Molecular monitoring of chronic myeloid leukemia: international standardization of BCR-ABL1 quantitation

Establishment of genomic RNA reference materials for BCR-ABL1 P210 measurement

Quantitation of BCR-ABL1 with the quantitative reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) is very important in monitoring chronic myeloid leukemia (CML), which relies on an RNA reference material. A genomic RNA reference material (RM) containing the BCR-ABL1 P210 fusion mutation was developed, and an absolute quantitative method based on one-step reverse transcription digital PCR (RT-dPCR) was established for characterizing the RM. The proposed dPCR method demonstrates high accuracy and excellent analytical sensitivity, as shown by the linear relationship (0.94 < slope < 1.04, R2≧0.99) between the measured and nominal values of b2a2, b3a2, and ABL1-ref within the dynamic range (104-101 copies/reaction). Homogeneity and stability assessment based on dPCR indicated that the RM was homogeneous and stable for 24 months at -80 °C. The RM was used to evaluate inter-laboratory reproducibility in eight different laboratories, demonstrating that participating laboratories could consistently produce copy concentrations of b3a2 and ABL1-ref, as well as the BCR-ABL1/ABL1 ratio (CV < 2.0%). This work suggests that the RM can be employed in establishing metrological traceability for detecting mutations in the BCR-ABL1 fusion gene, as well as in quality control for testing laboratories.

Measurable residual disease (MRD)-testing in haematological cancers: A giant leap forward or sideways?

Measurable residual disease (MRD)-testing is used in many haematological cancers to estimate relapse risk and to direct therapy. Sometimes MRD-test results are used for regulatory approval. However, some people including regulators wrongfully believe results of MRD-testing are highly accurate and of proven efficacy in directing therapy. We review MRD-testing technologies and evaluate the accuracy of MRD-testing for predicting relapse and the strength of evidence supporting efficacy of MRD-guided therapy. We show that at the individual level MRD-test results are often an inaccurate relapse predictor. Also, no convincing data indicate that increasing therapy-intensity based on a positive MRD-test reduces relapse risk or improves survival. We caution against adjusting therapy-intensity based solely on results of MRD-testing.

Optical Genome Mapping for Detection of BCR::ABL1-Another Tool in Our Toolbox

Background:BCR::ABL1 fusion is mostly derived from a reciprocal translocation t(9;22)(q34.1;q11.2) and is rarely caused by insertion. Various methods have been used for the detection of t(9;22)/BCR::ABL1, such as G-banded chromosomal analysis, fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), quantitative real-time reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and optical genome mapping (OGM). Understanding the strengths and limitations of each method is essential for the selection of appropriate method(s) of disease diagnosis and/or during the follow-up. Methods: We compared the results of OGM, chromosomal analysis, FISH, and/or RT-PCR in 12 cases with BCR::ABL1. Results:BCR:ABL1 was detected by FISH and RT-PCR in all 12 cases. One case with ins(22;9)/BCR::ABL1 was cryptic by chromosomal analysis and nearly missed by OGM. Atypical FISH signal patterns were observed in five cases, suggesting additional chromosomal aberrations involving chromosomes 9 and/or 22. RT-PCR identified the transcript isoforms p210 and p190 in seven and five cases, respectively. Chromosomal analysis revealed additional chromosomal aberrations in seven cases. OGM identified extra cytogenomic abnormalities in 10 cases, including chromoanagenesis and IKZF1 deletion, which were only detected by OGM. Conclusions: FISH offers rapid and definitive detection of BCR::ABL1 fusion, while OGM provides a comprehensive cytogenomic analysis. In scenarios where OGM is feasible, chromosomal analysis and RT-PCR may not offer additional diagnostic value.

