Specific differentiation of recombinant PVY(N:O) and PVY(NTN) isolates by multiplex RT-PCR

Detection of Plant Viruses and Disease Management: Relevance of Genetic Diversity and Evolution

Plant viruses cause considerable economic losses and are a threat for sustainable agriculture. The frequent emergence of new viral diseases is mainly due to international trade, climate change, and the ability of viruses for rapid evolution. Disease control is based on two strategies: i) immunization (genetic resistance obtained by plant breeding, plant transformation, cross-protection, or others), and ii) prophylaxis to restrain virus dispersion (using quarantine, certification, removal of infected plants, control of natural vectors, or other procedures). Disease management relies strongly on a fast and accurate identification of the causal agent. For known viruses, diagnosis consists in assigning a virus infecting a plant sample to a group of viruses sharing common characteristics, which is usually referred to as species. However, the specificity of diagnosis can also reach higher taxonomic levels, as genus or family, or lower levels, as strain or variant. Diagnostic procedures must be optimized for accuracy by detecting the maximum number of members within the group (sensitivity as the true positive rate) and distinguishing them from outgroup viruses (specificity as the true negative rate). This requires information on the genetic relationships within-group and with members of other groups. The influence of the genetic diversity of virus populations in diagnosis and disease management is well documented, but information on how to integrate the genetic diversity in the detection methods is still scarce. Here we review the techniques used for plant virus diagnosis and disease control, including characteristics such as accuracy, detection level, multiplexing, quantification, portability, and designability. The effect of genetic diversity and evolution of plant viruses in the design and performance of some detection and disease control techniques are also discussed. High-throughput or next-generation sequencing provides broad-spectrum and accurate identification of viruses enabling multiplex detection, quantification, and the discovery of new viruses. Likely, this technique will be the future standard in diagnostics as its cost will be dropping and becoming more affordable.

Genetic Diversity of Potato virus Y in Potato Production Areas in Northeast China

In 2011-2014, ELISA or nucleic acid spot hybridization (NASH) testing for common potato viruses or Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) was performed on 500 leaf samples collected in potato fields in the northeast provinces Heilongjiang and Inner Mongolia, China. The results revealed that 38.4% (Heilongjiang) and 27.7% (Inner Mongolia) were positive for Potato virus Y (PVY). To unveil the strain composition and population structure of PVY in the region, the multiplex RT-PCR described by Chikh-Ali et al. was performed on all of the ELISA-PVY-positive samples. Of the 158 samples whose PVY strain scenarios could be determined, PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-II and PVY^N-Wi were the most abundant strains, occurring in 58.9 and 47.5% samples, followed by PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-I (31.0%), PVY^N:O (19.6%), Eu-PVY^NTN (7.6%), NA-PVY^N (1.3%), and PVY^O (0.6%). In the 84 single-strain-infected samples, PVY^N-Wi accounted for 41.7%, PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-II for 40.5%, PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-I for 14.3%, and PVY^N:O and Eu-PVY^NTN for 3.6% each. Seven isolates representing PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-I (HLJ-6-1 and HLJ-9-4), PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-II (INM-W-369-12 and SC-1-1-2), PVY^N:O (HLJ-30-2), and PVY^N-Wi (HLJ-BDH-2 and HLJ-C-429) were sequenced and analyzed molecularly. Whereas the sequence identities for isolates belonging to the same strain group were >98.5%, they fell for isolates belonging to different strain groups to 92.7-98.1% at the genome level and 96.1-98.4% at the polyprotein level. Interestingly, the exact location of the recombination events varied among isolates within a strain group. Phylogenetic analysis of all 42 full length PVY sequences from China indicated that most clustered to various recombinant groups, despite the fact that the PVY isolates were isolated from at least five host species. Pathological analysis of four isolates representing PVY^N:O, PVY^N-Wi, PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-I, and PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-II revealed that the PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-II isolate incited the most severe symptoms on potato cultivar Kexin 13, followed by PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-I, PVY^N:O and PVY^N-Wi. The PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-I and PVY^NTN-NW-SYR-II isolates also caused necrotic ringspots on the tubers of Kexin 13, indicating their ability to induce the potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease in potato.

Simultaneous detection and differentiation of three genotypes of Brassica yellows virus by multiplex reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction

BACKGROUND

Brassica yellows virus (BrYV), proposed to be a new polerovirus species, three distinct genotypes (BrYV-A, BrYV-B and BrYV-C) have been described. This study was to develop a simple, rapid, sensitive, cost-effective method for simultaneous detection and differentiation of three genotypes of BrYV.

RESULTS

In this study, a multiplex reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (mRT-PCR) was developed for simultaneous detection and differentiation of the three genotypes of BrYV. The three genotypes of BrYV and Tunip yellows virus (TuYV) could be differentiated simultaneously using six optimized specific oligonucleotide primers, including one universal primer for detecting BrYV, three BrYV genotype-specific primers, and a pair of primers for specific detection of TuYV. Primers were designed from conserved regions of each virus and their specificity was confirmed by sequencing PCR products. The mRT-PCR products were 278 bp for BrYV-A, 674 bp for BrYV-B, 505 bp for BrYV-C, and 205 bp for TuYV. Amplification of three target genotypes was optimized by increasing the PCR annealing temperatures to 62 °C. One to three fragments specific for the virus genotypes were simultaneously amplified from infected samples and identified by their specific molecular sizes in agarose gel electrophoresis. No specific products could be amplified from cDNAs of other viruses which could infect crucifer crops. Detection limits of the plasmids for multiplex PCR were 100 fg for BrYV-A and BrYV-B, 10 pg for BrYV-C, and 1 pg for TuYV, respectively. The mRT-PCR was applied successfully for detection of three BrYV genotypes from field samples collected in China.

CONCLUSIONS

The simple, rapid, sensitive, and cost-effective mRT-PCR was developed successfully for detection and differentiation of the three genotypes of BrYV.

