A global environmental health perspective and optimisation of stress

Glyphosate hormesis stimulates tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) plant growth and enhances tolerance against environmental abiotic stress by triggering nonphotochemical quenching

BACKGROUND

Glyphosate is the most widely applied herbicide in the world. Hormesis caused by low glyphosate doses has been widely documented in many plant species. However, the specific adaptative mechanism of plants responding to glyphosate hormesis stimulation remains unclear. This study focused on the biphasic relationship between glyphosate dose and tomato plant growth, and how glyphosate hormesis stimulates plant growth and enhances tolerance to environmental stress.

RESULTS

We constructed a hormesis model to describe the biphasic relationship with a maximal stimulation (MAX) of 162% above control by glyphosate at 0.063 g ha-1. Low-dose glyphosate increased photosynthetic pigment contents and improve photosynthetic efficiency, leading to plant growth stimulation. We also found that glyphosate hormesis enhanced plant tolerance to diuron (DCMU; a representative photosynthesis inhibitor) by triggering the nonphotochemical chlorophyll fluorescence quenching (NPQ) reaction to dissipate excess energy stress from photosystem II (PSII). Transcriptomic analysis and quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction results revealed that the photosynthesis-antenna proteins pathway was the most sensitive to glyphosate hormesis, and PsbS (encoding photosystem II subunit S), ZEP (encoding zeaxanthin epoxidase) and VDE (encoding violaxanthin de-epoxidase) involved in NPQ played crucial roles in the plant response to glyphosate hormesis.

CONCLUSION

These results provide novel insights into the mechanisms of plant hormesis and is meaningful to the application of glyphosate hormesis in agriculture. © 2024 Society of Chemical Industry.

Current advances and future trends of hormesis in disease

Hormesis, an adaptive response, occurs when exposure to low doses of a stressor potentially induces a stimulatory effect, while higher doses may inhibit it. This phenomenon is widely observed across various organisms and stressors, significantly advancing our understanding and inspiring further exploration of the beneficial effects of toxins at doses both below and beyond traditional thresholds. This has profound implications for promoting biological regulation at the cellular level and enhancing adaptability throughout the biosphere. Therefore, conducting bibliometric analysis in this field is crucial for accurately analyzing and summarizing its current research status. The results of the bibliometric analysis reveal a steady increase in the number of publications in this field over the years. The United States emerges as the leading country in both publication and citation numbers, with the journal Dose-Response publishing the highest number of papers in this area. Calabrese E.J. is a prominent person with significant contributions and influence among authors. Through keyword co-occurrence and trend analysis, current hotspots in this field are identified, primarily focusing on the relationship between hormesis, oxidative stress, and aging. Analysis of highly cited references predicts that future research trends may center around the relationship between hormesis and stress at different doses, as well as exploring the mechanisms and applications of hormesis. In conclusion, this review aims to visually represent hormesis-related research through bibliometric methods, uncovering emerging patterns and areas of focus within the field. It provides a summary of the current research status and forecasts trends in hormesis-related research.

The metabolic mechanisms of Cd-induced hormesis in photosynthetic microalgae, Chromochloris zofingiensis

Cadmium, an environmental pollutant, is highly toxic and resistant to degradation. It exhibits toxicity at elevated doses but triggers excitatory effects at low doses, a phenomenon referred to as hormesis. Microalgae, as primary producers in aquatic ecosystems, demonstrate hormesis induced by cadmium, though the specific mechanisms are not yet fully understood. Consequently, we examined the hormesis of cadmium in Chromochloris zofingiensis. A minimal Cd2+ concentration (0.05 mg L-1) prompted cell proliferation, whereas higher concentrations (2.50 mg L-1) inhibited growth. The group exposed to higher doses exhibited increased levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS), malondialdehyde (MDA), glutathione (GSH), superoxide dismutase (SOD), and catalase (CAT). Contrastingly, the group exposed to low doses exhibited a moderate antioxidant response without significantly increasing ROS. This implies that increased levels of antioxidative components counteract excessive ROS, maintaining cellular redox balance and promoting growth under conditions of low Cd2+. Validation experiments have established that NADPH oxidase-derived ROS primarily coordinates the hormesis effect in microalgae. Comparative transcriptome analysis has proved the involvement of antioxidant systems and photosynthesis in regulating hormesis. Notably, Aurora A kinases consistently displayed varying expression levels across all Cd2+ treatments, and their role in microalgal hormesis was confirmed through validation with SNS-314 mesylate. This study unveils the intricate regulatory mechanisms of Cd-induced hormesis in C. zofingiensis, with implications for environmental remediation and industrial microalgae applications.

The challenges of defining hormesis in epidemiological studies: The case of radiation hormesis

In the current radiation protection system, preventive measures and occupational exposure limits for controlling occupational exposure to ionizing radiation are based on the linear no-threshold extrapolation model. However, currently an increasing body of evidence indicates that this paradigm predicts very poorly biological responses in the low-dose exposure region. In addition, several in vitro and in vivo studies demonstrated the presence of hormetic dose response curves correlated to ionizing radiation low exposure. In this regard, it is noteworthy that also the findings of different epidemiological studies, conducted in different categories of occupationally exposed workers (e.g., healthcare, nuclear industrial and aircrew workers), observed lower rates of mortality and/or morbidity from cancer and/or other diseases in exposed workers than in unexposed ones or in the general population, then suggesting the possible occurrence of hormesis. Nevertheless, these results should be considered with caution since the identification of hormetic response in epidemiological studies is rather challenging because of a number of major limitations. In this regard, some of the most remarkable shortcomings found in epidemiological studies performed in workers exposed to ionizing radiation are represented by lack or inadequate definition of exposure doses, use of surrogates of exposure, narrow dose ranges, lack of proper control groups and poor evaluation of confounding factors. Therefore, considering the valuable role and contribution that epidemiological studies might provide to the complex risk assessment and management process, there is a clear and urgent need to overcome the aforementioned limits in order to achieve an adequate, useful and more real-life risk assessment that should also include the key concept of hormesis. Thus, in the present conceptual article we also discuss and provide possible approaches to improve the capacity of epidemiological studies to identify/define the hormetic response and consequently improve the complex process of risk assessment of ionizing radiation at low exposure doses.

Environmental hormesis in living systems: The role of hormetic trade-offs

Hormesis (low-dose stimulation and high-dose inhibition) can be accompanied by hormetic trade-offs, that is, stimulation of some traits and inhibition (trade-off 1) or invariability (trade-off 2) of others. Currently, trade-off options and their biological significance are insufficiently studied. Therefore, the review analyses trade-off types, their relationship with asynchronous stress responses of indicators, the importance of trade-offs for preconditioning, hormesis transgenerational effects, fitness, and evolution. The analysis has shown that hormetic trade-offs 1 and 2 can be observed in evolutionarily distant groups of organisms and at different biological levels (cells, individuals, populations, and communities) with abiotic and biotic stressors, as well as various pollutants. Trade-offs 1 and 2 are found both between different functional traits (e.g., self-maintenance and reproduction in animals, growth and defense in plants), and between the endpoints of the same functional trait (e.g., seed weight and seed number in plants). Asynchronous responses of indicators to a low-dose stressor can lead to hormetic trade-offs in two cases: 1) these indicators have different responses (hormesis, inhibition or zero reaction) in the same dose range; 2) these indicators have hormetic responses with different hormetic zones. Trade-offs can have a positive, negative or zero effect on preconditioning, offspring, and fitness of the population. Trade-offs can potentially affect evolution in two ways: 1) the creation of trends in genotype selection; 2) participation in the assimilation of phenotypic adaptations in the genotype through the Baldwin effect (selection of mutations copying adaptive phenotypes).

