Structural biology of endogenous membrane protein assemblies in native nanodiscs

Compositional versatility enables biologically inspired reverse micelles for study of protein-membrane interactions

The study of membranes and their associated proteins is critical for understanding cellular processes. In vitro investigations utilizing membrane models often have limitations in their biological relevance due to the dissimilarity of experimentally compatible membrane mimetics to biological membranes. Development of membrane models that better mimic cellular membranes enables more biologically accurate observations of membrane associated proteins. In this work, we present upper tolerance concentrations for a range of lipids incorporated into reverse micelles (RMs), confirmed with dynamic light scattering (DLS). A breadth of lipid incorporation enabled biologically inspired RMs to be formulated based on the molar ratios of lipids present in eukaryotic membrane leaflets. Three systems were formulated matching lipid compositions of the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane (PM-RM), the outer mitochondrial membrane leaflet (MI-RM), and the outer rough endoplasmic reticulum membrane leaflet (ER-RM). The biologically-inspired RM formulations were characterized using DLS and cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and were found to have favorable properties for protein encapsulation. All three biologically inspired RM formulations effectively encapsulated fatty acid binding protein 4 (FABP4), a protein which shuttles fatty acids between membranes, confirmed by NMR. Also presented in this work is the first known high-resolution observation of the membrane-bound state of sterol carrier protein 2 (SCP2), a protein responsible for transporting an array of lipids between membranes. SCP2 was successfully encapsulated within all three RM systems, enabling NMR observation of the membrane interface of SCP2. The tolerances and formulations reported here allow for tailoring of RMs to mimic specific cellular membranes and will enhance studies of protein interactions with lipids and membranes among other investigations.

Nanodiscs remain indispensable for Cryo-EM studies of membrane proteins

Nanodiscs, small discoidal membrane patches stabilized by membrane-scaffold proteins (MSPs), are popular tools to stabilize integral membrane proteins (IMPs) for structural studies by cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM). While nanodiscs provide a near-native membrane environment for the incorporated IMPs, they do not reproduce all characteristics of a native membrane. Also, IMPs must first be purified in detergent before they can be reconstituted into MSP-based nanodiscs, a problem that has been overcome by newer approaches, such as copolymer-based native nanodiscs and cell-derived vesicles. In this review, we argue that despite these advances, MSP-based nanodiscs remain a unique tool for the structural interrogation of IMPs.

Advances in solubilization and stabilization techniques for structural and functional studies of membrane proteins

Membrane proteins (MPs) are indispensable in various biological processes, including material transport, signal transduction, immune response, and cell recognition. Unraveling the intricate interplay between MP structure and function is pivotal for advancing fundamental biology and pharmaceutical research. However, the inherent hydrophobicity and complex lipid interactions of MPs pose significant challenges in determining their three-dimensional configurations. In recent years, cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) has emerged as a powerful alternative for structural elucidation, overcoming the challenges faced by traditional techniques such as X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). This review centers on advanced solubilization and stabilization techniques for MPs, as well as MP functions and expression systems, highlighting the strengths and limitations of conventional detergents, liposomes, bicelles, and nanodiscs, alongside emerging alternatives like styrene-maleic acid (SMA) and diisobutylene-maleic acid (DIBMA). Notably, SMA and its derivatives provide promising detergent-free alternatives that preserve protein stability and native conformation, which is particularly valuable for accurate cryo-EM characterization of complex MPs. This work is designed to serve as both an updated resource for researchers already immersed in the field and an accessible entry point for those new to MP research. By consolidating recent advancements and highlighting critical gaps, this review aims to inspire future investigations that push the boundaries of MP structural and functional studies, ultimately driving innovations in drug discovery and therapeutic development.

Functional analysis of Candida albicans Cdr1 through homologous and heterologous expression studies

Candida albicans Cdr1 is a plasma membrane ATP-binding cassette transporter encoded by CDR1 that was first cloned 30 years ago in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Increased expression of Cdr1 in C. albicans clinical isolates results in resistance to azole antifungals due to drug efflux from the cells. Knowledge of Cdr1 structure and function could enable the design of Cdr1 inhibitors that overcome efflux-mediated drug resistance. This article reviews the use of expression systems to study Cdr1. Since the discovery of CDR1 in 1995, 123 studies have investigated Cdr1 using either heterologous or homologous expression systems. The majority of studies have employed integrative transformation and expression in S. cerevisiae. We describe a suite of plasmids with a range of useful protein tags for integrative transformation that enable the creation of tandem-gene arrays stably integrated into the S. cerevisiae genome, and a model for Cdr1 transport function. While expression in S. cerevisiae generates a strong phenotype and high yields of Cdr1, it is a nonnative environment and may result in altered structure and function. Membrane lipid composition and architecture affects membrane protein function and a focus on homologous expression in C. albicans may permit a more accurate understanding of Cdr1 structure and function.

Polymer nanodiscs support the functional extraction of an artificial transmembrane cytochrome

Polymer nanodiscs are an attractive alternative to surfactants for studying integral membrane proteins within their native lipid environment. Here, we investigate the use of such polymers to isolate a computationally-designed de novo membrane cytochrome named CytbX. We show that the block copolymers known as CyclAPols can efficiently extract CytbX directly from biomembranes and are compatible with the downstream purification and biophysical characterisation of this artificial protein. CyclAPol-solubilised CytbX is well-folded and highly robust with properties that are essentially identical to those observed for the same protein in a detergent micelle. However, electron transfer to CytbX from a diffusive flavoprotein is substantially faster in micelles than in the nanodisc system. Our results confirm that polymer nanodiscs will be a useful tool for the ongoing study and application of de novo membrane proteins.