RT-PCR Differentiation, Molecular and Pathological Characterization of Andean and Ordinary Strains of Potato virus S in Potatoes in China

A survey of potatoes in a field in Hubei, China, for common potato viruses revealed that Potato virus S (PVS) was the most abundant virus. To unveil the strain identity of the virus, primers specific to the ordinary and/or Andean strains of PVS (i.e., PVS^O and PVS^A) were designed. RT-PCR using these primers successfully detected PVS^O and PVS^A in the samples. Sequence analysis of the amplicons confirmed the correctness of the RT-PCR assay. Two isolates, PVS HB24 and PVS HB7, representing PVS^O and PVS^A, respectively, were chosen for molecular and biological characterization. Both isolates contained a genome of 8,453 nt in length with six open reading frames. They shared a sequence identity of 79.5% at the complete genome sequence level. Phylogenetic analysis placed PVS HB24 and PVS HB7 to PVS^O and PVS^A clades, respectively. PVS HB24 induced chlorotic local lesions on the inoculated leaves but no visible symptom on the upper uninoculated leaves of Chenopodium quinoa after mechanical inoculation, whereas PVS HB7 induced both local and systemic symptoms on C. quinoa. ELISA and RT-PCR confirmed that PVS HB7 infected C. quinoa systemically whereas PVS HB24 failed to do so. Both isolates infected potato cv. Shepody and Solanum chacoense asymptomatically, but did not infect Nicotiana occidentalis and N. tobaccum cv. Samsun.

Host recovery and reduced virus level in the upper leaves after Potato virus Y infection occur in tobacco and tomato but not in potato plants

In this study, the recovery phenomenon following infection with Potato virus Y (PVY) was investigated in tobacco (Nicotiana tobaccum), tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) and potato (Solanum tuberosum) plants. In tobacco plants, infection of severe strains of PVY (PVYN or PVYN:O) induced conspicuous vein clearing and leaf deformation in the first three leaves above the inoculated leaves, but much milder symptoms in the upper leaves. The recovery phenotype was not obvious in tobacco plants infected with PVY strain that induce mild symptoms (PVYO). However, regardless of the virus strains, reduction in PVY RNA levels was similarly observed in the upper leaves of these plants. Removal of the first three leaves above the inoculated leaves interfered with the occurrence of recovery, suggesting that the signal(s) mediating the recovery is likely generated in these leaves. In PVYN or PVYN:O but not in PVYO-infected tobacco plants, the expression of PR-1a transcripts were correlated with the accumulation level of PVY RNA. Reduced level of PVY RNA in the upper leaves was also observed in infected tomato plants, whereas such phenomenon was not observed in potato plants. PVY-derived small RNAs were detected in both tobacco and potato plants and their accumulation levels were correlated with PVY RNA levels. Our results demonstrate that the recovery phenotype following PVY infection is host-specific and not necessarily associated with the expression of PR-1a and generation of PVY small RNAs.

RT-PCR and real-time RT-PCR methods for the detection of potato virus Y in potato leaves and tubers

Potato virus Y (PVY) is a major threat to potato crops around the world. It is an RNA virus of the family Potyviridae, exhibiting many different strains that cause a range of symptoms in potato. ELISA detection of viral proteins has traditionally been used to quantify virus incidence in a crop or seed lot. ELISA, however, cannot reliably detect the virus directly in dormant tubers, requiring several weeks of sprouting tubers to produce detectable levels of virus. Nor can ELISA fully discriminate between the wide range of strains of the virus. Several techniques for directly detecting the viral RNA have been developed which allow rapid detection of PVY in leaf or tuber tissue, and that can be used to easily distinguish between different strains of the virus. Described in this chapter are several protocols for the extraction of RNA from leaf and tuber tissues, and three detection methods based upon reverse-transcription-PCR (RT-PCR). First described is a traditional two-step protocol with separate reverse transcription of viral RNA into cDNA, then PCR to amplify the viral cDNA fragment. Second described is a one-step RT-PCR protocol combining the cDNA production and PCR in one tube and one step, which greatly reduces material and labor costs for PVY detection. The third protocol is a real-time RT-PCR procedure which not only saves on labor but also allows for more precise quantification of PVY titre. The three protocols are described in detail, and accompanied with a discussion of their relative advantages, costs, and possibilities for cost-saving modifications. While these techniques have primarily been developed for large-scale screening of many samples for determining viral incidence in commercial fields or seed lots, they are also amenable to use in smaller-scale research applications.

An Improved Multiplex IC-RT-PCR Assay Distinguishes Nine Strains of Potato virus Y

A multiplex reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assay was previously developed to identify a group of Potato virus Y (PVY) isolates with unusual recombinant structures (e.g., PVY^NTN-NW and SYR-III) and to differentiate them from other PVY strains. In the present study, the efficiency of this multiplex RT-PCR assay was validated and extended considerably to include five additional strains and strain groups not tested before. To make the multiplex RT-PCR assay more applicable and suitable for routine virus testing and typing, it was modified by replacing the conventional RNA extraction step with the immunocapture (IC) procedure. The results obtained using well-characterized reference isolates revealed, for the first time, that this multiplex RT-PCR assay is an accurate and robust method to identify and differentiate the nine PVY strains reported to date, including PVY^O (both PVY^O and PVY^O-O5), PVY^N, PVY^NA-N, PVY^NTN, PVY^Z, PVY^E, PVY-NE11, PVY^N-Wi, and PVY^N:O, which is not possible by any of the previously reported RT-PCR procedures. This would make the IC-RT-PCR procedure presented here a method of choice to identify PVY strains and assess the strain composition of PVY in a given area. The IC-RT-PCR protocol was successfully applied to typing PVY isolates in potato leaf tissue collected in the field.

