Medulloblastoma in adults: survival and prognostic factors

Prognostic factors related to overall survival in adolescent and young adults with medulloblastoma: a systematic review

Background

Medulloblastoma is a rare diagnosis among adolescents and young adults (AYA). Though prognostic factors and treatment are well characterized among children with medulloblastoma, equivalent data for AYA are sparse. We conducted a systematic review to identify predictors of survival among AYA with medulloblastoma.

Methods

We searched for primary studies of AYA (age 15–39 at diagnosis) with medulloblastoma in high-income countries within OVID MEDLINE, EMBASE, and EBM Reviews-Cochrane library databases from inception to August 2020. Patient demographics, primary outcomes, and univariate and multivariable data on all prognostic factors were collected from included studies. Prognosticators were characterized as patient, disease, or treatment-related.

Results

We identified 18 articles. 5-year overall survival ranged between 40% and 89%, while disease-free survival ranged from 49% to 89%. Study quality was low as assessed by the Quality in Prognostic factor Studies tool. Though meta-analyses were not possible due heterogeneity, narrative summaries suggested that lower disease burden, superior postoperative functional status, and higher doses and larger fields of radiation were associated with improved survival. Reported chemotherapy regimens were heterogeneous in timing, agents, and relationship with radiation, precluding meaningful comparisons. Only one study included molecular subgroups for analysis, with the majority (76.5%) of tumors classified as Sonic Hedgehog (SHH).

Conclusions

Prognostication and treatment of AYA medulloblastoma is limited by a dearth of primary evidence and lack of specificity for patients aged 15–39. Dedicated prospective trials to delineate the benefit of various chemotherapy and radiation regimens are required in this population to identify prognosticators and ideal treatment regimens.

Prognostic Factors in Adult Medulloblastoma. A Clinico-Pathologic Study

Aims and background.

Medulloblastoma in adults is a rare tumor. The small number of cases in the reported series has not permitted a definite assessment of the prognostic role of clinical, pathologic and cell kinetics factors. The largest series of medulloblastoma in adults treated in a single institution is herein reported.

Methods.

The clinical, therapeutic, pathologic and proliferation features of medulloblastoma in 44 adult patients (> 18 years) were analyzed retrospectively with regard to postoperative survival. The proliferation potential of each tumor was evaluated by the immunohistochemical demonstration of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and Ki-67, clone MIB-1, in paraffin sections.

Results.

The overall 5- and 10-year survival rates were 40% and 35.6%, respectively. Significant factors in predicting a longer postoperative survival were: age < 37 years, decade of management (1977-1990), radiotherapy (50-55 Gy on the posterior fossa and 30-35 Gy on the spinal cord) and nuclear isomorphism. When corrected for adequacy of radiotreatment, desmoplastic type and differentiation were significantly correlated with a shorter survival. The PCNA-labelling index (LI) ranged from 34.5 to 82.2%, the MIB-1-LI ranged from 9.6 to 64.7%. No association was found between PCNA- or MIB-1-LI values and microscopic features, or between LI values and prognosis.

Conclusions.

Contrary to a general assumption, desmoplastic medulloblastoma and differentiated medulloblastoma are negative prognostic factors in adequately radiotreated adult patients. This may possibly be referred to lower radiosensitivity of these tumor variants. The LI with PCNA or Ki-67 is of no help in identifying aggressive tumors.

The Prognostic Factors and Outcome of Adult Medulloblastoma: Where We Stand

We designed our study to analyze the prognostic factors and treatment outcomes of adult medulloblastoma patients who received postoperative craniospinal irradiation. Fourty-three patients who were treated due to medulloblastoma at Istanbul University, Institute of Oncology between 1990 and 2013 were retrospectively analyzed. All of the patients were older than 18 years, with a median age of 27 years (range, 18–51 years). In 40 (93%) patients, total resection of the tumor was achieved, and 3 (7%) patients had undergone a subtotal tumoral resection. Risk assessment revealed 7 high-risk and 36 standard-risk patients. All patients received postoperative craniospinal irradiation, delivering a median craniospinal dose of 36 Gy, with an additional boost to the posterior fossa up to 54 Gy. Fifteen patients received chemotherapy. The median follow-up was 62 months (range, 3–213 months). The 5-year, 10-year, overall, and disease-free survival rates were 63%, 51%, 66%, and 55%, respectively. Univariate analysis revealed that hydrocephalus, initial local recurrence, subtotal resection in primary surgery, initial Karnofsky performance status ≤70, duration of symptoms shorter than 30 days, and primary site dose &lt; 54 Gy were found to be negative prognostic factors. Toxicity was moderate. The main therapy in adult medulloblatoms is craniospinal irradiation following surgery. The prognostic factors and outcomes of the patients in our study are concordant with previous reports in the literature.