A review on characterization of BCR - ABL transcript variants for molecular monitoring of chronic myeloid leukemia phenotypes

Chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) is a clonal myeloproliferative growth of human pluripotent stem cells which is estimated to occur at a rate of 1/100000 populations every year worldwide. A characteristic feature of this disease is the presence of the Philadelphia chromosome genotype, which results from the reciprocal translocation between human chromosomes 9 and 22. Two types of major genotypes are involved, which consequently result in two major types of expressed fusion mRNA transcripts: b3a2 and b2a2, i.e. major breakpoint segments (happening after exon 13 & after exon 14) of the BCR gene on chromosome 22 fuze with the ABL1 gene breakpoint (happening after exon 2) on chromosome 9, forming two genotypes coding for two transcripts: b3a2 (e14a2) and b2a2 (e13a2). The protein 'p210 BCR-ABL1', a protein which characteristically exhibits a high tyrosine kinase activity which is followed by the activation of various cellular processes that lead to increased cellular proliferation and cancer, is coded by both major BCR - ABL1 mRNA transcripts. Recent developments in the treatment of CML through molecular monitoring of the disease have managed to reduce patient morbidity and mortality. Advanced molecular techniques are aimed at detecting BCR-ABL1 transcript levels to monitor treatment response. Transcript typing is necessary to detect minimal residual disease and to achieve molecular response by helping to provide selective therapy based on the type of transcript identified, as transcript type is correlated with the disease course.The purpose of this review is to discuss: the role of the BCR-ABL1 fusion gene in the pathogenesis of CML; the role of BCR-ABL1 transcript characterization in the molecular monitoring of CML therapy; the association of BCR - ABL1 transcript types with different CML phenotypes, molecular responses, and treatment responses; and the laboratory techniques employed to detect and characterize BCR - ABL1 transcripts.

Setting up a network of comprehensive care for patients with chronic myeloid leukemia: Lessons learned from Tanzania

Over the last 2 decades, the introduction of targeted therapies and the advances in the detection of BCR::ABL1 oncogene have dramatically improved comprehensive care for patients with Chronic myeloid leukemia (CML). The once deadly malignancy has now transformed into a chronic disease with an overall patient survival approaching that of the age-matched general population. While excellent prognoses have been reported among CML patients in high-income countries, it is unfortunately not the same for those living in low and middle-income (LMIC) countries such as Tanzania. This disparity is largely contributed by barriers associated with the provision of comprehensive care including early diagnosis, access to treatment, and regular monitoring of the disease. In this review, we will share our experiences and lessons learned in setting up a network of comprehensive care for patients with CML in Tanzania.

Children with chronic myeloid leukaemia treated with front-line imatinib have a slower molecular response and comparable survival compared with adults: a multicenter experience in Taiwan

BACKGROUND

The direct comparison of molecular responses of front-line imatinib (IM) monitored at the same laboratory between children and adults with chronic phase (CP) of chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML) had not been reported. In this multicenter study, we compared the landmark molecular responses and outcomes of paediatric and adult CML-CP cohorts treated with front-line IM in whom the BCR::ABL1 transcript levels were monitored at the same accredited laboratory in Taiwan.

METHODS

Between June 2004 and July 2020, 55 newly diagnosed paediatric and 782 adult CML-CP patients, with molecular diagnosis and monitoring at the same reference laboratory in Taiwan, were enrolled. The criteria of 2020 European LeukemiaNet were applied to evaluate the molecular responses.

RESULTS

By year 5, the cumulative incidences of IS <1%, MMR, MR4.0 and MR4.5 of paediatric patients were all significantly lower than those of adult patients (58 vs 75%, 48 vs 66%, 25 vs 44%, 16 vs 34%, respectively). The 10-year progression-free survival (PFS) (90%) and overall survival (OS) (94%) of paediatric patients did not differ from those (92%) of adult patients.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrated the paediatric cohort had slower molecular responses to front-line IM and similar outcomes in 10-year PFS and OS in real-world practice.

Precision diagnostics: Integration of tissue pathology and genomics in cancer

Traditionally, cancer diagnosis and management has been reactionary in that symptoms lead to investigations, then a diagnosis is followed by clinical management. This process is heavily dependent on tissue diagnosis mainly by histopathology and to a lesser extent, cytopathology. However, in recent times there has been a shift towards precision medicine to enable prevention, prediction and personalisation in healthcare. The core of precision medicine is optimising therapeutic benefit for patients, by using genomic and molecular profiling, analogously termed precision pathology. This review explores (1) the evolution of pathology from a para-clinical discipline to a mainstream medical field integral to oncology tumour boards; (2) its critical role in preventative, diagnostic, therapeutic and follow-up cancer care; (3) the future of tissue pathology in the era of precision oncology; and (4) how pathologists may evolve to future-proof their profession.