DeFrND: detergent-free reconstitution into native nanodiscs with designer membrane scaffold peptides

Membrane scaffold proteins-based nanodiscs (NDs) have facilitated unprecedented structural and biophysical analysis of membrane proteins in a near-native lipid environment. However, successful reconstitution of membrane proteins in NDs requires prior solubilization and purification in detergents, which may impact their physiological structure and function. Furthermore, the detergent-mediated reconstitution of NDs is unlikely to recapitulate the precise composition or asymmetry of native membranes. To circumvent this fundamental limitation of traditional ND technology, we herein describe the development of membrane-solubilizing peptides to directly extract membrane proteins from native cell membranes into nanoscale discoids. By systematically protein engineering and screening, we created a new class of chemically modified Apolipoprotein-A1 mimetic peptides to enable the formation of detergent-free NDs (DeFrNDs) with high efficiency. NDs generated with these engineered membrane scaffold peptides are suitable for obtaining high-resolution structures using single-particle cryo-EM with native lipids. To further highlight the versatility of DeFrNDs, we directly extract a sampling of membrane signaling proteins with their surrounding native membranes for biochemical and biophysical interrogations.

In-Cell DEER Spectroscopy of Nanodisc-Delivered Membrane Proteins in Living Cell Membranes

Membrane proteins are integral to numerous cellular processes, yet their conformational dynamics in native environments remains difficult to study. This study introduces a nanodelivery method using nanodiscs to transport spin-labeled membrane proteins into the membranes of living cells, enabling direct in-cell double electron-electron resonance (DEER) spectroscopy measurements. We investigated the membrane protein BsYetJ, incorporating spin labels at key positions to monitor conformational changes. Our findings demonstrate successful delivery and high-quality DEER data for BsYetJ in both Gram-negative E. coli and Gram-positive B. subtilis membranes. The delivered BsYetJ retains its ability to transport calcium ions. DEER analysis reveals distinct conformational states of BsYetJ in different membrane environments, highlighting the influence of lipid composition on the protein structure. This nanodelivery method overcomes traditional limitations, enabling the study of membrane proteins in more physiologically relevant conditions.

Three-Dimensional Interaction Homology: Deconstructing Residue-Residue and Residue-Lipid Interactions in Membrane Proteins

A method is described to deconstruct the network of hydropathic interactions within and between a protein's sidechain and its environment into residue-based three-dimensional maps. These maps encode favorable and unfavorable hydrophobic and polar interactions, in terms of spatial positions for optimal interactions, relative interaction strength, as well as character. In addition, these maps are backbone angle-dependent. After map calculation and clustering, a finite number of unique residue sidechain interaction maps exist for each backbone conformation, with the number related to the residue's size and interaction complexity. Structures for soluble proteins (~749,000 residues) and membrane proteins (~387,000 residues) were analyzed, with the latter group being subdivided into three subsets related to the residue's position in the membrane protein: soluble domain, core-facing transmembrane domain, and lipid-facing transmembrane domain. This work suggests that maps representing residue types and their backbone conformation can be reassembled to optimize the medium-to-high resolution details of a protein structure. In particular, the information encoded in maps constructed from the lipid-facing transmembrane residues appears to paint a clear picture of the protein-lipid interactions that are difficult to obtain experimentally.

Novel class of peptides disintegrating biological membranes to aid in the characterization of membrane proteins

Styrene-maleic acid (SMA) and similar amphiphilic copolymers are known to cut biological membranes into lipid nanoparticles/nanodiscs containing membrane proteins apparently in their relatively native membrane lipid environment. Our previous work demonstrated that membrane raft microdomains resist such disintegration by SMA. The use of SMA in studying membrane proteins is limited by its heterogeneity and the inability to prepare defined derivatives. In the present paper, we demonstrate that some amphiphilic peptides structurally mimicking SMA also similarly disintegrate cell membranes. In contrast to the previously used copolymers, the simple peptides are structurally homogeneous. We found that their membrane-disintegrating activity increases with their length (reaching optimum at 24 amino acids) and requires a basic primary structure, that is, (XXD)n, where X represents a hydrophobic amino acid (optimally phenylalanine), D aspartic acid, and n is the number of repeats of these triplets. These peptides may provide opportunities for various well-defined potentially useful modifications in the study of membrane protein biochemistry. Our present results confirm a specific character of membrane raft microdomains.

Recognition and remodeling of endosomal zones by sorting nexins

The proteolipid code determines how cytosolic proteins find and remodel membrane surfaces. Here, we investigate how this process works with sorting nexins Snx1 and Snx3. Both proteins form sorting machines by recognizing membrane zones enriched in phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate (PI3P), phosphatidylserine (PS) and cholesterol. This co-localized combination forms a unique "lipid codon" or lipidon that we propose is responsible for endosomal targeting, as revealed by structures and interactions of their PX domain-based readers. We outline a membrane recognition and remodeling mechanism for Snx1 and Snx3 involving this code element alongside transmembrane pH gradients, dipole moment-guided docking and specific protein-protein interactions. This generates an initial membrane-protein assembly (memtein) that then recruits retromer and additional PX proteins to recruit cell surface receptors for sorting to the trans-Golgi network (TGN), lysosome and plasma membranes. Post-translational modification (PTM) networks appear to regulate how the sorting machines form and operate at each level. The commonalities and differences between these sorting nexins show how the proteolipid code orchestrates parallel flows of molecular information from ribosome emergence to organelle genesis, and illuminates a universally applicable model of the membrane.