Outcomes of adult medulloblastoma treated with a multimodality approach: A tertiary cancer center experience

OBJECTIVES

Adult medulloblastoma (AMB) is a rare central nervous system tumor. We aimed to analyze the treatment outcomes of AMB treated at our institute with surgery followed by craniospinal irradiation (CSI) and adjuvant chemotherapy.

METHODS

We retrospectively evaluated the treatment charts of 31 patients of AMB treated from 2003-2011. The patient demography, treatment details and survival data were collected in a predesigned proforma. Kaplan Meier method was used to analyze disease free survival (DFS) and the impact of prognostic factors was determined by univariate analysis (log rank test).

RESULTS

Male: Female ratio was 21:10. Cerebrospinal fluid dissemination was noted in 16% cases. CSI (36 Gray at 1.8 Gray/fraction to entire neuraxis and 20 Gray at 2 Gray/fraction boost to posterior fossa) was used in all cases. 26 patients received adjuvant chemotherapy (carboplatin plus etoposide). Median follows up was 26.85 months (9.47-119.73 months). The estimated 3 and 5 years DFS was found to be 84.9% and 50.7% respectively. On univariate analysis, tumor located laterally had a trend towards better DFS (HR 3.04; 95%CI 0.722 to 12.812; P = 0.07) compared to midline tumors. Other factors like adjuvant chemotherapy, age, gender, surgical extent had no statistically significant impact on survival.

CONCLUSION

The results of our study (largest series from India) show that the regimen of surgery, adjuvant CSI and chemotherapy is feasible and confers descent survival. AMB patients should be treated with a multimodality approach in a tertiary care centre.

Radiotherapy for adult medulloblastoma: Long term result from a single institution. A review of prognostic factors and why we do need a multi-institutional cooperative program

AIM

We retrospectively analyzed our Institution experience with these patients. The endpoints of the analysis were overall survival (OS), disease-free survival (DFS), local control (LC), metastasis free survival (MFS); results were compared with the literature.

BACKGROUND

Medulloblastoma in adult patients is a very rare disease; the 5 and 10-year overall survival rates range between 33-78% and 27-56%, respectively. The collection of more clinical data is strongly needed.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

From September 1975 to October 2006, we treated 16 adult patients (9 males and 7 females) with a histological diagnosis of medulloblastoma. Acute and late toxicities were scored according to RTOG toxicity scale. Karnofski performance status (KPS) and neurological performance status (NPS) pre- and post-RT were reported. Median age was 27 years (range 18-53 years). All the patients received cranio-spinal irradiation, two patients were also given chemotherapy. Median follow-up period was 121.5 months.

RESULTS

In January 2014, 10/16 patients were alive without evidence of disease, 6/16 died with progressive disease (1 local and spinal, 3 spinal and 2 extraneural). Ten-year LC, OS, DFS, MFS were, respectively, 84%, 67%, 60% and 59%. Univariate analysis shows that gross total resection is associated with better survival. No acute or late G3-G4 toxicity was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

This experience and the analysis of the literature confirm the efficacy of postoperative RT but also the need of large datasets to better define prognostic factors and the possible role of the association of chemotherapy.

Population-based Study of Medulloblastoma: Outcomes in Alberta from 1975 to 1996

Background:

The purpose of this study was to determine incidence, survival rate, and prognostic factors as well as the frequency of Collins’ Law Violators (CLVs) in an unselected population of medulloblastoma patients. Collins’ Law dictates that ’cure’ of a child with a tumor occurs after a period that includes the child’s age at diagnosis plus 9 months.

Methods:

Using the Alberta Cancer Registry a population-based review identified 49 patients with medulloblastoma (19 adults, 30 children) diagnosed from 1975-96. Pathology was reviewed in all cases. All patients had surgical resection, followed by radiotherapy in 47 patients and chemotherapy in 17.

Results:

The overall 5-year survival was 50%. There was a trend for the extent of resection to be associated with a longer survival (Long rank test, p< 0.06) but this was not significant. Tumor recurrence occurred a median of 22.4 months (range, 6.4-192.3) after diagnosis and median survival after recurrence was 9.3 months (range, 0.4-64.9). The survival curve did not appear to plateau but was affected by tumor-related deaths in 3 (21.4%) of the 21 long-term survivors diagnosed in childhood. These three patients had recurrences a mean of 11.7 years after diagnosis and are designated as CLVs.

Conclusions:

The survival rate in an unselected population of patients with medulloblastoma is poor. Aggressive resection of the tumors prolongs survival. The Collins’ Law Violators were relatively common and we suggest this concept be abandoned in medulloblastoma.

