From cells to organoids: The evolution of blood-brain barrier technology for modelling drug delivery in brain cancer

The 3C (Cell Culture, Computer Simulation, Clinical Trial) Solution for Optimizing the 3R (Replace, Reduction, Refine) Framework during Preclinical Research Involving Laboratory Animals

Preclinical research has traditionally utilized laboratory animals to elucidate the safety, tolerability, pharmacokinetics, and pharmacodynamics of new chemical entities prior to human trials. The use of animal models has been pivotal in advancing scientific knowledge and medical breakthroughs, contributing significantly to our understanding of the complex biological processes and human diseases. However, many promising treatments that have demonstrated efficacy in animal studies have failed to translate to human subjects during clinical trials. Consequently, animal testing faces ethical concerns and criticism regarding its predictive reliability for human responses. This has led to the development of 3R principles (Replacement, Reduction, Refinement), introduced in 1959, advocating for alternative methods and improved animal welfare in research. Furthermore, regulatory frameworks and recent legislation, such as the 2022 FDA Modernisation Act, emphasize modern scientific alternatives to traditional animal testing. Emerging approaches, known as the 3Cs-cell culture, computer simulation, and phase 0 clinical trials-offer promising nonanimal solutions that could accelerate drug development and address ethical concerns, potentially rendering preclinical research more humane and efficient.

3D Bioprinting Models for Glioblastoma: From Scaffold Design to Therapeutic Application

Conventional in vitro models fail to accurately mimic the tumor in vivo characteristics, being appointed as one of the causes of clinical attrition rate. Recent advances in 3D culture techniques, replicating essential physical and biochemical cues such as cell-cell and cell-extracellular matrix interactions, have led to the development of more realistic tumor models. Bioprinting has emerged to advance the creation of 3D in vitro models, providing enhanced flexibility, scalability, and reproducibility. This is crucial for the development of more effective drug treatments, and glioblastoma (GBM) is no exception. GBM, the most common and deadly brain cancer, remains a major challenge, with a median survival of only 15 months post-diagnosis. This review highlights the key components needed for 3D bioprinted GBM models. It encompasses an analysis of natural and synthetic biomaterials, along with crosslinking methods to improve structural integrity. Also, it critically evaluates current 3D bioprinted GBM models and their integration into GBM-on-a-chip platforms, which hold noteworthy potential for drug screening and personalized therapies. A versatile development framework grounded on Quality-by-Design principles is proposed to guide the design of bioprinting models. Future perspectives, including 4D bioprinting and machine learning approaches, are discussed, along with the current gaps to advance the field further.

Using Regular Porous Membrane-Based Blood-Brain Barrier Model to Screen Brain-Targeted Drugs with Nanochannel Electrochemistry

Constructing in vitro blood-brain barrier (BBB) model provides an innovative approach for studying the pathophysiology of the brain and screening drugs. Although commercial Transwell was the simplest and most widely utilized in vitro model, reasonably mimicking essential characteristics of human BBB and dynamic monitoring BBB function remain a challenge. Herein, inspired by the highly permeable extracellular matrix membrane in human BBB, a novel in vitro BBB model was established by combining functionalized anodic alumina oxide (AAO) membrane with nanochannel electrochemistry (ANE-BBB). Benefiting from the topographical nanostructures and modified cell-adhesive peptide on the AAO surface, a tight endothelial barrier was formed, which can be directly visualized by phase-contrast microscope, and the barrier function can be real time monitored by nanochannel electrochemistry. More importantly, according to the current signal induced by the diffusion of redox species through the nanochannels toward the underlying electrode surface, dynamic evaluation of BBB-crossing behavior and precise screening of brain-targeted nanodrugs can be achieved. The constructed ANE-BBB overcomes the shortcomings of invisible cell culture, low permeability, and inaccurate real-time monitoring of screening drugs in traditional Transwell and provides a reliable tool for the design of nanodrugs to the central nervous system.