Membrane-Driven Dimerization of the Peripheral Membrane Protein KRAS: Implications for Downstream Signaling

Transient homo-dimerization of the RAS GTPase at the plasma membrane has been shown to promote the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) signaling pathway essential for cell proliferation and oncogenesis. To date, numerous crystallographic studies have focused on the well-defined GTPase domains of RAS isoforms, which lack the disordered C-terminal membrane anchor, thus providing limited structural insight into membrane-bound RAS molecules. Recently, lipid-bilayer nanodisc platforms and paramagnetic relaxation enhancement (PRE) analyses have revealed several distinct structures of the membrane-anchored homodimers of KRAS, an isoform that is most frequently mutated in human cancers. The KRAS dimerization interface is highly plastic and altered by biologically relevant conditions, including oncogenic mutations, the nucleotide states of the protein, and the lipid composition. Notably, PRE-derived structures of KRAS homodimers on the membrane substantially differ in terms of the relative orientation of the protomers at an "α-α" dimer interface comprising two α4-α5 regions. This interface plasticity along with the altered orientations of KRAS on the membrane impact the accessibility of KRAS to downstream effectors and regulatory proteins. Further, nanodisc platforms used to drive KRAS dimerization can be used to screen potential anticancer drugs that target membrane-bound RAS dimers and probe their structural mechanism of action.

Factors influencing the detergent-free membrane protein isolation using synthetic nanodisc-forming polymers

The detergent-free isolation of membrane proteins using synthetic polymers is becoming the desired approach for functional and structural studies of membrane proteins. Since the expression levels for many membrane proteins are low and a high yield of functionalized reconstituted membrane proteins is essential for in vitro studies, it is crucial to optimize the experimental conditions for a given polymer to solubilize target membranes/proteins effectively. The factors that affect membrane solubilization and subsequently the isolation of a target membrane protein include polymer concentration, polymer charge, temperature, pH, and concentration of divalent metal ions. Therefore, it is important to have knowledge about the efficacy of different types of polymers in solubilizing cell membranes. In this study, we evaluate the efficacy of inulin-based non-ionic polymers in solubilizing E. coli membranes enriched with rat flavin mononucleotide binding-domain (FBD) of cytochrome-P450-reductase (CPR) and rabbit cytochrome-b5 (Cyt-b5) under various solubilization conditions. Our results show that a 1:1 (w/w) membrane:polymer ratio, low temperature, high pH and sub-millimolar concentration of metal ions favor the solubilization of E. coli membranes enriched with FBD or Cyt-b5. Conversely, the presence of excess divalent metal ions affected the final protein levels in the polymer-solubilized samples. We believe that the results from this study provide knowledge to assess and plan the use of non-ionic polymers in membrane protein studies.

Characterization of nanodisc-forming peptides for membrane protein studies

Lipid-bilayer nanodiscs provide a stable, native-like membrane environment for the functional and structural studies of membrane proteins and other membrane-binding molecules. Peptide-based nanodiscs having unique properties are developed for membrane protein studies and other biological applications. While the self-assembly process rendering the formation of peptide-nanodiscs is attractive, it is important to understand the stability and suitability of these nanodisc systems for membrane protein studies. In this study, we investigated the nanodiscs formation by the anti-inflammatory and tumor-suppressing peptide AEM28. AEM28 is a chimeric peptide containing a cationic-rich heparan sulfate proteoglycan- (HSPG)-binding domain from human apolipoprotein E (hapoE) (141-150) followed by the 18A peptide's amino acid sequence. AEM28-based nanodiscs made with different types of lipids were characterized using various biophysical techniques and compared with the nanodiscs formed using 2F or 4F peptides. Variable temperature dynamic light-scattering and 31P NMR experiments indicated the fusion and size heterogeneity of nanodiscs at high temperatures. The suitability of AEM28 and Ac-18A-NH2- (2F-) based nanodiscs for studying membrane proteins is demonstrated by reconstituting and characterizing a drug-metabolizing enzyme, cytochrome-P450 (CYP450), or the redox complex CYP450-CYP450 reductase. AEM28 and 2F were also tested for their efficacies in solubilizing E. coli membranes to understand the possibility of using them for detergent-free membrane protein isolation. Our experimental results suggest that AEM28 nanodiscs are suitable for studying membrane proteins with a net positive charge, whereas 2F-based nanodiscs are compatible with any membrane proteins and their complexes irrespective of their charge. Furthermore, both peptides solubilized E. coli cell membranes, indicating their use in membrane protein isolation and other applications related to membrane solubilization.

Investigating protein-membrane interactions using native reverse micelles constructed from naturally sourced lipids

Advancing the study of membrane associated proteins and their interactions is dependent on accurate membrane models. While a variety of membrane models for high-resolution membrane protein study exist, most do not reflect the diversity of lipids found within biological membranes. In this work, we have developed native reverse micelles (nRMs) formulated with lipids from multiple eukaryotic sources, which encapsulate proteins and enable them to interact as they would with a biological membrane. Diverse formulations of nRMs using soy lecithin, porcine brain lipids, or bovine heart lipids combined with n-dodecylphosphocholine were developed and characterized by dynamic light scattering and 31 P-NMR. To optimize protein encapsulation, ubiquitin was used as a standard and protein NMR verified minimal changes to its structure. Peripheral membrane proteins, which bind reversibly to membranes, were encapsulated and include glutathione peroxidase 4 (GPx4), phosphatidylethanolamine-binding protein 1 (PEBP1), and fatty acid binding protein 4 (FABP4). All three proteins showed anticipated interactions with the membrane-like inner surface of the nRMs as assessed by protein NMR. The nRM formulations developed here allow for efficient, high-resolution study of membrane interacting proteins up to and beyond ~21 kDa, in a more biologically relevant context compared to other non-native membrane models. The approach outlined here may be applied to a wide range of lipid extracts, allowing study of a variety of membrane associated proteins in their specific biological context.

