Tubby-like protein 1 as an autoantigen in cancer-associated retinopathy

Correlation of Anti-TULP1 Autoantibodies with Breast Cancer and Autoimmune Retinopathy

Autoantibodies have been implicated in the pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases, including autoimmune retinopathies. Our study aimed to identify retinal autoantigens recognized by serum autoantibodies (AAbs) in patients with visual disturbance. We evaluated 2453 serum samples for anti-retinal AAbs from patients with or without cancer and complaints of visual loss. Anti-TULP1 AAbs were more prevalent in the subset of women with breast cancer and vision loss. Epitope mapping was determined by ELISA using peptides covering the conservative carboxy terminal of TULP1, revealing major lineal epitopes within the sequences 334-341 and 480-488. We found no significant difference in the main epitope recognition between sera from patients with or without breast cancer. Although we show a correlation of anti-TULP1 AAbs with breast cancer, we found no TULP1 protein expression in breast cells, making this association unclear. In the retina, anti-TULP1 AAbs can disrupt the transport of proteins to outer segments and be involved in the degeneration of photoreceptors in a similar fashion to the degeneration induced by TULP1 gene mutation. Nevertheless, the strong association of detectable anti-TULP1 AAbs in breast cancer patients with vision problems indicates its potential as a biomarker for cancer-associated autoimmune retinopathy.

Plasma Antiretinal Autoantibody Profiling and Diagnostic Efficacy in Patients With Autoimmune Retinopathy

PURPOSE

To evaluate plasma antiretinal autoantibody (ARA) profiling and diagnostic efficacy for autoimmune retinopathy (AIR).

DESIGN

A multicenter, diagnostic evaluation study.

METHODS

Forty-nine patients with a clinical diagnosis of AIR, disease controls including 20 patients with retinitis pigmentosa (RP), and 30 normal controls were included. Plasma samples from patients were analyzed for the presence of 6 ARAs, including recoverin, α-enolase, carbonic anhydrase II, heat shock protein 60, aldolase C, and cone-rod homeobox/cone-rod retinal dystrophy 2 using western blotting.

RESULTS

Autoantibody detection rates against cone-rod homeobox/cone-rod retinal dystrophy 2, heat shock protein 60, and aldolase C in AIR were 67.3%, 40.8%, and 42.9%, respectively, which were higher than those in RP and normal controls (P < .001, P < .001, and P = .007, respectively), but recoverin, α-enolase, and carbonic anhydrase II were not different from other control groups (P = .117, P = .774, and P = .467, respectively). Among ARAs, antirecoverin antibody was the most specific, as it was found in 3 (6.1%) patients with AIR and none of the control groups. As the number of detected ARAs increased, the probability of AIR increased (odds ratio: 1.913; P < .001; 95% confidence interval: 1.456-2.785). The positive number of ARAs was significantly higher when photoreceptor disruption was observed on optical coherence tomography, or severe dysfunction was observed in electroretinography (P = .022 and P = .029, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

The profiles of ARAs in the AIR group were different from those in the RP and normal controls. The higher number of positive ARAs suggests a higher possibility of AIR diagnosis. ARAs should be used as adjunct tools for the clinical diagnosis of AIR.

Anti-Programmed Death Ligand-1 Induced Acute Vision Loss in a Patient With Cancer-Associated Retinopathy

Cancer-associated retinopathy (CAR) is a potentially blinding disease triggered by autoimmunity to cancer antigens at distant sites. It may masquerade as immune-related adverse events from the use of immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs). We present a patient with an underlying tubby-related protein 1 (TULP1) cancer-associated retinopathy who lost vision following initiation of atezolizumab for small-cell lung cancer. This 75-year-old man presented with no light perception, paramacular and peripheral retinal pigmentary changes, attenuated outer retina, and extinguished rod and cone responses. The visual loss followed the induction of atezolizumab therapy. Possible atezolizumab-associated acute macular neuroretinopathy was considered, and atezolizumab was discontinued. Vision improved on oral corticosteroid and deteriorated when corticosteroid was tapered quickly. Retinal autoantibody serology testing was negative for both anti-recoverin and anti-enolase and was positive for anti-TULP1 autoantibodies. Re-induction of atezolizumab concomitant with high-dose oral and intravitreal corticosteroids resulted in visual recovery at the three-month follow-up. These findings suggest that ICI therapy for cancer can exacerbate the retinal dysfunction in a patient with underlying autoimmunity from cancer. Patients with a high risk of CAR may need to be evaluated for retinal autoantibodies before initiation of ICI. 

