Surface stiffness affects impact force during a fall on the outstretched hand

A method for simulating forward falls and controlling impact velocity

Assessment of protective arm reactions associated with forward falls are typically performed by dropping research participants from a height onto a landing surface. The impact velocity is generally modulated by controlling the total height of the fall. This contrasts with an actual fall where the fall velocity is dependent on several factors in addition to fall height and not likely predictable at the onset of the fall. A counterweight and pulley system can be used to modulate the fall velocity in simulated forward falls in a manner that is not predictable to study participants, enhancing experimental validity. However, predicting the fall velocity based on participant height and weight and counterweight mass is not straightforward. In this article, the design of the FALL simulator For Injury prevention Training and assessment (FALL FIT) system is described. A dynamic model of the FALL FIT and counterweight system is developed and model parameters are fit using nonlinear optimization and experimental data. The fitted model enables prediction of fall velocity as a function of participant height and weight and counterweight load. The method can be used to provide controllable perturbations thereby elucidating the control strategy used when protecting the body from injury in a forward fall, how the control strategy changes because of aging or dysfunction or as a method for progressive protective arm reaction training.•Construction of device to simulate forward falls with controllable impact velocity using material that are commercially available is described•A dynamic model of the FALL FIT is developed to estimate the impact velocity of a simulated forward fall using participant height and counterweight load•The dynamic model is validated using data from 3 previous studies.

Protective responses of older adults for avoiding injury during falls: evidence from video capture of real-life falls in long-term care

BACKGROUND

falls are common in older adults, and any fall from standing height onto a rigid surface has the potential to cause a serious brain injury or bone fracture. Safe strategies for falling in humans have traditionally been difficult to study.

OBJECTIVE

to determine whether specific 'safe landing' strategies (body rotation during descent, and upper limb bracing) separate injurious and non-injurious falls in seniors.

DESIGN

observational cohort study.

SETTING

two long-term care homes in Vancouver BC.

METHODS

videos of 2,388 falls experienced by 658 participants (mean age 84.0 years; SD 8.1) were analysed with a structured questionnaire. General estimating equations were used to examine how safe landing strategies associated with documented injuries.

RESULTS

injuries occurred in 38% of falls, and 4% of falls caused injuries treated in hospitals. 32% of injuries were to the head. Rotation during descent was common and protective against injury. In 43% of falls initially directed forward, participants rotated to land sideways, which reduced their odds for head injury 2-fold. Upper limb bracing was used in 58% of falls, but rather than protective, bracing was associated with an increased odds for injury, possibly because it occurred more often in the demanding scenario of forward landings.

CONCLUSIONS

the risk for injury during falls in long-term care was reduced by rotation during descent, but not by upper limb bracing. Our results expand our understanding of human postural responses to falls, and point towards novel strategies to prevent fall-related injuries.

Age-related changes in protective arm reaction kinematics, kinetics, and neuromuscular activation during evoked forward falls

Fall related injuries in older adults are a major healthcare concern. During a fall, the hands and arms play an important role in minimizing trauma from ground impact. Although older adults are able to orient the hands and arms into a protective orientation after falling and prior to ground impact, an inability to avoid increased body impact occurs with age. Previous investigations have generally studied rapid arm movements in the pre-impact phase or absorbing energy in the post-impact phase. There are no known studies that have directly examined both the pre-impact and post-impact phase in sequence in a forward fall. The aim of this study was to identify age-related biomechanical and neuromuscular changes in evoked arm reactions in response to forward falls that may increase fall injury risk. Fourteen younger and 15 older adults participated. Falls were simulated while standing with torso and legs restrained via a moving pendulum system from 4 different initial lean angles. While there was not a significant age-related difference in the amount of energy absorbed post-impact (p = 0.68), older adults exhibited an 11% smaller maximum vertical ground reaction force when normalized to body weight (p = 0.031), and 8 degrees less elbow extension at impact (p = 0.045). A significant interaction between age and initial lean angle (p = 0.024), indicated that older adults required 54%, 54%, 41%, and 57% greater elbow angular displacement after impact at the low, medium, medium-high, and high initial lean angles compared to younger adults. These results suggested older adults may be at greater risk of increased body impact due to increased elbow flexion angular displacement after impact when the hands and arms are able to contact the ground first. Both groups exhibited robust modulation to the initial lean angle with no observed age-related differences in the initial onset timing or amplitude of muscle activation levels. There were no significant age-related differences in the EMG timing, amplitude or co-activation of muscle activation preceding impact or following impact indicating comparable neuromotor response patterns between older and younger adults. These results suggest that aging changes in muscular elements may be more implicated in the observed differences than changes in neuromuscular capacity. Future work is needed to test the efficacy of different modalities (e.g. instruction, strength, power, perturbation training, fall landing techniques) aimed at reducing fall injury risk.

Too far to fall: Exploring the relationship between playground equipment and paediatric upper limb fractures

AIM

Playground equipment, most notably monkey bars, appears to be involved in a high proportion of upper limb fractures (ULFs) in the Australian paediatric population. Despite this, in 2014, Australian playground standards increased the maximum acceptable 'free height of fall' playground equipment from 2.5 to 3.0 m, and maintained monkey bars at 2.2 m. An updated snapshot regarding playground ULFs since these changes is important. This study aimed to determine the number and severity of playground ULFs in a paediatric population, compared to other common activities involved in ULFs.

METHODS

Records of all patients aged 0-17 presenting to the Austin Hospital Paediatric Emergency Department with ULFs over a 12-month period were analysed retrospectively. ULFs included fractures to the carpal bones, radius, ulna or humerus. Variables documented included the activity involved with the fracture, and fracture management. Results were analysed using descriptive statistics.

RESULTS

A total of 725 ULF cases were collected. Playground equipment was involved in 23% (n = 162/697, missing n = 28) of fractures. Monkey bars were involved in 14% of fractures (n = 100/697, missing n = 28), 1.64 times more than the next most common activity. Monkey bars were involved in 62% (n = 100/162) of all playground fractures. In children aged 5-9, monkey bars were involved in 27% (n = 83/304) of ULFs. Monkey bars were furthermore involved in most cases of 'severe' fractures (requiring reduction/operation) (n = 33), with one-third of monkey bar fractures being severe.

CONCLUSION

Given these findings, the authors recommend a renewed focus on measures that reduce the frequency and severity of falls from monkey bars.

Mechanical Impedance and Its Relations to Motor Control, Limb Dynamics, and Motion Biomechanics

The concept of mechanical impedance represents the interactive relationship between deformation kinematics and the resulting dynamics in human joints or limbs. A major component of impedance, stiffness, is defined as the ratio between the force change to the displacement change and is strongly related to muscle activation. The set of impedance components, including effective mass, inertia, damping, and stiffness, is important in determining the performance of the many tasks assigned to the limbs and in counteracting undesired effects of applied loads and disturbances. Specifically for the upper limb, impedance enables controlling manual tasks and reaching motions. In the lower limb, impedance is responsible for the transmission and attenuation of impact forces in tasks of repulsive loadings. This review presents an updated account of the works on mechanical impedance and its relations with motor control, limb dynamics, and motion biomechanics. Basic questions related to the linearity and nonlinearity of impedance and to the factors that affect mechanical impedance are treated with relevance to upper and lower limb functions, joint performance, trunk stability, and seating under dynamic conditions. Methods for the derivation of mechanical impedance, both those for within the system and material-structural approaches, are reviewed. For system approaches, special attention is given to methods aimed at revealing the correct and sufficient degree of nonlinearity of impedance. This is particularly relevant in the design of spring-based artificial legs and robotic arms. Finally, due to the intricate relation between impedance and muscle activity, methods for the explicit expression of impedance of contractile tissue are reviewed.