The role of radiotherapy in adult medulloblastoma: long-term single-institution experience and a review of the literature

Medulloblastoma (MB) occurs infrequently in adult patients and standard treatment is still controversial. We report our long-term, single-institution experience of adult MB and a review of the literature. We analysed adult patients with histologically proved MB treated by postoperative radiotherapy. Primary endpoints were local control (LC), disease-free survival (DFS), and overall survival (OS). Acute toxicity was reported according to CTC-NCI score vers. 3.0 and specific neuropsychological assessment analysis was performed to define late brain toxicity. From 1990-2008, 13 patients were treated by craniospinal (CSI, 12/13) or cranial irradiation (1/13, because of bad clinical conditions). Median follow up was 101 months (64-218). Complete radiological response was observed in 12/13 patients and a partial response in 1/13. Ten-year LC, OS, and DFS were 91, 76, and 84%, respectively. Two patients died because of local and spinal progression after 13 and 62 months. Acute G3 haematological toxicity (RTOG score) was observed for one patient only. The neuropsychological analysis did not reveal late toxicity related to brain radiotherapy. This experience confirms the efficacy and safety of radiotherapy in adult MB patients, resulting in very interesting 10-year LC and OS.

Reappraisal of clinical outcome in adult medulloblastomas with emphasis on patterns of relapse

BACKGROUND

Clinical outcome and prognostic factors were assessed in adult medulloblastoma patients, with emphasis on patterns of relapse.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Records of 36 consecutive adult patients with medulloblastoma were reviewed. Patients were classified into 2 prognostic groups according to the extent of disease and quality of surgical excision based on the early postoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings. Standard-risk (SR) patients (n = 11) received postoperative craniospinal radiation therapy (RT) only, 36 Gy, 1.8 Gy per daily fraction, with a 18 Gy boost to the posterior cerebral fossa (PCF). High-risk (HR) patients (n = 25) received additional adjuvant chemotherapy.

RESULTS

With a median follow-up of 46 months (range 5-155), 19 patients experienced tumour relapse. Sites of relapse(s) included tumour bed in 6 patients, resulting in a PCF control of 83.4%. Three-year overall survival (OS) and progression-free survival (PFS) were 67.3% and 57.4%, respectively. The comparison of the HR and SR populations demonstrated significant differences in OS (p = 0.005) and PFS (p = 0.001). Quality of surgical excision and extent of disease beyond the PCF were predictive factors for OS (p = 0.04, p = 0.001, respectively) and PFS (p = 0.004, and p = 0.02, respectively).

CONCLUSION

The quality of resection was a significant prognostic factor, suggesting that surgery should be as extensive as possible. Systematic postoperative MRI allowed accurate selection of SR patients for whom RT alone was enough to obtain high local control. Every effort should be made to avoid RT disruption. Increased delay led to worse outcome.

[Medulloblastomas: review]

INTRODUCTION

The term of "medulloblastoma" refers to cerebellar tumors belonging to the family of primitive neuro-ectodermic tumors (PNET). Medulloblastomas represent 40% of cerebellar tumors, 15 to 20% of brain tumors and the first cause of malignant brain tumors in childhood. Seventy to 80% of cases are diagnosed in children versus 20 to 30% in adults.

UPDATED KNOWLEDGE

Diagnosis is based on clinical and radiological exams, and proved on pathological analysis in association with molecular biology. Treatment comprises surgery, craniospinal radiotherapy except for children under five years of age and chemotherapy according to age and high-risk criteria. Medulloblastoma is a rare case of a central nervous system tumor which is radio- and chemo-sensitive. Treatment goals are, on one hand, to improve the survival rates and, on the other hand, to avoid late neurocognitive, neuroendocrine and orthopedic side effects related to radiation therapy, notably in children. The prognosis is relatively good, with a five year survival rate over 75% after complete resection of a localized tumor although sequelae may still compromise outcome.

PERSPECTIVES AND CONCLUSION

Management of patients with medulloblastoma implies a multidisciplinary approach combining the contributions of neurosurgery, neuroradiology, pediatric oncology, neuro-oncology and radiotherapy teams.

Survival and prognostic factors in a series of adults with medulloblastomas

OBJECT

In this article, the authors report their experience in the management of adult patients with medulloblastoma at their institution to identify prognostic factors important for survival and disease control.