Current Techniques to Accurately Measure Anti-retinal Autoantibodies

Introduction

Autoimmune retinopathy (AR) is a sight-threating retinal disorder that is mediated by autoantibodies (AAbs) against retinal proteins. The visual paraneoplastic syndromes, including cancer-associated retinopathy (CAR) and melanoma-associated retinopathy (MAR) are mediated by anti-retinal AAbs. A number of immunochemical techniques have been used to detect serum anti-retinal autoantibodies in patients to help with autoimmune diagnosis.

Area covered

We review techniques used for serum autoantibody evaluation in patients with suspected autoimmune retinopathy.

Expert opinion

Detection of serum AAbs have served as the standard diagnostic tool for autoimmune retinopathies and for management of retinal disorders. An identification of anti-retinal autoantibody or multiple autoantibodies can be useful for not only for diagnosis of autoimmune retinopathies but also for management of retinal disorders. We propose that the line-blotting technique used in conjunction with immunohistochemistry are the best and most reliable assays for detection of serum anti-retinal AAb in the context of clinical history and findings. Clinician should recognize that the majority of antigenic targets identified to date in retinal autoimmunity are ubiquitously expressed proteins (e.g. enolase), which may be difficult to reconcile with the specific patterns of retinal damage observed in CAR, MAR, or AR.

Are Anti-Retinal Autoantibodies a Cause or a Consequence of Retinal Degeneration in Autoimmune Retinopathies?

Autoantibodies (AAbs) against various retinal proteins have been associated with vision loss in paraneoplastic and non-paraneoplastic autoimmune retinopathies (AR). There are two major paraneoplastic syndromes associated anti-retinal AAbs, cancer-associated retinopathy (CAR), and melanoma-associated retinopathy. Some people without a cancer diagnosis may present symptoms of CAR and have anti-retinal AAbs. The etiology and pathogenesis of those entities are not fully understood. In this review, we provide evidence for the role of AAbs in retinal death and degeneration. Studies of epitope mapping for anti-recoverin, anti-enolase, and anti-carbonic anhydrase II revealed that although patients' AAbs may recognize the same retinal protein as normal individuals they bind to different molecular domains, which allows distinguishing between normal and diseased AAbs. Given the great diversity of anti-retinal AAbs, it is likely some antibodies have greater pathogenic potential than others. Pathogenic, but not normal antibodies penetrate the target cell, reach their specific antigen, induce apoptosis, and impact retinal pathophysiology. Photoreceptors, dying by apoptosis, induced by other than immunologic mechanisms produce substantial amounts of metabolic debris, which consequently leads to autoimmunization and enhanced permeability of the blood-retinal barrier. AAbs that were made as a part of anti-cancer response are likely to be the cause of retinal degeneration, whereas others, generated against released antigens from damaged retina, contribute to the progression of retinopathy. Altogether, AAbs may trigger retinal degeneration and may also exacerbate the degenerative process in response to the release of sequestered antigens and influence disease progression.

Impacts of Cross-Linkers on Biological Effects of Mesoporous Silica Nanoparticles

Chemically synthesized cross-linkers play decisive roles in variable cargos attached to nanoparticles (NPs). Previous studies reported that surface properties, such as the size, charge, and surface chemistry, are particularly important determinants influencing the biological fate and actions of NPs and cells. Recent studies also focused on the relationship of serum proteins with the surface properties of NPs (also called the protein corona), which is recognized as a key factor in determining the cytotoxicity and biodistribution. However, there is concern that cross-linkers conjugated onto NPs might induce undesirable biological effects. Cell responses induced by cross-linkers have not yet been precisely elucidated. Herein, using mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNs) the surfaces of which were separately conjugated with four popular heterobifunctional cross-linkers, i.e., N-[α-maleimidoacetoxy]succinimide ester (AMAS), m-maleimidobenzoyl-N-hydroxysuccinimide ester (MBS), succinimidyl 4-(N-maleimidomethyl)cyclohexane-1-carboxylate (SMCC), and maleimide poly(ethylene glycol) succinimidyl carboxymethyl ester (MAL-PEG-SCM), we investigated cross-linker-conjugated MSNs to determine whether they can cause cytotoxicity, or enhance reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation, nuclear factor (NF)-κB activation, and p-p38 or p21 protein expressions in RAW264.7 macrophage cells. Furthermore, we also separately conjugated two biomolecules containing TAT peptides and bovine serum albumin (BSA) as model systems to study their cell responses in detail. Finally, in vivo mice studies evaluated the biodistribution and blood assays (biochemistry and complete blood count) of PEG-derivative NPs, and results suggested that TAT peptides caused significant white blood cell (WBC)-related cell and platelet abnormalities, as well as liver and kidney dysfunction compared to BSA when conjugated onto MSNs. The results showed that attention to cross-linkers should be considered an issue in the surface modification of NPs. We anticipate that our results could be helpful in developing biosafety nanomaterials.

