Neural correlates of frog calling. Masculinization by androgens

Emergence of In Vitro Preparations and Their Contribution to Understanding the Neural Control of Behavior in Vertebrates

One of the longstanding goals of the field of neuroscience is to understand the neural control of behavior in both invertebrate and vertebrate species. A series of early discoveries showed that certain motor patterns like locomotion could be generated by neuronal circuits without sensory feedback or descending control systems. These were called fictitious, or "fictive", motor programs because they could be expressed by neurons in the absence of movement. This finding lead investigators to isolate central nervous system tissue and maintain it in a dish in vitro to better study mechanisms of motor pattern generation. A period of rapid development of in vitro preparations from invertebrate species that could generate fictive motor programs from the activity of central pattern generating circuits (CPGs) emerged that was gradually followed by the introduction of such preparations from vertebrates. Here, I will review some of the notable in vitropreparations from both mammalian and non-mammalian vertebrate species developed to study the neural circuits underlying a variety of complex behaviors. This approach has been instrumental in delineating not only the cellular substrates underlying locomotion, respiration, scratching, and other behaviors, but also mechanisms underlying the modifiability of motor pathways through synaptic plasticity. In vitro preparations have had a significant impact on the field of motor systems neuroscience and the expansion of our understanding of how nervous systems control behavior. The field is ready for further advancement of this approach to explore neural substrates for variations in behavior generated by social and seasonal context, and the environment.

A neuroendocrine basis for the hierarchical control of frog courtship vocalizations

Seasonal courtship signals, such as mating calls, are orchestrated by steroid hormones. Sex differences are also sculpted by hormones, typically during brief sensitive periods. The influential organizational-activational hypothesis [50] established the notion of a strong distinction between long-lasting (developmental) and cyclical (adult) effects. While the dichotomy is not always strict [1], experimental paradigms based on this hypothesis have indeed revealed long-lasting hormone actions during development and more transient anatomical, physiological and behavioral effects of hormonal variation in adulthood. Sites of action during both time periods include forebrain and midbrain sensorimotor integration centers, hindbrain and spinal cord motor centers, and muscles. African clawed frog (Xenopus laevis) courtship vocalizations follow the basic organization-activation pattern of hormone-dependence with some exceptions, including expanded steroid-sensitive periods. Two highly-tractable preparations-the isolated larynx and the fictively calling brain-make this model system powerful for dissecting the hierarchical action of hormones. We discuss steroid effects from larynx to forebrain, and introduce new directions of inquiry for which Xenopus vocalizations are especially well-suited.

Sexual hearing: the influence of sex hormones on acoustic communication in frogs

The majority of anuran amphibians (frogs and toads) use acoustic communication to mediate sexual behavior and reproduction. Generally, females find and select their mates using acoustic cues provided by males in the form of conspicuous advertisement calls. In these species, vocal signal production and reception are intimately tied to successful reproduction. Research with anurans has demonstrated that acoustic communication is modulated by reproductive hormones, including gonadal steroids and peptide neuromodulators. Most of these studies have focused on the ways in which hormonal systems influence vocal signal production; however, here we will concentrate on a growing body of literature that examines hormonal modulation of call reception. This literature suggests that reproductive hormones contribute to the coordination of reproductive behaviors between signaler and receiver by modulating sensitivity and spectral filtering of the anuran auditory system. It has become evident that the hormonal systems that influence reproductive behaviors are highly conserved among vertebrate taxa. Thus, studying the endocrine and neuromodulatory bases of acoustic communication in frogs and toads can lead to insights of broader applicability to hormonal modulation of vertebrate sensory physiology and behavior.