Differential genomics and transcriptomics between tyrosine kinase inhibitor-sensitive and -resistant BCR-ABL-dependent chronic myeloid leukemia

Previously, it has been stated that the BCR-ABL fusion-protein is sufficient to induce Chronic Myeloid Leukemia (CML), but additional genomic-changes are required for disease progression. Hence, we profiled control and tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKI) alone or in combination with other drug-treated CML-samples in different phases, categorized as drug-sensitive and drug-resistant on the basis of BCR-ABL transcripts, the marker of major molecular-response. Molecular-profiling was done using the molecular-inversion probe-based-array, Human Transcriptomics-Array2.0, and Axiom-Biobank genotyping-arrays. At the transcript-level, clusters of control, TKI-resistant and TKI-sensitive cases were correlated with BCR-ABL transcript-levels. Both at the gene- and exon-levels, up-regulation of MPO, TPX2, and TYMS and down-regulation of STAT6, FOS, TGFBR2, and ITK lead up-regulation of the cell-cycle, DNA-replication, DNA-repair pathways and down-regulation of the immune-system, chemokine- and interleukin-signaling, TCR, TGF beta and MAPK signaling pathways. A comparison between TKI-sensitive and TKI-resistant cases revealed up-regulation of LAPTM4B, HLTF, PIEZO2, CFH, CD109, ANGPT1 in CML-resistant cases, leading to up-regulation of autophagy-, protein-ubiquitination-, stem-cell-, complement-, TGFβ- and homeostasis-pathways with specific involvement of the Tie2 and Basigin signaling-pathway. Dysregulated pathways were accompanied with low CNVs in CP-new and CP-UT-TKI-sensitive-cases with undetectable BCR-ABL-copies. High CNVs (previously reported gain of 9q34) were observed in BCR-ABL-independent and -dependent TKI, non-sensitive-CP-UT/AP-UT/B-UT and B-new samples. Further, genotyping CML-CP-UT cases with BCR-ABL 0-to-77.02%-copies, the identified, rsID239798 and rsID9475077, were associated with FAM83B, a candidate for therapeutic resistance. The presence of BCR-ABL, additional genetic-events, dysregulated-signaling-pathways and rsIDs associated with FAM83B in TKI-resistant-cases can be used to develop a signature-profile that may help in monitoring therapy.

Making Meaningful Clinical Use of Biomarkers

This review discusses the current state of biomarker discovery for the purposes of diagnostics and therapeutic monitoring. We underscore relevant challenges that have defined the gap between biomarker discovery and meaningful clinical use. We highlight recent advancements in and propose a way to think about future biomarker development.

The relative utilities of genome-wide, gene panel, and individual gene sequencing in clinical practice

Advances in technology that have transpired over the past 2 decades have enabled the analysis of cancer samples for genomic alterations to understand their biologic function and to translate that knowledge into clinical practice. With the power to analyze entire genomes in a clinically relevant time frame and with manageable costs comes the question of whether we ought to and when. This review focuses on the relative merits of 3 approaches to molecular diagnostics in hematologic malignancies: indication-specific single gene assays, gene panel assays that test for genes selected for their roles in cancer, and genome-wide assays that broadly analyze the tumor exomes or genomes. After addressing these in general terms, we review specific use cases in myeloid and lymphoid malignancies to highlight the utility of single gene testing and/or larger panels.