Assessment of SNaPshot and single step RT-qPCR methods for discriminating Potato virus Y (PVY) subgroups

Potato virus Y (PVY) is the most important virus infecting potato (Solanum tuberosum), causing potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD), with a great impact on seed potato production. Numerous PVY strain groups with different pathogenicity and economical impact are distributed worldwide. Tools for accurate and reliable detection and discrimination of PVY strain groups are therefore essential for successful disease management. Two state of the art characterization tools based on detecting molecular markers - RT-qPCR (Kogovsek et al., 2008) and SNaPshot (Rolland et al., 2008) - were assessed for their ability to assign PVY accurately to the correct group. The results were validated by bioassay, ELISA and in silico sequence analysis. The spectrum of PVY strain groups distinguished by SNaPshot is broader than that by RT-qPCR. However, the latter was more reliable in discriminating the PVY(NTN) group members, known for their ability to induce PTNRD on selected potato cultivars. The difference in discrimination precision was due to different molecular markers being targeted by RT-qPCR and SNaPshot. Both tools use genotypic markers for detecting PVY(NTN) strain groups. Future development, however, should be focused on identifying the genomic determinants of the tuber necrosis property. Until then, the RT-qPCR and SNaPshot methods remain the most powerful diagnostic tools for detecting the PVY subgroup isolates found in Europe.

Continuous and emerging challenges of Potato virus Y in potato

Potato virus Y (PVY) is one of the oldest known plant viruses, and yet in the past 20 years it emerged in the United States as a relatively new and very serious problem in potato. The virus exists as a complex of strains that induce a wide variety of foliar and tuber symptoms in potato, leading to yield reduction and loss of tuber quality. PVY has displayed a distinct ability to evolve through accumulation of mutations and more rapidly through recombination between different strains, adapting to new potato cultivars across different environments. Factors behind PVY emergence as a serious potato threat are not clear at the moment, and here an attempt is made to analyze various properties of the virus and its interactions with potato resistance genes and with aphid vectors to explain this recent PVY spread in potato production areas. Recent advances in PVY resistance identification and mapping of corresponding genes are described. An updated classification is proposed for PVY strains that takes into account the most current information on virus molecular genetics, serology, and host reactivity.

Response of Potato Cultivars to Five Isolates Belonging to Four Strains of Potato virus Y

The responses of 14 potato cultivars to five Potato virus Y (PVY) isolates belonging to four strains (ordinary [PVY^O], tobacco veinal necrosis [PVY^N], N:O group [PVY^N:O], and nonrecombinant potato tuber necrotic [PVY^NTN]) were studied in primary and secondary infections. For the primary infection experiments, foliage symptoms were monitored daily after mechanical inoculation with a PVY isolate until harvest; and, for the secondary infection experiments, foliage symptoms were monitored regularly from plant emergence until harvest. Tuber symptoms (namely, tuber necrotic ringspots) were checked at harvest and monthly postharvest for up to 4 months. In both infections, symptoms varied significantly depending on potato cultivar and virus strain or isolate. In primary infections, local lesions occurred on inoculated leaves of 'AC Chaleur', 'Eramosa', 'Goldrush', 'Jemseg', 'Katahdin', 'Ranger Russet', and 'Yukon Gold' after inoculation with PVY^O isolates, followed by systemic necrosis on latterly emerged uninoculated leaves. In contrast, plants of 'CalWhite', 'La Rouge', 'Red LaSoda', 'Russet Burbank', 'Russet Norkotah', and 'Superior' did not exhibit any visible symptoms on inoculated leaves but developed mild to severe mosaic on latterly emerged leaves after infection with PVY^O isolates. In all cultivars, near-symptomless to mild mosaic was induced by PVY^N and mild to severe mosaic by PVY^N:O. PVY^NTN induced mild to severe mosaic in plants of all cultivars except AC Chaleur, 'Cherokee', and Yukon Gold, which developed visible systemic necrosis. Necrotic ringspots were observed in tubers of PVY^NTN-infected plants of AC Chaleur, Cherokee, and Yukon Gold. The tuber symptoms were also incited by PVY^N-Jg on Cherokee. In secondary infections, the symptoms were generally more severe than primary infections even though the symptom types did not alter. As in the greenhouse, a clear symptom severity pattern (PVY^O-FL > PVY^O-RB > PVY^NTN-Sl > PVY^N:O-Mb58 > PVY^N-Jg) was observed in AC Chaleur, Cherokee, Eramosa, Goldrush, Jemseg, Katahdin, Ranger Russet, and Yukon Gold in the field.

Strain specificity and simultaneous transmission of closely related strains of a Potyvirus by Myzus persicae

Potato virus Y (PVY), a Potyvirus, is transmitted by aphids in a nonpersistent manner. PVY severely affects potato production worldwide. Single and mixed infections of PVY strains, namely PVY(O), PVY(NTN), and PVY(N:O) are a common occurrence in potato systems. However, information available on the ability of aphids to simultaneously transmit multiple PVY strains, specificity associated with simultaneous transmission, and factors affecting specificity are limited. Aphid-mediated transmission experiments were conducted to test the ability of individual aphids to transmit multiple strains using a PVY indicator host. Preliminary results revealed that aphids can transmit at least two viral strains simultaneously. Subsequently, aphid-mediated transmission of three dual-strain combinations was tested using potato plants. Individual aphids transmitted two viral strains simultaneously for all three dual-strain combinations. In all aphid-mediated dual-strain infections involving PVY(NTN), the rate of PVY(NTN) infection was greater than the infection rates of the second strain and dual-strain combinations, indicating specificity associated with transmission of PVY strains. Results of aphid-mediated transmission experiments were compared with results obtained through mechanical transmission. In general, PVY infection rates from aphid-mediated transmission were lower than the rates obtained through mechanical transmission. Unlike aphid-mediated transmission, component strains in dual-strain inoculations were not eliminated during mechanical transmission. These results suggest that there may also be interference associated with aphid-mediated transmission of closely related PVY strains. Perhaps, the observed specificity and/or interference may explain the increase in the incidence of PVY(NTN) and other necrotic strains in recent years.

