Impact of novel detergents on membrane protein studies

Cross-Linking Mass Spectrometry of the Antimicrobial Peptides Magainin 2 and PGLa Reveals Heterodimerization in Micellar Medium

RATIONALE

In this study, we applied cross-linking mass spectrometry (XL-MS) to characterize the oligomeric states of a PGLa/magainin 2 mixture and gain insight into the heterodimerization previously suggested in the literature. Both peptides have shown a synergistic enhancement of activity when tested in antimicrobial assays; however, the mechanism of action is still not well understood.

METHODS

Peptides solutions were prepared in HEPES buffer in the presence of membrane-mimicking DDM detergent micelles or POPE:POPG 3:1 vesicles. Cross-linking experiments were performed using disuccinimidyl suberate (DSS) or disuccinimidyl glutarate (DSG), and MALDI-MS was used to follow the cross-linking performance. Nano liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry was conducted on a Q Exactive Plus orbitrap to achieve linkage sites determination using pLink2 for data interpretation. Trypsin or pepsin digestion was performed for the characterization of intermolecular links.

RESULTS

XL-MS performed in a DDM micelle environment provided direct evidence of a specific PGLa/magainin 2 heterodimer, but no other oligomeric states were detected. Monitoring the reaction using MALDI-MS allowed unambiguous characterization of the cross-linked stabilized oligomers and facilitated a rapid optimization of conditions to achieve the best balance between stabilizing complex formation and avoiding unspecific aggregation. Comparison of the cross-linked species in detergent micelles and lipidic POPE:POPG bilayers revealed different behaviors suggesting that interaction between the peptides might occur differently in both membrane-mimicking media.

CONCLUSIONS

This study revealed that XL-MS was relevant at the peptidomic level. However, the cross-linking workflow had to be adjusted compared to its use in large-scale protein-protein interaction mapping in order to avoid technical bias arising from the rapid nature of the cross-linking reaction.

Improved Pendant-Bearing Glucose-Neopentyl Glycols for Membrane Protein Stability

Membrane proteins are biologically and pharmaceutically significant, and determining their 3D structures requires a membrane-mimetic system to maintain protein stability. Detergent micelles are widely used as membrane mimetics; however, their dynamic structures often lead to the denaturation and aggregation of encapsulated membrane proteins. To address the limitations of classical detergents in stabilizing membrane proteins, we previously reported a class of glucose-neopentyl glycols (GNGs) and their pendant-bearing versions (P-GNGs), several of which proved more effective than DDM in stabilizing membrane proteins. In this study, we synthesized additional GNG derivatives by varying the lengths of the pendant (P-GNGs), and by introducing hemifluorinated pendants to the GNG scaffold (fluorinated pendant-bearing GNGs or FP-GNGs). The synthetic flexibility of the GNG chemical architecture allowed us to create a diverse range of derivatives, essential for the effective optimization of detergent properties. When tested with two model membrane proteins (a transporter and a G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR)), most of the new (F)P-GNGs demonstrated superior stabilization of these membrane proteins compared to DDM, the original GNG (OGNG)), and a previously developed P-GNG (i.e., GNG-3,14). Notably, several P-GNGs synthesized in this study were as effective as or even better than lauryl maltose neopentyl glycol (LMNG) in stabilizing a human GPCR, beta2 adrenergic receptor (β2AR). Enhanced protein stability was particularly observed for the P-GNGs with a butyl (C4) or pentyl (C5) pendant, indicating that these pendant sizes are optimal for membrane protein stability. The volumes of these pendants appear to minimize the empty spaces in the micelle interiors, thereby enhancing detergent-detergent interactions in micelles complexed with the membrane proteins. Additionally, we identified one FP-GNG that was more efficient at extracting the transporter and more effective at stabilizing the GPCR than DDM. Thus, the current study demonstrates that both chain length and number of fluorine atoms in the pendants of the P-GNGs were crucial determinants for membrane protein stability. We not only developed a few (F)P-GNGs that are significantly more effective than maltoside detergents (LMNG/DDM) for protein extraction and stability but we also provided an effective strategy for detergent design through the utilization of partially fluorinated pendants of varying length.

Multiple Pendants-Bearing Triglucosides for Membrane Protein Studies: Effects of Pendant Length and Number on Micelle Interior Hydration and Protein Stability

Membrane proteins play central roles in cell physiology and are the targets of over 50% of FDA-approved drugs. In the present study, we prepared single alkyl-chained triglucosides decorated with multiple pendants, designated multiple pendant-bearing glucosides (MPGs), to enhance membrane protein stability. The new detergents feature two and four pendants of varying size at the hydrophilic-lipophilic interfaces, designated MPG-Ds and MPG-Ts, respectively. When tested with model membrane proteins, including the human adrenergic receptor (β2AR), the tetra-pendant-bearing MPGs (MPG-Ts) demonstrated superior performance compared to the dipendant analogs (MPG-Ds) and the gold standard DDM. All-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations results reveal that the four-pendant configuration of this detergent is remarkably effective in excluding water from the hydrophobic micelle interiors compared to the dipendant MPGs and DDM, an unprecedented feature of this new detergent. Our findings provide a novel strategy for designing water-resistant detergents, advancing the field of membrane protein research.

"Living Detergents": an in Situ Detergent Tailoring Strategy for Efficient Membrane Protein Stabilization and Analysis

Detergents are essential molecular tools for membrane protein (MP) research, yet traditional detergents with static properties often fail to address the diverse and evolving needs of MP studies. To this end, this study introduces "living detergents", an innovative class of detergents equipped with functional tags that enable bioorthogonal modifications with externally introduced structural elements. This approach allows for not only the parallel generation of new detergents, but also in situ tuning of MP samples within freshly formed detergents. The efficacy of this strategy was demonstrated through the rapid identification of optimal detergents for high-quality electron microscopy studies of A2AAR. Overall, this flexible and robust platform enables efficient tailoring of detergents, advancing the exploration of detergent structure-function relationships in MP research and opening pathways for more specialized solutions for diverse experimental demands.

Advances in solubilization and stabilization techniques for structural and functional studies of membrane proteins

Membrane proteins (MPs) are indispensable in various biological processes, including material transport, signal transduction, immune response, and cell recognition. Unraveling the intricate interplay between MP structure and function is pivotal for advancing fundamental biology and pharmaceutical research. However, the inherent hydrophobicity and complex lipid interactions of MPs pose significant challenges in determining their three-dimensional configurations. In recent years, cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) has emerged as a powerful alternative for structural elucidation, overcoming the challenges faced by traditional techniques such as X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). This review centers on advanced solubilization and stabilization techniques for MPs, as well as MP functions and expression systems, highlighting the strengths and limitations of conventional detergents, liposomes, bicelles, and nanodiscs, alongside emerging alternatives like styrene-maleic acid (SMA) and diisobutylene-maleic acid (DIBMA). Notably, SMA and its derivatives provide promising detergent-free alternatives that preserve protein stability and native conformation, which is particularly valuable for accurate cryo-EM characterization of complex MPs. This work is designed to serve as both an updated resource for researchers already immersed in the field and an accessible entry point for those new to MP research. By consolidating recent advancements and highlighting critical gaps, this review aims to inspire future investigations that push the boundaries of MP structural and functional studies, ultimately driving innovations in drug discovery and therapeutic development.

