Development of a flow-cytometric HLA-A locus mutation assay for human peripheral blood lymphocytes

Depletion of NK Cells Resistant to Ionizing Radiation Increases Mutations in Mice After Whole-body Irradiation

BACKGROUND

Ionizing radiation is a very powerful genetic mutagenic agent. Although immune cells are very sensitive to radiation, their sensitivity varies between different types of immune cell. We hypothesized that radiation-resistant immune cells survive after irradiation and then play a role in removing mutant cells.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Splenic lymphocytes and mice were irradiated with γ-rays. Cell populations were analyzed using flow cytometry after dyeing with antibodies and expression of B-cell lymphoma 2 (BCL2) was measured by western blot analysis. To deplete natural killer (NK) cells, anti-asialo GM1 antiserum was used. Micronuclei in polychromatic erythrocytes were measured by May-Grunwald/Giemsa staining. H-2Kb loss variant in T-cells induced by irradiation of B6C3F1 mice were detected by flow cytometry.

RESULTS

When splenic lymphocytes were irradiated in vitro, B cells notably died, while NK cells did not. In vivo, on the third day after whole-body irradiation, the total number of lymphocytes in the spleen decreased rapidly, but the proportion of NK cells was approximately three times higher than that of the normal control group. In addition, it was confirmed that high expression of BCL2 in NK cells was maintained after irradiation, whereas that of B-cells was not. Removal of NK cells by injection with anti-asialo GM1 antiserum immediately after irradiation increased the micronuclei of polychromatic erythrocytes in the bone marrow and the variant fraction with H-2kb loss in the spleen.

CONCLUSION

These results provide important evidence that radioresistant NK cells apparently survive by escaping apoptosis in the early stages after irradiation, and work to eliminate mutant cells resulting from γ-ray irradiation. Future studies are needed to reveal why NK cells are resistant to radiation and the in-depth mechanisms involved in the elimination of radiation-induced mutant cells.

Creation of Mice Bearing a Partial Duplication of HPRT Gene Marked with a GFP Gene and Detection of Revertant Cells In Situ as GFP-Positive Somatic Cells

It is becoming clear that apparently normal somatic cells accumulate mutations. Such accumulations or propagations of mutant cells are thought to be related to certain diseases such as cancer. To better understand the nature of somatic mutations, we developed a mouse model that enables in vivo detection of rare genetically altered cells via GFP positive cells. The mouse model carries a partial duplication of 3’ portion of X-chromosomal HPRT gene and a GFP gene at the end of the last exon. In addition, although HPRT gene expression was thought ubiquitous, the expression level was found insufficient in vivo to make the revertant cells detectable by GFP positivity. To overcome the problem, we replaced the natural HPRT-gene promoter with a CAG promoter. In such animals, termed HPRT-dup-GFP mouse, losing one duplicated segment by crossover between the two sister chromatids or within a single molecule of DNA reactivates gene function, producing hybrid HPRT-GFP proteins which, in turn, cause the revertant cells to be detected as GFP-positive cells in various tissues. Frequencies of green mutant cells were measured using fixed and frozen sections (liver and pancreas), fixed whole mount (small intestine), or by means of flow cytometry (unfixed splenocytes). The results showed that the frequencies varied extensively among individuals as well as among tissues. X-ray exposure (3 Gy) increased the frequency moderately (~2 times) in the liver and small intestine. Further, in two animals out of 278 examined, some solid tissues showed too many GFP-positive cells to score (termed extreme jackpot mutation). Present results illustrated a complex nature of somatic mutations occurring in vivo. While the HPRT-dup-GFP mouse may have a potential for detecting tissue-specific environmental mutagens, large inter-individual variations of mutant cell frequency cause the results unstable and hence have to be reduced. This future challenge will likely involve lowering the background mutation frequency, thus reducing inter-individual variation.