Construction and Applications of Mammalian Cell-Based DNA-Encoded Peptide/Protein Libraries

DNA-encoded peptide/protein libraries are the starting point for protein evolutionary modification and functional peptide/antibody selection. Different display technologies, protein directed evolution, and deep mutational scanning (DMS) experiments employ DNA-encoded libraries to provide sequence variations for downstream affinity- or function-based selections. Mammalian cells promise the inherent post-translational modification and near-to-natural conformation of exogenously expressed mammalian proteins and thus are the best platform for studying transmembrane proteins or human disease-related proteins. However, due to the current technical bottlenecks of constructing mammalian cell-based large size DNA-encoded libraries, the advantages of mammalian cells as screening platforms have not been fully exploited. In this review, we summarize the current efforts in constructing DNA-encoded libraries in mammalian cells and the existing applications of these libraries in different fields.

pH-tunable membrane-active polymers, NCMNP2a-x, and their potential membrane protein applications

Accurate 3D structures of membrane proteins are essential for comprehending their mechanisms of action and designing specific ligands to modulate their activities. However, these structures are still uncommon due to the involvement of detergents in the sample preparation. Recently, membrane-active polymers have emerged as an alternative to detergents, but their incompatibility with low pH and divalent cations has hindered their efficacy. Herein, we describe the design, synthesis, characterization, and application of a new class of pH-tunable membrane-active polymers, NCMNP2a-x. The results demonstrated that NCMNP2a-x could be used for high-resolution single-particle cryo-EM structural analysis of AcrB in various pH conditions and can effectively solubilize BcTSPO with the function preserved. Molecular dynamic simulation is consistent with experimental data that shed great insights into the working mechanism of this class of polymers. These results demonstrated that NCMNP2a-x might have broad applications in membrane protein research.

Lipid packing is disrupted in copolymeric nanodiscs compared with intact membranes

Discoidal lipid-protein nanoparticles known as nanodiscs are widely used tools in structural and membrane biology. Amphipathic, synthetic copolymers have recently become an attractive alternative to membrane scaffold proteins for the formation of nanodiscs. Such copolymers can directly intercalate into, and form nanodiscs from, intact membranes without detergents. Although these copolymer nanodiscs can extract native membrane lipids, it remains unclear whether native membrane properties are also retained. To determine the extent to which bilayer lipid packing is retained in nanodiscs, we measured the behavior of packing-sensitive fluorescent dyes in various nanodisc preparations compared with intact lipid bilayers. We analyzed styrene-maleic acid (SMA), diisobutylene-maleic acid (DIBMA), and polymethacrylate (PMA) as nanodisc scaffolds at various copolymer-to-lipid ratios and temperatures. Measurements of Laurdan spectral shifts revealed that dimyristoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DMPC) nanodiscs had increased lipid headgroup packing compared with large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs) above the lipid melting temperature for all three copolymers. Similar effects were observed for DMPC nanodiscs stabilized by membrane scaffolding protein MSP1E1. Increased lipid headgroup packing was also observed when comparing nanodiscs with intact membranes composed of binary mixtures of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphocholine (POPC) and di-palmitoyl-phosphocholine (DPPC), which show fluid-gel-phase coexistence. Similarly, Laurdan reported increased headgroup packing in nanodiscs for biomimetic mixtures containing cholesterol, most notable for relatively disordered membranes. The magnitudes of these ordering effects were not identical for the various copolymers, with SMA being the most and DIBMA being the least perturbing. Finally, nanodiscs derived from mammalian cell membranes showed similarly increased lipid headgroup packing. We conclude that nanodiscs generally do not completely retain the physical properties of intact membranes.

Role of surfactants in electron cryo-microscopy film preparation

Single-particle electron cryo-microscopy (cryo-EM) has become an effective and straightforward approach to determine the structure of membrane proteins. However, obtaining cryo-EM grids of sufficient quality for high-resolution structural analysis remains a major bottleneck. One of the difficulties arises from the presence of detergents, which often leads to a lack of control of the ice thickness. Amphipathic polymers such as amphipols (APols) are detergent substitutes, which have proven to be valuable tools for cryo-EM studies. In this work, we investigate the physico-chemical behavior of APol- and detergent-containing solutions and show a correlation with the properties of vitreous thin films in cryo-EM grids. This study provides new insight on the potential of APols, allowing a better control of ice thickness while limiting protein adsorption at the air-water interface, as shown with the full-length mouse serotonin 5-HT3A receptor whose structure has been solved in APol. These findings may speed up the process of grid optimization to obtain high-resolution structures of membrane proteins.

SMALPs Are Not Simply Nanodiscs: The Polymer-to-Lipid Ratios of Fractionated SMALPs Underline Their Heterogeneous Nature

Amphipathic styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers directly solubilize biomembranes into SMA-lipid particles, or SMALPs, that are often regarded as nanodiscs and hailed as a native membrane platform. The promising outlook of SMALPs inspires the discovery of many SMA-like copolymers that also solubilize biomembranes into putative nanodiscs, but a fundamental question remains on how much the SMALPs or SMALP analogues truly resemble the bilayer structure of nanodiscs. This unfortunate ambiguity undermines the utility of SMA or SMA-like copolymers in membrane biology because the structure and function of many membrane proteins depend critically on their surrounding matrices. Here, we report the structural heterogeneity of SMALPs revealed through fractionating SMALPs comprised of lipids and well-defined SMAs via size-exclusion chromatography followed by quantitative determination of the polymer-to-lipid (P/L) stoichiometric ratios in individual fractions. Through the lens of P/L stoichiometric ratios, different self-assembled polymer-lipid nanostructures are inferred, such as polymer-remodeled liposomes, polymer-encased nanodiscs, polymer-lipid mixed micelles, and lipid-doped polymer micellar aggregates. We attribute the structural heterogeneity of SMALPs to the microstructure variations amongst individual polymer chains that give rise to their polydisperse detergency. As an example, we demonstrate that SMAs with a similar S/MA ratio but different chain sizes participate preferentially in different polymer-lipid nanostructures. We further demonstrate that proteorhodopsin, a light-driven proton pump solubilized within the same SMALPs is distributed amongst different self-assembled nanostructures to display different photocycle kinetics. Our discovery challenges the native nanodisc notion of SMALPs or SMALP analogues and highlights the necessity to separate and identify the structurally dissimilar polymer-lipid particles in membrane biology studies.