Direct effect of membrane environment on the activation of mGluR2 revealed by single-molecule FRET

The microenvironment of membrane receptors controls their mobility, structure, interactions, and dynamics, but a systematic understanding of how it modulates receptor function is often lacking. Using single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET), we characterized how detergents and cholesterol modulate the conformational dynamics of metabotropic glutamate receptor 2 (mGluR2), a class C G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR). We found that, within the resolution of our measurements, all tested detergents stabilize the same overall active and inactive structure of different domains of mGluR2. However, the degree of stabilization and the equilibrium between active and inactive conformations depended on the detergent. Detergents with a single hydrophobic tail increased the active state occupancy compared to those with long, branched tails. Adding cholesterol to micelles with branched hydrophobic tails shifted the equilibrium toward the inactive state. Mutagenesis identified residues potentially involved in cholesterol interaction with mGluR2. Targeting the cholesterol-binding site with synthetic molecules could be a viable therapeutic approach.

Impact of Fluorination on Membrane-Protein Stabilization and Extraction by Lactobionamide Detergents

We report the synthesis of a series of detergents with a lactobionamide polar head group and a tail containing four to seven perfluorinated carbon atoms. Critical micellar concentrations (CMCs) were determined using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and surface tension (SFT) measurements, showing a progressive decrease from 27 mM to about 0.2 mM across the series. While the detergent with the longest fluorinated chain exhibited poor water solubility, the other three derivatives were freely soluble. Dynamic light scattering (DLS) measurements indicated an increase in hydrodynamic diameter with chain length, from 5 nm to 17 nm for the soluble derivatives. We evaluated these detergents for extraction and stabilization of two model membrane proteins, the human adenosine A2A receptor (A2AR) and the Bacillus subtilis multidrug resistance ABC transporter BmrA. The perfluorohexyl derivative demonstrated strong solubilization capacity, while the perfluoro-pentyl derivative was more effective for stabilization. The lack of a clear correlation between fluoroalkyl chain length and solubilizing or stabilizing efficacy highlights the importance of screening diverse detergents for membrane-protein studies.

Peptide-Scaffolded Detergents for Membrane Protein Studies

Detergents are essential for preserving the structural integrity and functionality of membrane proteins (MPs) outside the biological membrane or in aqueous solution, and thus ensuring accurate biochemical and structural analyses. Here, we introduce peptide-scaffolded detergents, a novel class of hybrid molecules formed by preassembling detergent monomers with peptides of varying lengths, mediated via Click chemistry. These detergents are characterized by scalable, straightforward synthesis and enhanced solubility. Among the variants, A4B2 emerged as the optimal detergent, demonstrating superior thermal stabilization across a range of G protein-coupled receptors, including A2AAR, SMO and GLP-1R. Additionally, A4B2 exhibits a low critical micelle concentration and small micelle size, together making it particularly effective for electron microscopy studies of A2AAR. This innovative design leverages the benefits of peptide-based and traditional detergents, offering new insights for the development of advanced detergents in MP research.

Unsymmetric Triazine-Based Triglucoside Detergents for Membrane Protein Stability

Membrane proteins play a crucial role in a variety of biological processes and are key targets for pharmaceutical development. Structural studies of membrane proteins provide molecular insights into the mechanisms of these processes and are essential for effective drug discovery. Historically, these studies have relied on solubilization of the target protein using detergents, but conventional detergents often fail to maintain the stability of challenging membrane proteins. To address this issue, there is a need to develop novel detergents with enhanced protein stabilization properties. In this study, we synthesized unsymmetric variants of recently reported tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane(TRIS)-linker-bearing triazine-based triglucosides (TTGs) by incorporating two different alkyl chains (long and short) into the detergent structure. When tested with model membrane proteins, including a G protein-coupled receptor, TTG-8,12 demonstrated superior efficacy in stabilizing membrane proteins compared to the original TTGs and the gold standard detergents DDM/LMNG. These results suggest that detergent unsymmetry is an important concept for improving detergent performance and unsymmetric detergents such as TTG-8,12 hold significant potential for advancing membrane protein structural studies.

Characterization of intact FeoB in a lipid bilayer using styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers

The acquisition of ferrous iron (Fe2+) is crucial for the survival of many pathogenic bacteria living within acidic and/or anoxic conditions such as Vibrio cholerae, the causative agent of the disease cholera. Bacterial pathogens utilize iron as a cofactor to drive essential metabolic processes, and the primary prokaryotic Fe2+ acquisition mechanism is the ferrous iron transport (Feo) system. In V. cholerae, the Feo system comprises two cytosolic proteins (FeoA, FeoC) and a complex, polytopic transmembrane protein (FeoB) that is regulated by an N-terminal soluble domain (NFeoB) with promiscuous NTPase activity. While the soluble components of the Feo system have been frequently studied, very few reports exist on the intact membrane protein FeoB. Moreover, FeoB has been characterize almost exclusively in detergent micelles that can cause protein misfolding, disrupt protein oligomerization, and even dramatically alter protein function. As many of these characteristics of FeoB remain unclear, there is a critical need to characterize FeoB in a more native-like lipid environment. To address this unmet need, we employ styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers to isolate and to characterize V. cholerae FeoB (VcFeoB) encapsulated by a styrene-maleic acid lipid particle (SMALP). In this work, we describe the development of a workflow for the expression and the purification of VcFeoB in a SMALP. Leveraging mass photometry, we explore the oligomerization of FeoB in a lipid bilayer and show that the VcFeoB-SMALP is mostly monomeric, consistent with our previous oligomerization observations in surfo. Finally, we characterize the NTPase activity of VcFeoB in the SMALP and in a detergent (DDM), revealing higher NTPase activity in the presence of the lipid bilayer. When taken together, this report represents the first characterization of any FeoB in a native-like lipid bilayer and provides a viable approach for the future structural characterization of FeoB.