Injury tolerance of the wrist and distal forearm to impact loading onto outstretched hands

BACKGROUND

The wrist/forearm complex is one of the most commonly fractured body regions, yet the impact tolerance of the wrist is poorly understood. This study sought to quantify the injury tolerance of the adult male forearm-wrist complex under loading simulating axial impact to an outstretched hand.

METHODS

Fifteen isolated cadaveric forearm/wrist specimens were tested. Loading was applied via an instrumented drop tower device designed to impact the palmar surface of the hand with the wrist extended to approximately 90 degrees. Impact severity was modulated by adjusting the boundary condition of the elbow. Elbow reaction force and deformation of the specimen (deflection of the palmar surface of the hand toward the elbow) were measured. Bone-implanted strain gauges were used to detect the time of fracture. Injury risk functions were developed using parametric survival analysis with a cumulative Weibull distribution.

RESULTS

Of 14 specimens, 10 exhibited a fracture to the wrist or forearm after test (one specimen was excluded from the analysis). Injury severities varied from nondisplaced fractures of the radius to severely displaced fractures and/or fracture-dislocations of the carpal bones. Of the potential predictors studied, the specimen deflection expressed as a percentage of the initial specimen length produced the injury risk model of best fit (50% risk of fracture at 1.69% deflection; 95% confidence interval, 1.38-2.07% deflection). The value of the elbow reaction force corresponding to a 50% risk of injury was 4.34 kN (3.80-4.97 kN).

CONCLUSION

These results provide information for the prediction of wrist and forearm injury in biomechanical models simulating impacts in the field and provide tolerance information for the development of injury mitigation countermeasures.

Biomarkers affected by impact velocity and maximum strain of cartilage during injury

Osteoarthritis is one of the most common, debilitating, musculoskeletal diseases; 12% associated with traumatic injury resulting in post-traumatic osteoarthritis (PTOA). Our objective was to develop a single impact model with cartilage "injury level" defined in terms of controlled combinations of strain rate to a maximum strain (both independent of cartilage load resistance) to study their sensitivity to articular cartilage cell viability and potential PTOA biomarkers. A servo-hydraulic test machine was used to measure canine humeral head cartilage explant thickness under repeatable pressure, then subject it (except sham and controls) to a single impact having controlled constant velocity V=1 or 100mm/s (strain rate 1.82 or 182/s) to maximum strain ε=10%, 30%, or 50%. Thereafter, explants were cultured in media for twelve days, with media changed at day 1, 2, 3, 6, 9, 12. Explant thickness was measured at day 0 (pre-injury), 6 and 12 (post-injury). Cell viability, and tissue collagen and glycosaminoglycan (GAG) were analyzed immediately post-injury and day 12. Culture media were tested for biomarkers: GAG, collagen II, chondroitin sulfate-846, nitric oxide, and prostaglandin E2 (PGE2). Detrimental effects on cell viability, and release of GAG and PGE2 to the media were primarily strain-dependent, (PGE2 being more prolonged and sensitive at lower strains). The cartilage injury model appears to be useful (possibly superior) for investigating the relationship between impact severity of injury and the onset of PTOA, specifically for discovery of biomarkers to evaluate the risk of developing clinical PTOA, and to compare effective treatments for arthritis prevention.

The role of flooring as a design element affecting patient and healthcare worker safety

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to review, identify, and synthesize the literature on patient and healthcare worker safety related to flooring. The topic of flooring in the design of healthcare facilities is complex: healthcare associated infections, push/pull limitations, falls and fall injuries, and noise as a contributing factor to quality of care.

BACKGROUND

Most hospitals have not been explicitly designed to enhance patient safety. Recommendations from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) include preventing patient falls, reducing infections, and preventing medication errors as the areas of emphasis of evidence-based design to improve patient safety and quality of care.

METHODS

A review of the literature was conducted through search engines using a predefined list of keywords to identify studies about flooring and the safety of patients and healthcare workers. Inclusion criteria included peer-reviewed theoretical and empirical studies published in English from 1982 to 2012. Final inclusion was obtained based on an analysis of research design.

RESULTS

Of those 27 articles that met inclusion, 7 focused on healthcare associated infections; 9 focused on slips, trips and falls; 7 articles focused on noise; and 4 focused on fatigue. The studies are profiled in tables and organized by environmental variable.

CONCLUSIONS

Though a limited number of studies met the criteria for this review, the evidence base is emerging to design for safety. Recommendations for future research and practical application of design are provided.

KEYWORDS

Evidence-based design, literature review, patients, safety, staff.

An In Vivo Lapine Model for Impact-Induced Injury and Osteoarthritic Degeneration of Articular Cartilage

OBJECTIVE

In this study, we applied a spring-loaded impactor to deliver traumatic forces to articular cartilage in vivo. Based on our recent finding that a 0.28-J impact induces maximal catabolic response in adult bovine articular cartilage in vitro using this device, we hypothesize that this impact will induce the formation of a focal osteoarthritic defect in vivo.

DESIGN

The femoral condyle of New Zealand White rabbits was exposed and one of the following procedures performed: 0.28 J impact, anterior cruciate ligament transection, articular surface grooving, or no joint or cartilage destruction (control). After 24 hours, 4 weeks, or 12 weeks (n = 3 for each time point), wounds were localized with India ink, and tissue samples were collected and characterized histomorphometrically with Safranin O/Fast green staining and Hoechst 33342 nuclear staining for cell vitality.

RESULTS

The spring-loaded device delivered reproducible impacts with the following characteristics: impact area of 1.39 ± 0.11 mm(2), calculated load of 326 ± 47.3 MPa, time-to-peak of 0.32 ± 0.03 ms, and an estimated maximal displacement of 25.1% ± 4.5% at the tip apex. The impact resulted in immediate cartilage fissuring and cell loss in the surface and intermediate zones, and it induced the formation of a focal lesion at 12 weeks. The degeneration was defined and appeared more slowly than after anterior cruciate ligament transection, and more pronounced and characteristic than after grooving.

CONCLUSION

A single traumatic 0.28 J impact delivered with this spring-loaded impactor induces focal cartilage degeneration characteristic of osteoarthritis.

Failure characteristics of the isolated distal radius in response to dynamic impact loading

We examined the mechanical response of the distal radius pre-fracture and at fracture under dynamic impact loads. The distal third of eight human cadaveric radii were potted and placed in a custom designed pneumatic impact system. The distal intra-articular surface of the radius rested against a model scaphoid and lunate, simulating 45° of wrist extension. The scaphoid and lunate were attached to a load cell that in turn was attached to an impact plate. Impulsive impacts were applied at increasing energy levels, in 10 J increments, until fracture occurred. Three 45° stacked strain gauge rosettes were affixed along the length of the radius quantifying the bone strains. The mean (SD) fracture energy was 45.5 (16) J. The mean (SD) resultant impact reaction force (IRFr) at failure was 2,142 (1,229) N, resulting in high compressive strains at the distal (2,718 (1,698) µε) and proximal radius (3,664 (1,890) µε). We successfully reproduced consistent fracture patterns in response to dynamic loads. The fracture energy and forces reported here are lower and the strains are higher than those previously reported and can likely be attributed to the controlled, incremental, dynamic nature of the applied loads.

