plectonemic (interwound) form over the range of supercoiling tested. The length of the superhelix axis is constant at 41% of the DNA length, whereas the superhelix radius decreases essentially hyperbolically as supercoiling increases. The number of supercoils is 89% of the linking deficit. Both writhe and twist change with supercoiling, but the ratio of the change in writhe to the change in twist is fixed at 2.6:1. The extent of branching of the superhelix axis is proportional to the length of the plasmid, but is insensitive to superhelix density. The relationship between DNA flexibility constants for twisting and bending calculated using our structural data is similar to that deduced from previous studies. The extended thin form of plectonemically supercoiled DNA offers little compaction for cellular packaging, but promotes interaction between cis-acting sequence elements that may be distant in primary structure. We discuss additional biological implications of our structural data.

lac repressor forms stable loops in vitro with supercoiled wild-type lac DNA containing all three natural lac operators

We have analyzed protein-DNA complexes formed between lac repressor and linear or differently supercoiled lac DNA (802 or 816 base-pairs in length), which carry all three natural lac operators (O1, O2 and O3) in their wild-type sequence context and spacing and compared them with constructs that contain specifically mutated "pseudo-operators" O2 or O3. We used gel retardation assays to identify the nature of the complexes according to their characteristic electrophoretic mobility and dissociation rate measurements to determine their stability. With linear DNA we found only indirect evidence for loop formation between O1 and O2. In covalently closed DNA minicircles the formation of a loop between O1 and O2 could be demonstrated by the observation that O1-O2 containing DNA with low negative supercoiling (sigma = -0.013 and less) is constricted by binding of lac repressor, resulting in an increased electrophoretic mobility. At elevated negative supercoiling (sigma = -0.025, -0.037, -0.05) O1-O2 containing DNA complexed with lac repressor migrates significantly slower than the corresponding O1-DNA, indicating loop formation. The dissociation of lac repressor-operator complexes is decreased with increasing negative supercoiling for all tested operator combinations of O1, O2 and O3. However, in the presence of at least two natural lac operators on the same DNA minicircle the enhancement of stability is particularly large. This indicates that a DNA loop is formed between these two lac operators, O1 and O2 as well as O1 and O3, since negative supercoiling is known specifically to promote the formation of looped structures. Additionally, we observe a dependence of dissociation rate on the spatial alignment of the operators as a result of changing helical periodicity in differently supercoiled DNA and consider this to be further evidence for loop formation between O1 and O2 as well as O1 and O3.

Parasite antigens expressed in Escherichia coli. A refined approach for epidemiological analysis

A simple method is described to generate carrier-free recombinant antigens following their expression in Escherichia coli. A plasmid, called pMSgt11, has been constructed such that the cleavage site for the protease factor Xa separates the recombinant antigen from an enzymatically active beta-galactosidase. Thus, rapid purification of the active beta-galactosidase recombinant protein, followed by digestion with factor Xa, releases the antigen of interest. The pMSgt11 plasmid is compatible with the phage expression vector, lambda gt11 and the feasibility of applying this system has been demonstrated using malarial recombinant antigens. Inserts from lambda gt11 recombinant Plasmodium falciparum clones have been recloned into the EcoRI site of pMSgt11 and the expressed soluble fusion proteins have been purified from crude extracts using a one step affinity chromatography. After protease digestion, the fusion protein cleavage products were analysed by immunoblot with a panel of different human immune sera. We were able to successfully demonstrate specific antibody titers to the parasite-derived carrier-free antigen, without interference from anti-Escherichia coli-specific antibodies. The general application of this approach to epidemiological analysis is discussed.

