Two-Year Results After AAV2-Mediated Gene Therapy for Choroideremia: The Alberta Experience

Quality of life in patients with CRB1-associated retinal dystrophies: A longitudinal study

PURPOSE

To assess the longitudinal vision-related quality of life among patients with CRB1-associated inherited retinal dystrophies.

METHODS

In this longitudinal questionnaire study, the National Eye Institute Visual Function Questionnaire (39 items, NEI VFQ-39) was applied at baseline, two-year follow-up, and 4-year follow-up in patients with pathogenic CRB1 variants. [Correction added on 20 November 2023, after first online publication: The preceding sentence has been updated in this version.] Classical test theory was performed to obtain subdomain scores and in particular 'near activities' and 'total composite' scores. The Rasch analysis based on previous calibrations of the NEI VFQ-25 was applied to create visual functioning and socio-emotional subscales.

RESULTS

In total, 22 patients with a CRB1-associated retinal dystrophy were included, […] with a median age of 25.0 years (interquartile range: 13-31 years) at baseline and mean follow-up of 4.0 ± 0.3 years. [Correction added on 20 November 2023, after first online publication: The preceding sentence has been updated in this version.] A significant decline at 4 years was observed for 'near activities' (51.0 ± 23.8 vs 35.4 ± 14.7, p = 0.004) and 'total composite' (63.0 ± 13.1 vs 52.0 ± 12.1, p = 0.001) subdomain scores. For the Rasch-scaled scores, the 'visual functioning' scale significantly decreased after 2 years (-0.89 logits; p = 0.012), but not at 4-year follow-up (+0.01 logits; p = 0.975). [Correction added on 20 November 2023, after first online publication: In the preceding sentence, "…after 4 years…" has been corrected to "…after 2 years…" in this version.] The 'socio-emotional' scale also showed a significant decline after 2 years (-0.78 logits, p = 0.033) and 4 years (-0.83 logits, p = 0.021).

CONCLUSION

In the absence of an intervention, a decline in vision-related quality of life is present in patients with pathogenic CRB1 variants at 4-year follow-up. Patient-reported outcome measures should be included in future clinical trials, as they can be a potential indicator of disease progression and treatment efficacy.

Clinical Pharmacology Perspective on Development of Adeno-Associated Virus Vector-Based Retina Gene Therapy

Adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector-based gene therapy is an innovative modality being increasingly investigated to treat diseases by modifying or replacing defective genes or expressing therapeutic entities. With its unique anatomic and physiological characteristics, the eye constitutes a very attractive target for gene therapy. Specifically, the ocular space is easily accessible and is generally considered "immune-privileged" with a low risk of systemic side effects following local drug administration. As retina cells have limited cellular turnover, a one-time gene delivery has the potential to provide long-term transgene expression. Despite the initial success with voretigene neparvovec (Luxturna), the first approved retina gene therapy, there are still challenges to be overcome for successful clinical development of these products and scientific questions to be answered. The current review paper aims to integrate published experience learned thus far for AAV-based retina gene therapy related to preclinical to clinical translation; first-in-human dose selection; relevant bioanalytical assays and strategies; clinical development considerations including trial design, biodistribution and vector shedding, immunogenicity, transgene expression, and pediatric populations; opportunities for model-informed drug development; and regulatory perspectives. The information presented herein is intended to serve as a guide to inform the clinical development strategy for retina gene therapy with a focus on clinical pharmacology.

Gene therapy for age-related macular degeneration: potential, feasibility, and pitfalls

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The landscape for age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is rapidly changing with addition of biosimilars and now United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved nonneovascular AMD (nnAMD) treatment options. These developments have inspired a burgeoning pipeline of gene therapy approaches focused on similar antivascular endothelial growth factors (VEGF) and complement related pathways. Historic and more recent setbacks in the gene therapy pipeline, including intraocular inflammatory reactions, have raised important concerns for adverse events related to AMD therapeutics both for gene and nongene approaches. The specific clinical profile of these therapeutics approaching later stage clinical trials are complex and under active investigation; however, these options hold promise to disrupt the current landscape and change management paradigms for one of the leading causes of vision loss worldwide.

RECENT FINDINGS

This review covers current gene therapy approaches for neovascular AMD (nAMD) and nnAMD. Intravitreal, suprachoroidal, and subretinal delivery routes are discussed with attention to technical procedure, capabilities for transgene delivery to target tissue, immunogenicity, and collateral effects. Suprachoroidal delivery is an emerging approach which may bridge some of the practical drawbacks for intravitreal and subretinal methods, though with less elaborated immunologic profile. In parallel to delivery modification, viral vectors have been cultivated to target specific cells, with promising enhancements in adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors and persistent interest in alternate viral and nonviral delivery vectors. Ongoing questions such as steroid or immunosuppressive regimen and economic considerations from a payer and societal perspective are discussed.

SUMMARY

The present review discusses emerging gene therapy options which could foster new, more durable nAMD and nnAMD therapeutics. These options will need refinement with regards to route, vector, and dosage, and specialists must decipher the specific clinical risk benefit profile for individual patients. Ongoing concerns for immunogenicity or dosage related adverse events could stifle progress, while further vector development and refined delivery techniques have the potential to change the safety and efficacy of currently options in the pipeline.

Retinal Imaging Findings in Inherited Retinal Diseases

Inherited retinal diseases (IRDs) represent one of the major causes of progressive and irreversible vision loss in the working-age population. Over the last few decades, advances in retinal imaging have allowed for an improvement in the phenotypic characterization of this group of diseases and have facilitated phenotype-to-genotype correlation studies. As a result, the number of clinical trials targeting IRDs has steadily increased, and commensurate to this, the need for novel reproducible outcome measures and endpoints has grown. This review aims to summarize and describe the clinical presentation, characteristic imaging findings, and imaging endpoint measures that are being used in clinical research on IRDs. For the purpose of this review, IRDs have been divided into four categories: (1) panretinal pigmentary retinopathies affecting rods or cones; (2) macular dystrophies; (3) stationary conditions; (4) hereditary vitreoretinopathies.

Cell-cell interaction in the pathogenesis of inherited retinal diseases

The retina is part of the central nervous system specialized for vision. Inherited retinal diseases (IRD) are a group of clinically and genetically heterogenous disorders that lead to progressive vision impairment or blindness. Although each disorder is rare, IRD accumulatively cause blindness in up to 5.5 million individuals worldwide. Currently, the pathophysiological mechanisms of IRD are not fully understood and there are limited treatment options available. Most IRD are caused by degeneration of light-sensitive photoreceptors. Genetic mutations that abrogate the structure and/or function of photoreceptors lead to visual impairment followed by blindness caused by loss of photoreceptors. In healthy retina, photoreceptors structurally and functionally interact with retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) and Müller glia (MG) to maintain retinal homeostasis. Multiple IRD with photoreceptor degeneration as a major phenotype are caused by mutations of RPE- and/or MG-associated genes. Recent studies also reveal compromised MG and RPE caused by mutations in ubiquitously expressed ciliary genes. Therefore, photoreceptor degeneration could be a direct consequence of gene mutations and/or could be secondary to the dysfunction of their interaction partners in the retina. This review summarizes the mechanisms of photoreceptor-RPE/MG interaction in supporting retinal functions and discusses how the disruption of these processes could lead to photoreceptor degeneration, with an aim to provide a unique perspective of IRD pathogenesis and treatment paradigm. We will first describe the biology of retina and IRD and then discuss the interaction between photoreceptors and MG/RPE as well as their implications in disease pathogenesis. Finally, we will summarize the recent advances in IRD therapeutics targeting MG and/or RPE.