The influence of headform orientation and flooring systems on impact dynamics during simulated fall-related head impacts

Novel compliant flooring systems are a promising approach for reducing fall-related injuries in seniors, as they may provide up to 50% attenuation in peak force during simulated hip impacts while eliciting only minimal influences on balance. This study aimed to determine the protective capacity of novel compliant floors during simulated 'high severity' head impacts compared to common flooring systems. A headform was impacted onto a common Commercial-Carpet at 1.5, 2.5, and 3.5 m/s in front, back, and side orientations using a mechanical drop tower. Peak impact force applied to the headform (F(max)), peak linear acceleration of the headform (g(max)) and Head Injury Criterion (HIC) were determined. For the 3.5 m/s trials, backwards-oriented impacts were associated with the highest F(max) and HIC values (p<0.001); accordingly, this head orientation was used to complete additional trials on three common floors (Resilient Rubber, Residential-Loop Carpet, Berber Carpet) and six novel compliant floors at each impact velocity. ANOVAs indicated that flooring type was associated with all parameters at each impact velocity (p<0.001). Compared to impacts on the Commercial Carpet, Dunnett's post hoc indicated all variables were smaller (25-80%) for the novel compliant floors (p<0.001), but larger for Resilient Rubber (31-159%, p<0.01). This study demonstrates that during 'high severity' simulated impacts, novel compliant floors can substantially reduce the forces and accelerations applied to a headform compared to common floors including carpet and resilient rubber. In combination with reports of minimal balance impairments, these findings support the promise of novel compliant floors as a biomechanically effective strategy for reducing fall-related injuries including traumatic brain injuries and skull fractures.

Effect of forearm axially rotated posture on shoulder load and shoulder abduction / flexion angles in one-armed arrest of forward falls

BACKGROUND

Falling onto the outstretched hand is the most common cause of upper extremity injury. This study develops an experimental model for evaluating the shoulder load during a simulated forward fall onto one hand with three different forearm axially rotated postures, and examines the shoulder abduction angle and shoulder flexion angle in each case.

METHODS

Fifteen healthy young male subjects with an average age of 23.7 years performed a series of one-armed arrests from a height of 5 cm onto a force plate. The kinematics and kinetics of the upper extremity were analyzed for three different forearm postures, namely 45° externally rotated, non-rotated, and 45° internally rotated.

FINDINGS

The shoulder joint load and shoulder abduction/flexion angles were significantly dependent on the rotational posture of the forearm. The shoulder medio-lateral shear forces in the externally rotated group were found to be 1.61 and 2.94 times higher than those in the non-rotated and internally rotated groups, respectively. The shoulder flexion angles in the externally rotated, non-rotated and internally rotated groups were 0.6°, 8.0° and 19.2°, respectively, while the corresponding shoulder abduction angles were 6.1°, 34.1° and 46.3°, respectively.

INTERPRETATION

In falls onto the outstretched hand, an externally rotated forearm posture should be avoided in order to reduce the medio-lateral shear force acting on the shoulder joint. In falls of this type, a 45° internally rotated forearm posture represents the most effective fall strategy in terms of minimizing the risk of upper extremity injuries.

Pressure distribution over the palm region during forward falls on the outstretched hands

Falls on the outstretched hands are the cause of over 90% of wrist fractures, yet little is known about bone loading during this event. We tested how the magnitude and distribution of pressure over the palm region during a forward fall is affected by foam padding (simulating a glove) and arm configuration, and by the faller's body mass index (BMI) and thickness of soft tissues over the palm region. Thirteen young women with high (n=7) or low (n=6) BMI participated in a "torso release experiment" that simulated falling on both outstretched hands with the arm inclined either at 20° or 40° from the vertical. Trials were acquired with and without a 5 mm thick foam pad secured to the palm. Outcome variables were the magnitude and location of peak pressure (d, θ) with respect to the scaphoid, total impact force, and integrated force applied to three concentric areas, including "danger zone" of 2.5 cm radius centered at the scaphoid. Soft tissue thickness over the palm was measured by ultrasound. The 5mm foam pad reduced peak pressure, and peak force to the danger zone, by 83% and 13%, respectively. Peak pressure was 77% higher in high BMI when compared with low BMI participants. Soft tissue thickness over the palm correlated positively with distance (d) (R=0.79, p=0.001) and force applied outside the danger zone (R=0.76, p=0.002), but did not correlate with BMI (R=0.43, p=0.14). The location of peak pressure was shunted 4 mm further from the scaphoid at 20° than that of 40° falls (d=25 mm (SD 8), θ=-9° (SD 17) in the 20° falls versus d=21 mm (SD 8), θ=-5° (SD 24) in the 40° falls). Peak force to the entire palm was 11% greater in 20° compared with 40° falls. These results indicate that even a 5 mm thick foam layer protects against wrist injury, by attenuating peak pressure over the palm during forward falls. Increased soft tissue thickness shunts force away from the scaphoid. However, soft tissue thickness is not predicted by BMI, and peak pressures are greater in high individuals than that of low BMI individuals. These results contribute to our understanding of the mechanics and prevention of wrist and hand injuries during falls.

Composite playground safety measure to correlate the rate of supracondylar humerus fractures with safety: an ecologic study

BACKGROUND

More than 200,000 children are injured at playgrounds in the United States each year. Our goal was to introduce a composite measure of playground safety and use this instrument to correlate the incidence of supracondylar humerus fractures with playground safety in an ecologic study design.

METHODS

We used a novel "overall-safety rating," defined as a composite of 3 previously validated instruments (National Program for Playground Safety School score, surface depth compliance, and the use zone compliance) to measure the overall safety of all playgrounds within a region. The regions were rated from most to least safe based on average playground safety as measured by this new method. The incidence of supracondylar fractures was calculated using Hasbro Children's Hospital Emergency Department data and state of Rhode Island Census data from 1998 to 2006. The incidence was then correlated with playground safety as defined by our composite measure.

RESULTS

Compared with the neighborhood deemed the safest, the least safe district had 4.7 times greater odds of supracondylar humerus fracture. Overall composite safety score of the district was linearly correlated with the injury rate observed in the population at risk (R=0.98; P=0.04).

CONCLUSIONS

Using our novel composite playground safety score, we found that the incidence of supracondylar humerus fractures was increased in districts with playgrounds with lower scores, suggesting that improvements in playground infrastructure may potentially reduce the incidence of supracondylar humerus fractures, and other injuries, in children.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV.

The potential for brain injury on selected surfaces used by cheerleaders

CONTEXT

Although playground surfaces have been investigated for fall impact attenuation, the surfaces that cheerleaders use have received little attention.

OBJECTIVE

To determine (1) the critical height for selected surfaces used by cheerleaders at or below which a serious head impact injury from a fall is unlikely to occur, (2) the critical heights for non-impact-absorbing surfaces for comparison purposes, and (3) the effect of soil moisture and grass height on g(max) (which is defined as the multiple of g [acceleration due to gravity at the earth's surface at sea level: ie, 32.2 feet x s(-1) x s(-1)] that represents the maximum deceleration experienced during an impact) and the Head Injury Criterion (HIC) at the critical height for a dry grass surface.

DESIGN

Observational study.

SETTINGS

A local cheerleading gym, indoor locations within the authors' institution, and various outdoor locations.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

g(max), HIC, and critical height.