Enhancing the stability and homogeneity of non-ionic polymer nanodiscs by tuning electrostatic interactions

The nanodisc technology is increasingly used for structural studies on membrane proteins and drug delivery. The development of synthetic polymer nanodiscs and the recent discovery of non-ionic inulin-based polymers have significantly broadened the scope of nanodiscs. While the lipid exchange and size flexibility properties of the self-assembled polymer-based nanodiscs are valuable for various applications, the non-ionic polymer nanodiscs are remarkably unique in that they enable the reconstitution of any protein, protein-protein complexes, or drugs irrespective of their charge. However, the non-ionic nature of the belt could influence the stability and size homogeneity of inulin-based polymer nanodiscs. In this study, we investigate the size stability and homogeneity of nanodiscs formed by non-ionic lipid-solubilizing polymers using different biophysical methods. Polymer nanodiscs containing zwitterionic DMPC and different ratios of DMPC:DMPG lipids were made using anionic SMA-EA or non-ionic pentyl-inulin polymers. Non-ionic polymer nanodiscs made using zwitterionic DMPC lipids produced a very broad elution profile on SEC due to their instability in the column, thus affecting sample monodispersity which was confirmed by DLS experiments that showed multiple peaks. However, the inclusion of anionic DMPG lipids improved the stability as observed from SEC and DLS profiles, which was further confirmed by TEM images. Whereas, anionic SMA-EA-based DMPC-nanodiscs showed excellent stability and size homogeneity when solubilizing zwitterionic lipids. The stability of DMPC:DMPG non-ionic polymer nanodiscs is attributed to the inter-nanodisc repulsion by the anionic-DMPG that prevents the uncontrolled collision and fusion of nanodiscs. Thus, the reported results demonstrate the use of electrostatic interactions to tune the solubility, stability, and size homogeneity of non-ionic polymer nanodiscs which are important features for enabling functional and atomic-resolution structural studies of membrane proteins, other lipid-binding molecules, and water-soluble biomolecules including cytosolic proteins, nucleic acids and metabolites.

Effect of Cholesterol on the Structure and Composition of Glyco-DIBMA Lipid Particles

Different amphiphilic co-polymers have been introduced to produce polymer-lipid particles with nanodisc structure composed of an inner lipid bilayer and polymer chains self-assembled as an outer belt. These particles can be used to stabilize membrane proteins in solution and enable their characterization by means of biophysical methods, including small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). Some of these co-polymers have also been used to directly extract membrane proteins together with their associated lipids from native membranes. Styrene/maleic acid and diisobutylene/maleic acid are among the most commonly used co-polymers for producing polymer-lipid particles, named SMALPs and DIBMALPs, respectively. Recently, a new co-polymer, named Glyco-DIBMA, was produced by partial amidation of DIBMA with the amino sugar N-methyl-d-glucosamine. Polymer-lipid particles produced with Glyco-DIBMA, named Glyco-DIBMALPs, exhibit improved structural properties and stability compared to those of SMALPs and DIBMALPs while retaining the capability of directly extracting membrane proteins from native membranes. Here, we characterize the structure and lipid composition of Glyco-DIBMALPs produced with either 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) or 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC). Glyco-DIBMALPs were also prepared with mixtures of either POPC or DMPC and cholesterol at different mole fractions. We estimated the lipid content in the Glyco-DIBMALPs and determined the particle structure and morphology by SAXS. We show that the Glyco-DIBMALPs are nanodisc-like particles whose size and shape depend on the polymer/lipid ratio. This is relevant for designing nanodisc particles with a tunable diameter according to the size of the membrane protein to be incorporated. We also report that the addition of >20 mol % cholesterol strongly perturbed the formation of Glyco-DIBMALPs. Altogether, we describe a detailed characterization of the Glyco-DIBMALPs, which provides relevant inputs for future application of these particles in the biophysical investigation of membrane proteins.

Composition of raft-like cell membrane microdomains resistant to styrene-maleic acid copolymer (SMA) solubilization

An advantageous alternative to the use of detergents in biochemical studies on membrane proteins are the recently developed styrene-maleic acid (SMA) amphipathic copolymers. In our recent study ^[1] we demonstrated that using this approach, most T cell membrane proteins were fully solubilized (presumably in small nanodiscs), while two types of raft proteins, GPI-anchored proteins and Src family kinases, were mostly present in much larger (>250 nm) membrane fragments markedly enriched in typical raft lipids, cholesterol and lipids containing saturated fatty acid residues. In the present study we demonstrate that disintegration of membranes of several other cell types by means of SMA copolymer follows a similar pattern and we provide a detailed proteomic and lipidomic characterization of these SMA-resistant membrane fragments (SRMs).

Mass spectrometry of intact membrane proteins: shifting towards a more native-like context

Integral membrane proteins are involved in a plethora of biological processes including cellular signalling, molecular transport, and catalysis. Many of these functions are mediated by non-covalent interactions with other proteins, substrates, metabolites, and surrounding lipids. Uncovering such interactions and deciphering their effect on protein activity is essential for understanding the regulatory mechanisms underlying integral membrane protein function. However, the detection of such dynamic complexes has proven to be challenging using traditional approaches in structural biology. Native mass spectrometry has emerged as a powerful technique for the structural characterisation of membrane proteins and their complexes, enabling the detection and identification of protein-binding partners. In this review, we discuss recent native mass spectrometry-based studies that have characterised non-covalent interactions of membrane proteins in the presence of detergents or membrane mimetics. We additionally highlight recent progress towards the study of membrane proteins within native membranes and provide our perspective on how these could be combined with recent developments in instrumentation to investigate increasingly complex biomolecular systems.