Short-term culture and gammaH2AX flow cytometry determine differences in individual radiosensitivity in human peripheral T lymphocytes

Histone H2AX, a subfamily of histone H2A, is phosphorylated and forms proteinaceous repair foci at the sites of DNA double-strand breaks in response to genotoxic insults, such as ionizing radiation. This process is believed to play a key role in the repair of DNA damage. In this study, we established a flow cytometry (FCM) system for measuring radiation-induced phosphorylated histone H2AX (gammaH2AX) in cultured human T lymphocytes to evaluate individual radiation sensitivity in vitro. Irradiation of short-term ( approximately 7 days) cultured T lymphocytes exhibited significant interindividual, but not interexperimental, differences in the cellular content of gammaH2AX 6 hr after 4 Gy of X-irradiation in three independent experiments using peripheral blood lymphocytes from six healthy donors. However, these differences were not as marked in uncultured lymphocytes, or lymphocytes that were cultured for a prolonged period ( approximately 13 days). The variation of gammaH2AX focus formation in lymphocytes of individuals was reproducible, with differences reaching about 1.5-fold following 7 days of culture. Therefore, the FCM-based gammaH2AX measurement appeared to reflect both the temporal course and the amount of DNA damage within the irradiated lymphocytes. Further, we confirmed that the differences in residual lymphocyte subsets were not involved in individual radiosensitivity. These results suggest that the FCM-based gammaH2AX assay using cultured T lymphocytes might be useful for the rapid and reliable assessment of individual radiation sensitivity involved in DNA damage repair.

The innate immune response to tumors and its role in the induction of T-cell immunity

Recent genetic studies have resurrected the concept that the adaptive and innate immune systems play roles in tumor surveillance. Natural killer (NK) cells recognize many tumor cells but not normal self cells, and they are thought to aid in the elimination of nascent tumors. Two main strategies are employed by NK cells to recognize tumor targets. Many tumor cells down-regulate class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules, thus releasing the NK cell from the inhibition provided by class I MHC-specific inhibitory receptors ('missing self recognition'). More recently, it has become clear that a stimulatory receptor expressed by NK cells, T cells and macrophages (NKG2D) recognizes ligands (MHC class I chain related [MIC], H6O, retinoic acid early inducible [Rae1] and UL16 binding proteins [ULBP]) that are up-regulated on tumor cells and virally infected cells but are not expressed well by normal cells. Ectopic expression of these ligands on tumor cells leads to the potent rejection of the tumors in vivo. Importantly, mice that previously rejected the ligand+ tumor cells develop T-cell immunity to the parental (ligand-) tumor cells. The recognition of induced-self ligands as a strategy to recognize abnormal self sets a precedent for a new immune recognition strategy of the innate immune system.

Possible role of natural killer cells in negative selection of mutant lymphocytes that fail to express the human leukocyte antigen-A2 allele

Increased frequencies of cells carrying mutations at several loci have been found in the blood cells of atomic-bomb (A-bomb) survivors upon testing four or five decades after the bombing. Interestingly, though, we have been unable to demonstrate any radiation-associated increases in the frequencies of mutant blood cells in which human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-A expression has been disrupted; this is true both of preliminary tests on the T cells of a small subset of A-bomb survivors and of the much more extensive study reported here in which we screened a much larger group of survivors for HLA-A2 loss mutations in B cells and granulocytes as well as in T cells. In attempting to explain our inability to detect any increases in HLA-A2-negative cell numbers in HLA-A2 heterozygous individuals exposed to A-bomb irradiation, we decided to test the hypothesis that HLA-A mutant lymphocytes might well have been induced by radiation exposure in much the same way as every other type of mutant we encountered, but may subsequently have been eliminated by the strong negative selection associated with their almost inevitable exposure to autologous natural killer (NK) cells in the bloodstream of each of the individuals concerned. We now report that mutant B lymphocyte cell lines that have lost the ability to express the HLA-A2 antigen do indeed appear to be much more readily eliminated than their parental heterozygous counterparts during co-culture in vitro with autologous NK cells. We make this claim first because we have observed that adding autologous NK cells to in vitro cultures of HLA-A2 heterozygous B or T cell lines appeared to cause a dose-dependent decrease in the numbers of HLA-A2-negative mutants that could be detected over a period of 3 days, and second because when we used peripheral blood HLA-A2 heterozygous lymphocyte cultures from which most of the autologous NK cells had been removed we found that we were able to detect newly-arising HLA-A2 mutant T cells in substantial numbers. Taken together, these results strongly support the hypothesis that autologous NK cells are responsible for eliminating mutant lymphocytes that have lost the ability to express self-HLA class I molecules in vivo, and may well therefore explain why we have been unable to detect increased frequencies of HLA-A2 mutants in samples from any of the 164 A-bomb survivors whose HLA-A2 heterozygote status made their lymphocytes suitable for our tests.