A Prospective, Observational, Noninterventional Clinical Study of Participants With Choroideremia: The NIGHT Study

PURPOSE

The NIGHT study aimed to assess the natural history of choroideremia (CHM), an X-linked inherited chorioretinal degenerative disease leading to blindness, and determine which outcomes would be the most sensitive for monitoring disease progression.

DESIGN

A prospective, observational, multicenter cohort study.

METHODS

Males aged ≥18 years with genetically confirmed CHM, visible active disease within the macular region, and best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) ≥34 Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) letters at baseline were assessed for 20 months. The primary outcome was the change in BCVA over time at Months 4, 8, 12, 16, and 20. A range of functional and anatomical secondary outcome measures were assessed up to Month 12, including retinal sensitivity, central ellipsoid zone (EZ) area, and total area of fundus autofluorescence (FAF). Additional ocular assessments for safety were performed.

RESULTS

A total of 220 participants completed the study. The mean BCVA was stable over 20 months. Most participants (81.4% in the worse eye and 77.8% in the better eye) had change from baseline > -5 ETDRS letters at Month 20. Interocular symmetry was low overall. Reductions from baseline to Month 12 were observed (worse eye, better eye) for retinal sensitivity (functional outcome; -0.68 dB, -0.48 dB), central EZ area (anatomical outcome; -0.276 mm2, -0.290 mm2), and total area of FAF (anatomical outcome; -0.605 mm2, -0.533 mm2). No assessment-related serious adverse events occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

Retinal sensitivity, central EZ area, and total area of FAF are more sensitive than BCVA in measuring the natural progression of CHM.

Toward low-cost gene therapy: mRNA-based therapeutics for treatment of inherited retinal diseases

Inherited retinal diseases (IRDs) stem from genetic mutations that result in vision impairment. Gene therapy shows promising therapeutic potential, exemplified by the encouraging initial results with voretigene neparvovec. Nevertheless, the associated costs impede widespread access, particularly in low-to-middle income countries. The primary challenge remains: how can we make these therapies globally affordable? Leveraging advancements in mRNA therapies might offer a more economically viable alternative. Furthermore, transitioning to nonviral delivery systems could provide a dual benefit of reduced costs and increased scalability. Relevant stakeholders must collaboratively devise and implement a research agenda to realize the potential of mRNA strategies in equitable access to treatments to prevent vision loss.

Using Goldmann Visual Field Volume to Track Disease Progression in Choroideremia

Purpose

Choroideremia is an X-linked choroidopathy caused by pathogenic variants in the CHM gene. It is characterized by the early appearance of multiple scotomas in the peripheral visual field that spread and coalesce, usually sparing central vision until late in the disease. These features make quantitative monitoring of visual decline particularly challenging. Here, we describe a novel computational approach to convert Goldmann visual field (GVF) data into quantitative volumetric measurements. With this approach, we analyzed visual field loss in a longitudinal, retrospective cohort of patients with choroideremia.

Design

Single-center, retrospective, cohort study.

Participants

We analyzed data from 238 clinic visits of 56 molecularly-confirmed male patients with choroideremia from 41 families (range, 1-27 visits per patient). Patients had a median follow up of 4 years (range, 0-56 years) with an age range of 5 to 76 years at the time of their visits.

Methods

Clinical data from molecularly-confirmed patients with choroideremia, including GVF data, were included for analysis. Goldmann visual field records were traced using a tablet-based application, and the 3-dimensional hill of vision was interpolated for each trace. This procedure allowed quantification of visual field loss from data collected over decades with differing protocols, including different or incomplete isopters. Visual acuity (VA) data were collected and converted to logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution values. A delayed exponential mixed-effects model was used to evaluate the loss of visual field volume over time.

Main Outcome Measures

Visual acuity and GVF volume.

Results

The estimated mean age at disease onset was 12.6 years (standard deviation, 9.1 years; 95% quantile interval, 6.5-36.4 years). The mean field volume loss was 6.8% per year (standard deviation, 4.5%; 95% quantile interval, 1.9%-18.8%) based on exponential modeling. Field volume was more strongly correlated between eyes (r2 = 0.935) than best-corrected VA (r2 = 0.285).

Conclusions

Volumetric analysis of GVF data enabled quantification of peripheral visual function in patients with choroideremia and evaluation of disease progression. The methods presented here may facilitate the analysis of historical GVF data from patients with inherited retinal disease and other diseases associated with visual field loss. This work informs the creation of appropriate outcome measures in choroideremia therapeutic trials, particularly in trial designs.

Financial Disclosures

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found in the Footnotes and Disclosures at the end of this article.

Endpoints for clinical trials in ophthalmology

With the identification of novel targets, the number of interventional clinical trials in ophthalmology has increased. Visual acuity has for a long time been considered the gold standard endpoint for clinical trials, but in the recent years it became evident that other endpoints are required for many indications including geographic atrophy and inherited retinal disease. In glaucoma the currently available drugs were approved based on their IOP lowering capacity. Some recent findings do, however, indicate that at the same level of IOP reduction, not all drugs have the same effect on visual field progression. For neuroprotection trials in glaucoma, novel surrogate endpoints are required, which may either include functional or structural parameters or a combination of both. A number of potential surrogate endpoints for ophthalmology clinical trials have been identified, but their validation is complicated and requires solid scientific evidence. In this article we summarize candidates for clinical endpoints in ophthalmology with a focus on retinal disease and glaucoma. Functional and structural biomarkers, as well as quality of life measures are discussed, and their potential to serve as endpoints in pivotal trials is critically evaluated.

Safety and Efficacy of Adeno-Associated Viral Gene Therapy in Patients With Retinal Degeneration: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Purpose

This systematic review evaluates the safety and efficacy of ocular gene therapy using adeno-associated virus (AAV).

Methods

MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, and ClinicalTrials.gov were searched systematically for controlled or non-controlled interventional gene therapy studies using key words related to retinal diseases, gene therapy, and AAV vectors. The primary outcome measure was safety, based on ocular severe adverse events (SAEs). Secondary outcome measures evaluated efficacy of the therapy based on best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) and improvements in visual sensitivity and systemic involvement following ocular delivery. Pooling was done using a DerSimonian Laird random effects model. Risk of bias was assessed using the Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool, version 1.

Results

Our search identified 3548 records. Of these, 80 publications met eligibility criteria, representing 28 registered clinical trials and 5 postmarket surveillance studies involving AAV gene therapy for Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA), choroideremia, Leber hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON), age-related macular degeneration (AMD), retinitis pigmentosa (RP), X-linked retinoschisis, and achromatopsia. Overall, AAV therapy vectors were associated with a cumulative incidence of at least one SAE of 8% (95% confidence intervals [CIs] of 5% to 12%). SAEs were often associated with the surgical procedure rather than the therapeutic vector itself. Poor or inconsistent reporting of adverse events (AEs) were a limitation for the meta-analysis. The proportion of patients with any improvement in BCVA and visual sensitivity was 41% (95% CIs of 31% to 51%) and 51% (95% CIs of 31% to 70%), respectively. Systemic immune involvement was associated with a cumulative incidence of 31% (95% CI = 21% to 42%).