Association kinetics of site-specific protein-DNA interactions: roles of nonspecific DNA sites and of the molecular location of the specific site

We have applied the formalism developed previously for the kinetics of domain-localized reactions [S. Mazur and M. T. Record, Jr. (1986) Biopolymers 25, 985-1008] to describe complex mechanisms of association of a protein with a specific site on a large DNA molecule also containing many nonspecific binding sites. These nonspecific sites participate in the mechanism of formation of the specific complex through competitive binding and the facilitating mechanisms of sliding and transfer. The effects of localizing the sites in a domain are represented by a simple algebraic expression, and the sequence of interactions within the domain are described by equations closely related to a conventional, homogeneous solution mechanism. We apply this formalism to examine the interplay between sliding and direct transfer in domain-localized interactions in general and in the lac repressor-lac operator interaction in particular. Experimental investigation of the effect of the molecular location of the specific site (e.g., end vs middle of the polymer chain) on the kinetics of association may allow the contributions of sliding and direct transfer to be resolved.

Position and density effects on repression by stationary and mobile DNA-binding proteins

We have investigated the effects of two types of DNA-binding proteins on bacterial repression. First, the effects of operator positioning on repression by stationary DNA-binding proteins, the Lac repressor and the Trp repressor, were examined in vivo. Both operator number and positioning play a role in determining in vivo levels of repression. Operators located within a promoter are more efficient regulators than those positioned at the start of transcription. Second, we investigated the effects of DNA-binding protein density on repression using a mobile DNA-binding protein, Escherichia coli RNA polymerase. We employed a transcriptional interference assay using convergent transcriptional units. The strong synthetic promoter conI and its derivatives were observed to interfere with expression of the aadA gene, which confers spectinomycin resistance upon its host. Transcriptional interference by RNA polymerase occurred only in cis and had a strong dependence on polymerase density that was modulated by varying the promoter strengths. A change in the density of approximately fourfold completely abolished the observed transcriptional interference. Several models are discussed to explain the repression patterns observed for stationary and mobile DNA-binding proteins.

Molecular interactions in the control region of the carAB operon encoding Escherichia coli carbamoylphosphate synthetase

The control region of the carAB operon, encoding carbamoylphosphate synthetase, comprises two tandem promoters (P1, upstream and P2, downstream) located 67 base-pairs apart and repressed respectively by pyrimidines and arginine. RNA polymerase and pure arginine repressor bind to the P2 region in mutually exclusive ways. Repressor protects the two adjacent palindromic ARG boxes overlapping P2 against DNase I. Binding of RNA polymerase to P1 is abnormal; the region protected against DNase I is shifted upstream by about 20 nucleotides with respect to the position expected from the transcription startpoint. This pattern is not due to interference with polymerase binding at P2, since it is observed also in the presence of repressor and on an isolated P1 region. Binding of RNA polymerase is relatively weak and heparin-sensitive suggesting that, in vivo, an ancillary factor is required to promote the formation of an open complex. S1 nuclease mapping experiments show that the simultaneous presence of pyrimidines and arginine represses the downstream arginine-specific promoter (P2) more efficiently than arginine alone. This effect is not due to a direct regulatory interaction between pyrimidines and P2, since it is not observed when P1 is inactivated by insertion mutations or partial deletion. It has been shown that transcription initiated at P1 can proceed even when arginine represses P2. We therefore suggest that P2 operator-arginine repressor complex is destabilized by RNA polymerase binding at P1 or transcription from P1. We describe a novel technique to select for expression-down mutants in a lac fusion context.

Insertion of d(pCpG)n.d(pCpG)n into the lacZ gene of Escherichia coli inhibits expression of beta-galactosidase in vivo

Plasmids that contain a d(pCpG)13.d(pCpG)13 insert instead of a lac operator show a 34-fold decrease of beta-galactosidase synthesis. The same sequence causes a 24-fold decrease when inserted between codons 5 and 6 of the lacZ gene. In such constructs with d(pCpG)n.d(pCpG)n inserts, beta-galactosidase activity decreases approximately 1.6-fold per d(pCpG).d(pCpG) unit when n ranges from 5 to 16.