Influence of Hydrophobic Groups Attached to Amphipathic Polymers on the Solubilization of Membrane Proteins along with Their Lipids

One of the biggest challenges in membrane protein (MP) research is to secure physiologically relevant structural and functional information after extracting MPs from their native membrane. Amphipathic polymers represent attractive alternatives to detergents for stabilizing MPs in aqueous solutions. The predominant polymers used in MP biochemistry and biophysics are amphipols (APols), one class of which, styrene maleic acid (SMA) copolymers and their derivatives, has proven particularly efficient at MP extraction. In order to examine the relationship between the chemical structure of the polymers and their ability to extract MPs from membranes, we have developed two novel classes of APols bearing either cycloalkane or aryl (aromatic) rings, named CyclAPols and ArylAPols, respectively. The effect on solubilization of such parameters as the density of hydrophobic groups, the number of carbon atoms and their arrangement in the hydrophobic moieties, as well as the charge density of the polymers was evaluated. The membrane-solubilizing efficiency of the SMAs, CyclAPols, and ArylAPols was compared using as models (i) two MPs, BmrA and a GFP-fused version of LacY, overexpressed in the inner membrane of Escherichia coli, and (ii) bacteriorhodopsin, naturally expressed in the purple membrane of Halobacterium salinarum. This analysis shows that, as compared to SMAs, the novel APols feature an improved efficiency at extracting MPs while preserving native protein-lipid interactions.

Membranes under the Magnetic Lens: A Dive into the Diverse World of Membrane Protein Structures Using Cryo-EM

Membrane proteins are highly diverse in both structure and function and can, therefore, present different challenges for structure determination. They are biologically important for cells and organisms as gatekeepers for information and molecule transfer across membranes, but each class of membrane proteins can present unique obstacles to structure determination. Historically, many membrane protein structures have been investigated using highly engineered constructs or using larger fusion proteins to improve solubility and/or increase particle size. Other strategies included the deconstruction of the full-length protein to target smaller soluble domains. These manipulations were often required for crystal formation to support X-ray crystallography or to circumvent lower resolution due to high noise and dynamic motions of protein subdomains. However, recent revolutions in membrane protein biochemistry and cryo-electron microscopy now provide an opportunity to solve high resolution structures of both large, >1 megadalton (MDa), and small, <100 kDa (kDa), drug targets in near-native conditions, routinely reaching resolutions around or below 3 Å. This review provides insights into how the recent advances in membrane biology and biochemistry, as well as technical advances in cryo-electron microscopy, help us to solve structures of a large variety of membrane protein groups, from small receptors to large transporters and more complex machineries.

A comparative study of interfacial environments in lipid nanodiscs and vesicles

Membrane protein conformations and dynamics are driven by the protein-lipid interactions occurring within the local environment of the membrane. These environments remain challenging to accurately capture in structural and biophysical experiments using bilayers. Consequently, there is an increasing need for realistic cell-membrane mimetics for in vitro studies. Lipid nanodiscs provide certain advantages over vesicles for membrane protein studies. Nanodiscs are increasingly used for structural and spectroscopic characterization of membrane proteins. Despite the common use of nanodiscs, the interfacial environments of lipids confined to a ~10-nm diameter area have remained relatively underexplored. Here, we use ultrafast two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy and temperature-dependent infrared absorption measurements of the ester carbonyls to compare the interfacial hydrogen bond structure and dynamics in lipid nanodiscs of varying lipid compositions and sizes with ~100-nm vesicles. We examine the effects of lipid composition and nanodisc size. We found that nanodiscs and vesicles share largely similar lipid-water H-bond environments and interfacial dynamics. Differences in measured enthalpies of H-bonding suggest that H-bond dynamics in nanodiscs are modulated by the interaction between the annular lipids and the scaffold protein.

Non-Ionic Inulin-Based Polymer Nanodiscs Enable Functional Reconstitution of a Redox Complex Composed of Oppositely Charged CYP450 and CPR in a Lipid Bilayer Membrane

Although polymer-based lipid nanodiscs are increasingly used in the structural studies of membrane proteins, the charge of the belt-forming polymer is a major limitation for functional reconstitution of membrane proteins possessing an opposite net charge to that of the polymer. This limitation also rules out the reconstitution of a protein-protein complex composed of oppositely charged membrane proteins. In this study, we report the first successful functional reconstitution of a membrane-bound redox complex constituting a cationic cytochrome P450 (CYP450) and an anionic cytochrome P450 reductase (CPR) in non-ionic inulin-based lipid nanodiscs. The gel-to-liquid-crystalline phase-transition temperature (Tm) of DMPC:DMPG (7:3 w/w) lipids in polymer nanodiscs was determined by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and 31P NMR experiments. The CYP450-CPR redox complex reconstitution in polymer nanodiscs was characterized by size-exclusion chromatography (SEC), and the electron transfer kinetics was carried out using the stopped-flow technique under anaerobic conditions. The Tm of DMPC:DMPG (7:3 w/w) in polymer nanodiscs measured from 31P NMR agrees with that obtained from DSC and was found to be higher than that for liposomes due to the decreased cooperativity of lipids present in the nanodiscs. The stopped-flow measurements revealed the CYP450-CPR redox complex reconstituted in nanodiscs to be functional, and the electron transfer kinetics was found to be temperature-dependent. Based on the successful demonstration of the use of non-ionic inulin-based polymer nanodiscs reported in this study, we expect them to be useful in studying the function and structures of a variety of membrane proteins/complexes irrespective of the charge of the molecular components. Since the polymer nanodiscs were shown to align in an externally applied magnetic field, they can also be used to measure residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) and residual quadrupolar couplings (RQCs) for various molecules ranging from small molecules to soluble proteins and nucleic acids.