Engineered 3D human neurovascular model of Alzheimer's disease to study vascular dysfunction

The blood-brain barrier (BBB) serves as a selective filter that prevents harmful substances from entering the healthy brain. Dysfunction of this barrier is implicated in several neurological diseases. In the context of Alzheimer's disease (AD), BBB breakdown plays a significant role in both the initiation and progression of the disease. This study introduces a three-dimensional (3D) self-assembled in vitro model of the human neurovascular unit to recapitulate some of the complex interactions between the BBB and AD pathologies. It incorporates primary human brain endothelial cells, pericytes and astrocytes, and stem cell-derived neurons and astrocytes harboring Familial AD (FAD) mutations. Over an extended co-culture period, the model demonstrates increased BBB permeability, dysregulation of key endothelial and pericyte markers, and morphological alterations mirroring AD pathologies. The model enables visualization of amyloid-beta (Aβ) accumulation in both neuronal and vascular compartments. This model may serve as a versatile tool for neuroscience research and drug development to provide insights into the dynamic relationship between vascular dysfunction and AD pathogenesis.

A guide for blood-brain barrier models

Understanding the intricate mechanisms underlying brain-related diseases hinges on unraveling the pivotal role of the blood-brain barrier (BBB), an essential dynamic interface crucial for maintaining brain equilibrium. This review offers a comprehensive analysis of BBB physiology, delving into its cellular and molecular components while exploring a wide range of in vivo and in vitro BBB models. Notably, recent advancements in 3D cell culture techniques are explicitly discussed, as they have significantly improved the fidelity of BBB modeling by enabling the replication of physiologically relevant environments under flow conditions. Special attention is given to the cellular aspects of in vitro BBB models, alongside discussions on advances in stem cell technologies, providing valuable insights into generating robust cellular systems for BBB modeling. The diverse array of cell types used in BBB modeling, depending on their sources, is meticulously examined in this comprehensive review, scrutinizing their respective derivation protocols and implications. By synthesizing diverse approaches, this review sheds light on the improvements of BBB models to capture physiological conditions, aiding in understanding BBB interactions in health and disease conditions to foster clinical developments.

Assessing central nervous system drug delivery

INTRODUCTION

Delivering drugs to the central nervous system (CNS) remains a major challenge due to the blood-brain barrier, restricting the entry of drugs into the brain. This limitation contributes to the ongoing lack of effective treatments for CNS diseases. To improve the process of drug discovery and development, it is crucial to streamline methods that measure clinically relevant parameters, allowing for good selection of drug candidates.

AREA COVERED

In this paper, we discuss the essential prerequisites for successful CNS drug delivery and review relevant methods. We emphasize the need for closer collaboration between in vitro and in vivo scientists to improve the relevance of these methods and increase the success rate of developing effective CNS therapies. While our focus is on small molecule drugs, we also touch on some aspects of larger molecules.

EXPERT OPINION

Significant progress has been made in recent years in method development and their application. However, there is still work to be done before the use of in silico models, in vitro cell systems, and AI can consistently offer meaningful correlations and relationships to clinical data. This gap is partly due to limited patient data, but a lot can be achieved through in vivo research in animal models.

Trojan Horse Delivery Strategies of Natural Medicine Monomers: Challenges and Limitations in Improving Brain Targeting

Central nervous system (CNS) diseases, such as brain tumors, Alzheimer's disease, and Parkinson's disease, significantly impact patients' quality of life and impose substantial economic burdens on society. The blood-brain barrier (BBB) limits the effective delivery of most therapeutic drugs, especially natural products, despite their potential therapeutic effects. The Trojan Horse strategy, using nanotechnology to disguise drugs as "cargo", enables them to bypass the BBB, enhancing targeting and therapeutic efficacy. This review explores the applications of natural products in the treatment of CNS diseases, discusses the challenges posed by the BBB, and analyzes the advantages and limitations of the Trojan Horse strategy. Despite the existing technical challenges, future research is expected to enhance the application of natural drugs in CNS treatment by integrating nanotechnology, improving delivery mechanisms, and optimizing targeting characteristics.