Intrinsic genetic instability of normal human lymphocytes and its implication for loss of heterozygosity

A combination of flow cytometry and microsatellite analysis was used to investigate loss of expression of HLA-A and/or HLA-B alleles and concurrent LOH at polymorphic chromosome 6 loci both in freshly isolated lymphocytes (in vivo mutations) and in lymphocytes cultured ex vivo. The fraction of in vivo mutants that showed LOH at 6p appeared to vary from 0%-49% for various donors. During culturing ex vivo, HLA-A(-) cells arose at a high rate and showed simultaneous loss of expression at the linked HLA-B locus. Up to 90% of the ex vivo arisen HLA-A2(-) cell population showed LOH of multiple 6p markers, and 50% had lost heterozygosity at 6q. This ex vivo spectrum resembles that found in HLA-A2 mutants obtained from lymphoblastoid cells. The HLA-A2 mutants present in vivo may reflect only a small fraction of the mutants that can be detected ex vivo. In normal lymphocytes, in vivo only mitotic recombination appears to be sustained, indicating the importance of this mechanism for tumor initiation in normal cells. Although mutations resulting in LOH at both chromosome 6 arms were shown to result in nonviable cells in normal lymphocytes, they have been shown to result in viable mutants in lymphoblastoid cells. We hypothesize that these types of mutations also occur in vivo but only survive in cells that already harbor a mutated genetic background. In light of the high rate at which these types of mutations occur, they may contribute to cancer progression.

Molecular methods for the detection of mutations

We report the results of a collaborative study aimed at developing reliable, direct assays for mutation in human cells. The project used common lymphoblastoid cell lines, both with and without mutagen treatment, as a shared resource to validate the development of new molecular methods for the detection of low-level mutations in the presence of a large excess of normal alleles. As the "gold standard, " hprt mutation frequencies were also measured on the same samples. The methods under development included i) the restriction site mutation (RSM) assay, in which mutations lead to the destruction of a restriction site; ii) minisatellite length-change mutation, in which mutations lead to alleles containing new numbers of tandem repeat units; iii) loss of heterozygosity for HLA epitopes, in which antibodies can be used to direct selection for mutant cells; iv) multiple fluorescence-based long linker arm nucleotides assay (mf-LLA) technology, for the detection of substitutional mutations; v) detection of alterations in the TP53 locus using a (CA) array as the target for the screening; and vi) PCR analysis of lymphocytes for the presence of the BCL2 t(14:18) translocation. The relative merits of these molecular methods are discussed, and a comparison made with more "traditional" methods.

NK-mediated elimination of mutant lymphocytes that have lost expression of MHC class I molecules

Mutant cells generated in vivo can be eliminated when mutated gene products are presented as altered MHC/peptide complexes and recognized by T cells. Diminished expression of MHC/peptide complexes enables mutant cells to escape recognition by T cells. In the present study, we tested the hypothesis that mutant lymphocytes lacking expression of MHC class I molecules are eliminated by autologous NK cells. In H-2b/k F1 mice, the frequency of H-2Kb-negative T cells was higher than that of H-2Kk-negative T cells. The frequency of H-2K-deficient T cells increased transiently after total body irradiation. During recovery from irradiation, H-2Kk-negative T cells disappeared more rapidly than H-2Kb-negative T cells. The disappearance of H-2K-deficient T cells was inhibited by administration of Ab against asialo-GM1. H-2Kk-negative T cells showed higher sensitivity to autologous NK cells in vitro than H-2Kb/k heterozygous or H-2Kb-negative T cells. Adding syngeneic NK cells to in vitro cultures prevented emergence of mutant cells lacking H-2Kk expression but had little effect on the emergence of mutant cells lacking H-2Kb expression. Results in the H-2b/k F1 strain correspond with the sensitivity of parental H-2-homozygous cells in models of marrow graft rejection. In H-2b/d F1 mice, there was no significant difference between the frequencies of H-2Kb-negative and H-2Kd-negative T cells, although the frequencies of mutant cells were different after radiation exposure among the strains examined. H-2b/d F1 mice also showed rapid disappearance of the mutant T cells after irradiation, and administration of Ab against asialo-GM1 inhibited the disappearance of H-2K-deficient T cells in H-2b/d F1 mice. Our results provide direct evidence that autologous NK cells eliminate mutant cell populations that have lost expression of self-MHC class I molecules.