Conclusions

AAV gene therapy vectors appear to be safe but the surgical procedure required to deliver them is associated with some risk. The large variability in efficacy can be attributed to the small number of patients treated, the heterogeneity of the population and the variability in dosage, volume, and follow-up.

Translational Relevance

This systematic review will help to inform and guide future clinical trials.

Gene Augmentation of CHM Using Non-Viral Episomal Vectors in Models of Choroideremia

Choroideremia (CHM) is an X-linked chorioretinal dystrophy leading to progressive retinal degeneration that results in blindness by late adulthood. It is caused by mutations in the CHM gene encoding the Rab Escort Protein 1 (REP1), which plays a crucial role in the prenylation of Rab proteins ensuring correct intracellular trafficking. Gene augmentation is a promising therapeutic strategy, and there are several completed and ongoing clinical trials for treating CHM using adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors. However, late-phase trials have failed to show significant functional improvements and have raised safety concerns about inflammatory events potentially caused by the use of viruses. Therefore, alternative non-viral therapies are desirable. Episomal scaffold/matrix attachment region (S/MAR)-based plasmid vectors were generated containing the human CHM coding sequence, a GFP reporter gene, and ubiquitous promoters (pS/MAR-CHM). The vectors were assessed in two choroideremia disease model systems: (1) CHM patient-derived fibroblasts and (2) chmru848 zebrafish, using Western blotting to detect REP1 protein expression and in vitro prenylation assays to assess the rescue of prenylation function. Retinal immunohistochemistry was used to investigate vector expression and photoreceptor morphology in injected zebrafish retinas. The pS/MAR-CHM vectors generated persistent REP1 expression in CHM patient fibroblasts and showed a significant rescue of prenylation function by 75%, indicating correction of the underlying biochemical defect associated with CHM. In addition, GFP and human REP1 expression were detected in zebrafish microinjected with the pS/MAR-CHM at the one-cell stage. Injected chmru848 zebrafish showed increased survival, prenylation function, and improved retinal photoreceptor morphology. Non-viral S/MAR vectors show promise as a potential gene-augmentation strategy without the use of immunogenic viral components, which could be applicable to many inherited retinal disease genes.

Subretinal timrepigene emparvovec in adult men with choroideremia: a randomized phase 3 trial

Choroideremia is a rare, X-linked retinal degeneration resulting in progressive vision loss. A randomized, masked, phase 3 clinical trial evaluated the safety and efficacy over 12 months of follow-up in adult males with choroideremia randomized to receive a high-dose (1.0 × 1011 vector genomes (vg); n = 69) or low-dose (1.0 × 1010 vg; n = 34) subretinal injection of the AAV2-vector-based gene therapy timrepigene emparvovec versus non-treated control (n = 66). Most treatment-emergent adverse events were mild or moderate. The trial did not meet its primary endpoint of best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) improvement. In the primary endpoint analysis, three of 65 participants (5%) in the high-dose group, one of 34 (3%) participants in the low-dose group and zero of 62 (0%) participants in the control group had ≥15-letter Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) improvement from baseline BCVA at 12 months (high dose, P = 0.245 versus control; low dose, P = 0.354 versus control). As the primary endpoint was not met, key secondary endpoints were not tested for significance. In a key secondary endpoint, nine of 65 (14%), six of 35 (18%) and one of 62 (2%) participants in the high-dose, low-dose and control groups, respectively, experienced ≥10-letter ETDRS improvement from baseline BCVA at 12 months. Potential opportunities to enhance future gene therapy studies for choroideremia include optimization of entry criteria (more preserved retinal area), surgical techniques and clinical endpoints. EudraCT registration: 2015-003958-41 .

Choroideremia: The Endpoint Endgame

Choroideremia is an X-linked retinal degeneration resulting from the progressive, centripetal loss of photoreceptors and choriocapillaris, secondary to the degeneration of the retinal pigment epithelium. Affected individuals present in late childhood or early teenage years with nyctalopia and progressive peripheral visual loss. Typically, by the fourth decade, the macula and fovea also degenerate, resulting in advanced sight loss. Currently, there are no approved treatments for this condition. Gene therapy offers the most promising therapeutic modality for halting or regressing functional loss. The aims of the current review are to highlight the lessons learnt from clinical trials in choroideremia, review endpoints, and propose a future strategy for clinical trials.

Emerging Gene Therapy Technologies for Retinal Ganglion Cell Neuroprotection

ABSTRACT

Optic neuropathies encompass a breadth of diseases that ultimately result in dysfunction and/or loss of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs). Although visual impairment from optic neuropathies is common, there is a lack of effective clinical treatments. Addressing a critical need for novel interventions, preclinical studies have been generating a growing body of evidence that identify promising new drug-based and cell-based therapies. Gene therapy is another emerging therapeutic field that offers the potential of specifically and robustly increasing long-term RGC survival in optic neuropathies. Gene therapy offers additional benefits of driving improvements following a single treatment administration, and it can be designed to target a variety of pathways that may be involved in individual optic neuropathies or across multiple etiologies. This review explores the history of gene therapy, the fundamentals of its application, and the emerging development of gene therapy technology as it relates to treatment of optic neuropathies.

Understanding and Tackling Immune Responses to Adeno-Associated Viral Vectors

As the clinical experience in adeno-associated viral (AAV) vector-based gene therapies is expanding, the necessity to better understand and control the host immune responses is also increasing. Immunogenicity of AAV vectors in humans has been linked to several limitations of the platform, including lack of efficacy due to antibody-mediated neutralization, tissue inflammation, loss of transgene expression, and in some cases, complement activation and acute toxicities. Nevertheless, significant knowledge gaps remain in our understanding of the mechanisms of immune responses to AAV gene therapies, further hampered by the failure of preclinical animal models to recapitulate clinical findings. In this review, we focus on the current knowledge regarding immune responses, spanning from innate immunity to humoral and adaptive responses, triggered by AAV vectors and how they can be mitigated for safer, durable, and more effective gene therapies.

Gene therapy for RAB28: What can we learn from zebrafish?

The eye is particularly suited to gene therapy due to its accessibility, immunoprivileged state and compartmentalised structure. Indeed, many clinical trials are underway for therapeutic gene strategies for inherited retinal degenerations (IRDs). However, as there are currently 281 genes associated with IRD, there is still a large unmet need for effective therapies for the majority of IRD-causing genes. In humans, RAB28 null and hypomorphic alleles cause autosomal recessive cone-rod dystrophy (arCORD). Previous work demonstrated that restoring wild type zebrafish Rab28 via germline transgenesis, specifically in cone photoreceptors, is sufficient to rescue the defects in outer segment phagocytosis (OSP) observed in zebrafish rab28-/- knockouts (KO). This rescue suggests that gene therapy for RAB28-associated CORD may be successful by RAB28 gene restoration to cones. It also inspired us to critically consider the scenarios in which zebrafish can provide informative preclinical data for development of gene therapies. Thus, this review focuses on RAB28 biology and disease, and delves into both the opportunities and limitations of using zebrafish as a model for both gene therapy development and as a diagnostic tool for patient variants of unknown significance (VUS).