Multi- and trans-generational effects of di-n-octyl phthalate on behavior, lifespan and reproduction of Caenorhabditis elegans through neural regulation and lipid metabolism

Di-n-octyl phthalate (DOP) is one important phthalate analog whose toxicities need comprehensive investigation to fully demonstrate phthalates health risks. In the present study, apical effects of DOP on behavior, lifespan and reproduction and the underlying mechanisms were explored in Caenorhabditis elegans for four consecutive generations (F1 to F4) and the trans-generational effects were also measured in the great-grand-children (T4 and T4') of F1 and F4. Multi-generational results showed that DOP caused both stimulation and inhibition on head swing, body bending, reverse, Omega steering, pharyngeal pump and satiety quiescence. The stimulation and inhibition altered over concentrations and across generations, and the alteration was the greatest in reverse locomotion which showed both concentration-dependent hormesis and trans-hormesis. DOP stimulated lifespan and inhibited reproduction, showing trade-off relationships. Significant trans-generational residual effects were found in T4 and T4' where the exposure was completed eliminated. Moreover, both similar and different effects were found in comparisons between F1 and F4, between F1 and T4, between F4 and T4' and also between T4 and T4'. Further analysis showed close connections between effects of DOP on neurotransmitters (including dopamine, acetylcholine, γ-aminobutyric acid and serotonin) and enzymes in lipid metabolism (including lipase, acetyl CoA carboxylase, fatty acid synthetase, carnitine palmitoyl-transferase, glycerol phosphate acyltransferase and acetyl CoA synthetase). Moreover, the close connections were also found between biochemical and apical effects. Notably, the connections were different in multi- and trans-generational effects, which urged further studies to reveal the response strategies underlying the exposure scenarios.

Thermal Preconditioning Alters the Stability of Hump-Snout Whitefish (Coregonus fluviatilis) and Its Hybrid Form, Showing Potential for Aquaculture

One of the little-studied ways that climate warming or temperature increases in aquaculture could affect aquatic animals is through accelerated aging. This study is dedicated to understanding the principles of molecular and cellular aging in the target tissues of juvenile whitefishes (Yenisei hump-snout whitefish and its hybrid) under the influence of acute heat stress (up to 26 °C), and the effects of thermal preconditioning as pre-adaptation. Non-adapted stressed hump-snout whitefish showed a higher induction threshold for functionally active mitochondria in the blood and a decrease in telomerase activity in the liver after heat shock exposure as a long-term compensatory response to prevent telomere shortening. However, we observed heat-induced telomere shortening in non-adapted hybrids, which can be explained by a decrease in mitochondrial membrane stability and a gradual increase in energy demand, leading to a decrease in protective telomerase activity. The pre-adapted groups of hump-snout whitefish and hybrids showed a long-term or delayed response of telomerase activity to heat shock, which served as a therapeutic mechanism against telomere shortening. We concluded that the telomerase and telomere responses to thermal stress demonstrate plasticity of tolerance limits and greater stability in hump-snout whitefish compared with hybrids.

Toxicity assessment of core-shell and superabsorbent polymers in cell-based systems

The identification of health risks arising from occupational exposure to submicron/nanoscale materials is of particular interest and toxicological investigations designed to assess their hazardous properties can provide valuable insights. The core-shell polymers poly (methyl methacrylate)@poly (methacrylic acid-co-ethylene glycol dimethacrylate) [PMMA@P (MAA-co-EGDMA)] and poly (n-butyl methacrylate-co-ethylene glycol dimethacrylate)@poly (methyl methacrylate) [P (nBMA-co-EGDMA)@PMMA] could be utilized for the debonding of coatings and for the encapsulation and targeted delivery of various compounds. The hybrid superabsorbent core-shell polymers poly (methacrylic acid-co-ethylene glycol dimethacrylate)@silicon dioxide [P (MAA-co-EGDMA)@SiO₂] could be utilized as internal curing agents in cementitious materials. Therefore, the characterization of their toxicological profile is essential to ensure their safety throughout manufacturing and the life cycle of the final products. Based on the above, the purpose of the present study was to assess the acute toxic effects of the above mentioned polymers on cell viability and on cellular redox state in EA. hy926 human endothelial cells and in RAW264.7 mouse macrophages. According to our results, the examined polymers did not cause any acute toxic effects on cell viability after any administration. However, the thorough evaluation of a panel of redox biomarkers revealed that they affected cellular redox state in a cell-specific manner. As regards EA. hy926 cells, the polymers disrupted redox homeostasis and promoted protein carbonylation. Concerning RAW264.7 cells, P (nBMA-co-EGDMA)@PMMA caused disturbances in redox equilibrium and special emphasis was placed on the triphasic dose-response effect detected in lipid peroxidation. Finally, P (MAA-co-EGDMA)@SiO₂ activated cellular adaptive mechanisms in order to prevent from oxidative damage.

Combination of slurry-bioreactors and actinobacteria consortia as strategy to bioremediate chlordane-contaminated soils

Soil contamination caused by pesticides poses a significant environmental challenge, and addressing it requires effective solutions. Bioremediation, combining the utilization of slurry-bioreactors and microbial consortia, emerges as an appropiated strategy to tackle this issue. Therefore, this research evaluated the chlordane (CLD) removal efficiency by a Streptomyces consortium through bioaugmentation of polluted soils, and slurry-bioreactors. For that, a Streptomyces defined consortium with CLD removal abilities was inoculated in soil microcosms and soil-slurry bioreactors (SB), with (SB-TSB) and without stimulation (SB-water). In soil, CLD presence has no negative effect on consortium growth. This was supported by comparing its duplication time (7.48 ± 0.14 h) with the obtained in the biotic control (7.45 ± 0.04 h). Furthermore, 17% of pesticide removal by microbial action was detected in the treated microcosms. In SB, the microbial development was not affected by the pesticide presence. In SB-TSB, the microbial growth was higher than in SB-water. This was supported by its lesser duplication time (7.27 ± 0.17 h) with respect to the non-stimulated systems (10.88 ± 0.29 h). However, SB-water showed the highest CLD removal ability (34.8%), with a concomitant increase in the chloride ion release. In the phytotoxicity test, the vigor index showed that the bioremediation in SB-water did not exert adverse effects greater than those generated by the CLD. Indeed, the root length increased after the treatment. These findings demonstrate the versatility of the Streptomyces consortium to remediate solid and semi-solid matrices impacted with pesticides, and the advantage of using bioaugmented SB to enhance the pollutants removal and accelerating the clean-up time required.

Hormesis effects in tomato plant growth and photosynthesis due to acephate exposure based on physiology and transcriptomic analysis

BACKGROUND

Hormesis is a common phenomenon in toxicology described as low-dose stimulation due to a toxin which causes inhibition at a high dose. Pesticide hormesis in plants has attracted considerable research interest in recent years; however, the specific mechanism has not yet been clarified. Acephate is an organophosphorus insecticide that is used worldwide. Here, hormesis in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) plant growth and photosynthesis after acephate exposure is confirmed, as stimulation occurred at low stress levels, whereas inhibition occurred after exposure to high concentrations.