Interindividual variation in mitotic recombination

Mitotic recombination (MR) between homologous chromosomes is a mutational event that results in loss of heterozygosity in half of the segregants at mitosis. Loss of heterozygosity may have important biological consequences. The purpose of this study was to describe human variation in the spontaneous frequency of MR. Using an immunoselection technique for isolating the somatic mutations that result in loss of expression of one of the codominant alleles at the HLA-A locus, we have measured the frequency and molecular basis of somatic mutations in lymphocytes from a population of young adults. Mutations were classified as being the result of intragenic changes, major deletions, or MR. Here we show that the MR mutation frequency in females was significantly greater than that in males but that intragenic mutation frequency showed no association with sex. Individual variation in MR frequency ranged over more than two orders of magnitude and was not normally distributed. Furthermore, the observed number of individuals from whom no mutants resulting from MR were obtained was significantly greater than was expected. The endogenous level of MR may be under genetic control. Given the association of loss of heterozygosity with cancer initiation and progression, low endogenous MR may confer a reduced lifetime risk of cancer, and the converse may apply.

Erythrocyte as a potential model for study of lifelong somatic mutations

The detection and measurement of somatic cell mutation in vivo is an important subject of research for the assessment of human cancer risk induced by various environmental genotoxic factors. The possible mechanisms which influence the persistence of mutant cells of the hematoimmune system in the peripheral blood are presented. The erythroid system is a system which accumulates mutational lesions and so stably generates red blood cells with various phenotypic changes.

Chromosome loss with concomitant duplication and recombination both contribute most to loss of heterozygosity in vitro

Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) plays an important role in the expression of recessive mutations in mammalian cells. To gain insight into the rate and mechanisms of LOH the autosomal HLA-A gene was used as a model system. Spontaneous HLA-A2 mutants originated with a rate of respectively 4.1 x 10(-6) and 6.9 x 10(-6) per cell per generation in TK6 and WI-L2-NS, two isogenic lymphoblastoid cell lines which differ in TP53 status. The rate of loss of HLA-A2 is 10-50 times higher compared to the mutation rate of the X-linked HPRT gene. The homozygous TP53 mutation in WI-L2-NS had no effect on the rate of HLA-A2 loss or the spectrum of these mutations. Microsatellite analysis of most of the HLA-A2 mutants (84%) showed LOH for multiple markers on chromosome arm 6p telomeric of a recombination breakpoint, LOH for all 6p markers, or LOH for markers on both the 6p- and 6q-arms. Cytogenetic analysis showed that these mechanisms gave mutant cells which harbored two intact chromosomes 6 and which were indistinguishable from non-mutant cells. Therefore, loss of HLA-A2 is mainly caused by somatic recombination (33-50%) or chromosome loss with duplication of the remaining chromosome (34-40%). These findings correspond to the mechanisms behind loss of the wild-type RBI allele in retinoblastoma and suggest that both somatic recombination and chromosome loss followed by duplication contribute to tumorigenesis.

Frequency of spontaneous and induced micronuclei in the peripheral blood of aging mice

The mouse peripheral blood micronucleus assay, a measure of DNA damage in erythroblastic cells, was used to determine: (1) the incidence of spontaneously occurring micronucleated reticulocytes (MNRETs) as a function of age, and (2) the induction of micronuclei following treatment of young and old animals with mitomycin C. Male C57BL/6 mice, 92 weeks of age, exhibited a significantly higher frequency of spontaneously occurring peripheral blood MNRETs than mice that were 6 or 10 weeks of age. Mice that were 5-6 weeks or 91-92 weeks old were treated with one dose, or two consecutive doses of mitomycin C; this resulted in dose-related increases in the frequency of MNRETs. Mitomycin C, at a single dose of 1 or 2 mg/kg, induced one-third as many MNRETs in the older animals as compared to the younger animals. When treated with a split dose of mitomycin C (total dose 0.5 to 2 mg/kg), older animals displayed on average two-thirds the mutagenic response of the younger animals. However, analysis of variance performed on these data indicated that the age of the animals did not have a significant effect on their mutagenic response to mitomycin C at any dose level. It appears that aging mice may not be more sensitive to the mutagenic effects of chemically-induced DNA damage than younger mice, suggesting that the higher spontaneous mutation frequency in older mice could be the result of an increased load of accumulated DNA damage.