Goats with low levels of AAV antibody may serve as candidates for large animal gene therapy

AAV vector-mediated gene therapy has been proposed as a feasible strategy for several eye diseases. However, AAV antibodies in the serum prior to treatment hinder the transduction efficiency and thus the therapeutic effect. Therefore, it is necessary to evaluate AAV antibodies in the serum before gene therapy. As large animals, goats are more closely related to humans than rodents and more economically available than nonhuman primates. Here, we first evaluated the AAV2 antibody serum level in rhesus monkeys before AAV injection. Then, we optimized a cell-based neutralizing antibody assay for detecting AAV antibodies in the serum of Saanen goats and evaluated the consistency of the cell-based neutralizing antibody assay and ELISA for goat serum antibody evaluation. The cell-based neutralizing antibody assay showed that the percentage of macaques with low antibody levels was 42.86%; however, there were no macaques with low antibody levels when the serum was evaluated by ELISA. The proportion of goats with low antibody levels was 56.67% according to the neutralizing antibody assay and 33. 33% according to the ELISA, and McNemar's test showed that the results of the two assays were not significantly different (P = 0.754), but that their consistency is poor (Kappa = 0.286, P = 0.114). Moreover, longitudinal evaluation of serum antibodies before and after intravitreal injection of AAV2 in goats revealed that the level of AAV antibodies increased and transduction inhibition subsequently increased, as reported in humans, indicating that transduction inhibition should be taken into account at different stages of gene therapy. In summary, starting with an evaluation of monkey serum antibodies, we optimized a detection method of goat serum antibodies, providing an alternative large animal model for gene therapy, and our serum antibody measurement method may be applied to other large animals.

Genome editing in the treatment of ocular diseases

Genome-editing technologies have ushered in a new era in gene therapy, providing novel therapeutic strategies for a wide range of diseases, including both genetic and nongenetic ocular diseases. These technologies offer new hope for patients suffering from previously untreatable conditions. The unique anatomical and physiological features of the eye, including its immune-privileged status, size, and compartmentalized structure, provide an optimal environment for the application of these cutting-edge technologies. Moreover, the development of various delivery methods has facilitated the efficient and targeted administration of genome engineering tools designed to correct specific ocular tissues. Additionally, advancements in noninvasive ocular imaging techniques and electroretinography have enabled real-time monitoring of therapeutic efficacy and safety. Herein, we discuss the discovery and development of genome-editing technologies, their application to ocular diseases from the anterior segment to the posterior segment, current limitations encountered in translating these technologies into clinical practice, and ongoing research endeavors aimed at overcoming these challenges.

Choroideremia: Toward Regulatory Approval of Retinal Gene Therapy

Choroideremia is an X-linked inherited retinal degeneration characterized by primary centripetal degeneration of the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE), with secondary degeneration of the choroid and retina. Affected individuals experience reduced night vision in early adulthood with blindness in late middle age. The underlying CHM gene encodes REP1, a protein involved in the prenylation of Rab GTPases essential for intracellular vesicle trafficking. Adeno-associated viral gene therapy has demonstrated some benefit in clinical trials for choroideremia. However, challenges remain in gaining regulatory approval. Choroideremia is slowly progressive, which presents difficulties in demonstrating benefit over short pivotal clinical trials that usually run for 1-2 years. Improvements in visual acuity are particularly challenging due to the initial negative effects of surgical detachment of the fovea. Despite these challenges, great progress toward a treatment has been made since choroideremia was first described in 1872.

AAV2-Mediated Gene Therapy for Choroideremia: 5-Year Results and Alternate Anti-sense Oligonucleotide Therapy

PURPOSE

To assess the long-term safety and efficacy of AAV2-REP1 in choroideremia (CHM) patients, and to test a potential antisense oligonucleotide therapy for CHM.

DESIGN

Extended, prospective phase 1/2 clinical trial and laboratory investigation.

METHODS

Five patients who received a single subfoveal injection of AAV2-REP1 were studied. The long-term safety was evaluated by ophthalmic examination, spectral domain optical coherence tomography, and fundus autofluorescence (FAF) for up to 5 years. Functional and structural changes were determined by different test modalities. Four antisense oligonucleotides (ASOs) were designed to treat the CHM c.1245-521A>G mutation, which was present in 2 patients within this trial.

RESULTS

Subject P3 experienced a localized intraretinal immune response that resulted in a significant loss of preserved retinal pigment epithelium (RPE). P4 experienced an exacerbation of peripheral retinoschisis. P2 had a constant ≥15-letter best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) gain in the treated eye, whereas P5 had ≥15-letter BCVA improvement once in the untreated eye. The preserved FAF areas declined more rapidly in the treated eyes compared to the untreated eyes (P = .043). A customized 25-mer ASO recovered 83.2% to 95.0% of the normal RNA and 57.5% of the normal protein in fibroblasts from 2 trial patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Intraretinal inflammation triggered by AAV2-REP1 subretinal injection stabilized after 2 years but resulted in permanent damage to the retinal structure. Long-term progression of the disease was seen in both treated and untreated eyes, casting doubt as to the effectiveness of this approach in late-stage CHM. Alternative approaches such as ASO may have a therapeutic effect in a subgroup of CHM patients.

Efficacy, pharmacokinetics, and safety in the mouse and primate retina of dual AAV vectors for Usher syndrome type 1B

Gene therapy of Usher syndrome type 1B (USH1B) due to mutations in the large Myosin VIIA (MYO7A) gene is limited by the packaging capacity of adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors. To overcome this, we have previously developed dual AAV8 vectors which encode human MYO7A (dual AAV8.MYO7A). Here we show that subretinal administration of 1.37E+9 to 1.37E+10 genome copies of a good-manufacturing-practice-like lot of dual AAV8.MYO7A improves the retinal defects of a mouse model of USH1B. The same lot was used in non-human primates at doses 1.6× and 4.3× the highest dose proposed for the clinical trial which was based on mouse efficacy data. Long-lasting alterations in retinal function and morphology were observed following subretinal administration of dual AAV8.MYO7A at the high dose. These findings were modest and improved over time in the low-dose group, as also observed in other studies involving the use of AAV8 in non-human primates and humans. Biodistribution and shedding studies confirmed the presence of vector DNA mainly in the visual pathway. Accordingly, we detected human MYO7A mRNA expression predominantly in the retina. Overall, these studies pave the way for the clinical translation of subretinal administration of dual AAV vectors in USH1B subjects.

The degree of AAV-induced retinal inflammation varies based on serotype and route of delivery: intravitreal, subretinal or suprachoroidal

Adeno-associated virus (AAV) mediated gene therapy has great potential for treating a wide range of retinal degenerative diseases. However, some initial enthusiasm for gene therapy has been tempered by emerging evidence of AAV-associated inflammation, which in several instances has contributed to clinical trial discontinuation. Currently, there is a paucity of data describing the variable immune responses to different AAV serotypes, and similarly, little is known regarding how these responses differ depending on route of ocular delivery, including in animal models of disease. In this study, we characterize the severity and retinal distribution of AAV-associated inflammation in rats triggered by delivery of 5 different AAV vectors (AAV1, AAV2, AAV6, AAV8, AAV9), each of which contained eGFP driven under control of the constitutively active CMV promoter. We further compare the inflammation across 3 different potential routes (intravitreal, subretinal, suprachoroidal) of ocular delivery. Compared to buffer-injected controls for each route of delivery, AAV2 and AAV6 induced the most inflammation across all routes of delivery of the vectors tested, with AAV6 inducing the highest levels of inflammation when delivered suprachoroidally. AAV1-induced inflammation was highest when delivered suprachoroidally, whereas minimal inflammation was seen with intravitreal delivery. AAV8 and AAV9 induced minimal inflammation across all routes of delivery. Importantly, the degree of inflammation was not correlated with vector-mediated transduction and expression of eGFP. These data emphasize the importance of considering ocular inflammation when selecting AAV serotypes and ocular delivery routes for the development of gene therapy strategies.