METHODS

Between 1977 and 2005, 27 patients who were >or=16 years old and had medulloblastoma were treated consecutively. There were 16 women and 11 men with a median age of 21 years (range 16-54 years). Gross-total resection was performed in 21 patients, subtotal (>or=90%) in 2, incomplete in 1, and biopsy in 3 patients. Six patients had the desmoplastic variant, and 21 patients presented with classic medulloblastoma. Staging according to the Chang classification showed 4 patients with tumors invading the brainstem (2 with Stage T3b and 2 with Stage T4), 3 patients with metastases (2 with Stage M2 and 1 with Stage M3), and 1 patient in whom the stage was unknown (Stage MX) who died 10 days postoperatively. Twenty patients were assigned to the standard-risk group and 7 to the high-risk group. All patients except the one whose status was classified as Stage MX underwent craniospinal radiotherapy at our institution. Seven patients received chemotherapy before radiotherapy.

RESULTS

The 5- and 10-year overall survival rates for the present study were 81 and 62%, respectively. The median overall survival time was 17.7 years. The 5- and 10-year event-free survival rates were 72 and 57%, respectively. The median event-free survival time was 17.9 years. Univariate analysis showed that survival was significantly correlated with sex (women had a better prognosis than men) and M stage (patients without metastases had a better outcome). Patient age, duration of symptoms, Karnofsky Performance Scale score at presentation, hydrocephalus, tumor location, brainstem invasion, extent of resection, histological subtype, preradiotherapy chemotherapy, risk group, and period of presentation were not significant variables. Multivariate analysis identified sex and M stage as well as the period of presentation as independent prognostic factors for overall and event-free survival times. Eleven patients suffered tumor recurrence within a median time of 4.2 years. The posterior fossa was not the most common site of recurrence, and delayed recurrence was not rare. All patients in whom the tumor recurred have died despite aggressive treatments. The median survival time after diagnosis of recurrence was 2.5 years. Questionnaires on quality of life and cognition showed high scores in favor of limited negative effects in the perception of mental and physical health after treatment. The authors observed 1 supposed second malignancy (thyroid carcinoma) and no evidence of pituitary dysfunction.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term survival is possible in adults treated for medulloblastoma. Although rare, metastasis seeding at presentation is a poor prognostic factor. The possibility of delayed recurrence necessitates close follow-up of all patients. Tumor recurrences should be treated with aggressive therapies as some patients may have sustained response. Adjuvant chemotherapy should be given to high-risk patients, but its role in reducing recurrences, particularly distant ones, remains unclear in the standard-risk group.

Adult neuroectodermal tumors of posterior fossa (medulloblastoma) and of supratentorial sites (stPNET)

Medulloblastoma and supratentorial primitive neuroectodermal tumors are rare diseases in adults. Due to this rarity, few prospective clinical trials have been conducted on medulloblastoma in adults, investigations being based exclusively on retrospective studies; the populations considered in literature are small, and the different treatments given span decades, during which diagnostic procedures, neurosurgical skills and radiotherapy techniques have changed. Unlike pediatric patients, adult medulloblastoma patients have been treated according to risk-adapted therapeutic strategies in only a few series and despite risk-tailored treatments, 20-30% of patients experience recurrence. Although patients could respond to second line treatments, the prognosis of relapsed patients remains dismal. An important challenge for the future will be the biological characterization of medulloblastoma, with the identification of specific genetic patterns of patients with a better or a worse prognosis.

Molecular pathogenesis of adult brain tumors and the role of stem cells

Primary brain tumors consist of neoplasms with varied molecular defects, morphologic phenotypes, and clinical outcomes. The genetic and signaling abnormalities involved in tumor initiation and progression of the most prevalent adult primary brain tumors, including gliomas, meningiomas, and medulloblastomas, are described in this article. The current understanding of the cell-of-origin of these neoplasms is reviewed, which suggests that the malignant phenotype is propelled by cells with stem-like qualities. A comprehensive understanding of the molecular basis of transformation and the cell-of-origin of these neoplasms will enable the formulation of more targeted treatment alternatives that could improve survival and quality of life.

Long-term results of a prospective study on the treatment of medulloblastoma in adults

BACKGROUND

Because medulloblastoma (MB) is rare in adults, the few studies on this condition have been retrospective, and the follow-up has tended to be short. Furthermore, the different therapeutic strategies used in these patients has made it difficult to assess survival rates and prognostic factors.

METHODS

In 1989, a prospective Phase II trial was initiated to evaluate the efficacy of treatment for adults with MB. Patients were staged completely with a neuroradiologic examination of the brain and neuroaxis and by cerebrospinal fluid cytology, according to Chang's staging system. Low-risk patients received radiotherapy alone, whereas high-risk patients received 2 cycles of upfront chemotherapy followed by radiotherapy and adjuvant chemotherapy. The current article reports on the long-term results from that trial.