Biased activation of the vasopressin V2 receptor probed by molecular dynamics simulations, NMR and pharmacological studies

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) control critical cell signaling. Their response to extracellular stimuli involves conformational changes to convey signals to intracellular effectors, among which the most important are G proteins and β-arrestins (βArrs). Biased activation of one pathway is a field of intense research in GPCR pharmacology. Combining NMR, site-directed mutagenesis, molecular pharmacology, and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we studied the conformational diversity of the vasopressin V2 receptor (V2R) bound to different types of ligands: the antagonist Tolvaptan, the endogenous unbiased agonist arginine-vasopressin, and MCF14, a partial Gs protein-biased agonist. A double-labeling NMR scheme was developed to study the receptor conformational changes and ligand binding: V2R was subjected to lysine 13CH3 methylation for complementary NMR studies, whereas the agonists were tagged with a paramagnetic probe. Paramagnetic relaxation enhancements and site-directed mutagenesis validated the ligand binding modes in the MD simulations. We found that the bias for the Gs protein over the βArr pathway involves interactions between the conserved NPxxY motif in the transmembrane helix 7 (TM7) and TM3, compacting helix 8 (H8) toward TM1 and likely inhibiting βArr signaling. A similar mechanism was elicited for the pathogenic mutation I130N, which constitutively activates the Gs proteins without concomitant βArr recruitment. The findings suggest common patterns of biased signaling in class A GPCRs, as well as a rationale for the design of G protein-biased V2R agonists.

Recent Advances in Expression Screening and Sample Evaluation for Structural Studies of Membrane Proteins

Membrane proteins are involved in numerous biological processes and represent more than half of all drug targets; thus, structural information on these proteins is invaluable. However, the low expression level of membrane proteins, as well as their poor stability in solution and tendency to precipitate and aggregate, are major bottlenecks in the preparation of purified membrane proteins for structural studies. Traditionally, the evaluation of membrane protein constructs for structural studies has been quite time consuming and expensive since it is necessary to express and purify the proteins on a large scale, particularly for X-ray crystallography. The emergence of fluorescence detection size exclusion chromatography (FSEC) has drastically changed this situation, as this method can be used to rapidly evaluate the expression and behavior of membrane proteins on a small scale without the need for purification. FSEC has become the most widely used method for the screening of expression conditions and sample evaluation for membrane proteins, leading to the successful determination of numerous structures. Even in the era of cryo-EM, FSEC and the new generation of FSEC derivative methods are being widely used in various manners to facilitate structural analysis. In addition, the application of FSEC is not limited to structural analysis; this method is also widely used for functional analysis of membrane proteins, including for analysis of oligomerization state, screening of antibodies and ligands, and affinity profiling. This review presents the latest advances and applications in membrane protein expression screening and sample evaluation, with a particular focus on FSEC methods.

Crystallographic insights into lipid-membrane protein interactions in microbial rhodopsins

The primary goal of our work is to provide structural insights into the influence of the hydrophobic lipid environment on the membrane proteins (MPs) structure and function. Our work will not cover the well-studied hydrophobic mismatch between the lipid bilayer and MPs. Instead, we will focus on the less-studied direct molecular interactions of lipids with the hydrophobic surfaces of MPs. To visualize the first layer of amphiphiles surrounding MPs and analyze their interaction with the proteins, we use the available highest-quality crystallographic structures of microbial rhodopsins. The results of the structure-based analysis allowed us to formulate the hypothetical concept of the role of the nearest layer of the lipids as an integral part of the MPs that are important for their structure and function. We then discuss how the lipid-MPs interaction is influenced by exogenous hydrophobic molecules, noble gases, which can compete with lipids for the surface of MPs and can be used in the systematic approach to verify the proposed concept experimentally. Finally, we raise the problems of currently available structural data that should be overcome to obtain a more profound picture of the lipid-MP interactions.

Localization of proteins involved in the biogenesis and repair of the photosynthetic apparatus to thylakoid subdomains in Arabidopsis

Thylakoid membranes in chloroplasts and cyanobacteria harbor the multisubunit protein complexes that catalyze the light reactions of photosynthesis. In plant chloroplasts, the thylakoid membrane system comprises a highly organized network with several subcompartments that differ in composition and morphology: grana stacks, unstacked stromal lamellae, and grana margins at the interface between stacked and unstacked regions. The localization of components of the photosynthetic apparatus among these subcompartments has been well characterized. However, less is known about the localization of proteins involved in the biogenesis and repair of the photosynthetic apparatus, the partitioning of proteins between two recently resolved components of the traditional margin fraction (refined margins and curvature), and the effects of light on these features. In this study, we analyzed the partitioning of numerous thylakoid biogenesis and repair factors among grana, curvature, refined margin, and stromal lamellae fractions of Arabidopsis thylakoid membranes, comparing the results from illuminated and dark-adapted plants. Several proteins previously shown to localize to a margin fraction partitioned in varying ways among the resolved curvature and refined margin fractions. For example, the ALB3 insertase and FtsH protease involved in photosystem II (PSII) repair were concentrated in the refined margin fraction, whereas TAT translocon subunits and proteins involved in early steps in photosystem assembly were concentrated in the curvature fraction. By contrast, two photosystem assembly factors that facilitate late assembly steps were depleted from the curvature fraction. The enrichment of the PSII subunit OE23/PsbP in the curvature fraction set it apart from other PSII subunits, supporting the previous conjecture that OE23/PsbP assists in PSII biogenesis and/or repair. The PSII assembly factor PAM68 partitioned differently among thylakoid fractions from dark-adapted plants and illuminated plants and was the only analyzed protein to convincingly do so. These results demonstrate an unanticipated spatial heterogeneity of photosystem biogenesis and repair functions in thylakoid membranes and reveal the curvature fraction to be a focal point of early photosystem biogenesis.

Photoswitchable Detergents for Light-Controlled Liposome Lysis and Channel Gating

Modulation of membrane properties via photoswitchable lipids has attracted attention due to the unparalleled spatiotemporal resolution of their functional control. Beside lipids, detergents are another prominent class for selective membrane perturbations owing to their ease of handling and spontaneous insertion in lipid bilayers. Herein, we describe the synthesis and characterization of three classes of visible light-sensitive surfactants with various azobenzene tail chain lengths. The photoswitchable detergents show water-solubility and micellization as well as undergo reversible isomerization under blue-/green light illumination. We demonstrate that the light-induced structural change of azobenzene can lead to vesicle rupture, making them a tool for controlled cargo release from vehicles. Via spontaneous insertion into the plasma membrane of mammalian cells transiently transfected with MscL, we used the azobenzene-derived detergents to optically activate the transmembrane mechanosensitive channel. This led to the rapid controlled uptake of membrane-impermeable molecules. Since detergents are extensively used in biochemistry and biotechnology, we propose that the photoswitchable detergents will be useful tools for the spatiotemporal modulation of membrane properties. Additionally, our work provides a design strategy for new detergents in membrane (protein) research.