Intravitreal gene therapy preserves retinal function in a canine model of CLN2 neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis

CLN2 neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis is a rare hereditary neurodegenerative disorder characterized by deleterious sequence variants in TPP1 that result in reduced or abolished function of the lysosomal enzyme tripeptidyl peptidase 1 (TPP1). Children with this disorder experience progressive neurological decline and vision loss starting around 2-4 years of age. Ocular disease is characterized by progressive retinal degeneration and impaired retinal function culminating in total loss of vision. Similar retinal pathology occurs in a canine model of CLN2 disease with a null variant in TPP1. A study using the dog model was performed to evaluate the efficacy of ocular gene therapy to provide a continuous, long-term source of human TPP1 (hTPP1) to the retina, inhibit retinal degeneration and preserve retinal function. TPP1-/- dogs received an intravitreal injection of 1 x 1012 viral genomes of AAV2.CAG.hTPP1 in one eye and AAV2.CAG.GFP in the contralateral eye at 4 months of age. Ophthalmic exams, in vivo ocular imaging and electroretinography were repeated monthly to assess retinal structure and function. Retinal morphology, hTPP1 and GFP expression in the retina, optic nerve and lateral geniculate nucleus, and hTPP1 concentrations in the vitreous were evaluated after the dogs were euthanized at end stage neurological disease at approximately 10 months of age. Intravitreal administration of AAV2.CAG.hTPP1 resulted in stable, widespread expression of hTPP1 throughout the inner retina, prevented disease-related declines in retinal function and inhibited disease-related cell loss and storage body accumulation in the retina for at least 6 months. Uveitis occurred in eyes treated with the hTPP1 vector, but this did not prevent therapeutic efficacy. The severity of the uveitis was ameliorated with anti-inflammatory treatments. These results indicate that a single intravitreal injection of AAV2.CAG.hTPP1 is an effective treatment to inhibit ocular disease progression in canine CLN2 disease.

Gene targeting as a therapeutic avenue in diseases mediated by the complement alternative pathway

The complement alternative pathway (AP) is implicated in numerous diseases affecting many organs, ranging from the rare hematological disease paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH), to the common blinding disease age-related macular degeneration (AMD). Critically, the AP amplifies any activating trigger driving a downstream inflammatory response; thus, components of the pathway have become targets for drugs of varying modality. Recent validation from clinical trials using drug modalities such as inhibitory antibodies has paved the path for gene targeting of the AP or downstream effectors. Gene targeting in the complement field currently focuses on supplementation or suppression of complement regulators in AMD and PNH, largely because the eye and liver are highly amenable to drug delivery through local (eye) or systemic (liver) routes. Targeting the liver could facilitate treatment of numerous diseases as this organ generates most of the systemic complement pool. This review explains key concepts of RNA and DNA targeting and discusses assets in clinical development for the treatment of diseases driven by the alternative pathway, including the RNA-targeting therapeutics ALN-CC5, ARO-C3, and IONIS-FB-LRX, and the gene therapies GT005 and HMR59. These therapies are but the spearhead of potential drug candidates that might revolutionize the field in coming years.

New frontiers of retinal therapeutic intervention: a critical analysis of novel approaches

A recent wave of pharmacologic and technologic innovations has revolutionized our management of retinal diseases. Many of these advancements have demonstrated efficacy and can increase the quality of life while potentially reducing complications and decreasing the burden of care for patients. Some advances, such as longer-acting anti-vascular endothelial growth factor agents, port delivery systems, gene therapy, and retinal prosthetics have been approved by the US Food and Drug Administration, and are available for clinical use. Countless other therapeutics are in various stages of development, promising a bright future for further improvements in the management of the retinal disease. Herein, we have highlighted several important novel therapies and therapeutic approaches and examine the opportunities and limitations offered by these innovations at the new frontier. KEY MESSAGESNumerous pharmacologic and technologic advancements have been emerging, providing a higher treatment efficacy while decreasing the burden and associated side effects.Anti-vascular endothelial growth factor (anti-VEGF) and its longer-acting agents have dramatically improved visual outcomes and have become a mainstay treatment in various retinal diseases.Gene therapy and retinal prosthesis implantation in the treatment of congenital retinal dystrophy can accomplish the partial restoration of vision and improved daily function in patients with blindness, an unprecedented success in the field of retina.

The inner junction protein CFAP20 functions in motile and non-motile cilia and is critical for vision

Motile and non-motile cilia are associated with mutually-exclusive genetic disorders. Motile cilia propel sperm or extracellular fluids, and their dysfunction causes primary ciliary dyskinesia. Non-motile cilia serve as sensory/signalling antennae on most cell types, and their disruption causes single-organ ciliopathies such as retinopathies or multi-system syndromes. CFAP20 is a ciliopathy candidate known to modulate motile cilia in unicellular eukaryotes. We demonstrate that in zebrafish, cfap20 is required for motile cilia function, and in C. elegans, CFAP-20 maintains the structural integrity of non-motile cilia inner junctions, influencing sensory-dependent signalling and development. Human patients and zebrafish with CFAP20 mutations both exhibit retinal dystrophy. Hence, CFAP20 functions within a structural/functional hub centered on the inner junction that is shared between motile and non-motile cilia, and is distinct from other ciliopathy-associated domains or macromolecular complexes. Our findings suggest an uncharacterised pathomechanism for retinal dystrophy, and potentially for motile and non-motile ciliopathies in general.

Update on Viral Gene Therapy Clinical Trials for Retinal Diseases

In 2001, the first large animal was successfully treated with a gene therapy that restored its vision. Lancelot, the Briard dog that was treated, suffered from a human childhood blindness called Leber's congenital amaurosis type 2. Sixteen years later, the gene therapy was approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. The success of this gene therapy in dogs led to a fast expansion of the ocular gene therapy field. By now every class of inherited retinal dystrophy has been treated in at least one animal model and many clinical trials have been initiated in humans. In this study, we review the status of viral gene therapies for the retina, with a focus on ongoing human clinical trials. It is likely that in the next decade we will see several new viral gene therapies approved.

Gene therapy in hereditary retinal dystrophy

Hereditary retinal dystrophies (HRDs), such as retinitis pigmentosa, Leber's congenital amaurosis (LCA), Usher syndrome, and retinoschisis, are a group of genetic retinal disorders exhibiting both genetic and phenotypic heterogeneity. Symptoms include progressive retinal degeneration and constricted visual field. Some patients will be legal or completely blind. Advanced sequencing technologies improve the genetic diagnosis of HRD and lead to a new era of research into gene-targeted therapies. Following the first Food and Drug Administration approval of gene augmentation therapy for LCA caused by RPE65 mutations, multiple clinical trials are currently underway applying different techniques. In this review, we provide an overview of gene therapy for HRD and emphasize four distinct approaches to gene-targeted therapy that have the potential to slow or even reverse retinal degeneration: (1) viral vector-based and nonviral gene delivery, (2) RNA-based antisense oligonucleotide, (3) genome editing by the Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeat/cas9 system, and (4) optogenetics gene therapy.

RNA gene editing in the eye and beyond: The neglected tool of the gene editing armatorium?