Stimulated rapid expression in vitro for early detection of in vivo T-cell receptor mutations induced by radiation exposure

The T-cell receptor (TCR) mutation assay for in vivo somatic mutations is a sensitive indicator of exposure to ionizing radiation. However, this assay cannot be immediately applied after radiation exposure because expression of a mutant phenotype may require as long as several months. In the present study, we eliminate this time lag by stimulating lymphocytes with a mitogen that can accelerate the turnover of TCR protein expression in T-cells. When lymphocytes obtained from healthy donors were irradiated with various doses of X-rays and cultured with human interleukin-2 after phytohemagglutinin (PHA) pulse stimulation, the mutant frequency (MF) of CD4+ T-cells increased dose dependently during the first 7 days, then decreased rapidly due to the growth disadvantage of mutant cells. This suggests that PHA stimulation can shorten the expression time of a mutant phenotype to within a week after radiation exposure. The relationship between radiation dose and TCR MF on the seventh day was best fitted by a linear-quadratic dose-response model. We applied this improved TCR mutation assay to gynecological cancer patients who received 5 days of localized radiotherapy, totaling about 10 Gy. The in vivo TCR MF in the patients did not change within a week after radiotherapy, whereas the in vitro TCR MF of PHA-stimulated lymphocytes from the same patients significantly increased 7 days after initiating culture. The estimated mean radiation dose to the peripheral blood lymphocytes of the cancer patients was about 0.9 Gy, based on the in vitro linear-quadratic dose-response curve. This estimated dose was close to that described in a previous report on unstable-type chromosome aberrations from cervical cancer patients after receiving the same course of radiotherapy. On the basis of these findings, we propose that the improved TCR mutation assay is a useful biological dosimeter for recent radiation exposure.

Isolation and molecular characterization of spontaneous mutants of lymphoblastoid cells with extended loss of heterozygosity

The human major histocompatibility complex comprising the HLA class I and II genes provides a versatile source of natural heterozygous loci. This polymorphic genetic system allows analysis of the mechanistic aspects of loss of heterozygosity (LOH), a major phenomenon observed at tumor suppressor genes in human cancer cells. Four lymphoblastoid cell lines, ORI, TK6, WI-L2-NS and VH, were used to adjust current HLA immunoselection protocols to quantify loss of HLA-A2 in human lymphoblastoid cell lines. The modified selection protocol was used to isolate independent spontaneous HLA-A2 mutants from the lymphoblastoid cell line ORI. The frequency of spontaneous loss of HLA-A2 in ORI was 1.7 x 10(-5). By HLA typing 35 spontaneous HLA-A2 mutants, we showed that 74% of the HLA-A2 mutants also lost expression of the HLA-B allele, which is located on the same haplotype as HLA-A2. Microsatellites on both arms of chromosome 6 were used for molecular characterization of the spontaneous HLA-A2 mutants. Loss of heterozygosity at various loci on the p-arm or loss of an entire chromosome 6 was found in 80% of the mutants. Surprisingly, it appeared that a presumed mitotic recombination event in the cell line ORI itself had resulted in homozygosity of all markers distal from the HLA locus up to the telomere. This greatly limited the detection of mitotic recombination, resulting in LOH up to the telomere, on the short arm of chromosome 6 in this cell line. However, gene dosage analysis detected two copies of the remaining D6S265 allele in mutants which showed LOH at various loci along the p-arm. This suggested that recombination resulted in LOH in these mutants. The lymphoblastoid cell line TK6 did contain informative microsatellites along the complete chromosome 6. Mutants of TK6 either retained heterozygosity of all p-arm markers, showed LOH of all p-arm markers or showed loss from a breakpoint up to the telomere. These data indicate that recombination and chromosome loss both are important mechanisms involved in loss of the HLA-A2 allele in vitro. Such mechanisms may be involved in LOH in vivo and contribute to loss of tumor suppressor alleles.