RESULTS

We found that low acephate concentration (5-fold lower than recommended application dosage) could enhance chlorophyll biosynthesis and stimulate photosynthesis effects, and thus improve S. lycopersicum growth. A high level of acephate (5-fold higher than recommended application dosage) stress inhibited chlorophyll accumulation, decreased photosystem II efficiency and blocked antioxidant reactions in leaves, increasing reactive oxygen species levels and damaging plant growth. Transcriptomic analysis and quantitative real-time PCR results revealed that the photosynthesis - antenna proteins pathway played a crucial role in the hormesis effect, and that LHCB7 as well as LHCP from the pathway were the most sensitive to acephate hormesis.

CONCLUSION

Our results showed that acephate could induce hormesis in tomato plant growth and photosynthesis, and that photosystem II and the photosynthesis - antenna proteins pathway played important roles in hormesis. These results provide novel insights into the scientific and safe application of chemical pesticides, and new guidance for investigation into utilizing pesticide hormesis in agriculture. © 2023 Society of Chemical Industry.

Hormone-mediated multi- and trans-generational reproductive toxicities of 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate on Caenorhabditis elegans

Ionic liquids (ILs) are emergent pollutants and their reproductive toxicities show hormesis, earning attentions on their environmental risk. Yet, their reproductive effects over generations and the mechanisms were seldom explored. In the present study, the reproductive effects of 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate ([C₂mim]PF₆) on Caenorhabditis elegans were measured in 11 continuously exposed generations (F1 to F11) to explore the multi-generational effects, and also in the non-exposed generations of F1 and F11 (i.e., their great-grand-daughters, T4 and T4') to explore the trans-generational effects. In multi-generational reproductive effects, there were concentration-dependent hormetic effects with hazard-benefit alteration between low and high concentrations (e.g., in F3). There were also generation-dependent hormetic effects with hazard-benefit alterations over generations (e.g., between F4 and F5, between F8 and F9, and between F10 and F11). Meanwhile, the results also showed benefit-hazard alteration between F2 and F3, between F6 and F7, and between F9 and F10. Trans-generational effects showed common inhibitions in T4 and T4' at both low and high concentrations. In the biochemical analysis, hormones and hormone-like substances including progesterone (P), estradiol (E2), prostaglandin (PG) and testosterone (T) showed multi- and trans-generational changes with inhibition and stimulation, which contributed to the reproductive outcomes in each generation. Such contribution was also observed in the hormones' precursor cholesterol and the proteins that are essential for reproduction including vitellogenin (Vn) and major sperm protein (MSP). Moreover, the biochemicals showed significant involvement in the connection among generations. Furthermore, the multi- and trans-generational effects of [C₂mim]PF₆ and histidine showed similar modes of actions despite some differences, implying the contribution of their shared imidazole structure.

Glyphosate-based herbicide (GBH) causes damage in embryo-larval stages of zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Glyphosate-Based Herbicides (GBH) show risks to the environment and also to aquatic organisms, such as fish. The present work aimed to evaluate the effects of GBH and Pure Glyphosate (PG) exposure on Danio rerio embryos at drinking water concentrations. Zebrafish embryos were exposed to 250, 500, and 1000 μg L^-1 of Roundup Original DI® and pure glyphosate for 96 h. Glyphosate concentration in water, parameters physicochemical water, survival, hatching rate, heart rate, malformations, behavior, and biomarkers were evaluated. We verified that at 6 h post-fertilization (hpf), animals exposed to GBH 500 showed decreased survival as compared to the control. The hatching rate increased in all groups exposed to GBH at 48 hpf as compared to the control group. The embryos exposed did not present changes in the spontaneous movement and touch response. Exposed groups to GBH demonstrated a higher number of malformations in fish embryos as compared to the control. Most malformations were: pericardial edema, yolk sac edema, body malformations, and curvature of the spine. In heart rate, bradycardia occurred in groups exposed, as predicted due to cardiac abnormalities. As biochemical endpoints, we observed a decrease in Glutathione S-transferase (GBH 250, GBH 500 and PG 250) and Acetylcholinesterase (GBH 250 and PG 250) activity. No differences were found between the groups in the concentration of protein, Total Antioxidant Capacity Against Peroxyl Radicals, Lipid peroxidation, Reactive Oxygen Species, Non-protein thiols, and Catalase. In conclusion, the damage in all evaluated stages of development was aggravated by survival and malformations. Therefore, the large-scale use of GBHs, coupled with the permissiveness of its presence could be the cause damage to the aquatic environment affecting the embryonic development of non-target organisms.

Reproductive toxicities of ofloxacin and norfloxacin on Caenorhabditis elegans with multi-generational oscillatory effects and trans-generational residual influences

The reproductive toxicities over generations are essential to assess the long-term impacts environmental fluoroquinolone antibiotics (FQs). In the present study, the multi-generational effects of ofloxacin (OFL) and norfloxacin (NOR) on reproduction were studied on Caenorhabditis elegans from 9 successive generations (F1-F9). Results showed that OFL showed no effects in F1, stimulation in F2 to F4, and inhibition F5 to F9. The effects of NOR also showed oscillation between stimulation and inhibition across generations. Further biochemical analysis demonstrated that the reproductive toxicities of OFL and NOR were more closely connected with total cholesterol (TCHO), progesterone (P) and testosterone (T), than major sperm protein (MSP) and vitellogenin (Vn). Moreover, OFL and NOR also showed significant trans-generational reproductive toxicities in T4 and T4', the great-grand-daughter of F1 and F9. Differences between T4 and T4' and between OFL and NOR, indicated influences of multi-generational exposure and urged more exploration on different mechanisms between FQs.

Hormetic Effects of Carbendazim on Mycelial Growth and Aggressiveness of Magnaporthe oryzae

Rice blast caused by Magnaporthe oryzae is one of the most destructive fungal diseases of rice worldwide. Stimulatory effects of low doses of fungicides on pathogens are closely relevant to disease management. In the present study, in potato dextrose agar (PDA) amended with carbendazim at a dose range from 0.003 to 0.3 μg/mL, stimulatory effects on the mycelial growth of three isolates sensitive to carbendazim were tested. Carbendazim at concentrations from 0.003 to 0.1 µg/mL showed stimulatory effects on mycelial growth of isolates Guy11 and H08-1a, while carbendazim at concentrations from 0.003 to 0.03 µg/mL stimulated the growth of isolate P131. The maximum stimulation magnitudes were 11.84% for the three isolates tested. Mycelial colonies grown on PDA amended with different concentrations of carbendazim were incubated at 28 °C in darkness for 7 days as the pretreatment. Pretreatment mycelia were inoculated on fresh fungicide-free PDA and subsequent mycelia growth stimulations were still observed, and the maximum stimulation magnitudes were 9.15% for the three isolates tested. Pretreatment mycelia did not significantly change the tolerance to H2O2 and NaCl, except that the tolerance to H2O2 was increased significantly (p < 0.05) when the carbendazim was at 0.3 µg/mL. After five generations of mycelial transference on fungicide-free PDA, the transgenerational hormesis of mycelial were exhibited when transferred onto PDA supplemented with carbendazim at 0.3 µg/mL, and the maximum percent stimulation was 51.28%. The time course of infection indicated that the visible initial necrotic symptoms could be detected at 2 DPI on leaves treated with carbendazim at 0.03 µg/mL, whereas no necrotic symptom could be discerned for the control. Statistical results of lesion area and lesion type at 7 DPI showed that there was a significant stimulation (p < 0.05) on aggressiveness of M. oryzae isolate Guy11 on detached rice leaves at 0.03 µg/mL carbendazim. These results will advance our understanding of hormetic effects of fungicides and provide valuable information for judicious application of fungicides.