Molecular characterization of two recombinant potato virus Y isolates from China

Isolates of potato virus Y (PVY) have been divided into several strains. We determined the genomic sequences of PVY isolates AQ4 and FZ10 from tobacco in China. AQ4 and FZ10 had genome of 9700 and 9698 nucleotides, respectively. In phylogenetic analysis of complete genome sequences, AQ4 was clustered with strain N-Wi, and FZ10 with NTN. AQ4 had two recombination sites within the P1 and P3 genes, while FZ10 had three within the P1, P3 and NIa-Pro genes. When compared to typical NTN isolates, FZ10 lacked a recombination site within the CP gene and, thus, represents a novel recombination type of PVY.

Differential pathogenicity of two different recombinant PVY(NTN) isolates in Physalis floridana is likely determined by the coat protein gene

A previous study has identified two types of recombinant variants of Potato virus Y strain NTN (PVY(NTN)) in China and sequenced the complete genome of the variant PVY(NTN)-HN2. In this study, the complete genome of isolate PVY(NTN)-HN1 was fully sequenced and analyzed. The most striking difference between the two variants was the location of recombinant joint three (RJ3). In PVY(NTN)-HN1, like other typical European-PVY(NTN) isolates such as PVY(NTN)-Hun, the RJ3 was located at nucleotide (nt) 9183, namely the 3' proximal end of the CP gene (nt. 8571-9371), thus leading to most (the first 613 nucleotides from the 5' proximal end) of the CP gene (801 bp) with a PVYN origin and PVYN-serotype; whereas in contrast, the RJ3 in PVY(NTN)-HN2 was located at nt 8572, consequently leading to a CP gene of PVYO origin and PVYO-serotype. The varied genome composition among PVY(O), PVY(N), PVY(N:O), PVY(NTN_-HN1 and PVY(NTN)-HN2 made them useful for the investigation of possible roles of gene segment(s) in symptom formation on host plants. When Physalis floridana plants were infected with different PVY isolates, two types of symptoms were induced. PVY(N) and PVY(NTN)-HN1 induced mild symptoms (mainly mild mottling) whereas PVY(O), PVY(N:O) and PVY(NTN)-HN2 induced serve symptoms including leaf and stem necrosis, leaf-drop and stunting. These results, together with a previous study using artificial PVY chimeras, demonstrate that the CP gene, especially the 5' proximal segment (nt 8572-9183), and/or CP likely determine the pathogenicity of PVY in P. floridana.

Recognition and Molecular Discrimination of Severe and Mild PVYO Variants of Potato virus Y in Potato in New Brunswick, Canada

A field isolate of Potato virus Y (PVY) was collected in New Brunswick, Canada in 2007 due to unusual symptoms observed on different potato cultivars. To unveil the PVY strain identity, tobacco and potato bioassays, PVY^O and PVY^N-specific antibody-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays, and reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based genotyping were carried out. All the assays demonstrated that the isolate, designated as PVY^O-FL in this study, belonged to the PVY^O strain group. Greenhouse tests with the potato cvs. FL 1533 and Jemseg confirmed the severe nature of infection by PVY^O-FL. The complete genome sequences of PVY^O-FL and PVY^O-RB, the latter a mild PVY^O isolate, were determined. BLAST analysis revealed that the two isolates shared 97 and 98% sequence identities at the nucleotide and polyprotein levels, respectively. Further BLAST analysis unveiled that PVY^O-FL shared 99.7% nucleotide sequence identity with PVY^O-Oz, an isolate reported in New York, United States, whereas the PVY^O-RB isolate shared 99.2% sequence identity with PVY^O-139, a PVY^O isolate reported in New Brunswick, Canada. A phylogenetic tree of available, full-length sequences of PVY isolates demonstrated two subgroups within the PVY^O branch, one clustered with PVY^O-RB and the other with PVY^O-FL. Group-specific sense primers for differentiation of the two subgroups were developed and evaluated. A limited survey of potato tubers collected from a field plot at the Potato Research Centre, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, using the newly developed PCR primers, indicated that 65.3 and 2.4% of the PVY^O-positive tubers were infected with PVY^O isolates belonging to the PVY^O-FL and PVY^O-RB subgroups, respectively. Assessment of the pathogenicity of three representative isolates from each subgroup on the potato cv. Jemseg demonstrated that severe and mild symptoms were induced by the PVY^O-FL-like and PVY^O-RB-like isolates, respectively.

Development and application of a multiplex reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction assay for screening a global collection of Citrus tristeza virus isolates

The emerging diversity of Citrus tristeza virus (CTV) genotypes has complicated detection and diagnostic measures and prompted the search for new differentiation methods. To simplify the identification and differentiation of CTV genotypes, a multiplex reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) technique for the screening of CTV isolates was developed. Variable regions within the open reading frame (ORF)-1a of diverse CTV genotypes were identified to develop first a simplex (S) and then a hexaplex (H) RT-PCR. CTV isolates have been grouped previously into five genotypes (namely, T3, T30, T36, VT, and B165) based on the nucleotide sequence comparisons and phylogenetic analyses. Nucleotide sequences from GenBank were used to design species and genotype-specific primers (GSPs). The GSPs were initially used for reliable detection of all CTV genotypes using S-RT-PCR. Furthermore, detection of all five recognized CTV genotypes was established using the H-RT-PCR. Six amplicons, one generic to all CTV isolates and one for each of the five recognized genotypes, were identified on the basis of their size and were confirmed by sequence analysis. In all, 175 CTV isolates from 29 citrus-growing countries were successfully analyzed by S- and H-RT-PCR. Of these, 97 isolates contained T36 genotypes, 95 contained T3 genotypes, 76 contained T30 genotypes, 71 contained VT genotypes, and 24 contained B165 genotype isolates. In total, 126 isolates contained mixed infections of 2 to 5 of the known CTV genotypes. Two of the CTV isolates could not be assigned to a known genotype. H-RT-PCR provides a sensitive, specific, reliable, and rapid way to screen for CTV genotypes compared with other methods for CTV genotype detection. Efficient identification of CTV genotypes will facilitate a better understanding of CTV isolates, including the possible interaction of different genotypes in causing or preventing diseases. The methods described can also be used in virus-free citrus propagation programs and in the development of CTV-resistant cultivars.