Molecular techniques for the personalised management of patients with chronic myeloid leukaemia

Chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) is the paradigm for targeted cancer therapy. RT-qPCR is the gold standard for monitoring response to tyrosine kinase-inhibitor (TKI) therapy based on the reduction of blood or bone marrow BCR-ABL1. Some patients with CML and very low or undetectable levels of BCR-ABL1 transcripts can stop TKI-therapy without CML recurrence. However, about 60 percent of patients discontinuing TKI-therapy have rapid leukaemia recurrence. This has increased the need for more sensitive and specific techniques to measure residual CML cells. The clinical challenge is to determine when it is safe to stop TKI-therapy. In this review we describe and critically evaluate the current state of CML clinical management, different technologies used to monitor measurable residual disease (MRD) focus on comparingRT-qPCR and new methods entering clinical practice. We discuss advantages and disadvantages of new methods.

Clinical and Technical Aspects of Genomic Diagnostics for Precision Oncology

The emergence of precision medicine has been predicated on significant recent advances in diagnostic technology, particularly the advent of next-generation sequencing (NGS). Although the chemical technology underlying NGS is complex, and the computational biology expertise required to build systems to facilely interpret the results is highly specialized, the variables involved in designing and deploying a genomic testing program for cancer can be readily understood and applied by understanding several basic considerations. In this review, we present key strategic decisions required to optimize a genomic testing program and summarize the technical aspects of different technologies that render those methods more or less suitable for different types of programs.

Molecular Analysis of Gene Rearrangements and Mutations in Acute Leukemias and Myeloid Neoplasms

A subset of acute leukemias and other myeloid neoplasms contains specific genetic alterations, many of which are associated with unique clinical and pathologic features. These alterations include chromosomal rearrangements leading to oncogenic fusion proteins or alteration of gene expression by juxtaposing oncogenes to enhancer elements, as well as mutations leading to aberrant activation of a variety of proteins critical to hematopoietic progenitor cell proliferation and differentiation. Molecular analysis is central to diagnosis and clinical management of leukemias, permitting genetic confirmation of a clinical and histologic impression, providing prognostic and predictive information, and facilitating detection of minimal residual disease. This unit will outline approaches to the molecular diagnosis of the most frequent and clinically relevant genetic alterations in acute leukemias and myeloid neoplasms. © 2017 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Current trends in molecular diagnostics of chronic myeloid leukemia

Nearly 1.5 million people worldwide suffer from chronic myeloid leukemia (CML), characterized by the genetic translocation t(9;22)(q34;q11.2), involving the fusion of the Abelson oncogene (ABL1) with the breakpoint cluster region (BCR) gene. Early onset diagnosis coupled to current therapeutics allow for a treatment success rate of 90, which has focused research on the development of novel diagnostics approaches. In this review, we present a critical perspective on current strategies for CML diagnostics, comparing to gold standard methodologies and with an eye on the future trends on nanotheranostics.

Measurement of BCR-ABL1 transcripts on the International Scale in the United States: current status and best practices

Chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) results from the Philadelphia chromosome (Ph) translocation and expression of its fusion oncoprotein BCR-ABL1. BCR-ABL1 tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) are the standard therapy for Ph-positive CML. Achievement of deep molecular responses (typically defined as ≥4-log reduction in BCR-ABL1 RNA levels) is an emerging treatment goal becoming attainable for more patients due to the availability of second-generation TKIs. Deep molecular responses are associated with improved long-term outcomes and are required prior to attempting cessation of treatment in treatment-free remission clinical trials. The National Comprehensive Cancer Network and European LeukemiaNet recommend regular monitoring of BCR-ABL1 RNA levels using real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RQ-PCR). However, BCR-ABL1 RQ-PCR is a complex laboratory-developed test; routine quantitative results from clinical diagnostic laboratories may differ from those used to establish the recommendations. Although an International Scale (IS) was developed for standardized reporting of BCR-ABL1 RNA levels, IS adoption has been slow in the United States, but is now used by the vast majority of laboratories. Here, we discuss the importance of molecular monitoring in CML, gaps between current and best molecular monitoring practices in the United States, and challenges and potential solutions for universal IS adoption in the United States.

Biomarkers in Hematological Malignancies: A Review of Molecular Testing in Hematopathology

BACKGROUND

Molecular interrogation of genetic information has transformed our understanding of disease and is now routinely integrated into the workup and monitoring of hematological malignancies. In this article, a brief but comprehensive review is presented of state-of-the-art testing in hematological disease.