NDT-C11 as a Viable Novel Detergent for Single Particle Cryo-EM

Single particle cryo electron microscopy (cryo-EM) is now the major method for the determination of integral membrane protein structure. For the success of a given project the type of membrane mimetic used for extraction from the native cell membrane, purification to homogeneity and finally cryo-grid vitrification is crucial. Although small molecule amphiphiles - detergents - are the most widely used membrane mimetic, specific tailoring of detergent structure for single particle cryo-EM is rare and the demand for effective detergents not satisfied. Here, we compare the popular detergent lauryl maltose-neopentyl glycol (LMNG) with the novel detergent neopentyl glycol-derived triglucoside-C11 (NDT-C11) in its behavior as free detergent and when bound to two types of multisubunit membrane protein complexes - cyanobacterial photosystem I (PSI) and mammalian F-ATP synthase. We conclude that NDT-C11 has high potential to become a very useful detergent for single particle cryo-EM of integral membrane proteins.

Reconstitution of the Melibiose Permease of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (MelBSt) into Lipid Nanodiscs

Membrane proteins play critical roles in cell physiology and pathology. The conventional way to study membrane proteins at protein levels is to use optimal detergents to extract proteins from membranes. Identification of the optimal detergent is tedious , and in some cases, the protein functions are compromised. While this detergent-based approach has produced meaningful results in membrane protein research, a lipid environment should be more suitable to recapture the protein's native folding and functions. This protocol describes how to prepare amphipathic membrane scaffold-proteins (MSPs)-based nanodiscs of a cation-coupled melibiose symporter of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (MelBSt), a member of the major facilitator superfamily. MSPs generate nano-assemblies containing membrane proteins surrounded by a patch of native lipids to better preserve their native conformations and functions. This protocol requires purified membrane protein in detergents, purified MSPs in solution, and detergent-destabilized phospholipids. The mixture of all three components at specific ratios is incubated in the presence of Bio-Beads SM-2 resins, which absorb all detergent molecules, allowing the membrane protein to associate with lipids surrounded by the MSPs. By reconstituting the purified membrane proteins back into their native-like lipid environment, these nanodisc-like particles can be directly used in cryo-EM single-particle analysis for structure determination and other biophysical analyses. It is noted that nanodiscs may potentially limit the dynamics of membrane proteins due to suboptimal nanodisc size compared to the native lipid bilayer. Key features • This protocol was built based on the method originally developed by Sligar et al. [1] and modified for a specific major facilitator superfamily transporter • This protocol is robust and reproducible • Lipid nanodiscs can increase membrane protein stability, and reconstituted transporters in lipid nanodiscs can regain function if their function is compromised using detergents • The reconstituted lipids nanodisc can be used for cryo-EM single-particle analysis.

Nanodisc Technology: Direction toward Physicochemical Characterization of Chemosensory Membrane Proteins in Food Flavor Research

Chemosensory membrane proteins such as G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) drive flavor perception of food formulations. To achieve this, a detailed understanding of the structure and function of these membrane proteins is needed, which is often limited by the extraction and purification methods involved. The proposed nanodisc methodology helps overcome some of these existing challenges such as protein stability and solubilization along with their reconstitution from a native cell-membrane environment. Being well-established in structural biology procedures, nanodiscs offer this elegant solution by using, e.g., a membrane scaffold protein (MSP) or styrene-maleic acid (SMA) polymer, which interacts directly with the cell membrane during protein reconstitution. Such derived proteins retain their biophysical properties without compromising the membrane architecture. Here, we seek to show that these lipidic systems can be explored for insights with a focus on chemosensory membrane protein morphology and structure, conformational dynamics of protein-ligand interactions, and binding kinetics to answer pending questions in flavor research. Additionally, the compatibility of nanodiscs across varied (labeled or label-free) techniques offers significant leverage, which has been highlighted here.

Detergent Chemistry Modulates the Transgression of Planetary Boundaries including Antimicrobial Resistance and Drug Discovery

Detergent chemistry enables applications in the world today while harming safe operating spaces that humanity needs for survival. Aim of this review is to support a holistic thought process in the design of detergent chemistry. We harness the planetary boundary concept as a framework for literature survey to identify progresses and knowledge gaps in context with detergent chemistry and five planetary boundaries that are currently transgressed, i.e., climate, freshwater, land system, novel entities, biosphere integrity. Our survey unveils the status of three critical challenges to be addressed in the years to come, including (i) the implementation of a holistically, climate-friendly detergent industry; (ii) the alignment of materialistic and social aspects in creating technical solutions by means of sustainable chemistry; (iii) the development of detergents that serve the purpose of applications but do not harm the biosphere in their role as novel entities. Specifically, medically relevant case reports revealed that even the most sophisticated detergent design cannot sufficiently accelerate drug discovery to outperform the antibiotic resistance development that detergents simultaneously promote as novel entities. Safe operating spaces that humanity needs for its survival may be secured by directing future efforts beyond sustainable chemistry, resource efficiency, and net zero emission targets.

Advances in Membrane Mimetic Systems for Manipulation and Analysis of Membrane Proteins: Detergents, Polymers, Lipids and Scaffolds

Extracting membrane proteins from the hydrophobic environment of the biological membrane, in a physiologically relevant and stable state, suitable for downstream analysis remains a challenge. The traditional route to membrane protein extraction has been to use detergents and the last 15 years or so have seen a veritable explosion in the development of novel detergents with improved properties, making them more suitable for individual proteins and specific applications. There have also been significant advances in the development of encapsulation of membrane proteins in lipid based nanodiscs, either directly from the native membrane using polymers allowing effective capture of the protein and protein-associated membrane lipids, or via reconstitution of detergent extracted and purified protein into nanodiscs of defined lipid composition. All of these advances have been successfully applied to the study of membrane proteins via a range of techniques and there have been some spectacular membrane protein structures solved. In addition, the first detailed structural and biophysical analyses of membrane proteins retained within a biological membrane have been reported. Here we summarise and review the recent advances with respect to these new agents and systems for membrane protein extraction, reconstitution and analysis.