Hormesis and insects: Effects and interactions in agroecosystems

Insects in agroecosystems contend with many stressors - e.g., chemicals, heat, nutrient deprivation - that are often encountered at low levels. Exposure to mild stress is now well known to induce hormetic (stimulatory) effects in insects, with implications for insect management, and ecological structure and function in agroecosystems. In this review, we examine the major ecological niches insects occupy or guilds to which they belong in agroecosystems and how hormesis can manifest within and across these groups. The mechanistic underpinnings of hormesis in insects are starting to become established, explaining the many phenotypic hormetic responses observed in insect reproduction, development, and behavior. Whereas potential effects on insect populations are well supported in laboratory experiments, field-based hypothesis-driven research on hormesis is greatly lacking. Furthermore, because most ecological paradigms are founded within the context of communities, entomological agroecologists interested in hormesis need to 'level up' and test hypotheses that explore effects on species interactions, and community structure and functioning. Embedded in this charge is to continue experimentation on herbivorous pest species while shifting more focus towards insect natural enemies, pollinators, and detritivores - guilds that play crucial roles in highly functioning agroecosystems that have been understudied in hormesis research. Important areas for future insect agroecology research on hormesis are discussed.

Hormesis induced by silver iodide, hydrocarbons, microplastics, pesticides, and pharmaceuticals: Implications for agroforestry ecosystems health

Increasing amounts of silver iodide (AgI) in the environment are expected because of the recent massive expansion of weather modification programs. Concurrently, pharmaceuticals, microplastics, hydrocarbons, and pesticides in terrestrial ecosystems continue contaminating forests and agroforests. Our review supports that AgI induces hormesis, a biphasic dose response characterized by often beneficial low-dose responses and toxic high-dose effects, which adds to the evidence for pharmaceuticals, microplastics, hydrocarbons, and pesticides induced hormesis in numerous species. Doses smaller than the no-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL) positively affect defense physiology, growth, biomass, yields, survival, lifespan, and reproduction. They also lead to negative or undesirable outcomes, including stimulation of pathogenic microbes, pest insects, and weeds with enhanced resistance to drugs and potential negative multi- or trans-generational effects. Such sub-NOAEL effects perplex terrestrial ecosystems managements and may compromise combating outbreaks of disease vectors that can threaten not only forest and agroforestry health but also sensitive human subpopulations living in remote forested areas.

Hormetic dose responses induced by organic flame retardants in aquatic animals: Occurrence and quantification

The organic flame retardants (OFRs) have attracted global concerns due to their potential toxicity and ubiquitous presence in the aquatic environment. Hormesis refers to a biphasic dose response, characterized by low-dose stimulation and high-dose inhibition. The present study provided substantial evidence for the widespread occurrence of OFRs-induced hormesis in aquatic animals, including 202 hormetic dose response relationships. The maximum stimulatory response (MAX) was commonly lower than 160% of the control response, with a combined value of 134%. Furthermore, the magnitude of MAX varied significantly among multiple factors and their interactions, such as chemical types and taxonomic groups. Moreover, the distance from the dose of MAX to the no-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL) (NOAEL: MAX) was typically below 10-fold (median = 6-fold), while the width of the hormetic zone (from the lowest dose inducing hormesis to the NOAEL) was approximately 20-fold. Collectively, the quantitative features of OFRs-induced hormesis in aquatic animals were in accordance with the broader hormetic literature. In addition, the implications of hormetic dose response model for the risk assessment of OFRs were discussed. This study offered a novel insight for understanding the biological effects of low-to-high doses of OFRs on aquatic animals and assessing the potential risks of OFRs in the aquatic environment.

Tritium: Doses and Responses of Aquatic Living Organisms (Model Experiments)

Tritium is a byproduct of many radiochemical reactions in the nuclear industry, and its effects on aquatic organisms, particularly low-dose effects, deserve special attention. The low-dose effects of tritium on aquatic microbiota have been intensively studied using luminous marine bacteria as model microorganisms. Low-dose physiological activation has been demonstrated and explained by the signaling role of reactive oxygen species through the “bystander effect” in bacterial suspensions. The activation of microbial functions in natural reservoirs by low tritium concentrations can cause unpredictable changes in food chains and imbalances in the natural equilibrium. The incorporation of tritium from the free form into organically bound compounds mainly occurs in the dark and at a temperature of 25 °C. When tritium is ingested by marine animals, up to 56% of tritium is accumulated in the muscle tissue and up to 36% in the liver. About 50% of tritium in the liver is bound in non-exchangeable forms. Human ingestion of water and food products contaminated with background levels of tritium does not significantly contribute to the total dose load on the human body.

The hormetic response of heart rate of fish embryos to contaminants - Implications for research and policy

Evidence of contaminant-induced hormesis is rapidly accumulating, while the underlying mechanisms of hormesis are becoming increasingly understood. Recent developments in this research area, and especially the emergence of the nuclear factor-erythroid factor 2-related factor 2 (Nrf2) as the master mechanism, suggest that contaminants can induce cardiac hormetic responses. This paper collates significant evidence of hormetic response of the heart rate of fish embryos to contaminants, in particular antibiotics, microplastics, and herbicides, characterized by a low-dose increase (tachycardia) and a high-dose decrease (bradycardia). The increase often occurs at doses about 100-800 times smaller than the no-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL). There are also indications for even triphasic responses, which include a sub-hormetic decrease of the heart rate by doses over 10⁶ times smaller than the NOAEL. Such sub-NOAEL effects cannot be captured by linear-no-threshold (LNT) and threshold models, raising concerns about environmental health and highlighting the pressing need to consider hormetic responses in the ecological risk assessment. A visionary way forward is proposed, but addressing this research bottleneck would require improved research designs with enhanced ability and statistical power to study diphasic and triphasic responses of heart rate.

Intermittent multi-generational effects of 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium nitrate on Caenorhabditis elegans mediated by lipid metabolism

Ionic liquids (ILs) become environmental pollutants. Their environmental toxicities included inhibitory effects, stimulatory ones and hormesis combining both aspects on various organisms. However, the mechanisms still need systematic investigations. Presently, 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium nitrate ([Hmim]NO₃) was chosen as one representative IL. Its effects on lifespan and reproduction were studied on C. elegans with lipid metabolism as the potential mechanism. Two types (A and B) intermittent multi-generational exposure arrangements were set up to mimic realistic ILs exposure scenarios. Type A arrangement had exposure in F1, F5 and F9 with recovery in T2-T4, T6-T8 and T10-T12, and type B arrangement had exposure in F1, F3, F5, F7, F9 and F11 with recovery in T2, T4, T6, T8, T10 and T12. In type A exposure, the effects of [Hmim]NO₃ on reproduction were 1.32-, 1.68-, 1.23-, 0.96-, 1.68-, 1.07-, 1.25-, 1.64-, 1.31-, 1.11-, 0.89- and 1.02-fold of the control in F1, T2-T4, F5, T6-T8, F9, T10-T12, respectively. The results showed oscillation between stimulatory and inhibitory effects. In type B exposure, the effects showed fewer inhibitions and more stimulations across generations. Moreover, the effects on reproduction showed trade-off relationships with lifespan, and the trade-off was more obvious in type B exposure. Further biochemical and gene expression analysis showed that lipid metabolism was closely related with lifespan and reproduction in type A exposure, but it was connected with cholesterol synthesis in type B exposure. The results demonstrated different strategies in the biological responses to the two arrangements of intermittent multi-generational exposure.