Genomic variability in potato virus M and the development of RT-PCR and RFLP procedures for the detection of this virus in seed potatoes

Potato virus M (PVM, Carlavirus) is considered to be one of the most common potato viruses distributed worldwide. Sequences of the coat protein (CP) gene of several Canadian PVM isolates were determined. Phylogenetic analysis indicated that all known PVM isolates fell into two distinct groups and the isolates from Canada and the US clustered in the same group. The Canadian PVM isolates could be further divided into two sub-groups. Two molecular procedures, reverse transcription - polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) were developed in this study for the detection and identification of PVM in potato tubers. RT-PCR was highly specific and only amplified PVM RNA from potato samples. PVM RNAs were easily detected in composite samples of 400 to 800 potato leaves or 200 to 400 dormant tubers. Restriction analysis of PCR amplicons with MscI was a simple method for the confirmation of PCR tests. Thus, RT-PCR followed by RFLP analysis may be a useful approach for screening potato samples on a large scale for the presence of PVM.

Detection of viral infections by an oligonucleotide microarray

The success of DNA expression microarrays has been followed by applications of this technology to molecular diagnosis, mainly in the fields of biology and medicine. The experiments described below apply microarray diagnosis to agriculture. This report presents results of field tests for a DNA microarray designed to diagnose major viral potato pathogens. The assays were performed on samples that had been tested previously for the presence of viral infection by ELISA. RNA isolation methods were optimised for high sensitivity, using only 3 microg of total RNA that were reverse transcribed using random hexamers, with the resulting cDNA hybridised after labelling to an oligonucleotide array. The results obtained confirm the presence of pathogens indicated by ELISA and simultaneously reveal other viruses in the same reaction, showing that this method is appropriate for rapid detection of mixed viral infections. This observation was verified by subsequent RT-PCR and sequencing.

The simultaneous differentiation of Potato virus Y strains including the newly described strain PVY(NTN-NW) by multiplex PCR assay

New recombinant strain and genotype of PVY, designated as PVY(NTN-NW) and SYR-III, respectively, shared properties with PVY(NTN) and PVY(N)W has been reported recently. PVY(NTN-NW) predominated in potato fields in Syria and was able to induce potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD). Due to the rapid spread of the recombinant strains of PVY which might be the case of PVY(NTN-NW), a specific and reliable detection method is an essential step to control this strain and minimize its spread. The shared properties of PVY(NTN-NW) and SYR-III with PVY(NTN) and PVY(N)W, however, complicate their identification involving multiple detection methods. Therefore, a multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR), that relies on a combination of previously published and newly designed primers was developed for the detection and identification of PVY(NTN-NW) and SYR-III in single or mixed infections with the main PVY strains, PVY(O), PVY(N), PVY(NTN) and PVY(N)W. In addition, the present PCR assay was able to detect the recombination points in the P1 region enabling the differentiation of the variable genotypes of the recombinant strains PVY(NTN-NW), PVY(NTN) and PVY(N)W. The reliability of this PCR assay was confirmed using a significant number of well characterized PVY isolates collected from Syria and Japan including those of PVY(NTN-NW), SYR-III, PVY(O), NA-PVY(N), PVY(N)W and PVY(NTN).

NE-11 represents a new strain variant class of Potato virus Y

This report describes the characterization by whole-genome sequencing of four PVY isolates with unique combinations of molecular and symptomatic characteristics. Three of these four isolates were of type PVY(N:O) (ID-1, OR-1, PN10A), including one of "type B", which contains an extra recombination event in the 5'UTR/P1 cistron; the other (NE-11) represents a novel PVY molecular genotype, previously misclassified as a PVY(NA-NTN) isolate. The full genome sequence of this latter isolate is unique inasmuch as it is nearly identical to that of PVY(N) isolates for the first 2,000 nucleotides (nts), after which it very strongly resembles PVY(NA-NTN) isolates for the next 600 nts. For the final 7,000 nts of its genome, NE-11 shares intermediate identity with these other two previously reported classes of PVY(N) genomes, except for a portion of the capsid protein region in which it resembles neither. Recombination in each of the four isolates was verified by a suite of recombination detection programs. PN10A represents the first complete sequence of a PVY strain variant of the class reported as PVY(N)-W (or PVY(N:O)) type B. Specific PCR assays for two unique regions of NE-11 are presented that will allow the identification of this strain variant by other researchers.

Genetic structure of a population of Potato virus Y inducing potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease in Japan; comparison with North American and European populations

The structure of Potato virus Y (PVY) populations causing potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD) was analysed. The full-length sequences of the genomic RNAs of five geographically distinct isolates from Japan were determined. Recombination and phylogenetic analyses of European, North American and Japanese isolates of PVY showed that the world PVY population has three major lineages and two sublineages. Most recombinants were interlineage, and one isolate from Europe was identified as an intralineage recombinant. No recombinants were found among Japanese PTNRD isolates, which were most closely related to PTNRD isolates previously found in North America. Comparison of the within- and between population nucleotide diversities in the N lineage sequences from Japan, Europe and North America showed that Japanese population was distinct from the European and North American populations. The nucleotide sequences of the protein 1 and coat protein genes of a further 18 isolates were determined. One Japanese clade had radiated in a star burst as shown by its deviation from the neutral equilibrium model and its small nucleotide diversity. Our results suggest that PVY PTNRD was recently introduced into Japan more than once, and has expanded throughout Japan from founder populations.

