Immunotherapy for drug-resistant tuberculosis

Levamisole as an Adjuvant to Short-Course Therapy in Newly Diagnosed Pulmonary Tuberculosis Patients

BACKGROUND

The estimated incidence and prevalence of tuberculosis in India are 2.1 and 2.6 million cases respectively. Immunotherapy may shorten tuberculosis treatments and improve the immunity of individuals as well. Hence we study the efficacy of levamisole (LVM) (immunomodulator) as an adjuvant to chemotherapy of pulmonary tuberculosis patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial was conducted for 21 months in newly diagnosed sputum positive pulmonary tuberculosis patients. Patients were subjected initially to clinical examination, sputum acid-fast bacilli smear and culture, tuberculin skin test and weight record. During follow-up, above investigations were repeated. Sixty-five patients were randomly assigned into two groups to receive either tab LVM 100 mg once in a day or matching placebo, orally as a single dose, thrice a week, for 2 months with short-course antituberculosis chemotherapy.

RESULTS

Sputum negativity at 1 week was observed in 11 (44%) patients in LVM group whereas only 3 (12%) in placebo group. All the patients 25 (100%) in LVM group were sputum negative compared to 14 (56%) in placebo group by the end of 3 weeks. In LVM group, 24 (96%) and 11 (44%) patients in placebo group show radiological improvement at 2 months. A direct correlation existed between quantum of immune response and weight gain with LVM. LVM rendered all anergic patients to positive tuberculin reactors. In LVM group, patients with initial Mantoux ≥20 mm and advanced cavitary disease, there was decrease in tuberculin reaction size.

CONCLUSION

Adjuvant immunomodulation with levamisole has the potential of shortening the total duration of antitubercular therapy.

The use of immunomodulators as an adjunct to antituberculous chemotherapy in non-responsive patients with osteo-articular tuberculosis

We studied 51 patients with osteo-articular tuberculosis who were divided into two groups. Group I comprised 31 newly-diagnosed patients who were given first-line antituberculous treatment consisting of isoniazid, rifampicin, ethambutol and pyrazinamide. Group II (non-responders) consisted of 20 patients with a history of clinical non-responsiveness to supervised uninterrupted antituberculous treatment for a minimum of three months or a recurrence of a previous lesion which on clinical observation had healed. No patient in either group was HIV-positive. Group II were treated with an immunomodulation regime of intradermal BCG, oral levamisole and intramuscular diphtheria and tetanus vaccines as an adjunct for eight weeks in addition to antituberculous treatment. We gave antituberculous treatment for a total of 12 to 18 months in both groups and they were followed up for a mean of 30.2 months (24 to 49). A series of 20 healthy blood donors served as a control group.

Twenty-nine (93.6%) of the 31 patients in group I and 14 of the 20 (70%) in group II had a clinicoradiological healing response to treatment by five months.

The CD4 cell count in both groups was depressed at the time of enrolment, with a greater degree of depression in the group-II patients (686 cells/mm3 (sd 261) and 545 cells/mm3 (sd 137), respectively; p < 0.05). After treatment for three months both groups showed significant elevation of the CD4 cell count, reaching a level comparable with the control group. However, the mean CD4 cell count of group II (945 cells/mm3 (sd 343)) still remained lower than that of group I (1071 cells/mm3 (sd 290)), but the difference was not significant. Our study has shown encouraging results after immunomodulation and antituberculous treatment in non-responsive patients. The pattern of change in the CD4 cell count in response to treatment may be a reliable clinical indicator.

Immunological consequences of three doses of heat-killed Mycobacterium vaccae in the immunotherapy of tuberculosis

We report the first study of triple-dose immunotherapy with heat-killed Mycobacterium vaccae (SRL 172) combined with short-course, directly observed chemotherapy in newly diagnosed pulmonary tuberculosis patients. The study was carried out in Rosario, Argentina, where single-dose immunotherapy with M. vaccae has previously been shown effective. Twenty-two HIV seronegative patients, sputum-positive for tubercle bacilli, entered a randomised and partly blinded trial. Twelve patients received injections of SRL 172 and 10 patients received placebo on days 1, 30 and 60 of chemotherapy. All patients were followed up clinically, by sputum bacteriology, chest radiography and haematology. Patients receiving SRL 172 showed faster and more complete clinical improvement, accelerated disappearance of bacilli from sputum, better radiological clearance and a more rapid fall in ESR, than did those receiving placebo. Follow-up continued for a year after therapy and no patient failed treatment or relapsed. Special investigations included longitudinal assessments of respiratory bursts and expression of CD11b on separated polymorphonuclear and mononuclear leukocytes. Tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) was measured in the supernates of cultured cells and both TNF-alpha and interleukin-4 (IL-4) were measured in serum samples. Immunotherapy recipients showed a significantly faster return towards normal values in all the immunological parameters, than did placebo recipients. The results are consistent with a regulatory activity on cellular immunity, reducing the influence of Th2 and enhancing Th1 to the benefit of the patients. This could allow a reduced period of chemotherapy without loss of efficacy and help to prevent the development of multi-drug resistance.