Serum Autoantibody Profiling of Patients with Paraneoplastic and Non-Paraneoplastic Autoimmune Retinopathy

PURPOSE

Although multiple serum antiretinal autoantibodies (ARAs) have been reported in patients with paraneoplastic and non-paraneoplastic autoimmune retinopathy ((n)pAIR), not all retinal antigens involved in (n)pAIR are specified. This study aims to serologically identify patients with presumed (n)pAIR through determination of both known and unknown ARAs by autoantibody profiling.

METHODS

An antigen suspension bead array using 188 different antigens representing 97 ocular proteins was performed to detect ARAs in serum samples of patients with presumed (n)pAIR (n = 24), uveitis (n = 151) and cataract (n = 21). Logistic regressions were used to estimate the associations between ocular antigens and diagnosis. Validation of interphotoreceptor matrix proteoglycan 2 (IMPG2) and recoverin antigens was performed by immunohistochemistry and immunoblot, respectively.

RESULTS

Samples of patients with presumed (n)pAIR exhibited a broad spectrum of ARAs. We identified retinal antigens that have already been described previously (e.g. recoverin), but also identified novel ARA targets. Most ARAs were not specific for (n)pAIR since their presence was also observed in patients with cataract or uveitis. High titers of autoantibodies directed against photoreceptor-specific nuclear receptor and retinol-binding protein 3 were more common in patients with presumed (n)pAIR compared to uveitis (p = 0.015 and p = 0.018, respectively). The presence of all other ARAs did not significantly differ between groups. In patients with presumed (n)pAIR, anti-recoverin autoantibodies were the most prevalent ARAs. Validation of bead array results by immunohistochemistry (anti-IMPG2) and immunoblot (anti-recoverin) showed concordant results in (n)pAIR patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with (n)pAIR are characterized by the presence of a broad spectrum of ARAs. The diagnosis of (n)pAIR cannot be based on the mere presence of serum ARAs, as these are also commonly present in uveitis as well as in age-related cataract patients.

The Disease Protein Tulp1 Is Essential for Periactive Zone Endocytosis in Photoreceptor Ribbon Synapses

Mutations in the Tulp1 gene cause severe, early-onset retinitis pigmentosa (RP14) in humans. In the retina, Tulp1 is mainly expressed in photoreceptors that use ribbon synapses to communicate with the inner retina. In the present study, we demonstrate that Tulp1 is highly enriched in the periactive zone of photoreceptor presynaptic terminals where Tulp1 colocalizes with major endocytic proteins close to the synaptic ribbon. Analyses of Tulp1 knock-out mice demonstrate that Tulp1 is essential to keep endocytic proteins enriched at the periactive zone and to maintain high levels of endocytic activity close to the synaptic ribbon. Moreover, we have discovered a novel interaction between Tulp1 and the synaptic ribbon protein RIBEYE, which is important to maintain synaptic ribbon integrity. The current findings suggest a new model for Tulp1-mediated localization of the endocytic machinery at the periactive zone of ribbon synapses and offer a new rationale and mechanism for vision loss associated with genetic defects in Tulp1.

Identification of α-fodrin as an autoantigen in experimental coronavirus retinopathy (ECOR)

The coronavirus, mouse hepatitis virus (MHV), JHM strain induces a biphasic disease in BALB/c mice that consists of an acute retinitis followed by progression to a chronic retinal degeneration with autoimmune reactivity. Retinal degeneration resistant CD-1 mice do not develop either the late phase or autoimmune reactivity. A mouse RPE/choroid DNA expression library was screened using sera from virus infected BALB/c mice. Two clones were identified, villin-2 protein and α-fodrin protein. α-Fodrin protein was used for further analysis and western blot reactivity was seen only in sera from virus infected BALB/c mice. CD4 T cells were shown to specifically react with MHV antigens and with α-fodrin protein. These studies clearly identified both antibody and CD4 T cell reactivities to α-fodrin in sera from virus infected, retinal degenerative susceptible BALB/c mice.

Autoimmune retinopathy

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Autoimmune retinopathy (AIR) is an immune-mediated disorder characterized by progressive visual loss, abnormal electroretinographic and visual field findings in the presence of circulating anti-retinal antibodies. This review highlights advances made toward understanding the pathophysiology, clinical manifestations, and trends in the management of AIR.