Living biobank: Standardization of organoid construction and challenges

ABSTRACT

In multiple areas such as science, technology, and economic activities, it is necessary to unify the management of repetitive tasks or concepts by standardization to obtain the best order and high efficiency. Organoids, as living tissue models, have rapidly developed in the past decade. Organoids can be used repetitively for in vitro culture, cryopreservation, and recovery for further utilization. Because organoids can recapitulate the parental tissues' morphological phenotypes, cell functions, biological behaviors, and genomic profiles, they are known as renewable "living biobanks". Organoids cover two mainstream fields: Adult stem cell-derived organoids (also known as patient-derived organoids) and induced pluripotent stem cell-derived and/or embryonic stem cell-derived organoids. Given the increasing importance of organoids in the development of new drugs, standardized operation, and management in all steps of organoid construction is an important guarantee to ensure the high quality of products. In this review, we systematically introduce the standardization of organoid construction operation procedures, the standardization of laboratory construction, and available standardization documents related to organoid culture that have been published so far. We also proposed the challenges and prospects in this field.

Demystifying the potential of lipid-based nanocarriers in targeting brain malignancies

Drug targeting for brain malignancies is restricted due to the presence of the blood-brain barrier (BBB) and blood-brain tumor barrier (BBTB), which act as barriers between the blood and brain parenchyma. Certainly, the limited therapeutic options for brain malignancies have made notable progress with enhanced biological understanding and innovative approaches, such as targeted therapies and immunotherapies. These advancements significantly contribute to improving patient prognoses and represent a promising shift in the landscape of brain malignancy treatments. A more comprehensive understanding of the histology and pathogenesis of brain malignancies is urgently needed. Continued research focused on unraveling the intricacies of brain malignancy biology holds the key to developing innovative and tailored therapies that can improve patient outcomes. Lipid nanocarriers are highly effective drug delivery systems that significantly improve their solubility, bioavailability, and stability while also minimizing unwanted side effects. Surface-modified lipid nanocarriers (liposomes, niosomes, solid lipid nanoparticles, nanostructured lipid carriers, lipid nanocapsules, lipid-polymer hybrid nanocarriers, lipoproteins, and lipoplexes) are employed to improve BBB penetration and uptake through various mechanisms. This systematic review illuminates and covers various topics related to brain malignancies. It explores the different methods of drug delivery used in treating brain malignancies and delves into the benefits, limitations, and types of brain-targeted lipid-based nanocarriers. Additionally, this review discusses ongoing clinical trials and patents related to brain malignancy therapies and provides a glance into future perspectives for treating this condition.

Hybrid-integrated devices for mimicking malignant brain tumors ("tumor-on-a-chip") for in vitro development of targeted drug delivery and personalized therapy approaches

Acute and requiring attention problem of oncotheranostics is a necessity for the urgent development of operative and precise diagnostics methods, followed by efficient therapy, to significantly reduce disability and mortality of citizens. A perspective way to achieve efficient personalized treatment is to use methods for operative evaluation of the individual drug load, properties of specific tumors and the effectiveness of selected therapy, and other actual features of pathology. Among the vast diversity of tumor types-brain tumors are the most invasive and malignant in humans with poor survival after diagnosis. Among brain tumors glioblastoma shows exceptionally high mortality. More studies are urgently needed to understand the risk factors and improve therapy approaches. One of the actively developing approaches is the tumor-on-a-chip (ToC) concept. This review examines the achievements of recent years in the field of ToC system developments. The basics of microfluidic chips technologies are considered in the context of their applications in solving oncological problems. Then the basic principles of tumors cultivation are considered to evaluate the main challengers in implementation of microfluidic devices, for growing cell cultures and possibilities of their treatment and observation. The main achievements in the culture types diversity approaches and their advantages are being analyzed. The modeling of angiogenesis and blood-brain barrier (BBB) on a chip, being a principally important elements of the life system, were considered in detail. The most interesting examples and achievements in the field of tumor-on-a-chip developments have been presented.