Probing co-operative DNA-binding in vivo. The lac O1:O3 interaction

The lac primary (O1) and weak upstream pseudo (O3) operators contained on a plasmid were footprinted in vivo in order to determine whether they act co-operatively in binding lac repressor in the cell. The occupancy at O3 by lac repressor was substantially reduced upon deletion of the lac primary operator, demonstrating co-operativity at a distance. Plots of operator occupancy versus active repressor concentration were obtained for each operator by treating the cells with different amounts of the lac inducer isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactoside and probing lac repressor binding. This analysis can be used to obtain relative binding constants in vivo and demonstrates that O3 binds repressor only 10.3-fold less tightly than O1 in their co-operative interaction. The removal of DNA torsional tension in vivo by the use of coumermycin leads to the same loss of binding at O3 as does deleting O1. These in-vivo results are analogous to the in-vitro situation, where O3 binds repressor strongly in a DNA repression loop only on supercoiled templates.

The inducible lac operator-repressor system is functional for control of expression of injected DNA in Xenopus oocytes

We have investigated the use of the Escherichia coli lac operator-repressor system to regulate the expression of genes introduced by microinjection into Xenopus laevis oocytes. We observe that expression of an MSV-cat fusion gene, in which the lac operator was inserted between the TATA box and the transcription start point (tsp), or between the tsp and the start codon (ATG), is completely repressed when the lac repressor protein is added to the plasmid suspension prior to injection. The lac repressor had no detectable effect on the expression of a coinjected HSV-1 tk gene that had no operator insertion (or on an MSV-cat gene without an operator), indicating that the nonspecific DNA-binding properties of the repressor do not inhibit transcription. CAT activity expressed from the operator-containing MSV-cat genes transcribed in the oocyte nucleus was also inhibited by repressor injected into the oocyte cytoplasm, showing that biologically active repressor proteins can enter the nucleus from the cytoplasm. Injection of the inducer IPTG into the oocyte cytoplasm markedly derepressed the repressed cat genes but not the HSV-1 tk gene coinjected as an internal control. Overall, our results show that the lac operator-repressor system can be useful as a genetic switch in the regulation of gene expression of injected DNA in frog oocytes. Finally, our observations on the vectors used in this work show that the MSV enhancer significantly activates transcription from the SV40 early promoter in frog oocytes, although previous studies have indicated that the MSV enhancer is not necessary for the activity of the MSV promoter in oocytes [Graves et al., Mol. Cell. Biol. 5 (1985) 1945-1958].

Transcription elements and factors of RNA polymerase B promoters of higher eukaryotes

The promoter for eukaryotic genes transcribed by RNA polymerase B can be divided into the TATA box (located at -30) and startsite (+1), the upstream element (situated between -40 and about -110), and the enhancer (no fixed position relative to the startsite). Trans-acting factors, which bind to these elements, have been identified and at least partially purified. The role of the TATA box is to bind factors which focus the transcription machinery to initiate at the startsite. The upstream element and the enhancer somehow modulate this interaction, possibly through direct protein-protein interactions. Another class of transcription factors, typified by viral proteins such as the adenovirus EIA products, do not appear to require binding to a particular DNA sequence to regulate transcription. The latest findings in these various subjects are discussed.

Positional requirements for the function of nif-specific upstream activator sequences

The upstream activator sequence (UAS) found in Klebsiella pneumoniae nif promoters and required for the activation of transcription by nifA, is absent from the nifF-nifL intergenic region, but is present downstream from the nifLA transcription start at +59. To determine whether nif upstream activator sequences can function in a 3' position, the nifH UAS was cloned downstream from the NifH transcription start, but no activation of transcription by nifA dependent upon the UAS in its 3' location could be detected. A mild repressive effect was detectable when the nifH UAS was placed downstream of the nifH promoter, but not when the cat promoter was substituted for the nifLA promoter upstream from the motif at +59 described above. However, deletion analysis showed that the UAS motif located downstream of the nifLA promoter has a role in transcription from the nifF promoter, although it is situated at position -263 with respect to the nifF transcription start, about 100 bp further upstream than previously described occurrences of the activator sequence.