High incidence of spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis in immunocompetent self-reactive human T cell receptor transgenic mice

Molecular Mechanisms in Autoimmune Thyroid Disease

The most common cause of acquired thyroid dysfunction is autoimmune thyroid disease, which is an organ-specific autoimmune disease with two presentation phenotypes: hyperthyroidism (Graves-Basedow disease) and hypothyroidism (Hashimoto's thyroiditis). Hashimoto's thyroiditis is distinguished by the presence of autoantibodies against thyroid peroxidase and thyroglobulin. Meanwhile, autoantibodies against the TSH receptor have been found in Graves-Basedow disease. Numerous susceptibility genes, as well as epigenetic and environmental factors, contribute to the pathogenesis of both diseases. This review summarizes the most common genetic, epigenetic, and environmental mechanisms involved in autoimmune thyroid disease.

Activation-induced cell death of self-reactive regulatory T cells drives autoimmunity

Activation of self-reactive T cells is a major driver to autoimmunity and is suppressed by mechanisms of regulation. In a humanized model of autoimmune thyroiditis, we investigated the mechanism underlying break of tolerance. Here, we found that a human TCR specific for the self-antigen thyroid peroxidase (TPO) is positively selected in the thymus of RAG KO mice on both T effector (T_eff) and T regulatory (T_reg) CD4⁺Foxp3⁺ cells. In vivo T_eff are present in all immune organs, whereas the TPO-specific T_reg are present in all lymphoid organs with the exception of the thyroid-draining lymph nodes. We suggest that the presence of TPO in the thyroid draining lymph nodes induces the activation of T_eff and the depletion of T_reg via activation-induced cell death (AICD). Our findings provide insights on the failure of the mechanisms of immune tolerance, with potential implications in designing immunotherapeutic strategies.

Breaking tolerance to thyroid antigens: changing concepts in thyroid autoimmunity

Thyroid autoimmunity involves loss of tolerance to thyroid proteins in genetically susceptible individuals in association with environmental factors. In central tolerance, intrathymic autoantigen presentation deletes immature T cells with high affinity for autoantigen-derived peptides. Regulatory T cells provide an alternative mechanism to silence autoimmune T cells in the periphery. The TSH receptor (TSHR), thyroid peroxidase (TPO), and thyroglobulin (Tg) have unusual properties ("immunogenicity") that contribute to breaking tolerance, including size, abundance, membrane association, glycosylation, and polymorphisms. Insight into loss of tolerance to thyroid proteins comes from spontaneous and induced animal models: 1) intrathymic expression controls self-tolerance to the TSHR, not TPO or Tg; 2) regulatory T cells are not involved in TSHR self-tolerance and instead control the balance between Graves' disease and thyroiditis; 3) breaking TSHR tolerance involves contributions from major histocompatibility complex molecules (humans and induced mouse models), TSHR polymorphism(s) (humans), and alternative splicing (mice); 4) loss of tolerance to Tg before TPO indicates that greater Tg immunogenicity vs TPO dominates central tolerance expectations; 5) tolerance is induced by thyroid autoantigen administration before autoimmunity is established; 6) interferon-α therapy for hepatitis C infection enhances thyroid autoimmunity in patients with intact immunity; Graves' disease developing after T-cell depletion reflects reconstitution autoimmunity; and 7) most environmental factors (including excess iodine) "reveal," but do not induce, thyroid autoimmunity. Micro-organisms likely exert their effects via bystander stimulation. Finally, no single mechanism explains the loss of tolerance to thyroid proteins. The goal of inducing self-tolerance to prevent autoimmune thyroid disease will require accurate prediction of at-risk individuals together with an antigen-specific, not blanket, therapeutic approach.