Comprehensive Collection and Prediction of ABC Transmembrane Protein Structures in the AI Era of Structural Biology

The number of unique transmembrane (TM) protein structures doubled in the last four years, which can be attributed to the revolution of cryo-electron microscopy. In addition, AlphaFold2 (AF2) also provided a large number of predicted structures with high quality. However, if a specific protein family is the subject of a study, collecting the structures of the family members is highly challenging in spite of existing general and protein domain-specific databases. Here, we demonstrate this and assess the applicability and usability of automatic collection and presentation of protein structures via the ABC protein superfamily. Our pipeline identifies and classifies transmembrane ABC protein structures using the PFAM search and also aims to determine their conformational states based on special geometric measures, conftors. Since the AlphaFold database contains structure predictions only for single polypeptide chains, we performed AF2-Multimer predictions for human ABC half transporters functioning as dimers. Our AF2 predictions warn of possibly ambiguous interpretation of some biochemical data regarding interaction partners and call for further experiments and experimental structure determination. We made our predicted ABC protein structures available through a web application, and we joined the 3D-Beacons Network to reach the broader scientific community through platforms such as PDBe-KB.

Native-like environments afford novel mechanistic insights into membrane proteins

Advances in cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) enabled routine near-atomic structure determination of membrane proteins, while nanodisc technology has provided a way to provide membrane proteins with a native or native-like lipid environment. After giving a brief history of membrane mimetics, we present example structures of membrane proteins in nanodiscs that revealed information not provided by structures obtained in detergent. We describe how the lipid environment surrounding the membrane protein can be custom designed during nanodisc assembly and how it can be modified after assembly to test functional hypotheses. Because nanodiscs most closely replicate the physiologic environment of membrane proteins and often afford novel mechanistic insights, we propose that nanodiscs ought to become the standard for structural studies on membrane proteins.

When SWEETs Turn Tweens: Updates and Perspectives

Sugar translocation between cells and between subcellular compartments in plants requires either plasmodesmata or a diverse array of sugar transporters. Interactions between plants and associated microorganisms also depend on sugar transporters. The sugars will eventually be exported transporter (SWEET) family is made up of conserved and essential transporters involved in many critical biological processes. The functional significance and small size of these proteins have motivated crystallographers to successfully capture several structures of SWEETs and their bacterial homologs in different conformations. These studies together with molecular dynamics simulations have provided unprecedented insights into sugar transport mechanisms in general and into substrate recognition of glucose and sucrose in particular. This review summarizes our current understanding of the SWEET family, from the atomic to the whole-plant level. We cover methods used for their characterization, theories about their evolutionary origins, biochemical properties, physiological functions, and regulation. We also include perspectives on the future work needed to translate basic research into higher crop yields.

Biophysical Characterization of Membrane Proteins Embedded in Nanodiscs Using Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy

Proteins embedded in biological membranes perform essential functions in all organisms, serving as receptors, transporters, channels, cell adhesion molecules, and other supporting cellular roles. These membrane proteins comprise ~30% of all human proteins and are the targets of ~60% of FDA-approved drugs, yet their extensive characterization using established biochemical and biophysical methods has continued to be elusive due to challenges associated with the purification of these insoluble proteins. In response, the development of nanodisc techniques, such as nanolipoprotein particles (NLPs) and styrene maleic acid polymers (SMALPs), allowed membrane proteins to be expressed and isolated in solution as part of lipid bilayer rafts with defined, consistent nanometer sizes and compositions, thus enabling solution-based measurements. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) is a relatively simple yet powerful optical microscopy-based technique that yields quantitative biophysical information, such as diffusion kinetics and concentrations, about individual or interacting species in solution. Here, we first summarize current nanodisc techniques and FCS fundamentals. We then provide a focused review of studies that employed FCS in combination with nanodisc technology to investigate a handful of membrane proteins, including bacteriorhodopsin, bacterial division protein ZipA, bacterial membrane insertases SecYEG and YidC, Yersinia pestis type III secretion protein YopB, yeast cell wall stress sensor Wsc1, epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), ABC transporters, and several G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs).

Mechanisms of Formation, Structure, and Dynamics of Lipoprotein Discs Stabilized by Amphiphilic Copolymers: A Comprehensive Review

Amphiphilic copolymers consisting of alternating hydrophilic and hydrophobic units account for a major recent methodical breakthrough in the investigations of membrane proteins. Styrene-maleic acid (SMA), diisobutylene-maleic acid (DIBMA), and related copolymers have been shown to extract membrane proteins directly from lipid membranes without the need for classical detergents. Within the particular experimental setup, they form disc-shaped nanoparticles with a narrow size distribution, which serve as a suitable platform for diverse kinds of spectroscopy and other biophysical techniques that require relatively small, homogeneous, water-soluble particles of separate membrane proteins in their native lipid environment. In recent years, copolymer-encased nanolipoparticles have been proven as suitable protein carriers for various structural biology applications, including cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM), small-angle scattering, and conventional and single-molecule X-ray diffraction experiments. Here, we review the current understanding of how such nanolipoparticles are formed and organized at the molecular level with an emphasis on their chemical diversity and factors affecting their size and solubilization efficiency.