Cuproptosis and Cuproptosis-Based Synergistic Therapy for Cancer Treatment

Copper, as an essential trace nutrient for human, plays a crucial role in numerous cellular activities, and is vital for maintaining homeostasis in organisms. Deviations from normal intracellular copper concentration range can disrupt the cellular homeostasis and lead to cell death. Cell death is the process in which cells lose their vitality and cannot sustain normal metabolism, which has various forms. The recently discovered cuproptosis mechanism differs from the previously recognized forms, which is triggered by intracellular copper accumulation. The discovery of cuproptosis has sparked interest among researchers, and this mechanism has been applied in the treatment of various intractable diseases, including different types of cancer. However, the developed cuproptosis-based therapies have revealed certain limitations, such as low immunostimulatory efficiency, poor tumor targeting, and inhibition by the tumor microenvironment. Therefore, researchers are devoted to combining cuproptosis with existing cancer therapies to develop more effective synergistic cancer therapies. This review summarizes the latest research advancements in the cuproptosis-based therapies for various types of cancer, with a focus on the synergistic cancer therapies. Finally, it provides an outlook on the future development of cuproptosis in anti-tumor therapy.

Research Progress on the Strategies for Crossing the Blood-Brain Barrier

Recently, the incidence of brain diseases, such as central nervous system degenerative diseases, brain tumors, and cerebrovascular diseases, has increased. However, the blood-brain barrier (BBB) limits the effective delivery of drugs to brain disease areas. Therefore, the mainstream direction of new drug development for these diseases is to engineer drugs that can better cross the BBB to exert their effects in the brain. This paper reviews the research progress and application of the main trans-BBB drug delivery strategies (receptor/transporter-mediated BBB crossing, focused ultrasound to open the BBB, adenosine agonist reversible opening of the BBB, aromatic resuscitation, transnasal administration, cell-mediated trans-BBB crossing, and viral vector system-mediated brain drug delivery). Meanwhile, the potential applications, advantages, and disadvantages of these strategies for crossing the BBB are analyzed. Finally, the future development prospects of strategies for crossing the BBB are also discussed. These strategies have potential value for treating brain diseases.

RGD-coated polymeric microbubbles promote ultrasound-mediated drug delivery in an inflamed endothelium-pericyte co-culture model of the blood-brain barrier

Drug delivery to central nervous pathologies is compromised by the blood-brain barrier (BBB). A clinically explored strategy to promote drug delivery across the BBB is sonopermeation, which relies on the combined use of ultrasound (US) and microbubbles (MB) to induce temporally and spatially controlled opening of the BBB. We developed an advanced in vitro BBB model to study the impact of sonopermeation on the delivery of the prototypic polymeric drug carrier pHPMA as a larger molecule and the small molecule antiviral drug ribavirin. This was done under standard and under inflammatory conditions, employing both untargeted and RGD peptide-coated MB. The BBB model is based on human cerebral capillary endothelial cells and human placental pericytes, which are co-cultivated in transwell inserts and which present with proper transendothelial electrical resistance (TEER). Sonopermeation induced a significant decrease in TEER values and facilitated the trans-BBB delivery of fluorescently labeled pHPMA (Atto488-pHPMA). To study drug delivery under inflamed endothelial conditions, which are typical for e.g. tumors, neurodegenerative diseases and CNS infections, tumor necrosis factor (TNF) was employed to induce inflammation in the BBB model. RGD-coated MB bound to and permeabilized the inflamed endothelium-pericyte co-culture model, and potently improved Atto488-pHPMA and ribavirin delivery. Taken together, our work combines in vitro BBB bioengineering with MB-mediated drug delivery enhancement, thereby providing a framework for future studies on optimization of US-mediated drug delivery to the brain.

Nanomaterials that Aid in the Diagnosis and Treatment of Alzheimer's Disease, Resolving Blood-Brain Barrier Crossing Ability

As a form of dementia, Alzheimer's disease (AD) suffers from no efficacious cure, yet AD treatment is still imperative, as it ameliorates the symptoms or prevents it from deteriorating or maintains the current status to the longest extent. The human brain is the most sensitive and complex organ in the body, which is protected by the blood-brain barrier (BBB). This yet induces the difficulty in curing AD as the drugs or nanomaterials that are much inhibited from reaching the lesion site. Thus, BBB crossing capability of drug delivery system remains a significant challenge in the development of neurological therapeutics. Fortunately, nano-enabled delivery systems possess promising potential to achieve multifunctional diagnostics/therapeutics against various targets of AD owing to their intriguing advantages of nanocarriers, including easy multifunctionalization on surfaces, high surface-to-volume ratio with large payloads, and potential ability to cross the BBB, making them capable of conquering the limitations of conventional drug candidates. This review, which focuses on the BBB crossing ability of the multifunctional nanomaterials in AD diagnosis and treatment, will provide an insightful vision that is conducive to the development of AD-related nanomaterials.