Antibodies to thyroid peroxidase arise spontaneously with age in NOD.H-2h4 mice and appear after thyroglobulin antibodies

Hashimoto's thyroiditis, a common autoimmune disease, is associated with autoantibodies to thyroglobulin (Tg) and thyroid peroxidase (TPO). TPO, unlike abundant and easily purified Tg, is rarely investigated as an autoantigen in animals. We asked whether antibodies (Abs) develop to both TPO and Tg in thyroiditis that is induced (C57BL/6 and DBA/1 mice) or arises spontaneously (NOD.H-2h4 mice). Screening for TPOAbs was performed by flow cytometry using mouse TPO-expressing eukaryotic cells. Sera were also tested for binding to purified mouse Tg and human TPO. The antibody data were compared with the extent of thyroiditis. Immunization with mouse TPO adenovirus broke self-tolerance to this protein in C57BL/6 mice, but thyroiditis was minimal and TgAbs were absent. In DBA/1 mice with extensive granulomatous thyroiditis induced by Tg immunization, TPOAbs were virtually absent despite high levels of TgAbs. In contrast, antibodies to mouse TPO, with minimal cross-reactivity with human TPO, arose spontaneously in older (7-12 months) NOD.H-2h4 mice. Unexpectedly, TgAbs preceded TPOAbs, a time course paralleled in relatives of probands with juvenile Hashimoto's thyroiditis. These findings demonstrate a novel aspect of murine and human thyroid autoimmunity, namely breaking B cell self-tolerance occurs first for Tg and subsequently for TPO.

Restricted autoantigen recognition associated with deletional and adaptive regulatory mechanisms

Autoimmune diabetes (T1D) is characterized by CD4(+) T cell reactivity to a variety of islet-associated Ags. At-risk individuals, genetically predisposed to T1D, often have similar T cell reactivity, but nevertheless fail to progress to clinically overt disease. To study the immune tolerance and regulatory environment permissive for such autoreactive T cells, we expressed TCR transgenes derived from two autoreactive human T cells, 4.13 and 164, in HLA-DR4 transgenic mice on a C57BL/6-derived "diabetes-resistant" background. Both TCR are responsive to an immunodominant epitope of glutamic acid decarboxylase 65(555-567), which is identical in sequence between humans and mice, is restricted by HLA-DR4, and is a naturally processed self Ag associated with T1D. Although both TCR use the identical Valpha and Vbeta genes, differing only in CDR3, we found stark differences in the mechanisms utilized in vivo in the maintenance of immune tolerance. A combination of thymic deletion (negative selection), TCR down-regulation, and peripheral activation-induced cell death dominated the phenotype of 164 T cells, which nevertheless still maintain their Ag responsiveness in the periphery. In contrast, 4.13 T cells are much less influenced by central and deletional tolerance mechanisms, and instead display a peripheral immune deviation including differentiation into IL-10-secreting Tr1 cells. These findings indicate a distinct set of regulatory alternatives for autoreactive T cells, even within a single highly restricted HLA-peptide-TCR recognition profile.

Application of new therapies in Graves' disease and thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy: animal models and translation to human clinical trials

Most current approaches for treating Graves' disease are based essentially upon regimes developed nearly 50 years ago. Moreover, therapeutic approaches for complications such as thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) and dermopathy are singularly dependent on conventional approaches of nonspecific immunosuppression. The recent development of an induced model of experimental Graves' disease, although incomplete as it lacks the extrathyroidal manifestations, provided opportunities to investigate immune intervention strategies, including influence upon the autoreactive B and T cell players in the autoimmune process. These major advances are generating new possibilities for therapeutic interventions for patients with Graves' disease and TAO.

Environmental factors and genetic background that interact to cause autoimmune thyroid disease

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To provide an updated list of genetic and environmental causative factors of autoimmune thyroid disease, and report about the recent discoveries concerning their interaction in the pathogenesis of thyroid autoimmunity.

RECENT FINDINGS

Although significant discoveries have been made on genetic and environmental factors underlying the development of autoimmune thyroid disease, few data are available about the mechanisms by which they interact. The most interesting news in this field comes from research on molecular mimicry between microbial antigens and thyroid autoantigens. The molecular mimicry model postulates that, in predisposed subjects, a microbial antigen could trigger autoimmunity because of its structural similarity to an autoantigen of the host, and is a paradigmatic example of the multifactorial interaction of several genes and environmental factors to cause autoimmune diseases, including thyroid diseases.