RESULTS

After a median follow up of 7.6 years, among a total of 36 adults with MB, the overall progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) rates at 5 years were 72% and 75%, respectively. In low-risk patients, the 5-year PFS rate was 80%, and the 5-year OS rate was 80%; in high-risk patients, the 5-year PFS rate was 69%, and the 5-year OS rate was 73%.

CONCLUSIONS

In adult patients with MB, long-term follow-up was essential for evaluating the real impact of treatments. Low-risk and high-risk patients did not differ significantly in terms of PFS or OS.

Histopathologic grading of adult medulloblastomas

BACKGROUND

Histopathologic evaluation of the degree and extent of anaplasia is a useful prognostic parameter in pediatric medulloblastomas. Whether the same applies to adult medulloblastomas is not known.

METHODS

The study included 74 adult patients with histologically confirmed medulloblastomas and retrospectively reassessed 67 cases with available slides for the presence of nodularity, collagen deposition (desmoplasia without nodules), and degree and extent of anaplasia.

RESULTS

Patients included 43 men and 31 women with the following age distribution: 18-40 years (84%); 41-50 years (9%); and 51-70 years (7%). At last follow-up, 56 patients were alive with a mean follow-up of 6.3 years (range, 0.1-20.8 years). A variety of treatments were employed during the study period, including postoperative radiation (85%) and chemotherapy (27%). Precise treatment modalities were unknown in 12% of patients. Anaplasia was absent (34%), mild (34%), moderate (27%), or severe (5%). Severe anaplasia was diffuse in 2 cases and focal in 1, although in the latter cases severe anaplasia was diffusely present at the time of disease recurrence. Male sex was associated with decreased 10-year recurrence-free survival (40% vs 66%; P = .021) and overall survival (38% vs 68%; P = .005). Severe anaplasia at first resection was found to be an independent predictor of decreased recurrence-free survival (P = .005) and overall survival (P = .015).

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of severe anaplasia in adult medulloblastomas is lower than in the pediatric population. Male sex and the presence of severe anaplasia at the time of first resection are predictors of decreased recurrence-free and overall survival. However, the significance of severe anaplasia should be regarded with caution based on the small number of tumors with this feature in the current study.

Common Strategy for Adult and Pediatric Medulloblastoma: A Multicenter Series of 253 Adults

PURPOSE

To assess prognostic factors for adults with medulloblastoma in a multicenter, retrospective study.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Data were collected by file review or mail inquiry for 253 adults treated between 1975 to 2004. Radiologists or surgeons assessed disease characteristics, such as volume and extension. Patients were classified as having either high- or standard-risk disease. Prognostic factors were analyzed.

RESULTS

Median patient age was 29 years. Median follow-up was 7 years. Radiotherapy was delivered in 246 patients and radiochemotherapy in 142. Seventy-four patients relapsed. Respective 5- and 10-year overall survival rates were 72% and 55%. Univariate analysis showed that survival significantly correlated with metastasis, postsurgical performance status, brainstem involvement, involvement of the floor of the fourth ventricle (V4), and radiation dose to the spine and to the posterior cerebral fossa (PCF). By multivariate analysis, brainstem, V4 involvement, and dose to the PCF were negative prognostic factors. In the standard-risk subgroup there was no overall survival difference between patients treated with axial doses of >or=34 Gy and patients treated with craniospinal doses <34 Gy plus chemotherapy.

CONCLUSION

We report the largest series of medulloblastoma in adults. Prognostic factors were similar to those observed in children. Results suggest that patients with standard-risk disease could be treated with radiochemotherapy, reducing doses to the craniospinal area, maintaining at least 50 Gy to the PCF. The role of chemotherapy for this group is still unclear. A randomized study should be performed to confirm these results, but because frequency is very low, such a study would be difficult.

Multifocal desmoplastic medulloblastoma in an african-american child with nevoid basal cell carcinoma (gorlin) syndrome. Case report

The authors present the case of a 2.5-year-old African-American boy with desmoplastic medulloblastoma (MB) and nevoid basal cell carcinoma syndrome (NBCCS), also known as Gorlin syndrome, an autosomal dominant disorder resulting from mutations in the patched (PTCH) gene that predisposes to neoplasias (including basal cell carcinomas [BCCs] and MB) and to widespread congenital malformations. The diagnosis of NBCCS was suspected based on the clinical examination, patient and family medical histories, and histopathological characteristics of the tumor. Radiotherapy was withheld. The diagnosis of NBCCS was confirmed by DNA testing, which revealed a novel mutation in the PTCH gene. This is the first report of an African-American child with MB diagnosed with NBCCS prior to radiotherapy. Although only a small number of patients with MB have NBCCS, the diagnosis must be considered because radiotherapy in such patients can lead to the formation of BCCs and other intracranial neoplasms within the irradiated field. This case emphasizes the importance of obtaining thorough family and patient medical histories and of carefully examining the patient and close relatives for signs of NBCCS to avoid the potentially devastating consequences of missing this diagnosis.