Environmental hormesis of non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms in plants

Adaptive responses of plants are important not only for local processes in populations and communities but also for global processes in the biosphere through the primary production of ecosystems. In recent years, the concept of environmental hormesis has been increasingly used to explain the adaptive responses of living organisms, including plants, to low doses of natural factors, both abiotic and biotic, as well as various anthropogenic impacts. However, the issues of whether plant hormesis is similar/different when it is induced by mild stressors having different specific effects and what is the contribution of hormetic stimulation of non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms in plant resilience to strong stressors (i.e., preconditioning) remains unclear. This paper analyses hormetic stimulation of non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms in plants and its significance for preconditioning, the phenomenon of the hormetic trade-off for these mechanisms, and the position of hormetic stimulation of non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms in the system of plant adaptations to environmental challenges. The analysis has shown that both non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms of plants can be stimulated hormetically by mild stressors and are important for plant preconditioning. Due to limited plant resources, non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms have hormetic trades-offs 1 (hormesis accompanied by the deterioration of some plant traits) and 2 (hormesis of some plant traits with the invariability of others). At the same time, hormetic trade-off 2 is observed much more often than hormetic trade-off 1, at least, this was demonstrated here for non-specific adaptive responses of plants. The hormetic stimulation of non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms is part of the inducible adaptation of plants caused by stress factors and is an adaptation to random (unpredictable) changes in the environment.

Multi-generational effects of enrofloxacin on lifespan and reproduction of Caenorhabditis elegans with SKN-1-mediated antioxidant responses and lipid metabolism disturbances

Antibiotics are ubiquitous environmental pollutants and they can provoke multi-generational impacts due to their pseudo-persistence. However, their multi-generational effects and potential mechanisms remained poorly studied. Presently, effects of enrofloxacin (ENR) were studied on Caenorhabditis elegans with a continuous exposure over 9 generations (from F1 to F9) at an environmentally realistic level. Regarding reproduction, ENR showed stimulation in F1 (1.18-fold of the control) and F2 (1.08), inhibition in F3 (0.70), stimulation in F4 (1.86), F5 (3.18) and F6 (1.53), inhibition in F7 (0.73) and F8 (0.69) and stimulation again in F9 (1.89). That is to say, ENR provoked multi-generational oscillatory effects on the reproduction. Such oscillation was also observed in effects on lifespan with much less magnitudes than those on reproduction. Biochemical assays were performed in F1, F3, F4 and F9 which represented the oscillation over generations. Results showed more antioxidants (e.g., superoxide dismutase and glutathione), mild oxidative stress (e.g., reactive oxygen species) and less oxidative damage (i.e., protein carbonyl) underlying the generation-dependent stimulation. Moreover, ENR provoked multi-generational oscillation on the enzymes that regulate the lipogenesis (e.g., fatty acid synthase and acetyl-CoA carboxylase) and lipolysis (e.g., acyl-CoA synthetase), with similarities to the effects on the oxidative stress and damage. Further analysis on SKN-1 and its activating PMK-1 and GSK-3 demonstrated their involvement in regulating both antioxidant detoxification and lipid metabolism.

Disinfectant-induced hormesis: An unknown environmental threat of the application of disinfectants to prevent SARS-CoV-2 infection during the COVID-19 pandemic?

Massive additional quantities of disinfectants have been applied during the COVID-19 pandemic as infection preventive and control measures. While the application of disinfectants plays a key role in preventing the spread of SARS-CoV-2 infection, the effects of disinfectants applied during the ongoing pandemic on non-target organisms remain unknown. Here we collated evidence from multiple studies showing that chemicals used for major disinfectant products can induce hormesis in various organisms, such as plants, animal cells, and microorganisms, when applied singly or in mixtures, suggesting potential ecological risks at sub-threshold doses that are normally considered safe. Among other effects, sub-threshold doses of disinfectant chemicals can enhance the proliferation and pathogenicity of pathogenic microbes, enhancing the development and spread of drug resistance. We opine that hormesis should be considered when evaluating the effects and risks of such disinfectants, especially since the linear-no-threshold (LNT) and threshold dose-response models cannot identify or predict their effects.

A method for assessing the frequency of hormetic trade-offs in plants

Hormesis is a biphasic response to stress, involving low-dose stimulation and high-dose inhibition. Currently, attempts are being made to use the hormetic stimulation of plant parameters to increase resilience to severe stress. However, due to hormetic trade-offs, low-dose stress does not always cause synchronous improvement of different plant parameters. Some parameters do not change and even some even worsen compared to the control. Therefore, there is a need to evaluate the frequency of hormetic trade-offs. In this study, a method for estimating the probabilities of two types of hormetic trade-off in plants was developed. This method is intended solely to improve the scientific understanding of plant hormesis and a first step towards a more extensive evaluation of hormetic trade-offs in plants.•The proposed method estimates the probabilities of hormetic trade-offs 1 and 2 in plants using simple calculations.•This method can be applied to estimate the probability of hormetic trade-offs 1 and 2 both for a set of independent experiments and in a single experiment.•This method could be used in the future to identify doses and factors that stimulate the greatest number of traits without worsening others.

Hormetic dose responses induced by antibiotics in bacteria: A phantom menace to be thoroughly evaluated to address the environmental risk and tackle the antibiotic resistance phenomenon

The environmental contamination of antibiotics caused by their over or inappropriate use is a major issue for environmental and human health since it can adversely impact the ecosystems and promote the antimicrobial resistance. Indeed, considering that in the environmental matrices these drugs are present at low levels, the possibility that bacteria exhibit a hormetic response to increase their resilience when exposed to antibiotic subinhibitory concentrations might represent a serious threat. Information reported in this review showed that exposure to different types of antibiotics, either administered individually or in mixtures, is capable of exerting hormetic effects on bacteria at environmentally relevant concentrations. These responses have been reported regardless of the type of bacterium or antibiotic, thus suggesting that hormesis would be a generalized adaptive mechanism implemented by bacteria to strengthen their resistance to antibiotics. Hormetic effects included growth, bioluminescence and motility of bacteria, their ability to produce biofilm, but also the frequency of mutation and plasmid conjugative transfer. The evaluation of quantitative features of antibiotic-induced hormesis showed that these responses have both maximum stimulation and dose width characteristics similar to those already reported in the literature for other stressors. Notably, mixtures comprising individual antibiotic inducing stimulatory responses might have distinct combined effects based on antagonistic, synergistic or additive interactions between components. Regarding the molecular mechanisms of action underlying the aforementioned effects, we put forward the hypothesis that the adoption of adaptive/defensive responses would be driven by the ability of antibiotic low doses to modulate the transcriptional activity of bacteria. Overall, our findings suggest that hormesis plays a pivotal role in affecting the bacterial behavior in order to acquire a survival advantage. Therefore, a proactive and effective risk assessment should necessarily take due account of the hormesis concept to adequately evaluate the risks to ecosystems and human health posed by antibiotic environmental contamination.