RESULTS

Critical heights for the surfaces tested ranged from 0.5 ft (0.15 m) for concrete and vinyl tile installed over concrete to more than 11 ft (3.35 m) for a spring floor. Increases in grass height and soil moisture resulted in an increase in the critical height for grass surfaces. Only spring floors and 4-in (0.10-m)-thick landing mats placed on traditional foam floors had critical heights greater than 10.5 ft (3.20 m), thus providing enough impact-absorbing capacity for performance of 2-level stunts.

CONCLUSIONS

The potential for serious head impact injuries can be minimized by increasing the shock-absorbing capacity of the surface, decreasing the height from which the person falls, or both. Cheerleaders and cheerleading coaches should use the critical heights reported in this study to compare the relative impact-absorbing capacities of the various surfaces tested, with critical height as an indicator of the impact-absorption capacity of the surface. The findings of this study can be used to select the most appropriate surface for the type of maneuver to be performed, based on the maximum height expected to be achieved by the cheerleader(s) during execution of the maneuver. Cheerleaders should not perform maneuvers at heights that exceed the critical height for the surface on which they are performing.

Age differences in energy absorption in the upper extremity during a descent movement: implications for arresting a fall

BACKGROUND

Falls are the number one cause of unintentional injury in older adults. The protective response of "breaking the fall" with the outstretched hand is often essential for avoiding injury to the hip and head. In this study, we compared the ability of young and older women to absorb the impact energy of a fall in the outstretched arms.

METHODS

Twenty young (mean age = 21 years) and 20 older (M = 78 years) women were instructed to slowly lower their body weight, similar to the descent phase of a push-up, from body lean angles ranging from 15 degrees to 90 degrees . Measures were acquired of peak upper extremity energy absorption, arm deflection, and hand contact force.

RESULTS

On average, older women were able to absorb 45% less energy in the dominant arm than young women (1.7 +/- 0.5% vs 3.1 +/- 0.4% of their body weight x body height; p < .001). These results suggest that, even when both arms participate equally, the average energy content of a forward fall exceeds by 5-fold the average energy that our older participants could absorb and exceeds by 2.7-fold the average energy that young participants could absorb.

CONCLUSIONS

During a descent movement that simulates fall arrest, the energy-absorbing capacity of the upper extremities in older women is nearly half that of young women. Absorbing the full energy of a fall in the upper extremities is a challenging task even for healthy young women. Strengthening of upper extremity muscles should enhance this ability and presumably reduce the risk for injury to the hip and head during a fall.

Effect of various forearm axially rotated postures on elbow load and elbow flexion angle in one-armed arrest of a forward fall

BACKGROUND

Falling onto the outstretched hand is a major cause of upper extremity injury. The overall objectives of this study were to develop an experimental model for elbow load during a simulated fall onto one-armed arrest using three different forearm axially rotated postures as alternative fall arrest strategies. Additionally, the relationship between the elbow flexion angle and different axially rotated postures were also investigated.

METHODS

Fifteen healthy young male Taiwanese graduate students with an average age of 23 years were studied. Subjects performed a one-armed arrest of a 5 cm fall onto a force plate. Each subject fell onto the force plate with his forearm 45 degrees axial externally rotated (ER), non-rotated (NR), and 45 degrees axial internally rotated (IR) postures. Kinematics and kinetics of the upper extremity were calculated and analyzed by using laboratory-developed motion analysis procedures.

FINDINGS

The valgus-varus shear forces in the ER group were 1.4 times greater than the NR group, and 2.7 times greater than the IR group. The elbow joint remained at almost full extension in the ER (3.9 degrees) group, while elbow flexion angle was observed in the NR (24.6 degrees) and IR (40.3 degrees) groups.

INTERPRETATION

A fall onto the outstretched hand with an externally rotated forearm should be avoided in order to reduce excessive valgus-varus shear force on the elbow joint. Knowledge of elbow kinematics and kinetics during a forward fall with various forearm axially rotated posture may be helpful in preventing injuries.

Falls: epidemiology, pathophysiology, and relationship to fracture

Falls are common in the elderly, and frequently result in injury and disability. Most falls result from an interaction between individual characteristics that increase an individual's propensity to fall and acute mediating risk factors that provide the opportunity to fall. Predisposing risk factors include age-associated changes in strength and balance, comorbidities such as osteoarthritis, visual impairment and dementia, psychotropic medications, and certain types of footwear. Fewer studies have focused on acute precipitating factors, but environmental and situational factors are clearly important to fall risk. Approximately 30% of falls result in an injury that requires medical attention, with fractures occurring in approximately 10%. In addition to the risk factors for falls, the fall descent, fall impact, and bone strength are all important determinants of whether a fall will result in a fracture. In recent years, numerous studies have been directed toward the development of effective fall and fall-related fracture prevention interventions.

A matched case-control study of circumstances of occupational same-level falls and risk of wrist, ankle and hip fracture in women over 45 years of age

This study examined the association between circumstances of occupational same-level falls and the risk of wrist, ankle and hip fracture in women over 45 years of age. Cases of fractures and matched controls who suffered non-fracture injuries, all from same-level falls, were selected from workers' compensation claims data. Cases and controls were matched on age, season of fall, industry and state. Information was obtained about manual material handling, fall hazard, initiating event and fall location. Falls during pushing/pulling were associated with increased wrist fracture risk. Falls due to tripping were associated with increased wrist fracture risk, but decreased risk of ankle fracture. Falling outdoors was associated with increased wrist and ankle fracture risk. Increasing age was associated with increased injury risk from tripping-initiated vs. slipping-initiated falls. Few circumstances increased risk of fracture at multiple sites, indicating that they affect risk of fracture by primarily affecting point of impact. The proportion of female workers over 45 years of age, who are at increased risk of fracture, is increasing in developed countries. This study examined the associations between circumstances of falls and wrist, ankle and hip fracture risks among these workers and found that the associations differed by fracture sites.

Preventing fall-related vertebral fractures: effect of floor stiffness on peak impact forces during backward falls

STUDY DESIGN

In vivo biomechanical study of 11 male volunteers.

OBJECTIVE

To measure the peak forces applied to the buttocks in a backward fall from standing, and to determine whether this force is lowered by reductions in floor stiffness.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Fall-related vertebral fractures are common and backward falls result in impact to the buttocks. Compliant flooring may reduce impact force and risk for vertebral fracture during a fall. However, we have little knowledge of the peak forces applied to the body during a backward fall, or how floor stiffness affects this force.

METHODS

Eleven males, mean age 25 +/- 5 (SD) years, were suddenly released from a backward lean of 15 degrees , falling backward onto the ground which was covered with 4.5, 7.5, or 10.5 cm of ethylene vinyl acetate foam rubber. We measured 3-dimensional impact forces applied to the buttocks at 960 Hz with a force plate. We used repeated measures analysis of variance and post hoc t tests to compare peak forces between conditions. We also modeled peak vertical force for falls onto a bare floor. RESULTS.: There was a significant difference in peak vertical force between falls onto the 10.5 cm foam condition compared with the 7.5 cm (P = 0.002) and 4.5 cm (P < 0.001) conditions. Peak vertical force (N) was (mean +/- SD) 5099 +/- 868, 4788 +/- 702, and 4544 +/- 672 for the 4.5, 7.5, and 10.5 cm foam conditions, respectively, and estimated at 6027 +/- 988 for the rigid (bare floor) condition. Compared with the bare floor, these foam floors provided, on average, 24, 20, and 15% force attenuation respectively.