Hormones and acoustic communication in anuran amphibians

Circulating hormone levels can mediate changes in the quality of courtship signals by males and/or mate choice by females and may thus play an important role in the evolution of courtship signals. Costs associated with shifts in hormone levels of males, for example, could effectively stabilize directional selection by females on male signals. Alternatively, if hormone levels affect the selection of mates by females, then variation in hormone levels among females could contribute to the maintenance of variability in the quality of males' signals. Here, I review what is known regarding the effects of hormone levels on the quality of acoustic signals produced by males and on the choice of mates by females in anuran amphibians. Surprisingly, despite the long history of anuran amphibians as model organisms for studying acoustic communication and physiology, we know very little about how variation in circulating hormone levels contributes to variation in the vocal quality of males. Proposed relationships between androgen levels and vocal quality depicted in recent models, for example, are subject to the same criticisms raised for similar models proposed in relation to birds, namely that the evidence for graded effects of androgens on vocal performance is often weak or not rigorously tested and responses seen in one species are often not observed in other species. Although several studies offer intriguing support for graded effects of hormones on calling behavior, additional comparative studies will be required to understand these relationships. Recent studies indicate that hormones may also mediate changes in anuran females' choice of mates, suggesting that the hormone levels of females can influence the evolution of males' mating signals. No studies to date have concurrently addressed the potential complexity of hormone-behavior relationships from the perspective of sender as well as receiver, nor have any studies addressed the costs that are potentially associated with changes in circulating hormone levels in anurans (i.e., life-history tradeoffs associated with elevations in circulating androgens in males). The mechanisms involved in hormonally induced changes in signal production and selectivity also require further investigation. Anuran amphibians are, in many ways, conducive to investigating such questions.

Central pattern generators for social vocalization: androgen-dependent neurophysiological mechanisms

Historically, most studies of vertebrate central pattern generators (CPGs) have focused on mechanisms for locomotion and respiration. Here, we highlight new results for ectothermic vertebrates, namely teleost fish and amphibians, showing how androgenic steroids can influence the temporal patterning of CPGs for social vocalization. Investigations of vocalizing teleosts show how androgens can rapidly (within minutes) modulate the neurophysiological output of the vocal CPG (fictive vocalizations that mimic the temporal properties of natural vocalizations) inclusive of their divergent actions between species, as well as intraspecific differences between male reproductive morphs. Studies of anuran amphibians (frogs) demonstrate that long-term steroid treatments (wks) can masculinize the fictive vocalizations of females, inclusive of its sensitivity to rapid modulation by serotonin. Given the conserved organization of vocal control systems across vertebrate groups, the vocal CPGs of fish and amphibians provide tractable models for identifying androgen-dependent events that are fundamental to the mechanisms of vocal motor patterning. These basic mechanisms can also inform our understanding of the more complex CPGs for vocalization, and social behaviors in general, that have evolved among birds and mammals.

Hormonal induction of thumb pads and the evolution of secondary sexual characteristics of the Southeast Asian fanged frog, Rana blythii

The fanged frogs of Southeast Asia do not express most of the hormone-dependent secondary sexual characteristics such as thumb pads that are common to other ranid frogs. At the same point in the evolutionary history of the group that these androgen-mediated characteristics are lost, male parental care first evolves. This behavior is often correlated with low androgen levels. Prior work indicates that in one of the fanged frogs, Rana blythii, adult males have low androgen levels compared to North Temperate species of Rana. This leads to the question of whether these low androgen levels are related to the unusual male parental care and the lack of expression of the thumb pad and other hormone-dependent secondary sexual characteristics in this species. We tested that hypothesis by examining the effects of exogenous dihydrotestosterone supplements on the expression of thumb pads in Rana blythii. Dihydrotestosterone injections appear to stimulate the expression of the thumb pad in R. blythii. These results support the hypothesis that low androgen levels are involved in the loss of the thumb pad in R. blythii. This work provides an example of how mapping characters on phylogenies can be a powerful approach for gaining insights into proximate physiological mechanisms of selection at the evolutionary level.

Brain vasotocin pathways and the control of sexual behaviors in the bullfrog

The neurohypophysial peptide arginine vasotocin (AVT) alters the display of several sexually dimorphic behaviors in the bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana). These behaviors include mate calling, release calling, call phonotaxis, and locomotor activity. Populations of AVT-immunoreactive cells are present in six areas of bullfrog brain and fibers are widespread. Neural areas involved in vocalization, in particular, contain AVT cells and fibers. As well, AVT concentrations in a subset of brain areas are sexually dimorphic and steroid sensitive. Effects of gonadectomy and gonadal steroid treatment vary, depending on the brain area and sex of the frog. For example, some anterior areas are sensitive to changes in both dihydrotestosterone (DHT) and estradiol. In some posterior brain areas, on the other hand, AVT levels are affected only by DHT. A similar situation exists for putative AVT receptors in bullfrogs. Receptors are widespread, occurring in many areas that have been linked to behavior. Receptor concentrations are sexually dimorphic in the amygdala pars lateralis, hypothalamus, pretrigeminal nucleus, and dorsolateral nucleus. Estradiol alters AVT receptor level in the amygdala of both sexes of bullfrog and both estradiol and DHT alter the receptor number in the pretrigeminal nucleus, but only in males. The mechanisms responsible for steroid effects on vasotocin neurons and their targets are unknown. Specific AVT cells, fiber terminal fields, and receptor populations are likely influenced by gonadal steroids for effective timing of individual behaviors displayed by bullfrogs.