RECENT FINDINGS

The pathophysiology of AIR is likely antibody-mediated. AIR serum autoantibodies are variable in their size and retinal tissue they target and can also be present in healthy controls and multiple autoimmune diseases. Rarely, AIR may be associated with dysregulated self-tolerance mechanisms in the thymus. Despite progress in research, our understanding of AIR remains incomplete. Lack of standardized methods for anti-retinal antibody testing continues to challenge the interpretation of seropositivity. Conventional immunosuppressives have been further studied, and promising immunomodulatory therapies, such as targeted B-cell therapy, have been introduced. Newer imaging modalities such as fundus autofluorescence and spectral domain optical coherence tomography may be helpful in diagnosis, monitoring progression of disease and response to treatment.

SUMMARY

AIR is a rare but vision-threatening disease whose pathogenesis is poorly defined. Lack of standardized clinical or laboratory criteria further complicates the diagnosis and management. Despite recent progress, further basic science research into the autoimmune process is needed. Prospective controlled clinical trials with immunomodulatory therapy can help define future treatment paradigms.

Autoimmune retinopathies: a report of 3 cases

PURPOSE

To describe 3 representative cases of autoimmune retinopathy (AIR).

METHODS

Clinical records of patients with a diagnosis of AIR were analyzed for demographic data, clinical findings, ancillary and laboratory tests, and treatment employed.

RESULTS

Three female patients diagnosed with AIR had bilateral reduction of electroretinogram amplitudes and elevation of visual field threshold within the central 30 degrees of the visual field that was disproportionately more severe than the clinical findings of retinal degeneration. The diagnoses were cancer-associated retinopathy, non-neoplastic AIR, and hereditary retinal dystrophy with secondary inflammation. Optic nerve involvement was also present in all cases. The patient with non-neoplastic AIR was successfully treated with systemic corticosteroids and immunomodulatory agents.

CONCLUSION

High index of suspicion is essential for an early diagnosis of AIR. Visual function and electrophysiological tests should be included in the initial workup of patients who present with suggestive clinical signs and symptoms of AIR.

Update on paraneoplastic neurologic disorders

When patients with cancer develop neurologic symptoms, common causes include metastasis, infections, coagulopathy, metabolic or nutritional disturbances, and neurotoxicity from treatments. A thorough clinical history, temporal association with cancer therapies, and results of ancillary tests usually reveal one of these mechanisms as the etiology. When no etiology is identified, the diagnosis considered is often that of a paraneoplastic neurologic disorder (PND). With the recognition that PNDs are more frequent than previously thought, the availability of diagnostic tests, and the fact that, for some PNDs, treatment helps, PNDs should no longer be considered diagnostic zebras, and when appropriate should be included in the differential diagnosis early in the evaluation.

Autoimmunity in retinal degeneration: autoimmune retinopathy and age-related macular degeneration

Autoantibody production is associated with a variety of ocular disorders, including autoimmune retinopathy (AIR) and age-related macular degeneration (AMD). A breakdown of immunologic tolerance (ocular immune privilege), including the blood-retinal barrier, anti-immune and anti-inflammatory proteins, and anterior chamber-associated immune deviation may play important roles in these disorders. Although the exact triggers for ocular autoimmunity are unknown, autoimmune targeting of retinal tissue is clearly associated with and may contribute to the pathogenesis of both AIR and AMD. Autoantibody production has long been associated with AIR, a collection of disorders that includes cancer-associated retinopathy, melanoma-associated retinopathy and non-paraneoplastic autoimmune retinopathy. A growing body of evidence indicates that AMD pathogenesis, too, involves ocular inflammation and autoimmunity. Identification and quantification of autoantibodies produced in patients with AIR and AMD may assist with diagnosis, prognosis, and choice of treatments. Animal models that allow investigation of ocular autoimmunity will also be needed to better understand the disease processes and to develop novel therapies. In this review we discuss ocular immune privilege and potential mechanisms of autoimmunity in the eye. We describe how autoimmunity relates to the pathogenesis of AIR and AMD. We explain how the antigen microarray technique is used to detect autoantibodies in patient serum samples, and discuss how current animal models for AMD can be used to investigate autoimmune pathogenesis. Finally, we outline unanswered questions and exciting areas of future study related to autoimmune retinal degeneration.

Paraneoplastic neurological syndromes: a review

BACKGROUND

Paraneoplastic neurologic syndromes (PNS) constitute a rare group of disorders resulting from damage to the nervous system in the setting of cancer physically unrelated to the tumor site. PNS are believed to result from an autoimmune attack of normal neuronal tissue, spurred by similar neuronal antigens ectopically expressed by tumor cells.