SUMMARY

Recent findings help us to better understand the functional mechanisms of the immune system, which are still only partially known. Beyond the scientific interest, this knowledge has immediate repercussions on clinical practice because it can suggest possible therapeutic targets for new treatments, as well as better and more specific uses of currently available drugs and resources.

Thyroid peroxidase as an autoantigen

Thyroid peroxidase (TPO) evokes high-affinity, IgG-class autoantibodies [TPO autoantibodies (TPOAbs)] and TPO-specific T cells that are markers of thyroid infiltration or implicated in thyroid destruction, respectively. A diverse repertoire of human monoclonal TPOAbs, unparalleled in other autoimmune diseases, provides invaluable probes for investigating antibody epitopes. Human TPOAbs recognize an immunodominant region comprising overlapping A and B domains on conformationally intact TPO. Amino acids recognized by TPOAbs are located in the regions with homology to myeloperoxidase (MPO) and the complement control protein (CCP) but not in the epidermal growth factor (EGF)-like region. T cells recognize epitopes in the MPO-like region but not in the CCP- or EGF-like regions in humans. Monoclonal human TPOAbs modulate processing of TPO protein to provide peptides for some T cells. A human T cell clone expressed transgenically in mice induces lymphocytic infiltration and hypothyroidism. This T cell's epitope is only generated by thyrocyte processing of endogenous TPO. Further, intact TPO expressed in vivo is also required for induction of TPOAbs in mice that resemble human autoantibodies. Overall, some TPO-specific T cells and the majority of autoantibodies in humans develop in response to TPO presented by thyroid cells, rather than to TPO released by damaged thyrocytes.

The NLR network and the immunological disease continuum of adaptive and innate immune-mediated inflammation against self

The nucleotide-binding domain, leucine-rich repeat containing family (NLR) network has provided pivotal genetic and molecular insights into diseases that were hitherto regarded as autoimmune. The NLR-related disorders include rare monogenic autoinflammatory diseases collectively termed cryopyrin-associated periodic syndromes, Crohn's disease which is a common polygenic disease and also an association at the mechanistic level with gout and pseudogout. Unlike the classical autoimmune diseases where disease immunopathogenesis is played out primarily in the primary and secondary lymphoid organs, the immunopathogenesis of the NLR-related disorders is played out in the tissues where inflammation arises. As the genetic mutations or molecular cascades associated with the NLR-related disorders have a widespread cellular distribution, it has been somewhat enigmatic why these disorders attack certain territories, but not others. This implies that tissue-specific factors in the target organs themselves contribute to disease expression. Such examples include the high abundance of NOD2 expressing cells in the part of the gut most typically afflicted by Crohn's disease and the preferential deposition of crystals in the joints to where inflammation localises in gout and pseudogout. The NLR network is associated principally with increases in TNF or IL-1 production, both of which are key players in innate immunity. Therefore, the NLR network identifies at the genetic and molecular level a robust paradigm for innate immune activation against self. This tissue-specific-factor-associated inflammation is the diametric opposite of classical autoimmunity. Of note, the MHC class-I-associated diseases including psoriasis (HLA-Cw6) and ankylosing spondylitis (HLA-B27) show striking clinical overlaps with Crohn's disease and also some rare monogenic diseases. Thus, the NLR innate immune pathway allows the full spectrum of inflammation against self to be viewed along an immunological disease continuum with autoantibody-associated disease at one end, innate immune diseases at the other and MHC class-1-related disorders as an intermediate.