RNA editing allows correction of pathological point mutations without permanently altering genomic DNA. Theoretically targetable to any RNA type and site, its flexibility and reversibility makes it a potentially powerful gene editing tool. RNA editing offers a host of potential advantages in specific niches when compared to currently available alternative gene manipulation techniques. Unlike DNA editors, which are currently too large to be delivered in vivo using a viral vector, smaller RNA editors fit easily within the capabilities of an adeno-associated virus (AAV). Unlike gene augmentation, which is limited by gene size and viral packaging constraints, RNA editing may correct transcripts too long to fit within a viral vector. In this article we examine the development of RNA editing and discuss potential applications and pitfalls. We argue that, although in its infancy, an RNA editing approach can offer unique advantages for selected retinal diseases.

The use of viral vectors in vaccine development

Vaccines represent the single most cost-efficient and equitable way to combat and eradicate infectious diseases. While traditional licensed vaccines consist of either inactivated/attenuated versions of the entire pathogen or subunits of it, most novel experimental vaccines against emerging infectious diseases employ nucleic acids to produce the antigen of interest directly in vivo. These include DNA plasmid vaccines, mRNA vaccines, and recombinant viral vectors. The advantages of using nucleic acid vaccines include their ability to induce durable immune responses, high vaccine stability, and ease of large-scale manufacturing. In this review, we present an overview of pre-clinical and clinical data on recombinant viral vector vaccines and discuss the advantages and limitations of the different viral vector platforms.

Emerging Gene Manipulation Strategies for the Treatment of Monogenic Eye Disease

Genetic eye diseases, representing a wide spectrum of simple and complex conditions, are one of the leading causes of visual loss in children and working adults, and progress in the field has led to changes in disease investigation, diagnosis, and management. The past 15 years have seen the emergence of novel therapies for these previously untreatable conditions to the extent that we now have a licensed therapy for one form of genetic eye disease and many more in clinical trial. This is a systematic review of published and ongoing clinical trials of gene therapies for monogenic eye diseases. Databases of clinical trials and the published literature were searched for interventional studies of gene therapies for eye diseases. Standard methodological procedures were used to assess the relevance of search results. A total of 59 registered clinical trials are referenced, showing the significant level of interest in the potential for translation of these therapies from bench to bedside. The breadth of therapy design is encouraging, providing multiple possible therapeutic mechanisms. Some fundamental questions regarding gene therapy for genetic eye diseases remain, such as optimal dosing, the relative benefits of adeno-associated virus (AAV)-packaging and the potential for a significant inflammatory response to the therapy itself. As a result, despite the promise of the eye as a target, it has proven difficult to deliver clinically effective gene therapies to the eye. Despite setbacks, the licensing of Luxturna (voretigene neparvovec, Novartis) for the treatment of RPE65-mediated Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA) is a major advance in efforts to treat these rare, but devastating, causes of visual loss.

Inflammation after voretigene neparvovec administration in patients with RPE65-related retinal dystrophy

OBJECTIVE

To report on the prevalence of intraocular inflammation after subretinal voretigene neparvovec (VN) administration.

DESIGN

Retrospective review of medical files.

PARTICIPANTS

All patients receiving VN in Denmark.

METHODS

Twelve patients had received VN gene therapy as standard-of-care for bi-allelic RPE65-related retinal disease. Bilateral treatment had been performed in 11 patients and unilateral treatmen in one patient. Patients had been followed clinically before and after VN administration using functional measurements (visual acuity, full-field scotopic threshold (FST) test, visual fields) and structural evaluations (fundus imaging (color and autofluorescence), optical coherence tomography (OCT), slitlamp).

MAIN OUTCOMES

Signs of intraocular inflammation including vitritis and outer retinal infiltrates.

RESULTS

Vitritis was observed in 9 out of 23 eyes receiving VN. The median time to resolution of vitritis from the time of treatment was 89 days. Four eyes also presented with outer retinal infiltrates at the time of vitritis. Inflammation subsided on immunosuppressant therapy. The presence of inflammation did not adversely affect visual outcome after VN therapy. In one eye outer retinal infiltrates were demonstrated to precede later development of atrophy.

CONCLUSION

Patients undergoing subretinal gene therapy needs to be closely monitored for signs of inflammation and although we did not observe a detrimental effect on visual function in eyes with inflammation, it seems wise to treat it appropriately as it may lead to atrophy of the RPE and outer retina. Also, it seems advisable to reduce the inflammatory load such as using a surgical technique that minimizes residual viral vectors in the vitreous body.

AAV2-hCHM Subretinal Delivery to the Macula in Choroideremia: Two Year Interim Results of an Ongoing Phase I/II Gene Therapy Trial

PURPOSE

To assess the safety of the subretinal delivery of a recombinant adeno-associated virus serotype 2 (AAV2) vector carrying a human CHM-encoding cDNA in choroideremia (CHM).

DESIGN

Prospective, open-label, non-randomized, dose-escalation, phase 1/2 clinical trial.

SUBJECTS, PARTICIPANTS, AND/OR CONTROLS

Fifteen CHM patients (ages 20-57 years at dosing).

METHODS, INTERVENTION, OR TESTING

Patients received uniocular subfoveal injections of low dose (up to 5x10¹⁰ vector genome (vg) per eye, n=5) or high dose (up to 1x10¹¹ vg per eye, n=10) AAV2-hCHM. Patients were evaluated pre- and post-operatively for two years with ophthalmic examinations, multimodal retinal imaging and psychophysical testing.

MAIN OUTCOME

Measures: visual acuity (VA), perimetry (10-2 protocol), spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) and short-wavelength fundus autofluorescence (SW-FAF).

RESULTS

We detected no vector-related or systemic toxicities. VA returned to within 15 letters of baseline in all but two patients (one developed acute foveal thinning, another patient, a macular hole); the rest showed no gross changes in foveal structure at two years. There were no significant differences between intervention and control eyes in mean light-adapted sensitivity by perimetry, or in the lateral extent of retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) relative preservation by SD-OCT and SW-FAF. Microperimetry showed non-significant (<3SD of the intervisit variability) gains in sensitivity in some locations and participants in the intervention eye. There were no obvious dose-dependent relationships.

CONCLUSIONS

VA was within 15 letters of baseline after the subfoveal AAV2-hCHM injections in 13/15 (87%) of the patients. Acute foveal thinning with unchanged perifoveal function in one patient and macular hole in a second suggests foveal vulnerability to the subretinal injections. Longer observation intervals will help establish the significance of the minor differences in sensitivities and rate of disease progression observed between intervention and control eyes.

Choroideremia: molecular mechanisms and therapies

Choroideremia (CHM) is a monogenic X-linked chorioretinal dystrophy affecting the photoreceptors, retinal pigment epithelium (RPE), and choroid; it is caused by mutations involving the CHM gene. CHM is characterized by night blindness in early childhood, progressing to peripheral visual field loss and eventually to complete blindness from middle age. CHM encodes the ubiquitously expressed Rab escort protein 1 (REP1), which is responsible for prenylation of Rab proteins and is essential for intracellular trafficking of vesicles. In this review we explore the role of REP1 in the retina and its newly discovered systemic manifestations, and discuss the therapeutic strategies for tackling this disease, including the outcomes from recent clinical trials.

Short-term Assessment of Subfoveal Injection of Adeno-Associated Virus-Mediated hCHM Gene Augmentation in Choroideremia Using Adaptive Optics Ophthalmoscopy

Importance

Subretinal injection for gene augmentation in retinal degenerations forcefully detaches the neural retina from the retinal pigment epithelium, potentially damaging photoreceptors and/or retinal pigment epithelium cells.