Does immunotherapy with heat-killed Mycobacterium vaccae offer hope for the treatment of multi-drug-resistant pulmonary tuberculosis?

The ability of immunotherapy with heat-killed Mycobacterium vaccae (NCTC 11659), as an addition to the available chemotherapy, to improve the outcome in patients with multi-drug-resistant tubercle bacilli (MDRTB) who had not been cured by chemotherapy alone was evaluated in tuberculosis centres in Estonia, Iran, Kuwait, New Zealand, Romania, Vietnam and the U.K. A total of 337 patients in the above countries received intradermal injections of M. vaccae in addition to chemotherapy. Patients were grouped according to the length of their histories of disease: less than or greater than 2 years duration. Initially, single doses of M. vaccae were given but subsequently up to 12 doses at 2-month intervals were given. Chemotherapy varied from isoniazid alone to drugs selected according to susceptibility tests. Most patients had failed to respond to repeated courses of chemotherapy and the majority, were expected to die from their disease. Results were assessed by sputum smear and culture and by clinical observations. Cured patients were followed for 18-24 months to exclude relapse. Eighteen of 22 (82%) patients with disease for less than 2 years were bacteriologically cured by one or two doses of M. vaccae. Among 315 chronic patients, 24 (7.6%) were cured after one dose, 37.9% after seven doses and 41.6% after 12 doses. Sixty-six chronic patients were lost to follow-up, or died, during the multi-dose regimens. Nine of 33 patients (27%) with advanced disease unaffected by several courses of chemotherapy and discharged on isoniazid alone in Vietnam were cured by 3-12 injections of M. vaccae. The data provide preliminary evidence that the addition of immunotherapy with M. vaccae to chemotherapy improves the rate of cure of MDRTB, most effectively in patients with short histories of disease, but multiple dosing can have beneficial effects in chronic patients in whom chemotherapy has failed. A randomized clinical trial of this immunotherapy in MDRTB patients is therefore required.

Double-blind placebo-controlled trial of Mycobacterium vaccae immunotherapy for tuberculosis in KwaZulu, South Africa, 1991-97

To investigate Mycobacterium vaccae immunotherapy in the treatment of human tuberculosis and to assess longer-term outcomes following treatment for tuberculosis patients, a double-blind placebo-controlled Phase-2 clinical trial was set up in the Mseleni and Manguzi health wards in north-eastern KwaZulu, South Africa. In 1991-93, 204 patients admitted with clinical tuberculosis to the 2 hospitals were allocated to receive single intradermal doses of 0.1 mL M. vaccae NCTC 11659 or 0.1 mL tetanus toxoid alongside standard 6-months chemotherapy with rifampicin, isoniazid, pyrazinamide and ethambutol. The main outcome measures were sputum bacteriology culture conversion to negativity, clinical assessment, weight gain, erythrocyte sedimentation rate and chest radiography. Patients were followed-up after 4 years to determine their health status. M. vaccae cases gained weight more quickly during the first 8 weeks compared with 'placebo' patients. Regression analysis found a synergistic relationship between BCG positive scar status and M. vaccae-induced weight gain. No further difference was found between treatment groups. The bacterial conversion rate to negativity at 2 months was much lower than expected (44.8% active, 38.8% placebo). Mortality was considerably higher than expected after treatment (7.1% each group) and after 4 years (25.8% active, 21.0% placebo; death from tuberculosis 14.5% and 16.1%, respectively). Immune sensitization to environmental mycobacteria may explain the geographical variability of M. vaccae efficacy, as occurs with BCG vaccination and occurred with Koch's tuberculins of the late 19th century. Multiple doses of M. vaccae may be more effective. Further work is required to link the ability of M. vaccae to modulate protective cytokine profiles to favourable outcome in clinical studies. The high mortality found in this study suggests urgent reviews of chemotherapy and monitoring of patients are necessary in KwaZulu.