Similarity of in vivo somatic mutations at an autosomal adenine phosphoribosyltransferase locus between T- and B-cells in human peripheral blood

In vivo somatic mutations have been detected at several human loci by using clonal cultures of peripheral blood T-cells. It has not been fully understood whether or not the somatic mutations in T-cells are similar to those of other cell types. To address this issue, we cloned, from human peripheral blood, T- and B-cells with mutations at an autosomal adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (APRT) locus. For the efficient detection of somatic mutations at the APRT locus, a blood sample from a human individual heterozygous for germline APRT deficiency was used. T- and B-cells deficient in APRT enzyme activity were cloned from peripheral blood mononuclear cells using a selecting agent, 2,6-diaminopurine. The APRT-deficient mutant frequencies were on the order of 10(-4) in both T- and B-cells. The single-strand conformation polymorphism analysis of the APRT DNA of mutant B-cell clones suggested that the molecular mechanisms leading to the APRT deficiency in B-cells were similar to those in T-cells. Our observations suggest that both the frequency and the mode of in vivo somatic mutations occurring spontaneously at general autosomal loci in B-cells are similar to those in T-cells.

Normal mutation frequencies of somatic cells in patients receiving growth hormone therapy

The number of reported cases of malignancy developing in growth hormone (GH) users worldwide has increased to more than 40. However, the causal relationship between GH administration and the occurrence of malignancies is still uncertain. We investigated somatic cell mutation frequencies (Mfs) or variant frequency (Vf) at three gene loci in patients with pituitary dwarfism receiving GH therapy to clarify the genetic effect of GH. Eighty-eight patients receiving GH therapy for at least 3 months and 42 age-matched healthy controls were studied. Mfs at hypoxanthineguanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) and T-cell receptor (TCR) loci in GH users were not significantly higher than in the controls. Although a few patients seemed to have a slightly increased Vf at the glycophorin A (GPA) locus, the difference was not statistically significant. In addition, there was no tendency for the Mfs (Vf) at these loci to increase with the duration of the GH therapy. These data seem to exclude the possibility that GH induces genetic instability in patients with pituitary dwarfism who are receiving GH therapy.

Late effects of radiation on the human immune system: an overview of immune response among the atomic-bomb survivors

The studies of the late effects of atomic-bomb (A-bomb) radiation on the immune system were started about 20 years after the bombings in 1945. The most remarkable late effects of radiation are the functional and quantitative abnormalities of T and B cells in survivors exposed to high doses (> or = 1.0 Gy). Abnormalities of T-cell immunity include (1) a decreased proportion of CD3+ T cells in peripheral blood lymphocytes, particularly the proportion of CD4+ CD45RA+ naive T cells (study period 1987-91); (2) an increased frequency of CD4- and CD8- (double negative) alpha beta + T cells (1987-91); and (3) functional defects in T-cell responses to mitogens and alloantigens (1974-85). B-cell abnormalities include: (1) a significant increase in the proportion of B cells among peripheral lymphocytes (1987-91); (2) an increase in serum immunoglobulin A levels in females and immunoglobulin M and the incidence of rheumatoid factor in both sexes (1987-89); and (3) an increased level of anti-Epstein-Barr virus antibody titer (1987-90). In contrast, suggestive (0.05 < p < 0.1) or not significant (p > 0.1) dose effects were observed for the number and function of natural killer cells (1983-91), and benign monoclonal gammopathy (1979-87). In addition, studies initiated sooner after the bombing such as the incidence of autoimmune diseases (1958-87), systemic bacterial infections (1954-67), and granulocyte functions (1947-79) also show little dose-effects. Thus, A-bomb radiation induced the alteration of the balance/interaction between the T- and B-cell subsets--specifically, a decrease in the T-cell population and an increase in the B-cell population in the periphery.

Mutation frequency in human blood cells increases with age

Using either the colony formation assay or flow cytometry, it is feasible to measure the frequency of rare mutant lymphocytes or erythrocytes in human peripheral blood. Accordingly, we have investigated the mutant cell frequencies of the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase and T-cell receptor genes in T lymphocytes and of the glycophorin A gene in erythrocytes of several hundred persons aged 0-96 years. The mutant frequency of every one of these genes increased significantly with age. A simple accumulation of mutations in hematopoietic stem cells over time may explain the age-dependent increase in the frequency of glycophorin A mutants. In contrast, a balance between mutant cell generation and loss should be taken into account for the mechanism of the increase of T-cell mutations.