Objective

To use adaptive optics scanning light ophthalmoscopy (AOSLO) to assess the short-term integrity of the cone mosaic following subretinal injections of adeno-associated virus vector designed to deliver a functional version of the CHM gene (AAV2-hCHM) in patients with choroideremia.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This longitudinal case series study enrolled adult patients with choroideremia from February 2015 to January 2016 in the US. To be included in the study, study participants must have received uniocular subfoveal injections of low-dose (5 × 1010 vector genome per eye) or high-dose (1 × 1011 vector genome per eye) AAV2-hCHM. Analysis began February 2015.

Main Outcomes and Measures

The macular regions of both eyes were imaged before and 1 month after injection using a custom-built multimodal AOSLO. Postinjection cone inner segment mosaics were compared with preinjection mosaics at multiple regions of interest. Colocalized spectral-domain optical coherence tomography and dark-adapted cone sensitivity was also acquired at each time point.

Results

Nine study participants ranged in age from 26 to 50 years at the time of enrollment, and all were White men. Postinjection AOSLO images showed preservation of the cone mosaic in all 9 AAV2-hCHM-injected eyes. Mosaics appeared intact and contiguous 1 month postinjection, with the exception of foveal disruption in 1 patient. Optical coherence tomography showed foveal cone outer segment shortening postinjection. Cone-mediated sensitivities were unchanged in 8 of 9 injected and 9 of 9 uninjected eyes. One participant showed acute loss of foveal optical coherence tomography cone outer segment-related signals along with cone sensitivity loss that colocalized with disruption of the mosaic on AOSLO.

Conclusions and Relevance

Integrity of the cone mosaic is maintained following subretinal delivery of AAV2-hCHM, providing strong evidence in support of the safety of the injections. Minor foveal thinning observed following surgery corresponds with short-term cone outer segment shortening rather than cone cell loss. Foveal cone loss in 1 participant raises the possibility of individual vulnerability to the subretinal injection.

Investigation of Cas9 antibodies in the human eye

Preexisting immunity against Cas9 proteins in humans represents a safety risk for CRISPR–Cas9 technologies. However, it is unclear to what extent preexisting Cas9 immunity is relevant to the eye as it is targeted for early in vivo CRISPR–Cas9 clinical trials. While the eye lacks T-cells, it contains antibodies, cytokines, and resident immune cells. Although precise mechanisms are unclear, intraocular inflammation remains a major cause of vision loss. Here, we used immunoglobulin isotyping and ELISA platforms to profile antibodies in serum and vitreous fluid biopsies from human adult subjects and Cas9-immunized mice. We observed high prevalence of preexisting Cas9-reactive antibodies in serum but not in the eye. However, we detected intraocular antibodies reactive to S. pyogenes-derived Cas9 after S. pyogenes intraocular infection. Our data suggest that serum antibody concentration may determine whether specific intraocular antibodies develop, but preexisting immunity to Cas9 may represent a lower risk in human eyes than systemically.

Pre-existing antibodies against Cas9 proteins represent a potential issue for gene therapies, including those targeting the eye. Here the authors assess the presence of intraocular antibodies, and show that Cas9 antibodies were prevalent in human serum but not the eye, unless prior bacterial infection occurred.

Lessons learned from research on choroideremia

Having devoted over 35 years of my professional life to various projects on choroideremia (CHM), I began to reflect on the many lessons that I learned along the way. One of the most important is: we should pay careful attention to possible, unintended psychological harm in clinical research. This lesson was learned early and then reinforced when I engaged CHM patients in an investigator-sponsored Phase IB clinical trial of ocular gene therapy for choroideremia. My second lesson came from the trial itself in that preliminary data may not be sufficient to predict the risks to patients in a clinical trial. In the significant push to begin a gene therapy trial for CHM patients, writing grants, recruiting personnel, interacting with regulatory authorities, acquiring research equipment to test outcome measures, I missed a third lesson. There is significant bias when the principal investigator of an investigator-sponsored clinical trial is also the treating physician in the trial. Ideally, those two roles should be kept separate. Finally, having completed the clinical trial, I learned that gene replacement with an AAV vector may not be the only genetic therapy for CHM; an antisense oligonucleotide therapy may be possible in select cases.

Bilateral visual acuity decline in males with choroideremia: a pooled, cross-sectional meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Choroideremia is a rare inherited retinal disease that leads to blindness. Visual acuity (VA) is a key outcome measure in choroideremia treatment studies, but VA decline rates change with age. An accurate understanding of the natural deterioration of VA in choroideremia is important to assess the treatment effect of new therapies in which VA is the primary outcome measure. We conducted a meta-analysis of data on individuals with choroideremia to determine the rate of VA deterioration between the better- and worse-seeing eye (BSE and WSE, respectively).

METHODS

Data were collected from the prospective Natural History of the Progression of Choroideremia (NIGHT) study (613 eyes, baseline data only), studies included in a recent meta-analysis, and studies identified in a targeted literature search performed on March 25, 2020, including individual best-corrected VA (BCVA) and age data in male individuals with choroideremia. Best-corrected VA decline rates (measured by logMAR units) by age and trends in BCVA decline rates in the BSE and WSE were evaluated.  RESULTS: Data from 1037 males (1602 eyes; mean age, 41.8 years) were included. Before and after an age cutoff of 33.8 years, BCVA decline rates for the WSE were 0.0086 and 0.0219 logMAR per year, respectively. Before and after an age cutoff of 39.1 years, BCVA decline rates for the BSE were 0.00001 and 0.0203 logMAR per year, respectively. Differences in absolute BCVA and decline rates increased between the 2 eyes until age ~ 40; thereafter, differences in absolute BCVA and decline rates were similar between eyes.

CONCLUSIONS

Using the largest choroideremia data set to date, this analysis demonstrates accelerated BCVA decline beginning between 30 and 40 years of age. Disparate interocular progression rates were observed before the transition age, with similar interocular progression rates after the transition age.

The safety and efficacy of gene therapy treatment for monogenic retinal and optic nerve diseases: A systematic review

PURPOSE

This study aimed to systematically review and summarize gene therapy treatment for monogenic retinal and optic nerve diseases.

METHODS

This review was prospectively registered (CRD42021229812). A comprehensive literature search was performed in Ovid MEDLINE, Ovid Embase, Cochrane Central, and clinical trial registries (February 2021). Clinical studies describing DNA-based gene therapy treatments for monogenic posterior ocular diseases were eligible for inclusion. Risk of bias evaluation was performed. Data synthesis was undertaken applying Synthesis Without Meta-analysis guidelines.

RESULTS

This study identified 47 full-text publications, 50 conference abstracts, and 54 clinical trial registry entries describing DNA-based ocular gene therapy treatments for 16 different genetic variants. Study summaries and visual representations of safety and efficacy outcomes are presented for 20 unique full-text publications in RPE65-mediated retinal dystrophies, choroideremia, Leber hereditary optic neuropathy, rod-cone dystrophy, achromatopsia, and X-linked retinoschisis. The most common adverse events were related to lid/ocular surface/cornea abnormalities in subretinal gene therapy trials and anterior uveitis in intravitreal gene therapy trials.

CONCLUSION

There is a high degree of variability in ocular monogenic gene therapy trials with respect to study design, statistical methodology, and reporting of safety and efficacy outcomes. This review improves the accessibility and transparency in interpreting gene therapy trials to date.