Microphysiological Blood-Brain Barrier Systems for Disease Modeling and Drug Development

The blood-brain barrier (BBB) is a highly controlled microenvironment that regulates the interactions between cerebral blood and brain tissue. Due to its selectivity, many therapeutics targeting various neurological disorders are not able to penetrate into brain tissue. Pre-clinical studies using animals and other in vitro platforms have not shown the ability to fully replicate the human BBB leading to the failure of a majority of therapeutics in clinical trials. However, recent innovations in vitro and ex vivo modeling called organs-on-chips have shown the potential to create more accurate disease models for improved drug development. These microfluidic platforms induce physiological stressors on cultured cells and are able to generate more physiologically accurate BBBs compared to previous in vitro models. In this review, different approaches to create BBBs-on-chips are explored alongside their application in modeling various neurological disorders and potential therapeutic efficacy. Additionally, organs-on-chips use in BBB drug delivery studies is discussed, and advances in linking brain organs-on-chips onto multiorgan platforms to mimic organ crosstalk are reviewed.

Current status and advances to improving drug delivery in diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma

Diffuse midline glioma (DMG), including tumors diagnosed in the brainstem (diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma - DIPG), is the primary cause of brain tumor-related death in pediatric patients. DIPG is characterized by a median survival of <12 months from diagnosis, harboring the worst 5-year survival rate of any cancer. Corticosteroids and radiation are the mainstay of therapy; however, they only provide transient relief from the devastating neurological symptoms. Numerous therapies have been investigated for DIPG, but the majority have been unsuccessful in demonstrating a survival benefit beyond radiation alone. Although many barriers hinder brain drug delivery in DIPG, one of the most significant challenges is the blood-brain barrier (BBB). Therapeutic compounds must possess specific properties to enable efficient passage across the BBB. In brain cancer, the BBB is referred to as the blood-brain tumor barrier (BBTB), where tumors disrupt the structure and function of the BBB, which may provide opportunities for drug delivery. However, the biological characteristics of the brainstem's BBB/BBTB, both under normal physiological conditions and in response to DIPG, are poorly understood, which further complicates treatment. Better characterization of the changes that occur in the BBB/BBTB of DIPG patients is essential, as this informs future treatment strategies. Many novel drug delivery technologies have been investigated to bypass or disrupt the BBB/BBTB, including convection enhanced delivery, focused ultrasound, nanoparticle-mediated delivery, and intranasal delivery, all of which are yet to be clinically established for the treatment of DIPG. Herein, we review what is known about the BBB/BBTB and discuss the current status, limitations, and advances of conventional and novel treatments to improving brain drug delivery in DIPG.

Involvement of Astrocytes in the Formation, Maintenance, and Function of the Blood-Brain Barrier

The blood-brain barrier (BBB) is a fundamental structure that protects the composition of the brain by determining which ions, metabolites, and nutrients are allowed to enter the brain from the blood or to leave it towards the circulation. The BBB is structurally composed of a layer of brain capillary endothelial cells (BCECs) bound to each other through tight junctions (TJs). However, its development as well as maintenance and properties are controlled by the other brain cells that contact the BCECs: pericytes, glial cells, and even neurons themselves. Astrocytes seem, in particular, to have a very important role in determining and controlling most properties of the BBB. Here, we will focus on these latter cells, since the comprehension of their roles in brain physiology has been continuously expanding, even including the ability to participate in neurotransmission and in complex functions such as learning and memory. Accordingly, pathological conditions that alter astrocytic functions can alter the BBB's integrity, thus compromising many brain activities. In this review, we will also refer to different kinds of in vitro BBB models used to study the BBB's properties, evidencing its modifications under pathological conditions.