Biostimulant Capacity of an Enzymatic Extract From Rice Bran Against Ozone-Induced Damage in Capsicum annum

Ozone is a destructive pollutant, damaging crops, and decreasing crop yield. Therefore, there is great interest in finding strategies to alleviate ozone-induced crop losses. In plants, ozone enters leaves through the stomata and is immediately degraded into reactive oxygen species (ROS), producing ROS stress in plants. ROS stress can be controlled by ROS-scavenging systems that include enzymatic or non-enzymatic mechanisms. Our research group has developed a product from rice bran, a by-product of rice milling which has bioactive molecules that act as an antioxidant compound. This product is a water-soluble rice bran enzymatic extract (RBEE) which preserves all the properties and improves the solubility of proteins and the antioxidant components of rice bran. In previous works, the beneficial properties of RBEE have been demonstrated in animals. However, to date, RBEE has not been used as a protective agent against oxidative damage in agricultural fields. The main goal of this study was to investigate the ability of RBEE to be used as a biostimulant by preventing oxidative damage in plants, after ozone exposure. To perform this investigation, pepper plants (Capsicum annuum) exposed to ozone were treated with RBEE. RBEE protected the ozone-induced damage, as revealed by net photosynthetic rate and the content of photosynthetic pigments. RBEE also decreased the induction of antioxidant enzyme activities in leaves (catalase, superoxide dismutase, and ascorbate peroxidase) due to ozone exposure. ROS generation is a common consequence of diverse cellular traumas that also activate the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) cascade. Thus, it is known that the ozone damages are triggered by the MAPK cascade. To examine the involvement of the MAPK cascade in the ozone damage CaMPK6-1, CaMPK6-2, and CaMKK5 genes were analyzed by qRT-PCR. The results showed the involvement of the MAPK pathway in both, not only in ozone damage but especially in its protection by RBEE. Taken together, these results support that RBEE protects plants against ozone exposure and its use as a new biostimulant could be proposed.

A gift from parent to offspring: transgenerational hormesis

Hormesis is a biological phenomenon characterized by opposite effects between low and high doses of stresses that can result in stimulatory and adaptive benefits to individuals within a population. While evidence of hormesis is well established, two recent studies (Nogueira et al., Belz and Sinkkonen) suggest that hormesis can also offer transgenerational benefit.

Multi- and trans-generational disturbances of perfluorobutane sulfonate and perfluorohexane sulfonate on lipid metabolism in Caenorhabditis elegans

Short-chained perfluorobutane sulfonate (PFBS, four-carbon) and perfluorohexane sulfonate (PFHxS, six-carbon) are widely employed to substitute long-chained per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFASs). Recent studies showed the potential persistence of PFBS and PFHxS, and also reported their correlation with obesity. However, the long-term outcome and underlying mechanisms remained poorly understood. Presently, the effects of PFBS and PFHxS were studied on C. elegans with multi- and trans-generational experiments. The multi-generational effects were measured in continuous four generational exposure (i.e., F1 to F4). Results showed that PFBS did not stimulate the fat content in F1 but in F4 with continuous but different disturbances on the lipid metabolism and the insulin and insulin-like (IIS) pathway. PFHxS stimulated the fat content in F1 and F4 with similar disturbances on the lipid metabolism and IIS pathway. The trans-generational results showed that the effects of PFBS and PFHxS on the lipid metabolism and IIS pathway were not totally recovered in the offspring of F1 (i.e., T1-T3) and F4 (i.e., T1'-T3') which were not continuously exposed. PFHxS showed a common pattern to up-regulate daf-7 in both multi- and trans-generational effects. The long-term consequences of the short-chained PFASs substitutes should be concerned and epigenetic regulations should be considered in future mechanism studies.

Do nanoparticles cause hormesis? Early physiological compensatory response in house crickets to a dietary admixture of GO, Ag, and GOAg composite

This study aimed to identify the physiological responses of house cricket females following short-term exposure to relatively low dietary doses of graphene oxide (GO, 20 μg · g^-1 food), silver (Ag, 400 μg · g^-1 food) nanoparticles (NPs), or graphene oxide‑silver nanoparticle composite (GO-AgNPs, 20: 400 μg · g^-1 food). Energy intake and distribution were measured on the third, sixth, and tenth day. A semi-quantitative API®ZYM assay of digestive enzyme fingerprints was performed on the third and tenth day of continuous treatment. Physicochemical properties of the NPs were obtained by combining SEM, EDX spectrometry, AFM, and DLS techniques. The obtained results showed decreased energy consumption, particularly assimilation as an early response to dietary NPs followed by compensatory changes in feeding activity leading to the same consumption and assimilation throughout the experimental period (10 days). The increased activities of digestive enzymes in NP-treated females compared to the control on the third day of the experiment suggest the onset of compensatory reactions of the day. Moreover, the insects treated with GO-AgNP composite retained more body water, suggesting increased uptake. The observed changes in the measured physiological parameters after exposure to NPs are discussed in light of hormesis.

Hormetic dose-responses for silver antibacterial compounds, quorum sensing inhibitors, and their binary mixtures on bacterial resistance of Escherichia coli

Silver antibacterial compounds (SACs) and quorum sensing inhibitors (QSIs), as the potential antibiotic substitutes, have been recommended to prevent and treat microbial infections for the purpose of controlling the increasingly serious bacterial resistance induced by the abuse of antibiotics. However, there is little information regarding the resistance risk of these compounds, especially their mixtures. In this study, bacterial mutation and RP4 plasmid conjugative transfer among bacteria were used to characterize the bacterial endogenous and exogenous resistance, respectively. The effects of SACs (including silver nitrate (AgNO₃) and silver nanoparticle (AgNP)), QSIs, and their binary mixtures on the bacterial resistance were investigated via setting the frequency of mutation and conjugative transfer in Escherichia coli (E. coli) as the test endpoints. The results indicated that these two endpoints exhibited hormetic dose-responses to each treatment. Furthermore, the joint resistance actions between SACs and QSIs were all judged to be antagonism. Correlation analysis suggested that the promotion of the bacterial resistance in each treatment was closely related to its toxicity. It was speculated that AgNO₃ and AgNP might both release Ag⁺ ions to facilitate the E. coli resistance, while QSIs probably acted on LsrR and SdiA proteins to stimulate the bacterial mutation and accelerate the RP4 plasmid conjugative transfer, respectively. These findings imply that the bacteria may generate targeted stress response to the survival pressure from environmental compounds, displaying hormetic phenomenon in resistance-related test endpoints. This study provides a new insight into the resistance risk induced by SACs and QSIs, benefiting the environmental risk assessment of these compounds from the perspective of bacterial resistance.

