Rationally designed helix-turn-helix proteins and their conformational changes upon DNA binding

Continuous evolution of compact protein degradation tags regulated by selective molecular glues

Conditional protein degradation tags (degrons) are usually >100 amino acids long or are triggered by small molecules with substantial off-target effects, thwarting their use as specific modulators of endogenous protein levels. We developed a phage-assisted continuous evolution platform for molecular glue complexes (MG-PACE) and evolved a 36-amino acid zinc finger (ZF) degron (SD40) that binds the ubiquitin ligase substrate receptor cereblon in complex with PT-179, an orthogonal thalidomide derivative. Endogenous proteins tagged in-frame with SD40 using prime editing are degraded by otherwise inert PT-179. Cryo-electron microscopy structures of SD40 in complex with ligand-bound cereblon revealed mechanistic insights into the molecular basis of SD40's activity and specificity. Our efforts establish a system for continuous evolution of molecular glue complexes and provide ZF tags that overcome shortcomings associated with existing degrons.

Designing synthetic transcription factors: A structural perspective

In this chapter, we discuss different design strategies of synthetic proteins, especially synthetic transcription factors. Design and engineering of synthetic transcription factors is particularly relevant for the need-based manipulation of gene expression. With recent advances in structural biology techniques and with the emergence of other precision biochemical/physical tools, accurate knowledge on structure-function relations is increasingly becoming available. Besides discussing the underlying principles of design, we go through individual cases, especially those involving four major groups of transcription factors-basic leucine zippers, zinc fingers, helix-turn-helix and homeodomains. We further discuss how synthetic biology can come together with structural biology to alter the genetic blueprint of life.

Engineering proteins that bind, move, make and break DNA

Recent protein engineering efforts have generated artificial transcription factors that bind new target DNA sequences and enzymes that modify DNA at new target sites. Zinc-finger-based transcription factors are favored targets for design; important technological advances in their construction and numerous biotechnological applications have been reported. Other notable advances include the generation of endonucleases and recombinases with altered specificities, made by innovative combinatorial and evolutionary protein engineering strategies. An unexpectedly high tolerance to mutation in the active sites of DNA polymerases is being exploited to engineer polymerases to incorporate artificial nucleotides or to display other, nonnatural activities.

The affinity-enhancing roles of flexible linkers in two-domain DNA-binding proteins

Recently many attempts have been made to design high-affinity DNA-binding proteins by linking two domains. Here a theory for guiding these designs is presented. Flexible linkers may play three types of roles: (a) linking domains which by themselves are unfolded and bind to DNA only as a folded dimer (as in a designed single-chain Arc repressor), (b) connecting domains which can separately bind to DNA (as in the Oct-1 POU domain), and (c) linking a DNA-binding domain with a dimerization domain (as in the lambda repressor). In (a), the linker keeps the protein as a folded dimer so that it is always DNA-binding-competent. In (b), the linker is predicted to enhance DNA-binding affinity over those of the individual domains (with dissociation constants K(A) and K(B)) by p(d(0))/K(B) or p(d(0))/K(A), where p(d(0)) = (3/4pil(p)bL)(3/2) exp(-3d(0)(2)/4l(p)bL)(1 - 5l(p)/4bL +...) is the probability density for the end-to-end vector of the linker with L residues to have a distance d(0). In (c), the linker is predicted to enhance the binding affinity by K(d)(C)/p(d(0)), where K(d)(C) is the dimer dissociation constant for the dimerization domain. The predicted affinity enhancements are found to be actually reached by the Oct-1 POU domain and lambda repressor. However, there is room for improvement in many of the recently designed proteins. The theoretical limits presented should provide a useful guide for current efforts of designing DNA-binding proteins.