CONCLUSION

In a backward fall onto the buttocks, peak impact forces are 6.4 to 9.0 times body weight in a fall onto a bare floor. Reducing floor stiffness using even a thin (4.5 cm) layer of foam may provide 15% vertical force attenuation during a fall onto the buttocks.

Off-axis loads cause failure of the distal radius at lower magnitudes than axial loads: a finite element analysis

Distal radius (Colles') fractures are a common fall-related injury in older adults and frequently result in long-term pain and reduced ability to perform activities of daily living. Because the occurrence of a fracture during a fall depends on both the strength of the bone and upon the kinematics and kinetics of the impact itself, we sought to understand how changes in bone mineral density (BMD) and loading direction affect the fracture strength and fracture initiation location in the distal radius. A three-dimensional finite element model of the radius, scaphoid, and lunate was used to examine changes of +/-2% and +/-4% BMD, and both axial and physiologically relevant off-axis loads on the radius. Changes in BMD resulted in similar percent changes in fracture strength. However, modifying the applied load to include dorsal and lateral components (assuming a dorsal view of the wrist, rather than an anatomic view) resulted in a 47% decrease in fracture strength (axial failure load: 2752N, off-axis: 1448N). Loading direction also influenced the fracture initiation site. Axially loaded radii failed on the medial surface immediately proximal to the styloid process. In contrast, off-axis loads, containing dorsal and lateral components, caused failure on the dorsal-lateral surface. Because the radius appears to be very sensitive to loading direction, the results suggest that much of the variability in fracture strength seen in cadaver studies may be attributed to varying boundary conditions. The results further suggest that interventions focused on reducing the incidence of Colles' fractures when falls onto the upper extremities are unavoidable may benefit from increasing the extent to which the radius is loaded along its axis.

Trends in fall injuries associated with children's outdoor climbing frames

Falls from publicly owned climbing equipment are often cited as the major cause of injury on children's outdoor playgrounds and have been the focus of substantial interventions in the UK since the early 1980s. Analysis of national data on falls from climbing frames for 1988 to 2002 shows that the main discernible trend during this period is an increase in the occurrence of injuries to the lower arm. Whether this is attributable to a behavioural response to some of the interventions, or to some other factor, is unknown.

Effect of compliant flooring on impact force during falls on the hip

Compliant flooring represents a promising but understudied strategy for reducing impact force and hip fracture risk due to falls in high-risk environments such as nursing homes, hospitals, gymnasiums, and senior centers. We conducted "pelvis release experiments" with young women (n=15) to determine whether floor stiffness influences peak hip impact force during safe, low-height falls. During the trials, we used a pelvic sling and electromagnet to lift and instantly release the participant from a height of 5 cm above a force plate, which measured the force applied to the hip region during impact. Trials were conducted for rigid floor conditions and with layers of ethylene vinyl acetate foam rubber overlying the floor that we regarded as firm (1.5-cm thick; stiffness=263 kN/m), semifirm (4.5-cm thick; stiffness=95 kN/m), semisoft (7.5-cm thick; stiffness=67 kN/m), and soft (10.5-cm thick; stiffness=59 kN/m). When compared to the rigid condition, peak hip impact force averaged 8% lower in the firm condition and 15% lower in the semifirm condition. Peak forces were not significantly different between the semifirm, semisoft, and soft floor conditions, indicating that a 4.5 cm-thick foam mat provides nearly the same force attenuation as a 10.5 cm-thick mat. These results support the need for laboratory experiments to measure the effect of floor stiffness on postural stability and for clinical trials to determine the effect of compliant flooring on hip fracture incidence in high-risk environments.

Out on a limb: risk factors for arm fracture in playground equipment falls

OBJECTIVES

To investigate and quantify fall height, surface depth, and surface impact attenuation as risk factors for arm fracture in children who fall from playground equipment.

DESIGN

Unmatched case control study.

SETTING

Five case hospitals and 78 randomly selected control schools.

PARTICIPANTS

Children aged less than 13 years in Victoria, Australia who fell from school playground equipment and landed on their arm. Cases sustained an upper limb fracture and controls had minor or no injury. A total of 402 cases and 283 controls were included.

INTERVENTIONS

Children were interviewed in the playground as soon as possible after their fall.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Falls were recreated on site using two validated impact test devices: a headform (measuring peak G and HIC) and a novel anthropometric arm load dummy. Equipment and fall heights, as well as surface depth and substrate were measured.

RESULTS

Arm fracture risk was greatest for critical equipment heights above 1.5 m (OR 2.39, 95% CI 1.49 to 3.84, p<0.01), and critical fall heights above 1.0 m (OR 2.96, 95% CI 1.71 to 5.15, p<0.01). Peak headform deceleration below 100G was protective (OR 0.67, 95% CI 0.45 to 0.99, p = 0.04). Compliance with 20 cm surface depth recommendation was poor for both cases and controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Arm fracture-specific criteria should be considered for future standards. These include surface and height conditions where critical headform deceleration is less than 100G. Consideration should also be given to reducing maximum equipment height to 1.5 m. Improved surface depth compliance and, in particular, guidelines for surface maintenance are required.

Prognostic factors in victims of falls from height

OBJECTIVE

Falls from height cause significant mortality in the urban environment, but reliable prognostic factors have not been identified. Even the intuitive relation between the distance fallen and mortality rate has been questioned. Our objective was to determine factors predictive of increased mortality rate in victims of falls from height.

DESIGN

Clinical observational study, retrospective for January 1998 to May 1999 and prospective from June 1999 to September 2000.

SETTING

The study population was drawn from Seine-Saint-Denis, an urban region near Paris with 1.3 million inhabitants treated by a French out-of-hospital medical emergencies unit.

PATIENTS

Patients were victims of falls from height >3 m, age >12 yrs. Study entry was performed on the scene by an emergency physician from the medical emergencies unit.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Studied data included age, gender, circumstances of fall, height of fall, nature of the impact surface (soft or hard), transient impact preceding final impact, and part of the body touching the ground first. The primary end point was mortality. The study included 287 patients, 116 (40%) during the retrospective phase and 171 (60%) during the prospective phase. Ninety-seven patients (34%) ultimately died. In multivariate analysis, age (mean, 41.6 +/- 16.6 yrs in patients who died vs. 34.9 +/- 14.9 in survivors; odds ratio, 1.05; p < .0005); height of fall (median, 5.0; 3.8-8.0 vs. 2.0; 1.2-3.0 floors; odds ratio, 1.24; p < .0001); nature of the impact surface (hard in 39% vs. soft in 22%; odds ratio, 2.7; p < .05); and head, anterior, and lateral body surfaces touching the ground first (with respectively mortality rates of 44%, odds ratio, 16.7, p = .0001; 57%, odds ratio, 10.6, p < 0.005; 32%, odds ratio, 11.1, p < .001) were independently correlated with the final mortality rate.

CONCLUSIONS

Patient age, height of fall, impact surface nature, and body part first touching the ground are independent prognostic factors in victims of falls from height.