Testosterone levels and evoked vocal responses in a natural population of the frog Batrachyla taeniata

Relationships between testosterone plasma levels and evoked vocal responses of males of the leptodactylid frog Batrachyla taeniata from southern Chile were studied. Evoked vocal responses were elicited in the field with playbacks of a synthetic imitation of the conspecific advertisement call and variants of this signal for which different temporal parameters were modified. Testosterone plasma levels were measured with radioimmunoassay in blood samples obtained from the experimental subjects immediately after the playback experiments and from nonstimulated males. Testosterone levels between groups did not differ significantly. A significant correlation between testosterone concentration and number of calls given in response to the synthetic advertisement call was found. Testosterone levels were also significantly correlated with the total number of calls given by the experimental subjects in response to the complete series of stimuli. Other measures of evoked vocal responses, i.e., number of pulses per call, call duration, pulse rate, and latency to first call, were not significantly correlated with testosterone levels. These results indicate a predominant effect of testosterone on the motivation of males of B. taeniata to call, rather than on the physical attributes of the vocalizations.

Sexual dimorphism in the vasotocin system of the bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana)

Arginine vasotocin (AVT) is widespread in amphibian brains, where its levels have been correlated with reproductive behaviors. To better understand which neural systems are involved in central actions of AVT, we used immunocytochemistry to compare the distribution of AVT in the brains of male and female bullfrogs (Rana catesbeiana). AVT-immunoreactive cells were observed in the septal nucleus, amygdala pars lateralis, magnocellular preoptic area, suprachiasmatic nucleus, and hypothalamus. AVT-immunoreactive cells were also found in the pretrigeminal nucleus, but only in animals killed in the fall. Immunoreactive fibers were broadly distributed in hypothalamic and extrahypothalamic areas. The most obvious sex differences were found in the amygdala pars lateralis, where the density of immunoreactive cells and fibers was significantly greater in male than in female bullfrogs. In addition, in the habenular nucleus, males had a denser distribution of AVT-immunoreactive fibers than females. In the suprachiasmatic nucleus, AVT-immunoreactive cells were larger in females than in males but did not differ in number. Since the areas that showed sex differences in AVT distribution have also been implicated in control of reproductive behaviors, they may form the neural substrates for the effects of AVT on sexually dimorphic behaviors in amphibians.

Acoustic modulation of neural activity in the preoptic area and ventral hypothalamus of the green treefrog (Hyla cinerea)

Responses of neurons in the preoptic area and ventral hypothalamus to conspecific mating calls or white noise bursts were examined in male green treefrogs (Hyla cinerea) during different seasons. In the winter, 34.3% of preoptic neurons and 46.7% of ventral hypothalamic cells demonstrated significant changes in activity level during presentation of a conspecific mating call. In contrast, only 13.3% of preoptic units and 16.7% of ventral hypothalamic cells responded to the white noise. The percentage of preoptic and hypothalamic units responding to the advertisement call did not differ significantly during the summer breeding season. Type I units exhibited a dramatic increase in activity during acoustic stimulation followed by a rapid return to baseline activity levels after stimulus offset. Type II cells showed a robust activity increase during stimulation, but maintained an intermediate activity level after stimulus offset. In the preoptic area, a third response type exhibited suppressed activity during acoustic stimulation. Although seasonal condition did not alter the percentage of acoustically responsive units within either nucleus, the proportion of Type I units in the ventral hypothalamus was greatest during the summer.

Neural correlates of frog calling: production by two semi-independent generators

The anterior preoptic nuclei of the isolated brainstem of male, Northern leopard frogs (Rana p. pipiens) were stimulated electrically and neural correlates of mating calling recorded from the rhombencephalic mating calling pattern generator. Lesions of discrete areas of the brainstem showed that the mating calling generator is separable into two generators, the pretrigeminal nucleus and the classical pulmonary respiration generator (which is approximately co-extensive with the motor nuclei IX-X). Each of these still can produce pulses when isolated from the other. Their interaction changes the expiratory phase of breathing into the vocal phase of calling. All stages of intermediates between these phases could be seen. An updated and simplified model of call production and evolution is presented.