Selection and design of high affinity DNA ligands for mutant single-chain derivatives of the bacteriophage 434 repressor

Single-chain repressor RR(Tres) is a derivative of bacteriophage 434 repressor, which contains covalently dimerized DNA-binding domains (amino acids 1-69) of the phage 434 repressor. In this single-chain molecule, the wild type domain R is connected to the mutant domain R(TRES) by a recombinant linker in a head-to-tail arrangement. The DNA-contacting amino acids of R(TRES) at the -1, 1, 2, and 5 positions of the a3 helix are T, R, E, S respectively. By using a randomized DNA pool containing the central sequence -CATACAAGAAAGNNNNNNTTT-, a cyclic,in vitro DNA-binding site selection was performed. The selected population was cloned and the individual members were characterized by determining their binding affinities to RR(Tres) The results showed that the optimal operators contained the TTAC or TTCC sequences in the underlined positions as above, and that the Kd values were in the 1 x 10(-12) mol/L-1 x 10(11) mol/L concentration range. Since the affinity of the natural 434 repressor to its natural operator sites is in the 1 x 10(-9) mol/L range, the observed binding affinity increase is remarkable. It was also found that binding affinity was strongly affected by the flanking bases of the optimal tetramer binding sites, especially by the base at the 5' position. We constructed a new homodimeric single-chain repressor R(TRES)R(TRES) and its DNA-binding specificity was tested by using a series of new operators designed according to the recognition properties previously determined for the R(TREs) domain. These operators containing the consensus sequenceGTAAGAAARNTTACN orGGAAGAAARNTTCCN (R is A or G) were recognized by R(TRES)R(TRES) specifically, and with high binding affinity. Thus, by using a combination of random selection and rational design principles, we have discovered novel, high affinity protein-DNA interactions with new specificity. This method can potentially be used to obtain new binding specificity for other DNA-binding proteins.

Isolation of altered specificity mutants of the single-chain 434 repressor that recognize asymmetric DNA sequences containing the TTAA and TTAC subsites

A novel single-chain (sc) protein framework containing covalently dimerized DNA-binding domains (DBD) of the phage 434 repressor was used to construct combinatorial mutant libraries in order to isolate mutant DBDs with altered specificities. The library members contain one wild-type DBD and one mutant domain with randomized amino acids in the DNA-contacting region. Based on previous studies, the mutant sc derivatives are expected to recognize a general ACAA-6 bp-NNNN sequence, where ACAA is contacted by the wild-type and NNNN by the mutant domain. In principle, any sequence can stand for NNNN and serve as a selection target. Here an in vivo library screening method was used to isolate mutant sc repressors that interact with an asymmetric operator containing the TTAA target. Several mutants showed high affinity in vitro binding to operators containing the target and strong (up to 80-fold) preference for the TTAA target over the wild-type TTGT. Specificity studies revealed that certain mutants bound with substantially higher affinities (K(d) approximately 10(-11)M) to operators containing the TTAC sequence, a close homolog of the TTAA target. Thus, we have fortuitously isolated mutant sc repressors that show up to a several hundred-fold preference for TTAC over TTGT.

DNA-induced conformational change of Gaf1, a novel GATA factor in Schizosaccharomyces pombe

A novel GATA factor in Schizosaccharomyces pombe, Gaf1, containing one zinc-finger motif was studied for conformational change that was induced by DNA-binding. Gaf1 was shown to bind to the upstream activation sequence of a gene in Saccharomyces cerevisiae containing GATA element by gel mobility shift assay. Circular dichroism spectra of Gaf1 indicated an increase of alpha-helix content of Gaf1 occurred upon binding to the upstream activation sequence. These results suggest that the binding of Gaf1 to the GATA element is required for the conformational change that may precede transactivation of the target gene(s).

A thermodynamic study of the 434-repressor N-terminal domain and of its covalently linked dimers

The isolated N-terminal 1-69 domain of the 434-phage repressor, R69, and its covalently linked (head-to-tail and tail-to-tail) dimers have been studied by differential scanning microcalorimetry (DSC) and CD. At neutral solvent conditions the R69 domain maintains its native structure, both in isolated form and within the dimers. The stability of the domain depends highly upon pH within the acidic range, thus at pH 2 and low ionic strength R69 is already partially unfolded at room temperature. The thermodynamic parameters of unfolding calculated from the DSC data are typical for small globular proteins. At neutral pH and moderate ionic strength, the domains of the dimers behave as two independent units with unfolding parameters similar to those of the isolated domain, which means that linking two R69 domains, either by a long peptide linker or by a designed C-terminal disulfide bridge, does not induce any cooperation between them.