Impact Modeling of Gymnastic Back-Handsprings and Dive-Rolls in Children

This study was to determine estimates of the stiffness and damping properties of the wrist and shoulder in children by examining wrist impacts on the outstretched hand in selected gymnastic activities. The influence of age, mass, and wrist and torso impact velocity on the stiffness and damping properties were also examined. Fourteen young gymnasts (ages 8 to 15 yrs) were videotaped while performing back-handspring trials or dive-rolls. Kinematic and ground reaction analysis provided input for computer simulation of the body as a rheological model with appropriate stiffness and damping. A significant positive linear relationship was obtained between wrist damping in dive rolls and age, mass, and wrist and torso impact velocity, while shoulder damping in the back-handsprings had a significant positive linear relationship with body mass. This new information on stiffness and damping at the shoulder and the wrist in children enables realistic mathematical modeling of children's physical responses to hand impact in falls. This is significant because modeling studies can now be used as an alternative to epidemiological studies to evaluate measures aimed at reducing injuries in gymnastics and other activities involving impact to the upper extremity.

Stochastic-rheological simulation of free-fall arm impact in children: application to playground injuries

The aim of this study was to develop and pilot a stochastic-rheological biomechanical model to investigate the mechanics of impact fractures in the upper limbs of children who fall in everyday situations, such as when playing on playground equipment. The rheological aspect of the model characterises musculo-skeletal tissues in terms of inertial, elastic and viscous parameters. The stochastic aspect of the model allows natural variation of children's musculo-skeletal mechanical properties to be accounted for in the analysis. The relationship of risk factors, such as fall height, impact surface, child mass and bone density, to the probability of sustaining an injury in playground equipment falls were examined and found to closely match findings in epidemiological, clinical and biomechanical literature. These results suggest that the stochastic-rheological model is a useful tool for the evaluation of arm fracture risk in children. Once fully developed, information from this model will provide the basis for recommendations for modifications to playground equipment and surface standards.

Cartilage tolerates single impact loads of as much as half the joint fracture threshold

We hypothesized that one mechanical insult could affect cellular proliferation, matrix turnover, and the structural integrity of cartilage, and that these effects would be dose dependent and time dependent. One impact load of low impact (14.4 MPa +/- 2.1 MPa), medium impact (22.8 MPa +/- 5.8 MPa), or high impact (55.5 MPa +/- 12.6 MPa) was administered to the posterior aspect of the medial femoral condyle of New Zealand White rabbits using a previously validated pendulum device. Animals were euthanized at 2, 6, and 12 weeks after impact, and the impacted and sham (contralateral limb) cartilage were harvested. Each specimen was assessed by light microscopy and by immunohistochemical methods. Although impacted specimens had greater loss of proteoglycan staining than sham cartilage, these changes were neither dose dependent nor time dependent. No structural damage, enzymatic proteoglycan or collagen breakdown, or cellular proliferation was identified in the different impact groups. Articular cartilage is a resilient tissue, particularly in situ, and can tolerate single impact loads of as much as 45% of the joint fracture threshold without considerable disruption or degradation.

Policy issues and risk-benefit trade-offs of 'safer surfacing' for children's playgrounds

The case for the universal application of 'safer surfacing' in playgrounds is assessed in terms of absolute risk, cost-benefit, and qualitative factors, and found to be open to question on each front. In parallel, it is noted that members of the child welfare and play communities are increasingly of the view that playgrounds are losing their appeal for children, which in turn has its own health, safety and developmental consequences. In part, this loss of attractiveness may have linkages with the recent concern over play safety and the imposition of measures such as 'safer surfacing'. It is proposed that the drive for play safety, which has existed for some 20 years, should be succeeded by a more holistic approach which, rather than considering play safety in isolation, acknowledges the importance of all attributes of play including child safety both on and off playgrounds, potential beneficial aspects of childhood risk exposure, adventure, and play value.

Acute effects of cartilage impact

Posttraumatic arthrosis after joint injury occurs as a result of the disruption of the matrix components and chondrocyte death. Matrix components can be disrupted by mechanical and enzymatic means, and proteoglycan loss also has been shown to occur after cartilage injury. Until recently, chondrocyte death has been thought to occur primarily as a result of necrosis. However, new evidence shows that chondrocyte apoptosis can be stimulated to occur as a result of mechanical injury. The role chondrocyte death plays in the development of posttraumatic arthrosis currently is unknown. The development of in vitro cartilage injury models has made it possible to investigate some of the effects of impact load (acute injury) on cartilage. In vivo models of cartilage injury have made it possible to investigate changes in the integrity of the matrix components and of the chondrocytes in response to injury with time. However, considerably more information regarding this process is necessary before improvements in the prevention and treatment of posttraumatic arthrosis can be developed.

Biomechanical analysis of arm fracture in obese boys

OBJECTIVE

To determine the role of the biomechanical factors of force of impact, bone strength, fall height and surface stiffness on the risk of forearm fracture in obese children compared to non-obese children.

METHODOLOGY

Anthropometric and dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry bone density data from 50 boys (25 obese pair-matched with 25 non-obese subjects) aged 4-17 years were entered into a rheological-stochastic simulation model of arm impact.

RESULTS

Obese children were shown to be at 1.7 times greater risk of fracture compared to non-obese children. Lower fall heights and softer impact surfaces were found not to reduce the relative risk of fracture between obese and non-obese children.

CONCLUSIONS

Environmental modifications are unlikely to lower the risk of arm fracture in obese children to the same levels experienced by non-obese children. The best option available for obese children to reduce fracture risk is to take steps to attain a healthy bodyweight.

On reducing hand impact force in forward falls: results of a brief intervention in young males

OBJECTIVE

To test the working hypotheses that after a brief (10 min) intervention, (a) young adults can volitionally reduce fall-related wrist impact forces, and (b) no difference in impact force would exist between intervention and control groups at 3-weeks or 3-months follow-up.

BACKGROUND

The wrist is the most commonly fractured site in the body at any age, most often as a result of impact with the ground while arresting a forward fall.Methods. Twenty-nine healthy young male volunteers participated. A 3-month intervention group (n=10) performed five standardized forward falls before and after a 10-min instructional intervention aimed at reducing wrist impact forces during the baseline visit. They, along with a 3-month control group (n=11) who did not receive the intervention, were remeasured in five trials at 3-weeks and 3-months follow-up, without intervening practice. A baseline control group (n=8) performed the five trials, then repeated them at the baseline visit without receiving the intervention. Unilateral body segment kinematics and bilateral hand-ground impact forces were measured and the hypotheses were tested using repeated measures analysis of variance.

RESULTS

At the baseline visit, a significant group-by-trial-block interaction was found (P=0.02): the 3-month intervention group reduced their average maximum impact forces by 18% from initial values (P=0.002); the baseline control group did not do so (0.5% increase, P=0.91). The 3-month intervention (20 falls) and control (15 falls) groups did not differ at the 3-month follow-up (P=0.62); however, when the groups were combined their maximum impact force had decreased significantly (8.9%, P=0.04) over that time.

CONCLUSIONS

Healthy young males learned in 10 min to significantly reduce wrist impact forces in forward falls, but retention was poor at 3-weeks follow-up. Irrespective of group, however, after the 5 falls at 3-weeks subjects had taught themselves to reduce their impact forces at the 3-months follow-up.

RELEVANCE

A brief educational intervention can significantly reduce forward fall-related impact forces in the short term. However, with or without the brief intervention, the experience of performing between 5-10 forward falls 3 weeks apart apparently resulted in decreased impact forces over the next 2 months, thereby reducing the risk of injury in these forward falls.

Induction of chondrocyte apoptosis following impact load

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the presence and extent of chondrocyte apoptosis following impact load of articular cartilage in an in vivo model.