REVIEW SUMMARY

The most common PNS are reviewed and also their association with specific onconeural antibodies, some directly pathogenic, others whose role in the disease process is less clear-cut. This diversity in pathogenesis is likely due to the relative role of humoral versus cellular immunity in PNS. Virtually any cancer may result in PNS but certain tumors, small cell lung cancer, gynecologic cancers (breast and ovarian), thymoma, and plasma cell tumors are more frequently encountered. In most instances, immunosuppressive therapy is unhelpful and outcome is poor.

CONCLUSIONS

PNS have diverse presentations, affecting both the central and peripheral nervous system and commonly, it is the PNS, not cancer that is the presenting symptom. Only subsequently, after onconeural antibodies are discovered or cancer is found, is PNS diagnosed. Neurologists should familiarize themselves with these rare syndromes and treatment principles, as rapid detection and treatment of the underlying tumor offer the best chance for recovery or prevention of further neurologic deterioration.

The need for standardization of antiretinal antibody detection and measurement

PURPOSE

To review the current literature on the detection and measurement of antiretinal antibodies.

DESIGN

Collaborative essay.

METHODS

Literature review and interpretation.

RESULTS

There is strong evidence to suggest a role for antiretinal antibodies, particularly those targeting recoverin and alpha-enolase, in the pathogenesis of autoimmune retinopathy (AIR). Additionally, numerous other autoantibodies have been described as putative mediators of retinal degeneration and more remain to be discovered. However, assay methods described in the literature by many laboratories for the detection of circulating antiretinal antibodies have been varied and diverse, making it difficult to interpret and compare their results.

CONCLUSIONS

There is currently little standardization of laboratory methods used to detect and monitor antiretinal antibodies. To measure and monitor levels of circulating antiretinal antibodies optimally in patients with AIR, development of standardized assays with stringent internal controls is required. A multicenter collaborative and validation effort is encouraged to reach a consensus on this issue.

Frequency of anti-retinal antibodies in normal human serum

BACKGROUND

Anti-retinal antibodies have been described in the context of autoimmune retinopathies and are often presumed to be pathogenic or disease associated. However, full characterization of patterns of anti-retinal antibody reactivity in normal human serum has been limited. The purpose of this work was to identify the profile of anti-retinal IgG antibodies in serum used as controls in laboratory testing.

METHODS

Normal human sera used in commercial diagnostic laboratories were tested for the presence of immunoreactivity against soluble human retinal proteins using Western blot analysis of fractionated soluble human retinal proteins. Reactivity was quantified using computerized densitometry, and the level of reactivity was standardized relative to a control positive serum with known reactivity against recoverin.

RESULTS

Some anti-retinal reactivity was observed in the majority of all tested normal sera. Reactivity against one to two protein bands was observed in 33%. Reactivity against five or more distinct bands was observed in 22%. There was a tendency for serum from women to react with three or more protein bands compared with serum from men.

CONCLUSIONS

The presence of anti-retinal antibodies is observed in a majority of normal control human sera, suggesting that identification of new candidate retinal autoantigens should be cautiously interpreted and subject to rigorous testing for disease association. Additional studies will aid development of a standardized protocol for validation of potential pathogenic seroreactivity.

Autoantibodies to p75/LEDGF, a cell survival factor, found in patients with atypical retinal degeneration

We have identified a group of patients with an atypical retinal degeneration having anti-retinal autoantibodies in their sera. This select population is characterized by a progressively severe loss of vision associated with a decrease in photoreceptor function, abnormal pigmentation of the retinal pigment epithelium and a negative family history of retinal dystrophy. Immunohistochemical analysis on mouse retinal tissues with sera from this group of patients demonstrated high titers of anti-retinal antibodies (320 to 1,280). Anti-retinal reactivity at these levels was not detected in sera from normal individuals, or from patients with uveitis or known genetic retinal degenerations. One antigen that was identified from a retina cDNA library with sera from a patient with atypical retinal degeneration was lens epithelium-derived growth factor (LEDGF). Western blot analysis revealed that sera from all three patients demonstrated reactivity to p75/LEDGF, a survival factor that protects cells from oxidative, thermal and UV damage. In conclusion, we have found a novel group of patients with a retinal degeneration of non-paraneoplastic, non-familial origin demonstrating immunoreactivity to an autoantigen, p75/LEDGF, heretofore not associated with this disease. Finally, identification of specific anti-retinal antibodies may have applications in the diagnosis and management of retinal degeneration.