Discussion paper: The naming of Potato virus Y strains infecting potato

Potato virus Y (PVY) strain groups are based on host response and resistance gene interactions. The strain groups PVY(O), PVY(C) and PVY(N) are well established for the isolates infecting potato in the field. A switch in the emphasis from host response to nucleotide sequence differences in the virus genomes, detection of isolates recombining sequences of different strains, and the need to recognize isolates that cause necrotic symptoms in potato tubers have led to the assignment of new acronyms, especially to isolates of the PVY(N) strain group. This discussion paper proposes that any newly found isolates should be described within the context of the original strain groups based on the original methods of distinguishing strains (i.e., tobacco and potato assays involving use of 'differential' potato cultivars). Additionally, sequence characterization of the complete genomes of isolates is highly recommended. However, it is acceptable to amend the names of PVY isolates with additional, specific codes to show that the isolate differs at the molecular, serological or phenotypic level from the typical strains within a strain group. The new isolates should preferably not be named using geographical, cultivar, or place-association designations. Since many new variants of PVY are being discovered, any new static classification system will be meaningless for the time being. A more systematic investigation and characterization of PVY from potato at the biological and molecular levels should eventually result in a biologically meaningful genetic strain concept.

A multiple single nucleotide polymorphisms interrogation assay for reliable Potato virus Y group and variant characterization

The complex Potato virus Y classification, including groups (PVYN and PVYO) and variants (PVYNTN and PVYN-W), is based mainly on biological properties of isolates. Published PVY detection tools targeting markers not associated with biological properties could fail to assign correctly isolates in the current classification. To improve PVY detection tools, a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNaPshot) detection assay was developed. The technique was adapted to target the T/C9259, A/C2271, G/C8573 and A/G2213 PVY polymorphic nucleotides. The "TAGA", "CCCG", "CACA" and "CAGA" four-digit codes associated with tested samples allowed identification of PVYN, PVYO, PVYN-W and PVYNTN isolates, respectively. The PVY SNaPshot procedure is efficient and reliable for PVY detection and characterization in samples containing as few as 10(2) viral RNA copies. Moreover, PVY group assignment is possible for fractions containing only 10 copies of a PVY RNA genome. Finally, the SNaPshot assay allows PVY(N)/PVYO dual characterization for mixed samples containing PVYN/PVYO quantity ratios in the range of 0.1-10. This innovative SNaPshot tool improved clearly PVY diagnostic assays described previously by targeting simultaneously major functional markers and sequence unlinked to biological properties used separately in PVY detection tools available currently.

The role of the coat protein region in symptom formation on Physalis floridana varies between PVY strains

The Potato virus Y (PVY) cDNA full-length clone created by Jakab et al. [Jakab, G., Droz, E., Brigneti, G., Baulcombe, D., Malnoë, P., 1997. Infectious in vivo and in vitro transcripts from a full-length cDNA clone of PVY-N605, a Swiss necrotic isolate of potato virus Y. J. Gen. Virol. 78, 3141-3145] was stabilized by inserting three introns into putatively toxic genes. Using this clone, hybrid viruses were constructed by in vitro recombination. The PVY-N/NTN and PVY-N/O chimeras carried the 3' end of NIb, the whole CP and 3'UTR region of PVY(NTN) and PVY(O), respectively, in a PVY(N) genetic background. The clones proved to be stable after several passages by re-sequencing the exchanged region. Both hybrid viruses showed reduced infectivity in particle bombardment experiments, but they were suitable for further mechanical plant inoculation. In five of the six host plant species, inoculated with the two chimeras and three parental strains, the chimeras produced similar symptoms to those of PVY(N). By contrast, Physalis floridana reacted with different pattern of symptoms. In this species, the symptoms caused by the N/O hybrid were similar to those of the 3'NIb-CP-donating PVY(O) strain, and not to those of the background (PVY(N)). The results suggest that symptom determinants may be different even between strains of the same virus species in a particular host.

Rapid identification of potato virus Y strains by one-step triplex RT-PCR

A one-step triplex RT-PCR method was characterised that allows rapid, strain-specific detection of potato virus Y (PVY) occurring on potato: PVY(N), PVY(O), PVY(NTN) (recombinant isolates), PVY(N)Wi and PVY(C). Three specific primer pairs were designed on aligned PVY sequences available from genomic data banks. The specificity of the selected primers was first examined by simplex RT-PCR with a large number of PVY reference isolates. Two fragments of 0.44 and 1.11kb were amplified for PVY(N) and non-recombinant PVY(NTN) isolates, two fragments of 0.53 and 0.66kb for PVY(O) isolates, a single fragment of 0.44kb for recombinant PVY(NTN) isolates, a 0.66kb fragment for PVY(C) isolates and a 0.53kb fragment for PVY(N)Wi isolate. The primers were then combined in a one-step triplex RT-PCR reaction, optimised stepwise and validated with the reference isolates. The great similarity between the genomes of PVY(N) and non-recombinant PVY(NTN) prevented their differentiation using this method. No fragments were amplified with samples infected by non-related potato viruses, as well as with samples from healthy tobacco and potato plants. The one-step triplex RT-PCR described here fastens specific detection of PVY strains that are otherwise only distinguishable by combined serological and biological assays.

Differentiation of Potato virus Y strains using improved sets of diagnostic PCR-primers

Potato virus Y (PVY) is one of the most important viruses of potato world-wide, several strain groups are recognized. In the past two decades, novel PVY variants have appeared causing necrotic symptoms on potato tubers. Implicated are two groups of recombinant strains: PVY(N)W and PVY(NTN), and NA-PVY(NTN). While the first two are recombinants between PVY-N- and O-strains the latter is a recombinant between an N-strain and an unknown PVY strain or other Potyvirus. Available biological and molecular data on PVY suggest that classification of PVY strains has to be revised. Some drawbacks have been found with recently published primers used in RT-PCR based differentiation of PVY strains as some defined isolates could not be identified correctly. Consequently we developed new primers using both recently available sequences and newly generated complete sequences of PVY strains. The reliability of these newly developed primers and procedures was successfully demonstrated on nearly 100 biologically and serologically characterised PVY isolates.