DESIGN

An in vivo animal model, using a pendulum device and New Zealand White rabbits, was designed to study the effects of impact load on the development of chondrocyte apoptosis. Animals were placed into either a High Impact group or a Low Impact group, and the right medial femoral condyle was impacted with a single impact load. A sham operation was performed on the left limb, and this cartilage served as the control.

SETTING

Academic medical center.

PARTICIPANTS

New Zealand White rabbits (3 months).

INTERVENTION

Impact load to the right medial femoral condyle.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Three different methods were used to assess the presence and extent of chondrocyte apoptosis: 1) light microscopy (hematoxylin and eosin and terminal dUTP nick end labeling staining); 2) transmission electron microscopy; and 3) fluorescent microscopy with Hoechst 33342 staining. Secondary outcome measures included determination of the magnitude of impact force and time to peak force.

RESULTS

Light microscopy demonstrated chondrocytes with changes consistent with apoptosis including condensed nuclei, deep eosinophilic cytoplasmic staining, and vacuolization within the impacted specimens. Terminal dUTP nick end labeling staining-stained specimens had a high degree of positively stained cells (60%) in both injured and uninjured specimens. Transmission electron microscopy of the impacted specimens demonstrated numerous chondrocytes with changes characteristic of apoptosis, including nuclear and cellular fragmentation, volume shrinkage, and cytoplasmic vacuolization. Eleven percent of the cells in the High Impact group had changes consistent with apoptosis, versus 3% for the low impact group and <1% for the sham specimens. The High Impact group received a statistically significant greater stress than the Low Impact group. Impact group (P < 0.05), and the average time to peak force was 0.021 seconds for each impact group.

CONCLUSIONS

The current data strongly indicate that in vivo chondrocyte apoptosis can be stimulated by the application of a single, rapid impact load and that the extent of chondrocyte apoptosis is related to the amount of load applied. The contribution chondrocyte apoptosis makes to the development of posttraumatic arthritis following joint injury or intra-articular fracture still remains to be determined.

Fall-related upper body injuries in the older adult: a review of the biomechanical issues

Although the epidemiology of fall-related injuries is well established for the elderly population over 65 years of age, the biomechanics of how, when and why injuries do and do not occur when arresting a fall have received relatively little attention. This paper reviews the epidemiological literature in the MEDLINE data base pertinent to the biomechanics of fall-related injuries, including data on fall rates, fall-related injury rates, fall directions and types of injuries available. It also covers primary sources not listed on MEDLINE, along with the pertinent biomechanics literature. Many falls in older adults are in a forward direction, and as a result the upper extremities are one of the most commonly injured structures, presumably in protecting the head and torso. In this review emphasis is placed on what is, and what is not, known of the biomechanical factors that determine the impact forces and injury risk associated with upper extremity injuries in forward falls. While decreased bone mineral density may be contributory, it is not a reliable predictor of fracture risk. Evidence is presented that fall-related impact forces can be reduced by appropriate volitional arrest strategies. Further theoretical and experimental research is needed to identify appropriate fall-arrest strategies for the elderly, as well as the physical capacities and skills required to do so. Inexpensive interventions might then be developed to teach safe fall-arrest techniques to older individuals.

Playground injury prevention

Playground safety recently has received increasing attention from parents and municipalities. Orthopaedic surgeons treat a large number of the more than 350,000 injuries per year sustained on the play areas of this country's school, home, and community play areas. A parent brings a child to the playground for fun, healthy exercise, and imaginative play. Unfortunately, most parents may not be aware of recommended injury prevention methods. Data from the Consumer Product Safety Commission and other epidemiologic studies document frequency, identify at-risk activities and equipment, give direction for additional research, and guide regulations. It is appropriate for the medical community to lead in this safety effort and to contribute to additional research and advocacy efforts.

Biomechanical simulations of forward fall arrests: effects of upper extremity arrest strategy, gender and aging-related declines in muscle strength

Computer simulation was used to predict the extent to which age-related muscle atrophy may adversely affect the safe arrest of a forward fall onto the arms. The biomechanical factors affecting the separate risks for wrist fracture or head impact were examined using a two-dimensional, 5-link, forward dynamic model. The hypothesis was tested in older females that age-related loss in muscular strength renders the use of the arms ineffective in arresting a forward fall without either a torso impact exceeding 0.5m/s or distal forearm loads sufficient to fracture the wrist. The results demonstrate that typical age-related decline in arm muscle strength substantially reduces the ability to arrest a forward fall without the elbows buckling and, therefore, a risk of torso and/or head impact. The model predicted that older women with below-average bone strength risk a Colles fracture when arresting typical falls, particularly with an extended arm.

Age-dependent variations in the directional sensitivity of balance corrections and compensatory arm movements in man

We investigated the effects of ageing on balance corrections induced by sudden stance perturbations in different directions. Effects were examined in biomechanical and electromyographic (EMG) recordings from a total of 36 healthy subjects divided equally into three age groups (20-34, 35-55 and 60-75 years old). Perturbations consisted of six combinations of support-surface roll (laterally) and pitch (forward-backward) each with 7.5 deg amplitude (2 pure pitch, and 4 roll and pitch) delivered randomly. To reduce stimulus predictability further and to investigate scaling effects, perturbations were at either 30 or 60 deg s(-1). In the legs, trunk and arms we observed age-related changes in balance corrections. The changes that appeared in the lower leg responses included smaller stretch reflexes in soleus and larger reflexes in tibialis anterior of the elderly compared with the young. For all perturbation directions, onsets of balance correcting responses in these ankle muscles were delayed by 20-30 ms and initially had smaller amplitudes (between 120-220 ms) in the elderly. This reduced early activity was compensated by increased lower leg activity after 240 ms. These EMG changes were paralleled by comparable differences in ankle torque responses, which were initially (after 160 ms) smaller in the elderly, but subsequently greater (after 280 ms). Findings in the middle-aged group were generally intermediate between the young and the elderly groups. Comparable results were obtained for the two different stimulus velocities. Stimulus-induced trunk roll, but not trunk pitch, changed dramatically with increasing age. Young subjects responded with early large roll movements of the trunk in the opposite direction to platform roll. A similarly directed but reduced amplitude of trunk roll was observed in the middle-aged. The elderly had very little initial roll modulation and also had smaller stretch reflexes in paraspinals. Balance-correcting responses (over 120-220 ms) in gluteus medius and paraspinals were equally well tuned to roll in the elderly, as in the young, but were reduced in amplitude. Onset latencies were delayed with age in gluteus medius muscles. Following the onset of trunk and hip balance corrections, trunk roll was in the same direction as support-surface motion for all age groups and resulted in overall trunk roll towards the fall side in the elderly, but not in the young. Protective arm movements also changed with age. Initial arm roll movements were largest in the young, smaller in the middle aged, and smallest in the elderly. Initial arm roll movements were in the same direction as initial trunk motion in the young and middle aged. Thus initial roll arm movements in the elderly were directed oppositely to those in the young. Initial pitch motion of the arms was similar across age groups. Subsequent arm movements were related to the amplitude of deltoid muscle responses which commenced at 100 ms in the young and 20-30 ms later in the elderly. These deltoid muscle responses preceded additional arm roll motion which left the arms directed 'downhill' (in the direction of the fall) in the elderly, but 'uphill' (to counterbalance motion of the pelvis) in the young. We conclude that increased trunk roll stiffness is a key biomechanical change with age. This interferes with early compensatory trunk movements and leads to trunk displacements in the direction of the impending fall. The reversal of protective arm movements in the elderly may reflect an adaptive strategy to cushion the fall. The uniform delay and amplitude reduction of balance-correcting responses across many segments (legs, hips and arms) suggests a neurally based alteration in processing times and response modulation with age. Interestingly, the elderly compensated for these 'early abnormalities' with enlarged later responses in the legs, but no similar adaptation was noted in the arms and trunk. These changes with age provide an insight into possible mechanisms underlying falls in the elderly.