METHODS

The primary medical literature and standard textbooks in the field were queried and reviewed to assess current practices and trends for molecular testing in hematopathology by disease.

RESULTS

Pertinent materials were summarized under appropriate disease categories.

CONCLUSION

Molecular testing is well entrenched in the diagnostic and therapeutic pathways for hematological malignancies, with rapid growth and insights emerging following the integration of next-generation sequencing into the clinical workflow.

Class III Receptor Tyrosine Kinases in Acute Leukemia - Biological Functions and Modern Laboratory Analysis

Acute myeloid leukemia (AML) is a complex disease caused by deregulation of multiple signaling pathways. Mutations in class III receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) have been implicated in alteration of cell signals concerning the growth and differentiation of leukemic cells. Point mutations, insertions, or deletions of RTKs as well as chromosomal translocations induce constitutive activation of the receptor, leading to uncontrolled proliferation of undifferentiated myeloid blasts. Aberrations can occur in all domains of RTKs causing either the ligand-independent activation or mimicking the activated conformation. The World Health Organization recommended including RTK mutations in the AML classification since their detection in routine laboratory diagnostics is a major factor for prognostic stratification of patients. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based methods are well-validated for the detection of fms-related tyrosine kinase 3 (FLT3) mutations and can easily be applied for other RTKs. However, when methodological limitations are reached, accessory techniques can be applied. For a higher resolution and more quantitative approach compared to agarose gel electrophoresis, PCR fragments can be separated by capillary electrophoresis. Furthermore, high-resolution melting and denaturing high-pressure liquid chromatography are reliable presequencing screening methods that reduce the sample amount for Sanger sequencing. Because traditional DNA sequencing is time-consuming, next-generation sequencing (NGS) is an innovative modern possibility to analyze a high amount of samples simultaneously in a short period of time. At present, standardized procedures for NGS are not established, but when this barrier is resolved, it will provide a new platform for rapid and reliable laboratory diagnostic of RTK mutations in patients with AML. In this article, the biological and physiological role of RTK mutations in AML as well as possible laboratory methods for their detection will be reviewed.

Marked Variability in Reported Minimal Residual Disease Lower Level of Detection of 4 Hematolymphoid Neoplasms: A Survey of Participants in the College of American Pathologists Flow Cytometry Proficiency Testing Program

Context

Flow cytometry is often applied to minimal residual disease (MRD) testing in hematolymphoid neoplasia. Because flow-based MRD tests are developed in the laboratory, testing methodologies and lower levels of detection (LODs) are laboratory dependent.

Objectives

To broadly survey flow cytometry laboratories about MRD testing in laboratories, if performed, including indications and reported LODs.

Design

Voluntary supplemental questions were sent to the 549 laboratories participating in the College of American Pathologists (CAP) FL3-A Survey (Flow Cytometry—Immunophenotypic Characterization of Leukemia/Lymphoma) in the spring of 2014.

Results

A total of 500 laboratories (91%) responded to the supplemental questions as part of the FL3-A Survey by April 2014; of those 500 laboratories, 167 (33%) currently perform MRD for lymphoblastic leukemia, 118 (24%) for myeloid leukemia, 99 (20%) for chronic lymphocytic leukemia, and 91 (18%) for plasma cell myeloma. Other indications include non-Hodgkin lymphoma, hairy cell leukemia, neuroblastoma, and myelodysplastic syndrome. Most responding laboratories that perform MRD for lymphoblastic leukemia reported an LOD of 0.01%. For myeloid leukemia, chronic lymphocytic leukemia, and plasma cell myeloma, most laboratories indicated an LOD of 0.1%. Less than 3% (15 of 500) of laboratories reported LODs of 0.001% for one or more MRD assays performed.

Conclusions

There is major heterogeneity in the reported LODs of MRD testing performed by laboratories subscribing to the CAP FL3-A Survey. To address that heterogeneity, changes to the Flow Cytometry Checklist for the CAP Laboratory Accreditation Program are suggested that will include new requirements that each laboratory (1) document how an MRD assay's LOD is measured, and (2) include the LOD or lower limit of enumeration for flow-based MRD assays in the final diagnostic report.