Central nervous system tumours in adolescents

Adolescents with brain tumours have been, and in most cases still are, haphazardly assigned, on referral, to either 'paediatric' or 'adult'-based treatment centres. In this age group, there is therefore a history of inconsistent treatment, delivery of inappropriate 'maturity-related' care and a reduced chance of gathering vital biological, clinical and treatment-related information germane to this group of patients and their tumours. These days, adolescents with brain tumours should be actively targeted for recruitment into clinical trials and admission into dedicated neuro-oncology centres or programmes that can deliver the necessary and age appropriate multidisciplinary management.

Medulloblastoma in adults: treatment results and prognostic factors

PURPOSE

To investigate the treatment outcome and prognostic factors of adult medulloblastoma patients who received postoperative craniospinal irradiation (RT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between 1983 and 2000, 30 adult patients (17 men and 13 women, age >or=16 years, median 27, range 16-45) underwent postoperative RT. The median duration of symptoms was 2 months (range 1-9). The tumor location was lateral in 16 (53%). A desmoplastic variant was seen in 12 (40%). Tumor resection was complete in 20 (67%) and incomplete in 10 (33%). All patients received craniospinal RT. The median dose to the whole brain was 40 Gy (range 36-51), to the posterior fossa 54 Gy (range 49-56), and to the spinal axis 36 Gy (range 24-40). The median interval between surgery and the start of RT was 31 days (range 12-69), and the median duration of RT was 45 days (range 34-89). Ten patients (33%) received adjuvant chemotherapy. The median follow-up was 51 months (range 5-215).

RESULTS

The 5- and 8-year overall survival and disease-free survival rates were 65% and 51% and 63% and 50%, respectively. Twelve patients (40%) developed relapse, with a median follow-up of 51 months. The posterior fossa was the most common site of relapse (6 patients). The median time to relapse was 26 months (range 4-78). Fifty percent of the relapses occurred after 2 years, 17% after 5 years. In univariate analysis, M stage and the interval between surgery and the start of RT were significant prognostic factors for disease-free survival. At 5 years, 70% of M0 patients were estimated to be disease-free, but none of the 3 M3 patients reached 5 years without recurrence (p = 0.0002). The 5-year disease-free survival rate for the patients whose interval between surgery and the start of RT was <3 weeks, between 3 and 6 weeks, and >6 weeks was 0%, 85%, and 75%, respectively (p = 0.002). The 5-year posterior fossa control rate for patients who received >or=54 Gy or <54 Gy to the posterior fossa was 91% and 33%, respectively (p = 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The survival results for medulloblastomas in adults compare favorably with those in children. However, late relapses, lateral tumor location, and desmoplastic histologic features are more frequent in adults. Spinal seeding at presentation is a poor prognostic factor for disease-free survival. A minimal dose of 54 Gy to the posterior fossa is essential for adequate tumor control. The interval between surgery and the start of RT, which was found to be a significant prognostic factor, is an interesting issue that requires further study.

Malignant pineal parenchymal tumors in adult patients: patterns of care and prognostic factors

OBJECTIVE

The aim of our study was to analyze patterns of care and to identify prognostic factors in patients at least 18 years of age who received radiotherapy for malignant pineal parenchymal tumors.

METHODS

In a multicenter, retrospective study, we analyzed data for 37 previously published cases and 64 patients treated at the participating institutions.

RESULTS

A total of 56 patients received postoperative radiotherapy, and 45 patients received primary radiotherapy. Chemotherapy was administered to 34 patients. The median follow-up period was 38 months, and median overall survival was 100 months. The variables that significantly influenced overall survival were the extent of disease (localized versus disseminated; P = 0.0002), differentiation (pineal parenchymal tumor of intermediate differentiation versus pineoblastoma; P = 0.001), and residual disease (> or = 50% versus < 50% reduction in size; P < 0.0001). In a multivariate analysis, the parameters turned out to be independent risk factors. The median survival in patients with local or spinal failure was 15 months. Local control was better in older patients (> or = 32 yr versus < 32 yr; P = 0.02). Spinal control was more successful in patients with pineal parenchymal tumors of intermediate differentiation than it was in patients with pineoblastomas (P = 0.03). Nine of 45 treatment failures occurred later than 5 years after treatment.

CONCLUSION

Stage, histological characteristics, and response are independent risk factors in adults with malignant pineal parenchymal tumors. Late relapses are common.