Single chain dimers of MASH-1 bind DNA with enhanced affinity

By designing recombinant genes containing tandem copies of the coding region of the BHLH domain of MASH-1 (MASH-BHLH) with intervening DNA sequences encoding linker sequences of 8 or 17 amino acids, the two subunits of the MASH dimer have been connected to form the single chain dimers MM8 and MM17. Despite the long and flexible linkers which connect the C-terminus of the first BHLH subunit to the N-terminus of the second, a distance of approximately 55 A, the single chain dimers could be produced in Escherichia coli at high levels. MM8 and MM17 were monomeric and no 'cross-folding' of the subunits was observed. CD spectroscopy revealed that, like wild-type MASH-BHLH, MM8 and MM17 adopt only partly folded structures in the absence of DNA, but undergo a folding transition to a mainly alpha-helical conformation on DNA binding. Titrations by electrophoretic mobility shift assays revealed that the affinity of the single chain dimers for E box-containing DNA sequences was increased approximately 10-fold when compared with wild-type MASH-BHLH. On the other hand, the affinity for heterologous DNA sequences was increased only 5-fold. Therefore, the introduction of the peptide linker led to a 4-fold increase in DNA binding specificity from -0.14 to -0.57 kcal/mol.

Dimerizing the estrogen receptor DNA binding domain enhances binding to estrogen response elements

In this work, we provide a rationale for the finding that the estrogen receptor (ER) binds to its DNA response element as a homodimer in vivo. Binding of the monomer estrogen receptor DNA binding domain (ER DBD) to a palindromic, consensus estrogen response element (ERE) is increased 5-6-fold when the ER DBD is dimerized either by a monoclonal antibody that recognizes an attached epitope tag or by expressing the ER DBD as a single molecule in which the two monomers are joined by a peptide linker. Most of the increase in binding is due to stabilization of the ER DBD.ERE complex. We observed only an approximately 2.5-fold reduction in binding when a consensus ERE was replaced with widely spaced ERE half-sites, suggesting that the interaction between ER DBDs on the ERE is relatively weak, and that in full-length ER the DBDs can move independently of each other. To test binding to an imperfect palindrome, typical of the imperfect EREs found in almost all natural estrogen receptor responsive genes, we used the pS2 ERE. Even at high concentrations of ER DBD, specific binding of the ER DBD to the imperfect pS2 ERE was undetectable. Both of the dimerized ER DBDs exhibited efficient binding to the imperfect pS2 ERE, with an affinity at least 25-fold greater than monomer ER DBD. These data support the view that steroid receptor dimerization provides an important mechanism facilitating the recognition of naturally occurring, imperfect hormone response elements.

Recombinant human O6-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase induces conformational change in bound DNA

Circular dichroism, and steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy were used to compare the native recombinant human DNA repair protein O6-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase (AGT) with AGT bound to ds-DNA. Contrary to fluorescence, analysis of the far-UV CD spectra indicated a conformational change of AGT upon binding to DNA: its alpha-helical content is increased by approximately 12%. Analysis of near-UV CD spectra revealed that DNA was also affected, probably being separated into single strands locally.

Binding of cationic (+4) alanine- and glycine-containing oligopeptides to double-stranded DNA: thermodynamic analysis of effects of coulombic interactions and alpha-helix induction

