Recombinant virus-expressed bovine cytokines do not improve efficacy of a bovine herpesvirus 1 marker vaccine strain

A retrospective evaluation of pooled serum ELISA testing in the frame of the French eradication program for infectious bovine rhinotracheitis

Pooled serum testing using whole-virus indirect ELISA has been recently recognized as an official method for surveillance of bovine herpesvirus 1 (BoHV1) in cattle herds in Europe. In this study, a retrospective analysis of data from the French BoHV1 surveillance campaign 2018-2019, including 7434 BoHV1-free certified herds and 157 infected herds, was performed in order to evaluate the diagnostic specificity and sensitivity of two pooled serum indirect ELISAs (from IDEXX and IDVet), in comparison with individual testing by blocking ELISAs targeting the gB and gE proteins. Pooled serum testing showed a relative specificity higher than 97.5% and a detection rate of 100% since all gB+/gE+ samples were found in positive pools. At the herd level, no more than one false positive pool was observed in most of BoHV1-free certified herds, leading to a herd relative specificity of 85.1% and 86.0% for the IDEXX and IDVet pooled serum ELISAs, respectively. Among infected herds tested by pool sizes up to 10 sera (n = 122), 46% of herds were detected through pools of size 10 containing a single positive sample, 23% through pools of size 10 containing at least two positive samples, and 31% through pools of smaller sizes. A complementary study based on manually constituted pools revealed that at least one positive sample in 100% and 93.4% of herds could be detected individually by pools of size 10 with the IDEXX and IDVet ELISAs, respectively. However, pooled serum ELISAs were influenced by the level of individual reactivity, since pools composed of either one weak-positive sample or one gB+/gE- sample could yield negative results. Altogether, these results provided the first evidence that pooled serum testing (pool size up to 10) is a suitable strategy for surveillance of BoHV1-free cattle farms.

Serological Cross-Reactivity Between Bovine alphaherpesvirus 2 and Bovine alphaherpesvirus 1 in a gB-ELISA: A Case Report in Italy

In this study, we demonstrated for the first time in Italy, the serological cross-reactivity between Bovine alphaherpesvirus 2 (BoHV-2) and Bovine alphaherpesvirus 1 (BoHV-1). Five months after arriving at a performance test station in Central Italy, a 6-month-old calf, which was part of a group of 57 animals, tested positive for BoHV-1 in a commercial gB-ELISA test. It was immediately transferred to the quarantine unit and subjected to clinical observation and serological and virological investigations. During this period, the calf showed no clinical signs. The results from laboratory investigations demonstrated the presence of antibodies via competitive glycoprotein B (gB) ELISAs, indirect BoHV-1 ELISAs, and indirect BoHV-2 ELISAs. Furthermore, the plaque reduction assay provided evidence for the presence of antibodies only for BoHV-2, whereas the virus neutralization test showed negative results for both BoHV-1 and BoHV-5. These findings strongly suggest the occurrence of a serological cross-reactivity between BoHV-2 and BoHV-1. Interference of BoHV-2 antibodies in serological BoHV-1 diagnostics should be considered during routine IBR tests, especially when animals are kept in a performance test station.

Improvement of eradication program for infectious bovine rhinotracheitis in France inferred by serological monitoring of singleton reactors in certified BoHV1-free herds

Within the framework of the national voluntary eradication program for Bovine alphaherpesvirus 1 (BoHV1) in France, the proportion of certified-free herds which experienced no more than two positive animals (termed singleton reactors) steadily increased to reach up to 95% in 2015. The aim of this study was to collate and evaluate serological data to gain insight into these epidemiological questionable BoHV1 seropositive animals. Preliminary evaluation of the performances of BoHV1 ELISA kits using a collection of 997 field sera with well-defined status revealed a relatively low specificity of the two gB blocking ELISAs most used in France for confirmatory testing (93.2% and 97.5% for gB-IDVet and gB-Idexx, respectively). In both ELISAs, the suboptimal specificity was associated with the presence of antibodies against BoHV2. Reassessment of the cut-offs led to a specificity and a sensitivity higher than 99.3%. Consequently, a comprehensive analysis of gB-positive sera from 2551 singleton reactors was performed by using gB ELISAs with optimized cut-offs, combined with viral neutralization test (campaign 2014-2015) or gE ELISA (campaign 2015-2016). Fifty percent of the 728 sera collected in 2014-2015 reacted below the optimized cut-offs in both gB ELISAs. Analysis of new blood samples collected at a minimum 6-week interval showed that these weak-positive reactions did not increase with time and could not be confirmed by confirmatory tests. Among the 1823 sera collected in 2015-2016, only 84 samples tested positive by gE ELISA, most of them corresponding to sera with reactivity above the optimized cut-offs in gB ELISAs. Screening for BoHV2 antibodies revealed a significantly increased prevalence among herds with singleton reactors, compared with the between-herd prevalence in French cattle herds. Altogether, these results provided suitable analytical strategies to limit the occurrence of false-positive BoHV1 reactions and inappropriate withdrawal of the BoHV1-free status, without alteration of diagnostic costs and reliability of eradication programs.