Paraneoplastic syndromes affecting the nervous system

The paraneoplastic neurologic disorders (PND) are a diverse group of diseases characterized by the presence of neurologic dysfunction in the setting of a remote cancer. PND can affect almost any part of the nervous system, and are most commonly associated with lung cancer (small cell) and gynecologic tumors. Laboratory studies have demonstrated that an autoimmune response links the neurologic disorder and the cancer, and established a model whereby the cancer is believed to initiate the syndrome by expressing a protein antigen normally expressed in the nervous system, leading to anti-tumor immune response followed by autoimmune neurologic symptoms. We review the currently known PND and their pathogenesis.

Long-term effect of therapeutic laser photocoagulation on gene expression in the eye

Microarray-based gene expression analysis demonstrated that laser photocoagulation (LPC) of mouse eyes had a long-term effect on the expression of genes functionally related to tissue repair, cell migration, proliferation, ion, protein and nucleic acid metabolism, cell signaling, and angiogenesis. Six structural genes, including five crystallins (Cryaa, Cryba1, Crybb2, Crygc, Crygs) and keratin 1-12 (Krt1-12), the anti-angiogenic factor thrombospondin 1 (Tsp1), the retina- and brain-specific putative transcription factor tubby-like protein 1 (Tulp1), and transketolase (Tkt), a key enzyme in the pentose-phosphate pathway, were all shown to be up-regulated by real-time PCR and/or Western blotting. Immunohistochemistry localized five of these proteins to the laser lesions and surrounding tissue within the retina and pigmented epithelium. This is the first study demonstrating long-term changes in the expression of these genes associated with LPC. Therefore, it suggests that modulated gene expression might contribute to the long-term inhibitory effect of LPC. In addition, these genes present novel targets for gene-based therapies aimed at treating microangiopathies, especially diabetic retinopathy, a disease currently only treatable with LPC.

Neuro-ophthalmology and paraneoplastic syndromes

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To describe the neuro-ophthalmological manifestations of paraneoplastic syndromes and their immunological associations.

RECENT FINDINGS

Neuro-ophthalmological signs and symptoms are usually present in paraneoplastic syndromes of the central nervous system. Unlike opsoclonus, less characteristic eye movement abnormalities are difficult to recognize as presenting symptoms of paraneoplastic syndromes. In this setting, the detection of several antibodies, including anti-Hu, Yo, Ma2, Ri, Tr, CV2/CRMP5 or voltage-gated calcium channel antibodies may help to establish that the neuro-ophthalmological disorder is paraneoplastic. Among the recently characterized antibodies, those against the Ma proteins often associate with brainstem encephalitis and vertical gaze paralysis. A small subset of patients with opsoclonus and ataxia harbor anti-Ri antibodies. In other patients, there is preliminary evidence that the autoantigens of opsoclonus reside in the postsynaptic density, but no dominant antibody marker has been identified. Uveitis and optic neuritis are rare accompaniments of paraneoplastic encephalomyelitis; some of these patients harbor anti-CV2/CRMP5 in association with other antibodies. Studies on paraneoplastic retinopathy indicate that immunity to retinal proteins other than recoverin can result in a similar syndrome to that associated with recoverin antibodies, and that melanoma-associated retinopathy may associate with several retinal antibodies.

SUMMARY

There is increasing recognition of an extensive variety of neuro-ophthalmological abnormalities as manifestations of paraneoplastic syndromes and of several antineuronal antibodies as clinical markers of these disorders. Basic immunological studies support the pathogenic role of some of these antibodies, and are elucidating the pathogenic mechanisms that underlie these and other antibody-associated paraneoplastic syndromes.

Tubby proteins: the plot thickens

The tubby mouse, which shows late-onset obesity and neurosensory deficits, arises from a mutation in the Tub gene. Tub shares homology with the genes for tubby-like proteins Tulp1, Tulp2 and Tulp3. Ablation of Tub, Tulp1 or Tulp3 causes disease phenotypes that are indicative of their importance in nervous-system function and development. Despite this importance, the biochemical functions of tubby-like proteins are only now beginning to be understood. At present, data indicate that tubby-like proteins might function as heterotrimeric-G-protein-responsive intracellular signalling factors, although an array of data also implicates them in other processes.

Paraneoplastic syndromes associated with visual loss

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The recent literature was reviewed to analyze the developments in the diagnosis, pathogenesis, and immunology of this group of paraneoplastic syndromes. Clinical features and pathologic findings are summarized.