Risk Mitigation of Immunogenicity: A Key to Personalized Retinal Gene Therapy

Gene therapy (GT) for ocular disorders has advanced the most among adeno-associated virus (AAV)-mediated therapies, with one product already approved in the market. The bank of retinal gene mutations carefully compiled over 30 years, the small retinal surface that does not require high clinical vector stocks, and the relatively immune-privileged environment of the eye explain such success. However, adverse effects due to AAV-delivery, though rare in the retina have led to the interruption of clinical trials. Risk mitigation, as the key to safe and efficient GT, has become the focus of 'bedside-back-to-bench' studies. Herein, we overview the inflammatory adverse events described in retinal GT trials and analyze which components of the retinal immunological environment might be the most involved in these immune responses, with a focus on the innate immune system composed of microglial surveillance. We consider the factors that can influence inflammation in the retina after GT such as viral sensors in the retinal tissue and CpG content in promoters or transgene sequences. Finally, we consider options to reduce the immunological risk, including dose, modified capsids or exclusion criteria for clinical trials. A better understanding and mitigation of immune risk factors inducing host immunity in AAV-mediated retinal GT is the key to achieving safe and efficient GT.

Gene Therapy in Inherited Retinal Diseases: An Update on Current State of the Art

Background: Gene therapy cannot be yet considered a far perspective, but a tangible therapeutic option in the field of retinal diseases. Although still confined in experimental settings, the preliminary results are promising and provide an overall scenario suggesting that we are not so far from the application of gene therapy in clinical settings. The main aim of this review is to provide a complete and updated overview of the current state of the art and of the future perspectives of gene therapy applied on retinal diseases.

Methods: We carefully revised the entire literature to report all the relevant findings related to the experimental procedures and the future scenarios of gene therapy applied in retinal diseases. A clinical background and a detailed description of the genetic features of each retinal disease included are also reported.

Results: The current literature strongly support the hope of gene therapy options developed for retinal diseases. Although being considered in advanced stages of investigation for some retinal diseases, such as choroideremia (CHM), retinitis pigmentosa (RP), and Leber's congenital amaurosis (LCA), gene therapy is still quite far from a tangible application in clinical practice for other retinal diseases.

Conclusions: Gene therapy is an extremely promising therapeutic tool for retinal diseases. The experimental data reported in this review offer a strong hope that gene therapy will be effectively available in clinical practice in the next years.

Molecular Therapy for Choroideremia: Pre-clinical and Clinical Progress to Date

Choroideremia is an inherited retinal disease characterised by a degeneration of the light-sensing photoreceptors, supporting retinal pigment epithelium and underlying choroid. Patients present with the same symptoms as those with classic rod-cone dystrophy: (1) night blindness early in life; (2) progressive peripheral visual field loss, and (3) central vision decline with a slow progression to legal blindness. Choroideremia is monogenic and caused by mutations in CHM. Eight clinical trials (three phase 1/2, four phase 2, and one phase 3) have started (four of which are already finished) to evaluate the therapeutic efficacy of gene supplementation mediated by subretinal delivery of an adeno-associated virus serotype 2 (AAV2/2) vector expressing CHM. Furthermore, one phase 1 clinical trial has been initiated to evaluate the efficiency of a novel AAV variant to deliver CHM to the outer retina following intravitreal delivery. Lastly, a non-viral-mediated CHM replacement strategy is currently under development, which could lead to a future clinical trial. Here, we summarise the rationale behind these various studies, as well as any results published to date. The diversity of these trials currently places choroideremia at the forefront of the retinal gene therapy field. As a consequence, the trial outcomes, regardless of the results, have the potential to change the landscape of gene supplementation for inherited retinal diseases.

Gene therapy for inherited retinal diseases

Inherited retinal diseases (IRDs) are a genetically variable collection of devastating disorders that lead to significant visual impairment. Advances in genetic characterization over the past two decades have allowed identification of over 260 causative mutations associated with inherited retinal disorders. Thought to be incurable, gene supplementation therapy offers great promise in treating various forms of these blinding conditions. In gene replacement therapy, a disease-causing gene is replaced with a functional copy of the gene. These therapies are designed to slow disease progression and hopefully restore visual function. Gene therapies are typically delivered to target retinal cells by subretinal (SR) or intravitreal (IVT) injection. The historic Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval of voretigene neparvovec for RPE65-associated Leber's congenital amaurosis (LCA) spurred tremendous optimism surrounding retinal gene therapy for various other monogenic IRDs. Novel disease-causing mutations continue to be discovered annually, and targeted genetic therapy is now under development in clinical and preclinical models for many IRDs. Numerous clinical trials for other IRDs are ongoing or have recently completed. Disorders being targeted for genetic therapy include retinitis pigmentosa (RP), choroideremia (CHM), achromatopsia (ACHM), Leber's hereditary optic neuropathy, usher syndrome (USH), X-linked retinoschisis, and Stargardt disease. Here, we provide an update of completed, ongoing, and planned clinical trials using gene supplementation strategies for retinal degenerative disorders.

Precision Medicine Trials in Retinal Degenerations

The beginning of the twenty-first century was marked by the innovative use of pharmacochemical interventions, which have since expanded to include gene-based molecular therapies. For years, treatment has focused on tackling the pathophysiology of monogenic orphan diseases, and one of the first applications of these novel genome editing technologies was the treatment of rare inherited retinal dystrophies. In this review, we present recent, ongoing, and future gene therapy-based treatment trials for choroideremia, X-linked retinitis pigmentosa, Stargardt disease, and age-related macular degeneration. As these trials pave the way toward halting the progression of such devastating diseases, we will begin to see the exciting development of newer, cutting-edge strategies including base editing and prime editing, ushering in a new era of precision medicine.

An Optimized Treatment Protocol for Subretinal Injections Limits Intravitreal Vector Distribution

Purpose

Subretinal injections (SRis) are commonly used in retinal gene therapy procedures to deliver adeno-associated virus (AAV) to photoreceptors and retinal pigment epithelial cells. We present an optimized surgical protocol to minimize off-target application of AAV in the vitreous, which in turn reduces the risk of extensive biodistribution and inflammation, ultimately leading to enhanced safety of the therapy.

Design

Experimental animal research study.

Participants

Eight cynomolgus monkeys (Macaca fascicularis).

Methods

Subretinal injections with an AAV2/8 vector were performed. The animals were allocated to 2 different vector dose groups (1×10^ˆ11 and 5×10^ˆ11 viral genomes [vg]). Samples of intravitreal fluid were taken at the end of the SRi procedure and again after a 3-minute lavage (wash-out) with balanced salt solution (BSS).

Main Outcome Measures

Intravitreal vector genome copies were analyzed with quantitative polymerase chain reaction and compared between groups.

Results

Even uneventful SRi leads to dissemination of millions of AAV particles (0.1–0.7% of viral vector loading dose) into the vitreous cavity. Three minutes of lavage led to a substantial decrease (on average 96%) of intravitreal vector load.

Conclusions

Multiple studies have shown that the intravitreal space is not as immune privileged as the subretinal space. Intravitreal AAV particles disseminate into the bloodstream, lead to increased biodistribution into lymphatic tissue, and help to stage an immune response with implications for both safety and efficacy. Therefore, minimizing off-target vector application after reflux of vector from the subretinal space is of significant interest. We show that a simple lavage of intravitreal fluid efficiently decreases the intravitreal vector load. Such a step should be considered when performing subretinal gene therapy.