A triple gene mutant of BoHV-1 administered intranasally is significantly more efficacious than a BoHV-1 glycoprotein E-deleted virus against a virulent BoHV-1 challenge

Bovine herpesvirus 1 (BoHV-1) causes respiratory infections and abortions in cattle, and is an important component of bovine respiratory disease complex, which causes a considerable economic loss worldwide. Several efforts have been made to produce safer and more effective vaccines. One of these vaccines is a glycoprotein E (gE)-deleted marker vaccine which is currently mandated for use in EU countries. In the present study, we have constructed a three-gene-mutated BoHV-1 vaccine virus (UL49.5 luminal domain residues 30-32 and cytoplasmic tail residues 80-96 deleted, gE cytoplasmic tail- and entire Us9-deleted) and compared its protective vaccine efficacy in calves after intranasal vaccination with that of a gE-deleted virus. Following vaccination, both the triple mutant and gE-deleted vaccine virus replicated well in the nasal epithelium of the calves. The vaccinated calves did not show any clinical signs. Four weeks post-vaccination, the animals were challenged intranasally with a virulent BoHV-1 wild-type virus. Based on clinical signs, both the gE-deleted and triple mutant group were protected equally against the virulent BoHV-1 challenge. However, based on the quantity and duration of nasal viral shedding, virus neutralizing antibody and cellular immune responses, the triple mutant virus vaccine induced a significantly better protective immune response than the gE-deleted virus vaccine. Notably, after the virulent BoHV-1 challenge, the triple mutant virus vaccinated group cleared the challenge virus three days earlier than the BoHV-1 gE-deleted virus vaccinated group.

Cell-mediated immune responses induced by BHV-1: rational vaccine design

Bovine herpesvirus-1 (BHV-1) is one of the major respiratory pathogens in cattle worldwide. Although antibodies have been correlated with protection and recovery from BHV-1 infection, the cell-mediated immune response is also a critical defense mechanism because cell-to-cell spread occurs before hematogenous spread. Furthermore, induction of robust T-cell memory is critical for the long-term duration of immunity. Among current commercial vaccines, the attenuated conventional vaccines induce a balanced immune response and long-term memory but may result in viral shedding. By contrast, inactivated vaccines primarily elicit a humoral immune response and relative short-term memory. These vaccines do not allow differentiation of vaccinated from infected cattle. Recent efforts are focusing on the development of vaccines that induce a balanced immune response and long-term memory, as well as having differentiation markers. This includes well-defined genetically engineered gene-deleted, subunit and vectored vaccines.

Improving vaccines by incorporating immunological coadjuvants

While vaccination continues to be the most successful interventionist health policy to date, infectious disease remains a significant cause of death worldwide. A primary reason that vaccination is not able to generate effective immunity is a lack of appropriate adjuvants capable of initiating the desired immune response. Adjuvant combinations can potentially overcome this problem; however, the possible permutations to consider, which include the route and kinetics of vaccination, as well as combinations of adjuvants, are practically limitless. This review aims to summarize the current understanding of adjuvants and related immunological processes and how this knowledge can and has been applied to the strategic selection of adjuvant combinations as components of vaccines against human infectious disease.

Effect of foot-and-mouth disease virus capsid precursor protein and 3C protease expression on bovine herpesvirus 1 replication

Several reports have previously shown that expression of the foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) capsid precursor protein encoding region P1-2A together with the 3C protease (P1-2A/3C) results in correct processing of the capsid precursor into VP0, VP1 and VP3 and formation of FMDV capsid structures that are able to induce a protective immune response against FMDV challenge after immunization using naked DNA constructs or recombinant viruses. To elucidate whether bovine herpesvirus 1 (BHV-1) might also be suitable as a viral vector for empty capsid generation, we aimed to integrate a P1-2A/3C expression cassette into the BHV-1 genome, which, however, failed repeatedly. In contrast, BHV-1 recombinants that expressed an inactive 3C protease or the P1-2A polyprotein alone could be easily generated, although the recombinant that expressed P1-2A exhibited a defect in direct cell-cell spread and release of infectious particles. These results suggested that expression of the original, active FMDV 3C protease is not compatible with BHV-1 replication. This conclusion is supported by the isolation of recombinant BHV-1/3C*, which contained mutations within the 3C ORF (3C* ORF)--probably introduced spontaneously during generation of BHV-1/3C*--instead of the authentic 3C ORF contained in the transfer plasmids. Within the 3C* ORF, the codons for glycine 38 and phenylalanine 48 were both substituted by codons for serine. The resulting 3C* protease exhibits a highly reduced activity for proteolytic processing of the P1-2A polyprotein and thus might be a good candidate for the generation of live attenuated FMDV variants.