Methylation of the nonhomologous end joining repair pathway genes does not explain the increase of translocations with aging

Chromosome translocations are especially frequent in human lymphomas and leukemias but are insufficient to drive carcinogenesis. Indeed, several of the so-called tumor specific translocations have been detected in peripheral blood of healthy individuals, finding a higher frequency of some of them with aging. The inappropriate repair of DNA double strand breaks by the nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) pathway is one of the reasons for a translocation to occur. Moreover, fidelity of this pathway has been shown to decline with age. Although the mechanism underlying this inefficacy is unknown, other repair pathways are inactivated by methylation with aging. In this study, we analyzed the implication of NHEJ genes methylation in the increase of translocations with the age. To this aim, we determined the relationship between translocations and aging in 565 Spanish healthy individuals and correlated these data with the methylation status of 11 NHEJ genes. We found higher frequency of BCL2-JH and BCR-ABL (major) translocations with aging. In addition, we detected that two NHEJ genes (LIG4 and XRCC6) presented age-dependent promoter methylation changes. However, we did not observe a correlation between the increase of translocations and methylation, indicating that other molecular mechanisms are involved in the loss of NHEJ fidelity with aging.

Analyzing molecular response in chronic myeloid leukemia clinical trials: pitfalls and golden rules

Clinical trials of chronic myeloid leukemia frequently rely on molecular markers as surrogates for clinical endpoints. Studies suggest that early molecular response (EMR) is a good indicator of a favorable prognosis and yet, to the authors' knowledge, the use of EMR as a robust surrogate marker for clinical response has yet to be fully explored. EMR to therapy appears to be affected by a variety of factors, including disease characteristics, risk score, adherence to treatment, and off-target effects of the treatment. Therefore, although molecular markers improve important research, they also bring with them important questions regarding their reliability. To be useful, markers must be must be easily measureable, capable of generating meaningful data, and clinically relevant. BCR-ABL1 is the hallmark marker in chronic myeloid leukemia. Nevertheless, investigators still struggle with how best to measure and interpret both high and very low BCR-ABL1 levels. Statistical models of BCR-ABL1 kinetics must address these concerns and account for the BCR-ABL1 variability between and within patients. Response models should also incorporate disease characteristics and other important parameters.

Conversion, correction, and International Scale standardization: results From a Multicenter External Quality Assessment Study for BCR-ABL1 testing

CONTEXT

Monitoring BCR-ABL1 expression levels relative to clinically validated response criteria on the International Scale (IS) is vital in the optimal management of patients with chronic myeloid leukemia, yet significant variability remains across laboratories worldwide.

OBJECTIVE

To assess method performance, interlaboratory precision, and different IS standardization modalities in representative laboratories performing routine BCR-ABL1 testing.

DESIGN

Fifteen blinded test specimens with 5-level nominal BCR-ABL1 to ABL1 IS percentage ratios ranging from 5% to 0.0005% and 4-level secondary IS reference panels, the ARQ IS Calibrator Panels, were tested by relative quantitative polymerase chain reaction in 15 laboratories in 5 countries. Both raw and IS percentage ratios calculated by using local conversion factors (CFs) or analytic correction parameters (CPs) were collected and analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 670 valid positive results were generated. BCR-ABL1 detection was associated with variable ABL1 quality metric passing rates (P < .001) and reached at least 0.01% in 13 laboratories. Intralaboratory precision was within 2.5-fold for all sample levels combined with a relative mean difference greater than 5-fold across laboratories. International Scale accuracy was increased by using both the CF and CP standardization methods. Classification agreement for major molecular response status was 90% after CF conversion and 93% after CP correction, with precision improved by 3-fold for the CP method.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite preanalytic and analytic differences between laboratories, conversion and correction are effective IS standardization methods. Validated secondary reference materials can facilitate global diffusion of the IS without the need to perform sample exchange and improve the accuracy and precision of BCR-ABL1 quantitative measurements, including at low levels of residual disease.