RECENT FINDINGS

The mechanism of cell death in cancer-associated retinopathy appears to occur through apoptotic pathways. Caspase inhibitors and a calcium antagonist have been used in animal models to block or suppress the effect of the antirecoverin antibodies on the retina with significant response. These agents are possible treatment options for cancer-associated retinopathy. Aberrant expression of recoverin by tumor cells does not necessarily induce antirecoverin antibodies and cancer-associated retinopathy. Many tumors, not just those producing the clinical picture of cancer-associated retinopathy, have been shown to express recoverin. Recoverin appears to play a functional role in tumor cells, and antirecoverin antibodies may have tumor-suppressing effects. Further research into this area may help design epitope-based immunotherapy for patients with recoverin-expressing tumors. Further evidence has emerged to support the initial observation that depolarizing bipolar cells are the likely retinal target in melanoma-associated retinopathy. Intravitreal injection of melanoma-associated retinopathy serum produced electroretinogram changes in animals very similar to the clinical findings in humans. Many new antibodies and antigens had been discovered to be linked to various paraneoplastic syndromes. Anti-collapsing response-mediating protein-5 is likely to be an important one; it was found to be the second most common autoantibody related to paraneoplastic neurologic syndromes.

SUMMARY

Further research into the functional role of recoverin in cancer cells may advance our understanding in cancer immunology. Immunotherapy may be possible if a specific epitope of recoverin can be found to contain the antigenic site for antitumor antibodies and not cross-react with retinal antigens. Research into the pathogenesis of the other paraneoplastic syndromes is required for a better understanding and treatment of these rare conditions. The missing link between primary cutaneous melanoma and uveal melanocytes still eludes investigators in bilateral diffuse uveal melanocytic proliferation. The discovery of the missing link may provide us with some understanding of the development of uveal melanoma.

Autoantibody-induced apoptosis as a possible mechanism of autoimmune retinopathy

Circulating antibodies specific to retinal proteins have been associated with retinal dysfunction in patients with retinopathy. Anti-recoverin antibodies found in patients with cancer-associated retinopathy (CAR) represent a unique model to study the relationship between retinal degeneration and autoimmunity. A body of evidence from in vitro and in vivo studies indicates that anti-recoverin autoantibodies are cytotoxic to retinal cells and induce apoptotic death of retinal photoreceptor cells, which leads to the degeneration of the photoreceptor cell layer. Similar to anti-recoverin autoantibodies, antibodies with other retinal specificities induce their target retinal cell death by activating a caspase 3-dependent apoptotic pathway. Thus, autoantibody-induced apoptosis may be a common pathway that leads to retinal death and blindness.

Paraneoplastic retinopathies and optic neuropathies

Unusual neuro-ophthalmologic symptoms and signs that go unexplained should warrant a thorough investigation for paraneoplastic syndromes. Although these syndromes are rare, these clinical manifestations can herald an unsuspected, underlying malignancy that could be treated early and aggressively. This point underscores the importance of distinguishing and understanding the various, sometimes subtle, presentations of ocular paraneoplastic syndromes. Outlined in this review article are diagnostic features useful in differentiating cancer-associated retinopathy, melanoma-associated retinopathy, and paraneoplastic optic neuropathy. These must also be distinguished from non-cancer-related eye disorders that may clinically resemble cancer-associated retinopathy. The associated antibodies and histopathology of each syndrome are presented to help in the understanding of these autoimmune phenomena. Treatment outcomes from reported cases are summarized, and some potential novel immunotherapies are also discussed.

Non-cancerous ophthalmic clues to non-ocular cancer

This survey reviews selected medical disorders in which the ophthalmologist has a unique opportunity of anticipating the existence of asymptomatic, life-threatening disease simply by recognizing that certain benign conditions involving the eye or adnexa represent clues to occult non-ocular cancer and other neoplasias. Having knowledge that these clues are associated with specific types of neoplasia, the ophthalmologist can then initiate a goal-directed oncologic investigation designed to identify the underlying neoplasm with the hope of providing potentially life-saving therapy. The survey is organized to feature each clue separately. The clinical characteristics of the clue are described and illustrated with color photographs when possible. A discussion reviews associated malignancies and other important medical features. The survey begins with clues expressed anteriorly in the lids, progressively reviewing those clues located more posteriorly, concluding with clues involving the retinal pigment epithelium and choroid.

Paraneoplastic neurological syndromes: an update on diagnosis, pathogenesis, and therapy

Since the discovery of the first clinically relevant anti neuronal antibody specific for a paraneoplastic aetiology in 1985, the number of such reactivities has grown at a rate of about one per year. Clinicians can now diagnose a paraneoplastic syndrome much more easily. This ability is especially important because, typically, the neurological symptoms occur before the cancer is diagnosed. Early tumour diagnosis is essential, because effective treatment of the cancer still seems to be the most efficient treatment option for the neurological symptoms. Immuno modulatory therapy should, nevertheless, be initiated as early as possible and seems especially helpful for peripheral syndromes and limbic encephalitis. The recent fundamental advances in understanding of the autoimmune pathology of these disorders, especially the role of cytotoxic T cells, should eventually lead to more effective treatment options.