Synthesis of Asymmetric Ionic Hybrid Detergents enables Micelles with Scalable Properties including Cell Compatibility

Ionic detergents enable applications and cause harm in biospheres due to cell toxicity. The utility of covalent combinations between ionic and non-ionic detergent headgroups in modulating cell toxicity remains speculative due to the yet rarely explored synthesis. We close this gap and establish the modular synthesis of ionic/non-ionic hybrid detergents. We restructure a combinatorial methallyl dichloride one-pot coupling into a two-step coupling, which reduces by-products, improves product yields, and enables the gram-scale preparation of asymmetric, cationic/non-ionic and anionic/non-ionic hybrid detergents. Our modular synthesis delivers new modalities for the design of ionic detergents, including an unprecedented scaling of properties that determine applications, such as charge, critical micelle concentration, solubilizing properties, hard water tolerance, and cell compatibility. We uncover that shielding the charge in ionic headgroups can switch the detergent species that is toxic to cells from monomers to mixtures of monomers and micellar assemblies. Establishing the chemistry of ionic/non-ionic hybrid detergents provides a missing evolutionary link in the structural comparison of ionic and non-ionic detergents, enables an easy synthesis access to yet unexplored chemical spaces of asymmetric hybrid materials, and delivers new modalities for designing the toxicity of supramolecular nanomaterials.

19F-NMR studies of the impact of different detergents and nanodiscs on the A2A adenosine receptor

For the A2A adenosine receptor (A2AAR), a class A G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR), reconstituted in n-dodecyl-β-D-maltoside (DDM)/‌‌‌‌‌cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHS) mixed micelles, previous 19F-NMR studies revealed the presence of multiple simultaneously populated conformational states. Here, we study the influence of a different detergent, lauryl maltose neopentyl glycol (LMNG) in mixed micelles with CHS, and of lipid bilayer nanodiscs on these conformational equilibria. The populations of locally different substates are pronouncedly different in DDM/‌‌‌‌‌CHS and LMNG/‌‌‌‌‌CHS micelles, whereas the A2AAR conformational manifold in LMNG/‌‌‌‌‌CHS micelles is closely similar to that in the lipid bilayer nanodiscs. Considering that nanodiscs represent a closer match of the natural lipid bilayer membrane, these observations support that LMNG/‌‌‌‌‌CHS micelles are a good choice for reconstitution trials of class A GPCRs for NMR studies in solution.

Rational Approach to Improve Detergent Efficacy for Membrane Protein Stabilization

Membrane protein structures are essential for the molecular understanding of diverse cellular processes and drug discovery. Detergents are not only widely used to extract membrane proteins from membranes but also utilized to preserve native protein structures in aqueous solution. However, micelles formed by conventional detergents are suboptimal for membrane protein stabilization, necessitating the development of novel amphiphilic molecules with enhanced protein stabilization efficacy. In this study, we prepared two sets of tandem malonate-derived glucoside (TMG) variants, both of which were designed to increase the alkyl chain density in micelle interiors. The alkyl chain density was modulated either by reducing the spacer length (TMG-Ms) or by introducing an additional alkyl chain between the two alkyl chains of the original TMGs (TMG-Ps). When evaluated with a few membrane proteins including a G protein-coupled receptor, TMG-P10,8 was found to be substantially more efficient at extracting membrane proteins and also effective at preserving protein integrity in the long term compared to the previously described TMG-A13. This result reveals that inserting an additional alkyl chain between the two existing alkyl chains is an effective way to optimize detergent properties for membrane protein study. This new biochemical tool and the design principle described have the potential to facilitate membrane protein structure determination.

Dark nanodiscs for evaluating membrane protein thermostability by differential scanning fluorimetry

Measuring protein thermostability provides valuable information on the biophysical rules that govern the structure-energy relationships of proteins. However, such measurements remain a challenge for membrane proteins. Here, we introduce a new experimental system to evaluate membrane protein thermostability. This system leverages a recently developed nonfluorescent membrane scaffold protein to reconstitute proteins into nanodiscs and is coupled with a nano-format of differential scanning fluorimetry (nanoDSF). This approach offers a label-free and direct measurement of the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence of the membrane protein as it unfolds in solution without signal interference from the "dark" nanodisc. In this work, we demonstrate the application of this method using the disulfide bond formation protein B (DsbB) as a test membrane protein. NanoDSF measurements of DsbB reconstituted in dark nanodiscs loaded with 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) and 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphorylglycerol (DMPG) lipids show a complex biphasic thermal unfolding pattern with a minor unfolding transition followed by a major transition. The inflection points of the thermal denaturation curve reveal two distinct unfolding midpoint melting temperatures (Tm) of 70.5°C and 77.5°C, consistent with a three-state unfolding model. Further, we show that the catalytically conserved disulfide bond between residues C41 and C130 drives the intermediate state of the unfolding pathway for DsbB in a DMPC and DMPG nanodisc. To extend the utility of this method, we evaluate and compare the thermostability of DsbB in different lipid environments. We introduce this method as a new tool that can be used to understand how compositionally and biophysically complex lipid environments drive membrane protein stability.

Trends in the Diversification of the Detergentome

Detergents are amphiphilic molecules that serve as enabling steps for today's world applications. The increasing diversity of the detergentome is key to applications enabled by detergent science. Regardless of the application, the optimal design of detergents is determined empirically, which leads to failed preparations, and raising costs. To facilitate project planning, here we review synthesis strategies that drive the diversification of the detergentome. Synthesis strategies relevant for industrial and academic applications include linear, modular, combinatorial, bio-based, and metric-assisted detergent synthesis. Scopes and limitations of individual synthesis strategies in context with industrial product development and academic research are discussed. Furthermore, when designing detergents, the selection of molecular building blocks, i. e., head, linker, tail, is as important as the employed synthesis strategy. To facilitate the design of safe-to-use and tailor-made detergents, we provide an overview of established head, linker, and tail groups and highlight selected scopes and limitations for applications. It becomes apparent that most recent contributions to the increasing chemical diversity of detergent building blocks originate from the development of detergents for membrane protein studies. The overview of synthesis strategies and molecular blocks will bring us closer to the ability to predictably design and synthesize optimal detergents for challenging future applications.

A Critical Evaluation of Detergent Exchange Methodologies for Membrane Protein Native Mass Spectrometry

Membrane proteins (MPs) play many critical roles in cellular physiology and constitute the majority of current pharmaceutical targets. However, MPs are comparatively understudied relative to soluble proteins due to the challenges associated with their solubilization in membrane mimetics. Native mass spectrometry (nMS) has emerged as a useful technique to probe the structures of MPs. Typically, nMS studies using MPs have employed detergent micelles to solubilize the MP. Oftentimes, the detergent micelle that the MP was purified in will be exchanged into another detergent prior to analysis by nMS. While methodologies for performing detergent exchange have been extensively described in prior reports, the effectiveness of these protocols remains understudied. Here, we present a critical analysis of detergent exchange efficacy using several model transmembrane proteins and a variety of commonly used detergents, evaluating the completeness of the exchange using a battery of existing protocols. Our data include results for octyl glucoside (OG), octaethylene glycol monododecyl ether (C12E8), and tetraethylene glycol monooctyl ether (C8E4), and these data demonstrate that existing protocols are insufficient and yield incomplete exchange for the proteins under the conditions probed here. In some cases, our data indicate that up to 99% of the measured detergent corresponds to the original pre-exchange detergent rather than the desired post-exchange detergent. We conclude by discussing the need for new detergent exchange methodologies alongside improved exchange yield expectations for studying the potential influence of detergents on MP structures.