Safety and immunogenicity of a five-dose series of inactivated Mycobacterium vaccae vaccination for the prevention of HIV-associated tuberculosis

Five doses of inactivated Mycobacterium vaccae vaccine were administered intradermally to 22 human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected patients (11 bacille Calmette-Guérin [BCG]-positive and 11 BCG-negative) in Zambia whose CD4 lymphocyte counts were >/=200 cells/mm(3). HIV viral load and lymphocyte proliferation responses were compared for vaccine recipients and 22 HIV-infected control patients (11 BCG-positive and 11 BCG-negative). Immunization was safe and well tolerated in all patients, and induration at the vaccine site decreased from dose 1 to dose 5. A transient decrease in HIV viral load was observed in BCG-positive vaccine recipients after dose 3 but not after subsequent doses. Median lymphocyte stimulation indices to M. vaccae were 6.0 in vaccine recipients and 2.3 in control patients (P<.001). Stimulation indices were >/=3.0 in 19 vaccine recipients (86%) and 7 control patients (32%; P=.001). A 5-dose series of vaccination with inactivated M. vaccae is safe in HIV-infected patients and induces lymphocyte proliferation responses to the vaccine antigen. M. vaccae vaccine is a candidate for the prevention of tuberculosis in HIV infection.

An epitope delivery system for use with recombinant mycobacteria

We have developed a novel epitope delivery system based on the insertion of peptides within a permissive loop of a bacterial superoxide dismutase molecule. This system allowed high-level expression of heterologous peptides in two mycobacterial vaccine strains, Mycobacterium bovis bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG) and Mycobacterium vaccae. The broader application of the system was analyzed by preparation of constructs containing peptide epitopes from a range of infectious agents and allergens. We report detailed characterization of the immunogenicity of one such construct, in which an epitope from the Der p1 house dust mite allergen was expressed in M. vaccae. The construct was able to stimulate T-cell hybridomas specific for Der p1, and it induced peptide-specific gamma interferon responses when used to immunize naive mice. This novel expression system demonstrates new possibilities for the use of mycobacteria as vaccine delivery vehicles.

Immunization with heat-killed Mycobacterium vaccae stimulates CD8+ cytotoxic T cells specific for macrophages infected with Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Immune responses to Mycobacterium tuberculosis are analyzed in mice which have been immunized with Mycobacterium vaccae to examine novel ways of altering protective immunity against M. tuberculosis. The spleen cells of mice immunized with M. vaccae proliferate and secrete gamma interferon (IFN-gamma) in response to challenge with live M. tuberculosis in vitro. Immunization with M. vaccae results in the generation of CD8+ T cells which kill syngeneic macrophages infected with M. tuberculosis. These effector cytotoxic T cells (CTL) are detectable in the spleen at 2 weeks after immunization with M. vaccae but cannot be found in splenocytes 3 to 6 weeks postimmunization. However, M. tuberculosis-specific CTL are revealed following restimulation in vitro with heat-killed M. vaccae or M. tuberculosis, consistent with the activation of memory cells. These CD8+ T cells secrete IFN-gamma and enhance the production of interleukin 12 when cocultured with M. tuberculosis-infected macrophages. It is suggested that CD8+ T cells with a cytokine secretion profile of the Tc1 class may themselves maintain the dominance of a Th1-type cytokine response following immunization with M. vaccae. Heat-killed M. vaccae deserves attention as an alternative to attenuated live mycobacterial vaccines.

The pathogenesis of tuberculosis

Tuberculosis patients relapse if treatment is not continued for 6 months, because chemotherapy fails to convert the patients' response from the necrotizing pattern characteristic of disease (Koch phenomenon) to the nonnecrotizing bactericidal function required for optimal immunity. We need to understand the nature of these two immunological states and how to convert one to the other. Studies in mice and humans implicate differences in cytokine profiles and in metabolism of adrenal steroids. Either enhanced susceptibility or protection can be evoked in mice with appropriate doses of a killed environmental saprophyte. This emphasizes the importance of shared epitopes and may explain the geographically variable efficacy of Mycobacterium bovis Bacillus Calmette Guérin vaccination. Unlike soluble antigens of M. tuberculosis itself, which tend to evoke necrosis, the shared mycobacterial epitopes evoke little skin-test reactivity in patients. Preparations of these epitopes show potential as immunotherapeutic agents to convert the response from necrotic to bactericidal mode.

Immunotherapy with Mycobacterium vaccae as an addition to chemotherapy for the treatment of pulmonary tuberculosis under difficult conditions in Africa