Current progress and challenges in the development of brain tissue models: How to grow up the changeable brain in vitro?

In vitro modeling of brain tissue is a promising but not yet resolved problem in modern neurobiology and neuropharmacology. Complexity of the brain structure and diversity of cell-to-cell communication in (patho)physiological conditions make this task almost unachievable. However, establishment of novel in vitro brain models would ultimately lead to better understanding of development-associated or experience-driven brain plasticity, designing efficient approaches to restore aberrant brain functioning. The main goal of this review is to summarize the available data on methodological approaches that are currently in use, and to identify the most prospective trends in development of neurovascular unit, blood-brain barrier, blood-cerebrospinal fluid barrier, and neurogenic niche in vitro models. The manuscript focuses on the regulation of adult neurogenesis, cerebral microcirculation and fluids dynamics that should be reproduced in the in vitro 4D models to mimic brain development and its alterations in brain pathology. We discuss approaches that are critical for studying brain plasticity, deciphering the individual person-specific trajectory of brain development and aging, and testing new drug candidates in the in vitro models.

Neuronanomedicine for Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease: Current progress and a guide to improve clinical translation

Neuronanomedicine is an emerging multidisciplinary field that aims to create innovative nanotechnologies to treat major neurodegenerative disorders, such as Alzheimer's (AD) and Parkinson's disease (PD). A key component of neuronanomedicine are nanoparticles, which can improve drug properties and demonstrate enhanced safety and delivery across the blood-brain barrier, a major improvement on existing therapeutic approaches. In this review, we critically analyze the latest nanoparticle-based strategies to modify underlying disease pathology to slow or halt AD/PD progression. We find that a major roadblock for neuronanomedicine translation to date is a poor understanding of how nanoparticles interact with biological systems (i.e., bio-nano interactions), which is partly due to inconsistent reporting in published works. Accordingly, this review makes a set of specific recommendations to help guide researchers to harness the unique properties of nanoparticles and thus realise breakthrough treatments for AD/PD.

Blood-Brain Barrier Breakdown in Neuroinflammation: Current In Vitro Models

The blood-brain barrier, which is formed by tightly interconnected microvascular endothelial cells, separates the brain from the peripheral circulation. Together with other central nervous system-resident cell types, including pericytes and astrocytes, the blood-brain barrier forms the neurovascular unit. Upon neuroinflammation, this barrier becomes leaky, allowing molecules and cells to enter the brain and to potentially harm the tissue of the central nervous system. Despite the significance of animal models in research, they may not always adequately reflect human pathophysiology. Therefore, human models are needed. This review will provide an overview of the blood-brain barrier in terms of both health and disease. It will describe all key elements of the in vitro models and will explore how different compositions can be utilized to effectively model a variety of neuroinflammatory conditions. Furthermore, it will explore the existing types of models that are used in basic research to study the respective pathologies thus far.

Recent advancements on in vitro blood-brain barrier model: A reliable and efficient screening approach for preclinical and clinical investigation

INTRODUCTION

The efficiency of brain therapeutics is greatly hindered by the blood-brain barrier (BBB). BBB's protective function, selective permeability, and dynamic functionality maintain the harmony between the brain and peripheral region. Thus, the design of any novel drug carrier system requires the complete study and investigation of BBB permeability, efflux transport, and the effect of associated cellular and non-vascular unit trafficking on BBB penetrability. The in vitro BBB models offer a most promising, and reliable mode of initial investigation of BBB permeability and associated factors as strong evidence for further preclinical and clinical investigation.

AREA COVERED

This review work covers the structure and functions of BBB components and different types of in vitro BBB models along with factors affecting BBB model development and model selection criteria.

EXPERT OPINION

In vivo models assume to reciprocate the physiological environment to the maximum extent. However, the interspecies variability, NVUs trafficking, dynamic behavior of BBB, etc., lead to non-reproducible results. The in vitro models are comparatively less complex, and flexible, as per the study design, could generate substantial evidence and help identify suitable in vivo animal model selection.