Modified bovine herpesvirus 1 for protein secretion

The traditional way to utilize bovine herpesvirus 1 (BHV-1) and many other herpesviruses as vectors for synthesis of heterologous proteins like reporter proteins, antigens, or immunomodulatory active molecules was (and still is) the expression of the protein of interest from an entire gene consisting of promoter, 5'- and 3'-noncoding regions, the open reading frame (ORF), and a signal sequence for polyadenylation. This approach is doubtlessly appropriate especially in cases when expression of large proteins or of proteins that do not enter the secretory pathway is envisaged. My laboratory has developed an alternative expression strategy for secreted proteins and peptides that uses the essential BHV-1 glycoprotein B (gB) as transporter for a cargo protein that is embedded in gB as a furin-excisable polypeptide that is released from the gB precursor molecule in the trans-Golgi network by the ubiquitously present endoprotease furin. The general applicability of this novel expression strategy is demonstrated by using GFP as reporter protein to monitor secretion. We hypothesize that also other secreted or membrane-bound (glyco)proteins can be engineered to function as transporters for oligopeptides and also more complex larger proteins.

High-level expression of biologically active bovine alpha interferon by Bovine herpesvirus 1 interferes only marginally with recombinant virus replication in vitro

An artificial open reading frame (ORF) for bovine alpha interferon (boIFN-α) with the codon preference of Bovine herpesvirus 1 (BHV-1) glycoprotein B was constructed to assess the effect of expression of boIFN-α by BHV-1 from an expression cassette. Transient expression of the ORF revealed that transfected cells secreted substantial amounts of biologically active boIFN-α, which moderately inhibited replication of BHV-1 after stimulation of bovine cells with 104 U ml−1. The boIFN-α-encoding expression cassette was recombined into the glycoprotein E locus of the glycoprotein E-negative BHV-1 vaccine strain GKD. Cells infected with the resulting recombinant BHV-1/boIFN-α secreted up to 107 U boIFN-α per ml cell culture supernatant, which is about 40- to more than 100-fold the activity reached with other virus expression systems. Bioassays demonstrated that the BHV-1-expressed interferon induced a rapid and sustained antiviral state in stimulated bovine cells. Analysis of the in vitro growth properties of the recombinant revealed, depending on the cell line used, no or only slight inhibition in direct spreading from cell to cell and a modest delay in virus egress from infected cells. Final titres, however, were comparable to those reached by the parent strain. Penetration into cells was not affected. The results from this study demonstrate that BHV-1/boIFN-α expresses high levels of boIFN-α, grows to high titres in cell culture and thus represents a potential alternative means to deliver endogenously produced boIFN-α in situ for a period of time.

Engineering glycoprotein B of bovine herpesvirus 1 to function as transporter for secreted proteins: a new protein expression approach

Glycoprotein B (gB) of bovine herpesvirus 1 (BHV-1) is essential for BHV-1 replication and is required for membrane fusion processes leading to virus penetration into the target cell and direct spreading of BHV-1 from infected to adjacent noninfected cells. Like many of the herpesvirus gB homologs, BHV-1 gB is proteolytically processed by furin, an endoproteinase localized in the trans-Golgi network. Cleavage by furin is a common mechanism for the activation of a number of viral fusion (F) proteins. Among these, the F proteins of both human and bovine respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) have the so-far unique feature that cleavage of the respective F protein precursors occurs at two furin recognition sites, resulting in the release of a 27-amino-acid intervening peptide which is secreted into the extracellular space. We showed recently that the intervening peptide of bovine RSV can be replaced by bovine interleukins which are secreted into the medium of cells infected with the respective bovine RSV recombinants (P. Konig, K. Giesow, K. Schuldt, U. J. Buchholz, and G. M. Keil, J. Gen. Virol. 85:1815-1824, 2004). To elucidate whether the approach to transport heterologous proteins as furin-excisable polypeptides functions in principle also in glycoproteins which are cleaved by furin only once, we inserted a second furin cleavage site into BHV-1 gB and integrated a 16-amino-acid peptide sequence, the 246-amino-acid green fluorescent protein (GFP), or the 167 amino acids for mature bovine alpha interferon (boIFN-alpha) as an intervening polypeptide. The resulting gB variants rescued gB-negative BHV-1 mutants, the resulting BHV-1 recombinants were fully infectious, and infected cells secreted biologically active GFP and boIFN-alpha, respectively. In contrast to the gB2Fu and gB2FuGFP precursor molecules, which were efficiently cleaved at both furin sites, the majority of pgB2FuIFN-alpha was not cleaved at the site between the amino-terminal (NH2) subunit and boIFN-alpha, whereas cleavage at the newly introduced site was normal. This resulted in virus particles that also contain the NH2-subunit/boIFN-alpha fusion protein within their envelopes. Our results demonstrate that BHV-1 gB can be used as a transporter for peptides and proteins which could be important for development of novel vaccines. In addition, the general principle might be useful for other applications, e.g., in gene therapy and also in nonviral systems.