Micro/nanoplastics effects on organisms: A review focusing on 'dose'

Microplastics have become predominant contaminants, attracting much political and scientific attention. Despite the massively-increasing research on microplastics effects on organisms, the debate of whether environmental concentrations pose hazard and risk continues. This study critically reviews published literatures of microplastics effects on organisms within the context of "dose". It provides substantial evidence of the common occurrence of threshold and hormesis dose responses of numerous aquatic and terrestrial organisms to microplastics. This finding along with accumulated evidence indicating the capacity of organisms for recovery suggests that the linear-no-threshold model is biologically irrelevant and should not serve as a default model for assessing the microplastics risks. The published literature does not provide sufficient evidence supporting the general conclusion that environmental doses of microplastics cause adverse effects on individual organisms. Instead, doses that are smaller than the dose of toxicological threshold and more likely to occur in the environment may even induce positive effects, although the ecological implications of these responses remain unknown. This study also shows that low doses of microplastics can reduce whereas high doses can increase the negative effects of other pollutants. The mechanisms explaining these findings are discussed, providing a novel perspective for evaluating the risks of microplastics in the environment.

US EPA: Is there room to open a new window for evaluating potential sub-threshold effects and ecological risks?

With a rule published on 6 January 2021, the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) considers for the first time sub-threshold responses, abandoning the use of default dose-response models. This may affect worldwide scientific research, in terms of research design and methodology, and regulatory actions in China and other countries.

Evidence-based meta-analysis of the genotoxicity induced by microplastics in aquatic organisms at environmentally relevant concentrations

Microplastics (MPs) attract global concern due to their ubiquitous existence in aquatic environments. However, the genotoxic effect of MPs on aquatic organisms in the natural environment remains controversial. Therefore, this meta-analysis was conducted by recompiling 44 individual studies from 12 publications to determine whether MPs could induce genotoxicity in aquatic organisms at environmentally relevant concentrations (≤1 mg/L, median = 0.5 mg/L). Multiple genotoxic endpoints were involved, including the percentage of DNA in tail (TDNA%), tail length (TL), olive tail moment (OTM), and the number of micronuclei (NM), and their increases represented the biologically adverse effects (i.e. genotoxicity). The results showed that all included endpoints tended to increase after exposure to MPs, among which TDNA%, TL and NM were significantly increased by 20%, 32% and 81% compared with the control group, respectively. The overall estimate of all endpoints in the MPs-treated groups was remarkably increased by 24%, with high statistical power and no obvious publication bias, suggesting the evident genotoxicity caused by MPs. In addition, the magnitudes of MPs-induced genotoxicity were independent of selected endpoint, MP composition, morphology, exposure concentration and duration, but closely correlated with particle size, living habitat and tested species. Overall, this work provided a reference for the health risk assessment of MPs in the natural environment, contributing to our understanding the action mode of MPs at environmentally relevant concentrations.

Measurement and modeling of hormesis in soil bacteria and fungi under single and combined treatments of Cd and Pb

Heavy metals are considered major environmental pollutants. Soil microorganisms represent a predominant component of soils ecosystems, yet there is little information regarding hormetic responses of soil microorganisms to single and combined exposures to heavy metals. In the present study, to explore and predict the hormetic response of soil microorganisms, dose-response relationships of bacterial and fungal populations to single and combined treatments of cadmium (Cd) and lead (Pb) were evaluated. The results revealed hormetic responses of bacterial and fungal populations to both single and combined Cd and Pb treatments. The maximum stimulation (M_max; relative to control treatment with no metals) of bacterial and fungal populations was 40% at 2 mg Cd/kg and 60% at 160 mg Pb/kg. An enhanced M_max occurred in bacterial (50%) and fungal (75%) populations in the presence of the binary mixtures of 0.6 mg Cd/kg + 160 mg Pb/kg and 4.0 mg Cd/kg + 200 mg Pb/kg, suggesting positive additivity. This study showed that the hormetic effects of the mixtures were related to the independent effect of Cd and Pb, but they could not be predicted by the single effect of Cd or Pb. These new findings of the hormetic response of soil microorganisms to single treatments of Cd and Pb and their binary mixtures can facilitate the determination and minimization of ecological risks in heavy metal-polluted soils.

Dose-dependent responses of metabolism and tissue injuries in clam Ruditapes philippinarum after subchronic exposure to cadmium

Marine cadmium (Cd) pollution has been globally occurring, which creates a pressing need to characterize toxicological effects and develop biomarkers for Cd. However, the dose-response relationships challenge toxicity characterization and biomarkers selection. Metabolic processes have been frequently targeted by Cd. In this work, we investigated the dose-dependent effects of Cd on metabolic endpoints in whole soft tissues as well as gill and hepatopancreas injuries in clam Ruditapes philippinarum, aiming to better understand the metabolic responses and develop biomarkers. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR)-based metabolomic analysis was conducted on clam whole soft tissues to identify metabolites. The enzymes and metabolites associated with tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle, glycolysis, and oxidative phosphorylation showed both monotonic and non-monotonic curves with the increase of Cd dose. In details, glutamine, glucose-1-phosphate, hexokinase (HK), and citrate synthase (CS) presented monotonic decreases with the increase of Cd dose, among which glutamine and CS were preferable biomarkers to Cd exposure based on lower benchmark dose (BMD) values. The monotonic decreases of HK and CS activities suggested Cd exposure potentially disrupted glycolysis and TCA cycle via inhibiting rate-limiting enzymes. In contrast, the non-monotonic responses of succinate dehydrogenase (SDH), alanine aminotransferase (ALT), and their substrates (succinate and alanine) were approximate to U- or J-shaped curves, suggesting the adaptive strategy of metabolic responses to different degrees of Cd stress, like induction of anaerobiosis as energy compensation. Especially, the alterations of succinate and SDH presented typical hormetic dose-response curves. What is more, clam hepatopancreas was more sensitive to Cd than gill in terms of injury occurrence. Overall, characterization of dose-dependent effect of Cd on metabolism and tissue injuries provides a new insight into understanding the metabolic adaptation in marine clams and risk assessment of Cd pollution.

Multi- and trans-generational effects of N-butylpyridium chloride on reproduction, lifespan, and pro/antioxidant status in Caenorhabditis elegans

Ionic liquids (ILs) became emerging pollutants. Their poor degradation and accumulation in organisms urged studies on the long-term effects and also the underlying mechanisms. Currently, 1-butylpyrinium chloride ([bpyr]Cl) was chosen to represent the pyridine-based ILs. Its multi-generational effects were measured on C. elegans for 14 consecutive generations (F1 to F14), and the trans-generational effects were also measured in the great-grand-children (T3 and T3') of F1 and F14. The multi-generational results from F1 to F14 showed that the effects of [bpyr]Cl on the initial and total reproduction and lifespan showed oscillation between inhibition and stimulation. Notably, hormetic effects on reproduction were observed in F7 to F10. The trans-generational effects in T3 and T3' showed different residual consequences between one generational exposure (F1) and multiple generational exposure (F14). Further biochemical analysis showed that the pro/antioxidant status also showed oscillation between inhibition and stimulation. The oscillation levels were greater in superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase (CAT) and protein carbonyl content (PC) than those in glutathione peroxidase (GSH-Px), reactive oxygen species (ROS) and hydroxyl radical (OH). The pro/antioxidant status contributed to both multi- and trans-generational effects of [bpyr]Cl. Future studies should pay attentions to the long-term influence of ILs and also epigenetic explanations.