Detergent Alternatives: Membrane Protein Purification Using Synthetic Nanodisc Polymers

The development of styrene maleic acid (SMA) and diisobutylene maleic acid (DIBMA) copolymers provides an alternative to traditional detergent extraction of integral membrane proteins. By inserting into the membrane, these polymers can extract membrane proteins along with lipids in the form of native nanodiscs made by poly(styrene co-maleic anhydride) derivatives. Unlike detergent solubilization, where membrane proteins may lose annular lipids necessary for proper folding and stability, native nanodiscs allow for proteins to reside in the natural lipid environment. In addition, polymer-based nanodiscs can be purified using common chromatography methods similar to protocols established with detergent solubilization purification. Here we describe the solubilization screening and purification of an integral membrane protein using several commercial copolymers.

Lipid Nanodiscs for High-Resolution NMR Studies of Membrane Proteins

Membrane proteins (MPs) play essential roles in numerous cellular processes. Because around 70% of the currently marketed drugs target MPs, a detailed understanding of their structure, binding properties, and functional dynamics in a physiologically relevant environment is crucial for a more detailed understanding of this important protein class. We here summarize the benefits of using lipid nanodiscs for NMR structural investigations and provide a detailed overview of the currently used lipid nanodisc systems as well as their applications in solution-state NMR. Despite the increasing use of other structural methods for the structure determination of MPs in lipid nanodiscs, solution NMR turns out to be a versatile tool to probe a wide range of MP features, ranging from the structure determination of small to medium-sized MPs to probing ligand and partner protein binding as well as functionally relevant dynamical signatures in a lipid nanodisc setting. We will expand on these topics by discussing recent NMR studies with lipid nanodiscs and work out a key workflow for optimizing the nanodisc incorporation of an MP for subsequent NMR investigations. With this, we hope to provide a comprehensive background to enable an informed assessment of the applicability of lipid nanodiscs for NMR studies of a particular MP of interest.

Membrane Sensor Histidine Kinases: Insights from Structural, Ligand and Inhibitor Studies of Full-Length Proteins and Signalling Domains for Antibiotic Discovery

There is an urgent need to find new antibacterial agents to combat bacterial infections, including agents that inhibit novel, hitherto unexploited targets in bacterial cells. Amongst novel targets are two-component signal transduction systems (TCSs) which are the main mechanism by which bacteria sense and respond to environmental changes. TCSs typically comprise a membrane-embedded sensory protein (the sensor histidine kinase, SHK) and a partner response regulator protein. Amongst promising targets within SHKs are those involved in environmental signal detection (useful for targeting specific SHKs) and the common themes of signal transmission across the membrane and propagation to catalytic domains (for targeting multiple SHKs). However, the nature of environmental signals for the vast majority of SHKs is still lacking, and there is a paucity of structural information based on full-length membrane-bound SHKs with and without ligand. Reasons for this lack of knowledge lie in the technical challenges associated with investigations of these relatively hydrophobic membrane proteins and the inherent flexibility of these multidomain proteins that reduces the chances of successful crystallisation for structural determination by X-ray crystallography. However, in recent years there has been an explosion of information published on (a) methodology for producing active forms of full-length detergent-, liposome- and nanodisc-solubilised membrane SHKs and their use in structural studies and identification of signalling ligands and inhibitors; and (b) mechanisms of signal sensing and transduction across the membrane obtained using sensory and transmembrane domains in isolation, which reveal some commonalities as well as unique features. Here we review the most recent advances in these areas and highlight those of potential use in future strategies for antibiotic discovery. This Review is part of a Special Issue entitled “Interactions of Bacterial Molecules with Their Ligands and Other Chemical Agents” edited by Mary K. Phillips-Jones.

The phosphoinositide code is read by a plethora of protein domains

INTRODUCTION

The proteins that decipher nucleic acid- and protein-based information are well known, however, those that read membrane-encoded information remain understudied. Here we report 70 different human, microbial and viral protein folds that recognize phosphoinositides (PIs), comprising the readers of a vast membrane code.

AREAS COVERED

Membrane recognition is best understood for FYVE, PH and PX domains, which exemplify hundreds of PI code readers. Comparable lipid interaction mechanisms may be mediated by kinases, adjacent C1 and C2 domains, trafficking arrestin, GAT and VHS modules, membrane-perturbing annexin, BAR, CHMP, ENTH, HEAT, syntaxin and Tubby helical bundles, multipurpose FERM, EH, MATH, PHD, PDZ, PROPPIN, PTB and SH2 domains, as well as systems that regulate receptors, GTPases and actin filaments, transfer lipids and assembled bacterial and viral particles.

EXPERT OPINION

The elucidation of how membranes are recognized has extended the genetic code to the PI code. Novel discoveries include PIP-stop and MET-stop residues to which phosphates and metabolites are attached to block phosphatidylinositol phosphate (PIP) recognition, memteins as functional membrane protein apparatuses, and lipidons as lipid "codons" recognized by membrane readers. At least 5% of the human proteome senses such membrane signals and allows eukaryotic organelles and pathogens to operate and replicate.

Regulation of the Phosphoinositide Code by Phosphorylation of Membrane Readers

The genetic code that dictates how nucleic acids are translated into proteins is well known, however, the code through which proteins recognize membranes remains mysterious. In eukaryotes, this code is mediated by hundreds of membrane readers that recognize unique phosphatidylinositol phosphates (PIPs), which demark organelles to initiate localized trafficking and signaling events. The only superfamily which specifically detects all seven PIPs are the Phox homology (PX) domains. Here, we reveal that throughout evolution, these readers are universally regulated by the phosphorylation of their PIP binding surfaces based on our analysis of existing and modelled protein structures and phosphoproteomic databases. These PIP-stops control the selective targeting of proteins to organelles and are shown to be key determinants of high-fidelity PIP recognition. The protein kinases responsible include prominent cancer targets, underscoring the critical role of regulated membrane readership.