Adult medulloblastoma: prognostic factors and patterns of relapse

OBJECTIVE

To determine the patterns of relapse and the prognostic factors for adult medulloblastomas treated in the magnetic resonance imaging era.

METHODS

Between 1986 and 1996, 32 adult patients (age, > or =16 yr) with medulloblastomas confined to the craniospinal axis were treated in our institutions. Twenty cases involved classic histological features and 12 involved the desmoplastic variant. The Chang staging distribution was as follows: T1, 2; T2, 17; T3, 10; T4, 3; M0, 24; M1, 1; M2, 4; M3, 3. Brainstem invasion was present in nine patients. Lesions were midline in 13 cases and lateral in 19. Resection was complete in 17 cases, subtotal in 6, and partial in 5, with biopsy only in 4 cases. All patients received postoperative radiotherapy, with median doses of 36 Gy to the entire craniospinal axis and 55 Gy to the posterior fossa. Twenty-four patients received chemotherapy (20 before radiotherapy, 3 after radiotherapy, and 1 before and after radiotherapy).

RESULTS

With a median follow-up period of 5.4 years, 17 patients experienced recurrences. At 5 and 8 years, overall survival rates were 83 and 45% and disease-free survival rates were 57 and 40%, respectively. The 5- and 8-year posterior fossa control rates were 67 and 59%, respectively. Twenty-nine percent of all relapses occurred more than 5 years after treatment. The posterior fossa was the most common site of relapses. In univariate analyses, factors adversely affecting posterior fossa control were less than complete resection (P<0.001), the presence of brainstem invasion (P = 0.02), and the use of chemotherapy (P = 0.03). The overall radiotherapy duration was marginally significant in predicting posterior fossa control, with 5-year posterior fossa control rates of 81 and 49% for durations of less than 48 days and 48 days or more, respectively (P = 0.06). In a multivariate analysis, complete resection was predictive of improved posterior fossa control (P = 0.02) and disease-free survival (P = 0.02) rates. Of the eight low-risk patients who received radiotherapy alone, three experienced recurrences in the bone as the only site of relapse.

CONCLUSION

Late relapse is common among adult patients with medulloblastomas, and long-term follow-up monitoring is important. Because of the high risk of systemic failure among the low-risk patients treated with radiotherapy alone, the role of chemotherapy for this group of patients needs to be further investigated. Complete resection, the absence of brainstem invasion, and an overall radiotherapy duration of less than 48 days are important prognostic factors.

Expression of the neurotrophin receptor p75NTR in medulloblastomas is correlated with distinct histological and clinical features: evidence for a medulloblastoma subtype derived from the external granule cell layer

Medulloblastomas (MBs) are primitive neuroectodermal tumors (PNET) of the cerebellum. They represent the most frequent malignant pediatric brain tumors, but their origin still remains unresolved and controversial. MB cells correspond to different stages of neural development and differentiation as illustrated by their expression of neuronal and glial markers. In the present study, we examined the expression pattern of the common low-affinity neurotrophin receptor p75NTR in a series of 167 MBs by immunohistochemistry. While p75NTR was present in only 17% of classic MBs (CMB), we found expression of p75NTR in all desmoplastic (nodular) MBs (DMB) examined, and in 71% of those MBs with a significant desmoplastic component. Furthermore, both desmoplastic histology and p75NTR expression were present preferentially in those tumors of adolescents and adults that are frequently located laterally in the cerebellar hemispheres. In DMBs, p75NTR was expressed predominantly in the proliferative, reticulin-rich areas, which may show coexpression of GFAP. In the pale islands of DMB, p75NTR was expressed only weakly or was absent. The expression pattern showed an inverse relation to that of the synaptic vesicle protein synaptophysin that was predominant in p75NTR negative classic MBs. Since the neurotrophin receptor p75NTR is expressed in cells of the external granule cell layer (EGL) of the fetal cerebellum, our findings suggest that progenitor cells of the EGL are the cellular origin of a distinct subset of MB, namely the desmoplastic variant and MBs with a significant desmoplastic component.

The role of CT simulation in whole-brain irradiation

PURPOSE

Evidence is growing that incorrect field-shaping is a major cause of treatment failure in whole-brain irradiation (WBI). To evaluate the potential benefits of CT simulation in WBI we compared field-shaping based on 3D CT simulation to conventional 2D simulation.

METHODS

CT head scans were obtained from 20 patients. Conventional 2D planning was imitated by drawing the block contours on digitally reconstructed radiographs (DRR) by four radiotherapists. Critical parts of the target and the eye lenses were subsequently marked and planning was repeated using 3D information ("3D planning"). The results of both methods were compared by evaluation of the minimal distance from the field edge according to each site.