Autoantibodies to photoreceptor membrane proteins and outer plexiform layer in patients with cancer-associated retinopathy

Cancer-associated retinopathy (CAR) is a paraneoplastic syndrome that is characterized by degeneration of the retina as a remote effect of cancer outside the eye. The detection of autoantibodies associated with the retinopathy may precede the diagnosis of the underlying cancer. We have examined the sera of two patients with CAR by Western blot analysis. Autoantibodies to a 40kD antigen doublet and a 35 kD antigen were detected. Tissue specificity of the autoantigens was determined by testing several different tissues. The 40 kD antigen doublet was most abundant in retinal extract but was also present in lung and spleen extracts. The 35 kD antigen showed little tissue specificity and was present in all tissues tested. Fractionation of retinal proteins into water-soluble and -insoluble proteins revealed that the 40 kD antigen doublet was highly insoluble and probably represented membrane-associated proteins. Immunohistochemical analysis of the retina showed that the 40 kD antigens locate to the photoreceptors while the 35 kD antigen is located in the outer plexiform layer.

Molecular cloning and characterization of human PTB-like protein: a possible retinal autoantigen of cancer-associated retinopathy

Human homologue of polypyrimidine tract binding protein (PTB), a possible autoantigen for cancer-associated retinopathy (CAR), was isolated from a human retinal cDNA library. This homologue, named PTB-like protein (PTBLP), encodes a 532 amino acid residue and has a 75% homology to the human PTB. The human PTBLP had four RNA recognition motifs (RRMs) and had a RNA binding ability. There are four splicing variants in PTBLP. The CAR serum recognized the full length form of PTBLP and the antigenic determinant was localized within 12 amino acids of the C-terminal region. The sequence was included in the fourth RRM sequence.

The photoreceptor cell-specific nuclear receptor is an autoantigen of paraneoplastic retinopathy

OBJECTIVES

To report a novel antibody associated with paraneoplastic retinopathy and to characterize the retinal autoantigen.

METHODS

Immunohistochemistry of rat and human tissues was used to identify antiretinal antibodies. Serologic screening of a bovine retinal cDNA expression library was performed to clone the target antigen.

RESULTS

A 72-year-old woman presented with a 6-month history of progressive visual loss, bilateral central scotomas, light flashes, and night blindness. Visual acuity was 20/40 OD and 20/30 OS. There was generalized loss of retinal pigment and narrow arterioles; discs were normal in appearance. The electroretinogram showed no response. Chest computed tomograph scan demonstrated a right lung mass; biopsy revealed poorly differentiated carcinoma. The patients' serum contained antibodies that immunolabeled nuclei of cells of the outer--and to a lesser extent, the inner--nuclear layer of the adult rat retina. No reactivity was identified with nonretinal adult human or rat tissues. Reactivity was seen in the developing rat embryo. Serologic screening of a bovine retinal library resulted in the isolation of three overlapping clones, encoding a protein highly homologous to the human photoreceptor cell-specific nuclear receptor gene product.

CONCLUSIONS

The target antigen of an antibody associated with paraneoplastic retinopathy is the photoreceptor cellspecific nuclear receptor, a member of a conserved family of nuclear receptors involved in photoreceptor cell development or maintenance.

Bilateral diffuse uveal melanocytic proliferation associated with extraocular cancers: review of a process particularly associated with gynecologic cancers

We reviewed cases of a paraneoplastic syndrome in which uveal melanocytes proliferated and led to blindness. Eighteen cases were derived from the literature, and two were taken from our institution. The average patient age at the time of the diagnosis was 63 years (range, 34-89 years). There were 13 women and 7 men. In approximately half of the cases, the ocular symptoms antedated those of the inciting tumor. Most of the inciting tumors were poorly differentiated carcinomas. The most common tumors were from the female genital tract (ovary and uterus) among the women patients and from the lung among the men. Tumors from the breast were rare (one possible case), and tumors of the prostate were conspicuously absent. All five inciting tumors whose histopathology was reviewed expressed neuron-specific enolase, but none prominently expressed antigens more specific for neuroendocrine carcinomas such as chromogranin or synaptophysin. It is our experience that many general pathologists are not aware of this unique paraneoplastic syndrome. Our report is the first to document a statistically significant association between this syndrome and gynecologic cancers.