Identification, Characterization, and Molecular Detection of Alfalfa mosaic virus in Potato

ABSTRACT Alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV) was detected in potato fields in several provinces in Canada and characterized by bioassay, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, and reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). The identity of eight Canadian potato AMV isolates was confirmed by sequence analysis of their coat protein (CP) gene. Sequence and phylogenetic analysis indicated that these eight AMV potato isolates fell into one strain group, whereas a slight difference between Ca175 and the other Canadian AMV isolates was revealed. The Canadian AMV isolates, except Ca175, clustered together among other strains based on alignment of the CP gene sequence. To detect the virus, a pair of primers, AMV-F and AMV-R, specific to the AMV CP gene, was designed based on the nucleotide sequence alignment of known AMV strains. Evaluations showed that RT-PCR using this primer set was specific and sensitive for detecting AMV in potato leaf and tuber samples. AMV RNAs were easily detected in composite samples of 400 to 800 potato leaves or 200 to 400 tubers. Restriction analysis of PCR amplicons with SacI was a simple method for the confirmation of PCR tests. Thus, RT-PCR followed by restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis may be a useful approach for screening potato samples on a large scale for the presence of AMV.

The Occurrence of PVYO, PVYN, and PVYN:O Strains of Potato virus Y in Certified Potato Seed Lot Trials in Washington and Oregon

Totals of 960 and 286 certified potato seed lots from locations across North America were planted in trials in Washington and Oregon, respectively, in 2001 to 2003 and tested for strains of Potato virus Y (PVY). The incidence of PVY^O-infected lots averaged 16.4 and 25.9% in the Washington and Oregon trials, respectively. There was a general trend of increasing incidence of the PVY^O, PVY^N:O, and PVY^N strains during this period, as evidenced by more infected cultivars, sites of seed origin, and number of seed growers providing infected seed lots. In particular, there was a dramatic increase in seed lots with the PVY^N:O strain from 2002 to 2003. PVY^N:O, in contrast to PVY^O, which only causes yield reduction, also causes internal and external damage to tubers, making them unmarketable. In 2003, PVY^N:O occurred in seed lots originating in eight states and three Canadian provinces. The increased incidence of PVY^N:O was likely due to the difficulty in differentiating this strain from PVY^O. The prevalence of PVY in potato seed lots documented herein poses a threat to potato production in the United States and suggests that current measures to reduce the incidence of this virus are inadequate.

A Multiplex PCR Assay to Characterize Potato virus Y Isolates and Identify Strain Mixtures

Potato virus Y (PVY) has become a serious problem for the seed potato industry, with increased incidence and rejection of seed lots submitted for certification. New PVY strains and strain variants have emerged in recent decades in Europe and North America, including the PVY^N strain that causes veinal necrosis in tobacco, and strain variants that represent one or three recombination events between the common strain (PVY^O) and PVY^N. Several reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assays have been described that characterize PVY isolates as to strain type, but they are limited in their ability to detect some combinations of mixed strain infections. We report here the development of a single multiplex RT-PCR assay that can assign PVY strain type and detect mixed infections with respect to the major strain types. Validation of this assay was achieved using 119 archived PVY isolates, which had been previously characterized by serology and bioassay and/or previously published RT-PCR assays. Results for single-strain isolates were comparable to previous results in most cases. Interestingly, 16 mixed infections were distinguished that had previously gone undetected. The new multiplex RT-PCR assay will be useful for researchers and seed production specialists interested in determining PVY infection type using a single assay.

Improvement of Potato virus Y (PVY) detection and quantitation using PVY(N)- and PVY(O)-specific real-time RT-PCR assays

A Potato virus Y (PVY) single nucleotide polymorphism (A/G(2213)), recently identified as a molecular determinant of the tobacco leaf necrosis symptom induced by PVY(N) isolates, has been used as a target to develop two PVY group-specific (PVY(N) and PVY(O)) fluorescent (TaqMan-based) real-time RT-PCR assays. These procedures allow detection, characterisation, and quantitation of a wide range of PVY isolates in samples containing 10(3)-10(8) viral transcripts. Moreover, the high specificity of these two new assays make the simultaneous detection and the reliable quantitation of PVY(N) and PVY(O) isolates in mixed solutions, regardless of the Y(N)/Y(O) ratio, feasible. The high sensitivity (threshold of 10(3) copies per reaction) and the PVY group specificity of these two new PVY detection tools clearly improve previously published PVY detection tests and offer new opportunities for PVY research programs.

Biological and Serological Properties of Potato virus Y Isolates in Northeastern United States Potato

A survey of six potato viruses, Potato virus A (PVA), Potato virus M (PVM), Potato virus S(PVS), Potato virus X (PVX), Potato virus Y (PVY), and Potato leafroll virus (PLRV), was conducted in New York and Maine during 2002 and 2003. Leaf samples were tested by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and PVY-positive samples were further tested to determine whether a necrotic strain of PVY (PVY^N) or a strain able to induce necrosis in tobacco and in potato tubers (PVY^NTN) were present. In both years, PVY and PVS were identified in a majority of the samples, and mixed infections predominated in 83% of the symptomatic leaves in 2002. Of the total 394 PVY-positive samples, 3 reacted with monoclonal antibody (MAb) 1F5 and caused veinal necrosis (VN) in tobacco. Two of these isolates caused tuber necrosis in the potato cv. Yukon Gold. Three PVY isolates reacted with MAb 1F5 but did not cause VN in tobacco, and two caused VN but did not react with MAb 1F5. None of these eight isolates were able to overcome the Ry resistance gene in the potato cultivar Eva, but several were able to overcome the Ny resistance gene found in Allegany. PVY^N isolates were not widespread in the northeastern United States; however, several PVY isolates differed from both PVY^N and the ordinary strain of PVY and may represent strain recombinants.