Melamine-cored glucosides for membrane protein solubilization and stabilization: importance of water-mediated intermolecular hydrogen bonding in detergent performance

Membrane proteins play essential roles in a number of biological processes, and their structures are important in elucidating such processes at the molecular level and also for rational drug design and development. Membrane protein structure determination is notoriously challenging compared to that of soluble proteins, due largely to the inherent instability of their structures in non-lipid environments. Micelles formed by conventional detergents have been widely used for membrane protein manipulation, but they are suboptimal for long-term stability of membrane proteins, making downstream characterization difficult. Hence, there is an unmet need for the development of new amphipathic agents with enhanced efficacy for membrane protein stabilization. In this study, we designed and synthesized a set of glucoside amphiphiles with a melamine core, denoted melamine-cored glucosides (MGs). When evaluated with four membrane proteins (two transporters and two G protein-coupled receptors), MG-C11 conferred notably enhanced stability compared to the commonly used detergents, DDM and LMNG. These promising findings are mainly attributed to a unique feature of the MGs, i.e., the ability to form dynamic water-mediated hydrogen-bond networks between detergent molecules, as supported by molecular dynamics simulations. Thus, MG-C11 is the first example of a non-peptide amphiphile capable of forming intermolecular hydrogen bonds within a protein-detergent complex environment. Detergent micelles formed via a hydrogen-bond network could represent the next generation of highly effective membrane-mimetic systems useful for membrane protein structural studies.

Overview of Membrane Protein Sample Preparation for Single-Particle Cryo-Electron Microscopy Analysis

Single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM SPA) has recently emerged as an exceptionally well-suited technique for determining the structure of membrane proteins (MPs). Indeed, in recent years, huge increase in the number of MPs solved via cryo-EM SPA at a resolution better than 3.0 Å in the Protein Data Bank (PDB) has been observed. However, sample preparation remains a significant challenge in the field. Here, we evaluated the MPs solved using cryo-EM SPA deposited in the PDB in the last two years at a resolution below 3.0 Å. The most critical parameters for sample preparation are as follows: (i) the surfactant used for protein extraction from the membrane, (ii) the surfactant, amphiphiles, nanodiscs or other molecules present in the vitrification step, (iii) the vitrification method employed, and (iv) the type of grids used. The aim is not to provide a definitive answer on the optimal sample conditions for cryo-EM SPA of MPs but rather assess the current trends in the MP structural biology community towards obtaining high-resolution cryo-EM structures.

Two-Dimensional NMR Spectroscopy of the G Protein-Coupled Receptor A2AAR in Lipid Nanodiscs

Eight hundred and twenty-six human G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) mediate the actions of two-thirds of the human hormones and neurotransmitters and over one-third of clinically used drugs. Studying the structure and dynamics of human GPCRs in lipid bilayer environments resembling the native cell membrane milieu is of great interest as a basis for understanding structure-function relationships and thus benefits continued drug development. Here, we incorporate the human A_2A adenosine receptor (A_2AAR) into lipid nanodiscs, which represent a detergent-free environment for structural studies using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) in solution. The [¹⁵N,¹H]-TROSY correlation spectra confirmed that the complex of [u-¹⁵N, ~70% ²H]-A_2AAR with an inverse agonist adopts its global fold in lipid nanodiscs in solution at physiological temperature. The global assessment led to two observations of practical interest. First, A_2AAR in nanodiscs can be stored for at least one month at 4 °C in an aqueous solvent. Second, LMNG/CHS micelles are a very close mimic of the environment of A_2AAR in nanodiscs. The NMR signal of five individually assigned tryptophan indole ¹⁵N-¹H moieties located in different regions of the receptor structure further enabled a detailed assessment of the impact of nanodiscs and LMNG/CHS micelles on the local structure and dynamics of A_2AAR. As expected, the largest effects were observed near the lipid-water interface along the intra- and extracellular surfaces, indicating possible roles of tryptophan side chains in stabilizing GPCRs in lipid bilayer membranes.

Dark nanodiscs as a model membrane for evaluating membrane protein thermostability by differential scanning fluorimetry

Measuring protein thermostability provides valuable information on the biophysical rules that govern structure-energy relationships of proteins. However, such measurements remain a challenge for membrane proteins. Here, we introduce a new experimental system to evaluate membrane protein thermostability. This system leverages a recently-developed non-fluorescent membrane scaffold protein (MSP) to reconstitute proteins into nanodiscs and is coupled with a nano-format of differential scanning fluorimetry (nanoDSF). This approach offers a label-free and direct measurement of the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence of the membrane protein as it unfolds in solution without signal interference from the "dark" nanodisc. In this work, we demonstrate the application of this method using the disulfide bond formation protein B (DsbB) as a test membrane protein. NanoDSF measurements of DsbB reconstituted in dark nanodiscs show a complex biphasic thermal unfolding pattern in the presence of lipids with a minor unfolding transition followed by a major transition. The inflection points of the thermal denaturation curve reveal two distinct unfolding midpoint melting temperatures (Tm) of 70.5 °C and 77.5 °C, consistent with a three-state unfolding model. Further, we show that the catalytically conserved disulfide bond between residues C41 and C130 drives the intermediate state of the unfolding pathway for DsbB in a nanodisc. We introduce this method as a new tool that can be used to understand how compositionally, and biophysically complex lipid environments drive membrane protein stability.

Interaction of detergent with complex mimics of bacterial membranes

Detergents are valuable tools to extract membrane proteins for biophysical, biochemical, and structural scrutiny. The detergent-driven solubilization of bilayers made from a single lipid species is commonly described in terms of pseudo-phase diagrams and a three-stage model accounting for three ranges comprising (i) intact vesicles, (ii) vesicle/micelle co-existence, or (iii) mixed micelles. Moreover, the pseudo-phase boundaries thus determined can often be quantitatively rationalized in terms of the molecular shapes of the lipid and the detergent used. Yet, it has remained unclear to what extent this approach can be applied to multi-component lipid membranes that more closely mimic the compositional complexity of cellular membranes. Here, we studied how lipid mixtures composed of palmitoyl oleoyl phosphatidylethanolamine (POPE), palmitoyl oleoyl phosphatidylglycerol (POPG), and tetraoleoyl cardiolipin (TOCL) are solubilized by the commonly used zwitterionic detergent lauryldimethylamine N-oxide using isothermal titration calorimetry. While phase diagrams of the diverse lipid mixtures showed the typical ranges of the three-stage model, we found that POPG-rich POPE/POPG bilayers are more difficult to solubilize than POPG-poor POPE/POPG bilayers. In turn, POPE/POPG/TOCL bilayers became increasingly resistant to detergent with increasing TOCL content. Since POPG is nearly cylindrically shaped and TOCL adopts inverted cone-like shapes under current buffer conditions, our solubilization data do not align with shape-based arguments. Instead, additional electrostatic interactions between lipids and detergents lead to non-additive mixing behavior affecting the resilience of complex lipid bilayers against solubilization.

Tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane Linker-Bearing Triazine-Based Triglucosides for Solubilization and Stabilization of Membrane Proteins

High-resolution membrane protein structures are essential for a fundamental understanding of the molecular basis of diverse cellular processes and for drug discovery. Detergents are widely used to extract membrane-spanning proteins from membranes and maintain them in a functional state for downstream characterization. Due to limited long-term stability of membrane proteins encapsulated in conventional detergents, development of novel agents is required to facilitate membrane protein structural study. In the current study, we designed and synthesized tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane linker-bearing triazine-based triglucosides (TTGs) for solubilization and stabilization of membrane proteins. When these glucoside detergents were evaluated for four membrane proteins including two G protein-coupled receptors, a few TTGs including TTG-C10 and TTG-C11 displayed markedly enhanced behaviors toward membrane protein stability relative to two maltoside detergents [DDM (n-dodecyl-β-d-maltoside) and LMNG (lauryl maltose neopentyl glycol)]. This is a notable feature of the TTGs as glucoside detergents tend to be inferior to maltoside detergents at stabilizing membrane proteins. The favorable behavior of the TTGs for membrane protein stability is likely due to the high hydrophobicity of the lipophilic groups, an optimal range of hydrophilic-lipophilic balance, and the absence of cis-trans isomerism.

Bioconjugation of Meldrum's acid activated furan: A detergent compatible assay for protein quantitation

A simple yet efficient assay for the quantitation of proteins ranging from plasma proteins to purified proteins from whole cell lysate, based on the bioconjugation reaction between protein and Meldrum's acid Activated Furan (MAF) is described. This easy to use, sensitive method is based on the conjugation of amine functionalities present on the protein with MAF to form the corresponding Donor Acceptor Stenhouse Adducts (DASAs) with characteristic absorption in the visible region. The reaction is rapid as well as reproducible and shows a proportionate increase in color change over a broad range of protein concentration. The assay was found to be sensitive up to 0.125 mg/mL concentration of the protein and was compatible with most of the commonly employed detergents and isolation protocols which makes it ideal for the estimation of protein samples containing detergents. Another striking feature of this protocol is its tolerance towards other major interference contributors such as chelating agents, reducing agents, carbohydrates and protease inhibitors.

Travel light: Essential packing for membrane proteins with an active lifestyle

We review the considerable progress during the recent decade in the endeavours of designing, optimising, and utilising carrier particle systems for structural and functional studies of membrane proteins in near-native environments. New and improved systems are constantly emerging, novel studies push the perceived limits of a given carrier system, and specific carrier systems consolidate and entrench themselves as the system of choice for particular classes of target membrane protein systems. This review covers the most frequently used carrier systems for such studies and emphasises similarities and differences between these systems as well as current trends and future directions for the field. Particular interest is devoted to the biophysical properties and membrane mimicking ability of each system and the manner in which this may impact an embedded membrane protein and an eventual structural or functional study.

Synthesis, Self-Assembly Properties, and Degradation Characterization of a Nonionic Photocleavable Azo-Sulfide Surfactant Family

We report the synthesis and characterization of a new family of maltose-derived nonionic surfactants that contain a photocleavable azo-sulfide linker (mAzo). The self-assembly properties of these surfactants were investigated using surface tension measurements to determine the critical micelle concentration (CMC), dynamic light scattering (DLS) to reveal the hydrodynamic radius of their self-assemblies, and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) to elucidate the micelle morphology. Ultraviolet-visible (UV-visible) spectroscopy confirmed the rapid photodegradation of these surfactants, but surface tension measurements of the surfactant solutions before and after degradation showed unusual degradation products. The photodegradation process was further studied using online liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (LC-MS),which revealed that these surfactants can form another photo-stable surfactant post-degradation. Finally, traditionally challenging proteins from heart tissue were solubilized using the mAzo surfactants to demonstrate their potential in biological applications.

Nonionic, Cleavable Surfactant for Top-Down Proteomics

Nonionic surfactants are often used as general reagents for cell lysis enabling protein extraction, stabilization, and purification under nondenaturing conditions for downstream analysis in structural biology. However, the presence of surfactants in the sample matrix often has a deleterious effect on electrospray ionization (ESI)-mass spectrometry (MS) analysis of proteins and complexes. Here, we report a nonionic, cleavable surfactant, n-decyl-disulfide-β-D-maltoside (DSSM), for top-down proteomics. DSSM was designed to mimic the properties of one of the most common surfactants used in structural biology, n-dodecyl-β-D-maltoside (DDM), but contains a disulfide bond that allows for facile cleavage and surfactant removal before or during MS analysis. We have shown that DSSM is compatible with direct electrospray ionization (ESI)-MS analysis and reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC)-MS analysis of proteins and protein complexes. We have demonstrated that DSSM can facilitate top-down proteomic characterization of membrane proteins such as a model ion channel protein and a G protein-coupled receptor as well as endogenous proteins from cell lysates for the determination of sequence variations and posttranslational modifications (PTMs). Conceivably, DSSM could serve as a general replacement for DDM in proteomic experiments and structural biology studies.

Expression in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Purification of a Human Phospholipid Flippase

Membrane proteins (MPs) are challenging to study from a biochemical standpoint owing to the difficulties associated with the isolation of these proteins from the membranes they are embedded in. Even for the expression of closely-related homologues, protocols often require to be adjusted. Prominently, the solubilization step and the stabilization of recombinant proteins during the purification process are key issues, and remain a serious bottleneck. Here, we present a method for the expression and the purification of the human ATP8B1/CDC50A lipid flippase complex. Selection of the right Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain proved to be a critical step for the successful purification of this complex. Likewise, the use of cholesteryl hemisuccinate, a cholesterol analogue, contributed to significantly increase the yield of purification. We hope that the simple method described here can help researchers to succeed in the expression of other mammalian difficult-to-express lipid flippases and, by extension, help in the production of other membrane proteins whose isolation has so far proven difficult.