Differential innervation patterns of three divisions of frog auditory midbrain (torus semicircularis)

The connectivity pattern of the laminar, principal, and magnocellular nuclei of the frog torus semicircularis (TS) was investigated. A small amount of horseradish peroxidase was injected focally into individual divisions of the TS and anterograde and retrograde transport patterns were observed. Results of our tracing study showed that these divisions of the TS possessed distinct innervation patterns. The principal nucleus appeared to be the primary input port of the TS receiving extensive inputs from all caudal brainstem auditory nuclei bilaterally, but especially from the contralateral dorsal medullary nucleus and the ipsilateral superior olivary and lateral lemniscus nuclei. Descending projection to this nucleus was limited to that from the posterior thalamic nucleus. In contrast, the laminar nucleus, but even more markedly the magnocellular nucleus, received extensive descending inputs from numerous structures in the dorsal thalamus and less pronounced ascending afferents from caudal brainstem auditory nuclei. Similar to the afferent connection patterns, the efferent projections originating from these three toral divisions differed substantially. The principal nucleus gave restricted ascending projections, limited mainly to the caudal region of the posterior thalamic nucleus, a region important in processing spectral information of complex sounds, and the pretectal gray. Its descending projection was also somewhat restricted, being limited to the superior olivary and lateral lemniscus nuclei. The laminar nucleus and especially the magnocellular nucleus gave robust descending as well as ascending projections; these nuclei serve as the main output paths for the TS and provide the main routes by which auditory input reaches the central thalamic nucleus, a structure previously shown to be involved in temporal information processing.

Anuran mating calling circuits: inhibition by prostaglandin

Male American toads (Bufo americanus) were induced to mating call in response to electronically simulated, conspecific mating calls. The injection of prostaglandin (PG) F2 alpha caused suppression of mating call answering. Neural correlates of mating calling were triggered by electrical stimulation of the anterior preoptic nucleus in the isolated brainstem of male, Northern leopard frogs (Rana p. pipiens). The addition of PGF2 alpha to the bath completely abolished the correlates of mating calling without changing the correlates of pulmonary respiration. The suppression of mating calling shown here, along with the suppression of release signalling described by Diakow and Nemiroff (1981), supports the hypothesis of a close interrelation between the neural circuits of these two calls. The suppression of the neural correlates of mating calling in an isolated preparation shows a central site of action of the PG. The retention of normal correlates of pulmonary respiration, even after suppression of mating calling correlates, suggests that the generation of mating calling patterns involves the extension and pulsing of the expiratory phase of breathing.

Neuroeffectors for vocalization in Xenopus laevis: hormonal regulation of sexual dimorphism

South African clawed frogs use sex-specific vocalizations during courtship. In the male, vocalizations are under the control of gonadal androgen. Though females have moderate levels of circulating androgen, they do not give male-typical mate calls. Both muscles of the vocal organ and neurons of the central nervous system (CNS) vocal pathway are sexually dimorphic and androgen-sensitive. Recent studies suggest that the failure of androgen to masculinize adult females results from a male-specific, androgen-regulated developmental program. At metamorphosis the larynx is sexually monomorphic and feminine in morphology, muscle fiber number and androgen receptor content. During the next six months, under the influence of increasing androgen titers and high receptor levels, myoblasts proliferate in the male and muscle fibers increase at an average rate of 100/day. Females have much lower hormone levels, receptor values decline and they display no net addition of fibers. At metamorphosis, both males and females have approximately 4000 muscle fibers. By adulthood, males have eight times the female fiber number. In the CNS, adult laryngeal motor neurons are more numerous with larger somata and dendritic trees in males than in females. Certain connections of neurons in the vocal pathway are also less robust in females. Unlike the periphery, motor neuron number does not appear to be established by androgen-induced proliferation. Our current hypothesis is that androgen acts at the level of laryngeal muscle to produce more muscle fibers and thus provide more target for motor neurons in the male. This process could regulate cell number by ontogenetic cell death. In the CNS, androgen-target neurons become capable of accumulating hormone shortly before metamorphosis. Androgen receptor in laryngeal motor neurons may permit the dendritic growth characteristic of males by increasing sensitivity to afferent stimuli. Such a process could account for the observed differences in CNS vocal "circuitry" in X. laevis and thus behavioral differences between the sexes.