A study to assess the impact of immunotherapy with Mycobacterium vaccae on the treatment of pulmonary tuberculosis was conducted under existing conditions in Kano, a large city in Northern Nigeria. Whilst it did not quite meet all the criteria of a well-controlled randomized or double-blind trial, the study produced results suggestive of a successful intervention. Immunotherapy with M. vaccae had a beneficial influence on clinical recovery and survival, whether given after 1, 2 or 3 weeks of chemotherapy, according to an assessment made 10-14 months after treatment. Approximately 3 weeks (19.8 days) after the onset of chemotherapy (SHRZ), 73% of the patients who received immunotherapy and 19% of those who received placebo (chemotherapy alone) had become sputum negative by microscopy for acid-fast bacilli (AFB). Similarly, a mean fall in erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) of 25.4 +/- 2.50 mm and 4.0 +/- 2.29 mm was observed in the immunotherapy and placebo recipients respectively, at the same time of assessment. When weight was assessed in the two groups, it was observed that 3 weeks after starting chemotherapy, the recipients of immunotherapy had a mean weight gain of 2.90 +/- 0.24 kg whilst placebo recipients had a mean weight gain of only 0.55 +/- 0.17 kg. These parameters were re-evaluated, 10-14 months later. They showed that 11% of the recipients of the active intervention and 84.6% of placebo recipients still had demonstrable AFB in their sputum. The mean weight gain had increased to 7.91 +/- 1.03 kg and 2.04 +/- 0.94 kg in the immunotherapy and placebo recipients respectively.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Adjuvants, endocrines and conserved epitopes; factors to consider when designing "therapeutic vaccines"

Research into immunity to complex intracellular parasites has recently placed emphasis on the identification of peptide sequences recognised by T-cells, often with the dual objectives of finding species-specific protective epitopes, and of understanding selection of Th1 versus Th2 response patterns. In this review it is suggested that although such work is interesting, it will not achieve these objectives, which must, however, be addressed before we can design the new generation of therapeutic vaccines which may eventually replace antimicrobial drugs in the treatment of infection. First, we suggest that the balance of Th1 to Th2 lymphocyte activity is not determined by epitopes, but rather by adjuvant effects of microbial components which we have barely begun to define, and local endocrine effects mediated by conversion of prohormones into active metabolites by enzymes in lymph node macrophages. Cytokines play a role as mediators within these pathways. In chronic disease states there is a tendency for T-cell function to shift towards Th2. We describe immunopathological consequences of this tendency, including a putative role for agalactosyl IgG, and review evidence for involvement of changes in the endocrine system, brought about not only by the cytokine-hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal axis, but also by direct actions on peripheral endocrine organs of excess levels of cytokines such as TNF alpha, TGF beta and IL-6. We summarise evidence that the epitopes that are targets for protective cell-mediated responses to complex organisms are usually not species specific. In tuberculosis, cellular responses to species-specific components appear to be associated with immunopathology rather than protection. Finally, we discuss how application of these principles has led to remarkable results in the immunotherapy of tuberculosis, including multidrug-resistant disease.

Immunotherapy of tuberculosis with Mycobacterium vaccae NCTC 11659

The history of immunotherapy for tuberculosis is briefly reviewed, and the early appreciation of the importance of secreted antigens, common mycobacterial antigens and stress proteins is noted. The methods by which Mycobacterium vaccae strain NCTC 11659 was selected for special attention, and results of some of the pilot studies of its use as an immunotherapeutic for tuberculosis are reviewed. The results suggested that immunotherapy with M. vaccae may be an important step forward in the treatment and eventual control of tuberculosis. Used in combination with modern short course chemotherapy, treatment failures and deaths during treatment can be significantly reduced. Preliminary data suggests that shortened courses of chemotherapy may be possible when combined with immunotherapy, and such treatment may also be effective in patients co-infected with HIV. Studies at several centers show that M. vaccae may have an important part to play in the treatment of multi-drug resistant tuberculosis, especially when resistance is of the primary type. The mechanism by which M. vaccae achieves these results may be through adrenal endocrine influences on immunity, but remains speculative.

T cell helper types and endocrines in the regulation of tissue-damaging mechanisms in tuberculosis

The necrotising immunopathology, which is accompanied by very little mycobactericidal activity, is probably the key to the pathogenesis of tuberculosis. Conventional chemotherapy fails to correct this immunoregulatory anomaly, so the host response does little to assist the drugs in the removal of the "persister" subpopulation of bacteria. Therefore chemotherapy must be prolonged for at least 6 months, with consequent problems of cost, resistance, and compliance. If we can learn to switch off the necrotising pathway, and replace it with bactericidal mechanisms, treatment of the disease will be enormously improved and shortened. One problem is that we do not know the mechanism of cell-mediated immunity to tuberculosis in man. On the other hand, we are gaining some insights into the mechanism of the necrosis, and there are encouraging indications that it can indeed be separated from immunity, and that it can be suppressed by suitable immunotherapy. We present here some evidence that when a TH2 response is superimposed upon a pre-existing TH1 response, the resulting cell-mediated inflammatory site becomes exquisitely sensitive to cytokine-mediated damage. There is clear evidence for a TH2 component in the immune response of tuberculosis patients. This inappropriate TH1 to TH2 shift may result from subtle endocrinological changes brought about by M. tuberculosis and the response to it. Immunotherapy should aim to switch off this TH2 component.