Whole genome characterization of Potato virus Y isolates collected in the western USA and their comparison to isolates from Europe and Canada

Potato virus Y (PVY) is a serious potato pathogen that affects potato seed and commercial production crops. In recent decades, novel PVY strains have been described that cause necrotic symptoms on tobacco foliage and/or potato tubers. The major PVY strains that affect potato include PVY(O) and PVY(N), which have distinct serotypes that can be differentiated by immunoassay. Other economically important strain variants are derived from recombination events, including variants that cause tuber necrotic symptoms (PVY(NTN)) and PVY(O) serotypes that cause tobacco veinal necrosis (PVY(N)-W, PVY(N:O)). Although the PVY(NTN) and PVY(N)-W variants were first reported in Europe, apparently similar strains have been appearing in North America. Confirmation of the existence of these recombinant strains in North America is important, as is whether they spread from a common source or were derived by independent recombination. Whole genome sequencing can be used to positively identify strain variants and begin to address the issue of origins. Symptomology, serology, RT-PCR, and partial sequencing of the coat protein region were used to identify isolates of the PVY(NTN), PVY(N), PVY(NA-N), and PVY(N:O) for whole-genome sequencing. Sequencing confirmed the presence of PVY(NTN) and PVY(N) isolates that were >99% identical to European sequences deposited in GenBank in the 1990's. Sequences of the PVY(NA-N) and PVY(N:O) types were 99.0% and 99.5% identical to known sequences, respectively. There was no indication that recombinant strains PVY(NTN) or PVY(N:O) had different parental origins than recombinant strains previously sequenced. This is the first confirmation by whole-genome sequencing that "European"-type strain variants of PVY(N) and PVY(NTN) are present in North America, and the first reported full-length sequence of a tuber necrotic isolate of PVY(N:O).

Specific detection of the PVY(N)-W variant of Potato virus Y

PVY(N)-W is one of the variant populations of Potato virus Y (PVY). This variant is of concern in seed potato production and requires a specific diagnosis since it induces more or less symptomless infections and is not detectable easily in field inspections. Moreover, this variant is serologically indistinguishable from the common strain PVY(O). This study describes a simple and specific molecular detection test for the PVY(N)-W variant using a PCR protocol based on the recombinant point within the HC-Pro/P3 region of PVY(N) variants (PVY(NTN), PVY(N)-W). To avoid both detection of recombinant PVY(NTN) and PVY(N)-W isolates, a forward PVY(N)-like primer located in the HC-Pro region coupled to a reverse PVY(O)-like primer located in the NIa region was designed to amplify a specific PCR product of 4114 nt from PVY(N)-W isolates. This technique was assessed on 41 PVY reference and field isolates. Only isolates referenced as PVY(N)-W were amplified and gave the expected PCR product of 4114 nt, whereas no band was obtained from PVY(N), PVY(NTN) or PVY(O) isolates. In conclusion, this PVY(N)-W diagnosis tool is rapid, easy-to-use and suitable for large-scale testing in laboratories of seed potato certification.

A single nucleotide polymorphism-based technique for specific characterization of YO and YN isolates of Potato virus Y (PVY)

One of the most important properties used to classify Potato virus Y (PVY) isolates is their ability to induce (PVY(N)) or not (PVY(O)) veinal necrosis symptoms on the indicator host plant Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi. As an alternative to biological assays, several serological and molecular detection tools have been developed for PVY detection and characterization and these have evolved as our knowledge of PVY has improved. However, the assays that have been previously published are all based on the use of neutral markers (antigenic determinants, sequence data, recombination sites or restriction enzyme cleavage sites), which are unlinked to the biological property being characterized (e.g. veinal necrosis). Using the recently identified molecular determinants of the tobacco leaf necrosis symptom induced by PVY(N) isolates, a one-step fluorescent [TaqMan] RT-PCR assay, based on a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) linked to the necrosis property of PVY isolates, has been designed. This assay reliably detects and distinguishes PVY(N) and PVY(O) isolates. The method is simple (leaf soak extraction process, gel-free, no post-PCR manipulations), rapid (96 tests in less than 3h from plants sampling to diagnostic results), sensitive (threshold in a range of 10(4)-10(5) PVY copies), reliable (correctly assigns 42 PVY isolates in their respective group) and allows co-detection of mixed samples containing close to equivalent PVY(N) and PVY(O) quantities. All these characteristics suggest that the newly developed SNP assay could be used to reliably classify PVY isolates, as a substitute for biological assays performed on N. tabacum cv. Xanthi.

Diversity Among Potato virus Y Isolates Obtained from Potatoes Grown in the United States

ABSTRACT Potato field isolates (Solanum tuberosum) of Potato virus Y (PVY) collected from the midwestern and western United States were characterized using serological, molecular, and biological assays. PVY field isolates were grouped into the previously defined categories: PVY(O), European PVY(NTN), North American PVY(NTN), and PVY(N:O) recombinant and four previously undefined groups. Studies reported here agree with published reports from Europe and elsewhere in North America as PVY isolates capable of causing veinal necrosis in tobacco indicator plants appear in high frequency. In contrast to European experiences, PVY tuber necrosis isolates have a PVY(O) coat protein rather than that of PVY(N). Several PVY(N:O) recombinant isolates induced potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD) in the highly susceptible potato cv. Yukon Gold. The PTNRD symptoms produced by these PVY(N:O) recombinants were atypical compared with lesions found on the same cultivar infected with either the European or North American PVY(NTN) isolates. These PVY(N:O) isolates produced a roughly circular, sunken necrotic lesion on the surface of the tuber instead of the typical external sunken ring pattern displayed by PVY(NTN) isolates. This study establishes the complex nature of PVY populations within the U.S. potato industry and clearly demonstrates the diverse nature of PVY in the United States.