Transition-Linker Containing Detergents for Membrane Protein Studies

It is a pressing need, but still challenging to explore the structure and function of membrane proteins (MPs). One of the main obstacles is the limited availability of matched detergents for the handling of specific MPs. We describe herein the design of new detergents by incorporation of a transition linker between the hydrophilic head and the hydrophobic tail. This design allows a gradual change of hydrophobicity between the outside and inside of micelles, in contrast to the abrupt switch in conventional detergents. Notably, many of these detergents assembled into micelles in while retaining low critical micelle concentrations. Meanwhile, thermal stabilizing evaluation identified superior detergents for representative MPs, including G protein-coupled receptors and a transporter protein. Among them, further improved the NMR study of MPs. We anticipate these that results will encourage future detergent expansion through new remodeling on the traditional detergent scaffold.

Influence of Hydrophobic Groups Attached to Amphipathic Polymers on the Solubilization of Membrane Proteins along with Their Lipids

One of the biggest challenges in membrane protein (MP) research is to secure physiologically relevant structural and functional information after extracting MPs from their native membrane. Amphipathic polymers represent attractive alternatives to detergents for stabilizing MPs in aqueous solutions. The predominant polymers used in MP biochemistry and biophysics are amphipols (APols), one class of which, styrene maleic acid (SMA) copolymers and their derivatives, has proven particularly efficient at MP extraction. In order to examine the relationship between the chemical structure of the polymers and their ability to extract MPs from membranes, we have developed two novel classes of APols bearing either cycloalkane or aryl (aromatic) rings, named CyclAPols and ArylAPols, respectively. The effect on solubilization of such parameters as the density of hydrophobic groups, the number of carbon atoms and their arrangement in the hydrophobic moieties, as well as the charge density of the polymers was evaluated. The membrane-solubilizing efficiency of the SMAs, CyclAPols, and ArylAPols was compared using as models (i) two MPs, BmrA and a GFP-fused version of LacY, overexpressed in the inner membrane of Escherichia coli, and (ii) bacteriorhodopsin, naturally expressed in the purple membrane of Halobacterium salinarum. This analysis shows that, as compared to SMAs, the novel APols feature an improved efficiency at extracting MPs while preserving native protein-lipid interactions.

Combinatorial synthesis enables scalable designer detergents for membrane protein studies

Non-ionic detergents with tailor-made properties are indispensable tools for today's world applications, such as cleaning, disinfection, and drug discovery. To facilitate their challenging production, herein we introduce a new detergent class, namely scalable hybrid detergents. We report a combinatorial synthesis strategy that allows us to fuse head groups of different detergents into hybrid detergents with unbeatable ease. Importantly, combinatorial synthesis also enables the choice between (i) high-throughput preparation of detergents for small scale applications and (ii) large scale preparation of individual detergents. This combinatorial synthesis strategy enables an unprecedented fine tuning of detergent properties, such as overall polarity and shape, which are determining factors in applications, such as membrane protein research. Our data show that membrane protein purification parameters, such as protein yields and activity, can be linked to overall polarity and shape. Conveniently, both parameters can be theoretically described by means of the hydrophilic-lipophilic balance (HLB) and packing parameter concepts. Both concepts are principally applicable to all non-ionic detergent classes, which facilitates the identification of widely applicable design guidelines for the predictable optimization of non-ionic detergents. Our findings permit access to a yet unexplored chemical space of the detergentome, therefore creating new possibilities for structure-property relationship studies. Seen from a broader perspective, combinatorial synthesis will facilitate the preparation of designer detergents with tailor-made properties for future applications in today's world.

Foldable detergents for membrane protein stability

Detergents are widely used for membrane protein structural study. Many recently developed detergents contain multiple tail and head groups, which are typically connected via a small and branched linker. Due to their inherent compact structures, with small inter-alkyl chain distances, these detergents form micelles with high alkyl chain density in the interiors, a feature favorably associated with membrane protein stability. A recent study on tandem triazine maltosides (TZM) revealed a distinct trend; despite possession of an apparently large inter-alkyl chain distance, the TZM-Es were highly effective at stabilizing membrane proteins. Thanks to the incorporation of a flexible spacer between the two triazine rings in the linker region, these detergents are prone to folding into a compact architecture in micellar environments instead of adopting an extended conformation. Detergent foldability represents a new concept of novel detergent design with significant potential for future detergent development.

Development of 1,3-acetonedicarboxylate-derived glucoside amphiphiles (ACAs) for membrane protein study

Detergents are extensively used for membrane protein manipulation. Membrane proteins solubilized in conventional detergents are prone to denaturation and aggregation, rendering downstream characterization of these bio-macromolecules difficult. Although many amphiphiles have been developed to overcome the limited efficacy of conventional detergents for protein stabilization, only a handful of novel detergents have so far proved useful for membrane protein structural studies. Here, we introduce 1,3-acetonedicarboxylate-derived amphiphiles (ACAs) containing three glucose units and two alkyl chains as head and tail groups, respectively. The ACAs incorporate two different patterns of alkyl chain attachment to the core detergent unit, generating two sets of amphiphiles: ACA-As (asymmetrically alkylated) and ACA-Ss (symmetrically alkylated). The difference in the attachment pattern of the detergent alkyl chains resulted in minor variation in detergent properties such as micelle size, critical micelle concentration, and detergent behaviors toward membrane protein extraction and stabilization. In contrast, the impact of the detergent alkyl chain length on protein stability was marked. The two C11 variants (ACA-AC11 and ACA-SC11) were most effective at stabilizing the tested membrane proteins. The current study not only introduces new glucosides as tools for membrane protein study, but also provides detergent structure–property relationships important for future design of novel amphiphiles.

Newly developed amphiphiles, designated ACAs, are not only efficient at extracting G protein-coupled receptors from the membranes, but also conferred enhanced stability to the receptors compared to the gold standards (DDM and LMNG).

Ugi Reaction Mediated Detergent Assembly for Membrane Protein Studies

Despite the continuous efforts, the current repertoire of detergents is still far from sufficient for the biophysics studies of membrane proteins (MPs). Toward the rapid expansion of detergent diversity, we herein report a new strategy based on Ugi reaction mediated modular assembly. Structural varieties, including hydrophobic tails and hydrophilic heads, could be conveniently introduced from the multiple reaction components. New detergents then were comprehensively evaluated in the physical properties and preliminarily screened by the thermal stabilization for a transporter MsbA and a spectrum of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). For the glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor (GLP-1R), a class B GPCR, detergent M-23-M finally stood out in a second evaluation for the maintenance of homogeneity and was further illustrated its application in the improvement of NMR study. Besides the promising utility in the MP study, the current results exhibit intriguing structural-physical relationship that would allow the guidance in the tuning of detergent properties in the future.