Coulombic interactions and coupled conformational changes make important contributions to stability and specificity of many protein-nucleic acid complexes. As models of these phenomena in simpler systems, we have investigated the binding to mononucleosomal (160 base-pair) calf thymus DNA of a high charge density (compact) 5-residue (+4) oligopeptide (with 4 lysines and 1 tryptophan) and of four lower charge density (extended) 17-residue (+4) oligopeptides (each with 4 lysines, 10-12 alanines, 0-2 glycines, and 1 tryptophan). The fractional helicity (f(h)) of each oligopeptide before and after DNA binding was determined using circular dichroism. At low univalent cation concentration ([M+] = 6.4 mM), binding to DNA increases f(h) significantly for all but one of the extended oligopeptides. Oligopeptide-DNA binding constants (K(obs)) and apparent binding site sizes (n) were quantified using the noncooperative McGhee-von Hippel isotherm to fit tryptophan fluorescence quenching data. For each of the oligopeptides studied, n is found to be approximately equal to four, the number of lysine charges. In the range 6.4 mM < or = [M+] < or = 21.5 mM, power dependences of K(obs) on [M+] (SK(obs) = d log K(obs)/d log[M+]) for all 17-residue (+4) oligopeptides are similar with an average value of -3.7 +/- 0.4, which is indistinguishable (outside uncertainty) from the value obtained here for the compact (+4) oligopeptide and from values reported elsewhere for another compact tetralysine and for spermine (+4). Our results are consistent with the conclusion that the nonspecific binding to DNA of all these tetravalent ligands is driven primarily by coulombic interactions. At any [M+] investigated, values of K(obs) for the four extended (+4) oligopeptides differ by less than an order of magnitude, but all are 1-2 orders of magnitude less than values of K(obs) for two compact (+4) oligopeptides and for spermine. The differences in K(obs) for oligopeptide-DNA complexes, which all have similar n and similar SK(obs) indicate that when an extended oligopeptide binds to DNA it becomes more compact as a result of conformational changes, such as the additional alpha-helix formation detected by circular dichroism.

Single-chain repressors containing engineered DNA-binding domains of the phage 434 repressor recognize symmetric or asymmetric DNA operators

Single-chain (sc) DNA-binding proteins containing covalently dimerized N-terminal domains of the bacteriophage 434 repressor cI have been constructed. The DNA-binding domains (amino acid residues 1 to 69) were connected in a head-to-tail arrangement with a part of the natural linker sequence that connects the N and C-terminal domains of the intact repressor. Compared to the isolated N-terminal DNA-binding domain, the sc molecule showed at least 100-fold higher binding affinity in vitro and a slightly stronger repression in vivo. The recognition of the symmetric O(R)1 operator sequence by this sc homodimer was indistinguishable from that of the naturally dimerized repressor in terms of binding affinity, DNase I protection pattern and in vivo repressor function. Using the new, sc framework, mutant proteins with altered DNA-binding specificity have also been constructed. Substitution of the DNA-contacting amino acid residues of the recognition helix in one of the domains with the corresponding residues of the Salmonella phage P22 repressor c2 resulted in a sc heterodimer of altered specificity. This new heterodimeric molecule recognized an asymmetric, artificial 434-P22 chimeric operator with high affinity. Similar substitutions in both 434 domains have led to a new sc homodimer which showed high affinity binding to a natural, symmetric P22 operator. These findings, supported by both in vitro and in vivo experiments, show that the sc architecture allows for the introduction of independent changes in the binding domains and suggest that this new protein framework could be used to generate new specificities in protein-DNA interaction.

Purification of streptodornase from Streptococcus equisimilis and its DNA-induced conformational change

Extracellular streptodornase was purified from fermentation media of Streptococcus equisimilis by stepwise carboxymethyl-Sepharose column chromatography. The active enzyme fraction was eluted with phosphate buffer containing 0.2 M NaCl. The purified enzyme showed a homogeneity on SDS-PAGE and had a subunit molecular weight of 35 kDa. Conformational change of streptodornase by binding to calf thymus DNA was examined by circular dichroism (CD). CD study clearly showed a DNA-induced conformational change in the secondary structure of streptodornase, resulting in a decrease of alpha-helical content of the enzyme.