A radioligand binding assay to measure anti-thyroperoxidase autoantibodies in mice

Autoimmune (Hashimoto's) thyroiditis is a chronic inflammatory disease which affects >3% of the population and shows an increasing prevalence with increasing age. Anti-thyroid autoantibodies, particularly against thyroperoxidase (also known as thyroid peroxidase or TPO), occur commonly in humans with autoimmune thyroid disease, and assays for anti-TPO autoantibodies are used in clinical diagnosis. In contrast anti-TPO autoantibodies have not been observed in classical mouse models of autoimmune thyroiditis, except in cases where mice were deliberately immunized with TPO. In the past, detection of anti-TPO autoantibodies in mice has relied on an indirect immunofluorescence assay (iIFA) which screens for thyroid follicle membrane staining in frozen sections of mouse thyroid glands. Since recent transgenic mouse models of autoimmune thyroiditis spontaneously develop anti-TPO autoantibodies, an assay other than serial dilution and iIFA would be useful to detect and quantify these autoantibodies. In this paper we describe such an assay, based on the capacity of autoimmune mouse sera to bind to the extracellular domain of mouse TPO which was produced in a radioactively labeled form using a coupled in vitro transcription/translation system. The same approach, using human TPO, could provide a highly sensitive method to detect anti-TPO autoantibodies in humans.

Regulatory T cells in human autoimmune thyroid disease

CONTEXT

T regulatory cells have a key role in the pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases in different animal models. However, less information is available regarding these cells in human autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD).

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to analyze different regulatory T cell subsets in patients with AITD.

DESIGN

We studied by flow cytometry and immunohistochemistry different T regulatory cell subsets in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) and thyroid cell infiltrates from 20 patients with AITD. In addition, the function of T(REG) lymphocytes was assessed by cell proliferation assays. Finally, TGF-beta mRNA in thyroid tissue and its in vitro synthesis by thyroid mononuclear cells (TMCs) was determined by RNase protection assay and quantitative PCR.

RESULTS

PBMCs from AITD patients showed an increased percent of CD4+ lymphocytes expressing glucocorticoid-induced TNF receptor (GITR), Foxp3, IL-10, TGF-beta, and CD69 as well as CD69+CD25(bright), CD69+TGF-beta, and CD69+IL-10+ cells, compared with controls. TMCs from these patients showed an increased proportion of CD4+GITR+, CD4+CD69+, and CD69+ cells expressing CD25(bright), GITR, and Foxp3, compared with autologous PBMCs. Furthermore, a prominent infiltration of thyroid tissue by CD69+, CD25+, and GITR+ cells, with moderate levels of Foxp3+ lymphocytes, was observed. The suppressive function of peripheral blood T(REG) cells was defective in AITD patients. Finally, increased levels of TGF-beta mRNA were found in thyroid tissue, and thyroid cell infiltrates synthesized in vitro significant levels of TGF-beta upon stimulation through CD69.

CONCLUSIONS

Although T regulatory cells are abundant in inflamed thyroid tissue, they are apparently unable, in most cases, to downmodulate the autoimmune response and the tissue damage seen in AITD.

Induction of autoimmune thyroiditis and hypothyroidism by immunization of immunoactive T cell epitope of thyroid peroxidase

Autoimmune thyroiditis (AT) is characterized by a continuous inflammatory self-destructive process that eventually leads to chronic progressive dysfunction of the thyroid. In a previously established experimental AT model, C57bl/6 mice immunized with recombinant mouse thyroid peroxidase (TPO) (rmTPO) developed lymphocytic thyroiditis and anti-TPO antibody but not chronic hypothyroidism. To determine the immunodominant epitope(s) of TPO, T cell proliferation assays were performed in which rmTPO-primed lymph nodes cells were reacted with recombinant mTPO fragments or short overlapping synthetic TPO peptides. Within residue 405-849, peptide 540-559 gave the maximum proliferation response with a stimulation index more than 12. Mice immunized with peptide 540-559 developed antibody against rmTPO and native mouse TPO protein, lymphocytic thyroiditis, and hypothyroidism. In conclusion, this study demonstrated that TPO is the autoantigen for the development of lymphocyte thyroiditis and thyroid dysfunction, and peptide 540-559 is the immunodominant T cell epitope of TPO. Identification of T cell epitopes of TPO may enable the development of immunotherapy to prevent chronic hypothyroidism in AT.