Somatic cell mutation frequency at the HPRT, T-cell antigen receptor and glycophorin A loci in Cockayne syndrome

Skin fibroblasts of patients with Cockayne syndrome (CS) are hypersensitive to the lethal or mutagenic effect of ultraviolet light, which may cause genetic instability. Up to now, however, no systematic study of in vivo somatic cell mutation in CS cells has been reported. This article describes our investigation of the mutation frequencies (Mfs) at three different loci, i.e. hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT), T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) and glycophorin A (GPA), in six patients with CS. Mfs at the HPRT and TCR loci were found to be within the normal range as determined in age-matched controls. In the GPA locus of two patients, there was a slight increase, but it was much smaller than that reported in other DNA repair deficient syndromes. The frequency of spontaneous HPRT mutation in Epstein-Barr virus transformed B-lymphoblastoid cells derived from CS patients was similar to that in cells from normal children. The molecular characterization of the representative HPRT mutant T cell clones from CS patients did not show any structural alterations. These results may explain, at least in part, why CS is not associated with predisposition to cancer.

Frequent involvement of visible chromosomal deletion in X-ray-induced mutants at the HLA-A locus in human T-lymphocytes

Mutant T-lymphocytes at the HLA-A locus were isolated using a recently developed flow-cytometric assay either immediately after drawing blood (in vivo mutants) or after X-irradiation in vitro. Mutants were subsequently propagated clonally for cytogenetic and molecular analyses. Among the 38 in vivo mutants, none contained an abnormal chromosome 6 on which the HLA-A locus resides (6p21.3). In contrast, mutants recovered after in vitro irradiation frequently carried abnormalities in the short arm of chromosome 6: 11/19 and 5/5 independent mutants for the 1-Gy and 2-Gy groups, respectively. Characteristically, the majority of the aberrations were deletions, commonly involving chromosome 6p21-p23. Because chromosomal deletions involving the selected gene are rare among radiation-induced mutants at the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (chromosome X) and thymidine kinase (chromosome 17) loci, the HLA-A locus can be considered as highly prone to chromosomal deletions after radiation exposure. It is generally believed that ionizing radiation randomly breaks DNA, and the higher frequency of chromosomal deletions at the HLA-A locus is unlikely to be due to preferential induction but more likely to the better survivability of the deletion-bearing mutants. Consequently, the results suggest that the human genome is quite heterogeneous with regard to the survivability of cells bearing a chromosomal deletion including different loci.

Increased rate of spontaneous mitotic recombination in T lymphocytes from a Bloom's syndrome patient using a flow-cytometric assay at HLA-A locus

Bloom's syndrome (BS) is an autosomal recessive disorder conferring high propensity for cancer and displaying a high degree of genetic instability; the frequency of sister chromatid exchange is characteristically 10 times above background. The symmetrical four-armed chromatid interchanges are much more readily detected in peripheral blood lymphocytes of BS patients, suggesting that the frequency of somatic recombination is also increased. In the present study, the rate of spontaneous loss of HLA-A allele expression was estimated following fluctuation analysis in cultured T lymphocytes using a flow-cytometric assay. It was found to be 10 times or more higher than normal in lymphocytes from a BS patient. Molecular and chromosome analyses showed that all 13 independent variants from the patient were most likely derived from somatic recombinations. Further tests for loss of heterozygosity at a closely linked proximal locus, HLA-DQA1, showed that as many as half of the recombinants retained heterozygosity irrespective of the donor. The results suggest that the HLA region is hyperrecombinogenic in somatic cells and that the elevated recombination rate in BS cells results from the general increase at ordinary sites and not from random creation of unusual sites for recombination.

Effect of dietary restriction on in vivo somatic mutation in mice

Dietary restriction is the one experimental variable which has been shown reproducibly to retard ageing. The effect of dietary restriction on in vivo mutation was studied in mice by feeding experimental mice 60% of the amount eaten by control mice and measuring mutations in lymphocytes at the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyl transferase locus at 4 weeks, 6 months and 12 months of age. Dietary restriction markedly decreased the age-associated accumulation of mutations observed in control mice, which suggests that somatic mutation is involved in the ageing process and that the majority of in vivo mutations result from dietary factors.