Analysis of the structural properties of cAMP-responsive element-binding protein (CREB) and phosphorylated CREB

The transcription factor CREB (cAMP responsive element binding protein) is activated by protein kinase A (PKA) phosphorylation of a single serine residue. To investigate possible mechanisms of CREB regulation by phosphorylation, we initiated a structural and biophysical characterization of the full-length, wild-type CREB protein, an altered CREB protein (CREB/SER) in which the three cysteine residues in the DNA-binding domain were replaced with serine residues and a truncated protein (ACT265) which encompasses the entire activation domain of CREB. Circular dichroism (CD) reveals that CREB and CREB/SER have identical secondary structures and contain approximately 20% alpha-helix, 9% beta-strand, 34% beta-turn, and 37% random coil structures. PKA phosphorylation does not alter the CD spectra, and therefore the secondary structure, of CREB or of CREB bound to DNA. Protease cleavage patterns indicate that PKA phosphorylation does not induce a global conformational change in CREB. Furthermore, PKA phosphorylation does not change the DNA binding affinity of CREB for either canonical or non-canonical CRE sequences as measured by a fluorescence anisotropy DNA binding assay. Since PKA phosphorylation of CREB results in its specific binding to the transcriptional co-activators CREB-binding protein and p300, we suggest that the PKA activation of CREB occurs by the production of specific, complementary interactions with these proteins, rather than through the previously proposed mechanisms of a phosphorylation-dependent conformational change or increased DNA binding affinity.

Towards an understanding of protein-DNA recognition

Understanding how proteins recognize DNA in a sequence-specific manner is central to our understanding of the regulation of transcription and other cellular processes. In this article we review the principles of DNA recognition that have emerged from the large number of high-resolution crystal structures determined over the last 10 years. The DNA-binding domains of transcription factors exhibit surprisingly diverse protein architectures, yet all achieve a precise complementarity of shape facilitating specific chemical recognition of their particular DNA targets. Although general rules for recognition can be derived, the complex nature of the recognition mechanism precludes a simple recognition code. In particular, it has become evident that the structure and flexibility of DNA and contacts mediated by water molecules contribute to the recognition process. Nevertheless, based on known structures it has proven possible to design proteins with novel recognition specificities. Despite this considerable practical success, the thermodynamic and kinetic properties of protein/DNA recognition remain poorly understood.

Covalent attachment of Arc repressor subunits by a peptide linker enhances affinity for operator DNA

By designing a recombinant gene containing tandem copies of the arc coding sequence with intervening DNA encoding the linker sequence GGGSGGGTGGGSGGG, the two subunits of the P22 Are repressor dimer have been covalently linked to form a single-chain protein called Arc-L1-Arc. The 15-residue linker joins the C-terminus of one monomer to the N-terminus of the second, a distance of approximately 45 A in the Arc-operator cocrystal structure. Arc-L1-Arc is expressed at high levels in Escherichia coli, with no evidence of degradation or proteolytic clipping of the linker, and is more active than wild-type Arc in repression assays. The purified Arc-L1-Arc protein has the molecular weight expected for the designed protein and unfolds cooperatively, reversibly, and with no concentration dependence in thermal-denaturation studies. Arc-L1-Arc protects operator DNA in a manner indistinguishable from that of wild-type Arc in DNase I and copper-phenanthroline footprinting studies, but the covalent attachment of the two monomers results in enhanced affinity for operator DNA. Arc-L1-Arc binds operator DNA half-maximally at a concentration of 1.7 pM, compared with the wild-type value of 185 pM, and also binds DNA fragments containing the left or right operator half-sites more tightly than wild type. Because wild-type Arc is monomeric at sub-nanomolar concentrations and must dimerize before binding to the operator, it was anticipated that Arc-L1-Arc would exhibit a lower half-maximal binding concentration. However, even when the change from a monomeric to a dimeric species is taken into account, the affinity of Arc-L1-Arc for operator and half-operator DNA is greater than the wild-type affinity. This tighter binding appears to result from slower dissociation, as Arc-L1-Arc DNA complexes with full or half-site operators dissociate at rates 5-10 times slower than the corresponding Arc--DNA complexes. Hence, the activity of the designed Arc-L1-Arc protein is substantially increased relative to wild-type Arc in a variety of assays.