RESULTS

In conventional planning using DRR, major geographic mismatches (< -3 mm) occurred in the subfrontal region and both eye lenses with 1% each location. Minor mismatches (-3 to 0 mm) predominantly occurred in the contralateral lens (21%), ipsilateral lens (10%), and subfrontal region (9%). Close margins (0-5 mm) were most frequently noted at the contralateral lens (49%), ipsilateral lens (35 %), and the subfrontal region (28%). When 3D planning was used, mismatches were not found. However, close margins were inevitable at the ipsilateral lens (5%), subfrontal region (30%), and contralateral lens (70%).

CONCLUSIONS

CT simulation in WBI is significantly superior to conventional simulation with respect to complete coverage of the target volume and protection of the eye lenses. The narrow passage between the ocular lenses and lamina cribrosa represents a serious limitation. These patients are safely identified with CT simulation and can be referred for modified irradiation techniques.

Etoposide-carboplatin association as 'emergency' up-front chemotherapy in a case of life-threatening adult medulloblastoma

Medulloblastoma is a rare tumor in the adult population. Current therapies include surgery and irradiation. Unlike in children, chemotherapy is not commonly used, and its potential has poorly been investigated to date. We report the case of an adult patient with disseminated medulloblastoma and fulminant neurological deterioration, precluding craniospinal irradiation. Emergency chemotherapy consisting of carboplatin (400 mg/m2) and etoposide (500 mg/m2) with intrathecal (i.t.) administration of cytosar and hydrocortisone was initiated. Impressive clinical response was achieved after the first cycle of chemotherapy, with the complete disappearance of the lesions detected by MRI. After 3 courses of chemotherapy, the patient underwent craniospinal irradiation (36 Gy to the entire neuraxis and 54 Gy to the posterior fossa). Two years after surgery, the patient was well, with complete clinical recovery, and a new MRI confirmed the disappearance of the lesions. Given the dramatic efficacy of the etoposide-carboplatin association (combined with i.t. cytosar), this regimen has to be considered in an emergency setting and seems to be a very attractive candidate to be investigated as first line therapy for poor risk medulloblastoma in adults.

[Medulloblastoma in adults. Val-de-Grace hospital experience (1975-1994) and literature review]

PURPOSE

Retrospective analysis of prognostic factors in a series of 14 adult patients presenting with medulloblastoma treated by surgery and subsequent radiotherapy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Thirteen male and one female patients (mean age, 27 years; range 20-40) presenting with medulloblastoma were treated at the Val-de-Grâce hospital from 1975 to 1994. The mean delay between the initial symptoms and the diagnosis was 17 weeks (range, 2-76). The tumor was median in three cases, lateral in seven, and median and lateral in four. Eleven medulloblastomas belonged to the classical subtype and three others to the desmoplastic type. Patients were treated by surgery followed by external radiation therapy. The ablation was complete in four cases and incomplete in ten cases.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

Five- and ten-year overall survival rates were 63 and 25%, respectively. There was a trend toward a higher probability of survival for older patients (ie, for patients above 26 years of age) presenting with a desmoplastic central tumor treated by complete surgery and subsequent post-operative radiotherapy. Results are discussed in regard to the literature.

Multivariate analysis of prognostic factors in adult patients with medulloblastoma. Retrospective study of 156 patients

BACKGROUND

Medulloblastoma is a rare disease in adult patients, with an annual incidence rate of 0.05 per 100,000 per year. Results are, therefore, sparse and comprise small series over long periods. The real survival rate, the prognostic factors, the optimal postoperative radiation dose, and the role of adjuvant chemotherapy are still unknown for this disease in adults.

METHODS

The authors collected 156 cases of histologically proven medulloblastoma in patients older than 18 years of age who were treated between January 1975 and December 1991 in 13 French institutions. They analyzed the prognostic factors for survival and the impact of postoperative treatment on survival.

RESULTS

The 5- and 10-year event free survival rates, 61 and 48%, respectively, are similar to those observed in children. The median time to recurrence is 30 months, but late relapses after 5 years remain frequent. Multivariate analysis identified postoperative performance status, spinal axis radiation dose, fourth ventricular floor involvement, and desmoplastic histologic subtype as factors significantly correlated with event free survival. No benefit of concomitant chemotherapy was demonstrated, and complete resection resulted only in severely reduced postoperative performance status.

CONCLUSIONS

The prognostic factors in adult medulloblastoma are comparable to those of medulloblastoma in children, but a new parameter, postoperative performance status, was identified in this adult series. Postoperative craniospinal irradiation remains the standard treatment for adults with medulloblastoma. A reduced dose to the supratentorial compartment should be tested in a prospective protocol.