Fall arrest strategy affects peak hand impact force in a forward fall

We measured the peak hand impact force involved in bimanually arresting a forward fall to the ground from a 1-m shoulder height in five healthy young males. The effects of three different subject instruction sets: "arrest the fall naturally"; "keep the head as far from the ground as possible"; and "minimize the peak hand forces" were studied by measuring body segment kinematics, ground reaction forces, and upper-extremity myoelectric activity. The hypotheses were tested that the (a) arrest strategy did not influence peak impact force, (b) arm configuration, impact velocity and upper-extremity electromyography (EMG) levels correlate to the peak impact force (c) and impacting the ground with one hand leading the other does not increase the impact force over that obtained with simultaneous hand use. The results show that these subjects were able to volitionally decrease the peak impact force at the wrist by an average of 27% compared with a "natural landing" (p=0.014) and 40% compared with a "stiff-arm landing" (p<0.0005). The magnitude of the peak unilateral wrist force varied from 0.65 to 1.7 body weight for these moderate falls onto a padded surface. Peak force correlated with the elbow angle at impact, wrist velocity at impact and with pre-EMG triceps activity. The force was not significantly higher for non-simultaneous hand impacts. We conclude that fall arrest strategy can substantially alter the peak impact forces applied to the distal forearm during a fall arrest. Therefore, the fall arrest strategy likely influences wrist injury risk independent of bone strength.

A method for delivering variable impact stresses to the articular cartilage of rabbit knees

OBJECTIVE

To develop a method by which a single impact force of controlled magnitude and rate could be applied uniformly to an area on the posterior aspect of the medial femoral condyle of adult rabbits.

DESIGN

An in-vivo animal model using a pendulum device, designed and manufactured to supply the kinetic energy necessary to apply different impact loads to the posterior aspect of the medial femoral condyle of a rabbit.

SETTING

Biomechanical laboratory, University Medical Center.

SUBJECTS

A total of thirty-six femoral condyles from 3-kilogram New Zealand White (NZW) rabbits were used during this evaluation.

INTERVENTION

An aluminum impactor was made based on the sagittal and coronal radii of curvature of six matched pairs (n = 12) of femurs from three-kilogram NZW rabbits. This impactor was coupled with the pendulum and used to apply different impact loads to both of the medial femoral condyle of the knees of NZW rabbits (n = 24).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

Peak impact force, time to peak impact force, and average contact area between impactor and medial femoral condyle, were measured for each group of animals tested.

RESULTS

The pendulum delivered a consistent impact force to the rabbit condyle of 120.0 N (+/-18.1; coefficient of variance, 15 percent) with 400 grams attached to the pendulum arm, at an average time to peak force of 0.021 seconds (+/-0.001, co. var. 4.8 percent). The peak impact force was significantly different for each of the three impact mass groups of animals (p < 0.001). By contrast, time to peak force for each mass group averaged approximately 0.020 seconds and the average contact area was 6.26 mm2 (+/-0.51). Quantitative assessment of the exposed medium pressure-sensitive film confirmed uniform impact force intensity within each specimen.

CONCLUSIONS

An in-vivo animal model was developed to deliver a controlled and rapid impact force to a specific area of the weight-bearing surface of the adult rabbit knee. These loads were applied at a rate comparable to the clinical setting of falling onto an outstretched hand, thus simulating a common clinical scenario by which cartilage is often injured. This model can be used in future experiments to investigate mechanism by which posttraumatic arthritis develops after articular injuries.

Biomechanical factors affecting the peak hand reaction force during the bimanual arrest of a moving mass

Fall-related wrist fractures are among the most common fractures at any age. In order to learn more about the biomechanical factors influencing the impact response of the upper extremities, we studied peak hand reaction force during the bimanual arrest of a 3.4 kg ballistic pendulum moving toward the subject in the sagittal plane at shoulder height. Twenty healthy young and 20 older adults, with equal gender representation, arrested the pendulum after impact at one of three initial speeds: 1.8, 2.3, or 3.0 m/sec. Subjects were asked to employ one of three initial elbow angles: 130, 150, or 170 deg. An analysis of variance showed that hand impact force decreased significantly as impact velocity decreased (50 percent/m/s) and as elbow angle decreased (0.9 percent/degree). A two segment sagittally-symmetric biomechanical model demonstrated that two additional factors affected impact forces: hand-impactor surface stiffness and damping properties, and arm segment mass. We conclude that hand impact force can be reduced by more than 40 percent by decreasing the amount of initial elbow extension and by decreasing the velocity of the hands and arms relative to the impacting surface.

Effect of elbow flexion on upper extremity impact forces during a fall

OBJECTIVE

The overall objectives are to develop a biomechanical model for a simulated fall with outstretched hand.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study involving young healthy volunteers in a university research laboratory setting.

BACKGROUND

Little is known about the factors which influence fracture risk during a fall on outstretched hand.

METHODS

A group of 11 male subjects volunteered for this investigation. A set of eight reflective markers was placed bilaterally on selected anatomic landmarks. Subjects were suspended with both elbows extended and wrists dorsiflexed, preparing to impact the ground and force plates from two different fall heights: 3 and 6 cm. Two different postures for the elbows were employed. In the elbow extension experiment, the elbows were extended at all times. In the elbow flexion experiment, the elbows were extended at impact, but then flexed immediately, as though in the initial downward phase of a push-up exercise.

RESULT

Increasing the fall height significantly increased the upper extremity axial forces by 10% and 5%. No significantly different differences were found in the axial forces applied to the wrist, elbow or shoulder between the elbow flexion and elbow extension trials, but the elbow mediolateral shear force was 68% larger (P=0.002) in the extension trials.

CONCLUSIONS

Performing an elbow flexion movement at impact reduces the first peak impact force value and postpones the maximum peak value. Although changing the fall arrest strategy from elbow extension to elbow flexion did not affect the peak impact force on the hand, it did require substantially greater elbow and shoulder muscle strengths.

RELEVANCE

This paper yields insights into how the physical demands of arresting mild falls may relate to upper extremity muscle capacity, joint dislocation and bony fracture.

Prediction of upper extremity impact forces during falls on the outstretched hand

Among the most common causes of upper extremity fracture is a fall on the outstretched hand. Yet few data exist on the biomechanical factors which affect injury risk during this event. In this study, we measured impact forces during low-height (0-5 cm), forward falls onto the outstretched hand, and found that these are governed by an initial high-frequency peak and a subsequent, lower-frequency oscillation. This behavior was well-simulated by a two-degree-of-freedom, lumped-parameter mathematical model. Increases in body mass caused greater increases in the peak magnitude of the low-frequency component (Fmax2) than the high-frequency component (Fmax1). However, increases in fall height more strongly influenced Fmax1, which exceeded Fmax2 for all but very low fall heights. Model predictions suggest that fall heights greater than 0.6 m carry significant risk for wrist fracture, since above this height, peak forces surpass the average fracture force of the distal radius. Finally, while the shoulder experiences lower peak force than the wrist (since Fmax1 is not transmitted proximally), it undergoes considerably greater deflection, and thereby absorbs the majority of impact energy during a fall.