Hormetic Effects of Dimethachlone on Mycelial Growth and Virulence of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum

Fungicide hormesis has implications for the application of fungicides to control plant diseases. We investigated the hormetic effects of the dicarboximide fungicide dimethachlone on mycelial growth and virulence of the necrotrophic plant pathogen Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. Dimethachlone at sublethal doses in potato dextrose agar (PDA) increased the mycelial growth of S. sclerotiorum. After the growth-stimulated mycelia were subcultured on fresh PDA and inoculated on rapeseed leaves, increased mycelial growth and virulence were observed, indicating that hormetic traits were passed down to the next generation. Dimethachlone applied to leaves at 0.002 to 500 μg/ml stimulated virulence, with a maximum stimulation amplitude (MSA) of 31.4% for the isolate HLJ4, which occurred at 2 μg/ml. Dimethachlone-resistant isolates and transformants had a mean virulence MSA of 30.4%, which was significantly higher (P = 0.008) than the MSA for sensitive isolates (16.2%). Negative correlations were detected between MSA and virulence in the absence of any fungicide (r = -0.872, P < 0.001) and between MSA and mycelial growth on PDA (r = -0.794, P = 0.002). Studies on hormetic mechanisms indicated that dimethachlone had no significant effects on expression levels of three virulence-associated genes, that is, a cutinase-encoding gene SsCut, a polygalacturonase gene SsPG1, or an oxaloacetate acetylhydrolase gene SsOah1. The results will contribute to understanding hormesis and have implications for the judicious application of fungicides to control plant diseases.

Toxicity and Antioxidant Activity of Fullerenol C60,70 with Low Number of Oxygen Substituents

Fullerene is a nanosized carbon structure with potential drug delivery applications. We studied the bioeffects of a water-soluble fullerene derivative, fullerenol, with 10-12 oxygen groups (F10-12); its structure was characterized by IR and XPS spectroscopy. A bioluminescent enzyme system was used to study toxic and antioxidant effects of F10-12 at the enzymatic level. Antioxidant characteristics of F10-12 were revealed in model solutions of organic and inorganic oxidizers. Low-concentration activation of bioluminescence was validated statistically in oxidizer solutions. Toxic and antioxidant characteristics of F10-12 were compared to those of homologous fullerenols with a higher number of oxygen groups:F24-28 and F40-42. No simple dependency was found between the toxic/antioxidant characteristics and the number of oxygen groups on the fullerene’s carbon cage. Lower toxicity and higher antioxidant activity of F24-28 were identified and presumptively attributed to its higher solubility. An active role of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in the bioeffects of F10-12 was demonstrated. Correlations between toxic/antioxidant characteristics of F10-12 and ROS content were evaluated. Toxic and antioxidant effects were related to the decrease in ROS content in the enzyme solutions. Our results reveal a complexity of ROS effects in the enzymatic assay system.

Influences of sex, rhythm and generation on the obesogenic potential of erythromycin to Drosophila melanogaster

Antibiotics are gaining attention due to their roles as emerging pollutants and environmental obesogens, yet several aspects between their environmental exposure and obesogenic influence on organisms remain poorly explored. Here, Drosophila melanogaster were exposed to erythromycin (ERY, 0.1 μg/L) for three consecutive generations (F1 to F3). Body weight, circadian rhythm (represented by eclosion timing) and lipid metabolism were measured. ERY increased the size of lipid droplets in larvae of all three generations. It modestly inhibited body weight in adults that abnormally eclosed in the morning (AM adults) in the F1 and F2 generations, and the inhibition was less in adults that eclosed in the afternoon (PM adults). In contrast, it stimulated body weight in F3 adults. Notably, ERY promoted morning eclosion of females. Combining the effects from F1 to F3, acyl-CoA oxidase (ACO) was commonly increased in AM female and male adults and also in PM female ones, while it was commonly decreased in PM male adults. Glucokinase (GCK) was commonly increased in both sexes of AM adults but decreased in PM male adults across generations. The IIS pathway showed a common up-regulation in the AM adults despite some differences between sexes, but it did not show any shared changes in the PM adults with dysrhythmia. The AMPK pathway was involved across generations without particular shared changes. Collectively, the effects of ERY on the key metabolites and enzymes in glucolipid metabolism and the genetic regulations depended on sex, rhythm and exposure generation.

Feeding partridges with organic or conventional grain triggers cascading effects in life-history traits

Farmland birds are declining across Europe and North America and the research of factors behind is the subject of extensive researches. Agricultural intensification is now recognized as a major factor governing the loss of biodiversity with strong evidence that pesticides induced direct bird mortality at a high dose. However, less attention has been given to the long-term effects of chronic exposure to low dose of pesticides. Here, we used an experimental procedure in which grey partridges were fed with untreated grains obtained from either organic (no pesticide) or conventional agriculture (with pesticide) for 26 weeks, thus strictly mimicking wild birds foraging on fields. We then examined a suite of life-history traits (ecophysiological and behavioural) that may ultimately, influence population dynamics. We show for the first time that ingesting low pesticide doses over a long period has long-term consequences on several major physiological pathways without inducing differential mortality. Compared to control partridges, birds exposed to chronic doses i) had less developed carotenoid-based ornaments due to lower concentrations of plasmatic carotenoids, ii) had higher activated immune system, iii) showed signs of physiological stress inducing a higher intestinal parasitic load, iv) had higher behavioural activity and body condition and v) showed lower breeding investment. Our results are consistent with a hormetic effect, in which exposure to a low dose of a chemical agent may induce a positive response, but our results also indicate that breeding adults may show impaired fitness traits bearing population consequences through reduced breeding investment or productivity. Given the current scale of use of pesticides in agrosystems, we suggest that such shifts in life-history traits may have a negative long-term impact on wild bird populations across agrosystems. We stress that long-term effects should no longer be ignored in pesticide risk assessment, where currently, only short-term effects are taken into account.

Detrimental effects of 6 months exposure to very low doses of a mixture of six pesticides associated with chronic vitamin deficiency on rats

This study aimed to evaluate the long-term low-dose effects of exposure to a mixture of 6 pesticide active substances (diquat, imazamox, imazethapyr, tepraloxydin, bentazone, acifluorfen) and to elucidate if chronic vitamin deficiency can influence their toxicity. Two hundred Wistar rats were divided in 4 groups: a vitamin-sufficiency control group, a vitamin-deficiency control group, a vitamin sufficiency test group and a vitamin-deficiency test group. The test groups were treated with the aforementioned pesticides at doses 100 times lower than the corresponding NOAEL. After 6 months, ten rats from each group were sacrificed and a complete evaluation of blood and urine biochemistry, biomarkers of oxidative stress, xenobiotic detoxification enzymes and lysosomal enzymes and organ histopathology was performed. The pesticides mixture and vitamin deficiency determined an increase in alkaline phosphatase levels and urinary calcium levels, abnormal serum lipid profile, and a decrease of total blood proteins levels, red blood cells, haematocrit and haemoglobin. The combination of the two stressors up-regulated CYP1A1, CYP1A2, CYP2B1 and GST levels. This study provides a new proof for the need to move forward from single chemical testing to a more complex approach to account for the multitude of stressors that can challenge the setting of real safety levels.